- Context
- Macron spoke at VivaTech 2025 in Paris alongside Nvidia's Jensen Huang and Mistral AI's Arthur Mensch to announce a landmark Nvidia-Mistral AI partnership.
- Main themes
- AI sovereignty, French AI ecosystem, Nvidia-Mistral AI partnership, strategic autonomy, digital infrastructure, computing capacity, European tech competitiveness, AI talent and human capital, cloud independence, startup ecosystem
- Duration
- ~52 min
- Words
- 6,210
- Sentences
- 364
- Readability
- 63
- Grade
- 8.6
- Syntax
- 2.67
- Vocabulary
- 2.10
Translated from French
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other364 sentences in 124 paragraphs
Maurice LÉVY
Why it is important that each nation create its own AI system.
Jensen HUANG
Because you cannot afford to outsource your intelligence, the intelligence of your country and codes and beds, its people's knowledge, history, culture, common sense, values. That is the definition of intelligence. That intelligence cannot be outsourced. You should do everything in your power to try to advance AI here.
Of course, there's nothing wrong with still using public AIs and cloud AIs and such, but you cannot afford to outsource all of it. Especially because you have incredible talent here. France, as you and I were having the great conversation about deep science, deep engineering, deep mathematics. You have the brain trust here, you have the human capital, you have the intellectual capital. We just have to give them the support and the willpower.
Emmanuel MACRON
I have to say, normally I was used to come here and to make a speech for my country, to try to convince people to invest, but this is my very first time with one of the most experienced CEOs coming from the US, I mean the best in class, and doing my job so I can go to bed, I'm finished. But honestly, what Jensen just told us is super important and what is very important is that having the entire world, but the French ecosystem hearing that, the fact that we have all these assets, talents, ecosystem, energy, infrastructure and such a vivid ecosystem of startups. And Arthur is here obviously as a front-runner with Mistral AI.
All these capacities and he's totally right, this is our fight for sovereignty, for strategic autonomy, which is to say we want to keep that. We want our cloud, we want our data centers, we want our computing capacities and we want all the services and infrastructures allowing us to preserve this intelligence, as you perfectly mentioned it, and the diversity, in fact, what we are. And I think the partnership announced today between Nvidia and Mistral AI is for me a historical one. Really. They did a wonderful job because we have, I mean what Arthur and his team did is absolutely unique and we, we want to help them.
In February, during the AI Summit, we launched a lot of projects to have computing capacities and data centers. And I want to thank all of those who launched MJX and some of those who launched very important projects and additional capacities. But now with such a global player, number one, going upstream in the system, we create so many synergies and a complete offer which will provide something unique to all those who want to use both Mistral solutions and Nvidia software, Nvidia solutions and so on. And it creates the capacity for us to scale up, obviously, but a capacity to build actual French and European offer.
I want to thank you for this trust. This is the synergies between two of you and I know that a lot of companies started to commit. So you had the first offsetters, and it was a challenge because we met few days ago, and the main question of was to say, I mean, will we find big companies committing with us and in fact starting to commit to buy solutions and, and join us. In a very few days, I would say the French and Mistral and Nvidia teams managed to have a sufficient number of people and very big cookies. Some of them are in this room. So it means large companies, top-notch French groups, they took the commitment and you launched the offer.
So I want to congratulate you because this is really a game changer. This is a game changer because it will increase our sovereignty, and it will allow us to do much more.
Jensen HUANG
Yeah. Congratulations. Let me say this. I was at the president's office, and I was describing this idea. And I told Mr. President that Arthur, Mistral needs the support of the largest companies in France. And Mr. President says, who are they? Let me call them.
And he called them. And in just a few days, in just a few days, the great companies of France came out to support Arthur and Mistral. And I think it's fantastic. Now, the circulation system business in France could be delivered through businesses in France. This circulation is going to be fantastic for the economy. It's going to be fantastic for starting a young company and getting it bootstrapped. That flywheel will start to go. This is how it happens. And just by asking Mr. President for a little bit of help, he mobilized his team to support us.
Arthur MENSCH
It's a great catalyst and we're very grateful for our launch partners and all of the companies that have agreed to work with us on putting that offer out. And, and there's multiple French companies, there's also German companies and I think that's going to be quite important to have this European focus.
It will be important because we have much to build, we have things to deploy, we have servers to set up, cables to connect and we have software to deploy. And so we're grateful that our existing customers that also companies that we've been working for the last two years are actually supporting that initiative pretty strongly.
Emmanuel MACRON
I think it's super important for obviously Mistral AI and the company, but it's extremely important for exactly what you said, because this is a whole ecosystem working together. We did it for all the startups. Some of them will join us, and a lot of them are in this room. But because we want to be sure that we will be working with European solutions. We want to cooperate with Chinese, American, Korean solutions and so on. But we want to be sure that we will choose this cooperation, but we will not be dependent on them.
It's very important for us precisely because we speak about our intelligence, our brain, our culture, about our history. We want to preserve this level of diversity. If I may say, of the whole restructuring of the industry. But now, we had to secure indeed AI infrastructures. This is what you provide and your solutions and your software and such a global reach that this is a game changer for us because, it will allow us to have more clients and to secure precisely all the synergies.
Now what we want to do, because I raised a question to Jensen, we want now to go upstream. We would have to have more on board. We do have a lot of companies and French companies working with you when you deploy these capacities, Schneider and so on. You mentioned them during our first meeting. But we want to go upstream and have the packaging of the chips in France and the production and the manufacturing of the chips in France.
What we want to do now, we have a great ecosystem there, but I mean the range of chips they produce is much more for the car industry. I speak under your control, but not for AI. And we want to go. If we want to consolidate our industry, we have now to get more and more of the chips at the right scale, meaning lower 2 to 10 nanometers. We just cooked a deal between Thales, Radiall and FoxConn and they will create capacities now to make the packaging of chips in France. Now, next steps, I want to convince them to make the manufacturing in France, to get the whole sovereignty of everything, which will allow us, from the chips to the solutions and the startups to have a complete offer.
But the deal today that these two guys announced is really a game changer for everybody. And I want to encourage all the large companies, but all the startups as well to join this team. Why? Because they will make you stronger. They will guarantee you that you have all the solutions you need with safety, European content, cloud in Europe, solutions controlled and produced here on your soil. You will make them stronger and they will make you stronger, which is exactly how you create synergies in an ecosystem.
My plea is clearly for all of you in this room and all those who are listening to us to team up with the new team announced this morning between Mistral AI and Nvidia.
Arthur MENSCH
It’s really on us as well to deliver the best technology. There's no such thing as a regional tech leader and so we've always been very focused to deliver state of the art models, state of the art products, and we'll be focused on, focused on delivering state of the art infrastructure as well. So you can trust us, we'll do everything we can and we can do a lot to make it happen.
We're very thankful to everybody that has been working with us so far.
Maurice LÉVY
We will continue with the President of the Republic and with some startups for a conversation. Mr. President of the Republic, first of all, I want to thank you because every year, you honor us with your presence.
As every year, you come back, you spend time.
Emmanuel MACRON
I am very happy to see all of you every year, and to see the developments year after year, to also see new startups joining the club, I have seen the Next40 expand with new talents, and then to follow them and to see the new challenges that are ours, because, in the end, we all have the same challenges, which is that we need to change, we need to readjust, sometimes accept that we have things that need to be corrected, succeed in the new challenges, continue to grow. And so, I am very happy about that.
Maurice LÉVY
VivaTech is yours, since when I had this idea and I talked about it with, at the time, those who were Les Echos, which is today the group, Le Parisien Les Echos, you supported us without the slightest hesitation and you have always accompanied and encouraged us. And even, I want to tell you, set goals. You did not hesitate to say, but it is not going fast enough. We absolutely must become number one. We must beat CES.
