Speech and subsequent discussion with the President of the Government at the close of the 32nd Meeting of the Economic Circle
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy addressed the 32nd annual meeting of the Economic Circle on May 28, 2016, reviewing Spain's economic trajectory and discussing government formation.
- Main themes
- Spanish economy recovery, government formation, employment as national goal, European integration, economic policy reforms, social inequality, banking system crisis, political leadership, historical economic review, diagnosis and reform strategy
- Duration
- ~84 min
- Words
- 10,023
- Sentences
- 399
- Readability
- 57
- Grade
- 11.3
- Syntax
- 3.06
- Vocabulary
- 1.89
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other399 sentences in 129 paragraphs
Ladies and gentlemen,
A very good day to you all. I have also joined in the applause you have given to Antón Costas, even though he has proved in his speech that he is not perfect; but then in life no one is perfect. We all have some things that put us in difficult situations.
In any event, as well as applauding him, I would like to thank him for his kind words of welcome and for saying that they should give me the Golden Ball award. In fact, the Golden Ball is what I should give, Antón, to the Economic Circle, because I must admit that I have always felt at home here. The Circle has always enriched me, I like coming here, and it creates a certain obligation for me because of course I prepare my speeches for here and I take them very seriously. So the Golden Ball award for the Circle and also for me, because I won't deny myself.
Ladies and gentlemen,
In his first presentation, in his introduction to these words that I am going to say, Antón Costas talked about certain things, things that concern the Spanish people. He talked about the economy in the broadest sense: the economy, social policy, inequality, and above all employment, which has to be the great national goal. He also talked about Europe; we are Europeans, that is what we are and that is, luckily, what we are going to continue to be for the rest of our days; a Europe with its problems, with its difficulties, but which is always capable of overcoming these difficulties and always ends up taking steps in the right direction. And he talked about the formation of the government, which undoubtedly is a subject that concerns and worries the Spanish people these days, above all after what I have seen.
My speech was going to deal with, and will deal with, the situation of the Spanish economy; but unless I am told otherwise, at the close of this speech I will make a brief comment on the formation of the new government, which will also be as a kind of response to the first of the questions that I may well be asked here today.
As Antón Costas recalled in his speech, this is the 12th time that I have attended the annual meeting of the Circle and since they invited me for the first time in 2004 I have not missed any of them. These days, preparing today's speech, I wanted to carry out the exercise of a chronological review, which would have been very illustrative, so I have re-read what I said at the forum in previous years; in other words, I have read the 11 speeches I have made here.
I can assure you that it has been a very illustrative exercise, and not because I reviewed my own words, obviously, but that I believe that they prove a very good compendium of our economic and social history over more than a decade; a compendium of what I thought, but it is a period that I have lived partly as President of the Government, and partly as representative of the main opposition party.
I would like to say that what has surprised me most in this review I have made of my speeches, is that in general lines I was not wrong in what I said to you; I was not wrong. And I have to admit that this is a cause of some satisfaction for me, because I have always tried to say here what I really thought about the major problems of the Spanish economy.
Put another way, when between 2005 and 2011 I forecast the risks that we ran as a result of wrong diagnoses and, as a result of the wrong policies derived from them, I have to say that, unfortunately, I was right. It was a tough time for me, as you can expect, when one assumes political responsibilities; a time in which I was dubbed a demagogue, unpatriotic, a purveyor of catastrophes and other things like that. But, unfortunately, I was right.
That helped confirm an old conviction I have, which is that there is no tail wind if you don't know where you're going. That's why when I became President of the Government, my first concern was to prepare with many other people, some of them members of the Government, others contributing their ideas from outside, a diagnosis as close as possible to reality, however tough it appeared at the time. Next what we did was to design and apply the set of measures that could take us out of that dramatic situation.
Whenever I have come here I have always used the same procedure. I have divided my speech into three parts: first, where we are coming from; second, what our position is; and third, where we are going. Today I am going to do exactly the same as on other occasions.
As you know, 2012 will remain in the memory of all Spanish people as one of the worst years in our recent history. Tens of thousands of people had lost their jobs, thousands of businesses had closed, there was credit for neither companies nor for families and the banking system was at the point of collapse. Everything that could have gone wrong ended up even worse than expected, and the succession of bad news was a depressing litany for the whole of Spanish society; and also, I have to say, for those who at the time had just become the Government of Spain.
In the rest of Europe things have not gone much better, you will recall. The euro, the best political project of the last century, appeared at the point of implosion due to the profound imbalances between the different European economies. Needless to say now all the sound and well-reasoned analyses that were written at the time about how it was impossible to move forward with the single currency. There was once more talk at the time of a two-speed Europe: the so-called "unsupportive north" and the "second-speed south". In short, and I don't want to tire you any more, 2012 was the year in which Spain was at the point of bankruptcy; there was a risk that our country's image could have suffered a deadly blow, as well as the welfare achieved by all the people of Spain during the recent years of democratic life.
I am not now going to enter into the details of the profound reform plan that we undertook, which perhaps, looking back on it now, was not seen clearly at the time; but today, with the perspective of time and the support of the results, it can clearly be seen as what Spain needed back then to move forward successfully.
