Response of the Prime Minister to the President's Address in the Rajya Sabha

India Narendra Modi · Prime Minister of India

8 February 2017 · Response to the President's Address in the Rajya Sabha · Rajya Sabha, India

Context
Modi responded in the Rajya Sabha on 8 February 2017 to the President's address, defending demonetisation and addressing opposition criticism.
Main themes
Demonetisation, black money and corruption, counterfeit currency, terrorism and Naxalism financing, parallel economy, Maoist surrenders, empowerment of the poor and middle class, formal financial system integration, historical policy precedents, hawala and drug trafficking
Duration
~61 min
96th percentile
Words
7,373
96th percentile
Sentences
441
98th percentile
Readability
62
91st percentile
Grade
8.6
8th percentile
Syntax
2.77
19th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from Hindi

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 30%29%
  • Economic 28%27%
  • Social 26%26%
  • Technological 7%7%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 2%

441 sentences in 54 paragraphs

Honorable Chairman, I stand before you to express gratitude on behalf of both Houses for the President's address. About 40 esteemed members have participated in this discussion. Mr. Ghulam Nabi Azad, Neeraj Shekhar, Mr. A. Navaneethakrishnan, Mr. Derek, Mr. D. Raja, Mr. Sharad Yadav, Mr. Sitaram, Mr. Ahmed Bhai, and just now Mr. Anand Sharma, I am very grateful to all of you. I am also thankful to other honorable members who have raised the subject. Most of the discussion has revolved around Demonetisation. We cannot deny that a malady has entered our country; we cannot deny that it has taken root in our economy and society. We cannot deny this, and therefore the fight against corruption and black money is not a political battle; it is not a fight to trouble any political party. There is no reason to think that way, and therefore no one should make this controversy a reason to associate with themselves. It is our responsibility in this House that we should do whatever our constitutional limits allow us and what our intellect permits us to do against this. It is also true that due to the entire Parallel Economy, the most damage has been done to the poor. The rights of the poor are taken away, and the middle class is exploited. And it is not that no efforts have been made before! Efforts have been made before; more efforts are needed. If these efforts lead to even more efforts, then we must go ahead. Because how long will we continue to sweep these problems under the carpet and manage our lives?

And therefore, as far as the subject of counterfeit notes comes up, the figures that are publicized are those that account for the counterfeit notes that have reached the banks. Most counterfeit notes do not reach the bank's doors due to that system. And it is also used to promote terrorism and Naxalism. Some people are jumping up and down saying that some two thousand rupee notes were found in the hands of terrorists. We should know that in our country, the period after this demonetisation, the attempts to loot banks and also to take new notes happened in Jammu and Kashmir. Because after the situation of counterfeit notes arose, they faced difficulties in their daily transactions. And the notes that were in the hands of the terrorists who were killed just a few days after the bank loot were those notes. So there is a direct relationship here; we should understand this, and there is no reason for us to hold any opinion in favor of such people. Honest individuals will not gain strength until strictness is shown towards the dishonest. And therefore, our clear opinion is that the ultimate benefit of these steps will be to empower honest forces.

Honorable Chairman, many years ago, a Vanchu Committee was formed. And regarding the economic needs of demonetisation, they submitted their report at that time when Mrs. Indira Gandhi was in power. And Yashwantrao Chavan also agreed with it and wanted to take it forward, but at that time, Indira ji said, "Oh, we are in politics; we keep fighting elections." This is in the book of Godbole ji; you should have shown such awareness, and you should have raised your voice against that book; were you asleep? What were you doing? And such a big accusation can be laid against Indira ji, and an officer can make an accusation, and you have remained asleep until now? If I were in your place, I would have filed a case against Godbole ji, but you did not. Today, when the discussion of Godbole ji's book is happening, you should know that the situation is a little more advanced than when the Vanchu Committee submitted its report; at that time, the problems of black money and cash were limited to that. Today, black money, terrorist organizations, the business of counterfeit notes, drug trafficking, and hawala have spread to many areas of life, so its magnitude is greater.

