Interview with the President of the Government on the program "La Mañana," of Cadena COPE.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

29 June 2015 · Interview on the program "La Mañana" of Cadena COPE

Context
Rajoy was interviewed on Cadena COPE's morning program on June 29, 2015, addressing the Greek debt crisis and Spain's economic situation.
Main themes
Greek debt crisis and eurozone exit risk, Spain's economic recovery and reforms, European financial solidarity, euro irreversibility, public debt write-offs, austerity measures, welfare state preservation, Spain vs Greece economic comparison, structural reforms, EU lending conditions
Duration
~66 min
96th percentile
Words
7,908
96th percentile
Sentences
361
97th percentile
Readability
58
84th percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
3.03
52nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

361 sentences in 156 paragraphs

Ángel Expósito .- President, good morning.

President .- Good morning.

Á. Expósito .- What happens if Greece leaves the euro?

President .- We must hope that it does not leave. It is not the best possible news. I believe it would be very negative for the Greeks for a long time. It would be bad for Greece, and it would not be good for Europe either; but I believe that in the situation we are in, Europe would continue with its currency, with the euro, and there would not have to be events of the severity that could have occurred if Spain were, for example, in the situation of 2012.

Á. Expósito .- Now let's go to the Spanish variable in all this, which has many facets, but why would it be so bad for Europe if Greece left the euro? Because it seems like a bottomless pit where we would keep pouring money, money, money, and honestly, I have serious doubts that they will pay.

President .- In reality, Greece has no one to lend to it, and at this moment it is only financed through loans granted under magnificent conditions by the various countries of the European Union. The European Union has lent Greece 90 percent of its GDP. It is as if the European Union had lent Spain nine hundred billion euros, an astronomical figure. It has lent over two hundred thousand million that have to start being paid back in thirty years and the interest in ten years. That is to say, the conditions are magnificent, and Europe has been very supportive of Greece.

But you say, "What happens if Greece leaves the euro?" There is a message that is not good, which is tantamount to saying that the euro is not irreversible, because someone might think that if Greece leaves the euro, why can't another country abandon it in the future. I believe that would be the most serious problem it could generate; but I insist, especially in our country, due to the reforms we have made over the last few years, we are no longer in the situation of 2012.

Á. Expósito .- A listener asks: "What would happen if there were a write-off in Greece?"

President .- In reality, there has already been a write-off. From private creditors, there has been a write-off of almost 50 percent of their debt, and that is why no one is lending to Greece at this moment. In the case of the rest of its current creditors, who are fundamentally, as I have told you, the countries of the European Union, what there is is a loan under magnificent conditions. Spain lent almost seven billion euros in 2010; Spain had to go to the market to ask for that money and charges Greece a much lower interest; but it still does not charge it because, as I said before, they do not start paying interest and capital until ten years from now and thirty years from now.

Therefore, there has already been a write-off from its private creditors, and that is why no one is lending to Greece at this moment; and from the public creditors, who are all the countries of the European Union, Spain has seven billion lent and eighteen billion guaranteed; that is to say, we are at twenty-five or twenty-six billion that Greece owes us.

Á. Expósito .- Twenty-five or twenty-six billion that, in case they do not pay, that will go to deficit.

President .- Yes, it will go to deficit at that moment, indeed. It would be two and a half points of deficit.

Á. Expósito .- Which is not bad.

President .- It is very bad, very bad.

Á. Expósito .- Another listener says: "Why have Spaniards had to make numerous efforts, and I imagine the Portuguese and the Irish --says Juan José-- and the Greeks, have not?" I believe they have also made efforts.

President .- They have too. The situation is different. Greece, Portugal, and Ireland were in a rescue situation. That is to say, neither Greece, nor Portugal, nor Ireland had anyone to lend to them, therefore, they could not meet their public services and, consequently, the European Union had to lend them money, and that money is lent, logically, in exchange for structural reforms aimed at enabling those countries to grow, create jobs, be viable countries, and repay their debts.

In the case of Spain, we fought a great battle in 2012 to free ourselves from the rescue, and we succeeded. Even so, we had to make reforms to grow and create jobs, and, frankly, it was difficult, it was hard, and it was unpleasant; but today, when we see such a difficult situation in Greece and see that Spain is growing at 3 percent, the highest in Europe, we can say: hey, everything we have done has been worth it.

