Control session of the Congress of Deputies questions to the President of the Government.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

11 May 2022 · Control session of the Congress of Deputies · Congress of Deputies

Context
Sánchez faced parliamentary questions in the Congress of Deputies on May 11, 2022, addressing the dismissal of the CNI director and related institutional controversies.
Main themes
CNI dismissal controversy, intelligence services oversight, institutional integrity, separatist political alliances, rule of law, opposition criticism, Spain's role in Europe, energy policy, government transparency, motion of censure legacy
Duration
~21 min
67th percentile
Words
2,467
67th percentile
Sentences
123
73rd percentile
Readability
55
77th percentile
Grade
10.5
26th percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
2.24
58th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

123 sentences in 47 paragraphs

The head of someone who has demonstrated an impeccable record was falling and rolling, just a month and a half before the NATO summit in Spain. But his partners were asking for a scapegoat. And you comply docilely.

The message sent with the dismissal at the CNI is a warning to navigators. Whoever fulfills their duty will be dismissed. But whoever lies and manipulates for the benefit of the Government will be rewarded. Do you think it is important to strengthen the institutions of the State? Because you are doing nothing but deteriorating them.

President: Thank you very much, Madam President. Your Excellency, it is evident that there has been a failure in the security of the communications of the Government of Spain.

And what the Government of Spain has done is what we have always done. Comply with the law, inform the judiciary of these criminal acts, and act with absolute transparency before public opinion.

Yesterday, indeed, the director of the CNI was dismissed, and I want to take this opportunity to acknowledge her work, and also to recognize the work of the 3,000 officials of the National Intelligence Center.

But in any case, Your Excellencies, I will tell you that, with this Government, neither public funds, nor the Security Forces and Corps of the State, nor the intelligence services will be used to cover up criminal acts, nor to pursue political adversaries outside the law.

Ms. Gamarra: Mr. Sánchez, who signs the intelligence directive that sets the objectives under which the CNI operates? You. To whom does the CNI report according to the law? To you.

Then the Government, contrary to what it has said, did know, because it had to know.

But it turns out that what we have learned is that you were negotiating governance with those whom the State had to investigate. And this does not happen in any democracy in the world. Why? Because it is the absolute degradation of politics, which is what you represent.

Have you ever wondered why the separatists want Pedro Sánchez at the head of the Government of Spain? Because with you they are stronger. Puigdemont, Junqueras, Otegi do not want Alberto Núñez Feijóo. They want you.

Your political partners, do not be mistaken, do not choose you for your worth. They want you for your weakness. Because the success of the political project of Esquerra and Bildu necessarily depends on a President, and that is you, who is willing to undermine the institutions of the Rule of Law from within. And you meet their expectations.

When you leave Moncloa, which is near, you will not only leave a serious economic crisis, to which we are already accustomed when the Socialist Party governs, you will also leave a harsh and difficult institutional crisis, which will be more difficult to reverse.

But in the Popular Party, we are perfectly aware of what we are going to find, and we are prepared to govern.

President: Thank you very much, Madam President. Your Excellency, look, in just a short time, four years will have passed since the motion of censure.

So, what country do we find ourselves in? We find a country where a unilateral declaration of independence had been approved in Catalonia. There was a government with a party convicted of corruption. With a Secretary General of the Popular Party and Minister of Defense who was destroying evidence for Justice with a hammer.

A para-police structure was created to follow political adversaries irregularly. Yes, Your Excellency. And Spain in Europe counted as a zero to the left.

The situation today, Your Excellency, is not perfect. The situation today is not perfect. But let us recognize that today the Constitution is upheld throughout the territory of Spain, that the crooks are not in the Government, as they were when you were in power.

Your Excellency, and that Spain, and that Spain, and that Spain today defends its interests in the European Union. It asserts itself and has influence.

Imagine, Your Excellency, if in addition to all that, if in addition to all that, we had the main opposition party helping the Government of Spain in responding to the pandemic or also to the economic consequences of the war, or helping the Government of Spain before the community institutions.