When the decision was made on November 8, the question of counterfeit notes returning did not arise at all. There would be some small bank! There would be no means, and it must have slipped in, then the Reserve Bank would search for it. But counterfeit notes were neutralized at that time. And therefore, if someone has an account of it, it is surprising how that is. Counterfeit notes were neutralized at that time. And the biggest, the biggest reason for this happened, and you must have seen a TV news report. A person who was involved in a large business of counterfeit notes in enemy countries had to commit suicide; this news ran on TV for many days.

Now see, in our country, in thirty to forty days, more than 700 Maoists have surrendered; this has happened for the first time in thirty to forty days, around 700 people have surrendered between November and December, and this process is still ongoing. If Maoists surrender, it cannot be that no one in this House is satisfied; how can that be? And if it is not happening, then there is some other meaning.

Similarly, it is also true that having money in the country's formal system is very important. After the printing of the thousand rupee note, it did not circulate in general; the five hundred rupee note circulated very little, and the thousand rupee note circulated very little, and bundles of bundles of transactions continued. This is a reality; we cannot deny this reality. Now that such a large currency has come to the banks, it is natural that the banks' ability to lend money to the common person will increase. Interest rates, for the first time in our country, all banks have reduced interest rates together. The benefit of the bank for the common people... here we are talking about unorganized workers; I truly expect from you people, especially from Sitaram ji and his party, that unorganized workers should receive security regarding their wages. It is a reality that what is said is not given as much; even in what is given, one or two people stand outside and take a cut; we all know these ailments, but we are familiar with many such ailments, and therefore if we establish this system, then those workers will benefit in time, they will be linked with EPF, they will be linked with the ESIC Scheme, and a very large security for workers will be possible because of this; that is our effort in that direction.

I want to give an example of Assam's agriculture. The government there has taken some initiative; they opened bank accounts for the workers working in tea gardens, about seven lakh, taught them to do business on a mobile app. Initially, the union people refused, saying cash would have to be given because other things were involved; because of this, the tea garden workers started receiving their full wages, cuts were made, and their business was secured in that area; it is a very large experience, and I believe we have...

Similarly, regarding demonetisation, some quote foreign newspapers, some quote foreign economists; there is a platform that if you quote ten, I can quote twenty; if you can quote ten great personalities, I can quote twenty. This is happening because there is no parallel to this in the world. Nowhere in the world has such a large and extensive decision ever been made. And therefore, the economists of the world have no criteria to account for this. This can become a very large case study for the economists of the world, for the universities of the world.

And how big a decision India has made, in the same way, the general public, what the strength of the country is, and I want to say to all the esteemed individuals sitting in this House that after this demonetisation, sociologists will definitely study; for the first time in the country, a horizontal divide has emerged. And when I say horizontal divide, the mood of the public is on one side and the mood of the leaders is on the other side. They are so cut off from the public; they are so cut off from the public; we should be satisfied for the first time; generally, when the government makes a decision, the public and the government are face to face; by and large, any government, this is the first such incident that some people were over there, but the government and the public were together.

In the same way, we should take pride in this; you may have some difficulties, but we must understand this, and we can proudly say to the world that there are 1.25 billion people in this country; they may be uneducated, they may not have received education as you describe, the report card you are giving that it is like this, it is like this, it is like this, even with all that, this is a country that is working hard to come out of its internal evils, is struggling. No matter what politician it is, no matter what party it is, it is a matter of pride for us that there are such people in this country, such citizens who are ready to endure hardships to fight against their evils, are ready to endure difficulties, and are searching for ways to come out of evils. And therefore, we must also understand this.

Honorable Chairman, in the last session, Manmohan ji expressed his views; it is true that perhaps a book has been published from your side, and the forward has been written by the doctor. When I was looking at your report, I thought that perhaps such a great economist would have contributed to the book. But it turned out that someone else wrote the book, and he wrote the forward. So, in his speech, I also felt that perhaps! This is a very significant understanding; for the last about 30-35 years, the words I did not even speak, he understood their meaning; this is a remarkable thing! Now Dr. Manmohan Singh ji is a former Prime Minister, a respected person. And in India, for the last 30-35 years, he has had a direct relationship with the economic decision-makers of India; he has played a decisive role. For 35 years in this country, there is hardly any person in the economic world who has had such dominance for half the time in the seventy years of India's independence. And so many scandals have come up, but especially we politicians have much to learn from Dr. Sahib. So much has happened, yet he has not been stained! Wearing a raincoat in the bathroom to bathe, only Dr. Sahib knows this art; no one else knows.

