Speech of the Prime Minister at the Conference of Accountants General and Deputy Accountants General

India Narendra Modi · Prime Minister of India

21 November 2019 · Conference of Accountants General and Deputy Accountants General · Accountant General's office

Context
Modi addressed Accountants General and Deputy Accountants General at a national conference in November 2019, urging CAG to act as a catalyst for good governance and transparency.
Main themes
Government accountability and auditing, CAG role in good governance, transparency and technology in governance, digital economy and infrastructure, direct benefit transfer and JAM trinity, GST reform, Gandhian values and ethics, Chanakya's principles of governance, outcome-based audit reforms, probity in public finance
Duration
~23 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,813
73rd percentile
Sentences
160
83rd percentile
Readability
55
77th percentile
Grade
9.9
20th percentile
Syntax
2.94
39th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
17th percentile

Translated from Hindi

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 69%69%
  • Economic 9%9%
  • Technological 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

160 sentences in 21 paragraphs

Mr. Rajeev Maharshi, both Deputy CAGs, all colleagues who have come from across the country, friends,

I have once again had the opportunity to come to the Accountant General's office. There isn't much opportunity to converse, but even in a short time, some experiences can be gained. It is indeed pleasant that this program is taking place in the year of Gandhi's 150th birth anniversary. Gandhi ji used to say that just as a person cannot see their own back, it is also very difficult for a person to see their own mistakes.

But all of you are the giants who stand in front of government systems with a mirror—pointing out the shortcomings, the mistakes, and the processes that are not right, and you hold accountable those who keep accounts. However, I am pleased with the presentation that Maharshi ji showed, where you displayed your accounts; this is a good initiative.

Friends, three years ago, I had the opportunity to discuss in detail with all of you during the seminar, and at that time, I observed that many points of discussion were taken up and implemented, and your processes are ongoing. I remember that I had said then that the CAG needs to work in a holistic manner rather than in fragments. This organization cannot be limited to just figures and processes; it must truly come forward as a catalyst for good governance. It is a matter of joy for me that you are seriously implementing the suggestion to make CAG a CAG Plus. And there have been many positive outcomes for the country as a result. It helps create an atmosphere of accountability and probity in the country. The system being developed for outcome-based time-bound work has a significant role for the CAG. All this is possible because of you and your colleagues, especially those who have to work in the field, who have to go out and conduct audits, whether it is mining or any other area, they have to go there and see. And in the states, they stay in the field for months alongside the AG Office, sitting there, scrutinizing each document. Sometimes, they have to stay away from their families for long periods, and that is how all the processes emerge. It is because of such dedicated colleagues that the credibility of the CAG has been established and strengthened.

Friends, bringing about rapid change in this system that has been built over decades is a significant challenge in itself. Because perhaps the CAG is the institution with the longest tenure in government systems, established in 1860? And it was established after 1857, so it has a history. If you delve deeper, you will find a lot in it. Nowadays, reform is considered a very fancy word. Everyone says they are also doing reform. Whatever is done, it falls under reform. But real reform comes when the entire rank and file of an organization is fully prepared and motivated for it. And this applies to every government, every institution, and every organization, including the CAG. The responsibility of the CAG is even greater because you play a crucial role in keeping the economic conduct of the country and society pure. Therefore, expectations from you are a bit higher.

Friends, the great Chanakya, a source of inspiration for policy, economics, and auditing, used to say—ज्ञानं भारं: क्रियां विना—meaning if you have knowledge but do not apply it in the right place and direction, it becomes a burden and is rendered useless. Therefore, you have a kind of dual responsibility. You need to disseminate your knowledge and experience while also strengthening ethics—which Chanakya emphasized the most throughout his treatise on governance. Hence, I believe that in today’s digital world, in this era of changing technology, the role of Audit and Assurance and the changes therein have become very important.

Friends, you have been continuously observing efforts to bring transparency based on technology over the past five years. The government's accounts have remained open and transparent, almost like a dashboard. Everything is in front of everyone, and it is clearly visible. From tenders to procurement, the government has established a transparent process. Now most tenders are online, and the monitoring of infrastructure-related projects is also done scientifically. JAM—Jan Dhan, Aadhaar, Mobile—has ensured that the benefits of government schemes reach the common man directly. And GEM—Government e-Marketplace—allows the government to procure directly. Today, the benefits of over 425 government schemes are reaching direct beneficiaries. As a result, about one and a half lakh crore rupees have been saved from going into the wrong hands. Particularly, you have played a commendable role in making challenging and complex reforms like GST a part of the country’s business culture.

