Press conference by President of the Government following Council of Ministers

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

31 July 2014 · Press conference following the last Council of Ministers before the summer break

Context
Rajoy addressed a press conference following the last Council of Ministers meeting before the summer 2014 recess, reviewing Spain's economic recovery.
Main themes
Spanish economic recovery, GDP growth, unemployment reduction, tax reform, market confidence, risk premium, consumer confidence, public debt management, regional liquidity, budget forecasts, Eurozone competitiveness
Duration
~88 min
98th percentile
Words
10,522
98th percentile
Sentences
434
98th percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
11.0
32nd percentile
Syntax
3.12
63rd percentile
Vocabulary
1.95
6th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

434 sentences in 156 paragraphs

President of the Government.- Good day. I appear before you, as is usual, following the last meeting of the Council of Ministers before the summer break.

This has been a long meeting, with many issues on the table, 103 to be precise, and some of them as important as the tax reform. You will find detailed information on these matters in the Council Reference and, if you wish, in the Q&A session, we can further discuss any issue of interest.

The reason for my appearance here, as you are aware, is to take stock of the period of political activity ending today.

If you remember, on 27 December last year, at an appearance similar to today's, I said to you that 2012 was the year of adjustments, 2013 the year of reforms and that 2014 was going to be the year of recovery. Well, I believe that this first half-year has confirmed that forecast in an overwhelming manner.

Without trying to bore you with a plethora of figures, I would like to highlight those figures which, in my opinion, clearly show the improvement in the Spanish economy.

The risk premium today stands at 138 basis points and the interest on the 10-year bond stands at 2.55%, in other words, at a level not seen before in Spain's recent history. That basically means that our country has recovered the market confidence it had lost. We have shown that we are trustworthy and that we meet our commitments.

I remind you that this year, before the deadline agreed, we have started to repay to Europe the loan we received to recapitalise those financial institutions that needed it. That helps gain confidence.

This reputation we have gained also translates into money; we have significantly reduced the interest we pay to service our debt and that has allowed us to allocate funds to other areas such as, for example, improving the liquidity of the regional governments through the restructuring of the Regional Liquidity Fund which was tackled yesterday at the Fiscal and Financial Policy Council. These are new financial facilities for an amount of more than 4 billion euros which will go towards maintaining essential public services, such as healthcare, pharmaceutical products and education.

Confidence has also significantly increased within Spain. The Consumer Confidence Index, which stood at 61.8% a year ago, today stands at 89.3%, in other words, a 27-point improvement. The current Economic Situation Indicator has risen from 45.9% to 74%, and the Expectation Indicator from 77% to 104%.

These are values that haven't been posted since 2007, in other words, since before the crisis, and which show that the Spanish people are starting to very clearly see an improvement. They show that fatalism and despair are transforming to a rational and reasonable sense of confidence in the future.

Last Wednesday we became aware of the growth figure for the Gross Domestic Product in the last quarter, which stands at 0.6%. Just a year ago this was still falling, by 0.1% while today we are growing strongly thanks to the competitiveness of our economy. The year-on-year rate now stands at 1.2% and I can tell you that after the summer break, when we draw up the new Budget, we will once again revise the growth and employment forecasts upwards. You know that less than a year ago, in September last year, the growth forecast made by the government for this year was 0.7%; in February, in the Debate on the State of the Nation, I said that we thought we would grow by 1%, and in April, in the notification we sent to the European Commission, we spoke about 1.2%, and now, in September, we will revise the growth forecasts for this year once again. We have been very prudent, but things are going better - I must say that this is a stroke of luck - than what we had originally forecast.

I also want to say that we are looking at healthy and diversified growth taking place within a framework of price stability and increased competitiveness. This growth is here to stay.

On this point, I would like to highlight that only a few months ago it seemed impossible for the Spanish economy to be one of those that would enjoy greatest growth in the Eurozone. Remember the press conference I gave in 2012, two years ago; well, in less than two years we have gone from being an economy on the verge of bankruptcy and a bailout to becoming one of the economies enjoying most growth in Europe.

In the end, all these figures are condensed and can be reflected in what is most important to us, in the target for which we have made all the reforms and towards which all our decisions are focused: creating jobs.

In this aspect, we have experienced an about-turn of 180 degrees. When we came to power, unemployment was growing by 12%, while the latest EPA survey shows that unemployment is now falling at a rate of 7%. This is the balance, in economic terms, of what has taken place in Spain over these last long two and a half years.

I could go on for a good while on this issue, but I am only going to highlight certain issues that are sufficiently illustrative in themselves:

Just look, year-on-year GDP growth in 2014 currently stands at 1.2% and the employment growth rate at 1.1%. With the so-called 'green shoots' of 2011, GDP grew by 0.6% while the employment rate fell by 1.2%. These are the effects of the structural reforms implemented and we hope that the figures for the month of July, which will be announced in the first week of August, are of the same vein as the employment and National Insurance contribution figures in recent months.

All these figures, and many other besides that I will not list to not overwhelm you, such as on inflation, tourism, household debt reduction, retail sales, automobile sales, etc. show a clear change of trend and an undeniable recovery regarding which I would like to make certain observations that I believe to be worthwhile.

Firstly, and this is how the government sees it, and hence, how we will convey this to Spanish society - recovery is firm and improving. This is neither an illusion nor false optimism. We are on firm ground. As I just said, the recovery is here to stay. That has been confirmed to us by the OECD, the International Monetary Fund and other international bodies.

