Ministerial Statement By The Prime Minister, In Parliament On 26 January 1987 On Mr Teh Cheang Wan'S Death

Singapore Lee Kuan Yew · Prime Minister of Singapore

26 January 1987 · Parliament of Singapore sitting · Singapore

Context
Lee addressed the Singapore Parliament on January 26, 1987, in a ministerial statement on the suicide of Minister Teh Cheang Wan, recounting the corruption investigation and defending the system for checking corruption.
Main themes
Suicide of Teh Cheang Wan, corruption investigation by the CPIB, allegation of $500,000 payments from a contractor, Ministry of National Development corruption risks, Coroner's inquest, role of the Attorney-General, timeline of 14 December 1986, Prevention of Corruption Act, public opinion against corruption, Prime Minister's backing for the CPIB
Duration
~10 min
36th percentile
Words
1,211
36th percentile
Sentences
64
42nd percentile
Readability
60
87th percentile
Grade
9.4
15th percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.51
96th percentile

Source: National Archives of Singapore ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 69%58%
  • Social 17%14%
  • Ceremonial 13%11%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 16%

64 sentences in 23 paragraphs

It is with sadness that I make this statement on the suicide of Teh Cheang Wan.

On Sunday, 14 Dec 86, at about 9.10 am at my home, my security officer, Inspector Ho Wah Hui, told me that Mr Teh Cheang Wan's SO, Sgt Richard Kua, had come, carrying a letter given to him by Mrs Teh Cheang Wan for me. Mrs Teh had told him that Teh Cheang Wan's body was found cold in bed at about 8.00 am.

I opened the envelope and read the undated note:

"Prime Minister

I have been feeling very sad and depressed for the last 2 weeks.

I feel responsible for the occurence of this unfortunate incident and I feel I should accept full responsibility. As an honourable oriental gentleman, I feel it is only right that I should pay the highest penalty for my mistake.

Yours faithfully

Sgd Teh Cheang Wan"

I noted 9.15 am as the time I read it on the corner of the envelope. Then I rang Mrs Teh at her home. She gave me her account of how she discovered that Teh Cheang Wan had not awakened from his sleep. I asked if a doctor had been called to certify his death. She handed the telephone to her daughter, Dr Teh Kwan Geok, who said that they were paging for Dr Charles Toh, the physician who had been treating Teh Cheang Wan for his high blood pressure.

The daughter said her mother hoped the cremation would not be delayed by an autopsy. I said that depended on whether the doctor would certify that the death was natural. I said I would visit them later.

I immediately rang up the Cabinet Secretary, Mr Wong Chooi Sen, and then my colleague Mr Goh Chok Tong. I asked them both to go over to Mrs Teh to render what help was needed. I asked Wong Chooi Sen to ring me up when Dr Charles Toh had examined the body.

At about 11.10 am Wong Chooi Sen informed me that Dr Charles Toh had examined the body but could not certify that death was by natural causes. My wife and I went over to visit Mrs Teh at Jalan Bukit Tunggal. She was not happy at an autopsy, but agreed that an autopsy had to be held. I showed her the handwritten letter by Teh Cheang Wan that she had handed to the SO for me.

That Sunday evening, 14 Dec 86, Dr Kwa Soon Bee, Permanent Secretary (Health), told me over the phone that the death was caused by an overdose of amytal barbiturate.

On Tuesday, 16 December, I wrote a letter of condolence to Mrs Teh and to acknowledge the significant contributions he had made in the HDB. I knew then that there would have to be a Coroner's inquest which will disclose his suicide and the reasons for it.

Members have read the evidence placed before the Coroner, at the inquest on 20 January. The Director of the CPIB, Mr Evan Yeo, had seen me on 21 November on a complaint of corruption against Teh Cheang Wan. I asked that investigations be discreet because once people came to know that the CPIB was investigating so prominent a Minister as that for National Development, the news would spread like wildfire. The Ministry of National Development has more opportunities for corrupt practices than any other. A Minister's reputation would be put to severe test by an investigation. Such an investigation could not be kept secret. Therefore, once open investigations had started, they would have to go on until all the evidence is uncovered to show either that the complaints are baseless, or that there is enough evidence to submit to the Attorney-General for him to place before a Court of Law for trial and judgement.

On 27 November, Director of the CPIB wrote to me giving a summary of the evidence he had gathered and asked for my permission for an open investigation. I was satisfied that there were sufficient grounds to do so. On 28 November I approved open investigations.

On 2 December, Director of the CPIB and his Senior Assistant Director, Tan Ah Leak, for the first time, interrogated Teh Cheang Wan at the Istana Villa.

They confronted him with Liaw Teck Kee, the contractor who said that he, as the intermediary, handed the two sums of $500,000/- to Teh Cheang Wan. Director of CPIB was satisfied that Liaw was a truthful witness. He reported this to me. I asked Cabinet Secretary, Wong Chooi Sen, to ask Teh Cheang Wan to take leave of absence till 31 December. By then the investigations would have been completed and the Attorney-General would have decided whether or not to prosecute. The investigation paper was sent to the Attorney-General on 11 December. Teh Cheang Wan died on Sunday, 14 December.

Teh Cheang Wan was a man of considerable ability. Behind his diffident demeanour and his Hokkien-accented ungrammatical English was a sharp clear mind. After open investigations started we did not meet. I received a letter from him dated Saturday, 13 Dec 86, on Saturday morning. The Permanent Secretary of the Ministry of National Development, Koh Cher Siang, told Dhanabalan that he was on overseas leave and was recalled by Teh Cheang Wan to vet his draft and correct his grammar. Teh's personal assistant typed the letter before he signed it. It was identical in terms to a letter he sent to the Director of the CPIB on the same date. In his letter he denied the charge that he had on two occasions been given half a million dollars of which he kept $400,000/- and gave the contractor $100,000/-. He went on to write on page 4 of his letter of 13 December:

"If I am brought to trial, the very process of it which will be painful and long, will certainly be the end of me even if I am found innocent."

The Attorney-General received the investigation paper from the Director of the CPIB on 11 Dec 86. After Teh Cheang Wan's death on 14 December, the Attorney-General could not proceed with the charges he was considering.

There is no way a Minister can avoid investigations and a trial if there is evidence to support one. Teh Cheang Wan chose death rather than face a trial on the charges of corruption which the Attorney-General had yet to settle. The effectiveness of our system to check or punish corruption rests: first, on the law against corruption contained in the Prevention of Corruption Act; second, on a vigilant public to give information on all suspected corruption; and third, on a CPIB which is scrupulous, thorough, and fearless in its investigations. For this to be so, the CPIB has to have the full backing of the Prime Minister under whose portfolio it comes. The strongest deterrent is in a public opinion which censures and condemns corrupt persons, in other words, in attitudes which make corruption so unacceptable that the stigma of corruption cannot be washed away by serving a prison sentence.

Members must share my profound regret that Teh Cheang Wan who has made such a signal contribution to Singapore's development should have ended his career and his life in this manner and in these circumstances.