Honorable Chairman, a person who has held such a high position used words like loot, launder in the House; then there was a need to think fifty times that if we cross the limits, we must also be prepared to listen, and we have the power to return the same coin. And we do it while staying within the limits of the Constitution; we are people who respect democracy, but in any form, we cannot accept defeat; how long will this continue?

Honorable Chairman, it is true that there have been many efforts to mobilize the common people, and today we see that if a small incident happens, two or four vehicles are set on fire; if a bus is late, one or two buses are set on fire. What will be the impact of this by and large is a subject of analysis, but these scenes are everyday occurrences. However, to fight our internal battles, we are committed that despite so many difficulties, they have not allowed any such incident to happen. And we should proudly present this strength of the people of India to the whole world; we should talk about it, and only then do I believe that the world will understand what kind of thinking we have.

I want to mention one more thing today that there was an issue that our ideologies are different, so it is natural for the presentation of thoughts to be different. But this was such a subject that when I was thinking, I had the full imagination that Sitaram ji and his party would be with us in this work. And the reason was that your party's senior leader, Mr. Jyoti Basu, in 1972, made a huge demand to place the Vanchu Committee report in the House and fought a great battle. The government did not agree; it was not presenting it; finally, he brought a copy himself and placed it on the table. He himself, Jyoti Basu ji, placed that report on the table; it is called a Private Member, and his speech that day is still very much presented; he said that on August 26, 1972, "Sir, on November 12, 1970, one of the primary services of a powerful and prestigious committee was demonetisation; Sir, Mrs. Indira Gandhi is surviving on black money. Her politics is alive on black money. Therefore, not only was this report not implemented, but it was also suppressed for a year and a half." This was said by Jyoti Basu ji in 1972; again, on September 4, 1972, in a speech in the Lok Sabha, Jyoti Basu ji said, "I have recommended demonetisation and other measures. I do not want to repeat them now. The government should honestly cooperate with the people. But the character of Prime Minister Mrs. Indira Gandhi and her government is that it is a government of black money, by black money, and for black money." I am talking about 1972, and the leader of the Congress party said this on September 4, 1972. Not only that, the senior leader of CPM, Harkishan Singh Surjit, gave a speech in this House on August 27, 1981, and he said, "Is the government really serious about taking any serious steps to curb black money? Can decisions like banning the hundred rupee note be taken?" This question was also raised by Surjit ji in this House in 1981, and therefore, especially to the Left, I urge you to support us in this fight, and I hope you will continue to express your views widely, but this work is such that you cannot separate yourself from it; your character does not allow it. But still, time will tell; it is true that in democratic systems, taking such tough decisions is generally believed to be a populist step. It becomes the nature of democracy to focus on short-term goals. And therefore, it takes a little time to understand such a big decision, so I do not blame anyone for that; gradually people will understand, even those who are opposing it today will understand how big a decision has come with the potential for the country's welfare, and we want to take it forward.

Here, there is a discussion regarding the digital system; I am surprised at how many speeches have been made, saying that this is not there, that is not there, this has not happened, that has not happened, if there is a toilet, there is no water, I do not know what all has been said. I was thinking, what are they saying? They were giving a report card of seventy years of Indian governments; whatever they were saying is not there, so it is a report card of seventy years; now my contribution in seventy years is only two and a half years. Did we lock the toilet you built? Did I dig up the road you built? Did I come and cut the tube of the water tap you installed? This is a reality; no one says that there is a digital system in every corner of India; who says that? The question is whether we can do this where there is a possibility to change the mindset or not.

