Press conference of the President of the Government after the V Conference of Presidents.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

1 October 2012 · V Conference of Presidents

Context
Rajoy addressed a press conference following the Fifth Conference of Presidents in Spain on October 1, 2012, summarizing agreements reached on fiscal consolidation and the economic crisis.
Main themes
Fiscal consolidation, economic crisis, Conference of Presidents, autonomous communities, public deficit reduction, euro zone obligations, fiscal pact, regional financing system, economic competitiveness, intergovernmental cooperation
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,032
86th percentile
Sentences
148
80th percentile
Readability
48
56th percentile
Grade
13.3
59th percentile
Syntax
3.30
82nd percentile
Vocabulary
1.95
6th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

148 sentences in 65 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen, and thank you very much for your attendance at this meeting.

The meeting of the Conference of Presidents has just concluded, which began, as you all know, this morning with a brief breakfast with His Majesty the King and with Prince Felipe. The actual meeting started at 9:30 in the morning; between 9:30 and 1:30, we discussed the initial intervention I made in my capacity as president of the Conference and president of the Government, and then, starting at 2:00 in the afternoon, we moved on to discuss various aspects related to a proposed Declaration, which was made available to all present.

In the end, we unanimously approved the proposed Declaration. I do not know if this proposal has been delivered to all of you at this moment. I am told it has not, but I assume that in a few minutes it will be made available to you, and I would like to make just a few comments on it.

First, I believe that today’s meeting of the Conference of Presidents has been very important, fundamentally for one reason: because we have talked about important issues. We have discussed the economic crisis, which at this moment is the greatest concern for all Spaniards; we have talked about people, their economic situation, and what we should do or what we could do to try to alleviate it as much as possible, to improve it, to face the crisis, and to resolve the problems of all Spaniards.

In my opinion, it has been very positive that we have reached points of agreement, points of agreement that I would say are general points of agreement; but I think it is very important. It would be impossible for us to reach agreements on every single policy that needs to be implemented and on all the reforms that need to be proposed, but we have reached agreements on some general points, which I want to say comforts me and I believe should comfort us all.

I want to thank all the Presidents of all the autonomous communities who have come here; they have all come, and they have also made an effort to bring positions closer together. There have been many interventions throughout the morning and, above all, also throughout the afternoon. In the end, an agreement was reached on a text of which I would highlight the following as the most important or most relevant issues:

First, the Conference of Presidents has expressed its commitment to fiscal consolidation. I believe this is very important; it helps to build confidence in our country, because all Administrations, the central State Administration and the autonomous Administration, are telling anyone who will listen that we are committed to fiscal consolidation and, therefore, to reducing the public deficit.

It is also established here that we will fulfill the obligations arising from our membership in the euro and the obligations arising from the Treaties on stability, coordination, and governance of the Economic and Monetary Union, which is the Fiscal Pact.

I believe this is important. That in Spain, as a whole, a strongly decentralized country, where spending centers are not only in the central State Administration but also in the Autonomous Communities and in Social Security itself; that we all express our commitment to meet the public deficit targets for the coming years is good, because it is fulfilling a commitment, but it is also good because reducing the deficit is never bad. On the contrary, what is not good is to spend for a long time what you do not have.

We have also agreed, in relation to this point of the public deficit, that the Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy will establish a procedure for next year to determine the criteria for distributing the public deficit targets arising from the path of fiscal consolidation within the European Union.

As you all know, there are already established criteria for this year, which have been reflected in the General State Budgets, and in those of some autonomous communities that have presented them, and next year these proposals or criteria will be discussed again within the Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy.

Also, in relation to this matter and referring to the financing system of the Autonomous Communities, the Declaration states that the Conference of Presidents is aware that, in accordance with the laws -- and I will not cite which ones; the paper will be delivered to you later --, in the terms and deadlines provided therein, it is the responsibility of the Permanent Technical Committee for Evaluation to analyze the effect of the application of the financing system and to report the results of these analyses to the Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy, which will make the appropriate decision if necessary.

Therefore, I believe this is the most important aspect in relation to the first point, which is the agreement to support fiscal consolidation policies.

Second point. Spain needs a more competitive economy, which is logical, and considers it essential to continue advancing in the implementation of measures to promote growth and job creation. There has been a debate, which you all know, about whether austerity or growth measures. I believe that all sensible people have understood that austerity is necessary and that, at the same time, growth and employment measures are needed, and the Conference of Presidents has also understood this today.