We then faced the most urgent aspect of starting to put our accounts in order and to negotiate with Europe a margin of flexibility to comply with our commitments; but there were many other tasks that could not wait. I refer to the restructuring and realignment of the financial system, which was incapable of performing its function; the reform of the labour market, whose adjustments could be counted in millions of unemployed; the fight against late payments which was strangling small companies; the energy reform that was to end with a growing deficit that was at the point of leading to the bankruptcy of the system; the reform of the public administration; market unity, the Entrepreneurship Plan, the system of flat rate contributions to the Social Security system, etc. etc. All these reforms have undoubtedly served to transform our economy.
I would like to say that all this was done without neglecting the fundamental elements of our system of social protection, and that is very important. Consider that more than 13,700,000 Spanish people receive some form of public income, whether as pensions, unemployment benefit, dependency benefit or civil service pensions. For example the spending on pensions has increased by 19.2 billion euros during this government and social spending is easily over half the budget, at 53.5%. We have also maintained the levels of expenditure on essential services such as health and education, and with careful programming we have even been able to complete certain infrastructures that are essential for our country.
All this - and I give it a great deal of importance - represents the other side, so often ignored, of the effectiveness of economic management: I am referring to security for the most vulnerable people. Balancing the accounts and creating jobs is the only way that guarantees the future of our welfare system, and only a good economic policy is capable of generating sufficient resources to allow payment of pensions, unemployment subsidies, jobseekers' income, grants, healthcare and a quality system of public education.
Good intensions are fundamental and people should have them; but these fundamental good intensions, which we must have, have to be accompanied by the capacity for a sound economic policy; if not, they remain, and are important, as I said, only as good intensions.
What is true is that we can recall all those years from the perspective of hope granted us by our current situation, but in no case from complacency, because there are many things that still have to be done if we are to be satisfied. However, without becoming complacent, we can say that we have managed to find the formula required to improve our economy: making it more open, reforms and ambition; a formula that if we apply with the same faith that we did over those years, will take us in the not too distant future to the final exit from the crisis that began back in 2007; in other words, to return to twenty million people in work, which has to be the main goal of the next government.
Ladies and gentlemen,
So that is where we came from. Now we are going to see where we are and then, in the last part of my speech, I will explain where we are heading.
The development of this ambitious reform agenda, which I have kept to a sketch because you know the reforms already and because they are already in the past, has not only managed to haul Spain out of the extreme situation we were in four years ago - we avoided bankruptcy, the bailout, etc. etc. - but, and this is most important with respect to the future, it has allowed us to transform the economy, recover the confidence of the international markets and gain efficiency, flexibility and capacity to compete.
We have corrected the imbalances and established sound bases to ensure a promising future; we have moved from a situation of deficit, recession and high level of job destruction to the recovery path of economic growth and job creation, and that is most important; and we have ensured that Spain has been transformed from a country without a future to a leader of growth and employment in the Eurozone. And today, in the light of the changes in our economic situation, it is also difficult to recall the calamity suffered by Spain in the past.
Some of the data on where we are today:
In short, Spanish growth today is a healthy growth. For the first time, we are growing and we are creating jobs without throwing our foreign accounts into imbalance. One of the main problems before of our model of production was that in phases of expansion the deterioration of the foreign sector - the increase in imports, fall in exports and the loss of competitiveness - ended up choking us; now, however, we are growing because we are more competitive because we export more and because we are not running up a debt. And for the first time in the Spanish economy, we are living better because of what we produce and sell, and not because of how we are indebting ourselves.
The improvement in economic activity leads - and I am talking about now - to the creation of jobs at very fast rates. In 2015 we reached a level of over half a million net jobs created, with the greatest annual reduction of unemployment in history: 678,000 fewer people. A very positive figure is that nearly 20% of this reduction corresponds to youth unemployment, 126,000 fewer young people per year, which is something very instructive and stimulating with respect to the future, because here we also have the great challenge for the future.
And as well as the trend in exports and the labour market, there are other indicators that are evidence of the strength of economic activity in our country:
And the question worth asking is: Now what? That is how we stand, also explained in a very brief summary, as it has to be, but where are we going? We have seen where we come from, where we stand, but where are we going?
For me the answer is clear: if we maintain the same economic policy guidelines we did so far, the following will occur: Spain will grow at high rates over coming years, around 2.5% per year, and perhaps in the right conditions, at above this figure. If these forecasts are met, we will be growing at significantly higher rates than those in the Eurozone, and one of the fastest rates in the most important economies. In other words, we will continue to head growth among the main economies in the Eurozone, ahead of Germany, France and Italy.
In the first quarter of this year we have grown at 0.8%. I don't know what our growth rate will be, nor do I want to risk giving figures for the second quarter of this current year, but they will be good. In any event, I can tell you that in the first half of 2016 we are going to grow more than in the first half of 2015, which as you know was a good half year for the Spanish economy. Not so long ago we learned the figures from the National Accounts which told us that comparing the first quarter of 2016 with the first quarter of 2015, a total of 533,000 full-time jobs were created by you and others like you.