Assume that there is potential in the city of Delhi; let’s start from Delhi, and let us contribute something positive. It is a matter of behavioral change. If the people of Kolkata have mobile phones, if the people of Kolkata have digital connectivity, then start from there. It may not be the case in the far-off villages of Bangladesh. It is one thing to say this, and another to keep singing praises about what we have done, what we have achieved, and what we have accomplished. Now, when it comes to implementation, we are facing difficulties.

Secondly, we play with words. Everyone believes it, brother. Ask any child, do you go to school daily? Anyone. If I ask your children, they will say, yes, I go daily. But I know, and they know too, that they do not go on Sundays. Everyone knows it. So, this is natural; in the same way, cashless in the country means gradually leading society in the direction of this type of payment. Even today, big countries in the world conduct elections by printing ballot papers and stamping them. The country that is considered illiterate, this India, the world's largest democracy, votes by pressing a button. The day the button-pressing system was introduced, who would have thought that such technology could be adopted by the poorest of the poor in our country?

That is, we should not underestimate the strength of our country. Yes, we feel that this path is wrong, that’s fine, but if there are inconveniences, if there are difficulties, then abandoning it is not right. There will be inconveniences, there will be fewer arrangements, but we must move forward. We must move forward.

Some people say that many countries in the world are ahead. Many countries in the world, I am surprised, Anand Sharma ji was saying. You will be astonished that Korea has created such a large incentive scheme for going digital. They are saying that you are spending crores of rupees to promote digital. Now, the BHIM app that has been created, there is not a single penny of expense in the BHIM app. Transactions are happening without any cost. Not even a rupee goes as commission to any bank or anyone, and that is why the world is moving towards paperless, premises-less banking. There is no reason for India to lag behind. It may take us two more years, five more years because our arrangements may be fewer. But to start or to think that this direction is wrong, I believe is not appropriate. We should make efforts to promote this, we should explain to people in our respective areas, and we should move forward in that direction.

Now see, the railways. Common people travel in our country. Today, 60 percent of railway bookings are being done online. Their payments are online. If they cancel their tickets, the money is being refunded online. Today, there are many families living in cities. If they have to pay the electricity bill, earlier they had to take half a day off to go to the office. Today, they come home at midnight and pay the electricity bill from their mobile phones. Convenience is increasing. If this convenience is provided scientifically through technology, then yes, we should definitely be concerned about its shortcomings. If there are any technological shortcomings, they should be rectified, but it is a misconception to think that if we move forward with negativity, we cannot do any good for the country.

Rupay Card - Arun ji was just telling. In this country, 21 crore people have been given Rupay Cards along with Jan Dhan accounts. And you cannot imagine what its power is. Generally, having this card in your pocket has become very prestigious for a certain class; if you have to make a payment, it is done with a card. It has also become a trend that the poor do not have this issue. Just now, Anant Kumar ji was telling me. He was coming from Bangalore, and there was an IT professional with him who heard about his driver’s experience. He said his driver is very happy with this demonetization. So, I asked why. He said today, a big man carries a card, I also carry a card. He started showing his card. He was very pleased. Now see, this is a change in the life of an ordinary person in society. A new self-confidence is created. A person who does not even have a bicycle at home feels overjoyed when a motorcycle arrives. A person who has a scooter feels proud even if it is an old one. We should make efforts to fulfill the aspirations of the small people in society.

Direct Benefit Transfer - what a huge benefit it has been. I have elaborated in that house that through Direct Benefit Transfer, we have saved nearly 50 thousand crores that were previously leaked and happened every year, and we do not know how much more will be saved in the future. In Direct Benefit Transfer schemes like scholarships, one individual takes from six places. A widow pension, a daughter who was not born has also become a widow, and a check is being cut. Because of this Direct Benefit Transfer scheme, the leakage that was taken away by middlemen has been curtailed. A significant treasure that was being looted has been stopped. So, the Direct Benefit Transfer scheme has also benefited from this. We should continue to make efforts to increase digital payments as much as we can.

