Meeting of the International Discussion Club "Valdai"

Russia Vladimir Putin · President of Russia

22 October 2015 · Meeting of the International Discussion Club Valdai

Context
Putin addressed the Valdai International Discussion Club annual meeting in October 2015, speaking on war, peace, and global security challenges.
Main themes
War and peace, global security, balance of power, unilateral dominance, international law, nuclear weapons and arms race, geopolitical competition, missile defense and ABM Treaty, historical lessons of peacekeeping, non-proliferation, Russia's foreign policy perspective
Duration
~170 min
99th percentile
Words
20,402
99th percentile
Sentences
985
99th percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
11.0
32nd percentile
Syntax
3.02
51st percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from Russian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 67%63%
  • Ceremonial 12%11%
  • Economic 9%8%
  • Institutional 8%7%
  • Social 5%4%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

985 sentences in 250 paragraphs

Dear colleagues, friends! Ladies and gentlemen!

Allow me to welcome you to the next meeting of the Valdai International Discussion Club.

Indeed, for more than ten years now, discussions on the most pressing issues have been held on this platform, exploring the paths and prospects for the development of Russia and the entire world. And of course, the composition of participants changes, but there is, so to speak, a core of this discussion platform – we have already turned into what I believe is an environment that understands each other.

Here, an open discussion is conducted; this is an open intellectual platform for the exchange of opinions, assessments, and forecasts, which are very important for us in Russia. I would like to thank all Russian and foreign politicians, experts, public figures, and journalists who participate in the work of this club.

This year, our discussion is focused on the issues of war and peace. This topic has undoubtedly concerned humanity throughout history. Even in ancient times, debates were held about the nature and causes of conflicts, about the just and unjust use of force, about whether wars will always accompany the development of civilization, alternating only with truces, or whether a time will come when disputes and contradictions will be resolved without war.

Here, of course, we recall our great writer Leo Tolstoy. In his great novel "War and Peace," he called war an event contrary to human reason and all human nature, while considering peace a blessing for people.

Indeed, peace and peaceful life have been and remain the ideal of humanity. Statesmen, philosophers, and lawyers have repeatedly proposed models for peaceful interaction among powers. Various alliances and coalitions proclaimed their goal to ensure a stable, as they once said, "eternal" peace. The problem, however, is that the way out of accumulated contradictions has often been sought through war. And war itself served as a means of establishing new, post-war hierarchies in the world.

At the same time, peace as a state of world politics has never been stable and did not arise by itself. Peaceful periods – both in European and world history – have always been based on the consolidation and maintenance of the established balance of power. This was the case in the 17th century, during the time of the Peace of Westphalia, which ended the Thirty Years' War. And in the 19th century, during the era of the Congress of Vienna. And 70 years ago in Yalta, when the victors of Nazism made decisions about the creation of the United Nations and the principles of state relations.

With the advent of nuclear weapons, it became clear that there could be no winner in a global conflict. The outcome could only be one – guaranteed mutual destruction. It turned out that man, in attempts to create ever more destructive weapons, made great wars meaningless.

By the way, the generation of world leaders of the 1950s, 1960s, 1970s, and even 1980s indeed treated the use of military force as an exceptional measure. And in this regard, they acted responsibly, weighing all circumstances and possible consequences.

The end of the "Cold War" put an end to ideological confrontation, but the basis for disputes and geopolitical contradictions did not disappear at all. All states always have and will have their own, sometimes divergent, interests. And the development of world history has always been accompanied by competition among powers and their alliances. And, in my opinion, this is absolutely natural.

The main thing is that such competition is built within the framework of certain political, legal, and moral norms and rules. Otherwise, rivalry and clashes of interests are fraught with acute crises and dramatic breakdowns.

We have seen this many times in the past. And today, unfortunately, we are once again facing similar situations. Attempts to promote a model of unilateral dominance by any means – I have spoken about this many times – have led to the destabilization of international law and global regulation systems, and therefore, there is a threat that competition – political, economic, military – may become uncontrollable.

What, for example, could such uncontrollable competition mean for the sphere of international security? It is the increase in the number of local conflicts, especially in "border" regions where the interests of major powers or blocs collide. It is also the probable decline of the non-proliferation system of weapons of mass destruction (which I consider extremely dangerous) and, as a result, a new round of the arms race.

The concept of a so-called first disarming strike has already emerged, including the use of high-precision non-nuclear means of long range, comparable in effect to nuclear weapons.

Under the pretext of a missile-nuclear threat from Iran, as we know, the fundamental basis of modern international security – the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty – has been destroyed. The United States unilaterally withdrew from it. Today, by the way, the Iranian nuclear problem has been resolved; there has been no threat from Iran, as we said, and there is none. The reason that seemingly prompted our American partners to build a missile defense system has disappeared. And we would have the right to expect that work on the development of U.S. missile defense would cease. But what is actually happening? Nothing of the sort is happening; on the contrary, everything continues.

Recently, the first tests of U.S. missile defense in Europe were conducted. What does this mean? It means that we were right when we argued with our American partners. We, and indeed the whole world, were once again misled. To put it simply – we were deceived. The issue is not about a hypothetical Iranian nuclear threat, which has never existed. The issue is about an attempt to destroy the strategic balance, to change the balance of power in their favor in such a way as to not only dominate but to have the ability to dictate their will to everyone: both their geopolitical competitors and, I believe, their allies. This is an extremely dangerous scenario for the development of events, harmful to all, including, in my opinion, the United States themselves.

The deterrent factor of nuclear weapons has begun to devalue. Some may even have the illusion that in a world conflict, real victory for one side is again achievable – without irreversible, unacceptable, as specialists say, consequences for the winner, if there is a winner at all.

Over the past quarter-century, the threshold for the use of force has clearly decreased. The anti-war immunity acquired after two world wars, which existed literally on a psychological, subconscious level, has begun to weaken. The very perception of war has changed: for viewers in front of their television screens, it has turned into a spectacular media image, as if during military actions, people do not die, do not suffer, cities and entire states are not destroyed.

Unfortunately, military terminology is now heard in practically all spheres of life. Thus, the reality of today's global economy is trade and sanctions wars; this has already become a cliché in the media. Moreover, sanctions are used, among other things, as a tool of unfair competition to squeeze out or completely "throw out" competitors from markets. As an example, I will cite the real epidemic of fines imposed on European companies by the United States. Fabricated pretexts are used, and those who dared to violate unilateral American sanctions are severely punished.

You know, this may not be a Russian matter, but we have a discussion club here, so I will still allow myself to ask: is this how allies are treated? No, this is how vassals who dared to act on their own are treated – they are punished for bad behavior.

Just last year, a fine of almost 9 billion dollars was imposed on one French bank – 8.9, I believe. Toyota paid 1.2 billion dollars, and the German Commerzbank signed an agreement to pay 1.7 billion dollars to the American budget, and so on.

We also see how the process of creating opaque economic blocs is unfolding, and the process of forming such structures is going on almost according to all the rules of conspiracy. The task is clear – to reformat the world economy in such a way as to extract even greater rent from their dominance and the spread of their standards of economic, trade, and technological regulation.

The formation of economic blocs by imposing their conditions on the strongest players will certainly not make the world safer, but will only lay mines of delayed action, the ground for future conflicts. After all, the World Trade Organization was once created. Yes, discussions there are difficult, yes, the Doha Round of negotiations may have reached a deadlock, but we must still seek exits and compromises, because only compromises can create a long-term system of relations in any sphere, including the economy. And if we simply pretend that the concerns of some countries, participants in international economic communication, are uninteresting, that they can somehow be bypassed, then these contradictions will not disappear anywhere; no one will resolve them, they will remain, and therefore – will manifest themselves at some point.

You know, we have a different approach. In the course of forming the Eurasian Economic Union, we are trying to build relationships with our partners, including establishing joint work within the framework of the Chinese initiative "Silk Road." We actively and on an absolutely equal basis work within BRICS, APEC, and the G20.

The global information space is also today shaken by wars, so to speak. An aggressively imposed "only correct" point of view and interpretation of events is being forced, certain facts are distorted or concealed. We have all become accustomed to the labeling and the creation of an enemy image.

The authorities of countries that, it would seem, have always appealed to the values of freedom of speech and the free dissemination of information (how often we heard about this in the past!), are now trying to hinder the dissemination of objective information and declare any other point of view, different from their own, hostile propaganda that must be fought against, and clearly by undemocratic means.

Unfortunately, the words "war," "conflict" are increasingly used when talking about the relationships between people of different cultures, religions, and nationalities. Today, hundreds of thousands of migrants are trying to integrate into another society, often without a profession, not knowing the language, traditions, or culture of the countries to which they are relocating. And the indigenous people, undoubtedly – and we must speak directly about this, there is no need to gloss over anything – the indigenous people express irritation about the foreign dominance, about the deterioration of the crime situation, about the money that is spent on refugees from the budgets of the respective countries.

Of course, many people, the majority of people sympathize with refugees and want to help them. The question is how to do this without infringing on the interests of the indigenous people of the countries to which the refugees are relocating. And a shock, mass, uncontrolled clash of different ways of life can lead to and is already leading to the rise of nationalism and intolerance, to the emergence of a permanent conflict in society.

Dear colleagues, let us be realistic: military force, of course, remains and will undoubtedly be for a long time an instrument of international politics. Whether this is good or bad, it is a fact of life. The question is different: will it be used only when all other means are exhausted? When it is necessary to confront common threats, such as terrorism, and according to the known rules set out in international law? Or will fists be used at any occasion, sometimes just to remind the world who is the master in the house, without thinking about the legitimacy of the use of force and the consequences of the use of force, not solving problems, but only multiplying them?

We see what is happening today in the Middle East. For decades, and sometimes perhaps for centuries, interethnic, religious, and political contradictions, acute social problems have accumulated here. In short, a volatile mixture has been growing, and attempts to roughly restructure the region from the outside have become the match that led to a real explosion, to the destruction of statehood, a surge of terrorism, and ultimately to an increase in risks for the entire world.

The terrorist organization known as the "Islamic State" has taken control of vast territories. How did it manage to do this? Just think: in the event of the capture of Damascus or Baghdad, terrorist gangs could gain the status of almost official authority, a foothold for global expansion would be created. Does anyone think about this or not? The entire international community must finally understand what we are dealing with. Essentially, we are facing an enemy of civilization, humanity, and world culture, which carries an ideology of hatred and barbarism, trampling on morality, the values of world religions, including Islam, and compromising it.

And there is no need to play with words, to divide terrorists into moderate and immoderate. I would like to understand what the difference is. Probably, according to some specialists, it is that moderate bandits, so to speak, behead people in a moderate number or in a gentle manner.

In essence, we are now witnessing a real knot of terrorist groups. Yes, sometimes the militants of the "Islamic State," "Jabhat al-Nusra," and other various heirs and fragments of "Al-Qaeda" even fight each other, but they fight for money, for the division of money, for sources of income, for territory to feed on; that is what they fight for. They do not fight for ideological reasons, and their essence and methods are the same: terror, murder, turning people into a beaten, frightened, obedient mass.