The Declaration speaks of the need to intensify collaboration and cooperation between Autonomous Communities and the State to promote the necessary reforms in order to facilitate economic development, to streamline the relationship of entrepreneurs with the Administrations, and to energize the Spanish productive fabric. Here some issues are pointed out; I will refer to them briefly and then they will be included in the Declaration.

An evaluation of active and passive employment policies will be carried out to strengthen their efficiency and to improve their interaction, as well as to strengthen the coordination processes between the state public employment service and the autonomous public employment services.

It is also mentioned to share a legal environment and more effective public Administrations to promote entrepreneurship, investment, growth, the productive fabric, and the development of new sectors of activity.

It is also mentioned, and we will do this, to create a working group within the Sectoral Conference to develop a program for administrative rationalization, in order to eliminate bureaucratic obstacles, simplify regulations, and procedures, and avoid duplications. I believe this is important. I believe that in Spain there is excessive regulation, sometimes contradictory, and I believe that an important effort can be made to reform the Administration, for which, I insist, a working group will be created within the corresponding Sectoral Conference.

Thirdly, the Conference of Presidents has agreed to support the measures adopted at the European Council within the framework of the Pact for Growth and Employment. As you know, very important decisions were made at the last European Council. This European Council was described by some as decisive for the future of the European Union. And what happens is that decisions were made, and their implementation is slow. What we ask from here is that what has been agreed in the Pact for Growth and Employment at the European Council at the end of June be implemented as quickly as possible.

Also, since before the end of the year, in this quarter, the community budget for the coming years will be discussed, there is clear support from the Conference for the Common Agricultural Policy and an adequate level of resources for cohesion policy, paying special attention to transitional regions and to the outermost regions, and taking into account the need to work for the development of a special treatment for insularity and specific for the Cities of Ceuta and Melilla.

Fourthly, in addition to, as I have said, the public deficit, structural reforms in Spain and structural reforms in Europe, the Conference of Presidents considers that financial tension and doubts about the viability of the single currency make it necessary to have instruments that guarantee access to adequate financing, not only for public Administrations but also for the private sector, with special consideration for small and medium-sized enterprises. This is a very important issue for Spain, as you know. It is very difficult to face the situation generated by the economic crisis when the difficulties for financing are great for many institutions and prices are exorbitant, and, of course, very far from the prices at which other countries in the Union are financed, which shows that, without a doubt, the Monetary Union is not complete in its design.

Therefore, the last point, which is the fifth, states that the Conference of Presidents notes that the economic crisis has highlighted the deficiencies in the institutional architecture of the eurozone and supports economic union, political union, fiscal union, and banking union, as proposed at the European Council last June.

In summary, this is a commitment from all for more Europe. Spain is a country that is very comfortable in Europe. We believe that Europe is a space of democracy, freedom, coexistence, and human rights. Our entry into the euro was very good for Spain. Consider that, although we are now in a situation that is not good and there are many people who cannot work, when we entered the euro, 12,500,000 people were working in Spain. Twenty million people reached employment, and today seventeen million or just over seventeen million are working, which, in any case, is many more than were working when we entered the euro.

The euro has been good for Spain; Spain bets on it, on its consolidation, on its irreversibility, and for Europe to be an important actor, one of the important ones, in an increasingly open and competitive global world. And to be so, we must advance in political union, economic union, fiscal union, and banking union.

In summary, there were people from different political parties here, and there were people who, even belonging to the same parties, could have contradictory interests, because some are presidents of an Autonomous Community with certain characteristics and others preside over other Autonomous Communities with different characteristics.

It was not easy to reach an understanding, but I believe that today Spain sends a good message: there is agreement, there are points of convergence on very important issues. It is true that we all talk about the need to make reforms, about fiscal consolidation and the public deficit, and we may not agree on whether to act in this or that area to reduce the public deficit. But I do consider it very important, and I give it a lot of value, and that is why I appreciate the effort that everyone has made, that essentially, on the most important objective, we have all agreed and reached a point of convergence.

Ladies and gentlemen, from there, I am at your disposal. I am a bit in a hurry because I have the Italian president, and I would not want him to arrive at Moncloa before I do.

Q.- Mr. President, I wanted to ask you if you do not think that next year the Government will yield and want the deficit to be distributed differently. The Government has agreed in the Declaration that it is possible that next year's deficit will be distributed differently, that it will not have to be reduced to 0.7 percent. Is this not a bad image for the markets, because it is true that the Autonomous Communities have been the main responsible for the public deficit during 2011, for the deviation that occurred? So, I do not know to what extent the Government will be willing to allow this revision to take place.

