Speech By The Prime Minister, Mr. Lee Kuan Yew, At The Opening Of The Seminar On The Role Of Universities In Economic And Social Development At The University Of Singapore, February, 7, 1966

Singapore Lee Kuan Yew · Prime Minister of Singapore

7 February 1966 · Seminar on the Role of Universities in Economic and Social Development · University of Singapore, Singapore, Singapore

Context
Lee addressed the opening of a seminar on the role of universities in economic and social development at the University of Singapore on February 7, 1966, arguing that a national university must define national problems and propose solutions.
Main themes
Role of universities in newly independent nations, degrees as political status symbols, university as source of informed national thinking, shortage of science and technology graduates, secondary education as foundation for technocrats, student-teacher ratios in Japan, India and China, expatriate versus local academics, exchange of posts between academia and government, student pranks and lack of urgency, meaning of a national university
Duration
~24 min
75th percentile
Words
2,934
75th percentile
Sentences
103
64th percentile
Readability
42
41st percentile
Grade
14.3
70th percentile
Syntax
3.30
82nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
39th percentile

Source: National Archives of Singapore ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 73%64%
  • Economic 9%8%
  • Geopolitical 7%6%
  • Ceremonial 7%6%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 12%

103 sentences in 45 paragraphs

I would have liked, had I the opportunity, to have put down some of the thoughts which have been in my mind over the last few days as I read through the data which I thought would be useful in discussing the points I want to raise in this seminar. For they raise basic and fundamental issues for you as academics and to me as representing government.

The first question which I ask myself is: what is the value of a university to the targets or the objectives which I would like to achieve. What does it cost?

Could I achieve those same targets by sending men abroad at perhaps less cost?

Before I answer that question as to the value of this university, Nanyang University, the Polytechnic and other institutions I would like to say what I think is the milieu in which these values are determined.

We are talking of newly-independent countries in Asia, in Africa. And almost without exception, all the leaders who have emerged in the first generation of leaders have been people who have received a university education, usually abroad -- whether you take Jawaharlal Nehru, Mohamed Ali Jinnah, Don Senanayake of Ceylon, Tengku Abdul Rahman of Malaysia, Kwame Nkrumah, Jomo Keyatta, Dr. Hastings Banda, Julius Nyerere or Milton Obote. They have all been through universities.

The net result is that the acquisition of a university degree is deemed a status symbol of immense political magnitude in all these newly-independent countries. The argument is: if my leader is what he is, it must have been because he went and imbibed knowledge; and if I can similarly imbibe knowledge, I can therefore, similarly emerge. And hence, the great desire of all institutions of tertiary education in all these newly-independent countries to award university degrees.

This presents us with our first problem. Is the university degree a symbol or proof that a man has imbibed knowledge? Or, is it a certificate that the man has gone through certain disciplines which will enable him to do critical analysis in search of the truth and which will enable him to be capable of creative thought? And the biggest problem faced by all universities in newly-independent nations is that with very few exceptions, the university degree is only a proof that a certain amount of knowledge has been imbibed, that the graduate has gone through a test which indicates that he has imbibed a minimum amount of knowledge within a certain fixed space of time.

What is interesting is that partly because of the popular approach to university education, partly because, by the very nature of things, it is difficult to get an institution of tertiary learning to produce and develop its own band of creative thinkers and researchers, your second generation political leadership invariably springs from some other source.

In the pre-independence era, your intellectual elite is the spearhead of revolution. He epitomises the feelings of the dispossessed. In the post-independence era, your intellectual elite comprises the job-fillers. Having pushed out the colonial regime, you have to fill a large vacuum of jobs in the administration, in science and technology. And there are more jobs than you can equip men to fill quickly enough. And the dispossessed find leadership either in the generals or ultimately in the Communists who still represent the dispossessed.

It is against that political background that I examine what I want a university to do. It is first, to produce the teachers, the administrators, the men to fill the professions -- your accountants, your architects, your lawyers, your technocrats, just the people to do jobs in a modern civilised community. And next and even more important, it is to lead thinking -- informed thinking -- into the problems which the nation faces.

This university has fulfilled the first requirements it has produced teachers;

it had produced administrators; it has produced some of the people required in the professions and some of the technocrats. But it has not fulfilled its second role: definitive thinking; the definition and the exposition of your problems and the tentative search for solutions.

Today, unlike what political leaders face in developed situations, I have both to expound the problem and then propound what I think is the solution in so many fields. There is no informed, coherent thought, whether it is economics, defence or problems of nation-building.