In recent years, the situation has worsened, the infrastructure of terrorists has expanded, the number of militants has increased, and the weapons that were transferred to the so-called "moderate opposition," "moderate oppositionists," inevitably ended up in the hands of terrorist organizations. I will go further; sometimes entire gangs switched sides, so to speak, "to the music and with the orchestra."

Why have the efforts, let’s say, of our American partners and their allies in the fight against the Islamic State not yielded clear results? It is obvious that the issue is not a lack of military equipment or potential. Undoubtedly, the United States possesses a vast, the largest military potential in the world; it is just always difficult to play a double game. To declare a fight against terrorists while simultaneously trying to use some of them to position pieces on the Middle Eastern chessboard in what seems to be their own interests.

It is impossible to achieve success against terrorism in general if part of the terrorists is used as a battering ram to overthrow undesirable regimes. There is no escaping these terrorists, and it is only an illusion that it will be possible to deal with them later, to remove them from power, or to somehow negotiate. The best example of this is the situation in Libya.

Let us hope that the new government will manage to stabilize the situation, but that is not yet a fact, although, of course, we must assist in stabilization.

We understand well that the militants fighting in the Middle East pose a threat to everyone, including us, to Russia. In our country, we know what terrorist aggression is, we know what the bandits did in the North Caucasus. We remember the bloody terrorist acts in Budyonnovsk, in Moscow, in Beslan, in Volgograd, in other cities of Russia. Russia has always fought against terrorism in all its manifestations and has consistently advocated for a real unification of the efforts of the world community in confronting this evil. This is precisely what dictated our proposal to create a broad anti-terrorist coalition, which was recently voiced in my speech at the United Nations.

After the appeal from the official authorities of Syria for support, we made the decision to begin a Russian military operation in that country. I want to emphasize once again: it is completely legitimate, its sole purpose is to contribute to the establishment of peace. And I am confident that the actions of the Russian military will have the necessary positive impact on the situation, helping the official authorities create conditions for subsequent actions in the area of political settlement, to deliver preemptive strikes against terrorists who threaten our country, Russia. Thus helping all countries and peoples who are undoubtedly in danger if these terrorists return to their homes.

What, in our opinion, needs to be done to support long-term settlement in the region, its social, economic, and political revival? First of all, to liberate the territories of Syria and Iraq from terrorists and not allow them to shift their activities to other regions. And for this, it is necessary to unite all forces: the regular armies of Iraq and Syria, Kurdish militia units, various opposition groups ready to genuinely contribute to the defeat of terrorists, and to coordinate the actions of regional and extra-regional countries opposing terrorism. At the same time, joint anti-terrorist activities must, of course, be based on international law.

Second. It is obvious that a military victory over the militants alone will not solve all problems, but it will create conditions for the main thing – for the start of a political process involving all healthy, patriotically minded forces of Syrian society. It is the Syrians who must determine their fate with the exclusively correct, respectful assistance of the international community, and not under external pressure through ultimatums, blackmail, and threats.

The collapse of official authority in Syria, for example, only mobilizes terrorists. Now it is necessary not to destabilize but to revive and strengthen state institutions in conflict zones.

I want to remind you that the Middle East has often been the arena of clashes between different empires and powers throughout its history. They redrew borders and the political structure of the region to suit themselves, based on their own interests. And the consequences were not always pleasant and good for the people living there. In fact, they were usually not even asked. The last to find out what was happening in their own countries were precisely the people who lived in the Middle East.

Of course, the question arises: is it not time for the international community to coordinate all its actions with those people who live in these territories? I think it is long overdue; we need to treat these people, just like all others, with respect.

It is of fundamental importance to involve Muslim clergy, leaders of Islam, and heads of Muslim states in the political settlement process. We rely on their consolidated position and assistance, on their moral authority. It is very important to protect people, especially the youth, from the destructive influence of the ideology of terrorists who try to use them as cannon fodder, nothing more. It is necessary to clearly draw a line between true Islam, whose values are peace, family, good deeds, helping others, respect for traditions, and the lies, hatred that militants sow while hiding behind Islam.

Fourth. We need to work out "road maps" for the economic and social revival of the region, for the reconstruction of basic infrastructure, housing, hospitals, and schools. Only such constructive work on the ground after the elimination of terrorism and political settlement can stop the huge flow of refugees to European countries and return home those who have already left.

It is clear that Syria will require massive financial, economic, and humanitarian assistance to heal the wounds of war. We need to determine the format within which we could carry out this work with the involvement of donor countries and international financial institutions. Currently, the problems of Syria are being discussed at the UN, other international organizations, and within the framework of intergovernmental relations. Yes, so far it has not always been possible to achieve understanding; it is painfully difficult to abandon unfulfilled expectations and unfulfilled calculations; nevertheless, there is progress.

We see that within the framework of the anti-terrorist operation, contacts between military departments are gradually being established, although not as actively and quickly as we would like. A significant step has been the coordination of the Russian-American document on ensuring the safety of military aircraft of the two countries over Syria.

We are also close to starting to exchange information with our Western colleagues about the positions and movements of militants. All of this, of course, are steps in the right direction. The main thing is to perceive each other as allies in the common struggle, to behave honestly and openly. Only in this way can we guarantee victory over terrorists.

Syria, despite the dramatic nature of the current situation, can become a model for partnership in the name of common interests, for solving problems that affect everyone, for developing an effective risk management system. We had such a chance after the end of the Cold War. Unfortunately, we did not take advantage of it. Such an opportunity also existed in the early 2000s when Russia and the United States, along with several other countries, faced terrorist aggression. Unfortunately, we also failed to maintain the good dynamics of cooperation then. I will not return to why we could not do this. It seems to me that everyone knows that already. Now it is important to draw the right lessons from what happened in the past and move forward.

I am confident that the experience we have accumulated and the current situation will finally allow us to make the right choice – a choice in favor of cooperation, mutual respect, and trust, a choice in favor of peace.

Thank you very much for your attention.

R. Legvold: Mr. President, thank you very much for sharing your thoughts, in addition to those you expressed at the UN, especially in the context of war and peace. I know that many are interested in this topic, and many will ask you questions about the last part, especially regarding events in the Islamic south and in Syria.

I would like to begin by emphasizing what you started with, namely how war, in various senses and forms, constantly intrudes into the mentality of the media, politics, and the public. A separate issue was raised that has been ignored since the end of the Cold War – the issue of nuclear weapons of states that already possess them. We talk about the problem of the proliferation of nuclear weapons, weapons of mass destruction, but we know that a very complex process is taking place among states that possess nuclear weapons.

In the context of the deteriorating situation after 1991 and 2000, as you mentioned, the tragedy is that the two countries that still possess 92 percent of such weapons must show leadership if we want not only to preserve the regime established over the last few decades but also to take the next steps. And it is these countries that must demonstrate such leadership. What else needs to be contemplated in the current circumstances? That these two countries either cannot or do not want to show this leadership.

Today, there are also very respected leaders present on this stage. And I would like to invite the speaker of the Iranian parliament, Mr. Ali Larijani, to speak first. The floor is yours.

A. Larijani: In the name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful!

Dear Mr. Putin! Esteemed members of the presidium! Honorable attendees, participants, ladies and gentlemen!

First of all, I would like to express my satisfaction at being present at this forum among researchers in the field of foreign policy. I hope that this meeting, which is being held in a beautiful place, will achieve its goals.

I will speak about a region that begins in countries like Afghanistan and Pakistan and includes the states of the Middle East and North Africa. What unites all these countries is a crisis-laden existence in conditions of terrorism, wars, and political instability.

Although the problem of terrorism is of an international nature, practically all countries are involved in this issue in one way or another, and today thousands of Americans and Europeans are also members of terrorist groups such as ISIS. Nevertheless, the center of gravity of the problem of terrorism lies precisely in the mentioned region. In recent years, this region has witnessed phenomena such as wars, the occupation of countries, and continuous political turmoil, which could not fail to affect the development of terrorism. In general, it can be stated that this region has undergone complete disorganization in security matters in recent years. What are the roots, the causes of this disorganization?

First. From the perspective of the distribution of international forces after the end of the bipolar world and the subsequent failure of the unipolar world order, practically all countries that were tied to this polarization of world powers found themselves in a suspended state. Some of them, in search of opportunities to enhance their influence or role, resorted to extremism. Some, even very small countries, with the help of money and quite crude political behavior, practically contributed to the creation of tension in the region. In general, it can be said that with the end of the period of polarization of the world, the discipline that existed in the past regarding security, although erroneous, was destroyed without any alternative.

Second. Dictatorial governments, which were often dependent on the United States and Western powers and remained in the citadels of power for a long time, faced the phenomenon of political consciousness of the people, especially among the youth, with the growth of science and education and the expansion of communication opportunities. And today’s demands of the youth in these countries are no longer limited to the demand for water, bread, and work, but increasingly touch on issues of political and religious ideals, participation in determining their own fate. The resistance of these governments to such phenomena has become a factor contributing to the departure of youth resistance from the arena of active actions and the entrapment of youth by terrorist groups.

Third. The occupation of countries, which has occurred in Afghanistan and Iraq over the last two decades, as well as the creation of chaos in countries like Syria, has in fact become the reason for the involvement of many young people in terrorist groups. This fact deserves attention from the perspective of social psychology, when people in any country experience a sense of contempt for themselves because they are under the domination of soldiers from a foreign state, especially if these soldiers behave rudely and foolishly. It is quite natural that the younger generation will not tolerate this and will seek a way to resist the occupiers. And in this state, youth becomes an excellent target for recruitment by terrorists.

An illustration of the correctness of this view is the way terrorist movements were created in Afghanistan and Iraq. This is why wars and occupations always create a fertile ground for the activation or emergence of terrorist movements. A similar phenomenon was observed during the war in Yemen when terrorists spread their influence to the southern regions of that country.

Fourth. The tactical and instrumental approach of major powers to the problem of terrorism is a significant strategic mistake made by these powers in recent decades. In the history of the formation and activities of most terrorist movements, the trace of the special services of some major states is noticeable. Even in the current conditions, when the leaders of countries generally point to the danger of terrorism, it is absolutely clear that in the Syrian crisis, major powers, disguising terrorists as moderate opposition, supply them with weapons and other capabilities. They believe that they will be able to deal with the terrorists after using them for their own interests. Such views have become the main problem leading to the development of terrorism. Meanwhile, the terrorists themselves make the best use of these immature perceptions. It is quite clear that when terrorist movements gain strength, they will pursue their own interests, and it will be difficult to fight them. In fact, neither the occupation of Afghanistan nor the occupation of Iraq eliminated the terrorists, and, unfortunately, this story will continue.

Fifth. Misjudgment of terrorism and incorrect approaches are another reason for the spread of terrorism in the region. For example, the United States government and some of its allies have stated that they seek to create and strengthen a moderate opposition in Syria, and for these purposes, they have conducted military training for several hundred individuals, equipped them, armed them, and sent them to the battlefield. According to a report from U.S. military commanders presented to Congress, these several hundred individuals, with their weapons, vehicles, and military equipment, joined terrorist groups. The latest case is the joining of the group "Jabhat al-Nusra," with only five or six individuals remaining from all these people.

