Speech at the First Judicial Conference of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation

Türkiye Recep Tayyip Erdoğan · President of Turkey

14 December 2018 · First Judicial Conference of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation · Istanbul, Türkiye

Context
Erdoğan addressed supreme court presidents of OIC member states in Istanbul on December 14, 2018, at the First Judicial Conference of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation.
Main themes
Justice and rule of law, Organization of Islamic Cooperation judiciary, fundamental rights protection, Islamic world challenges, terrorism and extremist organizations, Jamal Khashoggi murder, Ottoman heritage and justice, moral conscience in governance, oppression and injustice, geopolitical instability in Muslim-majority regions
Duration
~22 min
71st percentile
Words
2,688
71st percentile
Sentences
154
82nd percentile
Readability
62
91st percentile
Grade
8.9
10th percentile
Syntax
2.90
34th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from Turkish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 44%40%
  • Institutional 26%23%
  • Social 14%13%
  • Ceremonial 14%13%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

154 sentences in 38 paragraphs

In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.

Esteemed presidents of the supreme courts of the member countries of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation, Distinguished guests,

My dear brothers;

I greet you with love and respect. Peace be upon you and the mercy of Allah and His blessings. Welcome to our country and our beautiful Istanbul.

As the President just mentioned, I would like to express my condolences to Allah for our brother, the Provincial Police Chief, who was martyred a short while ago in my hometown of Rize. Similarly, I pray for Allah's mercy for the nine brothers who passed away in a train accident in our capital, Ankara, yesterday, and I wish healing for our injured.

Dear brothers;

I hope our conference on the topic of "The Role of the Supreme Judiciary in the Rule of Law and the Protection of Fundamental Rights" will be successful and bring about good for all of us. I would like to thank our President of the Constitutional Court and his team for their efforts in organizing this conference. I especially express my gratitude to you, the esteemed presidents of the supreme courts and legal professionals who have honored our meeting from all corners of the Islamic world, for your contributions to the ideal of a more peaceful and secure world.

Esteemed guests;

The concept of justice has been one of the most discussed and debated topics from the first human until today. In our country, there is a saying, "When there is justice, there is no need for bravery." A great soul who lived in our country also said, "The earth and the sky stand firm thanks to justice."

There is a tale attributed to one of the important jurists of our history, Ebussuud Efendi, and the powerful Ottoman Sultan Suleiman. Sultan Suleiman, who was also his teacher, asks Ebussuud Efendi, "Is there a sin in crushing an ant when it wraps itself around the fruit?" Ebussuud Efendi replies in the same courteous manner: "When the day of judgment comes, the ant will take its right from Suleiman." Yes, only a state governed by such a fine understanding of justice could survive for 600 years, and indeed it did.

Philosophers say that justice is a characteristic exclusive to the virtuous and the righteous. Likewise, it is not possible to achieve justice solely through laws and law enforcement without a corresponding moral conscience. Viewing justice merely as a means for the weak to seek their rights leads to justifying the injustices of the powerful.

However, justice is meaningful only when it resides with the powerful. We must accept that we live in a world where the powerful are virtuous, and the virtuous are not powerful. Unfortunately, those who are strong in the world today are not pursuing justice but merely advancing their own interests. History shows us that societies and states that deviate from the path of justice inevitably face destruction. The secret behind the collapse of many powerful leaders who once ruled significant parts of the world lies in their failure to establish a system based on justice. There are countless examples that demonstrate that oppression cannot endure.

Unfortunately, today, in many parts of the world, especially in our region, there are oppressions that pierce the conscience. Those who try to ensnare the Islamic world through terrorist organizations such as ISIS, Al-Qaeda, Boko Haram, Al-Shabaab, and FETÖ aim to dry up the lifeblood of Muslims. However, where there are Muslims, there should be no exploitation, no genocide, no hostility, no injustice, and no distortion in the distribution of wealth. But today, unfortunately, all these evils hover over the Islamic world like a dark cloud. It is our duty to find and implement what we need to do to disperse these dark clouds.

The recent murder of a significant figure from the press, Jamal Khashoggi, in our Istanbul, right here at the Saudi Arabian Consulate, is not a matter to be brushed aside. In fact, the issue is clear in every aspect, and I believe it is evident who the perpetrator is. It is very clear and evident that among the 15 people sent to our Istanbul, there is a perpetrator. The place where the incident occurred and the operation was carried out is also known.