When you discuss a subject like British defence, the British Defence Minister and his colleagues have already the problem defined for them by institutes of strategic studies, by men who make it their business to anticipate the role that Britain can play in the next decade, the costs of the various alternative roles that Britain could adopt. This leaves the final decision a much easier one, the problem having been defined, the terms of reference. There is unfortunately for us no such group. And this is not peculiar to Singapore alone. It is the case in almost all emerging countries. And it is for this reason -- to develop this second role, develop the men who could fulfill the second role -- that we pay for a university. It is probably cheaper for us, and perhaps in the short term more effective, to select man and pay for sending them abroad to universities elsewhere, established universities, to give them knowledge and skills so that they can come back and fulfil a function. But for it to be a self-creative, a self-generating process, you must have your own university.

I would like in the few minutes that I have this afternoon to propound what I think is the role of universities in such situations; how a university can best reach a position where it can discharge its role.

First, I read with considerable interest a great mass of data which a number of my friends in the university and elsewhere have collated for me. And with the exception of Japan, 75 percent of the universities in Afro-Asia were established after independence. Next, the faculties that have been established invariably are the easier facilities to establish -- the Arts and the Humanities.

Very few have had science and technology faculties established.

So, they all inherit more or less a situation such as ours, where we have established a more or less educated elite in the sense that they can write, they can read, they can compose their thoughts, they can perhaps become administrators, they can alleviate suffering as doctors or help discharge the administration of justice as lawyers; they can, in fact, increase your population and your capacity to consume, but they are unable to increase the things that the people want to consume. Your men who can produce your modern industrial society -- your industrial chemists, your technocrats -- are missing. So, insofar as the first stage is concerned your problem is accentuated, and not solved. I think there is considerable truth in the proposition that the more you persist in producing men who are educated but unable to increase your productive capacity, the more you are heading for an unstable situation.

I think what we must at the same time remember is that this is a position not easily remedied; not quickly remedied. For you do not produce a technocrat in the tertiary stage. You begin by producing him in the secondary stage. And unless you are first able to remedy that lack, it is unlikely that your university can fulfil its function of producing the men who can produce for you the industrial society.

But I think the biggest dearth of talent in the university in a situation such as ours is not just a lack in the skills in the technologies required for a developed society of an industrial community, but even more important and more urgent, the corps of informed thinking to lead, formulate and guide national thought on constructive lines. It is because this is lacking that military leaders can take over.

If your population, like ours, reveres people who have learning and scholarship, and if the people of learning and scholarship can give an informed lead on these matters, it is very unlikely that of obscurantist theories can find popular acceptance. It is when that is lacking that you find your ground beginning to accept xenophobic, obscurantist, absurd policies which are in no way related to their economic problems.

In the countries of Afro-Asia the one that has emerged as an industrial state is Japan. And I therefore look with considerable interest at the teacher-to-student ratios and the subjects they teach. With a population of about 90 million, the Japanese have, according to the Commonwealth Universities Year-Book 1964-65, about 285,000 students with a student-to-teacher ratio of 10.2.

I then looked at the other big country in Asia, India. With a student population of 1,107,000 students in 50 universities, India has a student-to-teacher ratio of a 100.3 and even more interesting was the division of the students between the Arts and the Humanities, and Science and technology. Again it was a reminder to me that the solution does not begin at the tertiary stage, but in the secondary stage; and that if you do not have your secondary pupils sufficiently equipped to go into science and technology in the tertiary stage, then your universities are unable yet to begin that function.

The other country which is of relevance because it faces a situation not unlike ours is China. I have not been able to fathom the sum total figures of students for they are not included in the Commonwealth Universities Almanac.

But I have discovered that there are 15 universities for Arts and Sciences, and 125 engineering, technological, medical, agricultural and other specialised Institutes or Colleges. Surely the key to their industrial growth and their determination to emerge as an industrial power is the 125 engineering, technological and other specialised Institutes or Colleges.

I have found my reading for the seminar a valuable respite from my daily problems, enabling me to pause and ask myself what it is that we are seeking to do with our own universities. And I therefore read with some interest the contributions and working papers put in by members of the teaching staff of the institutions in Singapore.

The first thought that struck me was that so many were not our own nationals. In fact, some of the better papers put in were by people from abroad who have come here to teach us. By their very background they cannot have the same feel for the aspirations on the ground, but they do in the papers that I have read think clearly as to what the objectives should be. It was left to our own products to have formulated a line of thought -- which left me gasping at the futility of this university if this in fact epitomises their values.