Now, what would have happened if we had gone for the rescue? Well, look, I have here what Portugal had to do. Portugal had to reduce its health spending, its educational spending...

Á. Expósito .- We have also done that.

President .- Yes, but we did it differently. They were forced because they had a program, and we have maintained the bulk of the Welfare State: we have raised pensions, albeit slightly, but throughout the time; we have maintained unemployment insurance; we have maintained the public health system and the education system; we have maintained aid... Without a doubt, we have tightened our belts because the deficit we had was 9 percent of GDP and every year we had to borrow ninety billion, but the situation is very different.

It is true that the Greeks have made efforts, and, you see, the growth forecast in Greece for this year was 3 percent; but of course, all these messes and problems generated by this new government have led to Greece returning to negative growth in the first quarter.

Á. Expósito .- Like everything, I imagine, like everything in life, but in these matters of macroeconomics or high politics, truths are not absolute. I ask you, President, how much of a point do the Greeks have. I imagine them today queuing to withdraw sixty euros or to collect their pension when they say that the conditions and the suffocation are unbearable.

President .- I believe that the people of Greece are not to blame.

Á. Expósito .- Everyone votes as they vote.

President .- Everyone votes as they vote, yes; but, of course, blaming the people makes little sense. That is to say, I would not have voted, obviously, for Syriza; but, as you rightly say, there are no absolute truths, and no one is always right, right?

Well, I believe that the current government has a great responsibility because, as I told you before, in Greece the problems do not arise in half an hour, that is to say, the problems have been around for a long time, just as the Spanish crisis did not arise in twenty-four hours. When things are done wrong and have been done wrong for a long time, in the end, they end up being paid for. This is like in any aspect of life.

Now, the previous government was complying, and I tell you, Greece was going to grow by 3 percent; it was improving little by little. That is to say, they were already going through the worst; but of course, this government came to the conclusion that it did not have to listen to those who were lending to it, and from there, this situation has been generated, which is really a true drama. But, I insist, Greece lives off the rest of the countries of the European Union, and we all want to be supportive, but, of course, one thing is to be supportive and another is to be supportive in exchange for nothing.

What we want is for Greece to make reforms like Spain did, for example, to grow and create jobs and to be a viable country, because if not, it is condemned to be a country that is supported by the rest of the countries of the European Union for all its life, and there comes a time when that cannot be accepted.

Á. Expósito .- Tsipras said yesterday that Greece's situation, what Greece owes to the world, is so important that he is the one who has the upper hand, more or less; or, if you allow me, the metaphor that has us by where we are caught.

President .- Well, look, sometimes one has the feeling that there are indeed some people in Greece who say, "the situation is such chaos that I can generate that, in the end, they will have to do what I say." Frankly, I do not see it that way. I have come to the conclusion that if the referendum is held and if Tsipras loses the referendum, that will be good for Greece because, from there, the Greeks will have said, "yes, we want to stay in the euro," and negotiations can be made with another government. However, if he wins the referendum, I really believe that Greece has no alternative but to leave the euro.

Therefore, we will have to wait to see what the result of the referendum is, and from there, Europe wants to continue negotiating; but when one is part of a club, in this case the euro, one has rights, but one also has obligations. That is to say, the world cannot exist without obligations. There are rights and there are also obligations.

Á. Expósito .- Yesterday, President, you had a gazpacho, a salad, and some squid with former President Sarkozy. With that, anyone can negotiate well.

President .- Yes, indeed, Sarkozy came here because we are going to create three working groups on three issues that are very important to people and are key for the future of all the countries of the European Union: on the issue of irregular immigration and people... the mafias that traffic in people; on the future of Europe, that is to say, where Europe is going, and on the fight against jihadist terrorism. We had a working meeting in the party, and then I invited him to lunch at a tavern next to Génova, where I used to go when I was regularly in Génova.

Yes, it was very pleasant; we reviewed the situation, and it went very well.

Á. Expósito .- I frame it in that press conference. Now let's go to the three chapters you have put on the table, which are each more interesting and important; but in the press conference, I don't know if it slipped out --I imagine it didn't, that it was studied--, you used the term Syriza-Podemos or Podemos-Syriza. Why? Are they campaigning for you from Greece?