The second observation I wish to make - it is true that the effects of this new scenario have still not filtered down to everyone in Spain, because the damage cause by this crisis has been enormous, but it is no less true, as I said in December, that the Spanish people have good reason to be hopeful.

The third observation - what has happened is not by chance or by good luck by any means. We have worked very hard to achieve these figures; they have required a lot of effort and tenacity on the part of the Spanish people. Whoever wishes to take this merit away from the government is entitled to do so, but they shouldn't ignore the extraordinary merit of the Spanish people as a whole. It is the families, the self-employed, the companies and their workers who have balanced the accounts with their determination and their courage; but it is no less true that sound economic policy has allowed these efforts not to go in vain; firstly it helped avoid a bailout and now we are returning to recovery in record time.

I want to make a fourth observation - we have been able to tackle this crisis without leaving the most needy unprotected. We have maintained pensions during the toughest and most uncertain times for our economy.

I would like to stress that this government has only ever increased pensions whereas previous governments have not. And I should say that some countries subject to a bailout have had to lower pensions by 10%, and some of our peer countries have had now to impose a freeze on pensions for 18 months, and they don't even have the same ideology as the Partido Popular [People's Party]. Hence, we have managed to prioritise and try to support those people suffering the most.

And we have managed to achieve, for the first time ever in Spain, an average retirement pension in excess of the 1,000-euro mark.

I would like to add that we continue to have universal, public and free healthcare. The same can be said of education and long-term care; there are more grants than ever and more people are being cared for than before.

In short, we are heading in the right direction, but we are aware, and this is fundamental, that there is still a lot to do and there are still many difficulties to overcome. For that reason, we must continue to persevere with good policies and it is now time to put our foot on the accelerator of growth. It is time to do what is necessary to increase economic activity, to create many more jobs and to better attend those who have been hardest hit by this crisis.

That is the objective of some of the reforms that we have approved today and of those that we will propose in the next parliamentary period, including:

Tax reform: this will help alleviate the fiscal burden on some 20 million Spaniards, mainly those on the lowest incomes. To start with, those that earn less than 12,000 euros will no longer pay Personal Income Tax. 72% of people who make a Personal Income Tax return in Spain declare an amount below 24,000 euros; these people will enjoy a tax break for two years, in 2015 and 2016, of some 30%, although some will in fact pay nothing, as I said before. Hence, this is a major tax reform. The tax rates for independent contractors and SMEs will also be improved, tax on families, the most needy social groups and on small savers will all be reduced. In total, over the course of the next two years, some 9 billion euros will be returned to the taxpayer's pocket.

The reform, which has been definitively approved and submitted to Parliament, also includes certain improvements on the initial draft:

Following agreement with the social stakeholders, the Employment Activation Plan will be started up in October, which provides for actions to help the long-term unemployed and those over the age of 45. Other measures to modernise the employment services in terms of efficiency and rigour in the training systems will be introduced, together with a review of the basic income model to improve coverage for those people suffering the most.

I want to underline that this plan also provides for the renewal of the Collective Bargaining Agreement signed three years ago with the social stakeholders and which has brought such positive results for the competitiveness of the Spanish economy.

In September, we will also take serious stock of the compliance with the Plan to Reform the Public Administration Services, an important, meticulous reform which we will continue to foster and step up with new measures such as the Law to Reform Administrative Procedures and the Law on the Legal System for the Public Administration Services.

By way of example of the results that are coming through, let me tell you that through the reform measures of the public administration that have been implemented to date alone, we have saved more than 10.4 billion euros. By centralising procurement and services within the ministerial departments and their dependent bodies alone, a saving has been made in less than a year of 160 million euros.

In this summary, I must mention European policy.

Following the elections held in May, we are at the start of a new legislature in Europe. My intention is to encourage our partners and the new heads of the EU institutions regarding the need and urgency of turning all our efforts to the economic activation of the continent.

After what we have gone through in the last few years, it is fundamental that European policy is aimed at growth and job creation. We also want the recovery in Europe to pick up, and, to that end, we will continue to propose initiatives and reforms to the European institutions. We do this in the conviction that economic growth and well-being are the best defence against Europhobes and the best policy for defending the great political project that is Europe.

Finally, in this hasty summary at the end of the parliamentary term, I would like to highlight the importance of the change of Head of State.

I believe that the process of abdication of Don Juan Carlos and the proclamation of Don Felipe took place with total constitutional normality; with smooth coordination between all the institutions and with loyal and responsible conduct from Spanish society as a whole, from the majority of the political parties to the media. This was helped by the experience and generosity of Don Juan Carlos and the training and prudence of Don Felipe. We can now say with satisfaction that this process has taken place with tranquillity and an institutional normality almost unheard of in our history.

Barely one month after his proclamation, the King and Queen have earned the respect and affection of the vast majority of the Spanish people, and they have also started to exercise, in a model fashion, their role as the maximum representatives of our country overseas. In these few weeks, they have undertaken a full agenda including visits to all those countries with which we share a border to help strengthen relations of good neighbours.

As regards Don Juan Carlos, he will shortly start his new institutional activity by attending, on behalf of Spain, the investiture of President Juan Manuel Santos in Colombia, at the start of this month of August; in other words, in a few days' time, next week.

I will draw to a close now.

I am aware that there are still many Spaniards who are having a very hard time, I know that. I know that for many the crisis is not over yet. I am not unaware of what is happening in my country, nor am I insensitive of the terrible situation that many people are in.