Emmanuel MACRON
And it is done.
A round of applause for all of you. What has been done in this room.
Maurice LÉVY
And this year is quite exceptional since we are breaking all records and we have very impressive figures. And then, there is something that is extremely important, it is that you are the origin of French Tech. By the way, everyone is very happy to see you wearing the "valiant rooster." VivaTech has had the chance to support this movement to the point where we are today.
I believe it is very important for people to realize how much the strategy you have developed has been fruitful and has become an essential element of the French ecosystem.
Emmanuel MACRON
It is as we have all carried it. I say it again in the times to come, because sometimes, an economic policy or the life of a nation is like all of you. In fact, you must constantly adapt, you want time for your clients, you want time to innovate, you want to transform your models. I speak under your control, I see, entrepreneurs who are joining us. It works if everything else is stable and if you have visibility and if the framework is pro-business.
That is what we did eight years ago with taxes, law, etc. That is also why I always say constantly, it did not work by itself, it works because there is energy that is yours, collectively, and because we created a framework that did everything to give you that energy, by saying, we take care of the rest, we provide visibility, we help you access foreign markets, we help you succeed when it is time to industrialize, we help you innovate, but the rest, stability. I say it collectively to everyone, the 10 years of French Tech and everything that has been done, it is not a spontaneous generation, far from it. It is stability and ambition of an economic policy.
It is a crazy energy of a French and European entrepreneurial ecosystem that wanted to work together and that said, "here, we believe in ourselves, we love ourselves." That is what I want to tell you. France loves its entrepreneurs because you help create jobs, make the world better because these jobs allow for better healthcare, they help meet the ecological challenge, they help change the world for the better.
I want us to continue to have this audacity, to continue to love our entrepreneurs, to help them succeed because it is good for the country and it is good for everyone.
Maurice LÉVY
You are doing it wonderfully well.
We will be joined by our entrepreneurs to debate with the President, we have Thomas Clozel, who is a doctor, a researcher, who created Owkin, a startup using AI, in the service of health and medicine. Eléonore Crespo who is co-founder of Pigment, and it is, we can say, a rising startup, and a startup that is starting to become indispensable to companies. Rachel Delacour, who is a serial entrepreneur, and whose latest creation is Sweep, and who will play, it seems, a major role in reducing carbon emissions. And then Vincent Huguet, also a serial entrepreneur, who has created quite a few companies, including Malt which has become the largest community of freelancers in Europe. Finally, Éléna Poincet, CEO and co-founder of TEHTRIS, the platform dedicated to cybersecurity, which has been much talked about this afternoon and which is already used in several countries.
Mr. President, a small selection of people who are succeeding thanks to the strategy and policy you have implemented. They all have questions to ask you.
Thomas CLOZEL
Mr. President, thank you for inviting us. So I have a rather simple question. In fact, we understand very well the ambitions of the United States on AI. It is to be number one. Their immigration policy, and all their policy is really linked to that objective.
In Europe, I had a straightforward question, and what is really Europe's ambition? What is it? What do we really want to do, especially in technology? And how do you define it?
Emmanuel MACRON
I will be more critical of the American strategy because I think their immigration policy will not allow them to be number one, if you want the bottom line of my thoughts. So they are adopting policies that will not allow them to be number one, because when you chase away talent, you are rarely number one for long.
I believe that the American model historically relied on this remarkable capacity to integrate. The model of Europe, as I have defended it for the past eight years, is, I would define it simply, to become autonomous again in service of a humanist vision. Let me explain. Europe is the cradle of a humanist vision and humanist civilization. It fundamentally places the free and rational individual, those we are, at the center, and thinks about our systems in that way. This has been the case since Antiquity, then the Renaissance, and then the philosophy of the Enlightenment. It is our history, and I believe it is also what we have brought to the world.
What does it mean to be humanist today? It means that we must continue to pursue the struggles for progress, respect, gender equality, and the ability to live together in a society. It now means integrating biodiversity and ecology into this adventure, and having a social model that is the most generous in the world. That is the humanist part. Simply, this humanist part has lost its autonomy in recent decades. It has lost its autonomy because it has endangered its capacity to produce, it has become increasingly dependent on the rest of the world, it has weakened its ability to produce autonomously, and due to a lack of innovation, sometimes out of naivety, it has opened up. What I defend is to say, I do not want to let go of this humanist model.
I do not believe in a Europe that will — sorry, I turn my back — but follow the United States in a model that is sometimes a bit post-humanist. I do not believe in that at all. I believe in the values that are ours. But on the other hand, we must regain strength. That is to say, we need to innovate much more and produce. This is the entire strategy of autonomy and independence that I have defended for eight years. And that is what we are gradually doing. Just look at AI, it is the conversation we had just before. Eighteen months ago, there were no large data centers in France, in Europe. There was even a debate among us about whether we should create them. Many said, should we create them? Not great. We were losing the battle, as we have somewhat lost on the cloud, the sovereign cloud. We have mixed clouds, but we have not really been fully on a sovereign model. Now, we have mobilized. We have several projects for very large data centers. We now have projects, the Mistral team, Nvidia, it is really something that will change, because we are moving up the chain again, we are creating the data center infrastructures, solutions that will be produced in Europe. We have now announced a deal, we will do semiconductor packaging here and we want to be able to produce.
So that is it, regaining our strategic autonomy. And that is also why, for the record, the first time we met with Thomas, it was a breakfast I had in Washington with Americans, he was there.
Because he had gone to the United States. I did not let go of him after saying, Owkin will return to France. Later, when I saw him again, he was at Gustave Roussy. That’s great.
Thomas CLOZEL
But it is an ambition of value, what you are telling us. Is it pragmatic?
Emmanuel MACRON
It is hyper pragmatic, it is not an option. It is values and a strategy. Values, it is humanism. I think what binds us is not a postmodern vision of the world, it is not a strategy. I do not believe in "drill, baby drill." I do not believe in a form of supremacy of one or the other. I am not for a policy of confrontation. But I think there can be a society of progress, a humanism faithful to the history of Europe and France that is much stronger and more powerful in creating wealth and values.
So the strategy behind it is to have a pro-business policy. That is what we have been doing for eight years in France. It is to accelerate now on simplification. For me, it is the key battle of the coming months in France and Europe. It is how we help you to go faster because our problem is that we are far too slow, because we have procedures that are too slow. You, for example, on clinical trials, etc., that is a point on which we need to move.
I would say, meter by meter, how we manage to continue to have a pro-business environment, to simplify the rules, to support the key sectors, to invest in these sectors, and to have a more united Europe, because one of the points of transformation is the day when the European market is really a market of 450 million consumers and inhabitants.
Elena POINCET
Mr. President. I had a question, so I completely agree with what you just said regarding humanism in Europe. The problem that I see at the level of cybersecurity is that Europe is putting in a lot of regulations, GDPR, NIS2, DORA, CSRD, which are a good thing for the protection of our data, for the protection of our environment, etc.
But in the end, there is a lack of a law that could really help us, all European companies, and I do not know if, one day, it will be initiated by France, precisely, to be proposed to the European Commission, it is the Small Business European Act, as the Americans have had since 1953, which allows them to have phenomenal growth and which, we, in Europe, weakens us and does not sometimes allow us to break this glass ceiling that is very hard, because we have to create a subsidiary in Germany, because we have to create a subsidiary in another European country, etc. And we do not benefit from public procurement.