My question is: could the military intelligence of the coalition not identify these individuals? Or do terrorist groups and some countries that provide them with financial assistance exploit immature policies and pass off terrorists and radicals as moderates? In this situation, how does the U.S. government intend to create a moderate opposition and, according to its own statements, hand Syria over to the moderate opposition? Today, the countries that are part of the coalition cannot claim that they are helping the moderate opposition because it is absolutely clear that they lack the ability to distinguish moderates from terrorists. If it were up to them, they could hand over all of Syria to terrorists and then say, yes, we made a mistake, just like the one we made in Libya.

So what should be done? The most important pillar of regional security is the responsible role of regional states. With all the peculiarities of the region, increasing the awareness of the people and achieving a model of sustainable security is only possible with the active participation of regional powers. Of course, major powers can assist in this matter, but under current conditions, taking into account the situation in the countries, their internal circumstances, and the unfounded notions that have taken root in some minds, the possibility of creating an integration aimed at achieving sustainable security seems unlikely.

Therefore, attention must be paid to two important factors that can steer the region towards security. First. There are countries in the region that have a real understanding of everything that is happening and demonstrate the will to fight terrorism. Of course, this topic has gradation; not everyone carries the same weight.

The Islamic Republic of Iran has always condemned the radical behavior of terrorists, has fought them seriously, and has paid a high price for it. Some other countries that constantly consult with Iran on both Arab and other issues are also concerned and interested in providing assistance. Although, in reality, they have not made significant progress on this issue, except for political statements. But if they make greater use of their support potential, they will be able to strengthen their presence on this stage.

Second. Responsible world powers can turn the necessary support for the fight against terrorism into a more tangible reality through their consultations and cooperation with the states of the region. Meanwhile, the role of Russia, followed by China and the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, remains enormous. The role of these major states is to awaken some other countries that also wish to help in this matter. This could serve as an initial basis for anti-terrorist activities.

From this perspective, we view Russia's presence in the region, occurring at the request of the Syrian government, as timely and conscious. And, unlike the propaganda activities of the "paper" coalition against terrorism led by the United States, which has achieved nothing substantial in the past year – terrorists have become even more rampant – Russia's actions, at the same time, have become a serious warning for terrorists and have influenced the very essence of the problem, rather than its propagandistic image.

Continuing this line and integrating other responsible powers into it could provide serious assistance in controlling security threats.

Dear participants! Given the ideological basis of terrorists, we should not lightly assume that the fight against terrorism can be concluded in a short time. The fact is that terrorists have grown and been educated in schools that have received investments for years. And although this is not characteristic of the Islamic tradition and none of the Islamic schools: neither Hanbalis, nor Shafi'is, nor Malikis, nor Hanafis, nor Shiites, Sufis, or Zaidis approve of the actions of terrorists, nevertheless, new sects are being created that, although few in number, have made fanaticism, radicalism, and heresy the currency of their teachings through financial support and consider it necessary to kill other people. These sects send their people to most countries to propagate their teachings and create social unrest. Social unrest helps attract people to these groups.

On the other hand, these movements are supported by large financial resources, despite the fact that leaders of Islamic schools, theologians from Al-Azhar University, which is the main university for Sunnis, as well as leaders of Zaidis, Shiites, and Sufis consider their theories a distortion of Islamic teachings. Therefore, in addition to fighting terrorists on the battlefield, as well as in political and diplomatic spheres, it is necessary to consciously pay attention to the cultural roots of these movements that underlie all these actions. It is essential to reach a common understanding of these roots and choose an adequate cultural direction in this struggle.

Another important point is that such a struggle can place states in positions that correspond to new threats. The main question is whether this order, which must necessarily be long-lasting and durable, can be formed without some theory of strategic coalition? If we think about the fight against terrorism from tactical and immediate positions (of course, in a positive sense in terms of fighting them, not the tactical methods that the West thinks of), applying negative instrumental approaches to terrorists, we will also suffer defeat in this struggle.

We must accept the fact that after the quantitative and qualitative spread of terrorism in the region, we can no longer treat this phenomenon thoughtlessly and lightly. If we evaluate the ways terrorism has developed in the region over the past more than two decades, we will conclude that terrorism has developed in leaps and bounds in the sense that, starting from guerrilla warfare in the mountains of Afghanistan, it has now spread to many countries. It has various territories and a lot of weapons at its disposal. ISIS alone has about 30 billion dollars. They have oil to replenish their financial reserves, and they receive much from other countries. Therefore, the fight against this trend cannot be regarded as a tactical and temporary measure. We will need long-term organizational work to create security in the region. Within this framework, we need long-term strategic ties that should include various aspects: cultural, political, economic, and security issues – so that responsible countries can feel trust in each other for a long time and begin to deepen that trust.

I thank our Russian friends for their hospitality. Thank you very much for your attention.

R. Legvold: Thank you very much, esteemed Ali Larijani, for your comments.

Over the past two or three days, many have commented on the fundamental changes taking place in the discussions of the Valdai Club since last year. Last year, we focused primarily on the Ukrainian issue; this year, we are discussing the Syrian issue and other turbulent regions that you just mentioned. We greatly appreciate the strategic vision you have brought to us and are grateful that you spoke at this session. Thank you very much.

The next speaker is the former President of the Czech Republic, Václav Klaus. The floor is yours, Klaus.

V. Klaus: Mr. President! Esteemed colleagues and friends! Ladies and gentlemen!

It is a great honor and pleasure for me to be here; thank you very much for the invitation. I must say that I have never been to Sochi before, and to this audience, I must say that I have never been south of Moscow on Russian territory, so I am glad to have made it here.

Today, we expected to talk about threats in this session. It seems to me that we have dedicated all three days to discussing threats. We have spent a full three days on this issue. But now we must say something different, and therefore I propose to change our point of view, to change our perspective; let us be less geopolitical. Every speaker has talked about some external threats, only external threats, that is, when someone threatens someone else. I did not expect a discussion on this topic to arise, and I prepared a few ideas that I titled: "The Threat is Us, the Threat is Within Us." It may sound somewhat paradoxical or surprising to some of you. Like many of you, I feel that our future is under threat; freedom, democracy, peace, security, and prosperity are also under threat.

Immediately after the collapse of the era of communism, at least in my country, in our part of Europe, we welcomed the end of the regime of repression. We thought we were entering a very promising game. Was it so or not? Now, looking back, we see that this was too optimistic and a misinterpretation of events. Paradoxically, the problems we are observing now began precisely with the collapse of the Soviet Union.

The fall of communism unleashed such processes, such ambitions, and erroneous concepts, and even illusions, that step by step led us to the current state of affairs. In general, it was assumed that it was enough to get rid of the political and economic system of communism. This was a task in which many post-communist countries succeeded. I must say that my country was among those that achieved this.

However, at that time, we did not clearly understand that this was not enough. When we create a new system, we must not carry with us or inherit all the old false beliefs, a priori assumptions, as well as some erroneous opinions and narrow-minded interests, as they give rise to new ones. I would like to clearly state that this does not mean that such problems exist only in the East. That is, the existing problems stem more from the West than from the East; I mean the East not in its old sense.

And now, when I look at the world from Central Europe, from Prague, I must mainly talk about our problems, about us. Europe has not been discussed too often over the past three days, but it should be said that it is in Europe that the failure in current developments has turned out to be more serious than in other parts of the world. To be understood correctly, I do not mean to compare the scale of catastrophe and human suffering, but rather to assess the scale of these mistakes. Europe has failed to implement certain things – perhaps to a much greater extent than in other countries of the world. From this perspective, it must be said that the most significant threat to our world, freedom, and democracy does not come from "Islamic State," "Al-Qaeda," or some Arab killers of all kinds that we observe in all countries of the world. It is not the EU, it is not Washington or some government officials or bureaucrats in Moscow who do not cease their attempts to control our lives. It is not the alarmist and populist media that tirelessly attempt to influence our minds. It is also not the autocratic major global bankers, businessmen who participate in the Davos World Economic Forum, in which I also participated several times when I was President, nor the remaining dictators. It must be said that the problem mainly lies in the fact that we ourselves are indecisive and unprepared to adapt to life. We accordingly downplay the importance of the urgent moment, and we observe growing fatigue among people. Without courage and bravery, without a clear vision of the future, we forget common sense and that we have a common goal and task.

We demonstrate an inability to learn from the past and to properly assess the role and significance of history. We have become victims of new erroneous "isms": this is the movement for human rights, multiculturalism, environmentalism, homosexuality, cosmopolitanism, and transnationalism – we have again become victims. At the same time, we contribute significantly to the mistakes associated with political correctness, and a new class of sufficiently prosperous and wealthy hedonistic seekers of the Western world, that is, we – we are accordingly undermining the significance of the institutions that contributed to the creation of a freer and more prosperous world. We are not ready to stop the multiculturalists' crusade against Western civilization; we are not ready to defend our own values, our culture, our religion, our way of life. We are not ready to sacrifice our relatively comfortable, cozy lives and start seriously fighting for freedom and democracy. We are not ready to bravely confront planetary thinking and defend our nation-states, which are the only reliable guarantors and custodians of democracy and democratic values.

I have already mentioned that I am from Central Europe, and therefore I speak from the perspective of a Central European resident. Thus, I do not claim to know Russia well enough, but I must say that I do not believe that Russia is free or protected from all these threats and dangers. Nevertheless, I remain an optimist, hoping that we can still create some feasible programs that will help us understand how to behave going forward. And we need to start this struggle at home, begin correcting mistakes from ourselves, with practical and feasible steps, instead of giving advice to someone else.

I do not agree with the proposals that have been mentioned many times over the last three days that we need to create a new world order. This is a utopia, a new delusion. Of course, we welcome the opening of countries, free trade, open exchanges of opinions, and the internationalization of various activities of people, but we must resist transnationalism and global governance. We live, as has been mentioned here many times again, in a divided world. There were certain opportunities, chances, at least hope that we could overcome this division in the early 1990s. But then there was an undesirable asymmetry, when the East was weak and had to focus on doing its homework, its homework of creating a normal society. The West was then considered a more desirable place to live and believed that it held superiority, and was not ready to work and cooperate with us.

I have always tried to emphasize that we can be significant partners because we did not feel like losers. The communist regime was defeated, not us. However, no one listened to our opinion.

We must ask ourselves: are we ready and do we want to do something real? I am not sure. We are not ready to give up and sacrifice our comfortable lives and compromise our prejudices. We do not have any strong opinions. There is a certain public apathy, there is a hollowing out and impoverishment of education, not to mention ideological indoctrination, the imposition of certain views, which reminds me of the communist era. We are replacing education with political correctness and the imposition of a certain ideology.

I actually prepared a long speech. I will send its electronic version to the organizers. Therefore, I will stop here and say that it seems to me that we need to speak sincerely and openly about all these issues.

I wish the Valdai Club to become an effective platform for finding mutual understanding, discussion, and for countering all these trends.