I know that we have had to adopt tough measures that no government likes to adopt and that, of course, no government approves lightly, but we have tried, at all times, to share out the cost fairly and preserve the core basis of our Welfare State. And now the results are starting to filter through.

If you remember rightly, in the summer of 2012, we were on the verge of a bailout, while we are now one of the European economies to enjoy most growth. Two years ago, unemployment was growing at a rate of 12% whereas now it is dropping at a rate of 7%. Two years ago, the risk premium stood at 600 basis points whereas now, despite today's ups and downs, it stands at 140 points. Two years ago, the Spanish stock market stood at some 6,500 points, whereas it now stands at some 10,500 points.

These are the figures - there are more - that show the magnitude of the change and of the colossal task undertaken by the Spanish people in record time. That is why I want to reiterate my feeling of pride and satisfaction at the ability of Spanish society to comprehend the situation our country was in, adapt to it and get to grips with turning it around.

This has been a great collective task that must necessarily lead to hope. If, between us all, we have been able to turn such a critical situation around in the most difficult of circumstances, then I have no doubts that now, under more favourable circumstances, we will be able to take the most from this new path of growth.

There is still a lot to do - a great deal, if you like - but we are increasingly gaining ground on our target of returning the well-being and confidence to the Spanish people that were lost during the crisis.

And that is all. Thank you very much, I will now take any questions.

Q.- President of the Government, the regional crisis also falls under this stock-taking exercise. Following the meeting you held on Wednesday with President Mas, I would like to know two things: firstly, in respect of the document he gave you, do you see any possibilities for agreement on any of the points raised there, on the deficit, investment…, on any of them?

And I would also like to know whether, following your conversation, you believe that the polling stations will be put to use on 9 November, despite the fact that the Constitutional Court can suspend the Referendum Act and the call for a referendum.

And lastly, a minor issue, you told us that you will revise the GDP upwards, but you have not told us what the new figure will be.

President of the Government.- I will answer your last question first. We have not decided yet. We will present the General State Budget on that date set by law, in other words, in the last fortnight of September. We have raised the forecast already, from 0.7% to 1%, and from 1% to 1.2%. I don't know for sure so I would rather not risk giving you a figure because… But we will certainly raise it. That and the employment forecast.

Second issue, the meeting with Mr Mas. I must say, because I have not spoken about this - I did so through a communiqué - that our meeting was held in a polite and respectful manner, as it should have been. I reminded him of my position, which you are all aware of and which is exactly the same as I have explained here. It wasn't precisely in this room, it was in a building adjacent to this; Mr Van Rompuy was here, the President of the European Council. On the same day, Mr Mas had announced in the morning, following a meeting at the Regional Government building with other political forces, his position and I expressed mine in the afternoon. Logically, in an issue of this nature, the President of the Government will not keep veering between positions.

I have always had my position very clear. Fortunately, I believe that I have the support of many political forces here, particularly the Socialist Party, which is the second largest political force in Spain today; we saw this in the debate that took place in Parliament. And the Constitutional Court clearly stated that it was of the same opinion.

Hence, and I said this to the President of the Regional Government of Catalonia, and I don't believe this came as any surprise to him, that my position was the one he was aware of, firstly, because the President of the Government is under an obligation - like everyone, but if someone should be the first to do this it is the President of the Government - to follow the Law, and this referendum is illegal; and because, moreover, I believe that this is very prejudicial for the people of Spain as a whole, for those Spaniards that live in Catalonia and for those Spaniards that live elsewhere.

Hence, I told him that my position was 'Legality and dialogue'. And, yes, the President of the Regional Government presented me with a document on a wide range of issues that we are studying, including such issues as financing, infrastructures, etc. It is a document containing those issues that people are concerned about, as you would expect, which I believe is what we need to talk about.

I also told him that my priority was to create jobs as swiftly as possible - a positive figure on job creation in Catalonia has just been announced and my priority is to continue trying, and I believe we are achieving this, to ensure that the autonomous regions, some of which are not in good shape, can maintain their public services. What has been done with the Regional Liquidity Fund and the Supplier Payment Plan has been very positive, because it has put more than 100 billion euros in circulation and, among other things, suppliers have been paid, but this has also kept public services operating smoothly, and hence I am going to continue working in this direction.

Aside from that, we will attend, as in many other parts of Spain, to the demands made by governors, by regional presidents and by mayors to the extent that, logically, budgetary possibilities so allow. And I, of course, will study this document for many reasons. Firstly, and most importantly, because this is my obligation and, hence, I will study this document and any other presented to me by the regional president of any other autonomous region in Spain.

You asked me about what I think will happen on 9 November. Frankly, I don't know what will happen on 9 November. I only know one thing: that Mr Mas has said that he will not do anything illegal. And I believe that that is a well-judged decision. Hence, I hope that is what will happen.

Q.- President of the Government, I deduce from your words that you feel calmer after your talk with President Mas, but, even so, I would like to ask you this. Of all the people who are still having a tough time in Spain, some of them are PP voters while many others are voters, for example, of CiU. What do you say to these people when, for example, three former treasurers of the Partido Popular are about to go on trial, and that Judge Ruz believes it proved that the PP had a slush fund, and that those who were a political benchmark for three decades were guilty of theft? What do you say to all these people?