Emmanuel MACRON
So, what you are saying is very true. There are two things. We are fighting, when I say we, because we are with Germany and several others, for there to be European content and for it to be verifiable. What does that mean? This exists at the NAFTA level, that is to say between, precisely, the United States, Mexico, and Canada. It is that sometimes on public markets, but generally on the possibility of having tariffs or not having tariffs, they look at the European content. We do not do that at all today. So that is the first thing to help production on European soil and move in that direction.
The second is what you just said, to have a regime for European SMEs and mid-sized enterprises that is simple and truly applicable to all 28. And we have pushed for this in Franco-German cooperation, it is in the Commission's project. President von der Leyen is creating this 28th regime for start-ups, which will be an options regime. Why is it harder? I try to explain without defending. When you start from 27 systems, it is very hard to converge them on all points.
Elena POINCET
But for regulation, does it work?
Emmanuel MACRON
Because in fact, it is a new system that you are creating. But if you want to create a unique system for all of us, you have to converge all the regulations that could exist. That is to say, if you really want to create a law for SMEs across Europe, you need to converge all labor laws, all corporate tax laws, etc. It is quite hard to converge. The good option is to create a system that is eligible for all companies up to a certain size that are innovative, and we will fight over the criteria, which is actually a 28th regime, but which is the real unified regime.
This option is exactly what you are asking for, and it is what the President of the Commission wants to carry and which we fully support, and which should normally come to fruition in the coming months.
I am like you, I think it changes everything. Because the day when start-ups can incorporate in Europe, they have the same rules, they have the same taxation, they have the same labor law, they have the same criteria, and stability, it changes everything.
Elena POINCET
And access to public procurement.
Emmanuel MACRON
And access to public procurement, that is true in all countries, because public procurement is still managed at the national or even local level. In recent years, we have reformed it to create flexibility and allow integration into that. We cannot change, it is each buyer who is free, but we have put in place the possibility of having innovation content, social content, local content, environmental content, and not just the price, which was the historical rule.
Rachel DELACOUR
I also wanted to make a small point about French Tech. I have been in this tech-entrepreneur circuit for 15 years. I saw the before, I saw the after French Tech. I think all French entrepreneurs starting today benefit from a huge advantage on this tech-entrepreneur scene. Appreciate it, because we who started before, there have been a lot of progress made.
I also wanted to thank the French Tech teams who are loyal to entrepreneurs. And that, frankly, thank you for them. I also thank them for myself, very selfishly. My question is the following.
It also relates a bit to the subject of state purchases. In my climate urgency, of course, there is a European issue, but I obviously want you to act even faster there, right now, at the national level to limit the environmental impact of any entity, whether public or private, the entity must act on its value chain. I just take the example of SNCF, which is one of our major clients. SNCF has done an incredible job in procurement, purchasing, to completely change this policy and decarbonize its value chain. They have a truly phenomenal impact and I already thank them for all of us.
How can you, the French state, actually shift from a policy, when it comes to state purchases, from a policy that is rather budgetary, to a truly industrial, decarbonized policy? You have the power to do it today, to act now, so what are we waiting for to go faster?
Emmanuel MACRON
I am ready for us to engage with you, my teams, even a point-by-point review, because it depends on each buyer. That is to say, there is a tendency to seek the lowest price, because budgets are constrained, and there is a real flaw, which is the lack of multi-annuality.
That is to say, if we want, and this is something we are pushing for and which I believe in and fully share, if we want to succeed at the state level in decarbonizing in the right way, we must not reason in budgetary annuality, which is unfortunately what our system forces us to do, and which makes buyers think too short-term and for themselves, and so they have a constrained budget and tend to buy the cheapest possible. They do not see that the solutions you propose, often the return is made in 2 to 3 years.
In any case, we can always do things by being innovative, so I take the ball and I am ready to do it with you.
Rachel DELACOUR
Thank you, you have heard us.
Emmanuel MACRON
I made the commitment in front of you. But now I will take my time, I will not let you go.
Rachel DELACOUR
With pleasure.
Éléonore CRESPO
Mr. President, first of all, thank you. Because I think that today, in France, there is no better country to innovate, and it is thanks to you, thanks to the action of Clara Chappaz and French Tech.
I think we can create global champions from France today. I am here to stay in France because, precisely, we are capable of doing it from this beautiful country.
So, thank you for all the action.
On the topics we are addressing today for children, the protection of children, very important. My question is: today, with artificial intelligence, we, Pigment, a big issue is the attractiveness of talent. And we have today, I think, the potential to attract many more talents from outside Europe, to France, and also to train them very quickly. But we will have to go very, very fast.
What action do you want us to take, we and you, with the Government, to train, attract, and retain talent, to really be able to be very competitive in the field of AI and deep tech?
Emmanuel MACRON
Thank you very much. This is one of the key points, talent, because if we look at AI, we have a huge advantage which is energy. Today, we have an advantage, it is indeed talent. We will continue to train them, and with the various plans we have put in place, we continue to rise. Earlier, we were with the AI Cluster in Saclay, which will open, I believe, 40,000 or 50,000 training programs next school year. We have increased our offerings across the territory, so that is key.
Now, we need to keep them. For me, to keep them, it is really about continuing to have maximum activity and to seek out, in these 9 AI Clusters we have set up, the talents who will graduate from school, and to have this solidarity. I am struck because, thank you, for the words you have for Clara, for all the successive ministers that have been, for the teams of FrenchTech, and thank you, because they are exceptional, the teams also from BPI, the ministry, and others, but it is an ecosystem that has been formed. And what I really like is that I see all of you evolving.
First of all, I see the friendships that have been formed, the solidarities, including in the difficult moments of business life, that this club, that this team has the reflex to seek out in schools, and that we have this mapping, and that we go seek these talents, and that we go, in a way, pitch to the younger ones to show them that there are future opportunities, and that in fact, here, I believe there is a balance, the ability to undertake, perspectives, because we have a real market depth and that you are all a nice and innovative ecosystem, which I find will last over time, and that the quality of life in our country is a very important point.
Many people who sometimes have the desire to go abroad who have gone, and it is a chance when they return from the other side of the planet. Sometimes, they forget that they will have children and that school is much more expensive, that the healthcare system is much more expensive on the other side of the planet. So I have all the tools to bring people back when they have gone to systems that seemed much more appealing at first glance.
Honestly, succeeding in developing businesses in France when the framework remains as pro-business as it is, is unique. I think our best chance to succeed in convincing young people to be trained, but to keep our talents, which is the obsession, and to help them grow, is just you. And it is that we have a team organization so that you go to the exit of our engineering schools, of our training programs, including, by the way, PhDs, of all those who come out of our research centers and our labs, to attract as many as possible.
Vincent HUGUET
To return precisely to these issues of talent and also the Small Business Act, we have a regime here in France with the BSPCE which I think is the best in Europe. My company operates in several countries in Europe and I can confirm that.
How do we export it somewhere? Instead of reinventing, why don’t we copy this model and create the 28th regime on this basis? And in the same way, this French Tech which I think is also unique, how do we make it a European Tech? Maybe we won’t have a rooster anymore, but I don’t know, the European flag here, but how do we scale up? Because we need this continental scale all the time we are around the table.
Emmanuel MACRON
So, I completely agree. I think that first, the Commission will do this work, so it is up to us to feed it. It would be my responsibility to do this work, I would just take in each country the system that is the most competitive. You are right, I think that on many systems, we really have something that is very competitive. Undoubtedly on other approaches, we have neighboring countries that are more so, but I think we have created an ecosystem that is quite exceptional.
Now, on SMEs, there are also European systems that will do this work. So it is up to us to feed it, and it is in the coming months that we must do this job. After that, we have tried in recent years to do what you say, and I think we must not give up. That is to say, we have set up the Tibi funds, the scale-up, which has allowed us to increase the tickets in France, and we have raised amounts and we have raised much larger quantities. We have been number 1 and we are still number 1 on this. Under the French presidency, we did everything to Europeanize it. We did this Scale-up Tour under the French presidency which was to create a European Tibi.
