Interview with President of the Government on Antena3 TV News
Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Sánchez gave a pre-election TV interview on Antena3 on 15 April 2019, addressing the Catalan crisis and reacting to the Notre Dame Cathedral fire.
- Main themes
- Catalan independence crisis, self-rule and autonomy, Spanish territorial model, co-existence in Catalonia, Statute of Autonomy reform, regional financing, constitutional framework, Notre Dame Cathedral solidarity, 2019 Spanish general election, federalism, dialogue over confrontation
- Duration
- ~36 min
- Words
- 4,367
- Sentences
- 224
- Readability
- 57
- Grade
- 9.8
- Syntax
- 2.92
- Vocabulary
- 2.08
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
224 sentences in 77 paragraphs
President of the Government .- No, not yet. I believe that the best thing at this time is not to interfere. And indeed, to convey all our solidarity to the French people over the loss of a jewel that is a World Heritage Site, a cultural jewel such as Notre Dame Cathedral. The truth is that we are all in shock.
Q.- Let's ask our first question because we only have 20 short minutes and it is about Catalonia. Today you have prepared your electoral programme, in which you mention Catalonia: they are asking for and you are offering more self-rule to the Catalan people, but not the right to self-determination, although a more federal system. Can you explain this to the audience please? What does this mean? Does it mean that the people of Catalonia will have more rights than the rest of the Spanish people? Does the Constitution need to be reformed? How can you explain this?
President of the Government .- Of course not. Let's see, here the question is that the problem in Catalonia is not one of independence. Both the right wing, which is so critical of me, and the pro-independence forces, know this. The problem in Catalonia is one of co-existence. What adds something for the people of Catalonia? What adds something for them is self-rule, the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia. And, in this regard, what we propose is to extend this self-rule, reform the Statute of Autonomy and improve some of the difficulties that currently exist in the territorial model.
Q.- Is a constitutional reform required for that?
President of the Government .- No.
Q.- What would you offer, what type of things can you give them, that will satisfy the Catalan pro-independence forces so that they will accept remaining part of Spain?
President of the Government .- It is not a question of satisfying the pro-independence leaders who, by the way, have been absolutely irresponsible in this shift for many years now in Catalonia; they are the main party responsible for the breakdown of co-existence in Catalonia. It is a question of offering a potential solution to Catalan society.
We have always said that the Catalan pro-independence forces must speak with the non-nationalist parties in Catalonia. And between them, they must agree on a new Statute of Autonomy. The problem in Catalonia is also closely related with their approval of the Statute of Autonomy, which was voted for by Catalan society and which was subsequently ruled out by a decision of the Constitutional Court. That is another problem that we must also resolve.
Q.- The Constitutional Court has its powers. It acted within its powers.
President of the Government .- Of course.
Q.- When you speak about greater self-rule, what model are you thinking about? It is hard to find a model anywhere else in the world with as much autonomy as Catalonia and the Basque Country have, for example.
President of the Government .- And the model in Andalusia as well. And in Extremadura. And in the Region of Madrid or the Region of Valencia.
I believe that we must sit down and talk, for example, about regional financing. We are not talking about questioning equality among Spaniards. We are talking about the fact that the regional financing system has not been renewed for many years now. And when we talk about the regional financing system we are talking about the Welfare State; about the provisions for healthcare, education, long-term care, social services…
Q.- But that was already negotiated, for example, by [Mariano] Rajoy with Artur Mas, and with Carles Puigdemont and you yourself have spoken about these matters with Joaquín Torra, but found no way to resolve the conflict.
President of the Government .- Of course. But look, I believe that as regards Catalan independence, the leaders must be well aware that they have to speak with Catalan society and tell them that they have deceived them. That independence is not possible. That the problem in Catalonia is not independence but co-existence. And that hence, the only way to resolve a problem of co-existence is first of all, through dialogue, within the Statute of Autonomy, within the Spanish Constitution, and not through the confrontation we have witnessed in recent years.
