Statements at the meeting with a group of professors, scholars, and elite students of the Qom Seminary.

Iran Ali Khamenei · Supreme Leader of Iran

24 October 2010 · Meeting with a group of professors, scholars, and elite students of the Qom Seminary · Qom

Context
Khamenei addressed professors, scholars, and elite students of the Qom Seminary in October 2010, delivering religious and moral guidance on spirituality and detachment.
Main themes
Detachment from the world, spiritual purification, Islamic scholarship, fear of God and weeping, sincerity in worship, heart and faith, hadith and Quranic guidance, Qom Seminary scholarly community, self-restraint and abstinence, supplication and humility, moral and ethical development
Duration
~73 min
97th percentile
Words
8,783
97th percentile
Sentences
382
97th percentile
Readability
53
70th percentile
Grade
11.4
38th percentile
Syntax
3.05
54th percentile
Vocabulary
2.28
68th percentile

Translated from Persian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 55%54%
  • Institutional 29%29%
  • Ceremonial 15%14%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

382 sentences in 64 paragraphs

In the name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful

All praise is due to God, the Lord of the worlds, and blessings and peace be upon our master and prophet, Abu al-Qasim Mustafa Muhammad, and upon his pure and chosen family, the guided, the infallible, the honored, especially the remaining one of God on the earth.

One of our good nights was tonight. This session was one of the best and most memorable sessions. I really enjoyed it. In 2007, we also had such a session in Tehran, and a group of scholars attended and spoke; that night, I truly enjoyed seeing these young scholars, these active minds, and these open thoughts. Tonight, that memory was renewed, and thank God, we heard very good points from you. Of course, I also have some remarks that I will briefly present, as there may not be enough time. Additionally, many of the points that were in my mind, I saw that these esteemed gentlemen expressed them well, perhaps in the best way and with the best articulation.

I have noted a narration that I will present first so that our speech may be blessed by mentioning this noble hadith, and the gathering may be perfumed by the fragrance of the statements of the Ahl al-Bayt (peace be upon them). The chain of the hadith is also good; in the "Wasail," in the chapters on the struggle against the self. Abu Abdullah (peace be upon him) said: "God revealed to Moses that My servants do not draw near to Me with anything more beloved to Me than three qualities. Moses said, 'O Lord, what are they?' He said, 'O Moses, detachment from the world.'" The first quality is detachment. We read and repeat these hadiths over and over again in sermons and speeches for the people. Just as some of the dear gentlemen mentioned, if these words do not arise from our hearts, if they do not manifest in our actions, they will have no effect. Detachment does not mean that a person should abandon the world altogether; this has neither been the way of the great ones of religion, nor is this the meaning of detachment. Detachment is disinterest, not being greedy, not clinging to the world and its material adornments. We should not cling to the world. The best achievement of a person in life is this; not to be attached to the world, not to be hanging on to these adornments; in this case, a person is also more at ease. "In this market, if there is profit, it is with the contented dervish." Dervish not in the sense of the common Sufi and dervish; it means poverty, indifference, and disinterest.

In this market, if there is profit, it is with the contented dervish.

O God, make me rich with dervishness and contentment.

Being rich - which in poetic expressions means being truly affluent - and being genuinely endowed is this. It has been narrated from the noble Prophet of Islam that he said, "I have asked God to let me be hungry one day and full the next; so that on the day I am hungry, I may ask from God; and on the day I am full, I may thank God; 'chastity and sufficiency.'" The worldly matters that are discussed in the context of detachment are not only about money and the material adornments of life; status, rank, prestige, and popularity are also part of it. Working for the world, studying for the world, striving for the world, all of these are among the things that in the context of detachment, we are encouraged to set aside and be disinterested in them. Then he says: "Abstaining from sins ... " - well, the foundation of the matter is abstinence - " ... and weeping from My fear." It is not enough for a person to perform obligatory worship or supererogatory prayers; the heart must prostrate to the truth, the heart must be attentive; if it becomes attentive, then tears will flow.

Weeping from the fear of God arises from the attention of the heart, from knowledge, from humility; we have been commanded to this, we need these, these are our needs. If we provide all these logical, reasonable, and correct mechanisms, but this spirit is not within us, this spirituality is not within us, this moral inclination is not there, the work will be useless or of little use; it will not progress. Our hearts need to resort to supplication and humility for stability.

The late Mr. Bahjat (may God be pleased with him) used to say, "Recite this supplication often: 'O God, O Most Gracious, O Most Merciful, O Turner of hearts, keep my heart steadfast in Your religion.'" There might have been a significant objection, and he would respond to that as well. Someone might say, when we say, "Keep my heart steadfast in Your religion," our religion is correct, logical, and solid; this is for the lower classes. He would say, in any class where a person's heart, faith, and religiosity exist, descending from that class is a regression. "Keep my heart steadfast in Your religion" means to maintain and stabilize the religion in that high class. If this happens, then life becomes sweet, and death also becomes easy. One of our fundamental problems is the problem of dying. Imam Sajjad (peace be upon him) addresses God, saying: "Our community is guided, not misguided, obedient, not coerced, not sinful." Well, a person has been on the path of guidance throughout their life, yet the Imam still prays: "Our community is guided, not misguided, obedient, not coerced, not sinful"; it becomes clear that it is dangerous.