We have tried in every area to do this, and especially for our start-ups to expand. If we really want to go all the way and create a European French Tech, we need to have a French Tech regime at the European level, so we can draw from our practices and have something even more competitive than us. We need to have this unique European capital market. That, for me, is really the heart of the battle. It may seem a bit technical and boring, but it is super important. It is that Europe, just to give you an idea of the stakes, Europe is the space in the world where there is the most savings. More than in the United States, more than in Asia. It is the place in the world where there is the most savings.
Simply, this savings remains in the wrong place, that is to say it is in the countries that are already rich, it does not go into the right sectors, it goes far too much into bond financing. Because it is, in fact, trapped in banks and insurance companies to which we have imposed regulatory rules that prevent it from going towards innovation. That is why our battle is to create a large securitization program to get it off their balance sheets and allow it to go towards equity, innovation, and to enable a unique capital market so that it goes much more towards equity and innovation in Europe.
Because today, this savings, when it wants to seek risk, it goes to seek it in American asset managers, which is madness. So that is an absolutely key battle. It is what we said, it is to integrate our European markets much more on their rules, that is to say to deepen the digital market, but even all sectoral markets. For example, in health, if we want to go much faster, that is why it is really a sector-by-sector European job, but we must go for it and take our spade and not give up. But if we want there to be a real single health market, we should not actually have 27 authorization agencies, but we should accept to have a single authorization agency.
Today, we have one in Europe, but then we go back in front of each agency at the French level. They do not have the same rules, not the same protocols. And under Thomas's control, clinical trials do not have the same protocols or the same timelines between Spain and France. In this case, they are better than us. So it is completely absurd. And that is what makes it so that we do not yet have a real single market. Essentially, we are shooting ourselves in the foot. So that, for me, is the heart of the European agenda for the coming years. It is what we are defending very strongly in the Franco-German context, and it is what we will really push with the European Commission.
Maurice LÉVY
Mr. President, I would like to warmly thank you and perhaps you can say a word of conclusion.
Emmanuel MACRON
First of all, I will meet again with entrepreneurs and investors because at the Élysée, we will continue the work. And I believe that Maurice Lévy has indeed provided practical work. So it is to continue to move forward.
First of all, thank you for your time and for being here. I have a few simple words. I am very proud of you, collectively, of all the work that has been done, of what has been built and of what you are doing with your teams in all sectors. Nothing was written ten years ago and you are making it happen. Then, I know how precarious all this is, as you know in your companies, and so we continue the fight and we must not give up anything. And so what I ask of you is to continue to have the same energy and the same confidence in the country. I love the energy you exude. Deep down, you are demanding, but each time with a will for us to do better.
So, keep faith in our country, in its capacity to transform, because you are the actors. And continue to convince everyone that they are the actors. We do not give up anything and I will not give up anything. So, thank you very much.
The original French. The tags above are read on the English translation's sentences.
Maurice LÉVY
Why it is important that each nation create its own AI system.
Jensen HUANG
Because you cannot afford to outsource your intelligence, the intelligence of your country and codes and beds, its people's knowledge, history, culture, common sense, values. That is the definition of intelligence. That intelligence cannot be outsourced. You should do everything in your power to try to advance AI here.
Of course, there's nothing wrong with still using public AIs and cloud AIs and such, but you cannot afford to outsource all of it. Especially because you have incredible talent here. France, as you and I were having the great conversation about deep science, deep engineering, deep mathematics. You have the brain trust here, you have the human capital, you have the intellectual capital. We just have to give them the support and the willpower.
Emmanuel MACRON
I have to say, normally I was used to come here and to make a speech for my country, to try to convince people to invest, but this is my very first time with one of the most experienced CEO coming from the US, I mean the best in class, and doing my job so I can go to bed, I'm finished. But honestly, what Jensen just told us is super important and what is very important is that having the entire world, but the French ecosystem hearing that, the fact that we have all these assets, talents, ecosystem, energy, infrastructure and such a vivid ecosystem of startups. And Arthur is here obviously as a front-runner with Mistral AI.
All these capacities and he's totally right, this is our fight for sovereignty, for strategic autonomy, which is to say we want to keep that. We want our cloud, we want our data centers, we want our computing capacities and we want all the services and infrastructures allowing us to preserve this intelligence, as you perfectly mentioned it, and the diversity, in fact, what we are. And I think the partnership announced today between Nvidia and Mistral AI is for me an historical one. Really. They did a wonderful job because we have, I mean what Arthur and his team did is absolutely unique and we, we want to help them.
In February, during the AI Summit, we launched a lot of projects to have computing capacities and data centers. And I want to thank all of those who launched MJX and some of those who launched very important projects and additional capacities. But now with such a global player, number one, going upstream in the system, we create so many synergies and a complete offer which will provide something unique to all those who want to use both Mistral solutions and Nvidia software, Nvidia solutions and so on. And it creates the capacity for us to scale up, obviously, but a capacity to build actual French and European offer.
I want to thank you for this trust. This is the synergies between two of you and I know that a lot of companies started to commit. So you had the first offsetters, and it was a challenge because we met few days ago, and the main question of was to say, I mean, will we find big companies committing with us and in fact starting to commit to buy solutions and, and join us. In a very few days, I would say the French and Mistral and Nvidia teams managed to have a sufficient number of people and very big cookies. Some of them are in this room. So it means large companies, top-notch French groups, they took the commitment and you launched the offer.
So I want to congratulate you because this is really a game changer. This is a game changer because it will increase our sovereignty, and it will allow us to do much more.
Jensen HUANG
Yeah. Congratulations. Let me say this. I was at the president's office, and I was describing this idea. And I told Mr. President that Arthur, Mistral needs the support of the largest companies in France. And Mr. President says, who are they? Let me call them.
And he called them. And in just a few days, in just a few days, the great companies of France came out to support Arthur and Mistral. And I think it's fantastic. Now, the circulation system business in France could be delivered through businesses in France. This circulation is going to be fantastic for the economy. It's going to be fantastic for starting a young company and getting it bootstrapped. That flywheel will start to go. This is how it happens. And just by asking Mr. President for a little bit of help, he mobilized his team to support us.
Arthur MENSCH
It's a great catalyst and we're very grateful for our launch partners and all of the companies that have agreed to work with us on putting that offer out. And, and there's multiple French companies, there's also German companies and I think that's going to be quite important to have this European focus.
It will be important because we have much to build, we have things to deploy, we have servers to set up, cables to connect and we have software to deploy. And so we're grateful that our existing customers that also companies that we've been working for the last two years are actually supporting that initiative pretty strongly.
Emmanuel MACRON
I think it's super important for obviously Mistral AI and the company, but it's extremely important for exactly what you said, because this is a whole ecosystem working together. We did it for all the startups. Some of them will join us, and a lot of them are in this room. But because we want to be sure that we will be working with European solutions. We want to cooperate with Chinese, American, Korean solutions and so on. But we want to be sure that we will choose this cooperation, but we will not be dependent on them.
It's very important for us precisely because we speak about our intelligence, our brain, our culture, about our history. We want to preserve this level of diversity. If I may say, of the whole restructuring of the industry. But now, we had to secure indeed AI infrastructures. This is what you provide and your solutions and your software and such a global reach that this is a game changer for us because, it will allow us to have more clients and to secure precisely all the synergies.
