Press conference by President of the Government and Prime Minister of the Portuguese Republic
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy held a joint press conference in Madrid with Portuguese Prime Minister António Costa on 14 November 2016, following their bilateral meeting on shared European and domestic issues.
- Main themes
- Spain-Portugal bilateral relations, Brexit negotiations, European Council agenda, bilateral summits resumption, Mediterranean EU summit, wildfires and cross-border issues, energy interconnections, Ukraine and Syria situation, Latin America, European integration, internal market four freedoms
- Duration
- ~43 min
- Words
- 5,104
- Sentences
- 161
- Readability
- 44
- Grade
- 14.7
- Syntax
- 3.29
- Vocabulary
- 2.02
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
161 sentences in 62 paragraphs
President of the Government.- Ladies and gentlemen, a very good afternoon and thank you very much for attending this press conference
For me, it is a pleasure to receive my good friend, the Prime Minister of Portugal, António Costa, here in Madrid. I know António Costa well. We worked together a few years ago on the Justice and Home Affairs Council of the European Union. We have coincided on numerous occasions over the last year at European Councils and other summits. Just a few weeks ago I had the pleasure of seeing him in Porto, on the occasion of a wonderful exhibition of the impressive collection of works of Joan Miró, owned by the Portuguese State. We had the opportunity to dine together there and agreed that, if I were finally to be invested as the President of the Government, I would like him to be the first of my European colleagues to visit me in Madrid. And here he is today.
Thank you very much, António; you are always welcome in our country.
Today we have taken the opportunity of his visit to Madrid to review the main issues on the bilateral, European and international agendas. As you are aware, we are living in complex times, we have many challenges ahead of us and many, if not all, of them, are the same for Portugal as for Spain; that is why it is so important for Portugal and Spain to work side-by-side.
At a bilateral level, we have decided to resume our bilateral summits. For Spain and Portugal these summits are fundamental for strengthening our political dialogue, but, above all, for resolving real problems of our citizens, both Portuguese and Spanish. In this regard, the common fight against wildfires, tolls, energy interconnections and cross-border healthcare are just some of the areas of common interest affecting people on both sides of the border.
At a European level, we have reviewed the main items that will foreseeably be on the agenda at the upcoming European Council and we have coordinated our positions in this regard. We also tackled 'Brexit' and I should say to you that most of our positions coincide. We hope that the British Government will formally notify its intention to leave the European Union in March next year. We will look for the best possible relationship between the United Kingdom and the European Union in the negotiations that will begin at that time. We will obviously defend our national interests, including our close relationship with the United Kingdom, but we will also firmly defend the process of European integration and the indivisibility of the internal market. In other words, we will defend the four freedoms of movement: of people, services, capital and goods.
I confirmed to the Prime Minister, António Costa, that I will be delighted to take part in the Summit of Mediterranean Countries of the European Union that will take place in Lisbon on 28 January next year. As you are aware, I was unable to attend the last summit in Athens at the start of September due to the political situation in Spain at that time, but now, with the government formed, I will not miss this important event. I fully agree with Prime Minister Costa that as Euro-Mediterranean countries we have many interests in common that we must protect and boost them. Hence the importance of working hard in light of the upcoming summits of the 27 in Valletta on 3 February and in Rome on 25 March.
Lastly, we also reviewed various issues of international politics, including the situation in Ukraine, Syria and Libya, and talked about the situation in Latin America, a priority region for both Portugal and Spain.
That is, in short - later, I will be free to take any questions you may have - what we have talked about at today's work meeting. I will now give the floor to my friend, António Costa, who I reiterate is most welcome now and at any time in Spain.
Mr. Costa.- Naturally, for me it is a great pleasure to be the first prime minister to come and congratulate and visit Mariano Rajoy after taking office in this new period for the Government of Spain and to wish him every success in his government, because the greatest successes of his government will be the greatest successes for Spain, for the Spanish people, for all of Europe and, in particular, for those who, like the people of Portugal, are its neighbours.
We have had very close relations over the course of this year with a high degree of trust. I had the opportunity to say that twice, when flight schedules were incompatible with the end of the European Councils, I had the honour of bestowing the representation of Portugal on Mariano Rajoy at these meetings. And this mutual trust, based on the friendship between our peoples, does not only exist in economic matters, but also in political issues that are common to both all the Governments of Spain and all the Governments of Portugal.