The ruling of concealment and intoxication is all about the end.

No one knows in what state they will end up.

In the continuation of the narration, he says: "Moses said, 'O Lord, what is the reward for one who does this?' God revealed to him, 'O Moses, as for those who are detached from the world, they are in paradise, and as for those who weep from My fear, they are in the highest rank, and no one shares it with them.'" This high rank is exclusive to those whose tender hearts, their sensitive hearts, become humble in the face of divine remembrance, and this humility makes their eyes weep. "And as for those who abstain from sins, I will overlook the people and not scrutinize them"; divine indulgence, God's turning a blind eye to some of the slips and shortcomings that a person cannot avoid. This hadith has a reliable chain; "from Abu Abdur Rahman from a man of his companions." The reports of Ibn Abi Umayr are considered as reliable as the established ones.

It has been said, and it is indeed true, that when a student enters the seminary and this path, it is with eagerness and desire for spirituality and true spirituality - there is no doubt about this - we have walked this path for years, we have moved, we have studied, we have breathed; but at the same time, one must seek refuge in God, one must ask for help from God, one must seek success from Him; without divine success, the work is very difficult. Imam Sajjad (peace be upon him) in the Sahifa Sajjadiya says: "This is the state of one who is shy for themselves before You and is displeased with themselves and is pleased with You." What kind of state is this, what condition is this that Imam Sajjad expresses his shame?

In any case, the work of spirituality, the work of devotion to the world of meaning, is fundamental in the seminary; this is something that everyone must pay attention to. The lack of this meaning in the seminary harms us. In the seminary, thank God, there are those who can quench us with the pure spirituality that flows from their hearts - it is not just lip service - especially the young students who need it the most, who are most affected by these statements. Sometimes in class, a teacher may say a few words on an occasion, and a student is transformed. The Imam (may God be pleased with him) on various occasions during class - sometimes on the first day of class, sometimes on the last day of class - with that extraordinary expression he had regarding spiritual matters and those spiritual considerations, sometimes he would say a few sentences, and the students would cry. After the passing of the late Ayatollah Borujerdi, in the Salmasi Mosque, the Imam gave a sermon - before that, the Imam did not give sermons, he would sit on the ground and teach, apparently out of respect for Mr. Borujerdi - he went up to the pulpit and sat down. Well, it was something new, and the Imam had a smile on his face. Then immediately he changed his demeanor and said: "The first day that the late Mr. Nayini (may God be pleased with him) sat on the pulpit, he cried; he said, 'This is the same pulpit that Sheikh Ansari sat on, now it has come to the point that we must sit on it.'" This statement shook the students and their hearts. Then he spoke in detail.

In Mashhad, the late Sheikh Hashim Qazwini, a well-known and distinguished teacher of the seminary of Khorasan, who in terms of expression and mastery of the subject, we have not seen his like in any other seminary; neither in Qom nor in Najaf, sometimes in the middle of a lesson - a lesson on the "Makasib" and "Kifayah" - which lasted about an hour, he would give advice for ten minutes or more; the students would shed tears. The heart of the young is ready; do not miss this opportunity. Read a hadith, give a couple of words of advice. First, the advice is for ourselves. The first person who is addressed by this hadith that I read, and God willing, the first person who should be affected by it is the speaker of the hadith himself; it is beneficial for yourself as well. The seminary needs this.

You see how a warm breath like Haj Mirza Ali Qazi in Najaf created so many blessings. The students of the late Mr. Qazi became a source of blessing wherever they were; one example is the late Allameh Tabatabai (may God be pleased with him) who illuminated Qom; he lit the lamp of rational sciences in Qom and continued it despite difficulties. The other students of the late Mr. Qazi and those influenced by him were the same everywhere. In Tehran, in Azerbaijan, in Najaf itself, in Borujerd, in other places, wherever his students were, they were centers of spirituality and the radiance of clericalism. These cannot be overlooked.

Advise the students. Guide the students to think, reflect, remember death, and avoid studying and striving to attain high ranks to attract people's attention to themselves. The students should study for God, in God, and with God; this is when it becomes a blessed seminary.

The issues that the gentlemen mentioned were all necessary matters. I noted the main points. Truly, none of the points that the gentlemen raised were of little importance; some were of utmost importance, and some were significant. First, if we want these desires and aspirations - as many of them were aspirations - to be realized, it can only happen with sincerity, with striving for God, with working for God, and with letting go of the problems that arise from our desires and worldly pursuits; otherwise, we will be at each other's throats over trivial matters and form various factions, making a fuss over nothing, and it is clear that we will not reach these goals; when there is no time left to accomplish all this great work. Secondly, even if these desires are realized, they lack spirit. How can we humble the hearts of contemporary humanity before Islam, while our own hearts are not humble? Thus, humility is necessary. He said:

Relying on piety and knowledge in the path is misguided.

The traveler, even if he has a hundred arts, must have reliance.