There is a figure about which I would like to comment because all the sectors have done well, but the one that has done least well is construction, where jobs were increasing at a rate of 3.1% and where they have fallen by 0.9%. In this respect, I would like to say something and then I will return to this issue.
Political instability and political uncertainty are very negative for the economy; but some decisions taken by some governments also do enormous damage to the Spanish economy; for example, those taken in the city councils of large Spanish cities.
Suspending new hotel licences for a year, extendible to two, is a very serious mistake; suspending tourist licences to rethink the tourist model of a city is a very serious mistake; taking away legitimacy from the public-private collaborative body Tourism of Barcelona is a very serious mistake; halting and making it difficult to apply the order governing outdoor tables harms the economy; bolstering the illegal street sales and promoting the creation of a trade union of street sellers harms the economy; refusing to cover the Ronda de Dalt ring road, which is an investment of enormous importance, harms the economy; filtering the wages of people who go on strike is also an enormous mistake; and paralysing, as has happened in Madrid, "Operation Chamartin", "Operation Campament9o" or penalising an investor who came from an important country and had made a commitment to Spain by acquiring, among others, a building of enormous importance in Princesa street in Madrid, is a very serious mistake.
Cheap populism, acting with ideological prejudice and not thinking of people's general interest does a great deal of harm to the economy, just as political instability and political uncertainty do. And undoubtedly some events we have seen here recently do harm and give a bad image of the country's economy.
On to the next issue. If we are capable of acting with common sense and maintaining as I have said before the general lines of economic policy we have engaged in over these years, we are going to grow at an average rate of one million jobs per year in 2016, 2017, 2018 and 2019, and thus we are going to ensure that at the end of 2019 there will be twenty million Spanish people working, which is the target we set on the Stability and Growth Plan that we have submitted to the European Union.
If we do things with common sense, as well as creating 500,000 jobs every year, we will consolidate the implementation of a healthier and longer lasting growth model in Spain, based on competitiveness. As I said before, compared with situations in which Spain was growing by accumulating imbalances, now for the first time we are growing because we export and we are doing so because we are more competitive. I repeat, this is giving rise to growth effects that will be solid and lasting.
If we continue to maintain reasonable economic policies, we will be in better conditions to overcome any difficulties that may arise in the international environment. You all know that there are uncertainties still to be resolved: the situation in China, the future of Europe, the effects of technological innovation, etc. Strong economies, and Spain can have one if it does not stray from the current path, will always be better prepared to face these uncertainties and offer stability to their citizens.
If we maintain the economic policies of recent years, the economic recovery, economic growth and growth in jobs will be the pillars of our new Welfare State, as they are the conditions required to guarantee an adequate level of social services. In addition, we will have more resources to invest in areas such as education, which is a great priority for the coming years in our country, R&D, infrastructures that are really useful for economic development, and any other measures that may contribute to support and promote economic activity in our country.
Well, ladies and gentlemen, that is what will happen over the next four years, and I am in a position to tell you because I believe it and because I have lived through it, if we do things sensibly.
It would be a mistake in my opinion not to continue to reduce the budget deficit, however tough it is. This year we have reduced it from 5.8% to 5%, but at the end of 2017, and after the new negotiations we have had with the Commission, the public deficit in Spain must be and will be under 3%. And we have already reduced it for more than four years, two of them in recession. So we have to continue to keep control of our public accounts.
It would be a monumental error to go into reverse gear on reforms, as we have heard suggested by some. Going back on the labour reform, on the Budget Stability Law, or on the reform of the energy system, would be a monumental error. It would be a serious error not to be careful with prices, with costs borne by companies, with debt and with unprofitable investments. It would be a serious mistake to raise taxes or generate mistrust. And it would be a serious mistake not to continue with the policy of reforms of recent years.
And so in my opinion, the only way of ensuring the Spanish economy prospers, grows and creates jobs is to maintain the reforms and strengthen them so that we can become even more competitive. That is the change that has taken place in Spain. Many people now talk of change and the change that has taken place in Spain is the change that has been produced in our economy over these four years.
And I say that because every day that costs and prices of Spanish products gain competitiveness in the Eurozone is a day in which we are winning the battle because we are ensuring that more Spanish people find jobs. Every day that we make structural reforms in areas such as education and innovation, or when we invest in infrastructures that are really useful for economic development, or when we design tax policies that create incentives for research and innovation, when we support the internationalisation of our companies and entrepreneurship, or when we develop all those measures supporting economic activity that you can think of, we will have more capacity to compete and thus more capacity for growth.
I am one of those who now say that we have to choose between two models of economic policy, and we have to do so soon: between a model that is supported by those who think that Spain will have strong and sustained growth over the coming years thanks to the improvement of our competitive position, and those who want to return to another type of policy that consists of spending more, running up more debt, not carrying out reforms or repealing those that have been made. That is my opinion. I believe that the best model is the first, because, among other reasons, it has demonstrated precisely this over these years.
Now allow me, ladies and gentlemen, to take a further step: If we apply the correct model of economic policy, not only will we grow and create jobs, but Spain will have many more resources for the future; a future in which as I said before, now has a basic target of twenty million jobs in the coming years. But once we have reached this goal, we have to try to achieve the great hope we have always had: to position ourselves at the forefront of the most advanced countries in Europe.
