Viktor Orbán's response

Hungary Viktor Orbán · Prime Minister of Hungary

25 September 2023

Context
Orbán responded to opposition speeches during a Hungarian parliamentary session on September 25, 2023, addressing critiques from DK and Jobbik factions.
Main themes
Ceasefire vs. peace negotiations, national cooperation, energy independence, guest worker policy, opposition to Gyurcsány era, Jobbik criticism, migration policy, Hungary's sovereignty, parliamentary debate
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,210
87th percentile
Sentences
218
91st percentile
Readability
61
89th percentile
Grade
9.5
15th percentile
Syntax
2.76
18th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
15th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 38%36%
  • Economic 21%20%
  • Social 15%14%
  • Ceremonial 13%12%
  • Environmental 7%6%
  • Institutional 6%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

218 sentences in 28 paragraphs

Mr. President!

Thank you for the floor!

First of all, I can perhaps claim for the first time in many long years that I was impressed by Ferenc Gyurcsány's statement, that someone trusts his wife so much and advocates for her. I wish him much success! In my opinion, it is a mistake what the Prime Minister said, that Hungary would be waging war against anyone. It is not waging war against anyone; we are primarily trying to create national cooperation in Hungary and also around Hungary. "Have we come closer to being a strong nation in general?" – asked the Prime Minister. Regardless of time and space, it is very difficult to answer questions of this type, but perhaps I can risk the assertion that we have come closer to a strong Hungary compared to how the country was during Ferenc Gyurcsány's government. We can say that with certainty. I will go a step further, because after listening to his proposals, I see, I can assume that the plan, the spouse plan, is to bring back the Gyurcsány era in Hungary – at most now not under the name of the spouse. I want to make it clear that in my opinion, Hungary does not want another Gyurcsány era, whatever it may be called. Hungary wants nothing to do with the period from which it could only fight its way out through hard and sweat-inducing work over many years. So, with all due respect to the DK, I can only say that we cannot support their ambitions for government.

The Jobbik. We are still at the beginning of the session period, and therefore a more discreet formulation may still be acceptable, so I will not say about the main speaker of the Jobbik that he lied when he claimed untruths, but rather that we are dealing with a lack of knowledge here. So the claim that Hungary has not done everything in the past ten to thirteen years to achieve as much independence as possible in its energy system can only stem from a lack of knowledge. When the government took office in 2010, Hungary was connected to the outside world by two interconnectors; when the war broke out, there were six. Six is more than two. Obviously, we pursued a policy before the war that allowed Hungary to obtain energy not only from two but from many more, in numerical terms from six alternative sources. It is not worth ignoring this fact in a serious parliamentary statement. You consider price caps to be a communist instrument – I would also advise caution here, as numerous European countries use price caps. It may be that France is considered communist in your view, which does not seem obvious at first glance, and they employ such means. And I do not want to get fully involved in that discussion – which is not so easy to understand – that you claim if we limit the price of something, it leads to price increases. This seems quite absurd to us.

As for the statement of the Jobbik faction leader: It is worth taking a moment to think about the relationship between peace and ceasefire. In my opinion, the question at hand is not what kind of peace there should be, as that is the second step. The first step is called ceasefire. What Hungary wants is not a peace plan, where someone from somewhere presents a peace plan and then everyone is happy and ends the war. What a childish idea that is! In reality, it happens that there is war, you can move the parties to a ceasefire, and then after the ceasefire, peace negotiations can begin. What we need, therefore, is not to fantasize about what a just peace would be, but to stop the mutual killings. The first step is that there should be a ceasefire. If there is a ceasefire, a time and space will emerge in which one can begin to discuss how to make the ceasefire permanent and how peace can emerge from the ceasefire. I would suggest this approach to you. Speculations about just peace do not bring us closer to a ceasefire, but rather take us further away from it.

I also do not quite understand why several of you constantly advocate for the influx of guest workers in the hundreds of thousands to Hungary. Why would we need that? In Hungary, there is a clear rule, which I believe is a good rule and must be adhered to. The rule states that you can only bring in as many guest workers to Hungary as there are unfilled job positions. Why do you want to change this? 500 thousand and these numbers are swirling around here. What nonsense is that?! What nonsense is that! We should uphold the validity of the law that currently exists in Hungary, according to which we can only grant permission to as many guest workers to come to Hungary as there are unfilled job positions, because Hungary belongs to Hungarians, and Hungarian jobs are primarily for Hungarians. Why do you want to change that? That is a good rule!