Of course, we asked the authorities sent to us: There is a perpetrator among these 15, and you know who this perpetrator is. And you are capable of bringing this perpetrator to light. Their response was, "We have currently detained 18 people." Later, they increased this number to 22. Well, now reveal the perpetrator as well. Initially, they tried to shift the blame for this crime onto here. What did they say? They said, "Jamal Khashoggi performed the marriage procedure there and left." However, that is a lie. He has a fiancée outside. He is not an ordinary person; he is someone with a place in the world of thought, someone with a pen. Is it possible for him to leave without picking up his fiancée? No. Later, they said, "We didn't mean to say that." They went further, and the Foreign Minister used this expression: "We did this with local collaborators." Well, who is this local collaborator? Tell us. And not only did they not tell us this, but they also lied by saying, "I did not use such a statement."

And what is even more interesting is that we learned from the audio recordings that among those who came, there are individuals who are currently closest to the Crown Prince, who took an active role in this matter and carried out the orders. Look, everything is now coming to light. They asked us: "If I send my Chief Prosecutor, will you allow him to meet with your Chief Prosecutor?" I said, "Let him come, let him meet with our Chief Prosecutor." He came, they met, but they delayed everything. They did not provide my Chief Prosecutor with the slightest piece of information or document. However, my Chief Prosecutor provided him with all the necessary information. Because the perpetrator is evident; they know this. Those who aided and abetted are also with them. And on a Friday of the week, a group comes here, and on Monday night, a second group comes and completes the operation, finishing the job and leaving. But the Chief Prosecutor leaves here with five suitcases of nuts. Because the concern is different. And along with all this, we explained everything clearly to the personnel they sent us, but they continued to conceal.

And in the meantime, what is interesting is that some segments and countries from the Islamic world, unfortunately, those who have fallen victim to the dollar or the riyal, did not speak the truth and reality within the framework of justice regarding these events. In the Western world, many barons also cannot speak about this. Why? Because dollars will come, for that reason.

Now, this country, which is rich in oil, unfortunately, has still not made a decision, nor can it. However, justice will find its place. You heard about the developments in the American Senate yesterday, and this will continue to develop. Why? Because we provided all the information to the Americans, to the intelligence agency, to the authorities. The British wanted it, we gave it to them; the Germans wanted it, we gave it to them; we gave it to Saudi Arabia, we gave it to the French. We said, "Whoever wants it, we are ready to provide it to all." Why? We gave it so that justice could find its place.

And since the crime was committed here according to international law, we said, "Give it to us, we will prosecute." Look, they are not giving it. And the Foreign Minister makes a statement, saying, "We cannot give our citizens." Look at this expression. If there were even a trace of a sense of justice, he could have said, "What do you mean, of course, we will give them, please go ahead and prosecute." Why can't they say that? Because it becomes evident where this issue will leap to.

You know that the U.S. Permanent Representative to the United Nations, Nikki Haley, made a statement and named names openly. This shows that everything is now coming to light. Our hope is that this issue will truly come to light. We will pursue it to the end; we will not let it go, so that justice can find its place.

Esteemed guests;

The foundation of Turkey's policy in its region is to stand with the oppressed against the oppressor, and not only that but also to actively ensure justice on the ground. Those who have burned and destroyed Iraq and Syria under the guise of fighting ISIS are as guilty as those who gave them this opportunity. One of the most striking examples of this is what we see right next to our borders in Syria. A terrorist organization that occupies one-third of Syrian territory, supported by America and some European countries, displays all kinds of oppression and treachery.

Since this terrorist organization directly targets our country, we are, of course, fighting it much more effectively. But in fact, the entire Islamic world should unite in the fight against this organization. Because through this organization, a part of Syria is being attempted to be removed from our civilization and culture, as if a dagger is being plunged into our hearts. It is unthinkable for us to allow such a terrorist organization, such a threat, to exist before our eyes.

For this reason, just as we did in Cerablus, Afrin, and Idlib with the agreement we reached with Russia, we are determined to bring peace and security to the regions east of the Euphrates as well. Indeed, as of last night, we carried out operations in Iraq. And we conducted operations against the steps taken in Sinjar and the foothills of Mahmur, which constantly pose a threat to our borders. Did we stop? No, there will be more to come. Why? Because if there is a threat coming from there, and there is, the response to that threat will be given immediately. These terrorist organizations will either be eliminated, or if they do not, we will eliminate them.