I could not believe my eyes when I saw that our session was titled "Achieving Common Progress." It seems to me that this is some kind of archaic phrase, and I am surprised that this archaic phrase is still used in the Valdai Discussion Club. And I agree with Edmund Burke, a conservative from Great Britain, who wrote back in 1770 that the world is decisively retreating. It has been almost 250 years since then, and I must agree with him.

Thank you very much for your attention.

R. Legvold: Thank you very much, President Klaus.

The originality of your thought has not disappointed us, although, of course, it was something that stimulates reflection, prompts it, and will certainly provoke certain thoughts.

At the end of the "Cold War" and after its conclusion, a period of promises and hopes began. And at the center of everything that happened at the end of the "Cold War" was Ambassador Jack Matlock. And now, 25 years later, we give the floor to Ambassador Jack Matlock.

J. Matlock: Mr. President! Mr. Moderator! Ladies and gentlemen!

I would like to thank the organizers for the opportunity to join you at this conference and for allowing me to speak alongside such esteemed speakers. I will take only a few minutes of your attention. I actually intended to do so, but I think I will need a little more time than I thought.

I do not intend to speak directly about what the previous speakers have said; it has all been very interesting. I would like to reflect a little on how crises were resolved in the past. After all, I am someone who survived, one might say – I am a kind of antique specimen, someone who lived through the "Cold War." I left the U.S. State Department a long time ago. A lot has happened, and I have been pondering how all that was relates to today. In general, it does relate. Looking back to the early 1980s, when the "Cold War" was still in full swing, I can recall that at that time those who advised President Reagan said that it was necessary to develop a negotiation plan – in fact, negotiations were needed to end the arms race. We did not hope that the "Cold War" would end completely, but we at least began to think about what the essence of the problem was.

We are now commenting on the fact that a second "Cold War" is beginning, we are on the brink of it, and it is fueled by various accusatory speeches that remind us of the "Cold War." But I would say that the issues that were on the agenda of the "Cold War" were much deeper ideologically. At that time, we were in a very dangerous arms race, both countries were involved, and we were constantly facing confrontations that encompassed almost the entire world; the problems were significantly larger in scale.

How did we manage to get out of that situation? In general, it happened; the "Cold War" ended, the leadership of the Soviet Union and leading European countries did it through negotiations. I will not go into details now; I have actually written three books about this, and I have described everything in great detail. But every agreement that was reached with the USSR generally served the interests of the USSR. We created the agenda together with the negotiators from the Soviet side. Most participants paid very close attention to what happened during the meetings of our countries' leaders. This implied a huge amount of work at all levels and practically continuous consultations. At one point, my office was busy working on 87 different areas at the expert level, at the level of consultants and advisors. We wanted to do the following: find an acceptable end, a resolution to all these problems, especially to find a way to end the completely senseless and very dangerous arms race.

A few thoughts that I would like to share with you seem to me to be relevant to today. First, when General Secretary Mr. Gorbachev met with President Reagan for the first time, one of the points on which they reached an agreement was this: in a nuclear war, no one can be a winner; therefore, there should be no such war between us. That is, both sides removed the question of war from the agenda right away and did not threaten each other with it throughout the negotiations.

Then came the realization: why are we building up arms if we do not intend to use them? We are actually forcing our people to live in a very dangerous world because there can be all sorts of emergencies, a situation of losing control over weapons can arise. Such a commitment to the idea was a key point that allowed us to move forward. In fact, we really did not threaten each other. And now I occasionally hear that we should not take military actions off the agenda. I remember that we ended the "Cold War" actually when we took that question off the very beginning of the agenda.

The end of the "Cold War," as I said, was achieved through negotiations. And everyone benefited from this. It happened long before the collapse of the Soviet Union. One of the deceptive myths we face today (of course, this affects politics and the relationships that exist now) is that the "Cold War" ended with the collapse of the Soviet Union and that this was some externally imposed solution by the West. In fact, this is not the case. I know that this opinion exists both in the West and here, but it does not correspond to the facts. The fact is that the end of the "Cold War" was predetermined as a result of negotiations in December 1989 and then implemented to the end. Both we and the Soviet diplomats cooperated on many issues to navigate through these thickets, these ruins that we inherited during the "Cold War." And in all the memoirs, it was said that when Reagan and Gorbachev parted, they parted as partners. Reagan never said: we won the "Cold War." That is, he even warned us when we went to negotiations that if a solution were found, we should not consider ourselves winners in this, because the solution should satisfy both sides; therefore, it cannot be said that the West won in this.

How did the Soviet Union collapse? It happened for internal reasons. It is said that the West caused the collapse of the Soviet Union, but that is what amazes me. This is a widespread view among people, but in reality, they do not look closely at what has really happened and do not think about it. In fact, at least as far as the U.S. and our main European allies are concerned, we did everything we could to help Gorbachev create a voluntary federation. We did everything we could to convince Yeltsin, who by 1991 was already the elected leader of the RSFSR, to cooperate with Gorbachev and keep the country united.

Yes, of course, we were convinced that the three Baltic republics should gain independence, restore it, but we still assumed that all the other 12 republics would unite in a voluntary union. How did it happen that they parted ways? Who was the leader who caused the collapse of the Soviet Union? It was the elected President of Russia, Boris Nikolayevich Yeltsin, who in cooperation with the leaders of Belarus and Ukraine, in fact, declared the end of the existence of the Soviet Union. Yes, the West was kind of the cause of such an end of the state; this is implied. Was the collapse of the Soviet Union a tragedy? I would not call it a huge geopolitical problem, a tragedy of the 20th century, but it was certainly a certain negative phenomenon, a phenomenon of the 20th century. When this happened, I wrote a book about it. I certainly could not resist opening a bottle of champagne and raising a toast.

I thought that better solutions could have been found. Even when President Bush went to Kyiv, it was August 1, 1991, he addressed the Verkhovna Rada, directly recommending that Ukrainians and other non-Baltic republics make a deal with Gorbachev: there is no need to go into murderous, destructive nationalism; freedom and independence are not synonymous, even if you choose freedom.

That is why I was very concerned about the situation when we repeatedly heard that this happened because of the West or the U.S., that they are to blame for the collapse of the USSR. You can blame anyone, but in the end, it was the elected leader of the RSFSR who was not ready for a voluntary organization of unification, and he did not support this idea.

I would also like to briefly mention that we often hear rhetoric about a unipolar and multipolar world. Now, it seems to me, the world is non-polar because the way it has developed over the last few decades shows that a lot of power has been taken out of the hands of the U.S. They do not determine everything. I am not only talking about non-governmental organizations or various criminal groups, terrorist groups; I am not only talking about that, but in general. Power is now very much diluted. And the idea that this could once have been or was applied by one power seems to me to be a delusion.

I think I have almost exhausted my time, but I would like to make a few comments regarding today.

The situation in Ukraine is certainly one of the main reasons for the polemics and tensions that currently exist between the U.S. and Russia, as well as between the European Union and Russia. I understand that I do not have time to delve into this issue, but I would like to say in general that some of Russia's actions have been very destructive for Russia in the long term. I am not sure that creating some precedent in relations with such a valuable neighbor and establishing certain relations is a way to resolve the situation, from which one can gain some dividends or somehow prosper. It seems to me that it is not in Russia's interest to maintain such a situation, to encourage it.

What worries me most about the current relations between the U.S. and Russia is how much we have allowed ourselves to stop and slow down on the issue of arms limitation. It is necessary to continue the work that ensures security, and this is also related to our military arsenals. I would say that this is a kind of "elephant" that is present here invisibly, but if we are not careful, it will again take up all the space. The U.S. and Russia must resume very intensive discussions on nuclear weapons in order to restore mutual security guarantees for this type of weapon and to start a process that would bring the U.S. and Russia to the same level as other nuclear powers. And other nuclear powers should also be involved in such a process. This is very important.

Of course, I am not in a position to speak on behalf of the government right now, but as a citizen of the country, I must say that there should be an interest from Russia to bring this issue to the agenda in order to achieve approval and cooperation on this issue with President Obama.

The current confrontation, which we may face again, certainly does not imply the use of nuclear weapons. After all, our leaders are not insane. But this does not exclude other problems. We are currently operating in a mode where we cannot rule out the worst-case scenario.

Undoubtedly, both sides will experience tremendous political pressure. We remember our nuclear potentials and what could happen. Then it will be a very, very dangerous world.

And finally, a few more words. We talked about threats and cooperation against them. We spoke exclusively about terrorism and military threats, to some extent about the economy. But there are even greater threats, it seems to me, that my grandchildren and children will face: this is a combination of environmental problems, the inability of states to function in many parts of the world, inequality between the rich and the poor, and a lack of attention to caring for the land that feeds us, as Pope Francis said. These problems cannot be solved without cooperation not just between Russia and the United States or between the European Union and Russia – it must be broader cooperation. But, if we think about cooperation in the future, we must also not forget about broader, perhaps even more serious, issues.

Thank you very much.

R. Legvold: Thank you very much, Ambassador Matlock. Thank you for reminding us of what was necessary, what helped end the "Cold War," and what is largely lacking today.

Now the following will happen: I will give our speakers the opportunity to express some ideas, ask questions, and then I will give the floor to the audience.

But first, if you will bear with me, let me start the conversation with a general point and question. What I am about to say will be very sincere (I am defending myself). I quote you, President Putin, when you spoke in Munich at the Security Conference in 2007 – you said: "The structure of this conference allows me to avoid excessive politeness; I am not obliged to say empty diplomatic words." If I were to justify myself in this way, I would recommend asking such questions that would lead to a productive exchange of views.

The world is full of problems, many challenges lie ahead of us, and they were listed in the comments of our speakers. Valdai is dedicated to developing ideas to begin addressing these challenges. I would say, here (forgive my focus on my own country, the United States): when it comes to various problematic relationships in the world, the most important not only for my country but also for Russia is precisely the relationship between Russia and the United States. These are the most important of the problematic relationships for the outside world as well.

Yesterday, one of the successful panels was dedicated to the role of diplomacy and its ability to address our current challenges. Ambassador Richard Burt spoke about the fact that this is not just diplomacy – it is the ability to govern a state. Diplomacy and the ability to govern are not just the activities of ambassadors or foreign ministers; they are also national leaders. Among the five qualities of a good diplomat, he mentioned prudence, courage, creativity, but in the end, he concluded with empathy – the ability to empathize: if you want to succeed as a statesman, this must manifest itself in empathy, the ability to empathize with the other side. He said that this does not necessarily mean agreeing with the other side – it is simply the ability to put yourself in another person's shoes if you want to interact effectively with the other side. And in the end, he said: today's problem is a deficit of empathy, of compassion. He spoke primarily about the lack of empathy in the relationship between the United States and Russia. And I would add to this (this is the main point of my speech, that this is necessary for successful empathy) – it is important to understand the other side accurately, that is what is lacking now. Instead, we have narratives that we are accustomed to in Washington, in the media, in Moscow, in your media, and at the level of national leaders. I believe that these narratives are distorted regarding how we communicate with each other. As a result, the fundamental characteristics of U.S.-Russia relations today can be compared to the early years of the "Cold War" – not the late period, but the beginning. Each country practically exclusively blames the other for the deterioration of relations, at least assigning most of the responsibility to the opposite side. And as a result, we lack these important moments in the relationship.