President .- No, no; not at all. What happens, I believe I remember, is that a colleague of yours asked me about some statements from Podemos supporting Tsipras. Everyone knows that, ideologically, I have nothing to do with Podemos, nor with Tsipras. They said that the Greek government was doing what it had to do, and I positioned myself with the whole European Union. In fact, all the euro countries, and that is the curious thing about this situation, think the same, act the same, have voted the same, and have told Tsipras... I have told him: "you are making a mistake, this is a mistake, maximalist positions lead nowhere." And, for the moment, what they have led to is that people cannot withdraw their money from the bank, which is terrible, regrettable, and generates all kinds of difficulties and problems.

Á. Expósito .- Allow me to ask you in another way: does what is happening in Greece benefit you in this electoral campaign?

President .- No, no. Frankly, electoral campaigns in each place are different. My position is clear: I believe that Spain has an objective, which is to create jobs and grow, and for that, the economy must be made competitive and reforms must be made. We have been in government for three and a half years, and we have had to make very bad decisions; but now, seeing what is happening to others, you say, "hey, this has been worth it."

In 2012 we were on the verge of bankruptcy and needing a rescue. Well, now we could be in a similar situation. Fortunately, that is not the case, and now the point is to continue acting with common sense, with sensibility, reforming the economy, and trying to be more competitive to create jobs, which ultimately is the great objective.

Á. Expósito .- Another listener asks: "Seeing Greece, do you think the PSOE's attitude in agreeing with Podemos is responsible?"

President .- No, I find it absolutely irresponsible. The PSOE in these elections has simply gone to the most extreme left, right? Moreover, it has done so, well, in a doubly democratic manner, because, of course, the Popular Party won in Madrid, and yet the PSOE has given the mayoralty to Podemos; the Popular Party won in Zaragoza, and the PSOE has given the mayoralty to Podemos; the Popular Party won in Valencia, and yet the PSOE has given the mayoralty to Compromís, with Podemos; the Popular Party won in Cádiz and also gave the mayoralty to Podemos; and the same has happened in La Coruña.

That is to say, the PSOE has preferred to give the mayoralty to Podemos against the one who won, which was the Popular Party, and, really, the ideas of Podemos, with all due respect, do not seem to me to be the best for the world we live in, which fortunately is moving along very different paths from those of this political force.

Á. Expósito .- You have given me examples in Autonomous Communities, examples in large municipalities, and I am sure there are also small ones. Is this extrapolable to the national Parliament? I mean, after the elections, whenever they are, in November or December, do you imagine a large leftist front, a multiparty coalition, if the PP does not get an absolute majority?

President .- It would be very bad for Spain, logically. I think that returning to the policies that the PSOE implemented between 2007-2008 and 2011, which led us to the greatest economic crisis in many decades in Spain, would be madness, and if we add to that some of the things we are hearing from Podemos, I believe that all this would be enormously negative for Spain.

I believe that Spain now has to persevere in the policies we have implemented. This year we are going to be the country in the European Union with the highest economic growth -- the European Commission has said so, and the International Monetary Fund has said so -- and I believe that if we maintain these policies, we can be growing at around 3 percent for the next four years, two million jobs can be created in the next legislature, and we can reach a point where twenty million people are working, which is a goal that, I insist, can be achieved and is necessary to maintain and improve pensions, and to raise money and improve the functioning of public services.

Creating jobs is the main objective, it is what we have to do, because if there is employment, it is good for the people, but it is also good for the rest of the citizens.

Á. Expósito.- Now I ask you about the employment data, but allow me to insist. You responded with a conditional. I asked you if you see that great left-wing multiparty front and you replied: "it would be very negative." Do you take for granted that if the PP does not gain enough, there will be that left-wing front?

President.- I take for granted what has happened in the municipal elections... Because the PSOE has voted for Podemos everywhere. That is to say, there has not been a single municipality in Spain where the PSOE, in order to prevent the Popular Party from governing, has voted for Podemos. Even, for example, in a municipality, which is the third largest in Catalonia, like Badalona, the PP won by more than double the second; well, the PSOE gave the mayoralty to the CUP, which is an independentist, extremist, and radical party, so they formed a coalition with the PSOE, Podemos, Esquerra Republicana de Cataluña, and the CUP.

I really do not know what the PSOE is trying to achieve with these things, but throughout Europe the PSOE is trying to position itself in the political center, as the popular parties do. Therefore, I have no reason to assert that if they can do it in the general elections, they will not repeat what they did in the municipal elections. I insist, I find it very negative, especially at a time like this when we have started in Spain on the path of economic recovery.