The government has developed that system. The need for POS machines. POS machines are being increased rapidly. Promotion is happening for mobile payments and e-wallets. Work is ongoing towards internet banking. ‘AADHAR based payment’. The way technology has developed, based solely on ‘AADHAR’, there will be no need for a mobile phone; one will be able to make payments, that day is not far away. And therefore, we should either try to understand these systems a little or make efforts to implement them with our teams.

The BHIM App has been developed in a very excellent manner. It has been created under the aegis of the Government of India, and the more we popularize the BHIM App, the less any trader will have to deal with any outside agency. It is a direct enabling platform from which people can benefit. We should do this.

Now see, the driver who goes on the highway. We know how much expense our petrol and diesel incur due to vehicles stopping. After November 8, a little emphasis was also placed on that, that drivers should use technology to pay their toll taxes. And through radio frequency identification, RFID, previously only a few people had that system. In such a short time, today nearly 20 percent of traffic is paying through RFID. The car comes, its registration is done directly, and the amount is deducted from the bank; it does not have to stop, it just goes. If this increases, how much petrol will be saved for the country. This situation has arisen regarding toll tax in our country. Similarly, at petrol pumps, nearly 29-30 percent of people have started working with digital currency today. We have formed a committee under the leadership of Chandrababu Naidu ji, and its interim report has come. Its study is ongoing. The final report will be coming soon. But we should prepare for change, and I believe that.

One subject is the Banking System - if you say anything, then I say that it is a report card. It is a report card of the old tenure. This government has first created the Debt Recovery Tribunal - 6, so that whatever debt is in the banks, the government has taken the initiative. There were no rules for appointments in banks; it was just running like that, an outdated system. This government has created the Bank Board Bureau, an independent agency that conducts the recruitment. Its Chairman, Managing Director, and Directors, etc. We have made efforts to bring professionalism into the banking system.

A two-day Round Table Conference was held for the banking and finance world, the Banking Sector, and the Economic World. They have deeply introspected on how to bring our country’s banking to global level standards, they have reflected, understood their shortcomings, and made efforts to rectify them.

The dignity of the Reserve Bank - I believe that if there is an attack on me, an attack on our party, an attack on our government, it is very natural; that will continue. But there is no reason to drag the Reserve Bank into it. There is no reason to drag the Governor of the Reserve Bank into it. We should contribute to upholding the dignity of such institutions. And even when the previous governor was there, some people raised their voices. I had opposed that too, saying that it is not appropriate. Such matters should be kept away from controversies. The rest of the government’s arrangements will continue; we need to do that. The Reserve Bank plays a very significant role in running the economy. We should have a positive active contribution in the direction of its credibility. But when people accuse the dignity of the Reserve Bank and this government, I want to say something to them today. And I want to say it with great sadness. The former Governor of the Reserve Bank, Dr. Subbarao, has written a book, ‘Who Moved My Interest Rate?’ and in that book, he has written that in 2008, under the then Finance Secretary, I was upset and disturbed by the government’s decision to appoint a Liquidity Management Committee. Chidambaram clearly overstepped the domain of the Reserve Bank regarding the Indian Reserve Bank. Liquidity management is entirely the function of the Reserve Bank. Not only did he not consult me on this matter, but he did not even inform me about issuing the notification. How was I to know that this decision would set the tone for an uncomfortable relationship between us in the last year of my tenure? This serious allegation has been made by the ex-Governor of the Reserve Bank against the previous government. It has been printed in the book, and no one has responded to it so far. Now that I am speaking, if someone says something, that is a different matter. But it is true that today we preach that they should also look into their own collars. And I would like to believe that we should keep this away from politics. We should strive to uphold the dignity of this institution.

And what have we done? The strength of the RBI has increased; the decisions of the Reserve Bank have been made by this government. We have amended the RBI Act to establish the Monetary Policy Committee. It had been discussed for many years, but no one did it; we did. This committee has been given full autonomy in conducting monetary policy. The head of this committee is the Governor of the RBI. Besides two officials of the RBI, there are three experts as members. There is not a single member from the central government in this committee. And such great autonomy in monetary policy is a significant matter. No one can imagine such great autonomy that this government has given to the RBI. And because of this, the strength of the RBI has been enhanced.