This is honestly what I wanted to say. The Russian interpretation of U.S. foreign policy is not only that mistakes were made and problems were created, which you, Mr. President, have very clearly articulated in many cases, including in your 2007 speech in Munich, but also that recent events are not just misguided but malicious policy. Today's U.S. foreign policy towards Russia is aimed at undermining Russia's foreign policy, at containing Russia, at rolling it back, at reducing its influence and damaging its strategic interests in a broader sense and among its neighbors. Even more, it is now said that the U.S. wants to change the regime in Russia, within Russia itself, in the strategic interests of the U.S. – an example being the color revolutions in Iraq, Syria, Ukraine, and so on. I do not pull this out of thin air; this was actually the theme of an interview with Nikolai Patrushev in "Rossiskaya Gazeta" a year ago, as if part of American foreign policy is to change the regime. And Lavrov also spoke about this a month later, in November, at the Council on Foreign and Defense Policy.

I can personally say, of course, one can agree or disagree with this, that this is a mischaracterization of the fundamental impulse underlying American policy towards Russia. There is much to criticize in Obama's policy; I will not do that, precisely from this perspective.

From the U.S. perspective, there is a similar distortion of these points that I am talking about. In the administration itself, it seems to me, the majority, not all, of course, not the Secretary of State and not the President, but in most cases, they are convinced that what I have just outlined as the Russian attitude towards American policy truly exists. The Obama administration believes in this attitude from Russia and your government. However, it is also believed that they feel no responsibility for what they have created. They try to explain why such an opinion exists, but they think that they can do nothing to change it. Therefore, they will do nothing in the area of cooperation or moving in the direction that you described, including you, Mr. President, in what should happen between the two sides. There is also a large part of the public, Congress, and the media that has a more rigid, fundamentally distorted narrative. The problem here is not in the interaction between the U.S. and Russia, but in how we have arrived at this point over the years.

But it is actually believed that this is primarily the result of Russian behavior, especially in the context of the Ukrainian crisis, and that this is a product not just of international relations or Russia's reaction to the outside world – it is a function of the essence, the nature of the Russian political system and regime, so it is believed. And Russian behavior is determined not by interaction with the outside world, but by the inherent elements of the Russian system. External enemies are needed so that democracy does not approach Russian borders – and also as a justification for economic difficulties in the country.

From my point of view, this is just as fundamentally incorrect, but it is more widespread than even the first interpretation of the Russian position.

I am telling you all this because I believe that before we can achieve any progress towards common approaches on these issues we are discussing, on these complex points, we must certainly have some common goal – in relation to ISIS, and of course, we must make progress on what Matlock spoke about, and you, Mr. President, in your comments, when we need to bring some order to this nuclear world. I am, of course, talking a lot to start the discussion, I apologize for that, but two questions arise, practical questions – these questions are for Mr. Putin. Is this a mischaracterization – how you, if we call things by their names, see the challenges presented by the American administration? But, in addition, if there is some truth in what I am saying, that narratives hinder us from achieving the cooperation that you want to see, and our leaders want to see, and our governments want to see – how should we begin to move in the opposite direction or, to put it another way, how will we start to change the trajectory at this most basic level?

First of all, I would like to thank all the speakers. I think it was very substantive, interesting, and I am very pleased that we are having a discussion that is not bland, but substantive.

Let us not delve into such a distant history of who is to blame for the collapse of the USSR – I think that, of course, it is primarily internal reasons, and here the ambassador is certainly right. The failure of the political and economic systems of the former Soviet Union was at the root of the collapse of the state. Who contributed to this is another question. I do not think that our geopolitical opponents stood aside, but, of course, the internal reasons were at the core. Mr. Ambassador, as I understand it, has entered into a remote discussion with me, and in this case, a direct one, and said that he does not consider, unlike me, the collapse of the USSR a tragedy of the 20th century. I continue to insist that it is a tragedy, and primarily of a humanitarian nature, that is what I was talking about.

As a result of the collapse of the USSR, 25 million ethnic Russians found themselves abroad against their will and, as we say in the people, overnight. I will repeat my thesis that the Russian people became the largest divided people in the world, and this is undoubtedly a tragedy. I am not even mentioning the socio-economic component: as a result of the collapse, the social system fell apart; the economy collapsed – the previous one, inefficient as it was, but it collapsed, leading to the impoverishment of millions of people, and this is also a tragedy for specific people and for specific families.

Now regarding the continuation of negotiations on limiting strategic offensive arms – again, you are right, this dialogue must continue. At the same time, I cannot say that nothing has been done in this area by Russia and the United States; after all, we have concluded a new Treaty on the Limitation of Strategic Offensive Arms, and it has set certain frameworks and posed certain tasks for us in the area of limiting these offensive arms. But the unilateral withdrawal of the United States from the treaty, which was a cornerstone in terms of ensuring the balance of power and international security, from the ABM Treaty, has put the entire system in a very difficult, complicated position.

In this regard, since we have a discussion club, I would still like to ask the esteemed Mr. Ambassador how he assesses the unilateral withdrawal of the U.S. from the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty.

J. Matlock: Personally, I was against this withdrawal; I understand what you are talking about. I would say that I do not think that any further plans to deploy such weapons could threaten the Russian system. But overall, I do not support ABM systems. The main source of this is not to threaten Russia; it is to create jobs in the U.S., after all, this is the military-industrial complex, and how many people work there.

Mr. Ambassador, I find your arguments unconvincing. I have great respect for your experience and for the diplomatic skill that you use impeccably, avoiding a direct answer. You did give a direct answer, but there were elements of embellishment in your response.

There is no need to create jobs that result in a threat to all of humanity. And then the creation of new systems, missile defense systems, creates new jobs – why create them in such a sphere? Let us create them in the field of biology, in the field of pharmaceuticals, in high technologies not related to the production of weapons.

Now regarding whether this threatens Russia or not. I assure you, American security and strategic weapons specialists are well aware that this threatens the Russian nuclear potential. And this entire system is being created to reduce the nuclear potentials of other nuclear states, apart from the U.S., to zero. And all the time, the arguments were different; we heard them: the Iranian nuclear threat. But in my speech, I said: we have always proceeded from the fact that there is no threat, and now not only we – the entire international community believes that it does not exist.

The United States was the initiator of signing the agreement with Iran to resolve the Iranian nuclear problem. We actively accompanied and supported our American and Iranian partners, achieved a coordinated solution, the agreement came into force, and Iran agreed to export enriched uranium. There is no Iranian nuclear problem. Why create a missile defense system? Stop it. No, it has not only not been stopped – on the contrary, new tests are being conducted, exercises have been held, by the end of this year these systems will be created in Romania, and by 2020 or 2018, systems will be created in Poland.

I can tell you, and specialists know this, that a positional area for missile defense can be effectively used for the deployment of strike systems of cruise missiles. Does this not create a threat for us? Of course, it does, and it fundamentally changes the very philosophy of international security. If one country believes that it has created a "missile umbrella" over itself and can protect itself from a retaliatory or counter-retaliatory strike, then it is free to use any kind of weaponry. This is a violation of the strategic balance. And you, as a person who has worked on disarmament agreements, have achieved remarkable results – one can only take off one’s hat, as the French say – chapeau, we take off our hats: indeed, you succeeded, and your Russian partners succeeded. But what is happening now cannot but worry us. And I am sure that deep down you cannot disagree with this. In fact, you agree – you said that you are against the unilateral withdrawal of the United States from this Treaty.

Now regarding Ukraine, about the dangers it creates for us – of course, it does. But did we create this situation? Just look, in what year was it when Mr. Yanukovych lost the elections, and Mr. Yushchenko came to power? But how did he come to power? As a result of a third round of voting, which is not provided for in the Constitution of Ukraine. This was actively supported by Western countries. Well, this is a complete violation of the Constitution. What kind of democracy is this? It’s just a bacchanalia. They did it once, and then repeated it in an even more crude form during the change of power, during the coup in Ukraine quite recently.

And Russia's position is not that we are fighting against the choice of the Ukrainian people – we accept any choice, it is indeed a fraternal country for us, a fraternal people, I do not make a distinction between Russians and Ukrainians at all. But we are against such a form of changing power. It is bad anywhere in the world, and absolutely unacceptable in the post-Soviet space, because we must say directly that many republics of the former Soviet Union do not yet have a tradition of statehood, a stable political system has not formed, and we must treat what exists very carefully, protect it, and help it develop. Were we against working with people who came to power even as a result of an unconstitutional third round in their time? Mr. Yushchenko, Ms. Tymoshenko – we worked with them, even though they were considered – I believe that such a characterization is generally incorrect, but nevertheless they were considered absolutely pro-Western politicians. We met with them, traveled to Kyiv, hosted them in Russia. Yes, we argued, sometimes we argued harshly – on economic issues, but we cooperated.

But how can we accept coups? You will arrange Iraq and Libya for us here. After all, the official authorities of the United States openly say that they spend billions of dollars – the official authorities say publicly: they spent 5 billion to support the opposition. Is this the right choice?

Now look, another colleague of ours, I understand, says that this is an incorrect interpretation, that the United States wants to change the political system, the power system in Russia. It is difficult for me to agree with your interpretation, but if it is directly stated in the law of the United States (I believe it concerns Ukraine, but Russia is mentioned directly) that the goal is the democratization of the Russian Federation – can you imagine that we would set a goal in our internal law to democratize the United States?

You know, that is at least impolite. And in principle, we could do this, and I will tell you why. There are grounds for this. It is well known that twice in the history of the United States of America, a president came to power who was elected by a majority of electors, behind whom stood a minority of voters. Is this democratic? No. Democracy is the power of the people, the majority of the people. How can a person be elected to the highest office in the state by a minority of voters? There is such a problem in the constitution. We do not demand that you change your constitution.

You know, one can debate as much as one wants, but if it is enshrined in internal laws, if internal opposition is financed: opposition is normal – it should only exist on its own basis, but if billions are almost openly spent to support internal opposition, is this normal political practice, does this create an atmosphere of trust at the interstate level? I think not.

Now regarding the promotion of democracy to our borders. You, apparently, are a very experienced person. Are we against the promotion of democracy to our borders? Do you mean by democracy the promotion of NATO to our borders? Is that democracy? NATO is a military bloc. We are not concerned about the promotion of democracy to our borders – we are concerned about the promotion of military infrastructure to our borders. How can we not react to this, how can we not think about it? That is what worries us.

Do you know what lies at the heart of today’s problems? I will share this with you, and we will definitely make public the document I am about to mention. These are the records of conversations between German political figures and Soviet leadership on the eve of the reunification of Germany. It is very curious, you know, you read it like detective literature.

One of the major political figures of then Germany, one of the leaders of the Social Democratic Party, during negotiations tells the Russian leadership, the highest Russian leadership – I cannot quote verbatim, but very close to the text, he says the following: "If we do not agree now on the principles of the reunification of Germany and the future of Europe, crises will not cease after the reunification of Germany, but will escalate, and we will not get rid of them, we will only meet them in a new guise." Then, when the Soviet leaders began to discuss with him, he was even surprised, he said: "It seems that I am now defending the interests of the Soviet Union," reproaching them, apparently, for myopia, "while I am thinking about the future of Europe." And he turned out to be absolutely right.