It cannot be done without God's help. Knowledge, good thought, good mind, high talent, great effort, if not accompanied by divine assistance - which is achieved through reliance on God and entrusting oneself to God - will not lead anywhere.

As for the matters that were mentioned and the issues raised regarding the seminary. First, as I mentioned, I truly enjoyed it. I am really grateful to God; what good words, what good thoughts, what well-considered points were expressed; these are very valuable. Let me tell you; when we were in this seminary, perhaps there was not a single person in the entire seminary who could categorize such matters in various sections. There were good scholars, good intellectuals - they were both knowledgeable and intellectual, and prominent - but at that time, the level of thought and perspective on issues in the seminary was not at this level at all; these are the blessings of the revolution, from the blessing of that wake-up call that the Imam gave to the seminaries and awakened everyone.

I am sure that if there was time and Mr. Mohaddesi allowed ten more people to speak, undoubtedly ten new topics, new subjects, new threads of discussion would emerge. These innovative and good words are not exclusive to these gentlemen who came and spoke; certainly, there are more people in the seminary who have similar innovative, interesting, beautiful, and delightful words. I thank each and every one of you.

I also truly enjoyed the interludes or, as Mr. Mohaddesi calls them, the intermissions. I had previously heard both his poetry and prose many times from him, but tonight it was very prominent; both his prose and his poetry, and the interesting points he made; this is also very interesting in its own right.

Regarding the issues that friends mentioned, I have some opinions; however, there is no time to express them now, as time has passed; but I will mention a few headings of other matters. First, when Mr. Khosro Panah presented his points, I wrote "well done" under the summary of his remarks; then Mr. Zibayee Nejad spoke, and he also made interesting points, and I wrote "well done" under his remarks as well; then when Mr. Shab Zendeh Dar and others spoke, I found myself writing "well done" repeatedly; I wrote one "well done" and drew a line to the end! The points were very good. Of course, there are points and opinions that now there is no time to express; in summary, I will just say one word.

Some of the issues that the gentlemen mentioned are not currently practical; they are aspirations. It is good for us to distinguish between aspirations and those things that can be included in a program. Today, the seminary needs planning. Of course, a vision must be set; this is correct. A vision document, or as some gentlemen have termed it, a mission statement for the clergy or the mission of the seminary is necessary; this must be drafted; however, preparing such a vision or such a statement is itself an important task; it is a fundamental project. It is not easy for five thoughtful and intelligent people to sit down and draft a mission statement or write a vision document; it requires preparations to create a vision document. Of course, if such a vision document is prepared, then it will be possible to develop scheduled programs based on it; specific short-term, medium-term, and long-term goals can be set; ten-year goals, twenty-year goals, fifty-year goals. Of course, these tasks are possible; however, the planning we need now must be focused on realities and practical actions that can be achieved in the seminary. One cannot live in a vacuum; planning must be done. Therefore, we must look at practical matters; that is, aspirations that are true and will undoubtedly be realized one day. I am not one of those hopeless, dead-end thinkers. I am certain that these aspirations will be realized, but it depends on how conditions and realities progress. The factors influencing events are often diverse; most of these events are beyond human comprehension, beyond calculations. The only thing that can be calculated is this: "If you help God, He will help you"; "Whoever is for God, God is for him," "And God will surely help those who help Him"; because it is hidden, and God Almighty has said it, and "He is the most truthful of speakers." Other than this, all these studies and plans are subject to challenge, because the factors influencing events are beyond calculation. The global powers today also know this in their calculations and take it into account; hence, you see that they plan or announce certain things, and then they do not materialize; not because they have regretted it, but because they see that it cannot be done. Events arise that were not calculated. Therefore, those things that are practical must be seriously addressed and pursued.

I would like to mention a point regarding the humanities that our dear brother Mr. Fathali Khani has raised. You see, we are not saying that the humanities are useless; we are saying that the humanities, in their current form, are harmful; that is the discussion. The point of contention between what we say and what he stated is twofold. The center of proof and denial is not the same thing. The discussion is not about whether we want sociology or psychology or management science or education or whether they are good or have benefits. Yes; they are definitely good; they are definitely necessary. One of the things I have is precisely this field of education in the seminary. The discussion is not that these sciences are not useful; the discussion is that what has been provided to us today is based on a worldview that is different from our worldview. The humanities are not like medicine, they are not like engineering, they are not like physics, where the worldview and perspective on human beings and the world do not have an impact; they do have an impact. If you are materialistic, you will organize the humanities in one way. Our humanities are rooted in the positivist thoughts of 15th and 16th century Europe. Previously, when there were no humanities, they came and formulated economics, sociology in the 18th and 19th centuries, a little before and a little after, and presented them; well, this is not useful for us. These humanities raise and educate their students in such a way that their perspective on the issues pertinent to that science and the focus of that science—whether it be economics, management, or education—is un-Islamic. We see that the same religious person within the university who has studied management or economics, whenever we talk to him about the religious foundations of these issues, it does not register with him. Not that he rejects it, no; but what you discuss with him regarding Islamic economics does not align with his scientific findings, with the two plus two equals four that he has studied in this science.