It is true. Many subjects have been discussed here. No government comes to sleep. The governments that have come before have also made some efforts to do something. We do not say that no one has done anything. I have spoken from the Red Fort, and no other Prime Minister of India has said what I have said. I have said that since the country gained independence, all the governments that have come, all the Prime Ministers who have come, all the public works that have been done, their contributions have brought the country to where it is today. We are such people. I know that, and they hesitate to name anyone. They do not like it when someone else has done something, and they keep mentioning it. History is a witness. But it is true that this government has worked a lot on governance issues. We will take small decisions, but those decisions have greatly empowered the common man.

We have introduced the practice of affidavits. People used to come to the homes of MPs, MLAs, and Corporators, standing in line to get their stamps. A queue would form. And they would not see anything. A peon or some fellow worker would sit there and stamp it. We have made the certificate self-attestation, and because of that, the common man has been saved from that crisis. Because when his final appointment will be, he will take the original copy. In the era of Xerox, what is the need to do everything?

We have abolished interviews. It will be determined through technology that those who have merit will get jobs based on merit. Because of that, corruption has gone. More than 1100 laws have been abolished by these two houses. Appointments to senior posts, many newspapers have written articles. For the first time, appointments are being made based on merit. All the old processes, my and yours, have gone, and many neutral newspapers have also written very good articles on this.

Through DBT, direct benefits have stopped leakages. Earlier, registering a company used to take 7-15 days, even two months. Today, a company can be registered in 24 hours. This is the system we have established. Earlier, it took months to get a passport; today, we have arranged to provide a passport within a week. And now we are also working towards converting the head office of the Postal Service into a Passport Office, and the common man will benefit from that too, and we are making efforts in that direction.

We also know how significant the auction of coal was. The government has easily implemented it. We have brought transparency. There is one very important decision that has not been discussed much yet, but I want to inform this house. The tradition of government procurement has been launched with GEM, the Government E-Marketplace. This system has also been honored with the South Asia Procurement Innovation Awards from the World Bank. Now, anyone who wants to give something to the government comes online, keeps their list, and the government can decide from there. There has been economic benefit, and if a payment of more than 5000 rupees needs to be made, it can be done through this GEM. We have made arrangements in that direction.

Against corruption, through Good Governance, by using technology, we have achieved great success in bringing transparency.

This government has created many new schemes for the empowerment of women. The Ujjwala scheme. We know what the era of gas cylinders was like; MPs used to get 25 coupons, and people would stand in line to get those 25 coupons. Those were the days. In the 2014 elections, whether to give 9 cylinders or 12 cylinders was a campaign issue. This is how much difference there is in the work of the government. Poor women could not even dream of having a gas stove. So far, nearly 1 crore 65 lakh poor families have been provided with gas connections. The complete intention is to reach five crore families. There are 25 crore families in the country, and the effort is to reach five crore families.

Under the Prime Minister's Housing Scheme, the legal provision for the registration of houses in the names of women has been made. In MGNREGA, 55 percent of women are now working, which used to be 40-45 percent.

In the currency scheme, money is given by banks without any guarantee. Seventy percent of the money is brought in by women, meaning that women in our country are joining as entrepreneurs.

The Pandit Deendayal Antyodaya Yojana - Self-Help Groups were functioning to some extent in South India. However, we have also made efforts to promote it across India and in Eastern India.

For poor pregnant women, 6,000 rupees are provided for maternal health, IMR, and MMR. The Beti Bachao Beti Padhao campaign has received significant acceptance and has become a social movement. The Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana has opened one crore accounts in the names of girls, providing a guarantee of security for their future with 11,000 crore rupees. The establishment of Women Empowerment Centers has been done in 14 lakh Anganwadi centers at a cost of 500 crore.

Mission Indradhanush - there was a lack of vaccination for children. Governments used to function, and vaccination programs were held. There were 5.5 million children who had not been vaccinated. Because of Mission Indradhanush, those children were identified, and efforts were made to save their lives.