At that time, your colleagues, Mr. Ambassador, did not agree on fundamental issues regarding what would happen with the reunification of Germany: whether it would be a member of NATO, how military infrastructure would develop, how security issues in Europe would be built and coordinated. They talked verbally then, put nothing on paper, fixed nothing, and everything went downhill. But verbally then (everyone remembered my speech in Munich, I said), verbally then the NATO Secretary General said that the Soviet Union could be assured, I quote, that NATO would not expand beyond the eastern borders of today’s GDR. Nothing of the sort, two waves of expansion are here, and now there are missile defense systems at our borders.

You know, all this, in my opinion, raises our legitimate concerns, and this certainly needs to be worked on. But we, I want to say, are ready, despite all the difficulties, we are ready for this. On the same acute issue of today, which I want to raise again, regarding the missile defense system, we proposed to work together: the United States, Russia, and Europe. What does it mean to work together? It means to identify missile-threat directions, to have equal access to the management of this system, and several other secondary issues. No, we were met with a refusal. It was not us who refused – we were refused.

And now there is an acute question regarding Syria, we will surely talk about this more. We are criticized for allegedly striking the wrong targets. I said recently, speaking in Moscow: tell me, which targets should we strike correctly, if you know – no, they do not say; tell me, which targets we should not strike – they also refuse.

You know, we had a wonderful film "Ivan Vasilievich Changes Profession," the Russian audience remembers. One main character says to another: "How can I understand you if you say nothing?" Thank God, now, it seems we are starting to agree at the military level, I have already said this. Life itself forces us. I hope that we can, if the military can agree among themselves, and they, apparently, are the most responsible people, then it is possible to reach some agreement at the political level.

Thank you.

R. Legvold: Thank you very much.

I know that everyone wants to ask a question and start an exchange of views, but I think our speakers should also comment on this first. If you want to comment on something – please.

President Klaus said that he also wanted to address you, gentlemen, or shall we pass the floor to the audience? Alright, then your questions, please.

Neil Buckley, please.

N. Buckley: Mr. President, my name is Neil Buckley, I am from the Financial Times.

I would like to ask you a question about Syria. How can you be sure that the Russian intervention, military actions in Syria will avoid the fate of the intervention of other forces in the Middle East and not exacerbate the situation and increase chaos?

Also, may I ask you to use this forum to tell us more specifically, in more detail, how you see the peace process and peaceful settlement in Syria? Is Russia ready to accept the division of Syria? Will Assad leave or not? Accordingly, if he leaves, what leader will come to replace him?

Thank you very much.

If I understood you correctly regarding the first part, regarding our confidence in how effective our work will be today in Syria, yes?

What kind of confidence can there be in such matters? Confidence is only provided by an insurance policy. We act in accordance with our beliefs and norms of international law. We expect that the coordinated actions of our strike aviation and other means of destruction, coordinated with the offensive operations of the Syrian army, will yield positive results. In my opinion, and the opinion of our military experts, such a result already exists.

Is it sufficient to say that terrorism in Syria has been defeated? No. Serious efforts are still needed to make such a statement. It will require even greater and, I want to emphasize, joint work.

We do not want to throw stones at anyone, nevertheless, for almost a year and a half, the coalition led by the United States has been striking there, more than 11 countries participated, over 500 strikes were made on various targets, but the result is absent, this is an obvious fact. What result is there if during this time terrorists have only strengthened their presence in Syria and Iraq, consolidated at the borders where they were, and expanded their area of presence? Therefore, in this sense, of course, our colleagues have not managed to achieve anything effective, in my opinion.

The first actions of our Armed Forces and the armed forces of the Syrian army have yielded results. But this is not enough. And, of course, it would be very good if we could unite the efforts of all those who genuinely want to fight terrorism, all the countries of the region and non-regional powers including the United States. In fact, we proposed this.

We proposed that at the first stage a military delegation come to Moscow, and then I said that we are ready to send a delegation at a high political level headed by the Chairman of the Government of the Russian Federation to discuss issues of a political nature. But we were told that our proposal was rejected. However, later American colleagues clarified at the ministerial level that we were not understood very correctly and that the door is still open, we can go down this path, we can and should think about uniting efforts.

Now there will be a meeting between the foreign ministers of the United States, Russia, Saudi Arabia, and Turkey. I think that, of course, it is necessary to involve other regional countries, without the participation of which it is impossible to resolve this issue, I mean, first of all, Iran. We have talked about this many times. But at least at this stage, let the ministers meet and talk. You know that we are in very close contact with our Iranian partners on this issue, Iran is making a significant contribution to the settlement.

Now regarding the division of Syria. I believe that this is the worst option, unacceptable, and it will not lead to the resolution of the conflict, but rather create conditions for its escalation and continuation. The conflict will then take on a permanent character. If Syria is divided into separate parts, into separate territories, they will inevitably fight among themselves endlessly, and nothing good will come of it.

Now regarding whether Assad should leave or not. I have said this many times: I believe that this is absolutely incorrect. How can we from the outside decide and raise the question of whether the head of a certain state should leave power or not? This should be decided by the Syrian people themselves. True, and here I want to qualify, we must be sure that power is formed on the basis of transparent democratic procedures, and one can certainly talk about some international control over these procedures, including over electoral procedures, but this, of course, must be objective control, that is the most important thing, and not biased by one power or a group of countries.

And finally, how do we see the political process itself. First of all, I will say now in the most general terms, but how this process should be formulated, its principles, final goals, what we should strive for and how to do it, this should still be formulated by the Syrians themselves, I mean both the legitimate government of Syria and the opposition forces. Of course, we believe that the basis of the Syrian conflict is not only the fight against militants and not only terrorist aggression, although this terrorist aggression is evident, and the terrorists simply took advantage of the difficulties within Syria itself. And it is necessary to separate the terrorist threat from domestic political problems. And, of course, the Syrian leadership must establish a working contact with those opposition forces that are ready for dialogue. As far as I understood from the conversation with President Assad the day before yesterday, he is ready for such a dialogue.

R. Legvold: Thank you very much.

Mr. Larijani, will you respond to this question?

A. Larijani: You know, regarding the dismemberment of Syria, I would also like to note a few points. I completely agree with Mr. Putin's analysis of the situation in Syria. But let's assume that yes, you have dismembered Syria – and what is the nature of this dismemberment? That is, the territories that are in the hands of terrorists, do you want to give them to them, that is, do you want to reward them? Do you want to change the very question, rather than the fight against terrorism: because the terrorists have territories, we recognize them, therefore we dismember? This is a major, gross strategic mistake. Thus, terrorists would enter other countries, seize territories, and then they would be recognized.

As for the fight that Russia has begun in Syria, I would like to compare it with the conditions when a coalition of 50-60 countries was striking in the region. You know, the Russians are currently cooperating in the fight against terrorism and are fighting terrorism in Syria, and our assessment is that the Russians have had success, and this is absolutely clear and visible.

What has the coalition of 50-60 countries led by the United States done? Let's look at what they have done in the last year and a half. You know very well that one of the issues of ISIS's strength is the sale of oil, the sale of oil through Syria to neighboring states. They do not transport this oil on donkeys; they transport it on tankers that travel in convoys. Why do the Americans not see these convoys? Do they really not know, having drones, that these are tankers carrying oil? Why do they not shoot them down, why do they not strike? There is no desire to strike. Let's assume that we are, so to speak, against the Syrian government, we do not want to work with Syria. Fine. You are not against the Iraqi government; you cooperate – why do you do nothing in Iraq?

It has been a year and a half since they created the coalition. Let's see what you have done. In Ramadi, when the mobilization popular forces took these territories from ISIS, they entered with a large convoy to reclaim these lands. The Americans stood by, watched, and did nothing. And they reclaimed. So what is the purpose of this coalition, what is all this for? The question here is that this coalition is playing with terrorism. Correctly, yes, they conducted various bombings there, but this is absolutely a controlled bombing. We have not seen anything serious, substantial in Iraq, nor in Syria. Therefore, I think that the dismemberment of Syria would be a reward for ISIS.

We cannot even disregard Russian actions, because that would not correspond to reality. We see that in a short time, Russia has achieved success in striking ISIS; the Armed Forces of Russia have achieved success, which is a very significant thing.

You know, I can tell you, I familiarize myself with video materials after strikes: it is impressive. There detonates such a quantity of munitions that they fly up almost to the aircraft. It seems that the munitions and weapons have been gathered from all over the Middle East; there is a colossal power accumulated, and indeed the question arises, where does the money come from – just a colossal power. Now it has, of course, become smaller. And indeed, the Syrian army is demonstrating successes with our support. They are modest so far, but they exist, and I am sure they will continue.

A. Levin: A question regarding airstrikes in Syria. Are there any intentions to help the Syrian leadership push ISIS forces from their current positions, or do you want to continue in order to completely destroy ISIS? Therefore, extending the campaign may imply developing actions not only in Syria but also in Iraq. Are there such plans?

There are certainly no such plans and cannot be. Because we do not have a request from the Iraqi government for assistance to Iraq. We are providing assistance to Iraq through arms supplies; we are already doing this, we are contributing to the Iraqi direction, contributing to the fight against terrorism by supplying weapons and munitions. But the Iraqi government has not approached us with such a request, although we cooperate with the Iraqi government not only through arms and military equipment supplies but also by exchanging information.

As you know, it is in Baghdad that the so-called information center has been established, consisting of Iran, Russia, Syria, and Iraq, where information is exchanged, and the main directions of the fight against terrorism, including ISIS, are determined, but no expansion of our combat operations using the Russian Aerospace Forces is planned.

M. Tlili: I am Mustafa Tlili from the Muslim Association. Mr. President, Iran is the main force in the Middle East, a great civilization that has a completely legitimate right to participate and play a certain role in the Syrian crisis and also in all issues related to Muslims; it has strength and claims to be the defenders of Sunni peace.

You communicate with both sects. What is your role in bringing both sides to cooperate in order to end the antagonism that exists between the two sects and bring peace to the Muslim world?

I want to tell you right away that the goal of Russian military operations and diplomatic efforts in this direction is to fight terrorism, not to mediate between representatives of different sects of Islam. Our friends who profess both Shia and Sunni Islam, as well as Alawites, are dear to us – we do not divide. We have very good relations with a number of states where the predominant direction is Sunni, and we have very good relations with those states where the majority of the population professes Shia Islam, so we make no distinction. I will repeat once again, our main goal, the only one, is the fight against terror.

At the same time, we understand the realities in which we operate. In Syria, for example, you know that out of 34, I believe, members of the cabinet (approximately, I may be mistaken), more than half are still Sunnis, and in President Assad's army, the Sunni part is represented as widely as in the government. Syria has always been, first and foremost, a secular state. But, I repeat once again, we understand the realities in which we have to work. And, of course, if our actions lead to the discussion between different religious sects acquiring a civilized, neighborly, friendly character and leading to the resolution of any conflicts, to the unification of efforts in the fight against terror, we would consider our mission accomplished.