That is why it is satisfying to be able to step up and normalise the day-to-day affairs in our relations. At the end of this month we will have the honour of receiving a State visit from H.M. the King of Spain, Felipe VI, and next year we will resume the bilateral summits between the Governments of Portugal and Spain. This time it will be held in Portugal, but it will start in Spain, because we want to highlight, with a short cross-border ride down the River Duero in the Duero International Park, the close links that unite our countries and our peoples, which is why we will hold this summit at the beginning of spring which will start here, in Spain, and then carry on in Portugal.
I would like to underline that our relations at a bilateral level are excellent, which is why we have devoted a large part of our attention to European Union affairs. Fortunately at a bilateral level, Spain enjoys strong growth, which has also significantly contributed to the strong performance from our exports which, over the course of this year, have already risen by more than 5% to Spain, which helps contribute to our growth and the creation of jobs in Portugal.
On 28 January, the Summit of Mediterranean Countries of the European Union will be held in Lisbon. We hope that countries as a whole will offer a positive contribution to enrich the debate that must culminate in Rome with a new boost to the European Union. In order to tackle populism, in order to tackle protectionist leanings that exploit the insecurities of common citizens regarding their future, we need a strong Europe, a Europe that knows how to defend its external borders, that knows how to offer solidarity within its own borders and that is capable of giving a new boost to economic growth, to job creation, to the convergence and stabilisation of the Eurozone as a whole.
With a little effort from everyone, with a commitment from everyone and with this idea at heart, we will organise this summit with the aim of making a shared contribution, not to be divisive but to have a Europe that is more united in terms of these shared values.
It gives me great satisfaction to be here and the only thing left is to wish Mariano Rajoy, with whom I have had the pleasure of working in the past on justice and home affairs issues, and with whom I have had the pleasure of working hard on our bilateral relations and at the level of the European Union, the very best of luck and reiterate our sincere gratitude to Spain for having supported António Guterres at the elections to become the new United Nations Secretary-General, which will certainly contribute to creating a stronger United Nations that will defend the shared values of Portugal and Spain.
Thank you very much, Mariano.
Q.- I have questions for both of you. Donald Trump has been elected and I would like to know whether there is a dark cloud gathering over Europe and the European project. Donald Trump has already said that he may suspend or even cancel the Paris Agreement, which could in fact lead to disloyalty in competition between European Union and North American companies. And the former President, Jorge Sampaio, said today that we may be heading, and we must avoid that, towards an abyss. I would like to know if we are indeed heading for this abyss. Next year, elections will be held in France and Germany, where the far right may also further add to the negative figures in this regard.
My second question is related to the European Union; I wanted to know whether financial orthodoxy, which often translates into the threat of imposing excessive deficit procedures on southern European countries undermines, to some extent, this project of solidarity that Europe wishes to employ.
President of the Government.- I will try to give my opinion on the issues you have raised as briefly as possible.
Mr Trump has been elected as President because that is what the people of the United States wanted, and hence, our only position, the only reasonable approach, and I have already done this, is to congratulate him and wish him the very best of success. Aside from that, Spain wants to have the best possible relations with the American people and with whom they choose to be their President.
We have been in Paris and tomorrow we will go to Marrakesh. One of the first bills I have presented to the Spanish Parliament is the ratification of the Paris Agreement, which we approved last Friday; I was unable to present it earlier because we were operating as a caretaker government. Hence, it is our intention to meet our commitments and I am absolutely convinced that all those who backed and signed these agreements, which are good for humanity as a whole, will continue to uphold them. Hence, I am not going to place myself in any other scenario than this one.
Excessive deficit procedures? Spain is in that situation at present. Almost five year ago, when we came to power, we had a very high deficit; we have reduced it from 9.3% to 4.6%, which I believe will be the final deficit this year, 2016. Next year, the target set for us by the European Commission is 3.1% and it is obviously this government's intention to meet this. We believe that it is not good to owe money and that the closer you bring spending to what is actually collected in revenue the better. We have already suffered many problems with tremendous risk premiums and with public authorities that were unable to find funding, and I believe that we must learn from this.
Aside from that, it is also important to pay attention to what really matters to people, which is economic growth and job creation. Hence, the position of the Spanish Government will be to make reducing the deficit compatible, because that is positive, with economic growth and job creation. We are reducing the deficit at this time; we have a reasonable level of economic growth and jobs are being created, which is the main national goal. It has been over the last four years and it will continue to be so in the next four.
