Interview with the acting Prime Minister at the TVE Breakfasts.

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

11 July 2019 · TVE Breakfasts interview

Context
Sánchez was interviewed on TVE Breakfasts on 11 July 2019, discussing stalled coalition negotiations with Unidas Podemos ahead of an investiture vote.
Main themes
Coalition government negotiations, cooperation vs coalition government, Unidas Podemos partnership, government formation, Catalan independence issue, policy priorities for citizens, internal government cohesion, minimum wage and social policies, progressive government, Article 155 and territorial integrity
Duration
~46 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,558
93rd percentile
Sentences
241
92nd percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
11.5
39th percentile
Syntax
3.02
51st percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
43rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

241 sentences in 82 paragraphs

Xabier Fortes.- President, good morning, thank you for being on public television.

President.- A pleasure.

Fortes.- Has Pablo Iglesias asked to be vice president of your Government?

President.- I do not like to reveal private conversations. What is evident is that the negotiation method we have had with Unidas Podemos over the past few weeks has not been the right one. We have mixed many things. We have talked about positions, about content. And I believe it is important to return to the beginning, to change the negotiation method. To talk, first, about what matters, without a doubt, to the citizens, which is not so much who is going to handle Health, but, for example, to extend dental health and recognize it within the National Health System, which is what we socialists are proposing.

Without a doubt, it is also important to know who is going to be the Minister of Labor, but more important for citizens is to know whether jobs will continue to be created and what quality that employment will have. And what salaries workers will have.

And, therefore, I announce that today I will call Mr. Iglesias to set up two teams that start talking about what matters to citizens, to set aside the differences, whether it is a coalition government or a cooperation government. To talk about what matters to citizens. And from there, we can start proposing a solution, which I believe is positive for all Spanish citizens.

Spain needs a Government, and that Government, the Government we are proposing is a progressive Government, for which we are marking Unidas Podemos as preferred partners, but that does not depend on the independentist forces. And, for that reason, we are also looking at Ciudadanos and the Popular Party so that they at least vote in favor, but with their abstention facilitate the constitution of a Government on July 22.

Fortes.- You have just informed about that call you are going to make in the coming hours to Pablo Iglesias. Does that mean that both sides are not focusing the negotiation well, that what happened 48 hours ago, last Tuesday, caused discontent among the citizens, and also among progressive voters?

President.- Without a doubt, the method has not worked, because we are stuck. We are talking about many things at once. And, therefore, I think it is important to return to the starting point, how we can start to unstick a situation that is indeed stopped, paralyzed.

I defend the cooperation government, and I believe that, moreover, with very solid arguments. But, in any case, I think that what is important is not to talk about who is going to be the Minister of Health or the Minister of Labor or the Minister who handles Social Security, but the pensions of our elders, the work of Spaniards. And, without a doubt, also, the National Health System for all Spanish citizens.

Fortes.- Irene Montero has just said that they are willing again to negotiate, and that the PSOE should abandon red lines. Do you also want Podemos to abandon red lines? I have to ask you again. Do not reveal what you talked about, just, would it be a red line whether or not Pablo Iglesias is in that Government?

President.- But look, the problem is another. You see, we have done many things together with Unidas Podemos over the past 12 months. We have raised the Minimum Interprofessional Wage; we have recovered the universality of Public Health; we have, for example, restored unemployment benefits for those over 52 years old who are unemployed. We have done things together. That is to say, it is evident that there are points of agreement with Unidas Podemos.

What is the problem? A Government must be a Government that enjoys internal cohesion, and internal cohesion, evidently, does not only involve such important policies as social policies, but also other state policies, where, evidently, we have very serious discrepancies with Unidas Podemos. Unidas Podemos, for example, on the Catalan issue is not only defending the right to self-determination, but also, when it was applied, unfortunately, because we had to do it in the face of the secessionist challenge in 2016 and 2017, Article 155 of the Spanish Constitution, to defend national sovereignty and territorial integrity, they challenged the application of Article 155 before the Judiciary. They talk about political prisoners. If you talk about political prisoners, it is because you consider that there is a way of understanding the State of our country that is different from what the Socialist Party defends. The Socialist Party defends that there are no political prisoners: that there are imprisoned politicians who, supposedly, have committed a series of illegalities that are currently being adjudicated in the Supreme Court.

