Reflections of the Commander in Chief. THE EMPIRE AND THE INDEPENDENT ISLAND. Second and third parts.

Cuba Fidel Castro · President of Cuba

15 August 2007

Context
Castro published a historical reflection on August 15, 2007, analyzing the imposition of the Platt Amendment and the establishment of the US naval base at Guantánamo following Cuban independence.
Main themes
Platt Amendment, Guantánamo naval base, Cuba-US relations, US imperialism, Cuban sovereignty, early Cuban Republic, Theodore Roosevelt, lease agreements, naval station negotiations, Bahía Honda, Isla de Pinos
Duration
~24 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,852
73rd percentile
Sentences
88
57th percentile
Readability
31
18th percentile
Grade
16.7
88th percentile
Syntax
3.46
92nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.49
95th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 75%75%
  • Institutional 18%18%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

88 sentences in 53 paragraphs

Second part: The application of the Platt Amendment and the establishment of the Naval Base in Guantánamo as the framework for relations between Cuba and the United States.

At the end of 1901, the electoral process began in which the candidacy of Tomás Estrada Palma achieved victory without opposition, receiving support from 47 percent of the electorate. The elected President in absentia departed from the United States for Cuba on April 17, 1902, and arrived three days later. The transfer of power took place on May 20, 1902, at noon. The Congress of the Republic had already been constituted. Leonard Wood embarked for his country on the battleship "Brooklyn."

In 1902, shortly before the Republic was proclaimed, the American government informed the newly elected President of the Island about the four locations selected to establish naval stations—Cienfuegos, Bahía Honda, Guantánamo, and Nipe—provided for by the Platt Amendment. The port of Havana was also considered nothing less than "the most advantageous place for the fourth naval station."

From the outset, despite its spurious origin, the Government of Cuba, in which many of those who fought for independence participated, opposed the granting of four naval bases, as it considered that two were more than sufficient. The situation became more tense as the Cuban government hardened its positions and demanded the final drafting of the Permanent Treaty of Relations, in order to "determine at the same time and not in parts, all the particulars that were the subject of the Platt Amendment and to fix the scope of its precepts."

President McKinley had died on September 14, 1901, as a result of the gunshots he received on the 6th of that month. Theodore Roosevelt had risen so high in his political career that he was already Vice President of the United States, and thus assumed the presidency after the fatal shots received by his predecessor. At that moment, it was not convenient for Roosevelt to specify the scope of the Platt Amendment, in order not to delay the military installation of the Base in Guantánamo, which would mean in the defense of the Canal—initiated and then abandoned by France in the Central American Isthmus—that the voracious government of the empire intended to complete at any cost. He was also not interested in defining the legal situation of Isla de Pinos. Therefore, he abruptly reduced the number of naval bases under discussion, withdrew the suggestion of the port of Havana, and finally agreed to grant two bases: Guantánamo and Bahía Honda.

Subsequently, in compliance with Article VII of the constitutional appendix imposed on the Constitutional Convention, the Agreement was signed by the Presidents of Cuba and the United States on February 16 and 23, 1903, respectively:

"Article I.- The Republic of Cuba hereby leases to the United States, for as long as they may need them and for the purpose of establishing coal or naval stations, the tracts of land and water located on the island of Cuba that are described below:

"1. In Guantánamo..." A complete description of the bay and the adjacent territory is provided.

"2. In Bahía Honda..." A similar description is made.

In this Agreement it is established:

"Article III.- While the United States recognizes on its part the continuation of the definitive sovereignty of the Republic of Cuba over the tracts of land and water described above, the Republic of Cuba consents, on its part, that during the period in which the United States occupies said areas under the stipulations of this agreement, the United States shall exercise complete jurisdiction and dominion over said areas with the right to acquire for the public purposes of the United States any land or other property located therein by purchase or expropriation, fully compensating its owners."

On May 28, 1903, the measurement work began to establish the boundaries of the naval station in Guantánamo.

In the Agreement of July 2, 1903, on the subject, the "Regulations for the leasing of Naval and Coal Stations" were approved:

"Article I.- The United States of America agrees and stipulates to pay the Republic of Cuba the annual sum of 2,000 pesos in gold currency of the United States for the time that they occupy and use said areas of land under the aforementioned Agreement."

"All privately owned lands and other real estate included in said areas shall be acquired without delay by the Republic of Cuba. The United States agrees to provide the Republic of Cuba with the necessary amounts for the purchase of said lands and privately owned properties, and the Republic of Cuba shall accept said amounts as advance payment against the rent due under said Agreement."

The Agreement regulating that lease, signed in Havana by the representatives of the Presidents of Cuba and the United States, respectively, was approved by the Senate of Cuba on July 16, 1903, ratified by the President of Cuba a month later, on August 16, and by the President of the United States on October 2, with the ratifications exchanged in Washington on October 6, published in the Gaceta de Cuba on the 12th of the same month and year.