I have no objection to the entry of the humanities into the seminary. I say that the seminary must lay the foundations of the humanities based on Islamic thought and the worldview of Islam; the same work that Mr. Misbah and his organization started at the beginning of the revolution; if it had continued until today, it would have reached certain points. These foundations must be laid; and this will not be possible unless we are familiar with the humanities; there is no doubt about that. Therefore, in the seminary, they should study the humanities, learn them, understand the formulation of issues and titles in these sciences; then return to the Islamic foundations, see how their corresponding issues align with Islamic thought and how they take shape. Therefore, I am not saying that the humanities are not beneficial; I am saying that what exists is harmful; what should exist is necessary.

However, what I have noted here about the seminary. Of course, in the course of what I have noted, I may omit some issues or some may seem to me to have priority to be raised in this short time.

One issue is that the essence of the seminary is knowledge; it is a seminary of knowledge. We say that the essence of the seminary has been lifted with knowledge. Thus, knowledge constitutes the true fabric, the true foundation, and the true identity of this seminary—seminaries everywhere are like this; it is not specific to the seminary of Qom—meaning the seminary is knowledge-centered. Being knowledge-centered has its requirements; one must adhere to these requirements. One of the things that is necessary for being knowledge-centered is that a knowledge-centered community is one that generates questions, is question-creating. When a scientific discussion is raised, questions arise, and one must face questions with an open mind; just as this has existed in the scientific tradition of our esteemed predecessors. You notice that in jurisprudence, there are many jurisprudential oppositions; sometimes they are accompanied by sharp tones. For instance, the late author of "Hadaiq" sometimes uses a sharp tone against the author of "Madarik"; conversely, the late author of "Jawahir" uses a very sharp tone against the author of "Hadaiq" in some cases. It has always been like this. The late Allameh, in "Mukhatalif," harshly criticizes Ibn Idris in many instances and shows a very strong reaction. Of course, Ibn Idris (may Allah be pleased with him) also, in his own way, confronted Sheikh Tusi with the same expression. This practice is common, and there is no problem with it; but in the field of knowledge. If Ibn Idris were alive, he would stand, and Allameh would pray behind him, kissing his hand. If Sayyid the author of "Madarik" were alive, the author of "Hadaiq" and others would pray behind him, kissing his hand—there is no doubt about that—but in the field of knowledge, they confront each other; there is no obstacle to that. These confrontations mean that raising questions, raising objections, raising doubts, raising new issues, and proposing new methods is not a problem. If what has been raised is wrong, then it must be addressed scientifically; that is, overlooking a scientific error is not permissible. If someone has made a scientific mistake, it is not permissible to overlook it and say that we should preserve his respect, consider him, and not speak; no, in the realm of knowledge, this issue does not exist. It must be addressed scientifically, but questions should not be stifled. The seminary must not cut off questions. Cutting off questions leads to cutting off knowledge. The path of questioning should not be closed.

Another point is that the seminary is open-minded. The characteristic of being scientific is open-mindedness. Stagnation in the field of knowledge has no meaning. That is, if we are scholars, if we are a seminary of knowledge, if we are seeking knowledge, we must allow thought to be free; of course, for those who are capable of thought. It is clear that in a scientific community, someone who does not have the intellectual qualifications does not dare to express an opinion; if they do express an opinion, they will be caught, and their error will be exposed. Those who have the qualifications to express an opinion must do so; whether in jurisprudence, whether in principles, whether in philosophy, whether in theology, or in other discussions and sciences prevalent in the seminary; that is, there must be open-mindedness.

Of course, this open-mindedness exists; we all must accept this. I read somewhere that it was written that today in the seminary of Qom, there is no scientific open-mindedness; it was yesterday, but today there is none. This is not correct; it was there yesterday, and it is there today; today it is even more than yesterday. Jurisprudential and principled opinions from the greatest jurists are being critiqued. One notices that some of Imam's outstanding and exceptional jurisprudential and principled opinions are being critiqued in scientific articles; there is no problem with that. The basis of Imam's legal addresses, which we believe is one of the most solid, innovative, and effective principled foundations of Imam, is being critiqued; both in lessons and in articles. I have read some articles that have critiqued them. Of course, in our view, those critiques are not valid, but they are critiqued nonetheless; and no one says why. One cannot accuse the seminary of having no critique, criticism, or freedom. Unfortunately, we read somewhere that it was written that these statements do not exist; while this is false, this is accusing the seminary.

We want to express that this open-mindedness should have a broad scope. As was stated, in philosophy, the statements of Akhund Mulla Sadra are not divine revelation. In jurisprudence, the fatwas of the author of "Jawahir" and a personality like Sheikh A'zam—who, despite all the greats and jurists, we do not have a counterpart to Sheikh A'zam from after Sheikh until today—are not divine revelation; neither in jurisprudence nor in principles. Therefore, they have been rejected, criticized, and objected to. This tradition must exist in the seminary.