In rural areas, I was surprised that cleanliness was being mocked. I cannot understand the reason. None of us want to live in filth. We also know that cleanliness is more of a behavioral issue. Infrastructure comes along with it. And I would say that we politicians sometimes fall short; I want to commend the media of this country for raising the cleanliness movement. Today, awards for cleanliness are being given through all media, and functions are being held. Regarding cleanliness today in India, otherwise, if the media is negative about any government program, that is natural. This is an exceptional program where the media has gone two steps ahead of the government and politicians and has made efforts to turn cleanliness into a movement, and I commend them through this house. And when someone stands here and says there is a toilet but no water, Mahatma Gandhi was very insistent on this matter. I fear that if Mahatma Gandhi were alive today and spoke about cleanliness, would we speak the same language? Is it not our responsibility? Can we not do something positive to bring about change in society? We will oppose everything. And therefore, I am happy that in rural areas, sanitation coverage, which was previously 42 percent, has reached 60 percent after this movement. When we talk about toilets, you can imagine the plight of women in villages, especially those living in urban slums, how much pain they endure; they cannot go to the toilet until it is dark. This pain should be felt. This is not a matter of bickering, but when someone mocks it, it hurts a lot. This cannot be a subject of mockery.

For the safety of women, the Universalization of Women Helpline 181 has been initiated, providing 24-hour emergency service. 18 states and Union Territories have advanced this women’s helpline system. The recruitment of women in the police has reached 33 percent, and some states have also accepted this. In the Union Territories, this has been made compulsory. Haryana has initiated a new experiment that others in India should follow. I have presented this before everyone. They have established a network of women police volunteers who are helping people in this manner. They have started a new scheme. My point is that by using panic button technology, we will be bringing it to you in the coming days.

Empowerment of farmers - this government has taken many steps. The most significant is the Prime Minister's Crop Insurance Scheme. Whether we like it or not, to provide security to farmers, we must link it with their income assurance. We have very little irrigation facility here. They are dependent on natural resources. In such a situation, if they cannot sow, and even after harvesting, if there is a loss, insurance is still available. And I believe that some progressive states have done insurance work for farmers at 40-50 percent. The government has also worked significantly to promote the crop insurance scheme for farmers. There has been a considerable increase compared to before, but some states are lagging far behind. This is a matter of concern. It needs to be advanced.

New Fertilizer Policy - production of urea. See, neem-coating has resulted in two significant benefits; one, the soil is benefiting, and production is also increasing. But earlier, subsidies were cut in the name of farmers, but they went into the chemical industry as raw material. Those who made synthetic milk also used urea. Due to 100 percent neem-coating, there is no other possible use for it except for the soil. It has been stolen. There is no black money in urea today. No Chief Minister writes a letter saying urea is not available. There are no queues for urea; no one is facing trouble for urea. You can see how even small changes can bring about significant transformations.

In our country, the production of pulses - this government has made efforts to promote it. The result is that this time there is a possibility of an increase of about 50 to 60 percent. The farmers of our country have accepted the government's call and have broken all records in this work.

e-NAM - Electronic Market in 500 mandis, now farmers can sell their goods at higher prices through technology. In 500 mandis, my farmers are not in a position to trade via mobile phones today. About 250 mandis have completed this work. States had to change some laws, and some have changed. We know that food processing will benefit our farmers when we emphasize food processing. The government has allowed 100 percent FDI to help food processing and value addition so that our farmers can have higher income, and we are working in that direction.

Empowerment of tribals - about 28 departments have some connection with tribals. For the first time, under a Tribal Sub-Plan, we have increased the funds, but under the Vanbandhu Kalyan Yojana, we have made a comprehensive plan that shows outcomes, and we have made a successful effort in that direction.

The Forest Rights Act - we have worked to implement it strongly. In tribal areas, for the first time, because all the minerals in our country, mining is mostly in tribal belts, whether it is coal, iron, or others, but they did not benefit from it. For the first time, the government has created a District Mineral Foundation and imposed a tax on what comes out of the mines there. The Chief Minister of Chhattisgarh told me that I have seven districts from where minerals are extracted, and because of this foundation you have created, I will never need extra budget for the development of those districts. A significant amount of funds will be beneficial for those poor tribals, and we have worked on that.