Allow me to ask the Jobbik faction leader, since he has already taken a stance against migration, whether it could be achieved that your party chairman, who is a Member of the European Parliament, does not vote in Brussels for proposals that support migrants. That would help Hungary a lot!

Dear fellow member Ungár!

You do not understand in what sense Hungary is a climate champion. In the sense that this dilemma must be overcome by almost every country striving for development, that it wants to grow while reducing its emissions, and that results in a ratio, and based on this, one can know who is capable and who is not. This is not usually measured in historical perspectives. Since 1990, Hungary has been able to do this. Growth is significant, and at the same time, emissions are lower than they were before 1990. As far as I remember – I hope I am not mistaken – there were 21 such countries in the past period, and we are among them. We are among the best. Why are we not proud that Hungary is solving this difficult dilemma well and that we belong to the club of climate champions?

Can a national consensus be achieved in foreign policy, but especially in geostrategic matters? That is very difficult! Very difficult, Mr. Member! The reason for this is that in the Western world at this moment, foreign policy has been placed on an ideological basis. You speak of the need to represent values in foreign policy. This makes things extremely difficult, because regarding values, we are generally not of the same opinion, which is why we are in different parties. If I base foreign policy on a values basis, I make unity impossible from the outset. Creating unity in foreign policy is possible on the basis of interests; we assess the mutual national interests and try to act together based on that. We see if we agree – although we are parties representing different values – we see if we think the same about the Hungarian national interest, whether harmony can be created – that cannot be ruled out – and then we will represent that on the basis of interests. But it will not work on a principled basis. If we look at European foreign policy, we will see that it appears everywhere with the claim that in all foreign relations – that is why we also want an independent foreign policy – it pursues an ideologized foreign policy. Today, European values revolve around three things: The war, which must be supported because it is morally right in their opinion, about gender, as it supposedly leads to freedom, and about migration, because for some reason they believe the world would be better if people could move freely from different corners of the world. These are the three European values today. They build European foreign policy on this. How will we reach an agreement on this? We do not agree! We stand on the side of peace regarding the war, instead of supporting gender, we support the traditional family model, and in our view, migration is not good, but bad, and it is good if everyone finds their happiness in the place that dear God has determined as their own homeland. We will not be able to form a consensus! I am not saying that we should not try, because the pursuit of consensus, even if it may remain unsuccessful, already improves the spirit of cooperation, and that is overall good for the country. So I, for my part, do not want to reject the proposal, although I see the difficulties of the government and the opposition, the left parties trying to reach a consensus in foreign policy and geostrategic matters.

Regarding what the Member said about the war, I can only note that war and its outcome are not a wish concert, but a matter of strength. The claim that it is realistic for Russia to reach the eastern border of Hungary with military force must be labeled as foolishness; not just a mistake, because that is stupidity. Let us look at the numbers, the ratios, and the strength! Russia is currently waging an obviously difficult war against Ukraine. How could it defeat NATO? How could Russia reach NATO's borders? It will not get there in any way, my dear fellow member! You can be sure that there is no script that would lead to Hungary and Russia having a common border again. That will not happen! They will not get this far! One does not need to reckon with this script, as we are members of NATO, and NATO is much stronger than that this development would occur. And this applies not only to the Hungarian border but also to Poland and Slovakia. The danger that Russia would even approach our borders is not a realistic assumption. The foreign policy based on that is built on a false axiom, on a false hypothesis.

Ladies and gentlemen!

The matter of the film in Sweden does not excite us, because art is such that one can freely choose its subject and also the opinion about it. We are not the least bit interested in what films are made in Sweden and how that concerns Hungary. That is indifferent to us. What concerns us is what is taught to Swedish children about Hungary in schools. Well, that interests us! That is not a question of freedom of artistic creation, but of state policy. If what we see in that film about Hungary is taught in a state school, in a state school system, then that is a matter that elevates the problem to the level of state policy, international policy, and we will not accept that. This also raises the question of whether anything is pressing us regarding Sweden's NATO membership. I see not a single such circumstance. Sweden's security is not threatened by anything. Nothing threatens it! We have no military connections to Sweden for which we would need to be on guard. The maintenance of the Gripen is an interesting question, but the situation is that at least ten other offers are on the table. It should not be a consideration for Hungary in a political decision from whom we buy something! Let us not make jokes!

Ladies and gentlemen!

The situation is that Sweden's security is not threatened by anything, the Swedish-Hungarian relations do not possess a single strategic element that would be violated if Hungary demands respect from Sweden and only then is ready to make a supportive decision. The analogy to Finland is, in my opinion, incorrect, as the Finns did not wait a single minute for their NATO membership because of Hungary. This claim would be true if Hungary had been the last country to ratify Finland's NATO membership. But that did not happen! We were not the last, therefore it shows a lack of knowledge if this question is raised in any context, if I may use that term again.