President of the Government.- In truth, those are two questions. In response to the first question, if I now feel calmer, well, I have always felt calm in this regard. My obligations include never losing my calm or peace of mind, and I believe I tend to always meet that obligation. Moreover, if I did lose my calm, this would be bad for Spain and bad for me. In other words, this is not going to happen.

My position derives from the fact that I am very clear about what I have to do and I am very clear about what my obligations are. Of course I would like this situation not to have arisen, because it is not good, it is not easy and, as I said before, it is bad for those Spaniards that live in Catalonia and for the rest of the people of Spain. But, in the end, these things happen and it is my obligation, first, to follow the law, and it is my second obligation to talk and try to resolve the problems of our citizens, wherever they may live and whoever they may be. And I will not renounce these two obligations ever.

As regards the second question you asked me, I should say that the fact that this type of occurrence takes place is clearly not something that anyone likes and that the most important objective, the key objective, in which I believe we must all lend our weight, is to avoid that this type of occurrence takes place again in the future. I believe that this is the main objective. It is true that there are those who are in the situation you described and I would like to say that, nevertheless, these are tens of thousands of politicians who are in a different situation, who haven't been put on trial and I hope never have to go on trial.

I would also like to say to you that our institutions are operating well and that is also good news. We have an executive power, a legislative power and a judicial power, and it is the judges who are entrusted with upholding the law. Justice works in our country and that is something that cannot be denied, and I believe that we can see how justice treats everyone on an equal footing.

Many of the people you have mentioned are no longer part of our political life. The only thing I have to say is that the courts are the ones who must decide and the rest of us must simply uphold the rulings handed down by the courts. And I will do this whether I like the decisions or not.

Secondly, and this affects all political leaders, is to do everything possible, and the impossible, to ensure that these situations do not arise again in the future. We have presented a raft of legislation to Parliament, perhaps the most emblematic of which is the Transparency Act that will come into force, I believe, at the end of 2014. I do not believe that there is any other country in Europe that has made such a great effort in this regard as we have with the Transparency Act. We have presented a law on the economic, fiscal and financial regime of political parties; we have presented a law containing the Statute on Senior Positions and I would like all of this to be agreed between all of the political parties. I don't believe this to be mere ideology, they are common-sense laws that help enhance transparency in public administration and I am convinced that they will be very useful in the future and they will help protect us from many evils.

Q.- President of the Government, you have also had the opportunity this week to hold a meeting with the new leader of the Socialist Party (PSOE), Pedro Sánchez. I wanted to know whether you came out of that meeting with the feeling that you will be able to maintain the same level of relations as you had with the previous leader, Mr Pérez Rubalcaba, on issues of State, such as Catalonia, and whether you feel that, as you asked him before the meeting, he will not remain equidistant between the Constitution and independence.

At this meeting, he also conveyed to you a resounding negative response, in his own words, to the proposal for the direct election of mayors. I wanted to know whether the government intends to push on in September with this proposal regardless.

President of the Government.- I believe so. I believe that what is reasonable and sensible is that, in the future, there is a correct relationship between the President of the Government and the Leader of the main Opposition Party. I believe that's how things should be and that this is very positive. I had this relationship with Mr Pérez Rubalcaba and I feel that nothing bad happened for our citizens as a whole as a result of this good relationship; quite the opposite, I believe that this was very positive.

I specifically told him that there were certain issues on which I felt it to be essential - I can't remember if I used the word essential or not but, of course, that is how I feel - for there to be consensus. First, regarding the model of State, in other words, whether what Spain is should be decided by the majority of the Spanish people - not the majority, rather all of the people of Spain - of course, I feel it is logical that the two main parties should be in agreement on this issue and I have no doubt that this will be the case.

Regarding the issue of Catalonia, Mr Sánchez also set out his position to me, which was already known, that he is against the holding of the referendum proposed for 9 November; hence, on that issue, I feel assured.

I also said to him that it was very important to reach an understanding on European issues - I believe that is pure common sense - I had that understanding with the previous leader, Mr Pérez Rubalcaba. Very important decisions are taken at an EU level that affect Spain and the very structure of our country. In other words, it would be unthinkable for us to join the Banking Union and to cede, as indeed happened, all the supervisory and resolution powers of the Spanish banks to the European institutions and that yet, we couldn't agree on that here. This, in my opinion, would be ridiculous, as it would have been ridiculous for only half of the Spanish people to be in favour of joining the Euro back then, and half against and that the political parties were in disagreement on the issue.

Hence, this is the second issue, the issue of Europe. I believe that we should reach agreement on that matter.

As regards defence policy, it is also very important for there to be agreement, above all, at such difficult times as the world is currently going through. Just look at what has happened yesterday and today in Libya or what is happening in Ukraine. This agreement is very important and I believe there will be no problems. And the same is true of defence policy.

Aside from that there are many issues. I also spoke to him about these laws on democratic quality that I alluded to before, but the former issues obviously concern me more, because they are State policies that should not be changed just because the government changes.

As regards direct elections for mayor, that is indeed his position, but let me tell you something quite frankly: this is not such a ludicrous proposal, since it has not only been made by the Partido Popular, but has also been contained in the election manifesto of all the widely supported political parties in Spain. Hence, it is not so ludicrous, nor is it so ludicrous when there are many absolutely democratic countries in the European Union that have this type of prevailing legislation: in the United Kingdom and in France, for example. Hence, this is an issue that we should consider. There are those who believe the mayor should be elected by the people, and this is the position proposed by the Partido Popular, while there are others who believe he shouldn't be. Let's just wait and see. I understand their position, but others may hold a different position. This issue has not yet been closed with the Socialist Party.