Now what we want to do, because I raised a question to Jensen, we want now to go upstream. We would have to have more on board. We do have a lot of companies and French companies working with you when you deploy these capacities, Schneider and so on. You mentioned them during our first meeting. But we want to go upstream and have the packaging of the chips in France and the production and the manufacturing of the chips in France.
What we want to do now, we have a great ecosystem there, but I mean the range of chips they produce is much more for the car industry. I speak under your control, but not for AI. And we want to go. If we want to consolidate our industry, we have now to get more and more of the chips at the right scale, meaning lower 2 to 10 nanometers. We just cooked a deal between Thales, Radiall and FoxConn and they will create capacities now to make the packaging of chips in France. Now, next steps, I want to convince them to make the manufacturing in France, to get the whole sovereignty of everything, which will allow us, from the chips to the solutions and the startups to have a complete offer.
But the deal today that these two guys announced is really a game changer for everybody. And I want to encourage all the large companies, but all the startups as well to join this team. Why ? Because they will make you stronger. They will guarantee you that you have all the solutions you need with safety, European content, cloud in Europe, solutions controlled and produced here on your soil. You will make them stronger and they will make you stronger, which is exactly how you create synergies in an ecosystem.
My plea is clearly for all of you in this room and all those who are listening to us to team up with the new team announced this morning between Mistral AI and Nvidia.
Arthur MENSCH
It’s really on us as well to deliver the best technology. There's no such thing as a regional tech leader and so we've always been very focused to deliver state of the art models, state of the art products, and we'll be focused on, focused on delivering state of the art infrastructure as well. So you can trust us, we'll do everything we can and we can do a lot to make it happen.
We're very thankful to everybody that has been working with us so far.
Maurice LÉVY
Nous allons continuer avec le Président de la République et avec quelques start-ups pour une conversation. Monsieur le Président de la République, avant toute chose, je tiens à vous remercier parce que chaque année, vous nous honorez de votre présence.
Comme chaque année, vous revenez, vous passez du temps.
Emmanuel MACRON
Je suis chaque année très heureux de vous retrouver toutes et tous, et de voir les évolutions année après année, de voir aussi de nouvelles start-ups qui joignent le club, j'ai vu le Next40 s'élargir avec de nouveaux talents, et puis de les suivre et de voir aussi les nouveaux défis qui sont les nôtres, parce qu'au fond, on a tous les mêmes défis, c'est-à-dire qu'il faut changer, nous réadapter, parfois accepter qu'on ait des choses qui sont à corriger, réussir les nouveaux défis, continuer de croître. Et donc, je suis très heureux de ça.
Maurice LÉVY
VivaTech, c'est chez vous, puisque lorsque j'avais eu cette idée et que j'en avais parlé avec, à l'époque, ceux qui étaient Les Echos, qui est aujourd'hui le groupe, Le Parisien Les Echos, vous nous aviez soutenus sans la moindre hésitation et vous nous avez toujours accompagnés et encouragés. Et même, ça, je tiens à vous le dire, donnez des objectifs. Vous n'avez pas hésité à dire, mais ça ne va pas assez vite. Il faut absolument devenir numéro un. Il faut battre le CES.
Emmanuel MACRON
Et c'est fait.
Un bravo à vous tous. Ce qui a été fait dans cette salle.
Maurice LÉVY
Et cette année, c'est une année assez exceptionnelle puisqu'on bat tous les records et nous avons des chiffres très impressionnants. Et puis, il y a quelque chose qui est extrêmement important, c'est que vous êtes à l'origine de la French Tech. D'ailleurs, tout le monde est très content de vous voir porter le « coq vaillant ». VivaTech a eu la chance d'accompagner ce mouvement au point où nous en sommes aujourd'hui.
Je crois qu'il est très important que les gens se rendent compte à quel point la stratégie que vous avez développée a été payante et est devenue un élément essentiel de l'écosystème français.
Emmanuel MACRON
C'est tel qu'on l'a tous porté. Je le redis dans les temps qui viennent, parce qu’il en est, parfois, d'une politique économique ou de la vie d'une nation comme de vous tous et toutes. En fait, vous devez vous adapter en permanence, vous voulez du temps pour vos clients, vous voulez du temps pour innover, vous voulez transformer vos modèles. Je parle sous le contrôle, je vois, d'entrepreneuses et d'entrepreneurs qui sont en train de nous rejoindre. Ça marche si tout le reste est stable et si vous avez de la visibilité et que le cadre est pro-business.
C'est ce qu'on a fait il y a 8 ans avec les impôts, le droit, etc. C'est pour ça aussi que je dis toujours constamment, ça n'a pas marché tout seul, ça marche parce qu'il y a de l'énergie qui est la vôtre, collectivement, et parce qu'on a créé un cadre qui a tout fait pour vous donner cette énergie, en vous disant, on s'occupe du reste, on donne de la visibilité, on vous aide à accéder aux marchés extérieurs, on vous aide à réussir quand il faut industrialiser, on vous aide à innover, mais le reste, stabilité. Je le dis collectivement à tout le monde, les 10 ans de la French Tech et tout ce qui a été fait, ce n'est pas une génération spontanée, loin de là. C'est de la stabilité et de l'ambition d'une politique économique.
C'est une énergie folle d'un écosystème entrepreneurial français et européen qui a voulu travailler ensemble et qui a dit, « ici, on croit en nous, on nous aime ». C'est ce que je veux vous dire. La France, elle aime ses entrepreneuses et ses entrepreneurs parce que vous aidez, à créer des emplois, à rendre le monde meilleur parce que ces emplois, ils permettent de soigner mieux, ils permettent de relever le défi de l'écologie, ils permettent de changer le monde dans le bon sens.
Je veux qu'on continue à avoir cette audace, qu'on continue à aimer nos entrepreneuses et nos entrepreneurs, à les aider à réussir parce que c'est bon pour le pays et c'est bon pour tout le monde.
Maurice LÉVY
Vous le faites formidablement bien.
Nous allons être rejoints par nos entrepreneurs pour débattre avec le Président, nous avons Thomas Clozel, qui est un médecin, un chercheur, qui a créé Owkin, une start-up utilisant l'IA, au service de la santé et de la médecine. Eléonore Crespo qui est cofondatrice de Pigment, et c'est, on peut dire, une start up qui monte, et une start up qui commence à devenir indispensable aux entreprises. Rachel Delacour, qui, elle, est serial entrepreneuse, et dont le dernier-né est Sweep, et qui va jouer, paraît-il, un rôle majeur pour réduire les émissions de carbone. Et puis Vincent Huguet, lui aussi serial entrepreneur, qui a créé pas beaucoup de boîtes, dont Malt devenue la plus grande communauté de freelances en Europe. Pour terminer, Éléna Poincet, PDG et cofondatrice de TEHTRIS, la plateforme dédiée à la cybersécurité, dont on a beaucoup parlé cet après-midi et qui est déjà employée dans pas mal de pays.
M. le Président, une petite sélection des gens qui réussissent grâce à la stratégie et à la politique que vous avez mise en œuvre. Ils ont toutes et tous des questions à vous poser.
Thomas CLOZEL
Monsieur le Président, merci de nous inviter. Alors moi, j'ai une question assez simple. En fait, on comprend très bien les ambitions des États-Unis sur l'IA. C'est être numéro 1. Leur politique migratoire, et toute leur politique est vraiment liée, à cet objectif-là.
En Europe, j'avais une question franche, et quelle est vraiment l'ambition de l'Europe ? C'est quoi ? Qu'est-ce qu'on veut vraiment faire, notamment en technologie ? Et comment vous le définissez ?
Emmanuel MACRON
Je serai plus critique sur la stratégie américaine, parce que je pense que leur politique migratoire ne permettra pas d'être numéro 1, si vous voulez le fond de ma pensée. Donc ils se dotent de politiques qui ne permettront pas, parce que quand on chasse les talents, on est rarement numéro 1 longtemps.