What we want to see is a claim stated for self-rule; a claim stated for a Spain made up of autonomous regions. And that must be done precisely at this time, right now, because we have a pro-independence movement that is calling for the Statute of Autonomy to be violated while, on the other hand, we have a tripartite right wing that wants to re-centralise a good many powers that are presently under the jurisdiction of the regional governments.
Q.- President of the Government, do you still maintain that Spain is a nation of nations?
President of the Government .- I have always backed Article 2 of the Constitution. I feel represented by Article 2 of the Constitution which states that "the Spanish nation is indissoluble". And, secondly, which "recognises both the autonomy of the autonomous regions and of nationalities". I believe that this is important, if this country considers that it is plural, which I believe is the case, that this plurality must be recognised in the functioning of our State of the autonomies.
Q.- President of the Government, the leaders of the 'procés' [movement to declare independence of Catalonia] are on trial and you are aware that the opposition accuses this government, once a ruling has been handed down, of being in favour of granting pardons. Is that the case? Will you pardon them?
President of the Government .- Just let me ask you a rhetorical question and see how you answer. Is there any precedent of a President of the Government considering the request for a pardon before a final ruling has been handed down in the last 40 years? No, there isn't. Moreover, just look, one thing is to talk about criminal liability, which is currently being resolved in the Supreme Court. And it is quite another thing to talk about political responsibilities. As President of the Government, but also when I was the Leader of the Opposition, I reproached the attitude and the strategy employed by the pro-independence movement.
Q.- Personally, would you be in favour of granting a pardon to the leaders of the 'procés' in the event that…?
President of the Government .- Why don't we just trust in the justice system? I trust in the justice system. I am convinced that the justice system will hand down an exemplary ruling that is fair in relation to the challenge made by the pro-independence leaders in October 2017.
And allow me to finish off this thought for a moment. Look, it is one thing to talk about criminal liability, which is currently being resolved in the Supreme Court. And it is quite another thing to talk about political responsibilities, which both as President of the Government and also when I was the Leader of the Opposition, I was very clear about - I reproach the attitude of the pro-independence leaders as irresponsible. But I would add something else, not only because this attitude was irresponsible but also because it has led to the breakdown of co-existence in Catalonia. And finally, we have even seen some of these leaders who, instead of taking responsibility, have actually fled our country.
So, let's leave the judges, the Supreme Court, to do their work, and I believe they are doing an extraordinary job. We respect the separation of powers. I am convinced that the Supreme Court will hand down the correct ruling, and from a political point of view, the pro-independence leaders can consider themselves under reproach from the President of the Government.
Q.- Do you not fear that a response such as this may be considered by some people as elusive and make them think that what you are doing, in reality, is hiding your true desire, when the time is right, to grant a pardon?
President of the Government .- But look, you are asking me about things I have already done. When I was Leader of the Opposition, I supported Article 155, and intervention in Catalonia precisely in order to recover the Statute of Autonomy. Precisely in order to recover the Statute of Autonomy, precisely in order to place the Catalan institutions back under the Statute of Autonomy and within the Spanish Constitution, which were precisely violated by the pro-independence leaders.
What do I mean by this? One thing is criminal liability, which is currently being resolved in the Supreme Court. And it is quite another thing to talk about political responsibility. The political responsibility shown by the pro-independence leaders is, from my point of view, absolutely reprehensible. And I would add something else so as to respond with more precision to your thought. I believe that when I have said "no is no" over the course of my political life, it can be seen that "no means no". And hence, there will be no independence under a socialist government, there will be no referendum on self-determination, and the Spanish Constitution will be respected.
Q.- Let's move on now, President of the Government. You will have seen the pictures, just like us. Colleagues, we would ask you to show us the pictures of the attacks that have been taking place since last week, of Cayetana Álvarez de Toledo, and also Vox this weekend in the Basque Country, and lastly in Rentería - these are the pictures of the mobbing of the leaders of Ciudadanos. The rivals of the PSOE are saying in this case, OK, the PSOE; the Socialist Party, has condemned these attacks, but the President of the Government has remained silent and not said anything. What do you say to that?
