Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

8 June 2010 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions during a June 2010 government control session in Spain's Congress, addressing austerity measures and the Bilbao spallation source project.
Main themes
Economic crisis response, fiscal deficit reduction, social spending and welfare state, parliamentary confidence, European Spallation Source project in Bilbao, Basque Country infrastructure investment, taxation reform, employment vs. deficit priority, public initiative, labor and pension agreements
Duration
~17 min
58th percentile
Words
2,060
58th percentile
Sentences
68
45th percentile
Readability
46
50th percentile
Grade
14.1
68th percentile
Syntax
3.30
82nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
31st percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 54%53%
  • Economic 34%34%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

68 sentences in 30 paragraphs

Mr. President, we are not condemned to choose between your melody and the louder melody of the Popular Party, between the anorexia of your measures and the famine of the Popular Party; there exists, in our opinion, a social exit from the crisis: a social exit that you have not even explored; an exit that rebuilds our taxation, the taxation of those who have the most; that maintains public initiative; that prioritizes employment over the deficit, and an initiative, moreover, that counts on labor agreements, on pension agreements and not on imposition.

Mr. President of the Government, today you are losing confidence in torrents, even if they seem like trickles, and today you do not have the confidence of the left in the Chamber.

President.- Mr. Llamazares, with all due respect, it will be the confidence of some deputy from the left in the Chamber, because I understand and interpret that you attribute the condition of the left in the Chamber to the Socialist Group.

I will tell you that the Government has made an extraordinary effort of public initiative during the severe economic crisis, reaching an 11 percent deficit, a situation that we cannot maintain. Public initiative, for what? To raise social protection, to support companies in difficulty, to support industries, to facilitate credit and to maintain social spending. That has been our response to the crisis until the current financial debt crisis demands that we reduce the deficit.

And I can assure you and remind you, because you have been part of that majority, that over the last six years we have significantly increased the benefits of the Welfare State, we have increased social spending by 50 percent, and now, making a necessary effort to contain spending, we are reducing social spending by 0.5 percent of the total social spending that we have increased by 50 percent in the last six years. I therefore appeal to a more measured judgment from the left.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josu Erkoreka, of the Basque Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, in the General State Budget for the year 2006, a budget item was included, agreed with the Basque Parliamentary Group, aimed at financing the launch of a large scientific facility in Bilbao: a neutron source by spallation that was to become an international reference for all scientists. Since then, this facility, this project, has gone through numerous vicissitudes that you are aware of and of which we have learned through the media.

A year ago, when we learned that the European neutron source was finally going to Sweden and not to Bilbao as we would have liked, I asked you about this matter in the Chamber, in a session like this one. You replied that Bilbao would continue to be a complementary site, that there was a project of 180 million euros that the Basque Government and the central Government would finance equally, and you added verbatim --this is recorded in the Official Journal of Sessions--: "This year, 2009, we have committed thirty million euros so that the works can begin immediately and be completed in 2011."

Indeed, the works began immediately. The first stone was laid in December of last year, with a spectacular display of resources. I have here some photos that attest to it: here you can see Minister Garmendia with Patxi López, all happy and smiling selling the merchandise. The problem is that the first stone was laid, but it was the only one. There have been no more, and since then, what was to be a great scientific facility of great international excellence has become a sad parking lot for vehicles without a project and without a budget. Can you give me an explanation regarding this, Mr. President?

President.- Mr. Erkoreka, indeed, as you have recalled, in 2006 the Spanish and Basque Governments signed an agreement to promote Bilbao's candidacy for the European Spallation Source for which we committed a contribution of ten million euros. This agreement has been more than fulfilled: we have already invested a total of forty million euros in the project between both Administrations, forty million euros.

As a result of this agreement, in 2009 we agreed with the Government of Sweden to present a joint candidacy from both countries for the Spallation Source: the main site, as Your Lordship well knows, would be built in Sweden, while Spain will hold 10 percent of the ownership of the infrastructure and a vice-presidency. In addition, Bilbao will host three facilities: a technology center for accelerators, a testing laboratory, and a software development center. This agreement with the Swedish Government entails an international commitment of investments in the Basque Country of 180 million euros over a period of five years.

Therefore, the agreement signed in 2006 expressly states that its purpose is the preparation of the candidacy and is valid until December 31, 2010. Before the year ends, a new agreement must be signed to regulate the execution of the project awarded to Spain, and in the meantime, the Governments are acting swiftly, as we have set the objective that the Spanish part of the project be completed before the works in Sweden begin, which will be the moment when the works in Bilbao will definitively start.