What do I want to say with this? What I want to say with this is that it is evident that there are fundamental differences and discrepancies that would make a Government of the characteristics proposed by Unidas Podemos a Government that would be paralyzed by its own internal contradictions.

Fortes.- It is also true that Pablo Iglesias regarding the Catalan issue said that he would be very disciplined with the line set by the Government itself, and you, in particular.

President.- Yes, look, Mr. Fortes, what can I say? If, unfortunately, in this legislature, in the face of a ruling that the Supreme Court will make in a few months, the Catalan independentists return, as they are saying they have not abandoned the unilateral path, that they would do it again. They are doing something like what they did two years ago. Is Unidas Podemos going to support the Government of Spain in the hypothetical application, which I do not wish, I insist, I do not wish, because I am a president who wants to resolve the Catalan issue, who has not renounced dialogue within the limits set by the Constitution, which are very broad, would they be in a Government that supports Article 155 of the Constitution, which must be applied? Would they be in a Government that believes that they are not political prisoners, but that they are imprisoned politicians who are currently accounting for their actions before Justice, as a result of alleged illegal acts committed during that time?

What I want to say with this and I do not want to emphasize the differences, I defend the cooperation government, because I believe it has been good for the country, because there are social policies that are being implemented thanks to the cooperation and understanding of Unidas Podemos and the Socialist Party. But my responsibility as president of the Government is to guarantee not only the investiture but a Government that makes possible all the advances that our country needs: In social justice, in ecological transition, in a recovery of labor rights that have now been subverted as a result of the labor reform of the Popular Party in 2012, of reconstruction and recovery of the welfare state.

All these issues, without a doubt, we can do many of them with Unidas Podemos, but we must also be aware, and we must say it clearly to the citizens, that a Government is social policies, very important for a left-wing president, as I can represent, but, without a doubt, also, state issues. And on state issues, I insist, there are fundamental discrepancies. And those fundamental discrepancies are discrepancies regarding the conception and diagnosis of problems, such as, for example, the crisis of coexistence that is being experienced in Catalonia.

Fortes.- Dates. Investiture, in two days, Tuesday and Thursday, within a week and a half, there is much talk about it. If you are not invested, will you reach September with a third call or will there be elections?

President.- I would like to tell the viewers that on many occasions, in the analyses, it is overlooked, it is not emphasized what the procedure that is regulated in the Constitution is. That is to say, I am a candidate for the Presidency of the Government because the King has appointed me as a candidate. That is to say, if I do not win this investiture on July 22, 23, and 24, it is evident that my candidacy as a candidate for the Presidency of the Government falls. And, therefore, it is up to the Head of State to once again conduct a round of consultations and see if there is, let’s say, water in the pool, to be able to present a second investiture. But that no longer depends on me, nor does it depend on the parliamentary forces.

For that reason, I believe that what is important is to tell the other parliamentary groups that, without a doubt, the main responsibility for there to be a Government lies with the first political force in this country, which is the Socialist Party. I assume it. I want to negotiate with all political forces. But the existence of a Government in Spain does not only depend on the Socialist Party, it does not only concern the voters of the Socialist Party, it concerns all Spaniards, and, consequently, all political parties.

For that reason, I make a call, knowing that there is no alternative Government to that of the Socialist Party, due to the difference in seats that has been obtained in the elections of April 28, I make a call to all political forces, the four main political parties to pull together and that on July 22, 23 there is a Government in Spain. And then, let them do the opposition they want. Let Ciudadanos and the Popular Party compete to see who leads the opposition, but let there be a Government so that they can oppose.

Fortes.- This leads me to the following reflection. There is a letter that circulated yesterday, and that appears in some newspapers, from an important group of deputies and former deputies who say, and ask the Popular Party that as they did, even if they do not agree, to abstain. Did you know about that letter?

President.- I did not know about that letter, and I appreciate, in fact, that former colleagues from the Socialist Party have done so.

But look, I am going to make, as President of the Government I believe I have the responsibility to also address a guarantee and an exit for the country on this issue. Let's see, there are two problems here: One is conjunctural, and the other is structural. The structural one is that we have Article 99 of the Spanish Constitution, which does not work?