President of the Government .- I am the General Secretary of the Spanish Socialist Party, and also the President of the Government. But look, I have always believed that democracy is incompatible with intolerance. And I also share a thought that Marta Pagaza left us with. She said that in the exercise of democracy you have to have the right to freedom. And I couldn't agree with her more. So, you have my reproach of this type of attitude because I consider that democracy is incompatible with intolerance.
I precisely advocate a respectful and tolerant Spain where insults and disagreements should give way to dialogue and reason. Of course, politics is emotional, but I believe that it is also important to call for moderation as a vital attitude in politics.
Q.- One of the key moments in this election campaign is the discussion as to potential post-electoral pacts. According to the figures coming through in the polls in the last few days, these figures are, in principle, very favourable to your candidature, that of the Socialist Party.
Just a few days ago, we had Pablo Iglesias sat here, in the very chair you are in now, and he warned us that if the right numbers are there for the PSOE and Podemos to govern together, then they will demand to form part of the new government. And you say that what you want to see is a single-party government, such as you have had to date. How will this be compatible, in the event that this outcome pans out?
President of the Government .- I think we are looking at things upside down. I believe that the Spanish people should firstly be allowed to speak; they must decide what they want through the ballot box. I am proposing this election campaign based on three main goals which I believe the country deserves for the next four years which means not only stability but also social justice; in other words, doing away with inequality; cleaning up politics, and hence, doing away with corruption; and co-existence, and hence, doing away with confrontation and territorial tensions.
Aside from that, I believe that if the opinion polls are saying anything, then it is precisely that a third possibility exists with a Socialist Party government that includes progressive independent MPs of renowned prestige which is precisely what we have had over these last 10 months. That is what we are doing, not so much thinking about pacts but more about a majority that offers the country stability to tackle the transformations based on these three pillars.
Q.- Mr Sánchez, we are looking at the latest CIS which is showing that the Socialist Party will win these elections on 28 April, but it will need to forge a pact with either Podemos or perhaps with Ciudadanos. Do you trust the CIS poll of [José Felix Tezanos], because it would seem that even he didn't trust it the other day?
President of the Government .- Just look, we saw the results yesterday in Finland which gave the victory to the Social Democrats but the far right, which started off in fifth place, ended up second. In other words, I believe that what the opinion polls show is a state of mind, and I believe that the state of mind in Spain is one of hope. It is a state of mind of making progress, of looking to the future, and of not looking to the past.
We are talking at this time of whether to return to the 1984 Abortion Act, from the last century. And such basic consensuses are being questioned as gender-based violence, or, for example, the abolition of the minimum wage, and some political parties are talking about privatising the public pension system.
Q.- Would you prefer [Pablo] Iglesias or [Albert] Rivera as Vice- President of the Government, as the case may be?
President of the Government .- I would prefer Carmen Calvo as Vice-President of the Government.
Q.- But depending on the results, which of those two would you prefer?
President of the Government .- I feel, and I stress this, that right now we should be talking about 28 April. Just look, when you start talking about pacts and, furthermore, with a fairly indecent distribution of the portfolios before even talking to the Spanish people, about whether this person is going to be the Minister for Foreign Affairs, about whether this person is going to be the Minister for Education or Home Affairs… A little bit of respect for the Spanish people, please.
I feel that election campaigns should serve to inform as to the project each party has for the next four years. Mine is quite clear: social justice and eliminating inequality. The fight against corruption, and hence, cleaning up politics and co-existence within the framework of the law, and hence of the Spanish Constitution.
Q.- President of the Government, when some pro-independence leaders state that they are in favour of helping you in the event of a potential investiture, are they doing you a favour or placing you in an awkward position?
