Speech By Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew At The National Press Club Luncheon On 10 October 1985 In Washington, Dc

Singapore Lee Kuan Yew · Prime Minister of Singapore

10 October 1985 · National Press Club Luncheon · National Press Club, Washington, DC, United States

Context
Lee addressed a National Press Club luncheon in Washington, DC on October 10, 1985, warning the US Congress against protectionist trade legislation and urging open, reciprocal trade to preserve peace and Pacific growth.
Main themes
US protectionist trade bills in Congress, open and fair trade, free trade and avoidance of war, Pacific Century and Asian growth, China's modernisation and opening, Japan's market barriers and reciprocity, impact of the Jenkins textile bill on ASEAN, US budget deficit and dollar, Singapore's open market and US trade surplus, lessons of 1930 protectionism
Duration
~15 min
52nd percentile
Words
1,786
52nd percentile
Sentences
93
59th percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
10.7
28th percentile
Syntax
2.84
27th percentile
Vocabulary
2.22
54th percentile

Source: National Archives of Singapore ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 72%69%
  • Geopolitical 21%20%
  • Institutional 4%4%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Ceremonial 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

93 sentences in 33 paragraphs

Singapore has one of the world’s most open of markets. Ninety-six per cent of US goods enter Singapore duty fee. We believe in open and fair trade.

We practise what we preach. As a result the US has enjoyed trade surpluses with Singapore in 14 out of the last 15 years. We do not complain.

The US has also one of the world’s most open of markets. Unfortunately, huge imports into the US has led Americans to believe that jobs will be lost.

Three hundred bills are now in Congress. If they are passed, there will be retaliation by the major industrialised countries.

What Congress does in the months ahead will have a decisive impact on the future. I am told most Congressmen know that taking the right decisions, against protectionism, at present means going against present popular sentiment of Americans. People believe that if they keep out foreign imports they will protect American jobs. They do not seem to understand that this was tried in 1930 with disastrous consequences. If Americans know the ultimate costs of contemplated solutions Congressmen will not come up with protectionist solutions. New jobs have to be created to take the place of jobs in obsolete plants, which are lost in any case, unless these plants can be upgraded to make them competitive again. By blocking imports, you reduce trade, and so reduce jobs. If you increase trade, you increase jobs. New jobs depend not on erecting more barriers to imports, but on tearing down barriers to American exports, whether to Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, ASEAN, Europe or elsewhere.

It is ironic that the world’s freest media has not been able to bring home to its readers, listeners and viewers the simple point that what is at stake is the issue of war or peace, and not the simple preservation of jobs, in plants that are no longer competitive internationally.

People now accept as commonplace the resurgence of the dynamic

German and Japanese economies without military expansionism. Open and fair trade and investments have enabled societies, as vigorous as the German and the Japanese, to keep within their own borders and still improve their standard of living. No people need to export themselves and their way of life or subjugate other territories and peoples. Without free trade, we can imagine what would have happened had the energies of the German and the Japanese peoples in their quest for a better life been frustrated.

If there are to be no violent conflicts over the better life all nations seek, then the system enabling free exchange of goods and services must be maintained. The US must have the will, and the power, and the stamina, to maintain open and fair trade. For open and fair trade enables changes and adjustments to be made in an orderly way.

For 40 years since the end of World War II, the world has avoided major wars because of open and free trade, plus free convertibility of currencies. This enabled many nations to realise their potential and to enjoy great abundance by exporting their goods and services, instead of exporting themselves and their systems and imposing their will on other peoples in other lands.

Economic dynamism and change has been evident in the last 30 years in the countries of the Western Pacific.

It has been manifest for many years that the Pacific has immensely greater potential for sustained high growth in the next 50 years compared to the Atlantic.

East Asia and ASEAN have over one-and-a-half billion people as against Western Europe’s 400 million, four times. Their per capita GNP at present is $1270, about one-seventh that of Western Europe, $8810. Their potential GNP, assuming that they catch up to half per capita earnings of Europeans by 50 years, is twice Western Europe’s current GNP, namely four times for population divided by two for half per capita GNP.

Many of these peoples believe that they can attain the standards achieved by the Japanese. The standards of education their populations have attained are comparable to the Japanese in percentages of each year’s cohort who make it to university, high school, etc. Growth rates compared to Western Europe will be between one-and-a-half times (Japan) to three times (China, from a very low baseline). It is no surprise therefore, that since 1980 the value of trans-Pacific trade exceeds that of trans-Atlantic trade. In anticipation, scholars have named the 21st Century the Pacific Century.

CHINA’S MODERNISATION: STABILITY

The most important development to influence the peace and stability of Asia and the Pacific is China’s decision in 1980 to open her door and modernise.