On December 14, 1903, it was announced that four days earlier, on the 10th of that month, the United States had taken possession of the areas of water and land for the establishment of the naval station in Guantánamo.

For the Government and the Navy of the United States, the transfer of part of the territory of the largest of the Antilles was a cause for great rejoicing, and they intended to celebrate it. In Guantánamo, ships from the Caribbean Squadron and some battleships from the North Atlantic Fleet gathered for that purpose.

The Cuban government designated the Chief of Public Works of Santiago de Cuba to hand over that part of the territory over which it theoretically exercised sovereignty on December 10, 1903, a date chosen by the United States. He would be the only Cuban present at the ceremony and only for a short time, as, having fulfilled his mission, without toasts or handshakes, he withdrew to the neighboring town of Caimanera.

The Chief of Public Works had moved to the battleship "Kearsage," which was the American flagship, aboard which Rear Admiral Barker was present. At 12:00 hours, 21 cannon shots were fired, and with the chords of the National Anthem of Cuba, the Cuban flag that was hoisted on that ship was lowered, and immediately the flag of the United States was raised on land, at the point called Playa del Este, with the same number of salutes, thus concluding the act.

According to the regulations of the Agreement, the United States was to dedicate the ceded lands exclusively to public uses, and could not establish any commerce or industries of any kind therein.

The authorities of the United States in said territories and the Cuban authorities mutually committed to deliver fugitives from justice for crimes or offenses subject to the jurisdiction of the laws of each party, whenever requested by the authorities of the nation that judged them.

The materials imported into the areas of said naval stations for their use and consumption would be exempt from the payment of customs duties, or any other kind, to the Republic of Cuba.

The lease of the aforementioned naval stations included the right to use and occupy the waters adjacent to said tracts of land and water, to improve and deepen their entrances and anchorages, and to whatever else was necessary for the exclusive uses to which they were dedicated.

Although the United States recognized the continuation of the definitive sovereignty of Cuba over those tracts of water and land, it would exercise, with the consent of Cuba, "complete jurisdiction and dominion" over said areas while occupying them in accordance with the other stipulations already mentioned.

In the so-called Permanent Treaty of May 22, 1903, concluded between the governments of the Republic of Cuba and the United States, the future relations between both countries were specified: that is, what Manuel Márquez Sterling would call "the unbearable yoke of the Platt Amendment."

The Permanent Treaty signed by both countries was approved by the Senate of the United States on March 22, 1904, and by the Cuban Senate on June 8 of that year, and the ratifications were exchanged in Washington on June 1, 1904. Therefore, the Platt Amendment is an amendment to an American law, an appendix to the Constitution of Cuba of 1901, and a permanent treaty between both countries.

The experiences gained from the Naval Base in Guantánamo served to apply similar or worse measures in Panama with the Canal.

In the American Congress, the method of introduced amendments, when discussing a law that by its content and importance is of urgent necessity, is often applied, forcing legislators to set aside or sacrifice dissenting opinions. Such amendments have bitten more than once the sovereignty for which our people tirelessly fight.

In 1912, the Secretary of State of Cuba, Manuel Sanguily, negotiated with the American chancery a new treaty by which the United States renounced its rights over Bahía Honda in exchange for an expansion of the limits of the station in Guantánamo.

In that same year, when the uprising of the Partido de los Independientes de Color occurred, which the government of President José Miguel Gómez—from the Liberal Party—brutally repressed, troops from the Naval Base in Guantánamo emerged to occupy different towns in the former province of Oriente, near the cities of Guantánamo and Santiago de Cuba, under the pretext of "protecting the lives and property of American citizens."

In 1917, due to the uprising known as "La Chambelona" in Oriente, carried out by elements of the Liberal Party who opposed the electoral fraud that led to the re-election of President Mario García Menocal, from the Conservative Party, Yankee detachments from the Base headed to various points in that Cuban province, using as a pretext "the protection of the water supply to the Base."

Reflections of the Commander in Chief

Third part: The formal repeal of the Platt Amendment and the maintenance of the Naval Base in Guantánamo.

In 1933, the arrival to power of the Democratic Administration of Franklin Delano Roosevelt in the United States opened the way for a necessary readjustment of the relations of domination that that country exercised over Cuba. The fall of the tyranny of Gerardo Machado under the pressure of a powerful popular movement, and the subsequent installation of a provisional government headed by the university professor of Physiology, Ramón Grau San Martín, constituted a serious obstacle to the realization of the program demanded by the people.

On November 24, 1933, President Roosevelt of the United States issued an official statement in which he encouraged the conspiracy of Batista and Ambassador in Havana, Sumner Welles, against Grau's government, which included the offer to sign a new trade treaty and repeal the Platt Amendment. Roosevelt explained that "...Any Provisional Government in Cuba in which the Cuban people demonstrate their confidence would be welcome." The impatience of the American administration to rid itself of Grau was increasing, as since mid-November the influence in the government of a young anti-imperialist fighter, Antonio Guiteras, had grown, who in the following weeks would take many of his most radical steps. It was necessary to quickly overthrow that government.