To do so, as well as the right economic policies I have referred to, we have to take a leap forward in other matters, such as for example innovation. There are those who consider that in this matter it is enough for the public budgetary items to be increased, but there is much more to it. Innovation must permeate all the economic activity of our country, from a research centre at the highest European level, to restaurant winning a Michelin star.
We could talk for hours about innovation in its broadest sense, but there is one aspect that seems crucial to me, and that is the Digital Agenda. The digital revolution, as you know, permeates everything. It is not a matter of one sector, it is a new form of working, of relating and living in all the sectors.
When in March 2013 we held the first European summit on the matter - and there have already been two more - I proposed a Digital Agenda for Europe and for Spain with six points: complete the deployment of networks and prepare for the next generation; support the creation of network-based business platforms and models; create a single tax system for digital transactions; define the intellectual property rights of the content industry precisely; define and ensure the capacity of the exercise of individual constitutional rights on the network; and the involvement of innovation in the service industry with digital technologies.
In that year 2013, during a plenary session of the Lower House, with no one responding with one word on the issue, I warned that in 2015 in Europe there could be up to 900,000 job vacancies going unfilled due to lack of personnel skilled in digital technology. In fact I was short of the real figure, there have been more, and so it is essential to face the challenges involved in this new digital age.
It is not an option. That is not an option. Not doing it, and not doing it in time and in the right way, involves costs of all kinds, particularly in terms of jobs. And it is cruelly paradoxical that in a country such as ours, with so much need for jobs, many of them are being unfilled each year due to lack of people with the right profiles.
So to win this commitment to the future it is crucial to prioritise everything that has to do with education and training, and not only in digital matters, but in everything else. A society that does not improve its level of training for its citizens is condemned to miss the train of history. A better educational system requires more resources, although as happens with innovation, that is a necessary condition but it is not sufficient.
Ladies and gentlemen,
The question to ask now, after what I have said in this speech, is: Is Spain in a condition to deal with these challenges? In other words, can Spain aspire to play in a higher league? I tell you it can, and I say it can because despite there being a trend on the part of many people to talk about how badly things are going or to talk about the things that are not good in our country - and I don't say they are not right... There are things that are not good in our country, but despite that, Spain is a great country.
Spain is among the seven economies that have progressed most in the last fifty years. The leap we have made in these five decades is unprecedented, and our level of income, our Welfare State, and our participation in the global markets bear no comparison today with things as they were back then.
Spain, as I said before, today exports a third of its gross domestic product, more than the United States, Japan, the United Kingdom, France or Italy; as I mentioned earlier, only Germany does more. We are a great nation for tourism, the third in the world. But look, although this may be extremely important, and indeed it is, non-tourist services, services to companies, have a greater weight in our balance of payments than what the tourist sector generates. In addition, we are great exporters of capital goods, of chemical products, we are the second biggest manufacturer in Europe of cars and we also have the most innovative and competitive agro-food industry in the European Union.
Ladies and gentlemen,
Spain is a country that it is worth living in. If not, why would seventy million tourists come here? No one makes them. Or Erasmus students. This is the European country that receives most Erasmus students. And in fact, to give you some figures, of the forty-six million plus people who reside in Spain, over four million are foreigners, to which has to be added two million Spanish people who were born abroad and who have obtained our nationality in recent years.
If you look at the Labour Force Survey for the first quarter, you see something that has not been talked about a lot when there is discussion about those who come or go. Spain is the European Union country that has most foreigners working here as a proportion of the number of people in work, over 10% according to the Labour Force Survey, not counting those who have dual nationality. There are more foreign people working here than in France or in Italy. The figures for the UK and Germany are close to ours. It must be for some reason. There must be something good about our country.
And there is more. Spain has the greatest biodiversity on the European continent, and although there is a long way to go in this field, we have examples that indicate we care for and take our land and our environment seriously. I'll give you just one example: we have the record figure in Europe for blue-flag beaches. That says something about our environmental policy, although some people do not want to recognise it
Spanish infrastructures are considered to be among the six best in the world and this model of construction and management of infrastructures has been exported to the five continents. All of you who get around are well aware of the roads there are out there, the high speed trains and the motorways we have. Obviously, the news is that there is no high-speed train in a certain city, but it could also be news that there is a high-speed train network in our country, or a road or motorway network.
Spain is a country with a public health service that international indicators rank among the five best in the world. That is a very important fact and it is also something that makes seventy million people come here every year.
And we also have the highest rates of citizen security in Europe. We don't talk about that, because citizen security is only talked about when at a certain point there has been a problem with citizen security.
Spain is a welcoming and friendly country to which people come almost spontaneously from abroad to take part in its economy, in its education, in its healthcare, and to contribute to its pension system. And this has to be maintained, ladies and gentlemen. It is also very important in a European continent with an ageing population. To a very significant extent the future of our country depends on us being capable of maintaining our capacity to attract other people from other parts of the world.
