Speech By The Prime Minister, Mr. Lee Kuan Yew, In Moving The Second Reading Of The Foreshores (Amendment) Bill At The Legislative Assembly On 10Th June, 1964.
Lee Kuan Yew · Prime Minister of Singapore
- Context
- Lee addressed the Legislative Assembly of Singapore on June 10, 1964, moving the second reading of the Foreshores (Amendment) Bill, which removes compensation as of right and speeds up foreshore land reclamation.
- Main themes
- Foreshores (amendment) bill, land reclamation in Singapore, scarcity of land, removal of compensation as of right for loss of sea frontage, east coast foreshore reclamation, Sungei Poyan agricultural reclamation, Kallang Basin reclamation, harbour reclamation at Tanjong Pagar and Jurong, ministerial authority over reclamation area limits, Land Acquisition and Planning amendment bills, windfall gains by land-owners and speculators
- Duration
- ~12 min
- Words
- 1,483
- Sentences
- 63
- Readability
- 47
- Grade
- 12.4
- Syntax
- 2.84
- Vocabulary
- 2.76
Source: National Archives of Singapore ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other63 sentences in 36 paragraphs
Mr. Speaker, Sir, I beg to move, "That the Bill be read a second time".
With the rapidly expanding population, growing pace of industrialisation, and the increasing tempo of housing and other public development, land is becoming a scarce and very expensive commodity in Singapore. It is imperative, therefore, that all available land is put to the most advantageous use for the benefit of the people of Singapore. Swamps and waste lands, therefore, have to be reclaimed. So too, suitable stretches of foreshore along the coast of Singapore.
It is estimated that 25 per cent of the total area of the island of Singapore consists of waste or swamp land. I have left in the library of this House a map of Singapore marking the areas where reclamation is planned. Most of them lie on lky/1964/lky0610c.doc the northern and western parts of Singapore where mangrove swamps could be reclaimed for either agricultural or industrial development.
7-mile stretch West Coast from Tanjong Tuas -- Tanjong Sekopek
An area of 168 acres is being reclaimed at Sungei Poyan for agricultural purposes. Eventually some 900 acres at the Sungei Poyan/Sungei Berih area will be reclaimed by building a dam at Tanjong Sekopek over the estuary of the confluence with a control gate to prevent instrusion of sea water and to allow the land reclaimed to desalinate over a period of time.
The same method will be used in Phase 2 of this scheme to reclaim another 300 acres in Sungei Bayan/Sungei Pasir on the northern side of Tanjong Pasir Laba promontory. The total cost of this scheme is estimated around $1.75- million.
In the third phase a further 450 acres will be reclaimed in the Sungei Tengeh area, South of the second phase. Further towards the centre of the State, in the Kallang Basin, an area of some 387 acres of mangrove swamps and land below high tide level is being reclaimed. A first 32 acres have already been established with surplus earth from Bukit Ho Swee. In Phase 1, some 200 acres lky/1964/lky0610c.doc will be reclaimed with surplus earth from Toa Payoh and Bukit Ho Swee.
Problems of acquisition and resettlement areas cover an area of 89 acres out of this 200.
In phase 2, a further 187 acres will be reclaimed with surplus earth from Paya Lebar and Ulu Bedok areas. The project is expected to cost $15 million spent over a period of five years.
East Coast Foreshore Reclamation
A pilot scheme for foreshore reclamation has been established and an area of 48 acres of land has been reclaimed at Bedok at a cost of approximately $750,000. It has been successful. The plan now is to reclaim a total area of 1,200 acres from Bedok Road to Rhu Cross, a distance of over six miles, extending to an average of one-third of a mile out to sea along the shore line.
Earth from Siglap Plain and the former Katong Catchment area will be used.
The land reclaimed will be used for public purposes including an express highway from Bedok to Tanjong Rhu, public parks, housing, schools and other public amenities. But it is proposed to set aside a portion of this reclaimed land for private development. In this way a total cost of about $48 million -- $33 million of which is estimated to be required for reclamation work and $15 million lky/1964/lky0610c.doc for a sea-wall -- will be in part recovered by sales to private developers for high quality development.
Harbour reclamation
In the Tanjong Pagar harbour area, reclamation is proceeding on a plan to create 48 acres of land in the East Lagoon area.