Q.- Mr President of the Government, I wanted to ask you about the institutional political situation. You have said that you don't see any crisis because the institutions work. I don't know whether the approach adopted by the nationalist parties will lead to an institutional problem in Spain or not.

On another note, do the results of the European elections, with the emergence of political forces that bring into doubt the so-called bipartisanship, concern you, because this is the rise of right-wing political forces and perhaps more central and left-wing forces that are fighting for supremacy over the PP and the PSOE?

President of the Government.- Those are two different issues. One refers to institutional health, something which is undoubtedly key for a country. A country without institutions is a country where there's no progress or well-being, and we can see this in other places in the world through seeing how the world operates.

The second question relates to the results of the European elections. You have asked me to give a brief analysis of how I see things; that's what I understand your question to be.

As regards the first point in relation to the proposals of certain nationalistic forces, quite frankly, something that is very important in any facet of life, not only in politics, is for people to feel secure and certain. That is key. An economy needs security and certainty; when someone sets up a company they need to know that this company is going to go well because, in order to sell, or when someone signs an agreement, they need the security and certainty that the other party is going to fulfil the terms of this agreement. Hence, whatever generates uncertainty and insecurity is not good for anyone.

It is clear that at this time, Spain, I stress, following a great effort made by the Spanish people over these last two years, has gained increased confidence overseas. That can be seen and people know that. Now, it is clear that, if we have a debate such as the present one, which does not influence matters, but of course doesn't help matters, which is what I conveyed to the President of the Regional Government of Catalonia the other day, aside from other observations. Just look, in the times in which we live, with processes of union all around, being here and going through a process that heads in entirely the opposite direction is nonsensical.

Hence, security, certainty, institutions that run smoothly and that are reliable are things that are very important for a country and shouldn't be toyed with.

The second point, the European elections. I will make two observations. Firstly, the results around Europe are somewhat different from the usual results, not just in Spain, but around the whole of Europe. Just look, for example at the United Kingdom; the government's party came third, while its coalition partner - the liberal democrats - came fourth. In France, just look, the far right won the elections. In Italy, the second largest political force - I will not try to describe the political forces at all - is what you know it to be. In Spain, the Partido Popular and the Socialist Party came first and second; they have lost many voters and a great deal of support, and that is something that we must obviously take into consideration. And, of course, I do take that into consideration.

Now, I, quite frankly, will tell you what I think, which is what I have to say, rather than what other people think. I believe that a model that is similar to the Spanish model is good for Spain and it is the model that exists in the countries with the greatest levels of well-being and wealth in the world. In the United States there are two political parties; in the United Kingdom there are two parties and then a third smaller party - the liberal democrats; in Germany as well, which is the party now in power; in France there have traditionally only been two political forces and although another party has come first in the European elections, I don't believe that will happen again in the future… that is what gives us stability and the security and certainty that you mentioned.

We now have to make an effort to recover the confidence of many voters. We have gone through a very complex, difficult stage. I am convinced that the Partido Popular will do this and I, of course, will work hard to achieve that, not to defend a political party, but rather because I believe it is the best party for the nation of Spain as a whole.

Aside from that, I'm not going to make judgement calls on anyone. The only thing I will say is that I respect all those Spanish citizens who turned out to vote for the political party of their choosing. That's as far as I will go. They have all my respect, but I will try to ensure that many of them -if they will allow me, those who did not vote for my party but for others - change their vote.

Q.- President of the Government, regarding the question for you about whether you believe that Mr Artur Mas will finally hold the referendum on Independence on 9 November, you said that you received his affirmation that he will not do anything illegal. Given that, what situation does your government expect to have in the end? Do you expect to have advance elections in Catalonia? Do you foresee the possibility of a coalition government between the CiU and ERC parties?

And on the subject of the regional debate, in light of the confessions by Jordi Pujol that he may have defrauded the tax authorities for 34 years, do you believe that will affect the independence process or not?

President of the Government.- I believe that the President of the Government shouldn't guess what might happen, on whether there will be a coalition government or whether elections will be held, because it is not really down to me to take that decision and I have no information to lead me to think one way or another. In other words, the main work of the government is to take decisions when events unfold or take place, and to take the initiative. That is what the government has to do - provide responses to situations and take the initiative on those matters that so require.

The only thing I have seen in the media, and that I have repeated on many occasions, is that nothing will be done that is illegal. And I have said that the law and dialogue must prevail. Aside from that, we cannot speculate further.

The second question is whether I think that what happened with Mr Pujol might affect this process that has been set in motion. Quite frankly, I believe that what affects this process that has been set in motion is its illegality and that, moreover, it is prejudicial to all the Catalan people and for the rest of the citizens of Spain. That is what affects this process, it is illegal, it is against the Constitution, it is contrary to the vote of the majority of the people of Spain and it is toying with something that solely corresponds to the people of Spain as a whole. That is what affects this process and, secondly, it is bad, negative, prejudicial and will impoverish both Catalonia and the rest of Spain. That is what truly affects this process.

Q.- President of the Government, your party will, by September, have a former treasurer, a former minister and a former provincial president in prison. Aside from the fact that they are no longer party members, they were when they committed the offences that sent them to prison. I would like to know how that affects the PP.

On another note, I wanted to know why the Partido Popular paid Jaume Matas a salary of 5,000 euros a month after leaving politics.