I repeat, and here I must end, that Spain is a great country, which allows us to nurture all kinds of hopes. I believe that we have won, together, the right to have a dream, which is to form part of the small core of most advanced countries in the European Union. But for this dream to come true, as is the case of all dreams, we have to make an effort, we have to overcome an initial stage: first, recover those twenty million Spanish people who have to be in work, and having taken this step, we can enter a different qualitative level that opens up for us the doors to a future of progress and prosperity for all.
DISCUSSION WITH THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT
President of the Government: In answer to the first question, if I have understood it correctly, what the Economic Circle has proposed is that if no candidate achieves an absolute majority, the list that received most votes should be allowed to govern, as is the case with mayors. That is not established anywhere in the case of parliaments. What the Circle proposes is, as I understand it, two things: one, that there should be a legal change, which is not to applicable in this case; but I believe that at this time without any legal change what the Circle proposes is that the political parties should agree for this to be the case, if there is no agreement that gives the majority in the House to another political party.
I think that's a good idea. Here in Spain there were elections on 20 December. I will later explain why it appears very good to me. It is for two reasons: one, the one you are thinking of at the moment; and another, which you are also thinking of at this time; but I will remind you of the two later.
The general election was held on 20 December. The result was what it was and on 21 December the Executive Committee of my party met and at my party's Executive Committee we said: that is what there is, the arithmetic is the arithmetic. The proposal we put forward was for a coalition between the People's Party (Partido Popular) and the Socialist Party, because they made up an absolute majority, but we also included Ciudadanos if they wanted, although their votes were not necessary.
Why was that? First, arithmetic required an understanding to be reached. The reason for the People's Party to govern was plainly and simply to respect people's wishes, because what people vote for has its importance and we had 1,700,000 more votes than the party in second place, and it is worth knowing that in democracy respecting what is said by people is something that is very important.
The third reason is that despite the disputes, problems and discussions we have had, these three great parties agree on the fundamental issues: they are in favour of the unity of Spain, the equality of Spanish people, national sovereignty, European policy, the market economy... We can then discuss as to whether income tax should be higher or lower, about whether to remove the inheritance and donations tax; but we agree on the fundamental aspects.
There is another reason, also important, which is that there was a very substantial majority, because the People's Party by itself only had an absolute majority in the Upper House; but the sum of the People's Party and the Socialist Party was the immense majority of members of the House and with the forty of Ciudadanos they undoubtedly numbered many more. So there was a possibility of implementing reforms for many years, the important reforms that Spain needs, because they were three parties that can be expected to continue to exist and with sufficient votes and support on the national political scene. It was a magnificent opportunity. It is easier to carry out structural reforms in this way than only with an absolute majority because if you have an absolute majority everyone is against what you do. At least that is my experience.
There was another reason, which is the European model: Germany. The Christian Democrat Party had won in Germany, but it didn't have a majority. It entered into a coalition with the Socialists and the president is Ms Merkel and the Deputy President is Mr Gabriel, who is the leader of the Social Democratic Party. And in Austria the opposite occurred: the Social Democratic Party won without an absolute majority and the People's Party came second; and the Chancellor, who has been replaced now, but his party is Social Democrat and the Deputy Chancellor, and then the government positions are distributed, is...
The same has happened in the European institutions. Mr Juncker is President of the European Commission because the People's Party won the elections and he was voted for by the members of the party and by the Socialists; in the European Parliament we voted for Mr Schultz, who is the leader of the Socialists, and Ms Mogherini is the High Representative and is from the Socialist Party.
That is how things work everywhere and the great political change, as you have talked about change, which should take place in Spain, is that it should be possible for two political parties that have traditionally alternated in government, to reach an agreement at a time when circumstances require it, as happens in all the countries with a democratic tradition.
That was my proposal and my proposal was dealt with in three seconds, so I didn't have any other proposal to make. Everything else is purely anecdotal. Believe me, ladies and gentlemen, it is anecdotal: whether I was going to the investiture session, whether the two-month period was beginning to be used up... That was one of the possible options and the other option was of the PSOE with Podemos and Esquerra Republicana, with Convergència and with some abstentions. And everything else was unviable, not because I say so, but because it was demonstrated and is simply a question of arithmetic.
What happens now? I am not a person that changes opinion easily or that contradicts my own actions. What will happen? We'll see what happens after the elections. If the Spanish people put their trust in the People's Party and give us a majority, apart from being very grateful I will try to form a government; but if not, I am not going to use a very different approach from what I did in January, because that would be really senseless and because I also believe that it is the best for Spain.
You have said "they should let you govern". For me, if they let me govern, I would try to govern, but I sincerely believe that what is good for Spain and what is serious is a pact for four years of which all the Spanish public opinion is aware, and if there are subjects in which we cannot reach agreement, we will set them aside; but there are many issues on which we can reach an agreement. Now, you can let someone govern with one hundred and something seats, whatever they are; but believe me, that is very difficult. So what I am going to say is, if things do not change substantially, exactly the same as what I said on 21 December, because that is what I believe. You will say, "it is good for you"; yes, but it is what I believe in and, sincerely, I believe it is the best for Spain.