Another point is self-confidence in knowledge and scientific self-reliance. The seminary and its scholars and students must reach a level of scientific self-confidence and self-reliance; this is very important. In the clash of opinions, in the quality of scientific movement, in the value ranks of the seminary, knowledge must have the highest status. Of course, piety, spirituality, asceticism, humility, and these are higher and superior values; however, these are not things that can be presented, that can be understood. Many people are of these meanings, but we do not recognize them; however, knowledge can be tested, is exposed, is within the circle.

Among the things that are part of the requirements of the seminary and the scientific ethics of the seminary necessitate is fairness in dealing with scientific issues; scientific fairness must be maintained.

The next point is seriousness and not abandoning the pursuit of work for the teacher and the student. Among the new afflictions and new culture and new educational system—imported from Europe—is that the teacher does not bother to produce new thoughts, often teaching without study. Our teacher does not teach without study. Our teacher studies, reflects, thinks; he teaches with thought. If you have taught the "Makasib" ten times, in the eleventh round, you must still think; perhaps something new will come to your mind.

Among the things that are necessary for the seminary is active communication with the national community within the country and the transnational community, which I saw in the statements of some gentlemen as well. The seminary must establish scientific communication with the seminary schools worldwide and with the domestic seminaries. In the past, despite the difficulties of communication, scholars communicated with each other from afar. The late Ibn Idris writes in his "Sirair" that a certain person—I do not remember his name—had issued a fatwa, I wrote him a letter, he replied, and I did not accept it. In the past, they wrote letters, presented scientific opinions, and this scholar would refute that scientific opinion; sometimes they would ask each other questions. The late Allameh Semnani had written several jurisprudential questions to the late Ayatollah Milani; he also gave a response, and they discussed it; it became a pamphlet, published. These practices were common, and they are still very necessary today; especially with these new means of communication. Therefore, the alignment and harmonization and mutual intellectual and scientific flow between the seminaries within the country and the seminary and university in issues that are related to each other and with seminaries outside the country is a necessity for the seminary. There is no problem in establishing communication with the scientific seminaries of the Sunni in Pakistan, in Hijaz, in Egypt, and in other places; of course, with structured and defined communications and from a specific center; because today, personal communications have no meaning or value.

One of the characteristics of scientific seminaries—that is, a seminary whose foundation is based on knowledge and learning—is that opposing opinions are not suppressed. Of course, I do not advocate that they should present rare opinions. Some are like this, seeking rare opinions; if there is no rare opinion on an issue, it seems they create a rare opinion; they are in pursuit of oddities. We do not want to say this; but there are opinions that are not famous, not accepted by the majority of scholars; however, it is still an opinion; it should not be suppressed; it should exist. Some of these non-famous opinions in the past have, in certain periods, turned into famous opinions; you have seen examples of this in the discussions of the "Manzuhat" and others, which are prevalent and well-known among all.

In the seminary, unscientific methods should not be used to refute opposing opinions. What is a scientific method? Reasoning and responding and answering; rational persuasion or at least reasoning. What is an unscientific method? Takfir; tafsiq. This is not correct. There are some opinions—whether in jurisprudence or in some matters related to knowledge—that may have differences; one person may have an opposing opinion; it should not be rejected in the sense of tafsiq. Yes, that opinion should be strongly criticized with the stick of reasoning—there is no problem with that—argue against it, write against it; instead of one, write ten; as it has been common in the seminary; sometimes we have seen a book published, and ten or five people wrote against it; it was very good, they should write; these writings are very good; however, tafsiq and declaring someone out of the religion and out of the sect is not beneficial; this is not a scientific method. This is also an issue that arises from the scientific nature of the seminary; that is, our commitment to the scientific nature of the seminary necessitates this.

Another point that is also a requirement of being scientific is that education in the seminary must be accompanied by thought, repetition, and research. This is also one of the areas where the new educational system imported from Europe lacks; it is based on memorization. We should not lean towards this direction. Any program that leads us in this direction is an incorrect program. In our planning, we should look at what drives the student towards memorization and prevents them from thinking, researching, and studying. Memorization is not correct; it is not beneficial. I also pointed out the other day that one of the characteristics of our seminary is thinking. The student must be compelled from the beginning of their studies to think. It was famously said: "Know, may Allah guide you"—why did he say know and not read?—the intention is to first awaken the sense of questioning in the student, and then to convey to them that reading is not the goal; knowing is the goal. This must truly be a comprehensive guideline for our planners.

Teachers should also pay attention to this point. Now there are exams in the seminary, which are very necessary and good. Of course, there were exams before, but they were not organized and structured in this way; today they are, and it is very good; nothing should be done to alter these exams; however, this does not contradict that the teacher should test during the lesson. Before starting the lesson, dedicate ten minutes to questioning the students; this has been tried. When I was teaching the same levels in Mashhad—Kifayah and Makasib and such—I did this. Before the lesson, we would open the book and ask one of the students to read or summarize the previous lesson. This had a great impact; we understood what the student was capable of, and he understood that there was a questioning and accountability process, and others learned that point if they did not know it; there are other benefits as well. This compulsion for the student to think, especially in the lower-level classes, is very important. In a session we had these nights, I spoke with one of the gentlemen, and this point came to my mind, and I said that the lower-level classes are very important. Mastering the essential principles of jurisprudential and principled matters enables the student to benefit in the advanced classes; otherwise, they will not benefit.