As regards Catalunya Banc and the missing 12 billion euros, I wanted to know if you continue to maintain that the bailout of the banks didn't cost the Spanish people anything.

And regarding Gaza, I wanted to know whether the government condemns the attacks by Israel on schools and, if this is the case, where you will announce this condemnation.

President of the Government.- As regards your first question, I answered that before and, as you well said - you said this well and I applaud you, because I can see you understand the issue well - they are no longer party members.

In relation to your question about the banks, I understand this but we only had two options: commit to maintaining these financial institutions or simply let them go under. That was the only other alternative available to this government. This alternative was available to many other governments of many other countries in Europe and in the United States, and everyone did more or less the same. It is true that they did this five or six years ago while we have only done this more recently, but that is because the person who should have done this didn't do it.

If we had let these banking institutions go under who would have paid their customer's deposits? Who would have taken responsibility for the pension funds? Who would have taken responsibility for those people holding investment funds?? What would have happened to all those workers at Bankia, Bancaja, Caixa Cataluña and Caixa Galicia? They would have all been without a job. What did we do? Offer them a way out in a very difficult situation for the financial institutions. Today, Caixa Cataluña has a national solution, Caixa Galicia has an international solution and Bankia has its own project.

Now, people often say, "you helped…" No. What would have happened to the thousands of people who worked for these financial institutions? They would have been out of a job. And the account holders, who would have paid them? The Spanish taxpayer? And who would have taken responsibility for the investment funds and the pension funds? That was the alternative open to this government and I can assure you that this was much cheaper and much better all round, much better for the vast majority of the Spanish people.

Gaza. Those of us who are in power are not only engaged in politics, we are also human beings and I have said this on various occasions, my priority in the issue of Gaza, my priority and that of any other decent person is to foster a ceasefire that is upheld and that this humanitarian drama be brought to an end in which many human lives are being lost, in which civilians, children and people who have nothing to do with what is taking place there are dying. That is the priority of any normal person; to do away with this situation that can only be described as terrible and all the efforts of the international community should solely be aimed at this. This is being done, and everything possible is being done, but it is not easy and, of course, the two parties should pay heed to what the international community is saying.

I repeat, that is the priority, but in the future this is not going to resolve anything at all until such time as a political solution can be found to the conflict and this political solution can only be a two-State solution with both nations living in peace and security. Until such time as this happens, I fear that we are going to see many such situations as the only you enquired after.

Q.- If you will allow me, I wanted to return to the issue of Catalonia, and also to the issue of the Basque Country.

On the issue of Catalonia, you dealt with Jordi Pujol on many occasions. One only need remember the Majestic Agreement, for example. How did you feel when you heard the news we all received last Friday? What was your first thought, having seen, let's say, the privacy of the individual's negotiations? What reflection do you believe this leaves in Catalan society? How is it possible that for 34 years he could hide this without anyone knowing it and reporting it?

Along the same lines, do you believe that this could have any influence on the emergence of this nationalism?

Finally, could the 23 proposals that Artur Mas presented to you the other day be the famous 'third way'? Is there anything there that could be negotiated in these terms as a way out of this maze?

As regards the issue of the Basque Country. We asked on many occasions at these press conferences after the issue of terrorism, of ETA. Fortunately we no longer need to do so in these terms, but I did want to ask you about the after-effects on Spanish society over these last few years. Specifically, there are police officers involved in the infamous "Faisán" case who are asking for a pardon. Will the government get involved in this?

We also hear how the Basque Regional Government often asks the government to intervene to close this chapter of our history. Do you believe that peace is definitively consolidated or may there be further events in the future?

President of the Government.- As regards the issue of a pardon, we will look into this at the right time, like always.

In relation to the other matter, I have already said on many occasions, and I believe this is a position shared by the vast majority of the Spanish people, that what ETA must do is break up, full stop. It's what it must do and, until such time as that happens, things will remain as they are - a terrorist organisation that is not broken up. That is exactly the case and I believe that it makes no sense to look at things any other way or say another word on the matter.

You asked me about what I thought of the matter and how I felt. Of course, you are asking me for a psychological analysis of myself and for me to say this out loud. This is a somewhat complicated issue. And what does Catalan society think of the matter? I don't know but, from what some people have told me, this has logically had a great impact. He is a person who has left nobody indifferent and the only thing I can say is, as I said before, that the institutions must do their work and the politicians should try to ensure that these things don't ever happen again. That is all I can say.

The 'third way'. You asked me a question, which is all well and good, but not because of what I am going to say now. I will tell you what the question is that I have been wondering for a long time now. So, of course, that gives us the sensation that, if I now say it is well and good, for that reason… But that is the question I have been asking myself. I don't know, I don't know what the other two ways are. In other words, the only thing here is what you are all aware of, which is a person who has decided to call or announce a referendum and the vast majority of Parliament has said that it is illegal and is very bad for the general interests of Catalonia, which could end up in a very difficult situation, and for the whole of Spain.

Aside from that, my position can be none other than this, and the whole world understands that: legality and dialogue. And that is where I stand; you will not find me operating outside of the law nor closing the path to dialogue with other people. I have never done this and I will not be starting now.

Q.- I wanted clarification, firstly, about whether in the meeting with Artur Mas this week it was the President of the Regional Government who guaranteed to you that he would uphold the law, in other words, if you are not referring to certain previous statements that he made, and rather that it was at this meeting when the President of the Regional Government clarified that he would always follow the law.