Well, the truth is that I am quite naive, because then we would be talking about a modern and European right, and not the misfortune of the right that suffers Spanish democracy.

Response from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the question posed by Deputy Néstor Rego Candamil of the Plural parliamentary group.

Mr. Rego: Thank you, Madam President. Mr. President, are you aware that your government is promoting an unsustainable model of electricity production with a significant social and environmental impact?

President: Thank you very much, Madam President. Despite the difficulties, I must tell you, Your Excellency, that this government has put forward a framework for energy and climate composed, first of all, by the first law in democracy on climate change, the National Energy and Climate Plan, and the strategy for a just transition of that energy model that is not only providing tools to meet those climate objectives, but we are also doing it with territorial balance and job creation.

In any case, I must tell you, Your Excellency, that from the point of view of the Government of Spain, the rating obtained from the community institutions is one of the most outstanding, and therefore we are, I believe, deploying a reasonable strategy for energy transition.

Mr. Rego: We already know and have just confirmed once again that you enthusiastically incorporated into your speech concepts such as energy transition, ecological transition, but neither this nor support for renewable energies alone really guarantees sustainable development policies.

Your government is promoting a model in which, again, as in Francoism, Galicia will be specialized in the large-scale production of electricity, largely for the rest of the Spanish State, because today 33% of the electricity produced in our country goes abroad. A predatory model that lacks prior planning and is based on a free-for-all for companies that choose where to install themselves, leading us to currently face more than 200 projects for large-impact wind farms, which affect not only areas of high environmental value but also agricultural land, our heritage, watercourses, and our best fishing grounds, with a great detriment to fundamental economic activities in Galicia, such as fishing, agriculture, or livestock.

By the way, I hope you fulfill the commitment regarding Decree 6/2022 to recover public participation in the processing of parks and review the zoning, and that it does not remain among one more of your many unmet commitments.

A model, ultimately unsustainable, because the impact of the wind turbines must be added to the high-voltage evacuation line, the transport over 600 kilometers, and the energy loss that occurs in it.

And all this could be avoided with a distributed generation model based on smaller-scale production, with social return, without environmental impact, and close to consumption centers.

But moreover, the Galicians do not benefit from that condition of a sedentary electricity-producing country. That is why the BNG once again demands a Galician electricity tariff because it is fair that if we bear the social and environmental impacts, we can compensate for them to some extent with a lower own tariff, as is the case in producer areas of other European states.

A Galician tariff that would not only benefit citizens but also companies and the economic development of our country.

President: Let's see, there are two things we need to be clear about. First, the Government of Spain is committed to adapting and mitigating the effects of climate change. And secondly, it is evident that the war in Ukraine has raised the need, the demand for the European continent to gain energy autonomy. And that is what the Government of Spain is doing. It is doing so, Your Excellencies, with some of the issues that you are unjustly criticizing the Government for.

First of all, we are rapidly deploying renewable energies that necessarily have to be ordered, compatible with the territory, as I said in my first intervention, and with society and with the maximum requirement for environmental assessment of those projects.

In our priorities, Your Excellencies, I do not know why you criticize it, self-consumption is also included, to which we have allocated 900 million euros. We have eliminated the sun tax that the previous administration imposed, the promotion of energy communities with 100 million euros, to which we add 220 million euros for large-scale storage and batteries in homes, and more than 200 million euros for renewable climatization.

And Your Excellency, I must also tell you that, for example, in all the auctions we are proposing for renewable energies, the companies that opt for those auctions must present a strategic plan in which they explain how they will make their projects compatible with the socioeconomic reality of the territory. And look, just to give you a figure, it is estimated that in the last auction an investment close to 4 billion euros will be mobilized and the creation of 36,000 jobs precisely in the territory.

