Archetypes

Public Voice Archetypes

Four dimensions of how a leader speaks in public, each read from every tagged sentence and against speeches of the same kind, give sixteen archetypes of public voice: patterns in the speeches, not verdicts on the person. Every leader in the Index with a tagged speech has one, 4,435 in all; those read from fewer than 8 speeches are tentative. Open a leader for their percentages.

Focus

NNation Speaks to and about the home country: domestic policy, people and institutions.

WWorld Speaks about other nations: bilateral ties, multilateral bodies, the region and the globe.

Outlook

UUnity Allies and heroes, the future, hope.

CConflict Adversaries and villains, the past, fear and anger.

Values

FFreedom Care, fairness and liberty: the individual and their rights.

TTradition Authority, loyalty and sanctity: the group, its order and what it holds sacred.

Register

HHeart Sentences that appeal to feeling: hope, pride, fear or anger.

MMind Sentences that state, explain and argue without an emotional appeal.

Leaders by archetype

Each leader's strength on the four letters of their type, against comparable speeches (50% is a typical speech of its kind). The best-known first.

NCFH Insurgency 334

All 334 leaders of Insurgency →

NUFH Uplift 395

All 395 leaders of Uplift →

WCFH Revolution 343

All 343 leaders of Revolution →

WUFH Bridge-Building 114

All 114 leaders of Bridge-Building →

NCFM Dissent 253

All 253 leaders of Dissent →

NUFM Reform 289

All 289 leaders of Reform →

WCFM Advocacy 266

All 266 leaders of Advocacy →

WUFM Internationalism 149

All 149 leaders of Internationalism →

NCTH Nationalism 182

All 182 leaders of Nationalism →

NUTH Kinship 368

All 368 leaders of Kinship →

WCTH Defender 186

All 186 leaders of Defender →

WUTH Sovereignty 177

All 177 leaders of Sovereignty →

NCTM Guardianship 216

All 216 leaders of Guardianship →

NUTM Stewardship 430

All 430 leaders of Stewardship →

WCTM Deterrence 335

All 335 leaders of Deterrence →

WUTM Statecraft 398

All 398 leaders of Statecraft →

How the archetypes are measured

What is read
Every sentence of every tagged speech carries an option on each of the twelve indices. Each dimension sets two groups of options against each other: Focus, domestic scope against bilateral, multilateral and global; Outlook, allies, heroes, the future and hope against adversaries, villains, the past, fear and anger; Values, the care, fairness and liberty foundations against authority, loyalty and sanctity; Register, sentences with an emotional appeal against neutral ones.
A speech's split
On each dimension a speech gets a 100% split between its two poles: the share of its sentences on one pole against the other. A speech needs at least 5 sentences on a dimension's poles to be read on it.
Like against like
Speeches are not compared in the absolute: a UN General Assembly address is mostly about the world, a national day speech mostly about the nation. Each speech's split is re-centred on the median of comparable speeches, so 50% is a typical speech of its kind. A speech in a recurring series is compared with its series; any other with speeches of the same occasion, read from its title and event; a true one-off with the remaining pool.
A leader's archetype
The mean of their speeches' re-centred splits, each speech counting once, for every leader with speeches read on all four dimensions; an archetype from fewer than 8 speeches is marked tentative. The letter is the pole they lean to; the percentage how far. The four letters are their archetype.
Choosing the four
Twelve candidate dimensions were tried. Several moved together (allies, the future, hope, a coordinate stance and calls to action against adversaries, the past, grievance, a dominant stance and assertion) and were pooled into one, Outlook; the four kept are those that are reliable and largely independent of one another (no two correlate beyond 0.25 across leaders).
Peer groups
Domestic event 12,169 · UN General Assembly 11,333 · Ceremony 8,310 · Summit forum 6,373 · Other 4,999 · Bilateral 4,568 · Parliament 2,941 · Address to nation 849 · US State of the Union 237 · G7 / G20 Summit Communiqués 162 · World Economic Forum · Davos 88 · COP Opening Addresses 79 · Munich Security Conference 78 · Inaugural Addresses 60 · NATO Summit Statements 40 · Russian Presidential Address to the Federal Assembly 27 · Chinese Leader's New Year Address 19, across 52,332 tagged speeches.
DimensionSpeeches readVenue explains, absoluteVenue explains, re-centredReliability
Focus: Nation / World95%40%12%0.94
Outlook: Unity / Conflict97%8%0%0.97
Values: Freedom / Tradition86%6%0%0.96
Register: Heart / Mind98%4%0%0.96

Venue explains: the share of the variation in speeches' splits that their peer group accounts for (eta squared), before and after re-centring. Reliability: a leader's odd-numbered speeches against their even-numbered ones, across the 101 leaders with enough of both (Spearman–Brown corrected).

Limitations

Related work