And at the same meeting as well, you said before that you felt very calm, like usual, but I wanted to know whether you face forthcoming events with optimism in terms of Catalonia. At any event, can the President of the Government tell us whether Spain's unity is at risk or not?

On another note, you are the only President of the Government who has ever held an audience with more than one king and I am curious to know if you can comment to us on any differences between an audience with one king and an audience with another.

President of the Government.- I have to think very hard about the response to the last question.

In the first question you asked me about whether Mr Mas said to me that he was going to uphold the law in relation to the referendum. I have answered this on many occasions and I am not capable of saying whether he said this in this way to me at the meeting the other day. The case is that I have taken it on board, I don't know whether this is as a result of the meeting or because he has said this on many occasions, that this is how things are, and hence, I don't have to question whether this is what he says and hence I don't.

Am I optimistic about the future? I am under an obligation to be realistic and balanced in my judgements. I feel calm about the fact that I know what I have to do and that gives me great interior strength and I know what I have to do. It is likely that there will be certain difficulties, but I believe things will get back on track.

Is Spain's unity in danger? I don't believe so.

And my audience with the kings? They are different people. Like with everything, no two people are the same, but both love their country, both work for their country, both have renounced many things for their country, for Spain, they are very familiar with the issues and I believe that the Spanish people can, as we do, feel very calm about things.

Q.- Are you still thinking about closing off this legislature without changing your government, as you led us to believe recently?

You have spoken about reforms, and within this issue of reforms what has most been delayed is the abortion reform. Can you simply clarify one thing for me: has the government decided whether to punish the so-called 'eugenic abortion' or not? It is simply to see whether progress is being made on the issue or not.

And as regards the tax reform you spoke about, you did indeed mention various groups that will benefit from it. There's one issue, more so in a country that is aging as much as Spain, which is also an economic issue, which is the issue of maternity benefits, which is well below the average of our peer countries. Little progress has been made there in the tax reform. When will there be a surplus to standardise maternity and other family benefits at the level of our peer countries?

President of the Government.- I believe that one of the most important issues about this tax reform is its social content and the increases in minimum family benefits.

But let's deal with things in order. Will I see out this legislature? Yes. Will I perform a cabinet reshuffle? No.

As regards the abortion reform, we are presently studying it and seeking the maximum consensus possible.

Then you asked me about the tax reform. There has been a very significant increase in minimum family benefits in the tax reform we have implemented: for descendents, a 30% increase in the minimum amount exempt; for under 3s, a 24% increase; for ascendants, a 25% increase and in the case of disability, there have also been highly significant increases in the minimum amount exempt.

Then, there are new forms of benefit for families and the disabled. Working mothers continue to receive the same benefit and new social protection concepts have been created for families with dependent offspring with a disability in excess of 33%, for families with dependent ascendants with a disability in excess of 33%, an annual quota of 1,200 euros per annum for large families and for large families under the special regime, which, furthermore, can be accumulated for each family situation.

I believe that it is the first time that this has been done in our country and, indeed, we would like to increase these benefits more in the future, but that also depends on the state of our economy. In other words, this is another area that I would like to see increased, in the same way as pensions, healthcare, education and all the other social benefits, but, logically, we need to see what revenue is available to decide on which costs we can afford. But I believe that a very important step has been taken in the right direction through this reform.

Q.- You have praised the change in the Head of State between Don Juan Carlos and Don Felipe VI. I wanted to ask you whether you share, as the Speaker of the Lower House said, that the express privileges afforded to Don Juan Carlos were a bit of a shambles, as he was textually quoted as saying.

Secondly, in light of the European election results, it seems that we are faced with a type of generational change. The King is twenty years younger than you, the Leader of the Opposition as well, and perhaps next year the United Left [Izquierda Unida] will have a new leader, such as Pablo Iglesias or Alberto Garzón, perhaps, I don't know. I wanted to ask you whether you intend to stand at the next general elections or whether you feel a little pressured to stand down as a result of this generational change in Spanish politics.

President of the Government.- Those are undoubtedly two important questions. As regards the first question, you should realise one thing: the idea was mine. What do you want me to feel about that?

As regards the second issue, I was elected by the Spanish people. I don't know whether you voted for me, but some people did vote for us.

Any other important issue for me?

Q.- I wanted to return to the issue of Catalonia. You said that your obligation is to resolve the problems of our citizens and you talk about the economy, about jobs and about the Welfare State, but what's not clear to me is what your response is to the millions of Catalans who have taken to the streets to express their wish to be consulted about being part of Spain. I don't know what path you intend to take to channel this ambition or if it is this same path, of responding to economic needs, jobs creation and well-being.

On another note, following your meeting with Pedro Sánchez, in the communiqué issued by the State Secretary for Communication, it stated that you were opposed to the constitutional reform proposed by the PSOE, because you considered that it wasn't the right time politically. I wanted to know what part of this constitutional reform you find objectionable.

President of the Government.- In reality, I am not opposed to it because it is not the right time politically-speaking, but rather because no-one has told me about it. In other words, it is very important, when a reform is made, to know what the objective is and, of course, when someone says "we are going to make a constitutional reform", you need to know why. I don't know if you understand me or not. It's amazing that these things need to be explained, but when someone proposes a constitutional reform… For example, in the case of Catalonia, a referendum has been proposed; I can understand that. It's like the case of the "third way" I was asked about before, exactly what is it? You yourselves have asked me about it. I believe that if someone wants to propose something, it should be clear what it is.