President of the Government .- Look, everyone is free to decide whatever they want. I, of course, and they are perfectly well aware of this, as is the right wing, and I did this as Leader of the Opposition as well, have always defended the Spanish Constitution, the Spanish State, territorial integrity and the national sovereignty of our country,
They know that there will be no referendum, that the Constitution will not be violated and just look, if I have to apply Article 155 of the Constitution, then I will do so, with a consensus, not how the PP and Ciudadanos are saying they will do it, without a consensus, by imposing it. And it will be proportional to the challenge from the secessionists. I don't want to do that, but if the pro-independence forces take this path again, then they should be aware that I, as President of the Government, will act as resolutely as needs be.
Q.- And with the same resolution as you say this, could you confirm to us here that you will not accept the support of the pro-independence forces in the event of a potential investiture.
President of the Government .- Look, let's see. I feel that the answer and how the matter should be posed is as follows: everyone can vote however they want. But the limits of the government's action that the Socialist Party will be under are those we have followed for the last 10 months: everything, but within the Constitution; nothing outside of the Constitution.
Q.- If, in contrast to what the polls have been saying recently, you are unable to renew your office as President of the Government, will you be the Leader of the Opposition in the next legislature?
President of the Government .- I understand, Vicente, why you are asking me that question, but at the moment I am a runner who is about to start a race, or who has already started a race, and what I obviously aspire to do is to win the elections. I believe that Spain deserves four years of stability. I believe that Spain deserves four years of transformations in these three areas: social justice, democratic regeneration and territorial co-existence. And I believe that at this time the only party that can guarantee this stability and these transformations to make progress in the future is the Socialist Party.
Q.- We are going to talk about pensions now which I am sure is a matter that our viewers are very interested in but, Mr Sánchez, which will we see first, the composition of the new government or [Francisco] Franco in El Pardo?
President of the Government .- Well, the date for the exhumation of the dictator is 10 June. This has been appraised and settled by…
Q.- It would seem there are some obstacles; it would now seem that some 20 Benedictine monks also need to be exhumed… Seeing how things are going eight months after the announcement… How do you see the situation? Do you believe that we will see a new government or Franco in another place first?
President of the Government .- We live in a social and democratic State under the rule of law. Look, I feel it is important to say two things about this matter. The first is that what the Government of Spain is doing is following the law. We are enforcing an article of the Historical Memory Act. And we are also enforcing a resolution passed by the Spanish Parliament in the Lower House - a democratic Parliament, which didn't see a single vote against. All the votes were either in favour or abstentions. And what this resolution of the Lower House of Parliament stated was that a mausoleum in a democracy cannot be, let's say, devoted to paying tribute to the dictator Franco. So, we have upheld the law at each turn. We have guaranteed…
Q.- But we don't see it happening on 10 June. How do you see it? Do you think he will be somewhere else on 10 June?
President of the Government .- The commitment of the Government of Spain is for it to be by 10 June. That is our commitment.
Q.- Let's talk about the economy. Several institutions, some of them Spanish, such the Bank of Spain, and other international institutions, such as the European Commission and the IMF are questioning your government's accounts. They don't believe we are in a position to reduce the deficit to the extent that we are committed to, or that we will be able to create the number of jobs we should create given that we have this differential whereby our level of unemployment is always double the European average. Why do you believe this is happening? To what extent have the measures the government has taken in recent weeks - in the so-called "social" Fridays - endangered compliance with these targets that are also important for the economy?
President of the Government .- Just look, in 2018, we ended up with a public deficit that was lower than that initially forecast by the previous government - 2.6% - when it had been set at 2.7% of the Gross Domestic Product. We ended up with 2.6%.
The target for this year, for 2019, is to close the year with a public deficit of 2%. Hence, we are following a path of fiscal consolidation and, moreover, I should add that just a few weeks ago we exited the corrective arm of the EU due to our excessive deficit, which we had been under since the start of the crisis.
So, our accounts balance. As a result of public revenue currently being collected, these accounts are consolidating their position and this is closely tied in to the level of economic activity in our country.