Á. Expósito.- Mr. President, do you feel questioned as the leader of the PP or even as the candidate of the Popular Party for president of the Government?

President.- Frankly, no. I believe I have the support of a large majority of the party and, therefore, I am very comfortable in that situation.

Á. Expósito.- Have you not received internal criticism, that you are aware of, or have they not told you to your face things that some veterans of the party do tell us journalists?

President.- We have had two meetings of the Executive Committee. I explained in more detail in the second one, because the first was held the day after the elections, some of the reasons why we had a result that we would have liked to be better, although we were the first political force. And what I detect now in the party is the will to look forward and to try to win the next elections.

Yesterday I had a Steering Committee, we are working intensively; we have a political conference in two weekends, and the great objective now is to try to convince the Spaniards, especially those people who supported us, that it is worth betting on the Popular Party again.

Á. Expósito.- I ask you for almost a confession, but do be sincere: how many times upon waking up during these last three years have you said "what a bunch" when you see cases like Olivas from yesterday, other cases like the cards; other cases like the "Gürtels" or other cases like the "Granados" and the "Púnicas"? What a bunch, right?

President.- There are two things, fundamentally, that have harmed us a lot, from a political point of view. First of all, the crisis has caused damage. We have had to make decisions that were not easy and uncomfortable actions; but, really, I believe that we did what we had to do. Honestly, I think we did what we had to do. We could have done nothing, things would be much worse, right? And, in the end, I said: "let's fulfill our duty and obligation knowing that this may have a political cost." And, therefore, I believe that this has had political costs. And, secondly, I believe that the events you referred to have also had political costs.

Á. Expósito.- Why do you put the crisis first and then corruption? I tell you my personal opinion, eh!; it has no more value than that: I believe that the cases of corruption have weighed more against the PP than the management of the crisis.

President.- Yes, that is the opinion of some. My opinion was not that and we have tested it. So, it has weighed... They are the two most important factors, a little more the crisis and then corruption. Both things, without a doubt, have done a lot of damage to the PP.

It is true that in the matter of the crisis we found ourselves with it and the only thing we have tried to do is overcome it. We have had to make difficult decisions, but not because we liked them nor, of course, with the intention of bothering anyone. It had to be done.

And in the matter of corruption, the party has its responsibility. We have made decisions: all those people you referred to are no longer members of the Popular Party and we have presented many legislative modifications in the Congress of Deputies to make these things more difficult and to prevent them from happening again in the future.

Á. Expósito.- A listener asks me if you are very timid when it comes to criticizing corruption in other parties and that, however, from other parties they hit you even in the card with their cases of corruption.

President.- It is possible that there are styles and styles, right? But, probably, one of the most regrettable cases of corruption we have experienced in recent times is the one that has occurred with the ERE in Andalusia and with the training courses. I believe that yes, the Popular Party of Andalusia has been very combative, has taken these issues to the courts, and has requested a Commission of Investigation.

But, in any case, there is a dynamic that I believe is not good, which is throwing corruption cases at each other. What we should strive for is to sanction those that have already occurred, expel those people who have been involved in it, and look forward and try to ensure that it does not happen again.

Á. Expósito.- Mr. President, you say that they have tested that the economy, the crisis, and corruption have undoubtedly harmed the Popular Party.

President.- Without a doubt.

Á. Expósito.- Why not the PSOE of Andalusia?

President.- The PSOE has had the worst result in its history in Andalusia.

Á. Expósito.- Yes, but people do not remember that, Mr. President. Who governs in Andalusia?

President.- But I tell you that it has had the worst result in history in Andalusia. Look, the Popular Party has not had the result we would have liked to have; but we have been, in the most difficult circumstances, the preferred force by the Spaniards, both in the European elections and in the municipal elections.

Á. Expósito.- Is there time, Mr. President, to recover the two million and more voters that the PP has lost in these last municipal and regional elections?

President.- I, of course, am going to try. We have had to govern in one of the most difficult stages I have known. I have been in government on other occasions and, of course, I follow Spanish politics very closely, because I was for several years the leader of the opposition. Really, receiving a country on the brink of bankruptcy, having to fight to avoid a rescue that would have forced us to make very tough decisions and face all the cases we have known now has not been easy; but today we can say that things are much better than in 2012.