Obviously the President of the Government cannot be frivolous about such things, nor set positions on issues that haven't been raised, because we don't know what they consist of and what the objective of the reform is. When someone has a reform and wants to propose it, I have already said that I am fully prepared to listen to them and even to support it if it seems reasonable.

I remember in 2011 when the then President of the Government José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero called me because he wanted to implement a constitutional reform. It seemed very reasonable to me and I said yes to him the very same afternoon, and within a month it had been approved by Parliament. But, when someone wants to propose something, well, they should do so properly and say exactly what it is that they want to do.

On this matter, I should say that I understand everyone's opinion. My position is very well-known. I support what the Constitution states. The Constitution can be amended, of course it can be amended and, indeed, it has already been amended. Now, there are things that I believe should not be amended. In other words, I don't believe that our State system should be amended; I believe it is right that Spain is a parliamentary monarchy. I believe that our national sovereignty should not be touched and I believe that only the Spanish people should decide on the model of State in Spain. I believe in Spain's unity.

That's my position and there are others that have other positions, and they are perfectly entitled to have them, and, if they want their positions to triumph, what they have to do is bring about a change in the law by means of the tools established by law because, if in a country like ours, which is one of the most important countries in the world, we start to call into question the law, it seems to me that we have taken the wrong path. Of course, for as long as I am President of the Government, the law will be upheld.

Q.- Will you revise the growth forecast in September beyond what Minister De Guindos raised it to this week, to 1.5% or 2%?

Then, as regards the tax reform, you spoke about it being a comprehensive reform, a global reform of the whole system. In the end, it has only focused on Personal Income Tax and you have not touched the reform of regional taxes, inheritance tax and wealth tax, which were contained in your election manifesto. Will this be done at another time? Do you undertake to carry out a comprehensive tax reform of regional financing in the next legislature if you win the elections?

Is the economic recovery sufficient to bear the tax reduction provided for in the tax reform?

Do you fear that the challenge from Mas will hit Spanish debt hard in the autumn and force the course of economic policy to change, including the tax reform?

President of the Government.- As regards economic growth, under no circumstances. No decision has been taken, as I mentioned before to one of your colleagues, but under no circumstance will the forecast for 2014 exceed 1.5%. But we do feel that the present forecast of 1.2% will fall short and hence we will raise it.

The second point is the other taxes. Indeed, the idea we mooted initially was, in addition to the most important taxes - Personal Income Tax, Value Added Tax, which we haven't touched, and Corporate Income Tax - to adjust everything at the same time and tie this in to the new model of regional financing. However, after talking to many stakeholders and also with the Fiscal and Financial Policy Council, and with regional presidents, we felt it wasn't the right time to carry out a reform of the model of regional financing, above all, because there are not sufficient resources available. That is the main reason.

Just look, we are still undergoing a process of reducing the public deficit, the target for which stands at 5.5% for this year, and we have managed to negotiate not having to reduce it so quickly. Hence, we didn't feel it was the right time and this opinion was shared by the vast majority of regional presidents. So, while we intended to adjust Inheritance Tax, Wealth Tax and the Tax on the Transfer of Assets, and we have adjusted but were going to further adjust the tax on bank deposits, this is the reason we were unable to do so.

I believe that this, on which we will work during the course of the remaining part of the legislature, should be a decision to be taken at the start of 2016, which will constitute the second part of the tax reform.

Your third question was whether there are sufficient resources available as a result of the tax reform to maintain our deficit targets. We believe so. The calculation we have made is of 9 billion euros over two years, 2015 and 2016. But we believe that this will also generate resources for the State, because it will result in increased private consumer spending and an increase in investment. Should that be the case, this will result in greater economic activity, and hence more VAT, more jobs, higher Personal Income Tax revenue and less unemployment benefits because more people are working.

So, this was not an easy decision, like the vast majority of decisions that must be taken on economic policy. In fact, as regards the deficit target, which stood at 5.8%, as you are aware, we said that we believe we can manage 5.5% this year. Next year will be more complicated, but we also depend on... We have made a commitment to growth in economic activity and increased tax revenue.

Then, you had a fourth question, which is rather an opinion. Look, anything that generates - I said this before - uncertainty, doubts, a lack of clarity or a void as regards where things are heading in the future cannot be good. Well, I should also tell you that we have already been talking about this issue for some time now and that, fortunately, the 10-year Spanish bond is now being paid at 2.5%, which is a new record. And last year we saved 9 billion euros in Spain as a result of the lower risk premium and the price of these Treasury bonds, in other words, it was a year… and I believe that we will save the same amount this year.

But in order for this to happen we must maintain our credibility. In other words, this is a problem of confidence; if the markets, which lend the money, see that this is a country undergoing reforms, which is starting to exit the crisis, which is growing and which controls its public spending, we will increasingly be lent more funds and at a lower price. If we do the opposite and spend what we don't have, and be constantly asking for more, increasingly… That is what happened in 2012.

What was the bailout? When there was talk about the bailout, what did that mean? It meant that we needed, and I said this on many occasions, 90 billion euros to pay our healthcare and education systems, and we had to resort to asking for it to be loaned to us, and we were receiving these loans at extraordinary interest rates. We have overcome that situation, but that doesn't mean that we don't have to continue governing with rigour and trying to do things right, because if we don't, we will once again relapse and quite frankly, I believe that's the worst thing that can happen to a country.

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you very much for your attention. Thank you.