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, without malice, allow me to make a suggestion: do not give me answers just to get by. You have answered me the same thing you did a year ago, and experience has shown that what you promised a year ago, that the works would be completed by 2011, is already absolutely impossible to fulfill.

Mr. President, we would like to have a clear and firm commitment from your Government regarding this infrastructure. We do not know the project, which is nothing more than a ghost circulating in the media. We also want to know dates, costs, and financing. If you have this information, give it to us; if you do not have it, we are willing to wait. But do not improvise. Do not invent, please; give us credible things and relationships.

By the way, the agreement, indeed, as you said, expires in December of this year, but you have exactly twenty days left to request its extension because it must be requested six months in advance. If you have the will, please do so.

President.- Mr. Erkoreka, we have no objection to providing absolutely all the information that, on the other hand, is quite well known as this is a project in which, of course, your Group and all Basque society have had quite an interest. And we are aware that the renewal of the agreement is about to end, we are going to renew the agreement and, of course, we are going to fulfill the commitments I have just referred to, and do not be surprised that they are the same as those I expressed in your last question, because, logically, the project has coherence and continuity.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- We have voted by majority in this Chamber that the size of your Government be reduced, the number of senior officials be reduced, that a rationalization of administrative structures of the General State Administration be carried out, and, furthermore, that they present a report on the structure of the Government of the General Administration, in order to improve inter-administrative coordination and avoid duplications. That is to say, this Chamber has voted that a structural reform be initiated and that, beforehand, the number of members of the Government and senior officials be reduced. It has been voted on up to five occasions.

The question I ask you is: why do you not comply with the Resolutions of this Chamber and what value do you give them?

President.- Mr. Rajoy, as you know, the Government, within the Deficit Reduction and Austerity Plan, has carried out and is developing a plan for the restructuring and rationalization of the General State Administration, which has already resulted in the reduction of management centers, the merging and, therefore, the reduction of public companies. That plan is ongoing, and we certainly do not rule out further measures.

As for the composition of the Government, I will say that this is a debate in which, indeed, the Chamber has expressed itself and that the Socialist Group and the Government have no objection to addressing. It is true that this is the first time this has occurred, and I remind you that the Government and all of us are obliged to comply with the Law. The current Government Law establishes the President of the Government's competence to determine the number and structure of the members of the Government, Vice Presidencies, etc. I have no objection to reconsidering, if there is now a legislative proposal underway, if it is a substantial change from what the rules of the game have been between Parliament and the Executive, if we can do it.

In any case, Mr. Rajoy, you will agree with me that we are not talking about this issue in terms of savings, if we are speaking in terms of seriousness. The savings in reducing the deficit in the General State Administration must encompass all items and must involve a rationalization of all Public Administrations. In that endeavor, Your Lordship knows that we are and we would like to count on the support, collaboration, and concertation at all levels of all political forces, because our country needs it and because surely things can be done with fewer resources than is usually done from the Public Administrations.

Mr. Rajoy.- All of that is very well, Mr. President, but I remind you that this Chamber has voted to initiate a reform of the Administration to avoid duplications, reduce costs, and be more effective, and you did not do it. This Chamber has voted for you to reduce the number of senior officials by 25 percent, where you have a historical record, and you did not do it. This Chamber has voted to eliminate the Ministries of Culture, Housing, and Equality, and you did not do it, and it would be a very important exemplary measure at this moment where some Autonomous Communities are already starting to do so. And I would add: eliminate the Third Vice Presidency of the Government.

In this Chamber, Mr. President, we have even had to vote for the Government to comply with the Resolutions of this Chamber, and you continue not to do so, and in this Chamber we have had to vote for the First Vice President to appear to explain how the Government complies with the Resolutions of this Chamber, and she has not done so either. So, the question that arises is what value you give to the Resolutions of this Chamber, what are we doing here, and whether what we deputies vote on is worth anything or not. And I ask you if all that you said about Parliament being the center of political life is really so, because twenty-two Resolutions of this Chamber have been unfulfilled in this Legislature; the last one, regarding pensions. Yesterday you told the Chamber that the freezing of pensions next year would not occur.

Are you going to heed what this Chamber says or not? Say it clearly so that we all know what to expect and so that we know what our vote is worth.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, the truth is that you have evaded what is quite evident that I affirmed in my response, which is that the Government complies with the Law, uses the powers granted to it by the Law, and the current Law grants the President of the Government the power to establish the number and composition of the Ministries. Therefore, we comply with the first mandate of a Rule of Law, which is compliance with the Law.

That said, we agree that the structures of the General State Administration and all Administrations must be rationalized, and we have, beyond the debates and votes that have taken place, the will to share it with all political groups and also with yours, if we set aside demagoguery and think about the general interest.

Thank you very much.