Between 2014 and 2015, one million people in Spain are going to find a job. It is not enough, but we are already walking in the right direction. We have already laid solid foundations, there are many things we have advanced in, and therefore, what I am going to tell the Spaniards is that now we cannot go back.

Á. Expósito.- You mentioned earlier the issue of employment and are talking about the economic situation and recovery. How are the unemployment figures that we are going to know in a few days?

President.- The unemployment and Social Security data will be known, I believe, on Thursday, the 2nd. I believe they are going to be good.

Á. Expósito.- Do you believe or do you know?

President.- No, I do not know. I believe they are going to be good. Well, the months of April and May were fantastic, because in May more than 200,000 Spaniards started contributing to Social Security and in April, 175,000; that is almost 400,000. We had set a job creation target for this year 2015 of 600,000 people which, added to the 440,000 that employment increased last year, 2014, would mean a little more than a million people finding employment in the last part of the legislature. I believe we are going to achieve it but, I insist, that is not enough, because in Spain we spent almost seven consecutive years destroying jobs. That is why I say it was a dramatic economic crisis, but now we are starting to recover. That is why it is very important that we persevere.

Á. Expósito.- For the elections, there are about five months left for that campaign. If I ask you about the date of the elections, you are not going to tell me, so I won’t waste my time, right? Or do you already have it?

President.- No, no. Besides, I do not know it. But it will be this year, of course.

Á. Expósito.- Yes, of course.

President.- But I do not know it either, Mr. Ángel. It is not a capital issue.

Á. Expósito.- There are about five months left, more or less, for the campaign, it is estimated that by the end of the year. In those five months, will there be time to make an energetic, credible, and sufficient reaction in the PP, as President Aznar put on the cover of "ABC" the other day?

President.- What I need time for, first of all, is to complete our government work and, secondly, to explain it and to get people to work intensively within the Popular Party. We are already preparing the budget for next year and our intention is to present it. This Friday, God willing, we will present the Spending Ceiling for next year. Our objective will continue to be to control public accounts and we have to continue making structural reforms. Therefore, that is the great objective from now until the end of the legislature.

As for the rest of the issues, that is what concerns me and, as president of the Popular Party, that is what I have to worry about. I will not make any comments on the rest.

Á. Expósito.- As we journalists usually qualify the budgets, probably in some cases with error or not, are they expansive or restrictive budgets?

President.- No, they are sensible, reasonable, and balanced budgets.

Á. Expósito.- What are you going to say!

President.- Well, yes, of course. At least, that is what I am going to try. I am not going to make demagoguery because it makes no sense. We have had very difficult budgets, because I remember that when we came to government, the difference between what we were earning and what we were spending was ninety billion euros a year. That is an astronomical figure and we had to ask for it in the markets. At that time, the risk premium was through the roof and we were paying enormous amounts for money.

There is one thing that, regardless of what Europe says and regardless of what economists say, is a great truth: those who have debts are less free than those who do not have them, they are less free, and I aspire for Spain to be a free country and for expenses to match revenues. That is to say, if Spaniards pay a thousand in taxes, we should spend a thousand, because if we pay a thousand in taxes and spend twelve hundred, in the end, what happened to Greece or other countries in the European Union could happen to us.

That is what we have tried to avoid over the years and that, believe me, yields results. What happens is that things do not produce results in five minutes, they take time. Now we have started to reap the fruits and now, when we see what happens to others, we say: "hey!", it was worth it.

Á. Expósito.- A civil servant says: "Are you going to return the extra pay from 2012?"

President.- Let's see. We had to eliminate the extra pay, the Christmas one from 2012. It was one of the moments, believe me, the hardest I lived as a politician, because that decision was made in July, here, where we are, in La Moncloa, after spending an afternoon with the economic team of the Government going over the situation. At that time, the risk premium was above six hundred points, a good part of the companies in the Ibex 35 could not finance themselves, and some Autonomous Communities could not finance themselves; that is why we later had to look for instruments because, if not, they could not attend to public services. And it was when we had to make very tough decisions, like this one, or like the increase in the Value Added Tax, or like many others.

We said that, as long as budgetary possibilities allowed, we would promote that officials recover their pay. They have already recovered 25 percent, and I would like — let’s see how revenue goes this year — for them to recover at least part of it in what remains of this year. But I insist, it all depends on how revenue evolves. If it evolves well, we will make a decision for them to start recovering, I insist, this extra pay that was taken because there was no other choice. That extra pay meant 0.5 percent of public deficit. Of course, it is difficult to explain why; but at that moment it was very important for Spain not to enter a situation of bankruptcy and rescue.