Fortes.- Should it be reformed?

President.- It needs to be reformed. This is the first national agreement that I am going to offer to all parliamentary forces. That is to say, what makes no sense is that on June 15, we all know that when a plenary session is called in the City Council of Barcelona, Madrid, Santander, Bilbao, or Cádiz that day a Government comes out, why? Because if there is no absolute majority, the most voted list governs.

I am not saying that this is the formula for the governability of Spain, but it is evident that we need to find a mechanism that allows an investiture. And that prevents negative coalitions that can lead to systematic electoral repetition.

Secondly, that is, let’s say, the structural approach that is important to offer to the Chamber, and I will do so in my investiture speech and, above all, to the main political forces.

Thirdly, there is the conjunctural problem. In the conjunctural problem, those political formations to the Popular Party and Ciudadanos, also particularly to Unidas Podemos, what I offer them is a national agreement. And that national agreement is: let’s guarantee governability; let’s put on the table, as a first measure, the constitutional reform of Article 99, so that this is the last time that this occurs in any future investiture process.

Fortes.- Would there be more constitutional reforms, taking advantage of the fact that the topic is already open?

President.- Yes. I have already offered, and we did it in the previous, in the 12 months we were in charge of the Government, the reform of Article 49 to define, I believe, in a much more adequate, accurate way, people with different abilities that are currently not recognized in how they are defined in the Spanish Constitution. And, also, logically, the suppression of privileges for politicians in the exercise of public action.

Fortes.- And the prevalence of men over women in the ...?

President.- Without a doubt.

Fortes.- We are talking about the Popular Party. I asked you about the letter because many focus on that, well, that was what Pedro Sánchez did not do when it was his turn.

President.- And they are right. But look, everything must be viewed in its political context.

In 2016, what happened? The exhaustion of a political project, that of Mr. Rajoy, and the Popular Party, very probably, no, surely, due to the crisis that he caused or the management he made of the economic crisis, but, without a doubt, due to corruption. In fact, it is evident that there was then a motion of censure that ousted the Government of the Popular Party due to the famous ruling of the National Court on the 'Gürtel case'.

And, secondly, it should be remembered that Mr. Rajoy lost; he went from one hundred eighty-something seats to 123 seats. That is to say, there was a very significant setback for the Popular Party even, effectively, taking into account that it continued to be the first political force in this country.

In the case of 2019, it is completely different; a new political cycle is opening. The Spanish people have said they want the Socialist Party. They said it on April 28. They said it more emphatically on May 26, and therefore, all I ask is that, if in the end it is impossible to reach an agreement with some and others, because, well, they prioritize a series of interests that, in my opinion, are the wrong ones, but, well, everyone is legitimate to defend their interests, at least allow the most voted list to govern. I believe that would provide a solution, a way out of this investiture crisis we have to truly face that reform that ensures this is the last time a candidate for the Presidency suffers a blockage of this nature.

Fortes.- This is the barometer. The distribution of seats. Socialist Party, 123; 42 is its preferred partner, we would have to keep adding, we will do that later, but this would be, let’s say, the basis for an investiture, and also for a legislature.

Some time ago, a few months back, you said in an interview with Jordi Évole that you had suffered strong economic pressures, the 'establishment', so to speak, to break that possibility of agreement. Have you experienced them in recent days?

President.- No, not at all. I am the acting Prime Minister.

Fortes.- But they could have done it, too.

President.- But look, on the contrary. If with Unidas Podemos, I insist, we have many issues on which we can agree, in the social sphere, in the area of ecological transition, in the recovery of labor rights. But, I insist, a government, a government must enjoy internal cohesion. And that internal cohesion is not only in sectoral issues, which are very important for a left-wing government, such as social issues. It is also about the Catalan issue.

And the Catalan issue, moreover, is not something that I have provoked, nor that Unidas Podemos has provoked either. It is something that has been bequeathed to us from many years of inaction by the Popular Party Administration, of an absolute lack of institutional and democratic responsibility on the part of the independentist forces, which are currently governing in Catalonia, and a timeline that is given to us by a ruling that is expected to occur in the autumn of this year.