The discussion is not about these current texts that we should say we must adhere to these texts; no, whenever the seminary, God willing, finds success, it will also prepare texts suitable for the times. Any text that is taught at the level must be read and understood by the student. Emphasis should be placed on understanding these texts; deepening instead of memorization, thinking and repeating to achieve that goal, which is to know the material in a research-oriented manner.

Being research-oriented is also the next point. The seminary requires a suitable research system. Also, attention to the lower-level classes in jurisprudence and principles, before going to advanced classes. The scientific identity of the seminary is also an important point; it is not limited to jurisprudence and principles. Jurisprudence and principles are very important; there is no doubt about that; we have previously said that the backbone of our seminaries is jurisprudence; however, this does not mean that we do not need philosophy. Today, we need philosophy more than ever.

There was a time when our great scholars, our great jurists, would "travel" to study philosophy—like Akhund Khorasani, who went to Sabzevar to study under Haj Mulla Hadi and sat at his feet to learn philosophy—or great figures among our jurists and principled scholars who went to study philosophy and mastered it. Today, we need it much more than that day. The day when the late Allameh Tabatabai was studying philosophy in Najaf under the late Sayyid Hussein Badkube'i, the need for Islamic philosophy was much less than today, when so many different schools, so many new thoughts, so many doubts, and so many intellectual proposals are being raised in the world; especially with these easy and rapid communications; with the internet and other means, books, magazines, and so on. Therefore, there is a need for philosophy. Not only for philosophy, but also for other sciences in the seminary of Qom.

Of course, someone who can combine all these sciences and become an expert and a scholar in all of them is, apparently, either impossible or ultimately not very easy. It was not possible in the past either; I should mention this to you. Sometimes, for the greatness of our great jurists and scholars, names like the late Sheikh Tusi or Allameh Hilli are mentioned. Yes, Sheikh Tusi (may Allah's mercy be upon him) was a great jurist and a founder of a school of thought and an innovator in principles; he and his contemporaries laid the first foundations of principles at that time; Sheikh Tusi is a jurist, a scholar of principles, a commentator, a hadith scholar, and also a specialist in the field of rijal; but did he excel in all these fields? No. Yes, he excels in jurisprudence - it is said that for 200 years after Sheikh, the jurists who came followed his method and way; they were called his followers - but you observe that in the field of rijal, Najashi is more authoritative. He is a reclusive person and, in fact, an obscure figure compared to Sheikh and a contemporary of Sheikh; however, the credibility of his book of rijal among those who are knowledgeable in this field is greater than that of Sheikh's books; both more than Sheikh's "Rijal" and more than Sheikh's "Fahrist." It is indeed the case; it is more rigorous, more credible. That is to say, it cannot be said that Sheikh, with that greatness, had the same greatness in rijal.

Or Allameh (may Allah's mercy be upon him), who is both a jurist and a scholar of principles, a logician, a philosopher, a theologian, and a rijal scholar, and in all these fields, Allameh has written books, and in philosophy, he has written a commentary on "Hikmat al-Ain" - which is a commentary on the book "Dabiran Katibi Qazwini," who was Allameh's teacher, and Allameh studied philosophy under Dabiran Katibi - but Allameh's book on philosophy is not among our first-rate philosophical books; that is, it cannot be compared with the books of Ibn Sina, nor with the books of later scholars. Therefore, it is not the case that we can say that in the past, individuals could be specialists in all fields; no, some were in one field and some in another. Well, we have an Allameh, we have a researcher in jurisprudence; we also have a Khwaja Nasir in philosophy or theology; there is no problem.

Today, it is the same. There is no problem that today we have jurists, philosophers, specialists in Islamic humanities, specialists in interpretation - interpretation cannot be underestimated; it requires specialists - and specialists in the arts of propagation. What is the problem with having among the greats of the seminary those who teach the art of propagation, the characteristics of propagation in this strange world today - and in the words of Mr. Kabiri, the even stranger world of the future - and can propagate the religion?

In various fields, we should have professors. The academic status of these individuals must be preserved. It should not be the case that if someone attains a rank in jurisprudence - even if not the highest rank - he is respected in society; but if someone attains the highest rank in philosophy, he is not respected to the same extent. It is not like that; it is knowledge, it is Islamic knowledge, it is needed in the seminary.

One of the important tasks is to classify the sciences - which some gentlemen have also mentioned - to prioritize, rank, evaluate, and measure them against needs. If it is measured against today's needs, I fear the result may turn out differently. In any case, what is certain is that in the seminary, the science of jurisprudence and principles - which follows jurisprudence - is the basis of the seminary's work; however, I am not in favor of dedicating principles as an independent science, and I do not find it very beneficial for the seminary; principles should serve jurisprudence. The jurists and scholars of principles themselves acknowledge that some of the discussions in principles do not serve jurisprudence at all and have no connection to it. Principles should be alongside jurisprudence; then, importance should be given to other important fields like philosophy, interpretation, and theology. How much do we need the field of theology today; all these fields are necessary.