As regards the question regarding the elections to be held next year in Europe, it is true that important elections will be held, because in countries like France and Germany, which are the two largest countries in the Eurozone in terms of Gross Domestic Product, it is no small matter who is in government. I am absolutely convinced that, as has always happened, both in Germany and in France, people will vote with common sense, moderation and wisdom will prevail and we will be able to push on with this great European project.
Europe is sometimes criticised too harshly. It is true that there are outbreaks of populism and parties emerge that I am not going to deign to mention, but let's not forget one thing: Europe accounts for 25% of the global Gross Domestic Product; Europe is a region where democracy, liberty, human rights and respect for individuals always reign, impregnating everyday rules and the way people act and behave. Europe is a continent that everyone wants to come and live in, and many people come here, and I believe that at this time Europe can claim to have something that few others in the world lay claim to, which is a Welfare State with a public pension system, a healthcare system and an educational system.
Hence, what has been done in Europe over recent years by successive governments, not populist governments but ideological governments, which, on the other hand, are not actually so different, I believe is something that we should all value because this has been very positive for all of us. I repeat, at this time, Europe, as a whole, is the best region in the world and we are proud that the political forces that have contributed to build this, with the constant support of their citizens, will continue to do so in the future.
Mr. Costa.- I would like to thank you for the question regarding relations with the United States. Portugal had the opportunity to congratulate the President-elect last week and to reaffirm our intention of maintaining friendly and close relations with the United States, both at an economic level, and in other areas because, in fact, we form part of a common defensive alliance based on shared values.
The best way to stop this plummeting into an abyss that the former President, Jorge Sampaio, mentioned is to provide specific responses to the common worries, concerns and fears that weigh heavy on our citizens. The response to those who are afraid of a threat is not to close our borders; it is to increase police cooperation, it is to increase judicial cooperation, it is to increase cooperation between information services, it is to act in a preventative manner to those phenomena that help foster radicalism and to boost intercultural dialogue. In that manner we can respond to the terrorist threat.
If we want to tackle the challenges relating to immigration policy, what we must do, as Spain did some years back, is invest in cooperation with African countries to try to contain migratory pressure at source, or as President Juncker is trying to do now, with his well-known plan to help develop Sub-Saharan countries, or the cooperation we have all taken part in to defend our common external borders, or through the entry into force of the European border and coast guard last October. That is how we are positively responding to this threat and then, in a manner that enhances solidarity and through a shared effort we can take in those who are entitled to international protection and merit the status of refugees.
The right response to the challenges of economic growth and job creation is not protectionism, but rather having a European Union with a good trade policy, which helps regulate globalisation, as we have done now through the agreement signed with Canada; which is a commitment to a single currency that is a good currency for everyone, which helps economic convergence, economic growth and job creation in all those countries involved. It is clear that a single currency requires common rules, but these rules must be applied in such a way that the Euro can be made stronger.
It is with great satisfaction that Portugal will have a deficit of below 3% for the first time this year, as acknowledged by the European Commission itself, and with great determination we will continue reducing the deficit until we reach 1.6%, which is the target set by the Commission; however, we must understand well that the common rule book cannot continue compounding the economic asymmetries of those economies that have to make an additional effort to become more competitive compared with those other economies that are already more competitive. This is a shared effort that we must all make in order to have common rules and opportunities so that the single currency is positive for everyone.
Q.- Firstly, I would like to ask the two Heads of Government what they expect from the future mandate of Donald Trump at the head of the United States, above all when the first contact Mr Trump has had has been with leaders of political formations who are against the shared European project. In this regard, what do you expect in relation to the Atlantic axis, when your two countries have played an important role, both Spain and Portugal, in the last two decades of relations with the United States, and particularly in relation to the European construction project?
Then, for President of the Government Rajoy, I would like to ask you, in domestic terms, a little about how the first contacts have gone that you have personally been holding with other political formations in order to push through the General State Budget for next year. In particular, we would like to know with which political formations you have already spoken and if, among these political formations, you have personally spoken with the Catalan nationalist parties and the Basque nationalist parties. What methods are you employing to try and push through this Budget? Do you have a Plan B in case this Budget is not approved, as suggested from some corners?