Antón Costas: Mr President of the Government, I hope that my insistence does not harm our friendship. Our rule is like a ladder with two rungs: the first is, if there is no possibility that a majority coalition can be formed, then it is up to the coalition that has the greatest number of seats; if that is not possible, the coalition with the greatest number of votes. When I say that, I can assure you that I am not thinking about what you say that we are thinking of.
President of the Government: And I'm not either, eh!
A. Costas: So there we are. Your attitude is very Galician, but we understand each other.
There is a series of questions, and I'll be brief. We can't cover them all now, because we are pressed for time. Some are about pensions. You have dealt with this question at some length, I believe. There is a question along these lines, in the case that you are at the head of the government, if another additional mechanism will be promoted to guarantee pensions, to the extent that our children will not be able to pay for our pensions. And there are others along these same lines to do with pensions.
I would like to take the opportunity, Mr President of the Government, to make a comment as I did yesterday in the presence of Mr Pedro Sánchez. My idea is: there will be many more crises and I hope that I have many years of life ahead of me, and you too, to experience many more crises. In these crises we will once more have to make adjustments; but we should foresee them. And just as we have an emergency fund for pensions that we can spend when things go badly, like Joseph and the Pharaoh's dream, why don't we also set up a fund for education or a fund for health, so that when there are these crises and these needs for adjustment occur again, there is a fund with some reserves to take care of them? Because my idea is that we talk a lot about pensions, probably because those of us doing the talking are close to becoming pensioners; but we have people behind us that I believe that we don't look at a lot, and who to a certain extent are greatly neglected.
But I repeat that you have already referred to this a great deal in your speech, and so it was only to reflect those people who have expressed an opinion.
President of the Government: Yes, those are obviously the most important issues for the future from the point of view of a political leader and from the point of view of any person who has an interest in the country doing well.
When I talked before in the last part of my speech about the Spanish economy having solid foundations and that Spain is really a country in which it is worth living, I talked about the Welfare State. These basic pillars of the Welfare State do not exist everywhere. In China there is no public pension system, expenditure on it is zero, and here it is nearly 40% of the government budget.
I always give the example of what happened with Ebola, which I don't know if I raised here last year. Here a person who had Ebola - yes, I did mention it last year - was cured for free and in the United States someone entered hospital with a 500,000 dollar cheque.
So for me the public pension system is non-negotiable and the same is true for public healthcare and education and, by the way, subsidized education, which is now under attack from many regional governments, and that is of some concern.
I am going to mention, because this issue of pensions... There is a figure, so that you can see how difficult it is to be in government, because I believe that it is very difficult, I can tell you... In 2007 revenues collected in Spain amounted to 442 billion euros. In 2015 we had still not recovered the level of revenues of 2007; in 2015 they were 413 billion. In other words, in eight years we have gone from 442 billion to 413 billion. Of course, then there is the system of regional finance, that is the key. But in 2009 we were at 375 billion; in other words, in two years, 2008 and 2009, we lost nearly 70 billion euros in revenue. And now things are improving. Of course, there was a good rise in 2104 with respect to 2013, and in 2015 with respect to 2014 there was also a good rise, despite the fact that we cut personal income tax.
Look at this figure: Today our revenues are 30 billion less than in 2007. Well, spending on pensions increased from 79 billion to 117 billion, nearly 40 billion more; the number of pensioners increased from 8.3 million to 9.4 million and the average Social Security pension is just over one thousand euros; but the average pension of those who enter the system now is 1,400 euros.
This is the great issue for the future. We have carried out a pension reform that is entering into force little by little. It will begin in the year 2019 and will of course take into account the revenues then; but I believe that the key, and that is why we could create the "pension fund", is to create jobs. At the end of the day, pensions are paid from the Social Security contributions, except for those that are paid from taxes, the non-contributory pensions. If we create two million jobs, we will not have to use the Social Security fund. What we will have to do is top up the Social Security fund again.
That is why the only sensible economic policy is the one that creates jobs in our country, and that is why I have told you everything I said in my speech. But I repeat, this is a key issue. It is key to raising revenue and to collect this it is not necessary to raise taxes, except in a crisis situation which I experienced in these four years; to collect revenue you have to generate economic activity and promote economic activity.
On the subject of education and healthcare, forgive me for boring you but I also have with me here the figures for what we spent money on in Spain, in all the different levels of government. By far and away what most money is spent on in Spain is social protection, which amounts to 187 billion euros. 187 billion. That is the main item; and the second is health, which amounts to 64 billion; and the third is education, at 43 billion. That is what money is spent in Spain and in all the levels of government: 187 billion on social protection; 64 billion on health and 43 billion on education. That is what we spend money on.
Obviously, maintaining health and education is something we have to do. In the end, I don't know if a fund is good or bad. In the case of pensions, the fund is paid into. When there are contributions to the Social Security system, we say: "We're going to pay more up to a certain figure and the rest goes to the fund." Of course, with respect to contributions in matters of healthcare and suchlike, perhaps use has to be made of taxation. At this point in time I don't think it's bad, but I have not studied this matter in depth.