A. Larijani: I would like to tell you about Shia and Sunni Islam, which have become a bargaining chip in today's world, to make it clearer what we are talking about. You know, a few years ago, Israel attacked Lebanon, and there was a 33-day war. And we supported Hezbollah in the face of the crime that Israel committed. And many created a tense atmosphere because Iran is Shia, Hezbollah is Shia, so Iran must support Shia Islam, and therefore we cannot cooperate.

That has passed. After that, we saw a 22-day war in Palestine, and the Israelis attacked Gaza; we then supported Hamas. Hamas is Sunni. And when they saw that we were supporting Sunnis here, they could no longer say that it was Shia and Sunni – they said that Persians were fighting.

You know, this is history, this is a question of Iran, the Islamic Republic. The Islamic Republic of Iran does not engage in such petty issues. The main problem in the region is that some are standing behind the scenes and do not want to tell the truth. And the problem of terrorism here is not a problem of Shia, Sunni, or which of these sects, so to speak, that has existed since the beginning of Islam, such as Hanbalis, Hanafis, Malikis, Shafi'is, who among them is with the terrorists. Sunnis even hate terrorists. In Iraq, there are different Sunni tribes; many communicate with us, and they tell us that they want to fight ISIS, which is a sect that has been created in the last 100 years, and this sect is militant and fights with other Islamic sects, considering both Sunnis and Shias to be infidels. Here, the facts must be understood very correctly – not what is said in propaganda.

You know, I was just thinking whether to say this or not. I will still slightly lift the veil on our negotiations with President Assad. I asked him: "How would you feel about it (if we even find armed opposition in Syria now, but ready to confront and actually fight against terrorists, against ISIS), how would you feel if we supported their efforts in the fight against terrorism, just as we support the Syrian army?" He replied: "I view this positively." We are currently thinking about this and trying, if possible, to translate these agreements into practical terms.

Shen Shilyan: My question is about Russia's place in the future world. I have a deep conviction that Russia was, is, and will be a great power in the world, but we had a debate among scholars of "Russistics" – essentially, four opinions. Some believe that there will be three first-magnitude stars on the world stage: Russia, the USA, and China. Others believe that there will be four centers of power in the world: again, Russia with the Eurasian Economic Union, the European Union, the USA, and China. The third group believes that there will be two groups of countries: the West and the non-West; the West is the USA and Europe, while the non-West includes Russia, China, other BRICS countries, and the third world. But there are also those who believe that Russia will take first place, but in the second row. Behind it will be India, Brazil, Germany, Japan, and so on, while only the USA and China will be in the first row.

I would ask you to express your opinion.

The answer is simple: in the modern world and in the near future, yes, I think even in the more distant future, the role and significance of any state in the world will depend on the level of economic development of that country, on how modern this economy is, how future-oriented it is, how much it is based on the latest technologies, and how quickly it will transition to a new technological structure. In this sense – I am not talking about territory, population, or military components; all of this is very important, and without it, a country cannot claim to occupy one of the leading places in the world, but at the core of everything is, of course, the economy and its development, the growth rates of the economy on a new technological basis.

I believe that Russia has every chance of being one of the leaders, considering the high level of education of the population and the high level of development of fundamental science. We have many problems here as well. They have always existed and will always exist, just as in other countries. But we are paying more and more attention not only to the revival of science, both fundamental and applied, but also to giving a new impetus to the development of these vital areas. If we take into account these circumstances and absolutely natural competitive advantages, then Russia will undoubtedly play a significant role.

Determining specific places seems to me very difficult. This is not a sporting competition, but it is obvious to me that Russia has a good prospect, a future, but, of course, in developing relations with our neighbors: this is primarily, of course, with our closest neighbors, partners, and allies in organizations such as the Eurasian Economic Union, the CSTO [Collective Security Treaty Organization]; with neighbors like the People's Republic of China, with which we have the largest trade turnover in labor terms – over 80 billion dollars; of course, with such a great country as India. Undoubtedly, we cannot conceive of our development without developing relations with Europe.

At the core of our unity, there is undoubtedly Christian culture, and we also have advantages because almost 20 percent of the population are Muslims, and in this sense, we can be a connecting link between many of our partners and the Islamic world. And of course, we are counting on developing relations with the United States, if, of course, our partners wish it.

A. Tsygankov: Dear Vladimir Vladimirovich, I have a question about the growing conflict of values regarding the USA and Russia and to what extent this will determine the relations between the two countries in the future?

What we see today, and we discussed this in one of the sessions, is a fierce information struggle, fierce rhetoric from both sides: on one side, the soulless West, on the other side – a neo-Soviet autocracy, a repressive system. Further in this regard, in terms of rhetoric, there is nowhere to go.

What about those Russians who love America? What about those Americans who love Russia? What do you think are the reasons for this situation? Are they political reasons that accompany the struggle for a new world order, primarily? What kind of reasons are these? Or is it still a cultural contradiction, such a deep cultural contradiction that we are returning to the times of cultural clashes, as American political scientist Samuel Huntington once spoke about? What do you think the problem is?

You know, if we look at the reasoning of our thinkers, philosophers, and representatives of classical Russian literature, they see the reasons for the disagreements between Russia and the West in general, in the broad sense of the word, in the difference of worldviews. And they are partly right. At the core of the Russian worldview lies the notion of good and evil, of higher powers, a divine principle. At the core of Western thinking – I do not want this to sound awkward, but still, at the core lies interest, pragmatism. And in this regard, it is necessary to use terms very precisely and uniformly.

Look, behind you are the slogans of our meeting today. On one side in English: "Societies between war and peace," then "logic of conflict in tomorrow’s world," that is, societies between war and peace. And in Russian, it says: "War and peace," and then the most important – "Man," then "the state and the threat of a major conflict in the 21st century." The English version already speaks of conflict as an inevitable future, and not just in the 21st century, but in general: "tomorrow’s world." You know, even in this conceptual apparatus, there are differences, and we need to strive for this conceptual apparatus to be used as accurately as possible and for what we write and say to be understood uniformly. That is the second point.

And third. I, unfortunately, cannot refrain from a certain criticism, but when today’s politics is based on some messianism and exclusivity, it is difficult for us to engage in dialogue in such a format, because this is indeed a departure from our common traditional values, which are undoubtedly based on the equality of all people before the Creator. This does not mean that we cannot or should not seek points of contact in such a framework. We will do this. Once again, I want to emphasize that we very much hope that our partners are also ready for such work.

Yes, and what about those who in Russia love the USA, and in the USA love Russia? Thank God, such people exist. They should guide society as a whole, those people who make decisions, that despite the differences between countries and approaches to development, to their own development, or to solving global problems, if there are people in Russia who love the United States, it means there is something there that deserves respect.

And conversely, if part of American society and the people have a friendly or loving attitude towards Russia, then they should explain to their, in this case, American society and those who make political decisions that Russia should be treated with respect.

R. Pukhov: Ruslan Pukhov, Center for Analysis of Strategies and Technologies. We primarily study military technologies. Right now, there is a serious discussion in America about the possibility of transferring portable anti-aircraft missile systems to the armed opposition in Syria. I do not think that Barack Obama will go for this, but, say, allies in the Middle East, including the monarchies with which we are negotiating, and tomorrow in Vienna, they may go for it, and our pilots, our planes are there now. And you know better than I do that, say, the Su-25 and Su-24 must fly low: unlike the Su-34, they fly below five thousand and can be subjected to attack. This means our pilots may risk their lives and even die. How will the Russian leadership respond to this, at least hypothetically?

This is a perfectly valid question; I see nothing here that could be classified as an inappropriate question, and I will respond as pragmatically as possible.

As far as we know, although God forbid I am wrong, American military forces are already transferring systems for combating tanks and armored vehicles and training crews. I think this is a big mistake. I believe this weapon will surely fall into the hands of terrorist organizations. First.

Second. As you know, our American colleagues have simply moved to the practice of dropping weapons and ammunition from aircraft in certain areas. To whom will this weapon and ammunition fall, who will use them, against whom? There is no certainty; I know this for sure, there is no certainty for anyone, including those who are doing it. Even if it falls into the right hands at the first stage, tomorrow it may end up, and most likely will end up, with ISIS or Jabhat al-Nusra and other organizations and the like. I believe this is also a big mistake.

Is the transfer of anti-aircraft systems, portable missile systems possible? I hope not, because the American leadership, although we disagree on many positions, are still reasonable people and realize that this weapon could end up in the hands of those who will direct it against American pilots, who also fly in the sky over Syria – illegally, it is true, but they still do it. And I think that at least this should stop them from transferring such weapons.

As for certain types of aircraft, and I have flown them, I know what they are like – I am generally surprised how pilots do this. There, with such overloads that they experience, you cannot even turn your head. You not only need to control the aircraft in this situation, but you also need to control the weapon, because strikes are mainly delivered visually. The overloads from the aircraft sharply descending and sharply climbing are colossal; only the fingers move. This is the highest piloting in the literal sense of the word. And these people undoubtedly deserve all respect.

Our military in Syria are certainly fighting terrorism and in this sense protecting the interests of the Syrian people, but not only that. First and foremost, they are protecting the interests of Russia and the Russian people. They strike at those bandits, their formations, which pose a threat to our country. Of course, they risk their health and lives. And in this sense, they are all heroes, but they chose this profession voluntarily. That is their choice. I am proud of them.

A. Rar: I wanted to ask you, Vladimir Vladimirovich, how do you assess the Minsk agreements – returning to Europe? Where are the obstacles to achieving peace in eastern Ukraine? And can you comment on your proposal, which you made at the UN, to return to negotiations on creating a joint space from Lisbon to Vladivostok? Can this idea be realized during the German presidency in the OSCE next year?

Alexander, I will answer both of your questions now, but I still want to finish.

You know, I just thought about something. Your sub-question is certainly such a complex one, and apparently, you considered it politically incorrect. But what if, God forbid, there are losses? I believe that in principle I have answered your question.

I would like to say, you know, that fifty years ago, a street in Leningrad taught me one rule: if a fight is inevitable – you must strike first. And the threat of terrorist attacks in Russia – it has not become any greater or lesser due to our actions in Syria, I assure you. It was and is, unfortunately. We did not take any actions in Syria – what made the terrorists strike in Volgograd at the railway station? Nothing, just their misanthropic mentality, their attitude towards human life, their struggle against Russia as such. And therefore, it is better for us to fight them there, as I have already said, than to wait here.

Now regarding the Minsk agreements. I believe, as I have already said, that there is no other way, if we want to achieve long-term peace in southeastern Ukraine and restore the territorial integrity of the country, there is no other way than to implement the Minsk agreements. Can Germany play any positive role in this? Yes, it can.

I believe that the Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany and the President of France are quite objective today, although it is clear that for political reasons they unequivocally support the current authorities in Kyiv, but still, in my opinion, they objectively assess the situation and already understand that the problems that have arisen there are not just two colors: white and black – it is much more complicated.