President of the Government.- I am not going to comment about who Mr Trump meets up with - he meets up, as does everyone else, with whomever he sees fit and opportune - nor am I going to comment on the statements he makes or any suchlike. The only thing I hope is that we have, as we have had over the course of recent years, good relations between Spain and the United States, and between the United States and the European Union and that we can work together to help people improve their standard of living and their levels of well-being and wealth and, if you will allow me, so that they can be happier. That is the only thing I hope for at this time.
I have held some talks, but allow me not to go into detail; other talks have also been held by my parliamentary group, also by the Vice-President of the Government and by some ministers, with leaders of the different political forces in Parliament. I believe that there is a certain urgency at this time to approve the ceiling on spending for next year and the budget stability and public debt targets, because this is what will allow the regional governments and local authorities to have clear guidelines and be able to finance their public deficit in the future.
That is the priority at this time and then I would like to approve the General State Budget. We will speak with everyone and try to push this through and I hope that there are good intentions from everyone.
I said in the Investiture Debate, and I mentioned this again this morning, that it is just as bad not to have a government as to have a government that cannot govern. Our attitude, and mine personally, will be positive. I will try to reach understandings, listen to everyone, and the only thing that concerns me at this time is to draft a Budget that allows us to say that Spain is continuing to enjoy economic growth, Spain is continuing to create jobs and Spain is continuing to meet its commitments with Europe, and hence, reduce its public deficit.
I repeat, that is what I am going to give my time over to. I won't talk about any Plan B; what I have is a Plan A that consists of approving the General Budget for the year 2017.
Mr. Costa.- I don't think the second question was for me.
As regards the first question, it is clear: everyone meets with whoever they want. I am very pleased at having met up today with my good friend and a good pro-European, Mariano Rajoy. I hope that each European country has excellent relations with the United States and that the United States has excellent relations, not only with each European country, but also with the European Union.
Q.- We have two Heads of Government before us, one from the left wing and one from the right wing. The question is, are there areas of understanding in order to act in accord in Europe, in this Europe that has an increasingly larger gap between the north and the south, in which there is increasing pressure on the financial system? The financial system in Portugal is at an impasse at this time.
I would also ask whether the situation of the Caixa Xeral de Depósitos is prejudicial.
As regards bilateral relations, I would like to know whether you have had the chance to speak about the question that divides Lisbon and Madrid, which is the Almaraz nuclear plant. Has the Government of Spain had the opportunity to offer an explanation today to the Government of Portugal? Have you spoken about this issue?
President of the Government.- I gather that the second question is for me, about the Almaraz nuclear plant.
I have spoken with the Prime Minister about the Almaraz nuclear plant. Last Friday, that is, on 11 November, the Spanish Minister for Environmental Affairs and the Minister for Energy, Tourism and Digital Agenda sent a letter to the Portuguese Environment Minister. Today we have spoken with the Minister for Agriculture who will invite the Environment Minister to come here to Spain. It is possible, but not certain, because she is in Brussels, that we could hold a meeting tomorrow in Marrakesh. At any event, what I would like to say is that I will do everything in my hands to resolve the doubts that may have arisen as soon as possible.
We want to see total transparency. I repeat, the Portuguese Environment Minister will come here and obviously what I want to leave absolutely clear is that we have a great deal of interest in clearing away any doubts that some people may have as soon as possible and, of course, we are very interested, for obvious reasons, in the strict security conditions at Almaraz being complied with.
Hence, we have spoken about this issue, talks will continue, the two Spanish ministers sent a letter to the Environment Minister last Friday and I am absolutely convinced that this incident will soon be closed off to everyone's satisfaction.
Mr. Costa.- I will answer the other two questions.
It is true that you have two Heads of Government, one from the left and the other from the right. Relations between Spain and Portugal can be interpreted in a very simple manner. When there is a government we are friends; when there isn't a government we are also friends. Hence, the relationship between Spain and Portugal is basically one of friendship.
The European Union is a union of diversities, of countries with different cultures, with different geographic positions and different political positions, but there is a common will, a common will to work together and thus strengthen Europe. This year Spain and Portugal have celebrated 30 years as members of the European Union and during these last 30 years there have been both left- and right-wing governments on both sides; but there has always been something in common: there has always been joint work, well thought out, for the good of Europe. Although our positions do not always match on certain matters, I think that has only been the case on a few occasions over the course of these 30 years.