This is not a rebuke, and not intended to be one. I quote this because I think it represents a particular frame of mind which I think is inimical to any appreciation of the problems involved in getting this university to play its role.

Said this paper, "You would not , I am sure, have failed to notice that my paper seems to be carelessly indifferent to any special local interest which a university in this part of the world should cater for". And he then went on to conclude that he is "not afraid of the winds of change".

If he is indifferent -- and carelessly indifferent -- to what we are facing, then I say, "What am I doing, pouring public funds into this institution?" How is it that a mind which is reasonably disciplined -- indeed, the style of the paper shows some discipline and literary skill -- should be completely devoid of a capacity of comprehension.

I have mulled over this problem in the last few days. And the conclusion I have some to is simply this: that until the people who set the thinking and the teaching in the university have had experience other than that of thinking and teaching 'in vacuo', then it is unlikely that a national university will ever emerge.

You can have your nationals in it, but your nationals will be thinking irrelevantly.

My mind flashed back to all the recent appointments that have been made.

Lord Butler -- a life-long career in public service and administration -- goes back as Master of Trinity College. I thought again of Ivory Jennings, who came to notice recently when he died, and the obituaries that I read of him -- the wealth of background and experience outside the bare bones of teaching. Galbraith, who sent me a little pamphlet over the Christmas holidays printing a little tit-bit about John Maynard Keynes to commemorate American thought and his impact on America. These are men of the world; not men outside this world, but men conscious of the specific problems they face in this generation, of what Britiain faces, not 'in vacuo'; what America face, the type of education they must have to produce the men to meet the challenge to American society and to America as a world power.

I thought to myself that unless we begin this process of educating ourselves it is unlikely that we will ever have a national university. I am convinced that if the Vice-Chancellor - again a man of no mean intellectual equipment and learning -- had also spent 10 years with the problems of Economic Development Board, not working on theories of economic and industrial development 'in vacua', but actually grappling with the problem of how to create 10,000 jobs in industry every year, I would never read this anywhere in any contribution.

Similarly, if some of the people in the Treasury and in the Ministry for Education in charge of determining the allocation of public funds to the university had also been teaching in this university for sometime and were 'an faith' with its problems and its needs, we would get less of the frustrations and the bitterness which academics feel when they are very bluntly and effectively stymied by people whom they feel have no sympathy and no understanding of their aspirations.

I would like to believe that in this next phase of our development, a certain broadening of the outlook by the 'swapping' of jobs would be possible now that we do have at least reasonably adequate numbers of trained administrators and professional men, some scientists and some technocrats.

I hope one day that the people who man this university would have had more than just their years of swotting effectively, their years of thesis-writing and teaching, as a sum total of their background; that perhaps after a man has led active work in economic development, industrial research, or the mechanics of getting the industrial plans to succeed, he would then be able to do an effective job here. And similarly, that young teachers in this university would benefit if they were given a dose of the realities, first of this society, then of the outer world.

I would like to believe that it is possible, by this broadening of the roles and this interchange of experience, that we could develop an approach, an ethos, in the university more in keeping with the problems that we face.

Recently, I read with very little amusement about how our undergraduates had taken to the pranks of undergraduates in universities in completely different social circumstance, where it is funny to raid women's colleges and disappear with their underwear. But for this particular community, faced with dire problems of life and death, to think that they have the leisure to afford this frivolity is an indictment not just of the student but, I think, an indictment of the teachers and also of the political leadership that has failed to bring home the urgency of these tasks, the acuteness of the problems to the students and give them the lead and thinking and inspiration.

But, there again I would not impose all the responsibility for this at the tertiary level. It goes back one step further to your secondary stage, and it goes back to the crash programmes over the last two decades where we literarily mass-produced teachers who were teaching while they were learning how to be teachers -- with the result that quality was sacrificed.

What I would like to see in the next few years, when I hope I will have an opportunity to sit down and discuss these problems with our own academics, is to hear them expounding these problems to me; explaining to me why they are what they are, and then propounding possible solutions to them; when the university no longer just teaches and trains, and the student no longer just imbibes knowledge for the sake of graduation and emerges as a politically complete citizen.

When the university is able to creatively pursue the problems of our society, define them, and then set out to attack them and provide solutions, then I say the university has been established, it has become a national university.

I would like to remind my nationalists that having a national university means more than just having nationals manning that university. It means an organism which responds to the needs and the challenge of our time in this particular part of the world and in this society. And when we succeed in producing an unending and self-generating corps of men who can do this with ever-increasing quality in standards, then we have succeeded in establishing civilized standards for a satisfying community in the post-independence phase.

Thank you.