540,000 jobs have been created over these last 12 months. The level of National Insurance contributors is at an all-time high of 19 million, including in relation to the number of female contributors. The number of permanent employment contracts and of young people in work have also both increased.
I believe that we are showing that a demanding economic policy is compatible with our social policy, which I feel is important in our country, because inequality affects many of our citizens. And economic growth that is not redistributed is useless economic growth. Hence, this government's commitment is to balance the public accounts, to guarantee economic growth, to create quality jobs and to redistribute this growth through the Welfare State.
Q.- We are faced with a scenario - that is what the economists are telling us - of economic slowdown - some were even talking about that of 2008. Is the government preparing for this scenario?
President of the Government .- Look, we are consolidating the public accounts and we are now at 2.6% with a target of 2%. By the way, if we had approved the Budget the public deficit target would be below 1.5% rather than 2%. In other words, I believe that this government is doing its homework; it is committed to fiscal consolidation and to meeting its targets with the EU. And as regards everything else, what we are doing is guaranteeing the legal certainty of the economic agents, of business owners, who, in the end, create jobs. And we are also clearly committed to creating quality jobs.
Q.- If everything is going so well why are these international institutions raising doubts about the public accounts, and the Bank of Spain as well? Because each report that is published reiterates the same.
President of the Government .- Just look at the change in the economic growth forecast made by the International Monetary Fund a few weeks ago, which showed that we are the developed economy to have its growth forecast reduced the least, by just 0.1%.
What I mean by this is that the foundations of economic growth in our country are solid. The Government of Spain wants to re-industrialise our country to tackle the ecological transition of our economy. To also end and shift the paradigm of the energy system towards clean energy, and consequently, to mitigate and adapt to the effects of climate change. To make a clear commitment to territorial cohesion and to the infrastructures of this country. To grant legal certainty to economic agents - to both the trade unions and business owners.
Q.- Out of curiosity, President of the Government, why doesn't Felipe González go to campaign meetings? We have seen both [José María] Aznar and [Mariano] Rajoy at PP meetings. What is your relationship now with the senior party members, with that old and traditional element of the Socialist Party?
President of the Government .- It is good. In short, this is a plural party. This is a party that holds many opinions on important matters. This is a party with 140 years of history. We have governed for a good part of the 40 years of democracy. I hold both Felipe González and José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero in great esteem. But I believe that we are the new generation, the leaders that currently head up the Socialist Party. It is now us who must propose this future to Spanish society. And I should state for the record that I count on the support of all of them.
Q.- But did Felipe González want to go to the meetings, or did you agree not…?
President of the Government .- I can only say to you that I don't know. You would have to ask the electoral committee that. But he undoubtedly has all my respect and appreciation, not only as President of the Government, but also as a party colleague.
Q.- One last question, President of the Government, before saying goodbye. On 23 April, you will be coming here, together with the other political leaders for a five-way debate. Some people criticise you for not having also accepted holding a two-way debate with the Leader of the Opposition, with Pablo Casado. They say that you don't dare to hold a debate with him alone, as [Mariano] Rajoy did with you, for example, before the elections in 2015. Why won't you hold this two-way debate, in addition to the five-way debate?
President of the Government .- Just look, the two-way debate was held in a completely different panorama, before 20 December, when there was no parliamentary representation of either Podemos or Ciudadanos. Now, we are not only four parties competing nationwide but there is also another emerging force - the far right. I don't want to see a far-right party in our country, but it exists. And hence, I feel that it is important to contrast the positions of these five parties which will clearly set the course for the country over the next four years.
Q.- If you win the elections and form a government, will some of your current ministers hold office again? A simple yes or no?
President of the Government .- Yes, absolutely, many of them.
Q.- President of the Government, we look forward to seeing you on Antena3 at the five-way debate. Thank you for being here with us
President of the Government .- My pleasure. Thank you very much.
Non official translation