President.- I believe that it is not good, in terms of the markets, as you say, and that is why it will not happen in 2013, but it is something to be considered for 2014, in light of the evolution of the State or the Central State Administration, and of the Autonomous Communities themselves.

In any case, the key objective is for Spain, as a country, to meet its deficit commitments with the European Union. I am not so concerned about the distribution at this moment, but I have no objection to that debate taking place for 2014. But it would not make sense now, and, of course, both the Central State Administration and the Autonomous Communities and Social Security must make a joint effort to overcome this situation.

Q.- I understand that if they have agreed to reform it for later, have all the Communities accepted this year's distribution because, according to what we are told, there has been a lot of debate within? We know that Catalonia was not in favor and Andalusia was not in favor of the distribution. Have all accepted the distribution? Do you think they will all comply? Will they accept what they have been told?

Second question, after the unemployment figure known today, are you concerned that the labor reform is not working as you expected?

Finally, Mr. President, is the request for a rescue for Spain imminent?

President.- In relation to the last question, no.

Regarding labor reform, it is evident that labor reform will produce all its effects as soon as economic activity begins to manifest itself in our country.

However, I must tell you something. The entrepreneurs' contract is functioning very well in such a difficult and complex situation as the one we are going through. And, in terms of EREs, while in recent years every time there was an ERE it ended with a dismissal, now many EREs no longer end in dismissal, but rather in a temporary suspension or a change in working conditions; for example, mobility. That is to say, that flexibility, from that point of view, we do believe has worked; but we already said at the time that labor reform is not the only instrument that allows for job creation, much less immediately. But it is a very important instrument for flexibilizing labor relations and for creating jobs in the future.

Therefore, I have confidence in labor reform, which is one of the reforms that has received the most support from the Government.

In relation to the first question, the Declaration that will be handed to you now has been signed by each and every one of the people who were there.

Q.- Mr. President, do you believe that this agreement strengthens the State of Autonomies? Above all, do you believe that Catalonia will continue to be a fundamental piece, a fundamental Community, of the State of Autonomies?

President.- With this agreement, I believe that common sense is certainly reinforced. I think that is fundamentally what is reinforced. In a situation that Spain is going through, the fact that the presidents of the Autonomous Communities meet with representatives of the Government of Spain, led by its President, the Minister of Finance, and the Vice President, I believe is a demonstration of common sense, because important matters have been discussed.

From there, I believe that the Autonomous Communities, about which we have heard many things, just like about the political class and many other things over these times, have played a very important role. The Autonomous Communities are part of the model of autonomous state that we all established in 1978. In my opinion, it is a model that is fully valid. The Autonomous Communities are now going through problems, just like the central State Administration and the Town Halls, because there are no revenues, there is no economic activity, and we are in a difficult situation; but the Autonomous Communities, along with the Government and the support of many more people, are decisive for Spain to emerge from the crisis.

Regarding the issue of Catalonia and the events that have occurred in recent days, there has been no debate on that matter nor has anyone raised anything. If you ask me if the issue of the Fiscal Pact or others has been raised, no. The president of the Generalitat has not raised it and has only spoken about the economic situation, which was the fundamental objective we wanted to address here.

Q.- Vice President, I wanted to insist on this point. You say that the Fiscal Pact has not been discussed, but I wanted to know if any president of another Autonomous Community has commented on that claim or that sovereignist debate that exists in Catalonia. Specifically, has there been any call from any president of a Community, or several, for the unity of Spain?

President.- As far as I remember, but I cannot assert it categorically, I have not seen any allusion to anyone present. There were debates, but on very specific issues, among each other. But no.

I believe the meeting took place in a good atmosphere, with a lot of sense and a willingness to overcome problems. I insist, it is difficult because, of course, the financing of the Autonomous Communities is not seen the same way by someone who has their entire population concentrated in large cities as by someone who has the population of the Community dispersed in many places. These are not easy matters, and reconciling the interests and perspectives of one and the other is not easy. But it did not seem to me that there was any reproach and, in no case, any bad manner from anyone towards anyone.

Q.- Would your Government physically act to stop a referendum in Catalonia?