Je pense que le modèle américain reposait historiquement sur cette capacité à intégrer, qui était remarquable. Le modèle de l'Europe, moi, tel qu'en tout cas, je le défends depuis 8 ans, c'est, je le définirai de manière simple, de redevenir autonome au service d'une vision humaniste. Je m'explique. L'Europe, c'est le berceau d'une vision humaniste et de civilisation humaniste. C'est mettre au fond l'individu libre et rationnel, ceux que nous sommes, au cœur, et de penser à nos systèmes comme ça. C'est ce qui a été dès l'Antiquité, puis la Renaissance, puis la philosophie des Lumières. C'est notre histoire, c'est, je crois aussi, ce qu'on a apporté au monde.
Qu'est-ce que c'est être humaniste aujourd'hui ? C'est de se dire que les combats de progrès, on doit continuer de les poursuivre, le respect, l'égalité femmes-hommes, la capacité, justement, à vivre ensemble dans une société. C'est maintenant intégrer la biodiversité et l'écologie dans cette aventure, et c'est d'avoir un modèle social qui est le plus généreux du monde. Ça, c'est la partie humaniste. Simplement, cette partie humaniste, elle a perdu son autonomie ces dernières décennies. C'est-à-dire qu'elle a perdu son autonomie parce qu'elle a mis en danger sa capacité à produire, elle est devenue de plus en plus dépendante du reste du monde, elle a fragilisé sa capacité à produire de manière autonome, et par manque d'innovation, parfois par naïveté, elle s'est ouverte. Ce que je défends, c'est de dire, j'ai pas envie de lâcher ce modèle humaniste.
Moi, je ne crois pas à une Europe qui va — pardon, je tourne le dos — mais suivre les États-Unis dans un modèle qui est parfois un peu post-humaniste. Je ne crois pas du tout à ça. Je crois aux valeurs qui sont les nôtres. Mais par contre, on doit retrouver du muscle. C'est-à-dire qu'il faut qu'on arrive à innover beaucoup plus à produire. C'est toute cette stratégie d'autonomie, d'indépendance que je défends depuis 8 ans. Et c'est ce qu'on est en train de faire progressivement. Regardez juste sur l'IA, c'est la conversation qu'on avait juste avant. Il y a 18 mois, il n'y avait pas de gros data center en France, en Europe. Il y avait même un débat chez nous pour savoir s'il fallait en faire. Beaucoup disaient, est-ce qu'il faut en faire ? Pas génial. On était en train de perdre la bataille, comme on l'a un peu perdu sur le cloud, le cloud souverain. On a des clouds mixtes, mais on n'a pas été vraiment totalement sur un modèle souverain. Là, on s'est mobilisés. On a plusieurs projets de très gros data centers. On a maintenant des projets, l'équipe Mistral, Nvidia, c'est vraiment quelque chose qui va changer, parce qu'on remonte encore dans la chaîne, on crée les infrastructures de data centers, des solutions qui vont être produites en Europe. On a annoncé maintenant un deal, on va faire du packaging de semi-conducteurs chez nous et on veut pouvoir produire.
Donc c'est ça, retrouver notre autonomie stratégique. Et c'est aussi pour ça, parce que pour la petite histoire, la première fois qu'on s'est vu avec Thomas, c'était un petit déjeuner que j'ai fait à Washington avec des Américains, il était là.
Parce qu'il était parti aux États-Unis. Je ne l'ai plus lâché après en disant, Owkin reviendra en France. Après, quand je l'ai revu, il était à Gustave Roussy. C'est super.
Thomas CLOZEL
Mais c'est une ambition de valeur, ce que vous nous dites. Est-ce que c'est pragmatique ?
Emmanuel MACRON
C'est hyper pragmatique, ce n'est pas une option. C'est des valeurs et une stratégie. Des valeurs, c'est l'humanisme. Je pense que ce qui nous lie, ce n'est pas une vision du monde postmoderne, ce n'est pas une stratégie. Moi, je ne crois pas au « drill, baby drill ». Je ne crois pas à une forme de suprématie de tel ou tel. Je ne suis pas pour une politique de la confrontation. Mais je pense qu'il peut y avoir une société du progrès, un humanisme fidèle à l'histoire de l'Europe et de la France qui soit beaucoup plus fort et puissant sur la création de richesses et de valeurs.
Donc la stratégie qu'il y a derrière, c'est avoir une politique pro-business. C'est ce qu'on fait depuis huit ans en France. C'est d'accélérer maintenant sur la simplification. Pour moi, c'est la bataille clé des prochains mois en France et en Europe. C'est comment on vous aide à aller plus vite parce que notre problème, c'est qu'on est beaucoup trop lent, parce qu'on a des procédures trop lentes. Vous par exemple, sur les tests cliniques, etc., c'est un point sur lequel il faut qu'on bouge.
Je dirais, mètre après mètre, comment on arrive, justement, à continuer à avoir un environnement pro-business, à simplifier les règles, à accompagner les secteurs qui sont clés, à investir dans ces secteurs et à avoir une Europe plus unie, parce qu'un des points de transformation, c'est le jour où le marché européen, c'est vraiment un marché à 450 millions de consommateurs et d'habitants.
Elena POINCET
Monsieur le Président. J'avais une question, donc je suis complètement d'accord avec ce que vous venez de dire concernant l'humanisme en Europe. Le problème que moi, je rends compte au niveau de la cybersécurité, c'est que l'Europe met beaucoup de régulations, RGPD, NIS2, DORA, CSRD, qui sont une bonne chose pour la protection de nos datas, pour la protection de notre environnement, etc.
Mais au final, il manque une loi qui pourrait vraiment nous aider, toutes les sociétés européennes, et je ne sais pas si, un jour, elle va être à l'initiative de la France, justement, pour être proposée à la Commission européenne, c'est le Small Business European Act, comme les Américains l'ont depuis 1953, et qui leur permettent, justement, d'avoir une croissance phénoménale et qui, nous, en Europe, nous fragilise et ne nous permet pas, quelquefois, de casser ce plafond de verre qui est très dur, parce qu'il faut créer une filiale en Allemagne, parce qu'il faut créer une filiale dans un autre pays européen, etc. Et on ne bénéficie pas de la commande publique.
Emmanuel MACRON
Alors, ce que vous dites est très juste. Il y a deux choses. Nous, on se bat, quand je dis nous, parce qu'on est avec l'Allemagne et plusieurs autres, pour qu'il y ait un contenu européen et qu'il soit vérifiable. Qu'est-ce que ça veut dire ? Ça, ça existe à l'échelle du NAFTA, c'est-à-dire entre, justement, États-Unis, Mexique et Canada. C'est que sur parfois des marchés publics, mais en général sur la possibilité d'avoir des tarifs ou pas des tarifs, ils regardent le contenu européen. Nous, on ne le fait absolument pas aujourd'hui. Donc ça, c'est la première chose pour aider à la production sur le sol européen et avancer dans ce sens.
La deuxième, c'est ce que vous venez de dire, c'est avoir un régime pour les PME et les ETI européennes qui soit simple et vraiment à 28. Et ça, on a poussé en franco-allemand, c'est dans le projet de la Commission. La Présidente von der Leyen est en train de créer ce 28e régime pour justement les start-ups et qui sera un régime d'options. Pourquoi c'est plus dur ? J'essaie d'expliquer sans défendre. Quand on part de 27 systèmes, c'est très dur de les faire converger sur tous les points.
Elena POINCET
Mais pour la régulation, ça marche ?