Friends, today India is one of the leading digitized economies in the world, and rapid development of digital infrastructure is taking place here. The digital system has strengthened the interface, harmony, and trust between citizens and the government, and it has also had a positive impact on government processes. Our methods of record-keeping are also changing. Let me give you an example—previously, payments made to the government required citizens, government offices, and the treasury to keep separate receipts. But now, there is no need for a physical copy; it is stored in a paperless manner in an app. This has not only made it convenient for the public but has also brought about a significant change in the CAG's audit process.

Friends, as India moves towards becoming a 5 trillion dollar economic power, you all have a significant role in this. Because what you do will directly impact the efficiency of the government, the government’s decision-making, and policy-making. What you do will also directly affect the efficiency of business institutions, and it will impact investment in India and the ease of doing business. All stakeholders today require accurate audits so that they can execute their plans correctly. At the same time, they do not want the audit process to take too much time. This is where your challenge begins. To tackle this challenge, two things are very important. One is related to skill and training, and the other is related to tools. Those new colleagues joining this profession must be equipped with updated technology, and it is equally important to upgrade the skills of those already working. Just as auditing organizations worldwide are moving towards crowd-based solutions, we must also incorporate the best global practices regarding technology into our systems and work on India Pacific tools.

Friends, our goal is to make Evidence-Based Policy-Making an integral part of governance by the year 2022. This will also help in creating a new identity for New India. In this context, it is the right time for the transformation of the Audit and Assurance Sector. Now the CAG must also move towards CAG 2.0. I have been informed that you are rapidly moving in this direction. We can only accomplish this quickly if we can bridge some gaps and connect some links swiftly. The data being generated here is vast and stored in various agencies and departments. This data has been collected by these agencies and departments for their own use. But it is also true that often this data is not shared with each other. This vast data is not linked. Therefore, the accountability gap also arises as a natural course. We need to bridge this. And for this, some efforts are being made at the government level, steps are being taken. I am confident that you all will also discuss this topic among yourselves and share it with other agencies and departments. I remember the last time I gave an example of road construction in a single district. I explained how when two different departments build roads of the same length in the same district, there can often be a significant difference in costs. During separate audits, both may seem fine, but when looking at the overall picture, they are not found to be correct. There are many such examples in government departments where big data analysis can lead to improvements. And I believe that when you analyze large databases for your audits, your insights can greatly assist in Evidence-Based Policy-Making. If the CAG can provide advice based on this data-related information and offer some institutional solutions, I believe it will serve the country greatly. And I would also urge you to think not just from an audit perspective but also from the viewpoint of a think tank.

Friends, I also spoke about institutional memory last time. Digital audit and digital governance can strengthen this institutional memory across different organizations. Another task you can easily undertake is that the CAG audits many international organizations and provides technical support to other countries in auditing. You can create an institutional mechanism where international audit teams can share their experiences and best practices, making the CAG's audit reports more meaningful. Can we choose the topic of audit for discussion? We should definitely consider this. You are coming up with various types of audits. My suggestion is that you also consider process audits. Until now, you have only looked at whether the process was followed or not. But is there any possibility of improvement in that process so that the set goals can be achieved? This suggestion will come, and I believe it will be very helpful. Another complaint from departments is that CAG audits are done too quickly, which means the findings are not as useful. Is it possible for internal audits of departments to be strengthened, and how can they be in tune with the CAG so that we can save time and increase efficiency? This will mean that when departments conduct routine audits, they pay attention to all these details so that when the CAG goes there, the ready-made material will require very few additional items, and we can increase efficiency and speed.

Friends, this challenge is about dealing with the technology that those who do wrong have. Now, CAG and all auditors, whether internal or external, will have to find innovative ways to tackle new challenges. And for this, we must first promote the core values of auditors; only then can we rein in occupational fraud. In recent years, there have been many efforts to combat fraud in government departments. Now the CAG must develop technical tools so that there is no room for fraud in institutions. And I would like to suggest—recently, I have experimented with this—can the CAG think about this? I requested various departments of the Government of India to identify what problems they face in finding solutions or in delivery. Initially, it is difficult for departments to accept this, so the first report from everyone is that there are no issues, everything is fine, and everything is running very well. I kept probing, asking repeatedly, and eventually, about 400 issues came from different departments. They felt that if there were technological solutions, it would be beneficial.