Á. Expósito .- It was a sine qua non condition to move forward without a rescue.

President .- No one had put it that way; but we either took it from pensions, or we took it from officials, or we took it from unemployment, because those were the big items, because we had already cut a lot from the rest of the budget items.

Á. Expósito .- Why is it not recognized — I also present my personal opinion, you respond as you see fit, of course! — by politicians, with a certain perspective, that the pension system is unsustainable purely due to demographics in ten, fifteen, or twenty years? I’m not talking about next year, I’m talking about afterwards.

President .- Because I am not so sure that what you say is true, nor am I so sure that the assertions made by some in that regard are true. I have been hearing this for a long time.

It is true that Spain is the second country in the world in life expectancy, only surpassed by Japan, which, you know, is a very positive fact; but there are people who can be receiving a pension for twenty-five years, and there are quite a few in Spain.

At this moment in Spain, there are 9,250,000 people receiving a pension, and there are approximately seventeen million people contributing to Social Security, who are the ones paying those pensions. So, in the end, what it is about is creating jobs, which is what I told you before: creating jobs is the key. If we have twenty million jobs, the pension system will be maintained and will be maintained for a long time. And then, what we have to do we have already done: there is a pension reform that has been made, which will come into effect in three or four years, by which pensions will rise or be maintained, because they will never decrease, depending on what the Social Security revenue is at any given moment.

Therefore, I believe that the system can be perfectly maintained; but I believe that it must be adapted to the economic situations that arise at each moment.

Á. Expósito .- Let’s return to the anger or reaction of a lot of listeners, voters, as they express themselves, from the PP. I am going to raise three issues, three chapters; the first of them, abortion. A Twitter user says: "Please, ask the President why they have failed to fulfill the electoral promise to repeal the Aido Law." Another listener says: "Why did he backtrack on the issue of abortion, if it was in his program?"

President .- We are not going to get into exactly what our program said because, evidently, there is that perception on the part of the people.

It was a decision we made at a certain moment because we understood that it was not good to introduce more elements of division in Spanish society at that specific moment. It is a matter that divides Spanish society a lot. We believed that there was a very specific issue, which was the need for knowledge or consent on the part of parents for the abortion of girls who were under eighteen years old. We believed that this had more majority support…

Á. Expósito .- Sixteen.

President .- Sixteen, yes, yes. There is a pending ruling from the Constitutional Court regarding a challenge raised by the Popular Party. My position is well known and I maintain it. We have made some important decisions, also in support of people who have children, especially in the last reform of the Income Tax. We want to continue doing so in the future, and it is a topic that is there, open for the coming times.

Á. Expósito .- Another listener says: "I am a victim of terrorism. Do you think we are right when we feel hurt or accuse the Government of a lack of energy, or worse, against ETA?"

President .- Look, I have been Minister of the Interior and, unfortunately, because it has happened, I have had to attend many funerals. I have seen many things and I have accompanied many families that were devastated because, of course, there is nothing worse that can happen to a person than having a family member killed, let alone if it is a child. I have seen many things and I believe that, as Minister of the Interior, as leader of the opposition, and as President of the Government, I have always wanted to be by the side of the victims of terrorism.

Forty-eight hours ago, I was at an event we held in Congress; at an event where the president of the Victims of Terrorism Foundation, Marimar Blanco, spoke. A short time ago, in April approximately, we inaugurated a large building in Vitoria, the Memorial of the Victims of Terrorism, the former Bank of Spain building, at a solemn event that took place there. I believe we attend to the victims of terrorism. Then, within the victims of terrorism, not everyone thinks exactly the same on all issues. Everyone thinks alike on the fundamental issues, as is natural.

For the victims of terrorism, I am willing to do everything that is in my power; but I am not aware that we have a serious problem because, in fact, we are very often with them.

Á. Expósito .- I ask you to engage in self-criticism, if you consider it appropriate, of course! In the matter of the independentist challenge from Catalonia, has the Government and, specifically, the President of the Government, lacked energy against Artur Mas?