Reclamation has also increased the area of Pulau Semulong, which is now a ship-building yard in the Jurong Industrial complex, from 56 acres to 77 acres.
Plans are also being finalised for reclamation of large portions of the shoreline in the Jurong harbour area and of Sungei Jurong.
In trying to achieve this aim of reclaiming more swamp and waste lands and the foreshore to provide more land so badly needed in Singapore, the Government should not be hampered or hindered by elaborate and lengthy procedures with regard to reclamation nor should it be faced with claims for alleged injurious affection and compensation from private land-owners.
lky/1964/lky0610c.doc
The Foreshores (Amendment) Bill has been drafted to revise the existing Foreshores Ordinance with a view to eliminating the elaborate and lengthy procedures in connection with foreshore reclamation and in the assessment of claims for compensation in respect of such foreshore reclamation.
The main provision in this Foreshores (Amendment) Bill is in Clause 4 which seeks to repeal section 7 of the Ordinance relating to compensation for interference with public or private rights in certain cases and to substitute therefore a new section providing that there shall be no compensation as of right in respect of any land or any interest therein alleged to be injuriously affected whether on account of loss of sea frontage or for any other reason by the execution of such reclamation works. But where the execution of such reclamation works has directly caused damage to property, the owner may appeal to the Minister for relief and the Minister is empowered to order the payment of compensation of the execution of repairs as are necessary. The decision of the Minister is final.
In view of this new provision, Clause 5 of the Bill repeals sections 8, 9, 10, 11 and 12 of the Foreshores Ordinance which lay down lengthy and elaborate procedure for notice of foreshore reclamation to be given, procedure for determination of claim to compensation and the hearing of claims. They would be no longer necessary.
lky/1964/lky0610c.doc
Another amendment is Clause 3 which provides that the area of land for which the Minister is empowered to authorise reclamation would be increased from one acre outside port limits to ten acres outside port limits and from five-thousand square feet within port limits to five acres within port limits. The existing limitation is completely unrealistic under the pressure of our present land needs.
The other two clauses of the Bill need only brief mention, namely, Clause 2 which provides for permission for the erection of any building within 50 feet of any foreshore to be approved by the Director of Public Works. At present the Ordinance limit such approval within 50 feet of the bank of any port, river or channel.
Clause 6 is a procedural amendment to provide for only one insertion in the Gazette of the substance of proposed foreshore leases together with a description of the property to be leased. This makes for expenditiousness by obviating the necessity of having to publish in it every issue of the Gazette for a period of three months.
lky/1964/lky0610c.doc
Sir, there is urgency in proceeding with land reclamation in Singapore today. Work which has been slowed down will be speeded up with the passage of this Bill. Because of expanding population and because of increased industrial progress and higher standards of public housing and other educational, social and health buildings and the need for more open spaces, we have to stretch our available land to its maximum.
This Foreshores (Amendment) Bill helps to achieve this. The three Bills that I have introduced today, Land Acquisition (Amendment) Bill, Planning (Amendment) Bill and the Foreshores (Amendment) Bill are based, albeit in an imperfect way, on certain allied principlies.
The Land Acquisition (Amendment) Bill seeks to prevent the government from having to pay enhanced compensation rates when acquiring land for public purposes when the reason for the enhanced value has been because of development in the area at public expense.
The Planning (Amendment) Bill provides that where an increase in density is allowed for building, a premium shall be paid. This premium will in part defray the extra burden on public expenditure -- roads and traffic solutions, lky/1964/lky0610c.doc services and other public expenditure which will increase as a result of higher density of population.
The Foreshores (Amendment) Bill seeks to prevent land-owners from pursuing outmoded concepts of property right which are no longer valid in the context of public development at public expenditure in present day Singapore.
Public expenditure unavoidably and inevitably enhances the values of the land-owners' property. Sometimes as in the case of Foreshores (Amendment) Bill, it is conceivable that its value may be diminished as loss of sea frontage. But even in this case it will be offset by the increased values that will result from the building of an express highway to the town and the laying out of parks and other public amenities on the reclaimed area.
The whole object of these amendments is to ensure that the inevitable increase in the value of land because of the increase in population and development should not lead to unjust or windfall gains by private land-owners and speculators.
Sir, I beg to move.
10th June, 1964.