Emmanuel MACRON
Parce qu'en fait, c'est un système nouveau que vous créez. Mais si vous voulez créer un système unique pour nous tous, vous devez faire converger toute la régulation qui pourrait exister. C'est-à-dire, si vous voulez créer vraiment un droit pour les PME partout en Europe, il faut faire converger tous les droits du travail, tous les droits de la corporate taxe, etc. C'est assez dur à faire converger. La bonne option, c'est de créer un système qui est éligible pour toutes les entreprises jusqu'à une certaine taille qui sont innovantes, et on va se battre sur les critères, qui est en fait un 28e régime, mais qui est le vrai régime unifié.
Cette option, c'est exactement ce que vous demandez, et c'est ce que veut porter la présidente de la Commission et qu'on soutient à fond, et qui, normalement, doit aboutir dans les prochains mois.
Je suis comme vous, je pense que ça change tout. Parce que le jour où les start-ups peuvent s'incorporer en Europe, elles ont les mêmes règles, elles ont la même fiscalité, elles ont le même droit du travail, elles ont les mêmes critères, et de la stabilité, ça change tout.
Elena POINCET
Et l'accès au marché public.
Emmanuel MACRON
Et l'accès au marché public, ça, c'est vrai dans tous les pays, parce que le marché public, il est encore géré à l'échelle nationale, voire locale. Ces dernières années, on l'a réformé pour créer de la souplesse et permettre d'intégrer à cela. On ne peut pas changer, c'est chaque acheteur qui est libre, mais on a mis la possibilité d'avoir le contenu innovation, le contenu social, le contenu local, le contenu environnemental, et pas simplement le prix qui était la règle historique.
Rachel DELACOUR
Je tenais juste aussi à refaire un micro-point sur la French Tech. Moi, ça fait 15 ans que je suis dans ce circuit tech-entrepreneur. J'ai vu l'avant, j'ai vu l'après la French Tech. Je pense que tous les entrepreneurs français qui démarrent aujourd'hui, vous bénéficiez quand même d'un énorme plus sur cette scène de tech-entrepreneur. Appréciez-le, parce que nous qui avons commencé avant, il y a eu énormément de progrès qui ont été faits.
Je tenais à remercier aussi les équipes de la French Tech qui sont fidèles aux entrepreneurs. Et ça, franchement, merci pour eux. Je les remercie aussi pour moi, à titre très égoïste. Ma question est la suivante.
Ça rejoint aussi un petit peu le sujet des achats de l'État. Moi, dans mon urgence climat, bien sûr qu'il y a un sujet européen, mais j'ai bien évidemment envie que vous agissiez encore plus vite là, tout de suite, au niveau national pour limiter l'impact environnemental de n'importe quelle entité, qu'elle soit publique ou privée, l'entité doit agir sur sa chaîne de valeur. Je prends juste l'exemple de la SNCF qui est l'un de nos grands clients. La SNCF a fait un travail de dingue au niveau du procurement, des achats, pour complètement changer cette politique-là et décarboner sa chaîne de valeur. Ils ont vraiment un impact assez phénoménal et je les en remercie déjà pour nous tous.
Comment est-ce que vous, l'État français, vous pouvez en fait passer finalement d'une politique, quand il s'agit des achats de l'État, d'une politique qui est plutôt budgétaire, à une politique vraiment industrielle, décarbonée ? Vous avez ce pouvoir de le faire aujourd'hui, d'agir maintenant, donc, qu'est-ce qu'on attend pour aller plus vite ?
Emmanuel MACRON
Moi, je suis prêt à ce qu'on engage avec vous, mes équipes, même un examen au point par point,
parce que ça dépend de chaque acheteur. C'est-à-dire qu'il y a une tendance à aller chercher le prix le plus bas, parce que les budgets sont contraints, et il y a un vrai défaut, qui est le manque de pluriannualité.
C'est-à-dire que si on veut, et ça, c'est quelque chose qu'on est en train de pousser et auquel je crois et je partage totalement, si on veut réussir au niveau de l'État à décarboner de la bonne manière, il ne faut pas raisonner en annualité budgétaire, ce qui est malheureusement ce que notre système nous oblige à faire, et ce qui fait que les acheteurs raisonnent trop à court terme et pour eux-mêmes, et donc ils ont un budget contraint et ils ont tendance à acheter le moins cher possible. Ils ne vont pas voir que les solutions que vous proposez, souvent le retour, il se fait en 2 ans à 3 ans.
De toute façon, on peut toujours faire des choses en étant innovants, donc moi, je prends la balle au bond et je suis prêt à le faire avec vous.
Rachel DELACOUR
Merci, vous nous avez entendu.
Emmanuel MACRON
J'ai pris l'engagement devant vous. Mais donc là je vais vous prendre du temps, je ne vais pas vous lâcher.
Rachel DELACOUR
Avec plaisir.
Éléonore CRESPO
Monsieur le Président, déjà, merci. Parce que je pense qu'aujourd'hui, en France, il n'y a pas un meilleur pays pour innover, et c'est grâce à vous, grâce à l'action de Clara Chappaz et de la FrenchTech.
Je pense qu'on peut créer aujourd'hui des champions mondiaux depuis la France. Moi, je suis là pour rester en France, parce que, justement, on est capable de le faire depuis ce beau pays.
Donc, merci pour toute l'action.
Sur les sujets qu'on est en train de traiter aujourd'hui pour les enfants, la protection des enfants, très important. Ma question, c'est : aujourd'hui, avec l'intelligence artificielle, nous, Pigment, un gros sujet est l'attractivité des talents. Et on a aujourd'hui, je pense, le potentiel d'attirer beaucoup plus de talents venant d'en dehors de l’Europe, en France, et aussi de les former très vite. Mais il va falloir aller très très vite.
Quelle est l'action que vous voulez qu'on prenne, nous et vous, avec le Gouvernement, pour former, attirer, retenir les talents, pour être capables vraiment d'être très compétitifs dans le secteur de l'IA et des deep-tech ?
Emmanuel MACRON
Merci beaucoup. C'est un des points clés, les talents, parce que si on regarde l'IA, on a un énorme avantage qui est l'énergie. On a aujourd'hui un avantage, c'est en effet les talents. On va continuer d'en former, et avec les différents plans qu'on a mis en place, on continue à monter. Tout à l'heure, on était avec le Cluster IA, de Saclay, qui va ouvrir, je crois, 40 000 ou 50 000 formations à la rentrée prochaine. On a augmenté notre offre partout sur le territoire, donc ça, c'est clé.
Maintenant, il faut les garder. Pour moi, pour les garder, c'est vraiment de continuer à avoir une activité maximale et d'aller chercher, dans ces 9 Clusters IA qu'on a mis en place, les talents qui vont sortir d'école, et d'avoir cette solidarité. Moi, je suis frappé, parce que, merci, des mots que vous avez pour Clara, pour tous les ministres successifs qu'il y a eu, pour les équipes de la FrenchTech, et merci, parce qu'elles sont extras, les équipes aussi de BPI, du ministère et autres, mais c'est qu'un écosystème qui s'est constitué. Et moi, ce qui me plaît beaucoup, c'est que je vous vois tous évoluer.
D'abord, je vois les amitiés qui se sont nouées, les solidarités, y compris dans les moments difficiles de la vie des entreprises, que ce club, que cette équipe ait le réflexe d'aller chercher dans les écoles, et qu'on ait bien cette cartographie, et qu'on aille chercher ces talents, et qu'on aille, en quelque sorte, pitcher les plus jeunes pour leur montrer qu'il y a des capacités d'avenir, et qu'en fait, ici, je crois qu'il y a un équilibre, la capacité à entreprendre, des perspectives, parce qu'on a une vraie profondeur de marché et que vous êtes tous un écosystème, je trouve, sympa et innovant,, qu'il y en aura dans la durée, et que la qualité de vie dans notre pays est un point très important.