President .- Absolutely not. All of Artur Mas's pretensions have not been fulfilled, none have been fulfilled. I believe that the response we gave was proportional and, for the moment, in Catalonia, the situation is the same as it was five years ago, ten, fifteen, twenty, or twenty-five. The institutions are functioning. If Mr. Mas now decides to call elections, as he has announced, they will be regional elections, where the only thing being elected is a regional parliament, and if Mr. Mas breaks the law, we will act in the same way we have acted in recent times.

It is likely that there are some people who would have liked a different type of more forceful reaction. All of that is debatable; but I believe that the President of the Government and the Government of Spain have acted proportionally. The Prosecutor's Office has made the corresponding complaint before the Courts, they are the ones who have to decide; the Constitutional Court, unanimously, made the decisions it made after the challenges raised by the Government of Spain, and therefore, what we have to have confidence in is the law.

The Government is here to ensure that the law is upheld and not for other types of things. I know that there are people who, perhaps, would have liked some other type of striking action; but I have to make decisions that seem just and balanced, sensible and proportional, and, above all, that achieve the objective.

Á. Expósito .- Are you in favor of primaries within political parties? Of having more internal democracy to choose leaders?

President .- Yes, there can be more internal democracy within parties; but, look, the primaries held by some parties usually have only one candidate. For example, in the case of the PSOE primaries in Madrid, the candidate who won the primaries was thrown out by the national party leadership after fifteen days, and that’s it.

We have a system that is by delegates, we have had it throughout our history. It is elected within the provinces, the provinces have delegates who elect the party president. But, without a doubt, the internal functioning of political parties can be improved.

Á. Expósito .- Is it possible to defeat Islamic terrorism, jihad, without putting "boots" on the ground?

President .- What you are referring to is whether it is possible to win the battle without having soldiers, right?, on the ground. Look, I am not, as is obvious, an expert in these matters; but today times have changed and wars are no longer the classic conventional wars. Nowadays, one faces, for example, what happened in Tunisia, where a single person organized a terrible massacre a few days ago, or what happened in France. Today there are suicide terrorists. Today the battle against terror — this, without a doubt, is one of the great problems we have as humanity — must be fought taking into account how the world is evolving, and, logically, there are many people with a lot of experience and knowledge who are dedicated to this, and they are the ones we must listen to.

What needs to be done? Many things. When we are, for example, as we are now, in Somalia or we are in Mali, which I visited recently, what are we doing? We are trying to help these countries to have strong institutions, to have security forces that allow them to fight effectively against terrorism, to have an army, and to gradually emerge from poverty.

In other words, the most important thing is that there are no failed states or territories in the world where the law and democratic states do not prevail. There must be states with strong institutions, with armies, with security forces, states that fight against poverty, states that respect human rights… Only with that can a very important part of the battle be won, and then there are the conventional methods of fighting, of course.

Á. Expósito .- That’s what I was going to say, that those types of failed states, or those massacres against Christians or other minorities, are not won diplomatically nor by asking nicely not to kill others. They are won with soldiers, President.

President .- Many battles are won with soldiers and others are won with intelligence, too, right?

Á. Expósito .- Which are usually the same.

President .- They are usually the same, but one thing is a war with the usual procedures and another, with intelligence and very selective attacks, hitting where it needs to be hit.

We are undoubtedly facing one of the most important issues. Now what I tell you is key because, for example, regarding the situation in Libya, it is evident that a country with two governments and two parliaments is a country that generates many difficulties. From there, all the trafficking of people is coming, 170,000 people, to Italy. What does Libya need? It needs strong institutions, it needs a democratic army, it needs democratic security forces, and it needs to fight against poverty. For me, that is a capital issue: always addressing the root causes of problems, not the consequences.

Á. Expósito .- Don’t you find, I don’t know how to qualify it, indescribable the spectacle of the European Union with the distribution of refugees?

President .- We had a debate, indeed, a short time ago in the European Union and I expressed my position there. What has been decided is that people who request asylum will be distributed by quota among the different countries of the Union. I think that this does not address the root of the problem. I believe that the most important problem in immigration right now is immigration that occurs for economic reasons. And why does this happen? Well, because there are people living in their countries, mainly in African countries, where they cannot lead a dignified life, and those people, if they cannot lead a dignified life, have to make a living wherever they can, and they have to take risks as they do, and many people lose their lives.