On December 13, 1933, Ambassador Sumner Welles definitively returned to Washington, and was replaced five days later by Jefferson Caffery.

During the days of January 13 and 14, 1934, Batista convened and presided over a military meeting in Columbia in which he proposed to remove Grau and appoint Colonel Carlos Mendieta y Montefur, which was agreed upon by the so-called Military Junta of Columbia. Grau San Martín submitted his resignation in the early hours of January 15, 1934, and embarked for Mexico, exiled, on the 20th of that same month. Mendieta then took office as president through a coup d'état on January 18, 1934. Although Mendieta's administration had been recognized by the United States on January 23 of that year, in reality, as is known, Ambassador Caffery and Batista directed the destinies of the country.

The overthrow of the aforementioned provisional government of Grau San Martín in January 1934, victim of its internal contradictions and the arsenal of pressures, maneuvers, and aggressions wielded against it by imperialism and its criollo allies, represented a first and indispensable step in imposing an oligarchic-imperialist alternative as a solution to the Cuban national crisis.

The government presided over by Mendieta would be tasked with readjusting the links of the country's neocolonial dependency.

Neither the oligarchy reinstated in power nor the government of Washington were then in a position to ignore the mood of the Cuban people towards neocolonialism and its instruments. The United States was also aware of the importance of the support of the governments of Latin America—Cuba among them—in the already foreseeable confrontation with other emerging imperialist powers such as Germany and Japan.

In the process that was then beginning, formulas would be structured to guarantee the renewed functioning of the neocolonial system. The "good neighbor" policy took into account Latin America's opposition to the open interventionism that Washington had practiced in the hemisphere. Roosevelt's policy aimed to obtain a new image in its continental relations through the diplomatic formula of the "good neighbor."

As one of the measures of readjustment, on May 29, 1934, a new Treaty of Relations between Cuba and the United States was signed, modifying the one from May 22, 1903, which had been signed by another Roosevelt, perhaps of distant kinship, the one from the Rough Riders, who landed in Cuba.

Two days earlier, on May 27, at 10:30 in the morning, as the United States ambassador, Jefferson Caffery, was preparing to leave, as usual, his residence in Alturas de Almendares, he was the target of an assassination attempt involving three shots fired by several unknown individuals from a car. The next day, on May 28, while traveling at noon along Fifth Avenue in the Miramar neighborhood, the car serving the first secretary of the United States embassy, H. Freeman Matthews, returning after dropping off the diplomat at the Embassy, was assaulted by several individuals armed with machine guns who were traveling in a car. One of them addressed the driver, telling him to inform Matthews that he was given a week to leave Cuba; immediately afterward, he smashed the windshield of the car and they quickly disappeared.

These acts revealed a general state of hostility against the United States and may have precipitated the signing of the new Treaty of Relations, which proposed the supposed end of the unpopular Platt Amendment.

The new Treaty of Relations provided for the suppression of the right of intervention of the United States in Cuba and stated that:

"The Republic of Cuba and the United States of America, animated by the desire to strengthen the bonds of friendship between the two countries and to modify, for that purpose, the relations established between them by the Treaty of Relations signed in Havana on May 22, 1903, (…) have agreed on the following articles:

[…]

"Article 3.- As long as the two contracting parties do not agree on the modification or abrogation of the stipulations of the Agreement signed by the President of the Republic of Cuba on February 16, 1903, and by the President of the United States of America on the 23rd of the same month and year, regarding the lease to the United States of America of lands in Cuba for coal or naval stations, the stipulations of that Agreement regarding the naval station at Guantánamo shall remain in force. Regarding that naval station, the supplementary arrangement concerning naval or coal stations concluded between the two Governments on July 2, 1903, shall also remain in force, in the same forms and conditions. Until the United States of America abandons the said naval station at Guantánamo or until the two governments agree on a modification of its current boundaries, it shall continue to have the territorial extent that it currently occupies, with the boundaries it has on the date of the signing of this Treaty."

The United States Senate ratified the new Treaty of Relations on June 1, 1934, and Cuba on June 4. Five days later, on June 9, the ratifications of the Treaty of Relations of May 29 of that year were exchanged in Washington, formally eliminating the Platt Amendment, but the Naval Base at Guantánamo remained.

The new Treaty legalized the de facto situation in which the naval station at Guantánamo found itself, thus rescinding the part of the agreements of February 16 and 23 and July 2, 1903, between the two countries regarding lands and waters in Bahía Honda, and modifying, in the sense of expanding, that which referred to the waters and lands at the naval station in Guantánamo.

The United States maintained the naval station at Guantánamo as a strategic site for surveillance and protection, to ensure its political and economic predominance over the Antilles and Central America and for the defense of the Panama Canal.

( to be continued )