The original text of the Prime Minister's address at the inaugural ceremony of the 10th Annual Conference of the Central Information Commission.

India Narendra Modi · Prime Minister of India

16 October 2015 · inaugural ceremony of the 10th Annual Conference of the Central Information Commission

Context
Modi addressed the 10th Annual Conference of the Central Information Commission in October 2015, marking the 10th anniversary of India's Right to Information Act.
Main themes
Right to Information Act, transparency in governance, Digital India initiative, proactive disclosure, democracy and citizen empowerment, trust between government and public, online auctions and open processes, secrecy culture in bureaucracy, RTI 10th anniversary, freedom of information history
Duration
~20 min
66th percentile
Words
2,420
66th percentile
Sentences
180
86th percentile
Readability
64
93rd percentile
Grade
7.6
3rd percentile
Syntax
2.55
5th percentile
Vocabulary
1.91
3rd percentile

Translated from Hindi

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 76%75%
  • Social 10%10%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Technological 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

180 sentences in 17 paragraphs

Esteemed guests present,

Today we are completing 10 years of the Right to Information Act. I would like to thank and extend my best wishes to all those who have contributed to advancing this system to build trust in it.

It is true that the first aspect of the Right to Information is the right of the common person to know, but it should not be limited to that. They should also have the right to question power. And that is the foundation of democracy. The faster we work in that direction, the more trust people will have in democracy. People’s awareness, in a way, empowers governance and not only that, it becomes a significant trust of the nation to have an aware society. There are certain systems that nurture, reward, encourage, and lead to results.

According to the information available, it is said that the first initiation of this was in Sweden in 1766. It started in written form. Informally, it might have existed in many systems. But this system came to America in 1966. It took two hundred years. Some countries passed laws. However, there was a two-year gap between passing and implementing the law, so that people could be educated. The governance system could be made aware. And a mature way of developing the system could emerge. Our country’s experience is different. We made decisions and kept improving, correcting, and empowering it as we worked. And this process will continue; only then will the institution become stronger, and continuous efforts will be made for it in the coming days.

One thing is certain: the dream of Digital India is, in a way, complementary to the spirit of RTI. Because when things start to go online, transparency comes automatically. There should be trust between governance and the public, and trust comes through transparency. If there is transparency, trust will naturally follow. And that is why the dream of Digital India is to make things as online and open as possible, which will reduce the number of questions. Recently, there was an auction of coal.

We know how much uproar there was regarding coal earlier. How many big questions were raised. The Supreme Court had to get involved. People associated with RTI worked hard on this. When this issue came before the current government, we made everything online, not just online, but displayed it on a large screen in a public place where anyone could come and see the entire process. Every evening, we tracked where things stood. Media personnel also came and sat. In this system, I do not believe anyone will ever need RTI again, because I believe what was to be obtained through RTI was already in front of them. We recently auctioned FM Radio, and that was also done online in the same way. The spectrum auction was also conducted in the same manner. And when the auction was happening, everyone was online. It lasted for weeks, ten days. Media personnel also sat. Others also participated. Anyone could do it.

Why shouldn’t we proactively ensure transparency? Why should someone have to make an effort to know? Information should be easily accessible. Governance should strive to ensure that information is readily available in a democracy. Some things had become so entrenched here. It takes time to change them gradually. For instance, if you need to apply somewhere and submit a photocopy of your certificate, it is not accepted. Until you get a stamp from some gestated officer or political leader, it is not recognized. This has been going on for years. We decided to trust the citizen. If they say it once, we should take it as the truth, and when it is finalized, they can bring the original certificate, and we will verify it. And today that system has been implemented. The point is that we should run systems by trusting citizens. If we operate by doubting citizens, then we will also try to hide ourselves somewhere. The more openness there is in governance, the more it empowers the common citizen.

The nature of the government is also such. It works in silos, and not only that, even if four officers are sitting in the same room, there is a great effort to ensure that the person next to them does not see the file. Now, this mentality of secrecy may have had some reasons in the past, but today I do not believe that such a situation will persist. If there is openness, it is an open matter; we have to discuss and do four tasks. I believe that this leads to simplicity and speed. If there is a shortcoming in one or two things, then a colleague points out, “Hey, you should look at this aspect.” So, improvement happens automatically. To improve, our fundamental nature in governance must change. There is a great expectation that this change should be brought about, and we are working in that direction. I am confident that this effort will yield results.

Today, I believe that there is a limit to RTI. That limit is that the person who needs information does receive it. Some information is useful to the media. Some matters remain confined to justice. The process is known. But still, the product is not known. I am saying this in the sense that if a contract for a bridge is awarded, then if someone asks through RTI, they will find out how the file started, how the tendering happened, what the noting was, how the site was selected, all these things will be available. But how the bridge was built, whether it was built correctly or not, whether there are shortcomings, whether it was completed on time or not—these things need attention now. So, the more we focus on the process through RTI, there will come a time when we also need to bring as much transparency to the product; only then will change occur. Otherwise, that information is only for satisfaction. Ultimately, the use of RTI should primarily be to bring about change in governance.