What is my thesis? My thesis is that Europe needs to make a great cooperation plan in these countries from where irregular immigrants come and where the mafias are thriving; and they need to make, in exchange for that plan, helping them with schools or creating institutions, readmission agreements so that it is known that anyone who comes irregularly and is used by the mafias will not be able to come to our country.

We have agreements with some countries and they really work very well, and we are very pleased with how they have been made; but Europe needs a global immigration policy and what you say about quotas really amounts to little. That is a patch, that is addressing the consequences and not going to the root of the problems.

Á. Expósito .- Is it a mistake to frame this electoral campaign with the vote of fear?

President .- Well, I don’t know what the vote of fear is. I, of course, am going to…

Á. Expósito .- Should I explain it to you?

President .- Yes.

Á. Expósito .- The vote of fear is something like let’s vote for the PP or the big parties, because anything that comes is very scary.

President.- I am going to ask for the vote for the Popular Party, fundamentally, for one reason: because Spain has overcome or is in the process of overcoming the greatest economic crisis in decades and because to go to policies that have proven ineffective and that have generated the crisis, or to policies typical of the 19th century... Of course, I do not want to live in a country where decisions are made like those of the current Greek Government so that we later have the issue of the "corralito." I do not know if that is a vote of fear or not, but there are also many people who say, "Hey, do not vote for the Popular Party because the Popular Party is the right," and they accuse us of being the cause of all evils.

I believe that this idea of the vote of fear frankly makes very little sense. Each party in a campaign defends its positions positively, I do, and criticizes, because this is normal in a democratic system, the positions of others. I do not know any party in any country in the world where in political debate there is no criticism of the opponent. Criticism must be educated, reasoned, and motivated. But that does not exist, does it?

Á. Expósito.- You were Minister of Education, Culture, and Sports, I believe as well.

President.- Yes, yes, sir.

Á. Expósito.- Was the transfer of education to the Autonomous Communities a mistake?

President.- The transfer of education to the Autonomous Communities I believe was not... It was done many years ago, it was included in all the Statutes, it was an agreement among all. What has been a mistake, in my opinion, is the actions by some and not respecting the basic legislation of the State. But, really, the Education Law that we have implemented, which is a first-order structural reform, I am absolutely convinced will serve to overcome many shortcomings in the Spanish educational system.

Á. Expósito.- Is Luis de Guindos going to be president of the Eurogroup?

President.- We are going to try to make him so, because Luis de Guindos has demonstrated, as a member of the Spanish Government, that a country that was said in 2012 to be the problem of Europe, is now presented in that same Europe as an example of a country that has been able to overcome difficulties, that has demonstrated it is a society that has resilience and is capable of making an effort, and today it is positioned not as an example of the problem of Europe, but as an example of recovery in Europe.

Á. Expósito.- Let me see if I can phrase this well: What emerged more from under the stones: a bunch of sycophants at the beginning of being president of the Government or a bunch of internal enemies at the end of this Legislature?

President.- I do not have great internal enemies in the party, despite some insisting on looking for them, and I really am not a person excessively prone to getting very happy when I am flattered, quite frankly. I believe I maintain a certain balance and that is very positive. I am absolutely aware that when one assumes a responsibility like mine, which is president of the Government, one is subject to criticism. If I were at home, no one would criticize me.

Á. Expósito.- Or yes.

President.- Or yes. Yes, you should not rule anything out in this life. You are right.

Indeed, I have been the subject of criticism. Criticism must be listened to, it must be understood; some are fair, others unfair, and in life, one learns from everything, from the good and the bad.

Á. Expósito.- Are two Legislatures as president of the Government enough?

President.- That depends on each person. Here, in Spain...

Á. Expósito.- That is why I tell you that, as it depends on you...

President.- Not on me, no; it depends on the people. After all...

Á. Expósito.- Don’t let me escape.

President.- That if I am going to... I would like to run in these elections and then, I will see. Who knows!

Á. Expósito.- Who knows!, no. Surely you have already thought about it.

President.- It is very difficult to know what one wants to do, can do, or in what conditions one is, or what one's state of mind is. The important thing is to have a good state of mind and be positive, and to know how to overcome difficulties; that is important. I understand that it is easy to say and not so easy to do, but one must strive.

Á. Expósito.- We have been almost 45 minutes chatting with the president of the Government, Mariano Rajoy, here, in his home, in the Palace of La Moncloa. Thank you very much, President, and good luck.

President.- Thank you very much.