We have launched the Rurban Mission, which is likely to benefit the tribal areas the most. The tribal market should develop into a large market. When it develops in the market, an education system comes there, medical facilities come there, and entertainment facilities come there. Gradually, it becomes a center for 50-100 neighboring villages, and through Rurban, we are working to create 300 new cities in tribal belts. This will be a significant effort for the development of tribal areas.

Similarly, cleanliness, as I mentioned at the beginning, should become a people's movement. Everyone should contribute something to create a people's movement. Since we started ranking for cleanliness, through an independent agency, competition has begun among cities. If one city progresses, another city checks it, saying look, that city has progressed, why are we not cleaning? Gradually, this message has started to reach down. We should emphasize this, and I would like all political parties in our country to recognize that they have the opportunity to govern these days. Some will be in municipal bodies, some in district panchayats, some in states. You should also compete with the governments of your party. Compete in cleanliness among the cities ruled by communists. Compete in cleanliness among the district panchayats ruled by communists. An environment will be created. In BJP-ruled states, municipal bodies should compete. Once we promote this competition, I believe this cleanliness campaign will be successful. This is not a government program; it should be a people's movement. This is a necessity of the ages, a need for behavioral change. The World Bank report states that due to uncleanliness, a burden of about 2.5 lakh crore rupees falls on health. If we care this much, the country can save 2.5 lakh crore rupees; this is the World Bank report regarding India. For a poor person, the expense comes to about 7,000 rupees a year. It is very natural for diseases to arise from filth. We can prevent this.

Now children should wash their hands before eating. Everyone agrees with this. But if we say so, someone will say there is no water, no tap, no toilet, the child will go to the well. Oh, we don’t think like that. This thinking has trapped the country here. Just think a little; if we come out, difficulties will arise, but solutions will emerge. But if we sit at home and tell children to wash their hands, but there is no toilet, no this, no that, a country does not change like this. Therefore, we are causing a lot of damage to the country with this mentality. We need to come out of this mentality. In the world, we see our neighboring countries, whether it is South Korea, Malaysia, Thailand, or Singapore, these small countries have dedicated 15 years to cleanliness, and today they appear as models for us. Why can’t we do this in India? We should also have the dream that if these small countries can do it, why can’t we? We need to make efforts in that direction. But sometimes it seems that the kind of environment that has been created, as a poet said, "The city is yours, the killer is you, the martyr is you, the ruler is you; I am sure my fault will come out." But I believe we should come out of that.

I would like to conclude my remarks with one more topic. Ek Bharat Shreshtha Bharat - we launched this on October 31, on the birth anniversary of Sardar Patel. In our country, becoming a sister state or sister city with any state in the world has been going on for many years, but we have not developed the habit of meeting different people within our own country. We have done it in such a way that many states began to feel that they were being neglected. It is necessary to capture the potential of our country. Under the Ek Bharat Shreshtha Bharat program, we have made efforts, and I would like the members of the house to help understand and promote it. Just as two states sign an MoU, 12 states have perhaps done so with each other. For example, Haryana and Telangana have done it. So, in Haryana, people will learn to speak 100 sentences in Telugu. Where is the hospital? Where can I find an auto? Where is the hotel? Where is the first station? Where is the policeman? If they can learn this, and people from Telangana learn the language of Haryana. There can be a film festival of Telangana in Haryana, and a film festival of Haryana in Telangana. There can be quiz competitions, and children from Haryana can participate in the quiz competition of Telangana. In a way, it will be a campaign to know the country, to connect with the country, and the more we promote this, sometimes it seems that there are no words in Hindi, but there are some good words in Tamil, but we are not familiar with them. There are great words in Marathi, and very good words in Bengali; we are not familiar with them. Our country has such great strength. In the direction of connecting this strength, the campaign of 'Ek Bharat Shreshtha Bharat' is underway.

I once again express my gratitude to all the esteemed members for their thoughts, and I thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak and for supporting the President's address. I conclude my remarks with this. Thank you very much.