Beaucoup de gens qui ont parfois le désir du large qui sont allés, et c'est une chance quand ils reviennent à l'autre bout de la planète. Parfois, ils oublient qu'ils vont avoir des enfants et que l'école est beaucoup plus chère, que le système de santé est beaucoup plus cher à l'autre bout de la planète. Donc moi, j'ai tout le kit pour faire revenir les gens quand ils sont partis dans des systèmes qui paraissaient beaucoup plus sympathiques de prime abord.
Honnêtement, réussir à développer des entreprises en France quand le cadre reste comme il est pro-business, c'est unique. Je pense que notre meilleure chance pour réussir à convaincre des jeunes d'être formés, mais garder nos talents, ce qui est l'obsession, et les faire grandir, c'est juste vous. Et c'est qu'on ait une organisation en équipe pour que vous alliez à la sortie de nos écoles d'ingénieurs, de nos formations, y compris, d'ailleurs, des PhD, de tous ceux qui sortent de nos centres de recherche et de nos labos, pour pouvoir en attirer un maximum.
Vincent HUGUET
Pour revenir justement sur ces sujets de talent et aussi de Small Business Act, on a justement un régime ici en France avec les BSPCE qui est, je pense, le meilleur d'Europe. Mon entreprise est sur plusieurs pays d'Europe et je peux le confirmer.
Comment on fait pour l'exporter quelque part ? Au lieu de réinventer, pourquoi on ne copie pas ce modèle-là et on crée le 28e régime sur cette base ? Et de la même façon, cette French Tech qui est, je pense, aussi unique, comment on en fait une European Tech ? Peut-être qu'on n'aura plus un coq, mais je ne sais pas, le drapeau européen ici, mais comment on passe à l'échelle ? Parce qu'on a besoin de cette échelle continentale tout ce temps qu'on est autour de la table.
Emmanuel MACRON
Alors, je suis 100 % d'accord. Je pense que d'abord, la Commission va faire ce travail, donc c'est à nous de la nourrir. Il me reviendrait de faire ce travail, je prendrais juste dans chaque pays le système qui est le plus compétitif. Vous avez raison, je pense que sur beaucoup de systèmes, on a vraiment quelque chose qui est très compétitif. Sans doute sur d'autres approches, on a des pays voisins qui le sont davantage, mais je pense qu'on a créé un écosystème qui est assez exceptionnel.
Maintenant, sur les PME, il y a des systèmes aussi européens qui vont faire ce travail. Donc c'est à nous de le nourrir, et c'est dans les mois qui viennent qu'on doit faire ce job. Après, on a essayé ces dernières années de faire ce que vous dites, et je pense qu'il ne faut pas lâcher. C'est-à-dire qu'on a mis en place les fonds Tibi, le scale-up, qui a permis d'accroître les tickets en France, et on a levé des sommes et on a levé des quantités beaucoup plus importantes. On a été numéro 1 et on est encore numéro 1 là-dessus. Sous présidence française, on a tout fait pour l'européaniser. On a fait ce Scale-up Tour sous présidence française qui était faire un Tibi européen.
On a essayé dans chaque domaine du jeu de faire ça, et puis surtout que nos start-ups s'étendent. Si on veut vraiment aller au bout et faire une French Tech européenne, il faut, qu'on ait un régime French Tech à l'européenne, donc nous nourrir de nos pratiques et qu'on ait quelque chose d'encore plus compétitif que nous. Il faut qu'on ait ce marché du capital unique européen. Ça, c'est vraiment le cœur, pour moi, de la bataille. Ça paraît un peu technique et ennuyeux, mais c'est super important. C'est que l'Europe, pour que vous ayez juste une idée de l'enjeu, l'Europe, c'est l'espace du monde où il y a le plus d'épargne. Plus qu'aux États-Unis, plus qu'en Asie. C'est l'endroit du monde où il y a le plus d'épargne.
Simplement, cette épargne, elle reste au mauvais endroit, c'est-à-dire elle est dans les pays qui sont déjà riches, elle ne va pas dans les bons secteurs, elle va beaucoup trop sur le financement obligataire. Parce qu'elle est, en fait, prise dans les banques et les assurances auxquelles on a mis des règles de régulation qui l'empêchent d'aller vers l'innovation. C'est pour ça que notre bataille, là, c'est d'aller faire un grand programme de titrisation pour les sortir de leur bilan et permettre d'aller vers les fonds propres, l'innovation, et c'est permettre d'avoir ce marché du capital unique pour que ça aille beaucoup plus vers l'equity et l'innovation en Europe.
Parce qu'aujourd'hui, cette épargne, quand elle veut chercher du risque, elle va le chercher dans les assets managers américains, ce qui est de la folie. Donc ça, c'est une bataille qui est absolument clé. C'est ce qu'on disait, c'est intégrer beaucoup plus nos marchés européens sur leurs règles, c'est-à-dire approfondir le marché du numérique, mais même tous les marchés sectoriels. Par exemple, sur la santé, si on veut aller beaucoup plus vite, c'est pour ça que c'est vraiment un travail secteur par secteur européen, mais il faut y aller et prendre sa bêche et pas lâcher. Mais si on veut qu'il y ait un vrai marché unique de la santé, il ne faut en fait pas avoir 27 agences d'autorisation, mais il faut accepter d'avoir une seule agence d'autorisation.
Aujourd'hui, on en a une en Europe, mais après, on repasse devant chaque agence au niveau français. Elles n'ont pas les mêmes règles, pas les mêmes protocoles. Et sous le contrôle de Thomas, les essais cliniques n'ont pas les mêmes protocoles ni les mêmes délais entre l'Espagne et la France. En l'espèce, ils sont meilleurs que nous. Donc c'est complètement aberrant. Et c'est ça qui fait qu'on n'a pas encore un vrai marché unique. Au fond, on se tire une balle dans le pied. Donc ça, pour moi, c'est le cœur de l'agenda européen des prochaines années. C'est ce qu'on défend en plus en franco-allemand très fortement, et c'est ce sur quoi on va vraiment pousser avec la Commission européenne.
Maurice LÉVY
Monsieur le Président, je voudrais vous remercier très chaleureusement et que peut-être, vous pouvez dire le mot de la fin.
Emmanuel MACRON
D'abord, je retrouve tout à l'heure des entrepreneurs et des entrepreneuses et des investisseurs parce qu'à l'Élysée, on va continuer le travail. Et je crois que Maurice Lévy a donné d'ailleurs des travaux pratiques. Donc c'est pour continuer d'avancer.
D'abord, merci de votre temps et d'avoir été là. Moi, j'ai quelques mots simples. Je suis très fier de vous, collectivement, de tout le travail qui a été fait, de ce qui a été bâti et de ce que vous êtes en train de faire avec vos équipes dans tous les secteurs. Rien n'était écrit il y a 10 ans et vous êtes en train de le faire. Ensuite, je sais à quel point tout ça est précaire, comme vous le savez dans vos entreprises, et donc on continue le combat et on ne doit rien lâcher. Et donc moi, ce que je vous demande, c'est de continuer d'avoir la même énergie et la même confiance dans le pays. J'adore l'énergie que vous dégagez. Au fond, vous êtes exigeants et exigeantes, mais à chaque fois avec une volonté qu'on fasse mieux.
Donc, gardez confiance dans notre pays, dans sa capacité de se transformer, parce que vous en êtes les acteurs. Et continuez de convaincre tout le monde qu'ils en sont les acteurs. On ne lâche rien et je ne lâcherai rien. Donc, merci beaucoup.