I said this at the meeting in New York with my American colleague and partner – the President of the United States of America, I said that without the participation of Europe, without the participation of the United States, it is unlikely that the situation can be resolved. Because it is useless to endlessly accuse Russia of not implementing or not encouraging the authorities of the unrecognized republics in southeastern Ukraine to take any actions to implement the Minsk agreements if the key provisions of the Minsk agreements are not being implemented by the Kyiv authorities, and they are not being implemented by the Kyiv authorities.

I will not reveal any secret; we often talk about this, yet I will repeat what I mean when I assert that the current Kyiv authorities are not implementing the Minsk agreements. The first thing that needs to be done in terms of political settlement is to amend the Constitution of Ukraine, this is directly stipulated in the Minsk agreements, but importantly: by agreement, it is written, with these territories, the unrecognized republics. The Kyiv authorities amended the Constitution without any agreement with these unrecognized republics, claiming that they coordinated with the Venice Commission. Fine, but the Minsk agreements say nothing about the Venice Commission – it says about coordination with Donbas. This was not done.

Second. These changes must be made on a permanent basis. They were made in transitional provisions, and, in essence, in our view, this is a temporary measure. Our opponents say the opposite. But what, in essence, has been added to the Constitution? Essentially, a law on the special status of governance in these territories has been added, which has already been adopted. To my question, what this law is, both the Chancellor and the President of France and the President of Ukraine confirmed that it is about the law that has already been adopted by the Rada of Ukraine, the parliament of the country. I ask them: "Is this on a permanent basis?" – they say: "Yes." I then asked them: "Do you know that this law is adopted for only three years? A year has already passed," – Mr. Poroshenko confirmed this. My European partners expressed their position, according to which this law, if it is included in the Constitution, should operate on a permanent basis. But then it needs to be enshrined in the Constitution.

Next. The dispute was about municipal elections in the unrecognized republics. The Minsk agreements stipulate that the election law must be adopted by the Rada and elections must be held according to Ukrainian law, but this law again must be agreed upon with these unrecognized republics. They sent their proposals three times – no response!

Moreover, the law that has been adopted explicitly states that elections will not be held in these territories. So what should they do? That is why they announced that they would hold elections themselves. We managed to persuade them now, both in one territory and in the other, to postpone the election date. We agreed that it is necessary to prepare this law together with Kyiv. But it needs to be done.

Finally, the Minsk agreements explicitly state: within 30 days after the signing of these Minsk agreements, the Rada must adopt a resolution on the enactment of the law on the special status of governance. It, as I have already said, was adopted by the Rada earlier. What did our partners in Kyiv do? They adopted a resolution of the Rada and seemingly formally fulfilled the Minsk agreement. But at the same time, without coordination with Donbas, they adopted another article, Article 10, in this law, which states that it will only take effect when elections are held there, that is, they postponed its enactment again. But this is just manipulation; I told my Ukrainian partner about this. This is just manipulation! Although formally – they did it. As our Marxist-Leninist classics used to say, in form – it is correct, in essence – it is mockery.

Finally, a law on amnesty must be adopted. If everyone tells us that elections must be held according to OSCE standards, then we must not forget that OSCE standards provide for the implementation of one very important point in electoral campaigns: no one should be subject to criminal prosecution. And all the leaders of the LPR and DPR are under criminal prosecution. But everyone agrees with this: both our American partners and the Europeans – a law on amnesty must be adopted. It has not been adopted. Well, it is directly written in the Minsk agreements. The reference to the fact that it is included in the law on special status does not work because the law does not work. The reference to the fact that it will be enshrined in the law on future elections is also ineffective because there is no law itself. A separate law on amnesty must be adopted. I doubt that anyone in this audience will say that this cannot be done. This is a global standard: elections cannot be held where people who have active and passive voting rights and participate in the electoral campaign are subject to criminal prosecution.

There are a number of other questions, but they lie – the ball, as they say, is in the court of the Kyiv authorities. This needs to be done, and it can only be done in the work of the Kyiv government and the President with their European and American partners, not with Moscow.

I apologize for taking so long, but I must clarify my position.

R. Desai: Mr. Putin, I have two questions for you. The first is about the economy, and the second is about Syria.

Any role of the state in the world must rely on a strong economy. And recent events, such as the fall in oil prices, have created problems for the Russian economy. For many years, we have heard that the government recognizes how important it is to diversify the economy, to move away from excessive reliance on energy resources. The question is simple: what initiatives are you implementing to achieve this, and what are the main obstacles that need to be overcome to achieve successful diversification of the Russian economy, apart from oil?

As for Syria. You certainly spoke very interestingly and said a lot of interesting things. And you mentioned a few phrases about the agreement between Russia and Iran, as well as the governments of Iraq and Syria to coordinate actions to defeat the terrorists. On the other hand, you also said that it will be important in this process to communicate with the USA, Turkey, and Saudi Arabia to develop a common plan to achieve this. Given that it seems that one of the goals of the USA is still to get rid of the Assad regime, while the goal of your coalition is to try to support him, it is quite likely that the second meeting will not take place. In this case, how far can the joint efforts of Iran, Russia, Iraq, and Syria go? How far can they go and what can these four countries achieve in the absence of such cooperation?

The first question is about the crisis, the problems of the economy, and its development.

As we know from the forecasts of all respected international organizations, including economic and political ones: the UN, the World Bank, the IMF, the global economy is not developing at the rates we all dreamed of. In this sense, the entire global economy is experiencing problems. The Russian economy is facing several issues, going through several problems and trials. They are related not only to the restrictions that are often mentioned, the politicized restrictions in the economic sphere – the so-called sanctions: they play a certain role, but, of course, not a decisive one. The most important factor limiting growth, reducing the pace of economic growth, is, of course, the fall in prices for traditional goods of our exports, but this concerns not only Russia – it affects almost all developing markets. And the Russian market is also suffering, perhaps even a little less than some other developing markets; just look at the statistics.

What needs to be done? You have already mentioned this yourself and also pointed out that in Russia it is often and consistently said about the need to diversify the economy, to give it a more diversified state, to rely on high-tech industries. Yes, this process is going slowly. Is something positive happening there or not? Yes, it is happening, and here is how I can illustrate this. If, say, 5–7 years ago, the share of the oil and gas sector in Russia's GDP was about 14 percent, today the share of the oil and gas sector in the GDP of the Russian Federation, in the economy of the country, is 9 percent. For comparison, I will say that the share of the oil and gas sector, say, in Saudi Arabia, if I remember correctly, is 45 percent, and in some Gulf states it reaches 50 percent; in Venezuela, for example, it is 30 percent; for us – 9 percent. As you can feel, the difference is very large. For the first time, despite all the difficulties in the last quarter, unexpectedly, perhaps for us, but such is the effect of our efforts, and I will now say what these efforts are about: the export of machinery has increased – despite the overall decline in production in this sector of the economy. And the growth of machinery exports has risen.

What are the problems today: the fact that our economy, facing the situation in the external market, is structurally not ready to support the necessary growth rates. Certain sectors are under threat, and we believe that special attention should be paid to this. I will now say what we are doing for this. This is, first of all, of course, industry. In some sectors, declines amount to 10 percent or more. This causes us particular concern, but we know what needs to be done here as well. Finally, we need to pay attention to the national currency; the Central Bank is doing this, and it is doing it quite confidently.

In this regard, I consider the statements of our specialists and members of the Government who believe that the peak of the crisis has been passed to be justified, and now we need to focus on these factors that I mentioned – on supporting the most affected sectors of industry: construction, machine engineering, automotive manufacturing, and some high-tech construction sectors. For this, the Government has allocated additional resources amounting to 150 billion rubles, and about 300 billion rubles is allocated for agriculture, so financial support is, in principle, available.

We need to continue the work that we have been doing over the past years, and one of them is being carried out by the Central Bank, as I mentioned – this is the stabilization of the national currency, and this is also one of the indicators that gives us the right to assert that some stabilization has occurred. The exchange rate of the national currency has certain market fluctuations related to the price of oil, but it has also stabilized. Our positive trade balance is confidently maintained, despite any difficulties and problems.

We have quite high gold and foreign exchange reserves of the Central Bank – over 370 billion dollars. We have good reserves in the Government's funds: in one fund, a little over 70 billion, in another reserve fund, 74 billion. Yes, we are structuring our economic development strategy in such a way that we will slightly deplete them, but still, even by the end of 2018, I am confident that we will have reliable reserves of the Government – in addition to the reserves of the Central Bank.

In the previous period, in the last quarter, our budget deficit was only one and a half percent. Our inflation is falling: last month, I believe, it was 0.5 percent, and by the end of the year, it will be significant, probably around 11.9, maybe 12 percent. But we assume that in the coming years it will still have a tendency to decrease. Rather, this trend has already begun. We assume that we will be able to keep it under control.

And in general, we will strive in every way to maintain macroeconomic indicators with a very conservative approach to budget expenditures, keeping in mind that real wages have slightly declined at the moment. I am confident that they will grow in the future with the growth of the economy. But in this regard, we must move to (appropriate decisions will now be made at the legislative level) more targeted support in the social sphere. Here is a rough set of tools that we want to use to ensure further diversification and, of course, the necessary growth rates of the economy.

Now regarding Syria. As you said: the goal of the United States is to get rid of Assad, and the goal of Russia is to support Assad? The goal of the United States is to get rid of Assad. Perhaps that is so. Our goal is to defeat terrorism, to fight against terror, and to help President Assad achieve victory over terror, thereby creating conditions for the start of, and I hope, a successful political process of settlement. And I believe that this is the only correct way out.

A. Larijani: I would like to clarify that the conditions will not be as pessimistic as you said. You know, the countries you mentioned, over the past four years, when Syria has been involved in this story, periodically come to us and tell us that yes, in two weeks Bashar Assad will fall. And here we are, four and a half years later, seeing that he is still in power.

I would like to draw your attention to the fact that those countries where, over the past 70–80 years, there has not even been a single instance, not even a precedent of holding elections, have no right to speak about democracy in Syria and to say that Bashar Assad is not a democrat. Countries that do not allow women to drive cannot speak about democracy in Syria. There is a paradox in the region; it is even funny.

Therefore, it is necessary to pay attention to the fact that one cannot stubbornly govern the world. If two countries, regions say that yes, 100 percent Bashar Assad must go, what kind of illogical behavior is that? I remember that several years ago, one of the leaders (I had a meeting with him) of a country in the region, they were then at war with Iraq, when he saw me, said that this Prime Minister of Iraq must go because he spoke to me poorly on the phone. Then he said that Bashar Assad must also go. I said, I am talking to you for ten minutes, and you say two leaders must go. But in any case, one cannot stubbornly govern the world. Therefore, I think that in the future, one cannot have such a pessimistic view.

Negotiations must be held; ultimately, pragmatism must prevail.

R. Legvold: I want to apologize to those people who wanted to ask a question. And I want to express admiration for all of you for your patience, for your good questions, and, above all, on your behalf and on my own behalf, I want to thank our group of speakers, and also Larijani, and Václav Klaus, Mr. Putin, and Ambassador Metlaka for this work. And once again, I want to thank the organizers of the Valdai Club and especially the translators who worked well for us. Thank you.