Another point in this context of the scientific nature of the seminary and that its identity is a scientific identity is that we should not be afraid of new methods in teaching science, in educating science, in expanding science, in producing science; we should not be apprehensive about new methods. When the goal is to engage with science, we are truly seeking knowledge, and the reins of work are in the hands of knowledgeable individuals; new methods, however they may be, are acceptable.

I should mention that in this Qom seminary, the innovator of programmed schools was one of the well-known jurists exclusively in the field of jurisprudence; that is, the late Ayatollah Golpaygani. The programmed school in the Qom seminary was established by Mr. Golpaygani; before the Haqqani school. The late Mr. Beheshti and others established the Haqqani school based on Mr. Golpaygani's school. In fact, the late Mr. Beheshti and some other teachers were there; then they left and founded the Haqqani school themselves. Mr. Golpaygani's school - which apparently still bears that name - is the oldest programmed school in the seminary. Mr. Golpaygani was a proficient jurist specialized in jurisprudence and committed to the issues of jurisprudence; he was not afraid to implement a new program in education. Of course, he had other innovations as well. The first place where computer-related issues were introduced in the seminary was Mr. Golpaygani's institution, which later gained more popularity.

One issue is the system of ethics and education in the seminary; since time is passing quickly, I will just mention this and conclude the discussion. Several gentlemen have elaborated on the discussion of education and ethics very well - may Allah reward their efforts - and I accept those statements. The issue of education and ethics is important to us from two aspects: one is the internal aspect of the seminary. After all, we want to be clerics, we want to be propagators. For the same reasons they mentioned, with the same aspects they pointed out, we must have proper ethics. The second is the external aspect; it involves very vast domains that we cannot engage with without familiarity and awareness of educational and ethical foundations. You see, in the country, there is a vast nationwide agricultural field of high yield called education. If we speak on television, if that listener sits at our sermon on television, how many listeners do we have? But education every year finds millions of listeners, lasting listeners who are with education for twelve years. Is there a better channel than this? This channel of nourishing hearts and minds is concentrated in education. How much share do we have in education? It must be said none. The fact that a cleric goes to a school to hold a congregational prayer or to say something is nothing at all; it is absolutely nothing.

If we have a field of education and training within the seminary, and we train specialists in education and training; if the discussion of ethics and education is taken seriously in the seminary, then the seminary and the clergy can make education their field of presence. Not that we go and become the Minister of Education; that is not effective at all. The discussion of education involves textbooks and the training of teachers, the religious training of teachers, and the production of religious and non-religious books; that is, a physics book or a mathematics book can also teach monotheism, it can make people irreligious; it can instill monotheism and devotion in students, and it can also make them irreligious, indifferent to the origin and resurrection.

We must be able to prepare the seminary. The seminary is not ready now. I have no complaints about the education system; I should tell you this. I am a seminary student, I see the seminary myself; the seminary currently does not have the readiness for us to say, "Come, enter, prepare the necessary materials for training teachers and the necessary materials for organizing textbooks according to religious thought and religious guidance." This work is also among the necessary tasks of the seminary.

In the end, the seminary has a lot of work to do. Of course, when we say certain fields should come, certain tasks should be carried out, some say, "You have neglected jurisprudence and principles; we no longer have a Jauhar or Sheikh Ansari graduated from the seminary." This is a common saying. I do not accept this statement. First of all, where is someone like Sheikh Ansari? In the seminaries that were specifically for this work, how many Sheikh Ansaris did we have? I said; it does not seem to me that after Sheikh Ansari, none of his students or the students of his students have reached the rank of Sheikh Ansari until today. Yes, his words are mentioned, objections are raised, and the objections are valid; but the issue of Sheikh is a different matter.

The framework that Sheikh, may Allah have mercy on him, provided for jurisprudential inference after the owner of Jauhar and on the shoulders of the owner of Jauhar, you can compare Sheikh's "Makasib" with Jauhar's "Mutajir" to see how much the difference between Sheikh and the owner of Jauhar is. After the owner of Jauhar, how many like the owner of Jauhar have we trained in the seminaries that now we complain that we do not train the owner of Jauhar! Well, these were peaks; every once in a while, a scientific and human collection reaches a peak. If in our time the owner of Jauhar or Sheikh Ansari did not emerge, it is not a place for complaint that we could not; to think that if we had set aside these lessons and only clung to jurisprudence and principles, we would now have several owners of Jauhar; no, even the day when the Najaf seminary was exclusively dedicated to jurisprudence and principles and nothing else - as the late Sayyid Isfahani (may Allah's mercy be upon him) stated that there should only be jurisprudence and principles - we did not see anyone trained in Najaf like the owner of Jauhar or Sheikh Ansari. This is the first point.

