Against the War

Italy Benito Mussolini

17 November 1912

Context
Mussolini spoke against war and in defence of the socialist position on its relation to revolution on November 17, 1912, apparently to a socialist audience; the occasion and place are not stated in the text.
Main themes
War as imposed on the peoples, bourgeois enthusiasm for war, socialism as opponent of war, critique of soldierly courage, war and revolution in history, Paris Commune, Russo-Japanese war and Russian reaction, Libyan war atrocities, moral autonomy of the working class, risk of a European conflagration
Duration
~7 min
23rd percentile
Words
811
23rd percentile
Sentences
46
30th percentile
Readability
65
94th percentile
Grade
8.5
8th percentile
Syntax
2.73
15th percentile
Vocabulary
2.34
82nd percentile

Translated from Italian Source: it.wikisource.org ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 63%52%
  • Social 24%20%
  • Institutional 8%7%
  • Economic 3%2%
  • Ceremonial 3%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 17%

46 sentences in 6 paragraphs

But let us return to the war. A war of peoples? Not at all; the peoples suffer it. No one has the right to say that the peoples applaud the sharp-eyed plunder of governments. When were they ever asked whether they wished to go and kill or die? There are millions upon millions of men who live a purely economic life: they eat, they drink, they reproduce; but everything that is civil, political, cultural life is completely unknown to them. They do not have even the embryo of a principle of moral autonomy: this is the herd that suffers war and goes to the slaughter without even asking why.

The bourgeois, on the other hand, when they sing the praises of war, are in their proper place. War for war's sake is what they want. This is the arrière pensée of these gentlemen. A war that would free them from socialism, while it is still a young shoot easy to cut down.

In fact the Vaterland, the Austrian clerical organ that chose to call itself Fatherland, wrote plainly that a European war "would free us from socialism for 50 years". But let us be clear: we are not against war out of cowardice. If we were faint-hearted we would not be in this place. And besides, we do not believe that true courage is that of the soldier who, drunk on brandy, runs to the slaughter of himself and of others. That is a courage of an inferior kind, base, primordial; it is an unthinking courage. More than that: socialism is an even better adversary of war than bourgeois and democratic pacifism is. We are against it because it represents the utmost exploitation of the worker. With war, that is, the proletarian is called upon to shed his own blood, after having given all his sweat in the workshops.

And if only it were true, at least, that war precedes and prepares revolution. It is an illusion, a sophism. Let us read history. The connection between the American War of Secession and the French Revolution is a distant one. Moreover, Lafayette, who took part in it, adopted an ambiguous and uncertain attitude at the beginning of the Revolution. It was the people of Paris who demolished the Bastille, it was the people who in three days and three nights made 50,000 pikes and, urged on by Camille Desmoulins, hurled themselves upon the fortress that represented and symbolised the ancien régime. The bloody days of '48 in Paris, are they perhaps connected with some war? Ah! the Commune! It was born of an unfortunate war, and it is this flaw in its origin that killed it.

Let us come to more recent wars. The one of '97 between Greece and Turkey, the one of '98 between Spain and the United States did not give rise to revolutionary movements. It seemed that the Russo-Japanese war would feed the Russian revolutionary fire, but instead, after the bloodiest of red Sundays, it is the most ferocious reaction that triumphs, and official Russia – with the open protection of the Slavs of the Quadruple Alliance – regains in the concert of the European Powers the ascendancy it had lost on the plains of Manchuria under the deadly blows of the little men of Japan. By contrast, the latest political revolutions of any importance, in Portugal and in China, are not connected with any war. To make a revolution you need citizens, that is, soldiers who remain citizens, intelligent rifles; but war barbarises, bestialises, brutalises men.

Indeed, the most ferocious butchers of the Communards were the soldiers who had fought the colonial wars in Algeria and had grown accustomed to every kind of atrocity. Did not the Italian soldiers come back from the glorious Libyan exploit with the ears of Bedouins cut off and kept as precious relics? War does not create revolutionary feeling where it does not exist; on the contrary, it depresses it, and where it is weak it crushes it. We are a minority, it is true, but what does it matter? This obliges us to continue our battle. It is a matter of creating the moral autonomy of the working class, which until now has been a passive instrument in the hands of all the bourgeois hierarchies. The danger of European conflagrations will return. But then let us hope we will be ready. One of two things. It is a matter of creating the moral autonomy of the proletariat in order to prevent war. And if the bourgeoisie nevertheless wants to attempt the supreme gamble, the proletariat will know how to take advantage of it for its own specific demands, and then bourgeois rule – already corroded, undermined and worn out – will shatter to pieces. On that day the question of the human race will be united. The new history will begin.