Address by the Prime Minister at the Joint Conference of Chief Ministers and Chief Justices in New Delhi

India Narendra Modi · Prime Minister of India

24 April 2016 · Joint Conference of Chief Ministers and Chief Justices · New Delhi, India

Context
Modi addressed a joint conference of Chief Ministers and Chief Justices in New Delhi on April 24, 2016, to discuss judicial reforms and cooperation between the executive and judiciary.
Main themes
Judicial reform, case backlog reduction, rule of law, legislative drafting quality, obsolete laws removal, judicial-executive cooperation, public faith in justice system, court infrastructure and capacity, access to justice, legal system efficiency
Duration
~11 min
38th percentile
Words
1,301
38th percentile
Sentences
77
50th percentile
Readability
65
95th percentile
Grade
8.3
6th percentile
Syntax
2.83
25th percentile
Vocabulary
1.84
1st percentile

Translated from Hindi

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 81%79%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

77 sentences in 12 paragraphs

Respected Chief Ministers present, respected Judges,

Every year we have a meeting like this. This time there are quite extensive agendas and issues. I have been informed that for two days the Judges have discussed in great detail, and many good suggestions have come up, and I have also been told that there has been an effort from all sides to move things forward with great commitment. I extend my heartfelt congratulations to the esteemed Thakur Sahib and his entire team for the meaningful efforts being made to advance these matters.

Recently, there was a Retreat program in Bhopal, which I heard about from Thakur Sahib yesterday, and I was very pleased to learn that outside the law point, there is a very large country to understand and know what is happening at the national and international levels, what challenges there are, what possibilities exist, and eminent experts from the country were invited. All the Judges were listening to them and engaging in a question-answer session. I believe this tradition in itself is a very excellent tradition. Perhaps in the future, similar efforts may also take place in the states, as Thakur Sahib mentioned… it was happening in between, but it had been halted for many years. I believe that such connections will be quite catalytic.

Many subjects will be discussed here, so I will not delve too deeply into them. But it is true that the common citizen of India still has complete faith in the justice system. What faith! It is a belief, a reverence. And this is a great asset of our country. It is our collective responsibility to maintain this faith. We must uphold it so that the common person never finds themselves in a situation where they wonder where to go. There is a place where they have faith that they can go. And the government has a significant responsibility in creating that situation. I am confident that the government will never falter in fulfilling its responsibilities.

Today, Thakur Sahib rightly said that I am not a person from the world of law, nor do I have such a background, so I gained knowledge today about when the Supreme Court was established, what happened, and all the details. I can also understand their pain that if the discussions that took place in '87 have continued to this day in 2016, there must have been some reasons or constraints since '87. I have never gone into the details of what happened in '87, how it happened. But "when one wakes up, it is morning"! Let us do something good moving forward. While reducing the burden of the past, how do we move ahead?

There will be many reasons, and one reason that Thakur Sahib just mentioned is that strength in itself is a very significant reason. But some changes also occur in social life. We know that there was a time when there was a village physician, and the entire village remained healthy. Now there is an eye doctor, an ear doctor, a foot doctor, a heart doctor, but the diseases have increased. So this problem must also arise in society in various forms; what could be the reasons for this is a matter for all of us to ponder.

In the government, I believe that the vigilance required while making laws is somewhat lacking here. From drafting to debate to the formation of laws, this has become a significant reason for a large number of matters going to court regarding interpretation. Otherwise, the law should be such that any person can make a decision with minimal confusion. Gradually, we will have to move towards that efficiency.

Another issue is that we have a plethora of laws. I have started a task as soon as I arrived to relieve the common person from the burden of laws, to reduce the number of laws. A committee was formed, and about 1500 to 1700 such laws have come to mind that date back to 1800, 1850, 1880, 1890, and such laws are now irrelevant. So what happens is that if someone wants to stop something, they can show a 200-year-old law. Look, there was such a law that you cannot do this, and then they go to court. Such things are causing significant obstacles in the systems. The cleanup is ongoing. Gradually, I believe that as much time as I have, I will make full efforts during that time. Processes should be expedited, and efforts should be made to meet the needs. These dreams are everyone's work, and we will continue to do them. We should do so.

And I would like that if Thakur Sahib finds it convenient, perhaps some constitutional limits create difficulties, then maybe a few key people from the government and all your team members can sit together in a room to shoulder the solutions to these problems and find ways to resolve them. It is possible that some solutions can be found because the points you mentioned are very important. And we will have to find a way for those important matters as well. I am not the kind of person who will just listen and leave. I will take it seriously and try to find some solutions. Success or failure is a different matter, but we should make an effort. I would like to try. And I am confident that with the support of experienced people like you, I will find a way.

I remember I have been coming to this meeting for 15 years and always sat in front, and later when I sat above, there were no cameras, so I spoke more openly. And I once said that how about extending court hours? How about reducing vacations? And I don't know what calamity befell me that after that lunch, many Judges caught me and asked, what do you think of yourself? Since that day, I have been scared. But still, I believe that everyone who has a responsibility is working honestly, with dedication, for the welfare of the poor people of the country; we should all have that faith. And I am fully confident that our country's judiciary is active and alert in that direction. I have complete faith. And we will all remain confident that the country's problems will also be resolved. And we will sit together and find solutions; I have full confidence in that.

Once again, I welcome all the esteemed Chief Ministers and have listened to all the discussions. They also run their governments with equal responsibility. Because they too have to answer the public and have to do so once every five years, and now elections are coming repeatedly, so in some form, they have to go three times in five years. Because discussions are ongoing these days. All parties are telling me that how can the elections for the Lok Sabha and the Assembly be held together? In every way, because a lot of time is being consumed. Many things get delayed in decision-making for forty to fifty days because the Code of Conduct comes into effect. And there is some place in the country where the Code of Conduct is in effect. So these days, I met all the opposition leaders, and they were also saying that please find a way. Therefore, the elections for the Assembly and Parliament should be held together so that other work can be done. So there are some difficulties; we will have to find a way out of all these things by sitting together.

And I apologize that I have to leave here for Jharkhand, but I once again welcome you all, express my gratitude, and today there will be a meeting with the Chief Ministers throughout the day, and some discussions will emerge. Thank you very much.