In short, I believe that there are projects that we need to launch also on a smaller scale, as you referred to earlier, but I must tell you that the objectives are set. We need to accelerate the agenda, have larger renewable plants that meet, of course, the environmental and social criteria of our energy framework. But undoubtedly, Your Excellency, we must face the climate challenge.

Response from the President of the Government, Pedro Sánchez, to the question posed by Deputy Edmundo Bal Francés of the Ciudadanos Parliamentary Group.

Mr. Bal: How far are you willing to go to maintain your parliamentary alliances?

President: You asked me about the stability of the Government of Spain. The stability of the Government of Spain is manifested, for example, with the 13 agreements we have with social agents. Also with a significant result in the votes of the main measures, quite important in this Chamber, which has received the support of many parliamentary groups. I am recalling the last Royal Decree Law in response to the economic and social crisis arising from the war, but also the General State Budgets. And without a doubt, Your Excellency, I express the will of the Government of Spain to guarantee that stability until the end of the legislature in 2023, which is what the Spanish people deserve and need.

Mr. Bal: Look, Mr. Sánchez, it has not been 24 hours since you dismissed the director of the CNI. An exemplary official, whose head has been served on a silver platter to the separatists, and you come here as if nothing is happening. Yes, something is happening, it is that those convicted of crimes are the ones who set the administrative career of public servants who uphold the application of the law.

And why did you do it? I will tell you, to stay in power, to stay in Moncloa. You are capable of tarnishing the good name of public servants by supporting slanders or insults that suggest that the director of the CNI behaved at least with negligence or even implies that she was outside the law. And that is an immorality. It is an indignity.

Are you capable of putting yourself in the shoes of a public servant who has been working for Spain for 40 years and whose government leaves him in the lurch? Can you imagine the personal sacrifices this person has had to make over these 40 years so that you drag their good name through the mud? Don’t you think it is the most cowardly thing in the world to vilify a person who cannot defend themselves because they work in secret? You have no right to do that. And I say this as someone who can say it with the greatest authority in this chamber, because I know perfectly how this government behaves with public servants who prioritize loyalty to Spain over blind and submissive obedience to this government.

They also asked you, I imagine, for my head, right? And you gave the thumbs down. Well, the irony is that I am here telling you to your face what I think. I know what it is to interfere in your path of ambition. I know it perfectly. Just like Sánchez Corbí, just like Diego Pérez de los Cobos, just like Margarita Mariscal de Gante, just like the director of the CNI. You do not believe in Spain, you only believe in yourself. One day you will look back, you will be alone, and you will see the path of destruction and corpses you have left in your wake, many from your own party. Other public servants but above all, the good name and prestige of Spain and its institutions. And for that, so that nothing remains unscathed. Please…

President: Thank you very much, Madam President. The truth is that when I listen to you, Mr. Bal, I must acknowledge your technical qualification, your brilliant oratory. And I also sympathize with you, because it must be quite frustrating to feel so good and so unrecognized as when you ran for election and you are not even able to secure a seat.

Mortals, Your Honor, that is what we are; we make mistakes, some successes. In any case, I am going to tell you the following: look, when I arrived in government four years ago, after a motion of censure, I had to face the following request from the National Court: whether to declassify or not documents that would allow justice to investigate the paramilitary structure that had been set up by the administration of the Popular Party to illegally spy on political opponents and also to obstruct the investigation of justice in its corruption cases. What did the Government of Spain do? The Government of Spain collaborated with justice and declassified those documents. And thanks to that, Your Honor, the former Minister of the Interior is being prosecuted and the former Secretary of State for Security is also being prosecuted.

What has the Government of Spain done in this matter? What the Government of Spain has done in the face of a clear ruling on the security of government communications is to hand over a criminal act to justice and to be absolutely transparent with public opinion.

You may say, Your Honor, that you do not agree with our decision to hand this information, this criminal act, over to justice. So, what are you telling me as the State Attorney, Your Honor? That I should cover up a crime? This is not the government that does that. It was a previous one.