I gave these 400 issues to IT-based students from various universities and conducted a hackathon across the country. Millions of young people participated. For a minimum of 36 hours, these teams worked nonstop. From among them, when about 10-12 thousand students remained, I personally discussed with them. You will be surprised that most of the solutions for these 400 issues were provided by these 18-20-22-year-old students, technology-based solutions. I also commend the government for incorporating about 80 percent of these solutions into their systems. Can the CAG today, facing challenges as you mentioned in the presentation about auditing hospitals, which is a significant technical task, identify such issues? If a doctor can be found, they can guide you in that direction. Can we identify such issues and find technical solutions?

If you can provide these types of issues to these young people, I can suggest to the HRD Ministry to coordinate with this. And such hackathons can be organized to create tools for the CAG, bringing such solutions to the CAG. If some of your people get the opportunity to discuss with them, I believe a good mechanism can be established, and this can be done annually. These hackathons will also benefit our country’s youth, as they will learn how the oldest and most experienced institution in India operates and the challenges it faces. I believe this work can be thought about and should be explored. Such efforts will reduce the problems of the common man in the country and strengthen their trust in all institutions. At the same time, there will be harmony between the government mechanism and yours.

I believe that the CAG will meet all the expectations of the country and will strengthen its role in making New India a clean India, not the clean India that I talk about, but the other one that you refer to. And I urge you—there is one thing to conduct an audit. But is it right to put someone in the dock through an audit? Are we supposed to stop there? No, wherever we are, working under any umbrella, ultimately we all work for the country, we work for the bright future of the country, we work for our coming generations. And therefore, the hard work we do, can it contribute to good governance? Can it contribute to efficiency? And this can be done—like it is not always necessary that we find flaws in what exists, it is not always necessary. But if at the beginning of the year you take ten departments. Let there be brainstorming regarding those ten departments, with the departments, with your people, those who are experts, even those working at the grassroots level, those working at the district level, at the state level, at the national level. By brainstorming, suppose you directly come up with 100 points, and they are told that look, we will come for an audit after a year. The 100 points that we have collectively identified, you should weigh your work against these 100 points. The things you will keep records of, do keep these 100 aspects in mind.

This means that the audit mindset will indicate beforehand that look, to avoid mistakes, I will provide you with a pro forma. You see, this will make a difference; efficiency will increase, new aspects of governance will emerge, which will become a strength for the government itself. And therefore, I would like us to explore if we can make such efforts. Secondly, you must have seen, ultimately you must have seen, in the budget, in the house, we also keep an outcome report, which was not there before. Because discussing output is quite simple, that there was ten rupees, ten rupees were given. What was done, why it was done, how it was done, for whom it was done, when it was done, whether it should have been done or not, all these matters go into your domain. And that is where the outcome begins. And therefore, within the house, we have developed and institutionalized the arrangement for outcomes these days.

But sometimes the process is good, the product is good, but what about the outcome? Where does the outcome fall short? Where there is theft, the outcome falls short; that is a different matter, mostly bad governance is responsible for that. If governance is right, then in the natural course, outcomes and efficiency are visible. And therefore, we can also make our discussions a part of good governance. And so I would say what was the target, what has been achieved, and regarding this, while your perspective is nuanced, I would definitely like us to strive for how we can move forward to strengthen our respective institutions in advance.

Once again, I have the opportunity to be among you today. I wish you all the very best in serving the country excellently. In 2022, it will be 75 years of independence. What will be the targets of the CAG in 2022, the 75th year of independence as an institution? How will we make this institution more friendly? How will we make it productive? How will we make it a contributor to good governance? The strength of our experience in finding flaws also has the power to prevent those flaws. It has the power to prevent flaws from occurring, can we connect with all these aspects to make this large institution even more effective? And I believe it is possible.

You may feel that looking at files can be tiring and that the Prime Minister is bringing four new tasks, but I believe that then your burden will automatically lessen, and you will also feel satisfied that the contributions you have made have been institutionalized in a way that has played a significant role in changing the mindset of the country’s map, and this is possible.

With these expectations, I wish you all the very best.

Thank you very much.