But I repeat, that is what we spend the money on. When it is said that there is no social spending, in fact everything is social spending. Look, and I'm sorry because I know that there are many questions, in 2007 to 2016 - before I said that revenue was still below the 2007 figure - the expenditure items that increased were healthcare, which has increased by 3 billion plus euros; education, a little; and social protection, 50 billion euros. That is the State budget and that is from the report of the State Auditor's Office.
At the end of the day it is good to know that, but we should be aware and we should be clear on this, that either we have an economic policy, we have a stable, sensible government without any great ideas... In other words, as people say now, you don't govern with tweets, that's not how to govern. This means things have to be done well; it requires thought about what is to be done and it does not need populism or frivolity.
A. Costas: I agree, Mr President of the Government. Keeping an eye on the clock and looking at all of you is not probably the right criterion, or at least there are other criteria, but I am going to choose only four questions according to the number of questions that there are on these four matters. There are others, such as the reform of the public administration and some aspects that probably have been dealt with in the last part of the President of the Government's speech and I received the questions before. But there are four questions, Mr President of the Government, that I would like to ask you.
One of them is on corruption and regeneration in the general sense and in the sense affecting your own party. Allow me to read (this one has a name to it and the way it is written suggests it must be a young member): "I share many of your ideas and policies. The only thing that puts me off from voting for your party is the limited regeneration (in age, not of positions) that I see." As I say, I think that the other cards there are here point to what you said you understood that we were thinking.
The second batch of questions is on Catalonia. Perhaps expressing it in a general way I would say: President Puigdemont here on Thursday said something like the People's Party, your party, has no specific proposal to deal with Catalan aspirations. These aspirations can be defined in many ways, of course, but there is no specific proposal. When I asked you, and almost urged you, to continue in some way with these talks you began to tackle specific problems... Does your party really have no specific proposal for Catalonia?
And, now with an eye on the clock, I would not like to leave the European Union out of it and the question of the fines and relations with the European Union. Personally, Mr President of the Government, I have often expressed my disagreement with the conduct of the European Union in terms of its fixation on deficit targets and its austerity policy. At times I have even said that I felt like Saint Augustine when in his "Confessions" he said: "Lord, lord, grant me austerity, but not just yet." I don't know if in your relations with the European Union you have also often felt like Saint Augustine, but how will the matter of fines go? And let's leave the questions there, if that's all right with you.
President of the Government: I'll start with the fines. The question of austerity can be expressed in another way as well. Let's suppose that any of you is fifteen kilos overweight and the doctor tells you: "Look, you have to lose fifteen kilos, because if you don't you'll have a heart attack." So you say: "Yes, but not in a week, please, because then I'll die of something else. Give me at least six months or a year to lose these kilos." That is austerity.
I'll give you my opinion on the subject of the deficit. We came to government with a public deficit of 9.3%. Four years later, the public deficit was 5% of GDP. We have cut it by 4.3 points in four years and of these four years, in the first two, 2012 and 2013, Spain was in a recession. So no one can reproach the government of Spain by saying that it has not made an effort on the matter of the budget deficit.
Second, last year in 2015, in the light of what we have heard and read in some quarters you may have the impression, or it could be given, that we have not cut the budget deficit. Yes, we cut it from 5.8% to 5%. We cut it.
Third, the Government of Spain has the firm will to get the budget deficit under 3% in 2017 and we have agreed that with the European Union.
Fourth, the European Union has been flexible. In 2012 the deficit target for Spain was 4.4%, because in 2011 the deficit had been 6%; but, of course, in 2011 instead of 6% it was 9.3%. I went there and said: "Look, how can I cut the deficit from 9.3% to 4.4% in a recession?" We could negotiate and we did negotiate. And this year we have also negotiated. We had to be under 3% in 2016 and now it will be in 2017. I believe that is reasonable.
I believe it is good not to have large budget deficits, among other things because when you owe money you are less free and I have unfortunately had the opportunity to experience that situation, above all in 2012 and 2013. Many Spanish companies had enormous difficulties in the markets then.
So I agree on two things: you have to reduce the deficit, but as you said, not just now, please. This year, in 2016, we believe that we can reduce the public deficit and reach the target in 2017. I therefore believe that the situation at the present time is balanced.
With respect to the fine or lack of a fine, I hope that it does not happen, because it makes no sense. I am convinced that there will not be any kind of fine. What is more, what the Spanish government wants is to do things well, because in the end that is profitable, because it has determined that it is good, positive and generates trust.
In 2012 we went to the markets with a ten-year bond at just over seven per cent; the other day we issued one at fifty years, fifty, at 3.5%. Look, that is a substantial change. Many things would have influenced it, but some things were also done well in our country.
So I believe that the deficit has to be cut, and there has been flexibility on the part of the Commission because they have given us an addition year. I believe that is positive.
Finally, a comment: cutting the budget deficit is a matter that affects all of us. The budget deficit does not depend only on the local councils, which have had a surplus; it does not depend only on the Government of Spain, which spends a lot of money; not only on the Social Security system; not only on the regional governments, but on them as well; it depends on all the levels of government making an effort. So of course there are those who do not meet the deficit target and say: "I won't meet the public deficit target because they don't give me what I should have." Of course, as it is impossible to prove that we are giving people what they should have, and it is impossible to confirm their statement, we don't get anywhere.