Secondly, our belief is that today we are servants of the religion; we are not servants of names. What is the purpose of the clergy? The clergy exists to be able to provide religious nourishment to the people; of course, in a knowledgeable manner. In the past, a student would come to Najaf, study jurisprudence and principles, study rijal and some other things, become a cleric, become a scholar; if he stayed in Najaf, he would become Bahr al-Uloom and Kashif al-Ghita; if he left Najaf, he would become Mirza Qumi and Mulla Mahdi Naraki and Mulla Ahmad Naraki and Haji Kalbasi and Sayyid Shufti and the like. That is, each of these individuals, wherever they were, was sufficient for the guidance and spiritual and intellectual nourishment of their people. A Sayyid Shufti or a Haji Kalbasi or a Mirza Mahdi Shahid in Mashhad could nourish the people intellectually with himself and his students. At that time, the misleading and distracting factors for the people were not many; it was the personal desires of individuals that humans have always been afflicted with; that too could largely be alleviated with preaching and admonition and reminders; a part of it remains, as there are always sinners. Back then, there was no television, no internet, no plethora of books and magazines and new thoughts, no new philosophies in people's minds, no home video networks, no satellites, no distractions and misguidances that affect the young and old - various thoughts and doubts - did not exist. Back then, when a scholar entered a city - like Mirza Qumi or Haji Kalbasi - he was the most knowledgeable among all the people of that city. The scholars of each city were those who had read a few sentences of literature or rational sciences or similar things; they were better than all of them, higher than them; in terms of scientific confrontation and competition, no one could stand against them; but today it is not like that. Today, when we study jurisprudence and principles, if we go to a city, it is not the case that we are stronger than everyone; in various fields, in different works, in different words, in different thoughts, there are those who are proficient, skilled; if someone wants to take the stage from them, they must have as much strength as them. Today, jurisprudence and principles are not enough for a person to propagate the religion. Therefore, the responsibilities of the seminaries are very heavy. This diversity in seminary sciences is an absolute and urgent necessity and must be taken into account in planning.

Of course, it has been pointed out, and I also agree that quantity is important in the seminary. The quantity of our seminaries is small. If we want to increase the quantity, it requires necessary pathways; it cannot be done just by a public call; today there are various methods for attraction in the world; we must use these methods. Individuals who have talent, interest, readiness, and can be attracted to the seminary must be brought in. Therefore, there is much to say, much work to do.

Fortunately, the seminary is moving in the right direction. Thank God, important work has been done in recent years. This issue of management must be taken very seriously. Management, with the structure that has been established and exists, is a solid management, an acceptable management, and the signatures of the authorities are on this management. The Supreme Council of Management and the management of the seminary should not be weakened; a vacuum should not be created; they should do their work. It is possible that someone may have an objection to something, to a statement, to an action; very well, the objection can be conveyed, it can be corrected. Be careful that management is not weakened; just as you should be careful that the Society of Teachers is not weakened. Do not weaken the deep-rooted and foundational institutions of the seminary. The Society of Teachers is a valuable entity; the Society of Teachers is not just individuals; it is a collective body, it is a title that has been continuous; it has been present in various fields and arenas for over forty years; it must be preserved.

The last point I have noted to mention here - of course, there are several pages between this and the last and what has been said, which there is no time to present - is that if we value religion, deepening religion, promoting religion, and expanding religiosity, we must recognize the enemy of this approach. Who is that position and that power that today is fearful of the expansion of religion and the deepening of religiosity and is hostile to it? This point is the arrogance, at the head of which is America and the most active of which are the Zionists; both the Zionist network and the fake Zionist government; these are the enemies of religiosity. Do not underestimate the issue of burning the Quran, do not underestimate the issue of cartoons against the noble Prophet of Islam. Of course, it started with Salman Rushdie; but before him and after him, the vast Hollywood film industry and Hollywood companies have been tasked with Islamophobia. At that time, their followers in Iran say, "Does the Islamic Republic expect artists to act on orders?" You are acting on orders; do you think we do not understand!? It is an order to make films against Islam, against the clergy, against the Quran, against religiosity and devotion, especially against the Islamic Revolution; which, well, they clearly make films against the Islamic Revolution and say; these are enemies.

The enemy of the approach of religiosity and acceptance of religion and belief in religion and the expansion of this meaning is the arrogance. The seminary cannot remain silent in the face of arrogance; I should mention this. The seminary must always have a position against arrogance.

One of the most important examples of insight is to see which actions may help that enemy; we must be careful. It does not matter whether they are great or small in the seminary; everyone must be vigilant. Sometimes a word, an action, a move may benefit that enemy. We do not intend to do this, but some things are not dependent on intention; they have their own effect. When a bullet is fired from a gun and hits someone in the chest, well, the person falls and dies; now whether you intended it or not does not matter. The effect of this bullet in his chest does not depend on whether you had intent. You must be careful not to make mistakes. In such matters, a punishment has also been set for the wrongdoer. Therefore, care must be taken not to assist. In addition to not assisting, it must be fought against.

O Lord! Make what we have said and what we have heard for You and in Your way. O Lord! Make us among the loyal to the knowledge of religion and the teachings of the Ahl al-Bayt (peace be upon them). O Lord! By Muhammad and the family of Muhammad, make the sacred heart of the Awaited Imam pleased and satisfied with us, with what we do, with what we say, and with what we practice. O Lord! Make our death as Imam Sajjad (peace be upon him) has requested from God. Make our death a martyrdom in Your way.

And peace be upon you and Allah's mercy and blessings.