President.- Anticipating events is something that is not advisable to do in any aspect of life, and much less when one is a ruler. A ruler takes positions in response to events that actually occur. Therefore, if that to which you refer were ever announced, I would be happy to answer you.

Q.- Mr. President, I would like to know in what terms the King addressed the regional presidents early this day and if he took the opportunity to make any call for the unity of Spain, as he has publicly done, on the other hand.

President.- You know that I am not the most suitable person to say what the King says and much less to comment on his words. So I regret that I cannot answer your question. What I can tell you is that the presence of the King was very pleasant for all the people who were there.

Q.- Mr. President, you highlight the positive side of the points of agreement that have been reached during the Conference, but do you find it normal that, with a direct threat of an independentist referendum, whether or not it is in the Constitution, with that threat, the president of an Autonomous Community comes before his peers and you, who are the President, and says absolutely nothing about it? Do you think it is normal that there is a crisis of the state model, or some say there is, and it is not raised at the moment they meet? And the same goes for the PSOE and federalism.

President.- I find it positive that everyone has focused on a topic that affects Spaniards, such as the economic crisis. From there, it is evident that there are many things on which the Popular Party and the Socialist Party disagree, the Popular Party and Convergència i Unió, the Socialist Party and Convergència i Unió, or Coalición Canaria. But what seems positive for Spain is that we have focused on that issue.

Today we were not addressing other matters. We did not come here to talk about the state model, nor the Common Agricultural Policy, nor Spain's foreign policy in relation to Latin America or the problems occurring in the Middle East. No, we came here to talk about the economy and we have reached some points of agreement, and whenever points of agreement are reached, one is in a better situation than when none are reached, and I believe the country is too.

Q.- Regarding the request for help from the European Central Bank, did you tell us that the decision has not been made or that it will not be raised this weekend? I do not know if the Government is negotiating that request for help and if there is, if the President knows, the conviction that Germany does not want the rescue to be requested now.

Regardless, I would like an assessment of the leaks to which the Government of Spain is subjected, yesterday, again, from the Reuters agency.

President.- Regarding the leaks, as you know much better than I do, I have never leaked anything in my life. Moreover, I do not intend to do so, and that is why it makes me such a popular figure among some of the journalists who are not here at this moment.

From there, I cannot be responding to leaks every day, because there are even days when the leaks are contradictory. Here the one about the weekend has come out. Well, if there is an agency or someone who says that this weekend we are going to request the rescue, as they say, there are two possibilities: that this agency is right and has better information than I do, which is very possible; or that it is not so, which may also be possible or not, what does it matter!

But, if it serves you at all what I can tell you, and if you think that what I can tell you is more important than that leak, I will tell you no. But, even so, you can think what you deem appropriate and convenient because, moreover, you may be right. So...

Q.- You say that the Autonomous Communities have committed to meet the deficit targets, although many of them may privately acknowledge that it is difficult. Would you bet your hand that they will comply this year?

Then, I do not know if there has also been talk of mechanisms like the Autonomous Liquidity Fund, which may seem to fall short, of which 90 percent has already been requested and there are many Communities to come. Is the Government thinking of expanding it, improving this mechanism for next year?

President.- Regarding the second question, we are going to help the Autonomous Communities to finance themselves. It would be an absolutely irresponsible Government if it did not do so. Therefore, we are going to do it and, in return, we will ask them, as is natural, to comply with their public deficit targets.

This is a difficult moment, this is a moment in which Spain must act together, at least all its Administrations, and the autonomous Administrations are decisive, as I said earlier in response to a colleague, to emerge from the crisis.

Regarding the first question, these are the questions... "Will you bet your hand?" Then, if I do, fine; if I do not, also. It is like that thing of "you rule out or do not rule out," and then we are always in the same. What I am convinced of is that the autonomous Administrations and the Government of Spain itself will do everything in their power to meet the deficit targets. We know it is difficult because we have to go from 9 percent to 6.3 percent, which is 2.7 points, in a time of recession and in a time when financing is difficult to obtain and expensive. But, even so, we are absolutely aware that this is good for Spain; that, moreover, it is our commitment to Europe and that it is a good message for the markets.

And I will tell you more: Spain currently has a very high public deficit, but Spain has been a country that until not long ago had a budget surplus and a public debt that was equivalent to 40 percent of GDP, which is, as you know, very low public debt.

Therefore, this is a cyclical problem, it is not a structural problem of our country, and do not have the slightest doubt that we will overcome it and that together we will make an effort to do so.

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you very much to all.