And that is why when Vijay ji met me, I mentioned in passing that have we analyzed the questions that people ask us? How many questions come regarding the railways? How many questions come regarding Home? How many questions come on various subjects? The analysis is that there are departments where thousands of questions come. There are departments where fewer than a hundred questions come. Then we should analyze the questions that come to see if there is any policy paralysis at the root. We can identify it. If we limit RTI to just answering questions, then the governance system does not benefit. The citizen has asked a question, which means there is something in the governance system that necessitated the question. If the system were so sensitive, and if we analyze the questions that arise, we will find that due to policy matters, this problem keeps arising, and people keep asking questions. Then the government should think at a high level about what changes should be made in policy matters. A small question through RTI can compel you to change policy, and sometimes it asks such precise questions that it brings to attention that we have not focused on this aspect. Therefore, for Good Governance, how RTI can be utilized is crucial; merely answering questions will not bring about Good Governance. It can only serve to create disputes. It cannot work to change the situation.

Secondly, I suggested that one part is due to policy, and the other is due to the person, that the nature of the person sitting there is such. Therefore, such situations arise where they do not respond, are lax, and let things go as they are. Then the question arises about the person. Why are so many issues related to one person? There must be some deficiency; how can it be corrected? We should think about that. There may be situations where someone realizes that people have asked questions, but due to a financial resource crunch, it is not happening. Or there may be some work that is causing local arrangements to create obstacles. When we perfectly analyze these questions and find the shortcomings of the government in the citizens’ questions, the shortcomings of the system can be revealed, and the shortcomings of the process can be revealed. And to correct that, we may find a way. Therefore, I would like you to consider how we can use RTI as a means to move towards Good Governance when you debate this.

Since coming to the Government of India, I have been conducting a program called Pragati. I gather all chief secretaries and secretaries of the Government of India and take 12-15 issues. And it brings attention. The questions I take are based on letters from citizens. Someone wrote to me that there is a problem with pensions for soldiers. So, I raised that issue. I called everyone, seated them, and everyone is on video; we do not hold meetings. I sit in a small room. But it creates a situation where it immediately comes to attention that this issue needs to be handled. Someone also wrote to me that the post office has not delivered mail for 15 days, 20 days. I took that up in Pragati, and we immediately found out what the reason was for the slow process.

The point is that if we give importance to the voices of citizens. When I was in Gujarat, I created a system. The MLAs ask questions; my experience is that MLAs, regardless of the party, should be given attention and importance. It should be assumed that they are speaking for the public interest. However, when answers are given in the House, by and large, it becomes a media-centric process. In a way, what will be published in the media the next day dominates. Therefore, in the House, everyone answers to settle their scores. Now, what can be done? It has become a compulsion of politics that the news should not be bad in the media the next day. So, they do their thing and may win. That is a different matter. But I had started a process. After the Assembly session, I instructed every department to analyze every question and provide me with an action taken report. Regardless of whose question it was, whatever answer you gave in the House is fine. If someone said that a road has not been built, I need the result. And this created a sensitivity towards governance among elected representatives. I believe such sensitivity connects us with RTI questions. If this can be achieved in the entire country’s governance system, we can make significant progress. And we are working in that direction.

Another point is that when we talk about RTI, it should not be thought that all communication, the process of accessing information, should be transparent, timely, and trouble-free. The more we ensure this, because if we provide information after a long time, it neither improves governance nor makes governance accountable. Then the situation arises, what can be done? The building has been constructed; how can it be demolished? What can be done? People have come to live there. How can they be removed? If timely information had been provided, perhaps the wrong decision could have been stopped, and we would have immediately taken notice. Therefore, it should be transparent, timely, and trouble-free. If we emphasize this, we can create laws, but we can utilize those laws better. We can achieve better results.

Today I have seen that in villages... it is true that in every matter, there may be some doubts or concerns, but in the larger interest, it is very beneficial and useful. I have run state governance, so I know how a poor person uses RTI. If someone has made a wrong encroachment in the village and is a powerful person, the government cannot do anything. But if a poor person asks a question through RTI, it comes to light, and the government is compelled to remove the encroachment. And the land of the public or the government has to be cleared. I have seen many such examples. Even a small person in the village...

When we were in Gujarat, we conducted an experiment. It is known as the Gujarat model for tribals. We directly gave money to the tribals. We told them to create a committee plan according to their requirements, and they could do their work because the government plans from Gandhinagar. It wants to dig a well. The villagers say they do not need a well; they need a school, and instead of giving money for the well, we gave it to the villagers. But in the village assembly, they had to provide all the details and write on a board that we allocated this much money for this work. The common person in the village could also ask the head of the panchayat, “You say you spent two hundred rupees here; I do not see that; tell me.” And transparency emerged. The more openness we bring, the more it guarantees transparency. Therefore, RTI is a medium to move towards transparency, but at the same time, learning from RTI, we need to bring transparency into the governance system. And I am confident that if there are no ill intentions, there will never be any difficulty, and there will be no problems. Right actions yield right results. And as I said, it is not just about the process. In the coming days, we also need to pay attention to the quality of the product. We need to think about how to account for everything because the government runs on the people’s money. All construction works are done with the people’s money. And the people are paramount in a democracy. We will continue to work towards strengthening the interests of the people and that system. I believe it will be very beneficial.

Today, you all will be sitting together all day. I am confident that all the officials of the state are also present here. The good suggestions that come out of that deliberation will come to the government’s attention. We will certainly make efforts to see how much good we can do, but we want the more powerful the public becomes, the more powerful the citizens become, that power truly becomes the strength of the nation. We should support that. With this expectation, I wish you all the best. Thank you.