What do I want to say with this? That a government must face very important issues for this country, which have to do with coexistence, with the claim and strength of our Social and Democratic State of Law. And on this issue, we have fundamental discrepancies.

Therefore, having proposed a cooperation where we are not talking about the presence of ministers from Unidas Podemos in the Council of Ministers, but rather about a representation of Unidas Podemos in different areas of the Public Administration; having said that they are a preferred parliamentary partner, proposing that we will make a program with contents and social advances over the next four years. And, in addition, a monitoring committee to evaluate the degree of compliance with those agreements, seems to me, honestly, honestly, Mr. Fortes, the most sensible, most realistic, and most generous proposal we can make in the current context and politics.

Fortes.- Three questions and then I will give the floor to my colleagues, you say that there are fundamental differences that do not allow for a coalition government but you also said that this cannot happen because you do not add up, if you added up those fundamental differences would still exist. Would there be a coalition government?

President.- Look, indeed, you are right. We would have 176 seats. It is often said that in Europe there are coalition governments. Let’s take the case of Germany, which is, let’s say, the paradigm of all coalitions. It is true that there are other coalitions in Europe, there are other countries, for example, in Denmark or Portugal where there are no coalitions, where there is a minority government of the Socialist Party with left-wing forces supporting from the outside. But let’s take the case of Germany. In Germany, there is no territorial crisis like the one we are suffering in Spain. Point one. Point two: if there were that territorial crisis, I am convinced that the SPD and the CDU would have an approach regarding the nature of the crisis being experienced in Catalonia and its solutions that would be similar. This is the problem we have with Unidas Podemos.

Fortes.- That would be the same, but then I do not understand the argument of we do not form a coalition because we do not add up because if it adds up, the territorial problem would still exist.

President.- But, look, we raise this issue especially when Unidas Podemos says that we have not reached or have not proposed the execution of the agreements during these twelve months as we agreed with them. I deny the premise. In most cases, we have done so. But, in any case, in those issues, for example, like the Housing Decree where we could not effectively materialize the agreement we had with them in the last legislature was due to the fact that we did not have an absolute majority and, therefore, we had to add other political formations from the center-right nationalists like the Basque Nationalist Party, to give an example, where they also propose their approach to how to resolve the housing rental crisis. Therefore, what I want to say with this is that there is a summation of objective reasons to be aware that we cannot mimic or make a tautology of what represents a coalition government in the City Council of Barcelona, as was signed yesterday, for example, or a coalition government in Valencia, as has been stated more than a month ago, to what represents the governability of our country.

Fortes.- In that conversation with Pablo Iglesias that you will have in the afternoon, will you talk already, apart from programs, about profiles of potential ministers from the Podemos environment or from Podemos?

President.- I left the door open for Unidas Podemos to propose some independent person of recognized prestige who could join the Government. It does not seem that this solution would please them either. I insist the proposal is political. It is not a proposal for the distribution of seats, of power quotas. It is a proposal in which, as Prime Minister, I have to guarantee several things: first, an investiture; second, a functioning government; third, stability; and fourth, sufficient internal cohesion so that the challenges we face as a State are addressed adequately, which is what I am proposing. From there, look, we have no problem sharing that power. What we need is a serious, generous, and undoubtedly also realistic approach regarding the political situation in our country.

Fortes.- One last question very briefly, and we will start with Anabel, have you already spoken with Albert Rivera who has been hospitalized?

President.- I sent him a message yesterday. I did not want to call him because I do not think he is in the circumstances… I wish him the best and that he recovers as soon as possible. Fortes.- What do you think about not going to see him? Has the message not been completed with a "we can meet"?

President.- No, one thing is one thing and another is another. From here, I wish him a speedy recovery beyond the political discrepancies we logically have. I do not have a bad personal relationship with Mr. Rivera. I do believe he is making a mistake. I deplore that he does not even make the effort to meet with someone who has been chosen by the King, and undoubtedly as a result of the votes of the Spanish people, as the first political force to try to form a government.

Among other things because I believe that the formation of a government, given the parliamentary characteristics we have in Congress, does not depend solely on the Socialist Party. That is why I say that all political formations must pitch in to resolve this investiture crisis. From there, I insist, I have the doors open to meet with Mr. Rivera as many times as he deems appropriate.