The treacherous attack on our soldiers in Afrin from Tel Rifat yesterday demonstrated how accurate our decision was. The reality that the weapons and terrorists amassed at our borders will eventually target us has been proven once again by this incident. Indeed, there are 22 known American bases in northern Syria, and over 20,000 trucks of weapons and equipment have been sent here. Who are these going to? They are going to the PKK, PYD, YPG there, and they are using them through these means. And when these come into our hands, we also see where they came from and through whom they were sent. And in intelligence, there is known human intelligence and technical intelligence. We use both human intelligence and technical intelligence, and with all this, we learn what is where, how many vehicles have come in, and what has been brought where. And I am someone who has explained all this to the highest authorities, including Mr. Obama and Mr. Trump, with dates and everything. However, they all seem to hear, but they do not hear, and they do not take action.

We said justice; when this does not happen, at that moment, those seeing eyes suddenly become blind. Until today, we are strategic partners, we are together in NATO, we are together with many international organizations. Think about what those who do not take these steps with us or cannot do so will do with countries that have no connection to such organizations.

Now they want a new plan from us - we have a saying - "Look at the juggler," they are trying to distract our attention with the story of Manbij, which they have turned into a game. Manbij is a place where 85-90% of the population is Arab, but they have completely handed it over to those terrorist organizations. They promised us, "We will clear them from there and send them east of the Euphrates," but they did not send them. Now we say, you have cleared them, you have removed them, if you do not remove them, we will also enter Manbij.

I speak openly; Turkey has lost enough time in intervening in the terrorist swamp east of the Euphrates. From now on, we have no tolerance for even a single day's delay. The scene we encountered in the Afrin operation is confirmed by the reports from our intelligence units. This data is sufficient to show us what is being done in the east of the Euphrates and what will come our way if we do not act immediately.

I want this truth to be known: With the steps we take in Syria, we are not only ensuring the security of our own country but also protecting the dignity of the ummah and all humanity. No tribalism or sectarian fanaticism can cover this truth. Anyone who does not chase their own interests and approaches the issue with fairness will see this reality. Those who are truly in pursuit of peace, justice, and morality in the region must support Turkey in this struggle.

Esteemed guests;

One of the greatest dangers regarding justice is the control of the judiciary by those who abandon reason and judgment and pursue their own ideological obsessions. Turkey has experienced this problem with the FETÖ issue. Through its elements in the police and judiciary, and then by using its militants within the army, this organization attempted to stage a coup in our country, and its members are now being held accountable before the law.

No matter how great the betrayal we have experienced, we continue our struggle against them without compromising on law, justice, rights, and conscience. We do not fall into complacency; we keep our determination alive, but we also continue to adhere strictly to the principle of the rule of law. As I have always said, just as we do not allow any criminal to go unpunished, we cannot tolerate even a single innocent person being wronged.

Justice and the legal framework that implements it, the laws, and the judicial mechanisms are effective to the extent that they are seen by the entire society. Turkey has faced a historical test in this regard and has managed to emerge from the process with its head held high.

No one can say a word about our country's democracy, the quality of the rule of law, or our sincerity regarding rights and freedoms.

We all witness how Western countries, which do not leave democratic values, liberalism, and respect for differences to anyone when it comes to words, turn to fascist practices in the face of the slightest threat. The difference between those who use democracy and law as a facade and those who place these values at the center of their lives can only be revealed through such tests.

I regret to express that the governments of most Islamic societies are still far from justice, law, and freedoms to the extent that they have not even been subjected to these trials. I say this as a self-criticism. The attitudes displayed just after the murder of the late Jamal Khashoggi have once again slapped this reality in our faces. While the place of unjustly taking a life is clear in our faith, we are almost alone in pursuing this murder, which was committed in a truly inhumane manner.

Without addressing these shortcomings, it is impossible for us as Islamic societies to reach the place we deserve, to attain the peace and happiness that our Lord and our Prophet have promised us. I hope that our conference will turn into a platform where all these issues are discussed, debated, and solutions are proposed.

Once again, I thank each of you for your participation on behalf of myself and my nation. I extend my love and respect to you all, and I wish you to stay healthy.