It is good that we are talking about this now, even though it may not be the most important question whether it is right to base foreign policy on an emotional foundation – said the honorable representative – and to relate to a country based on whether we love it or not or its ruling party. That is not right! Therefore, I do not recommend a foreign policy that would want to build Hungarian foreign policy on the love established for the respective ruling party. Thus, Hungarian foreign policy never puts anything on just one color, as you said, and especially not on red, but it is certain that there are countries that have governments that constantly attack Hungary and that do not only attack Hungarians – let’s speak plainly! – but give you money so that you can come to power and not us. Who has put everything on one color here? Not those who gave the money? Shouldn’t this question be asked of the Americans? We cooperate with everyone, while one American political party, taking advantage of the opportunity, has given you money to overthrow us. Who has put something on a color here? So, should we provide explanations in American-Hungarian relations? Really? Are we joking?

Ladies and gentlemen!

The situation is that Hungary is ready to cooperate with everyone. The essence of foreign policy is that a country gathers friends and not enemies, goodwill and support; this is what we must strive for, and Hungarian foreign policy is also ready to cooperate with the respective American administration, regardless of what party colors it may have otherwise.

The question of data release also came up. I can tell you that we do not release any data; the laws in Hungary are clear, and they do not allow this for the government.

Demography. Dear Madam Representative, you are knocking on the right door with me. I do not consider your criticism regarding the government to be fair in that the government would not mobilize all available resources in the interest of supporting families. The numbers I work with say that we spend 5.5 percent of our gross domestic product on family support, which is 2,400 billion forints more than it was during the Gyurcsány era, and that is the highest in the European Union. So, criticizing Hungary in a matter where we perform the best in the European Union does not seem fair to me. It may be that more should be spent, yes, I also believe you are right that more is needed, but not for the reason you mention, that we have done nothing – that is unfair – but because the matter is a serious one, the challenge is great, and more must be spent for this purpose. I also agree that the problem should be sought deeper; to elaborate or debate this perhaps in the context of the speeches before the agenda is not a rational undertaking, but the question of whether one wants to have children is fundamentally not a question of the wallet or money, but fundamentally a question of the heart. What we can do – we cannot move hearts; what we can do is to ensure that there is no existential obstacle in front of those whose hearts are moved and who would like to have children that would deter them from this desire. That is what we can do; I believe we cannot do more. It is also not fair of you, Madam Representative, to claim that we have ended the systems for supporting families. That does not exist! There is no such situation! There will not be one… No! No, no, no, the support for renovating apartments has nothing to do with family support, but the support for creating homes very much does. There will not be a moment when the benefit for creating homes will be stopped and not replaced by some other form of support. Because by the end of the year, this system will end, and at the beginning of the next year, we will announce another one. We will not only maintain the benefit for creating homes in the village, but we will also increase its amount, and the urban one, for which interest has waned, we could also maintain, but in my opinion, that is not a rational proposal on your part, as we see that in the cities, the form of support for the benefit of creating homes is no longer sufficient; instead of maintaining it, a new thing must be started there, and we will also start that in January. So, what you say, that something has been lost and nothing else has taken its place, does not correspond to reality. Such a situation will not exist. And perhaps we can also agree that family policy must fundamentally be based on supporting mothers; the government is happy to accept any of your proposals in this regard.

I do not agree with my fellow representative Bertalan Tóth, who would claim that all that we have talked about so far is not good news for the Hungarian people. In my opinion, it is good news that it has been possible to protect every job. So, the very difficult period of the past, COVID and then the war, did not lead to a decrease in the number of people working in Hungary; on the contrary: the number of working people has increased even despite the crisis, even in the last months, meaning that it was possible to protect jobs. Inflation was high, but it is possible to protect retirees as well, because the Minister of Finance was able to align the state budget in such a way that we can pay retirees the pension increases they are entitled to by law. We have been able to do this so far, and we will also be able to do this in November to provide the missing amount to them in accordance with the laws. That we have been able to protect pensions under such conditions is, in my opinion, good news and a serious achievement. I can also name a European country where, with 17 percent inflation, pensions were raised by 2 percent; there are more than one country where the inflation situation has been resolved to the detriment of retirees, but Hungary does not want to resolve the inflation situation at the expense of retirees – that is what you did, my dear fellow representative, you resolved it by taking away a monthly pension. You did that! We did not do that; we do not want to do that either, which is why it is good news for retirees that we do not have a Gyurcsány era now, and therefore we will give retirees the amount that is necessary for their lives at this inflation. And in a similar way, we are fighting for wages to show at least as many percentage points of increase by the end of the year as inflation has been – we will see if this succeeds. We very much hope that by the end of the year it will turn out that real wages have not decreased year-on-year. That is very difficult, and it is also not certain whether it will succeed, but we are doing everything in the interest of making it so, and now I can already tell you with certainty, excuse me, with a high probability I can tell you that in 2024, according to our plans, it will also happen that wages will rise more than inflation. So, there will be a real wage increase again in 2024, and, we hope, also in 2025.