Fortes.- I mentioned what is coming because he was hospitalized, in case some of our viewers do not know, for gastroenteritis. We will now start the question round, Anabel.

P.- Anabel Díez. Yes, Mr. President. I suppose there are many reasons for distrust that Unidas Podemos also raises, one of them at least they say publicly, is that your propensity would be to pact, they say with the right, that if you could, what happens is that Mr. Rivera gives you the cold shoulder, but that your natural inclination would be for there to be a pact with Cs. Is this the case, if you could, as many citizens also say, would you make a pact with Cs and not with Unidas Podemos?

President.- I want to understand each other with Unidas Podemos, the preferred partner of the Socialist Party Government is Unidas Podemos, without a doubt, because we have many points of coincidence, but I insist, we also have some points of disagreement that will define this mandate, this legislature, and I insist, it is not a timeline that we have imposed, it is not a timeline that we have provoked, it is a timeline that is imposed on us by a political reality that we have inherited as a consequence, in my opinion mainly, of the irresponsibility of the independentist leaders, also of a certain inaction on the part of the previous Popular Party Administration and consequently we have to manage that reality and that reality requires a government with absolute internal cohesion. Does that mean we should not find areas where we can share executive responsibilities between Unidas Podemos and the Socialist Party? I believe we can find them, but for that, we all have to make an exercise of responsibility and generosity. That is why I said that what is important is to return to the beginning, rewind and return to the starting point. Propose a negotiation, not mixing everything, but first talking about contents, seeing where we can reach agreements and finally, unraveling, revealing how we can materialize that government that executes all the contents we may have achieved. I insist, is it important who will be the minister of Health? without a doubt, but it is much more important for citizens to know what commitment is made to public health in our country.

P.- Iolanda Mármol. Mr. President, you have opened the door to recognized independent figures from the Podemos sphere. Within that category of independents, you are the acting Prime Minister, would you include people, for example, deputies, not from Unidas Podemos, but from confluences, for example, Equo, the Mareas, would they fall within that category of recognized independent figures, for example, if they had a previous career?

President.- I do not have any prejudice against members or companions of Unidas Podemos, of their confluences. I insist, I believe that I made, I made a government twelve months ago, where more than a third are people of recognized prestige, independents, who have nothing to do with a political affiliation to the Socialist Party. And I believe that this was also rewarded by the citizens because I proposed an open government to society and not a government closed to party logics, which is somehow what can be proposed through a coalition government. Therefore, if Unidas Podemos has a similar approach to this, I would be willing to open it. Why? Because I believe we can do many things together, but I insist, there are central elements of politics, not of policies, of State policy, that require internal cohesion that right now, as a consequence of the discrepancies we maintain with Unidas Podemos, we cannot guarantee. And this is something I have told Mr. Iglesias on many occasions, which I would also like to convey to public opinion. That a government logically requires social policies, that is my main priority, of social advances, of recovery of rights, especially in the labor field, of consolidation of economic growth, of making the ecological transition of our country a reality, of addressing the digitalization of our country, but also logically, of facing systemic crises that affect national sovereignty, territorial integrity, which will require the generosity of all. And the generosity of all requires, implies, that Unidas Podemos is aware that there are such discrepancies, that the best way to guarantee a progressive government is a government of cooperation like the one we are proposing.

P.- Ignacio Camacho. Yes, Mr. President, good morning, when you reach an agreement with Unidas Podemos, you will still be missing a handful of votes, with the PNV and some regional minority groups, but even so, you would need at least some more abstention, which can only come from the separatist parties or from Bildu, unless you entered into the game proposed by Unión del Pueblo Navarro to exchange the Government of Navarra for their support. What do you prefer?

President.- Let's see, I believe I have been clear from the beginning. The investiture crisis can only be resolved among the four main parties in the country. I exclude Vox. Between the PP and Ciudadanos, Unidos Podemos, and the Socialist Party. I have proposed a progressive government that does not depend on the independentist forces. The progressive government requires an understanding, we will see how, with Unidas Podemos and that does not depend on the independentists requires the commitment of the Popular Party and Ciudadanos. What do I ask of them? I ask them to vote in favor. The only thing I ask is that as long as there is no alternative, because parliamentary majorities prevent it, to a government other than one that can be led by the Socialist Party, at least they facilitate the constitution of their government. I insist, I am even open to negotiating with them the abstention. I have told this to both Mr. Casado and Mr. Rivera. Unfortunately, until today what I have found has been a no. But I hope they will make an exercise of responsibility and reflection.