Lastly, what I have observed in relation to the Portuguese financial system over this last year is precisely that we have come out of this impasse. A year ago we had a set of banks that were in difficulties, whereas now, the main Portuguese bank, the pillar of stability of our financial system, which is the Caixa Xeral de Depósitos, has a major operation and it is that the European Union has authorised 100% public capitalisation of this bank such that it remains a public bank, a benchmark for the stability of the financial system, a guarantee for families and an instruments at the service of our economy. This capitalisation plan, which is essential, is being carried through with all normality, it is under way and it will conclude according to its time frame.
We have had problems with other private banks; one with a conflict between shareholders that was resolved with a significant investment from a major Spanish bank, La Caixa, which will consolidate its dominant position in BPI and thus allow the bank to continue with its operations in a duly capitalised position. And there were, and this is also being resolved, issues that affected another bank with another major foreign investment, with capital that has been strengthened by its shareholders; I am talking about Millenium.
Hence, we are precisely coming out of this period of instability in our financial system, it has been stabilised and we are finishing working, together with the Bank of Portugal, on a systematic solution to resolve problematic situations of the least efficient assets, such that we will have a banking system that allows the monetary policy of the European Central Bank to filter through correctly to the economy. Spain's experience is an excellent example of this; the priority Spain gave to resolving the banking problem is one of the underlying causes, one of the reasons behind the strong economic growth that Spain is currently enjoying. Portugal had to deal with other priorities and it must now do what Spain did in the past in order to enjoy the same results.
Q.- Before meeting with Mr Costa, we heard that you have called your party's congress and I presume that you will stand again as president of your political formation. I wanted to ask you whether you will do so together with the current general secretary, if this is what you have agreed to with her following her incorporation in the government, or whether you think that now is the time to give new faces a voice or bring in younger members, perhaps, to the general secretariat.
And as regards the challenges of this term of office that you have commented to us, I wanted to ask you about another challenge, that of Catalonia. I wanted to know whether, as you already announced in the Investiture Debate, you had a proposal - you said you would design one - on Catalonia, regarding how to tackle the pro-sovereignty process, whether it would help by setting up a ministerial department for regional issues, whether you have already planned to meet with Regional President Puigdemont to try to convince him to at least attend the Conference of Regional Presidents, and whether or not you are going to call this soon. How is this issue going?
And forgive me, earlier you left an issue pending. I am not asking for your schedule of contacts, but do you plan to meet with the President of the Management Board of the PSOE to discuss the Budget and the ceiling on spending, which is now pressing or will that be tackled at another level?
President of the Government.- My counterpart is the President of the Management Board of the Socialist Party, as is only correct. The thing is that as regards specific issues, the ceiling on spending and other issues, these are logically held at a different level. But, in principle, the party that says what it wants to talk about and which I imagine sets out these positions is the management board of the PSOE, which is the body that its members have assigned to govern during this transition period. And my counterpart for talks, I repeat, is Mr Fernández.
As regards the Conference of Regional Presidents, I would like all of the regional presidents to attend this type of meeting, among other things, because you don't lose anything by attending a meeting of this nature. I believe that it is a good idea if we give over a day to all airing our views about that which we consider fit and opportune and also, about the general situation of the country, the challenges we face ahead of us, the economic situation, what we can do to meet our commitments with Europe, to say that "we are going to try and grow and create jobs", about what we can all contribute, the general ideas on what our regional financing model should be… I believe it is always positive to talk. Sometimes you reach agreements, sometimes you don't, but you don't lose anything by doing that, and hence, I would like Mr Puigdemont and everyone else to attend. If he doesn't want to, you will appreciate that I can do nothing further.
Aside from that, I spoke with Mr Puigdemont by phone not long ago and I agreed to call him to speak in the near future. I will speak with him. As I have said on many occasions, I am always prepared to talk, but there are some things that we shouldn't speak about aren't there, such as contracts of adhesion or about how to try to go against our national sovereignty and the rules that have governed our co-existence for many years now? But, if there is a will and an ability to be constructive, then I believe that we can take some positive steps in the right direction and I will try to involve all the political forces that want to be constructive in this issue.
As regards other matters, the truth is that today we have called the party congress, there is still a lot of time ahead of us and hence, I will notify this at the right time, within a more reasonable framework - I don't want to say that this is not the right framework, but you appreciate perfectly well what it is that I want to say - all those decisions you referred to in your speech. But, if I didn't specify what my candidature would be earlier this morning, then it is not reasonable for me to do so now, in the event that I am going to stand, but I imagine that you are all perfectly well aware of what is going to happen.
Thank you very much.