I do not want to offend my fellow representative Bertalan Tóth, but I feel some kind of spiritual defect in your wishing for Hungary not to receive the resources from the European Union. Do you think that is normal? So, that according to the laws, a certain amount is due to us from the European Union, it is due to Hungarians, it cannot be denied to them, it is due to them, and for political reasons, they only give it very reluctantly, through all possible hard negotiations, if they give it at all, and you are happy about that. Is that good? In my opinion, that is not a normal thing. That is distinctly a spiritual defect. How can someone root against their own country? I suggest that you talk to your representatives who sit out there in the European Parliament and regularly express themselves on this issue, and tell them to say in Brussels that they should not give support to Hungary; get them to do that – after all, they are Hungarians… In this matter, since my fellow representative Péter Ungár has already spoken about it, that it would be good to create some consensus on this issue… Is it being stolen? What? The teachers will steal the money that should be given to the teachers from Brussels… Then at least… Then at least support this! It should not be difficult for you; you should at least support the salaries of Hungarian teachers, ladies and gentlemen!

I inform my fellow representatives that there is a rule that does not allow any investment in Hungary to receive greater support than the resulting state revenues will be. All the horror stories about what you say, that the Hungarian state supports investments more than what comes back from them – that is simply a mistake! Legislation excludes that, and this legislation was not only valid but is still valid now, so you can be sure that in Hungary, every support for an investment pays off for Hungary.

This brings us to the question of the automotive industry. Today, about 140,000 people work directly in the automotive industry in Hungary. According to international standards, this number is multiplied by four to determine how many families indirectly live off the automotive industry. By rough estimates, we can talk about 500,000 people. So today, 500,000 people in Hungary earn their daily bread in a field related to the automotive industry for their families. Since the European Union has decided that the factories that currently produce in Hungary will not be allowed to produce after 2035, at least not such cars, there are two options: one is to close them; they will close these businesses. Let’s imagine Győr without Audi: closed! In Kecskemét: no Mercedes factory. The BMW factory operates for only ten years, and then it’s over. Just imagine that! The only way to avoid this is to carry out a technological change in these businesses and to settle an industry next to them that will keep these factories operational even after 2035. If there is a battery factory next to the car factory, there will be work in the car factory. If there isn’t, it will be closed. What you say, those who argue against battery factories, you are actually arguing for the closure of today’s Hungarian industrial vehicle manufacturing capacity. Are you aware of what you are saying? I recommend that you reconsider this; we should discuss it. I am convinced that it is in Hungary’s interest, while adhering to the strictest environmental regulations, to provide reliable, measured, calm answers to the fears of the population and to save those capacities in manufacturing where people today earn their daily bread. That is possible; we are working on it, and I ask you not to hinder this but rather to support it. As is done by the opposition in all Western European countries. It is also an absurd thing that in Hungary, the groups that consider themselves green attack the battery factories. Do you know what the motto of the Greens in Germany is? Batteries are a piece of the future. Those are your comrades! Study what is happening there!

Ladies and gentlemen!

And this question of water demand also comes up all the time. I want you to know that Hungary exports more water than water flows into the country. This means we have a surplus that we can capture; if we want and if it is necessary, we can bring this amount of water through the Hungarian sewage system anywhere – if it is necessary! Hungary is not suffering from any water shortage today, and if the demand increases, we are able to meet that demand. That is a very simple mathematical question. The flow rate of the Danube brings more water in five seconds than the annual demand of a battery factory. Let’s not be laughed at! So, I want to tell you that neither the aspects of environmental protection nor the water industry nor the jobs support the position that we should not settle the most modern technology of Europe in Hungary.

Ladies and gentlemen!

In conclusion, I would also like to respond to my fellow representative Gelencsér, but I had the impression that his speech was nothing more than a hopeless struggle with meaning. I cannot make anything of that, but I wish him luck.