Q.- Ignacio Camacho. If they do not, do you need the abstention of any separatist party?

President.- But look, Mr. Camacho, I understand your approach, but these calculations that are made add or rather, they lack an approximation. The support of a political formation, such as Navarra Suma, can subtract the support of other political formations. Therefore, there are sums that subtract. And this may be for citizens who are not in the day-to-day of politics, but for you who are in the daily analysis of politics, you know perfectly well what I am talking about. Probably the support of a political formation like Navarra Suma would imply the non-support of the Basque Nationalist Party for that investiture and therefore, we would be talking about two that you gain, six that you lose. I insist, those are the margins to reach those 176. It seems much more responsible to me that main parties like the PP and Cs, which call themselves state parties, allow the constitution of a government and that the first country agreement we put on the table is the constitutional reform so that the next candidate for the Presidency of the Government, when the elections are in four years, does not suffer what Mr. Rajoy suffered four years ago or what I am suffering right now in this investiture.

Fortes.- We have one minute left, briefly, in addition to other questions for the current president. An important clarification for what we have talked about, you have made a very strong self-criticism in the negotiation and have talked more about positions.

Q.- Jordi Juan. We understand that the teams that are going to meet will talk exclusively about the program, they will seek a programmatic agreement and will not talk about positions and only in case a programmatic agreement is reached will they move on to the second phase of positions. And the specific question within the clarification, voices have come out from Esquerra Republicana saying that they are in favor of abstention in exchange for avoiding new elections, which would be very bad, and that on the other hand, the PP and Ciudadanos are in another position. Like it or not, it is contradictory the degree of Esquerra Republicana that is PP and Ciudadanos.

President.- I would not say that, but I do notice the sarcasm in your question, I think it is a contradiction that both the Popular Party and Ciudadanos will have to clear up, they do not stop talking about constitutionalism, they do not stop talking about a sense of state, but they are evidently preventing the constitution of a government. And in relation to the first question, if what we want is that the negotiation method we have had has unfortunately not worked, because we have a problem and it is regarding how to materialize that government that puts into motion the agreements contained, therefore let’s return to the starting point, let’s negotiate the contents, let’s set aside what government it would be. I am willing to do it, if Unidas Podemos is also willing to do it. I will defend the cooperation government because I believe it is the most sensible, the most reasonable, and what can guarantee the stability of the country during these next four years. And indeed, let’s leave for the end how we can, let’s say, agree on the main obstacle in my opinion that Unidas Podemos has, which is more about who the Minister of Health is, to give an example, than about the public health of this country.

Fortes.- Two very brief questions aside from all this, today we read in a newspaper El País, not only about the exhumation of Franco but referring to the Pazo de Meirás. Are you going to act as you have all the legal arguments this time?

President.- Without a doubt.

Fortes.- Why?

President.- Because they acted against the law.

Fortes.- So clear?

President.- So clear.

Fortes.- Do you have it all tied up?

And one last question, Nadia Calviño has just said that she raises the growth forecasts for the economy, although it is said that there are some clouds on the horizon, but the Commission has raised the growth forecasts for our country.

President.- We continue to lead that growth, I think it is important that as a consequence of this good performance of the economy we have a government as soon as possible so that we can approve a budget as soon as possible. This was the main reason why the elections were called on April 28, because there were no budgets. Therefore, I believe that Spain cannot stop. This talk of second investitures or third investitures, Spain needs a government in July, it does not need a government in September and October or November, and of course I also tell you one thing, I do not contemplate and do not work with a scenario of electoral repetition.

Fortes.- Would you understand, finally, your voters and those of Podemos if an agreement is not reached?

President.- Look, I believe that the voters are very aware of the problems that the country has and I think that what is important, I insist, is not only to carry out an investiture, but to have a government that guarantees that stability during the next four years.

Fortes.- Mr. President, thank you very much for being on Spanish public television.

President.- A pleasure.