But I have to say that the subject of funding all the levels of government in Spain (local government, regional government and central government) does not come from any system of any kind, it comes from the brutal fall in revenues I referred to before. I repeat, today, at the end of 2015, our revenues were still lower than at the end of 2007. We are improving, but this is something that has to be taken into account, like when people say: "We spend less now." Yes, but we can't spend. That is what happens in any company, and here there are many company owners, and it happens in any family or to any private individual. If you earn a thousand, you can spend one thousand two hundred for a certain time, but not for too long.
That is the story of the deficit. I am now satisfied with the decision taken by the Commission and if I continue in government I will undoubtedly work to reduce the budget deficit and then the debt, because I believe it is good for Spain.
Second issue, Catalonia, that we don't have any specific proposal for Catalonia. He has told others that his problems were not resolved with a constitutional reform "because the only concrete idea that some have presented are vague statements that fit in the 140 characters of Twitter." That is what he said here. I have not proposed any reform of the Constitution, so this does not affect me. It affects others.
I had a meeting with Mr Puigdemont, which went well. It was a good meeting. Mr Puigdemont has a position I don't share, because as I have explained here once, frankly I am not the President of the Government of Spain in order to liquidate national sovereignty. I am not going to do it. So don't count on my support for a referendum that liquidates the national sovereignty, because no, I believe in the unity of Spain, it is my duty to fight for it and for the equality of the people of Spain.
Having said that, I am absolutely convinced that if we all reach a compromise in our positions, we can talk about everything. We have, and it has to be done, the new model of regional funding of which I talked earlier; that has to be implemented and it has to be done. We have very important matters of infrastructure, they are out there: there is the Mediterranean Corridor, now we have already practically completed the high-speed line, but there are still things to do in the ports. We have the contribution, with their ideas, opinions and decisions and votes in the Upper and Lower House, on the measures required by the Spanish economy.
I recall the parliamentary group of Convergència at one time expressing opinions on issues affecting the whole of Spain. And certainly on matters of the economy and on matters of pensions, health and education. What we want is for them to collaborate and get involved in solving the major national issues.
And the subject of Europe is not a minor matter; it is a subject on which we should all express our opinion.
One can't, in the end, reduce all political activity to this matter, because there are many more things in life. We want the budget here to be approved soon. It is necessary, it is very important, for the Catalan government to have a budget. You have to make an effort. We approved the budget here twice, because we were asked to: in 2011 and 2012. Now we won't because it appears that they don't want to talk with other people. The last time two budgets in a row were approved here was with the votes of the People's Party, which is now called all kinds of names. We have acted responsibly. We have made many mistakes, but we have been responsible.
So I am completely open-minded, and believe me it is better to talk to someone who says he is completely open-minded, but says clearly some things that cannot be done, than with someone who is limited to 140 characters on Twitter. That does not work.
Then there is the subject of regeneration and the issue of age. The subject of corruption has been a nightmare for my party, for many other parties, for the institutions and for the people of Spain as a whole. I believe that at this time the courts have acted with absolute independence and freedom, as has the Public Prosecutor and the Police, the Civil Guard, and the State Tax Agency and the Customs Service. With absolute independence and freedom.
We have approved all the laws we could pass to try to be effective in the prevention and penalisation of corruption. I am prepared to accept any proposal that is made on this matter, any that is reasonable; I am prepared to do so. I believe that it is something that we all have to become involved in decisively.
We have removed from the party and from our electoral lists very many people who were involved in acts of corruption and others whose cases were dropped by the courts themselves or in some cases acquitted.
And then there is talk of the subject of age. The People's Party has a Vice President of the Government and a General Secretary of the party. Ten years ago, these people were not in Spanish public life in positions of great responsibility. Less than ten years ago one was appointed spokesperson of the Parliamentary Party and the other, General Secretary of the Party. And with them came a very important change in my party. Then less than a year ago, four new people who not long ago were practically unknown in our country were appointed as deputy general secretaries of the Party.
To say that people who were born before the approval of the Spanish Constitution should not dedicate themselves to politics is a joke; for politics or for any other activity. Where would most of you be? Not many of you but some were born after 1978. It's a joke. In politics there are people who are very capable and who are of an advanced age and there are people who are rather incompetent and who are not very old, and vice versa. To be capable or not is not a question of age, it is a question of what you are now thinking.
So I am of the opinion that in life one should be prudent, one should be reformist and not abolish everything, because there are people who say "I don't want to change everything", but in reality they want to change everything. I understand that in this matter... We have given many opportunities to many people. I have named a woman who at the time was forty years old as First Vice President of the Government. Obviously, I didn't appoint her because she was a woman, or because she was forty years old. I appointed her because she was and is intelligent, capable and a faithful servant of the public administration and thus of the people of Spain.
A. Costas: Thank you very much, Mr President of the Government.
We've come to an end. An old saying goes, and if it doesn't exist then we'll invent it, "all good things come in thirteens". So I hope...
President of the Government: I'm certainly up for it. Believe me, I'm perfectly serious.