She wants foreign trade, investments, technology, and knowhow. China was an exporter of revolution. She provided arms, ideology and radio support to guerilla insurgencies in Southeast Asia. For the present, she has discontinued this support. She has also announced her decision to reduce her army of five million by one million, or one-fifth. She is signalling to the world, including the Soviet Union, that she wants peace and quiet to get on with her economic development, to overcome her poverty and backwardness. She has settled the problem of Hong Kong with the British in a manner which makes it clear that she needs to use Hong Kong for her own development.

But if protectionism prevails in the US, then the assumptions which led China to want to join the international trading system become invalid. Indeed then Japan also will have to cast around for new links to sustain her present living standards. Once America alters the rules of international trade, there will be fundamental realignments of economic and political positions, with profound geo-political consequences. The resulting conflicts will lead to wars.

There is a danger that although the frustrations felt by Congress are directed against Japanese, the legislation which may be adopted will not hurt Japan as much as other countries like ASEAN. For example, the Jenkins Bill which restricts textile imports will hurt four of the six ASEAN countries more than Japan. Textile exports of Indonesia and Thailand will be cut by 90 per cent and 70 per cent respectively; Japan’s will be reduced by only 25 per cent.

If America erects barriers to trade, although these are aimed against Japan, they will also keep out the exports of the rest of the Pacific. Furthermore, since these Pacific countries export between 10-30 per cent of their total exports to Japan, they will be hit twice: first their exports (25 per cent of total) will be shut out from US by the same barriers erected against Japan (half of these countries export more to the US than to Japan); and second, they will export less to Japan (18 per cent of total) because Japan will not need to import much of their intermediate products because Japan would have lost exports to US.

TWO APPROACHES: ERECT US BARRIERS,

OR KNOCK DOWN FOREIGN BARRIERS

There are two ways of tackling the problems of US trade imbalances. The first is to put up barriers to protect domestic industries. That will spell disaster for the world and for US. The second is to maintain the present system of open and fair trade. Of course to ensure open and fair trade the US can demand reciprocity of access to markets and a dismantling of barriers to US exports. In this second way, open and fair trade but demanding reciprocal access, lies hope of job creation. Forcing down trade barriers in other countries leads to a more open and fair system of trade. It will increase trade and so increase jobs.

In a different age, Japan’s customs regulations, quality testing procedures, and other esoteric games were amusing. Americans looked at these almost impenetrable bureaucratic defences against exports to Japan with benign tolerance, the tolerance of a master puzzled at the anxiety of an industrious, keen but impoverished pupil, jealously guarding his small turf of a market. In today’s bitterly urgent climate, the Japanese must be reminded that they are no longer poverty-stricken pupils. As behoves one who has graduated magna cum laude, they have to conduct themselves like their master, as an honourable nation of principle. Therefore they now have to observe the same high code of conduct and to establish the same open and fair trade rules which have enabled them to make the grade. The Japanese market is now ample and deserves to be shared.

The opening up of this market will be an enormous boon not just to America, but even more so to the other communities of the other Pacific Basin countries, for they do not wield the leverage that America does.

Never before in human history has there been such a mass market of people in countries of the world with market economies all linked multilaterally.

This large, more or less free trading group of countries has brought to the peoples in the non-communist world a life of abundance they never dreamt of before, with the highest consumption of goods and services ever in the history of man.

All this will be in jeopardy if the US Congress goes protectionist.

The US pried open a hermit-like Japan and a reluctant China and forced trade upon them. They were two arrogantly complacent societies, happy to be self-sufficient and so satisfied with their lot that they were determined to keep out the world. It is preposterous that America, temporarily troubled by difficulties over the balance of trade, is on the point of closing her markets to Japan, China, and the rest of Asia. Has it not occurred to Americans that if they close up their windows, then one day Japan and China may come knocking at America’s door to get in and to trade? What an ironic reversal of historical roles this would be.

The only rational option is for Congress to maintain the present open and fair trading system. By all means barriers to US exports must be demolished. Of course it also requires that Congress begins to reduce the budget deficit further to bring down interest rates. Then the US dollar will go down in a soft landing; US trade imbalances will diminish as exports grow and imports shrink.

To shut down the present system of multilateral open trade is to choke off these outlets for the energies of societies. It will mean a return to the old-fashioned, if historically traditional, method of creating bigger markets and improving living standards. It is expansionism, or colonialism, through spheres of influence, or satellites, or colonies. East Asia and Southeast Asia are in a dynamic phase. To choke off their exports to the US is to bottle them up.

Bottled up pressures must end up in conflicts and wars.

-------------------------- M1/PM/Pgs.1-7