Meeting with members of the factions of political parties in the State Duma

Russia Vladimir Putin · President of Russia

14 August 2014 · Crimea

Context
Putin met with State Duma faction members in Crimea on August 14, 2014, to discuss Crimea's integration, legislative progress, and regional development priorities.
Main themes
Crimea integration into Russia, State Duma legislative work, regional and municipal governance reform, infrastructure development, energy supply, transport connectivity, elections in Crimea, economic and social development, unity of political forces, transitional period measures
Duration
~158 min
99th percentile
Words
18,983
99th percentile
Sentences
1,113
99th percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
9.5
15th percentile
Syntax
2.81
23rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from Russian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 30%28%
  • Economic 25%24%
  • Institutional 18%17%
  • Social 15%14%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

1,113 sentences in 245 paragraphs

Good afternoon, esteemed colleagues, dear friends!

Our meeting today is taking place in Crimea, and we specifically wanted to meet with you here. First of all, I would like to thank all of you for your constant attention to the development of our new subjects of the Federation and, of course, for the consolidation, unity, and solidarity that all factions of the State Duma and all political forces of the country have shown during the fateful days for Sevastopol, for Crimea, and indeed for all of Russia.

Taking this opportunity, I would also like to note the fruitful and substantive work of the State Duma during the spring session. Amendments to the Constitution of the state were approved, and important laws affecting economic and social issues were adopted. In a short time, the so-called Crimean package of laws was considered, which allowed for the regulation of key areas of life in Crimea and Sevastopol during the transitional period, which was extremely important. This included the functioning of the banking and financial system, the payment of pensions and salaries, and a number of other important decisions that directly affect the interests of the people. In total, I remind you, 12 federal constitutional laws and 283 federal laws were adopted.

Finally, within the framework of the spring session, work began on improving the system of local self-government, with a decision made that significantly increases the role and responsibility of municipalities and regions. In general, a lot of work has been done, complex work, and of course, we deserve to meet in Crimea at this time.

If we talk about the decisions that have been made in the area of developing municipal and regional power, we can say that these are quite flexible approaches, and such flexible logic is fundamentally significant for the new subjects of the Russian Federation, for Crimea and Sevastopol, where much has to be done literally from scratch.

Here in September, as in many other regions of the country, elections will be held for state and local government bodies, and it is important that their further work is initially organized effectively, with clear distribution of powers and responsibilities.

And I repeat, the specifics and traditions of these regions, as well as the best municipal and regional management practices, must be taken into account. And above all, the interests of the people living in these territories must be prioritized.

I know that many deputies arrived in Crimea even before our meeting, and surely not just to enjoy the summer sun on the southern coast, but I also know that you met with people, and this is extremely important. Indeed, it is important, and extremely useful. In fact, the deputies of the State Duma constantly carry out such work in the territories. It was very important, of course, to be here and to communicate with the people.

A serious expert discussion also took place during the special seminars on economic issues and the history of Crimea that were held the day before. Many of the proposals and ideas voiced during the seminars, I hope we will discuss today. I generally propose that we do not just conclude our meeting today as an evening or day of questions and answers, but I expect that we will exchange some ideas and proposals. Both Dmitry Anatolyevich and I will be happy to listen to what you have formulated as proposals for the development of these territories.

There is a lot to be done here. A huge pile of problems has accumulated that have not been resolved for decades. Sometimes it seems that Crimea lived in the status of a poor relative. The previous authorities extracted much from it, giving little or practically nothing in return. My candid conversations with some leaders speak directly to this. They do not actually hide it.

Yes, there were many problems, and now there are even more in the country, there, in that country. And, of course, it was necessary to support other territories. Much was taken from Crimea, and little was given. Hence the neglected infrastructure, economy, social sphere, and the low income level of the majority of citizens. Now, within the framework of the transitional period, we are taking the most urgent priority measures to rectify the situation.

First. Work has been launched to improve the reliability of energy supply in Crimea. Reserve capacities have been created for key social facilities.

The next step is the integration of the energy systems of Crimea and the entire south of Russia, which will help to alleviate the energy deficit problem. Significant work is also underway to establish water supply and create new communication and telecommunications systems.

Second is infrastructure, the removal of transport restrictions. Despite the increase in the number of flights and ferries on the Kerch crossing, problems still remain. Additional work will be required from the Government and regional authorities. Such instructions have already been formulated and given.

I want to draw your attention to the fact that this year more than 5.6 billion rubles have been allocated from the federal budget for the improvement of roads in Crimea. We are starting to implement the project for the construction of the Kerch Bridge. Work at the site will begin in the coming weeks. The bridge crossing should be opened by the end of 2018.

Just yesterday, we discussed this issue and came to the conclusion that even if it is not fully loaded at first, we will still carry out this project, so to speak, for future growth, keeping in mind that there will definitely be a need to develop the port infrastructure.

Third is the social sphere. I have already mentioned: it is in a neglected state. This applies to both healthcare and education. This year, we will send about two billion rubles from the federal level for the modernization of hospitals and clinics in Crimea and Sevastopol. People who need high-tech medical assistance will be able to receive it in leading clinics in Russia. Funds for this have also been allocated: for 2014, half a billion rubles for Crimea and Sevastopol.

In the future, healthcare in Crimea and Sevastopol will operate within the framework of the compulsory medical insurance system of Russia. There will be an update and re-equipping of the entire network of medical organizations – from large hospitals to outpatient clinics and feldsher-obstetric points.

We will also bring the entire education system in order – from universities to kindergartens and children's recreation institutions. This is a large task, and it is certainly impossible or very difficult to do everything at once, but we will definitely proceed step by step along this path and will do everything.

I met yesterday with regional leaders in Sevastopol – there is a natural decline in the population. It is surprising. Birth rates are lower than the average in Russia. And where is this? In Crimea, on the Black Sea coast. It is truly incredible! So, a lot of work will have to be done.

I would like to note that children's health camps and sanatoriums in Crimea were fully booked during the first shift of this year. Children from Crimea and other regions of the country rested here. And literally these days, here in Crimea, the international youth forum "Tavrida" is taking place.

The potential for organizing children's and youth recreation in Crimea is very large, enormous, and of course, it has not been fully realized, but it must be realized. In this regard, I certainly support the proposal of Gennady Andreyevich Zyuganov to create a presidential international children's center based on the legendary "Artek."

Next. It was necessary to prioritize the issue of increasing pensions and salaries for budget workers. They were significantly lower than in Russia. We have been gradually increasing pensions and salaries. Thus, pensions in Crimea have already nearly doubled, closely approaching the average Russian level. From January 1, 2015, the payment of pensions and salaries for budget workers will be carried out in full accordance with the legislation of the Russian Federation.

Dear colleagues! Dear friends! At this time, the long-term tasks of economic and social development of Crimea and Sevastopol are becoming particularly important. A corresponding federal program has been prepared. The Government, and Prime Minister Dmitry Anatolyevich Medvedev, are paying great attention to this work. The total volume of the program until 2020 is over 700 billion rubles.

The main goal is to ensure the dynamic development of Crimea and Sevastopol, to make them economically self-sufficient and successful, to create new jobs, to update infrastructure, industry, agriculture, the social sphere, and the tourism complex. I expect that the deputies of the Duma and the regions you represent will actively engage in the implementation of these tasks and provide all necessary support to Crimea and Sevastopol.

A crucial condition for success is the preservation of stability, interethnic and interreligious harmony in the region. I spoke about this yesterday at a meeting of the Security Council in Sevastopol. Work must be fully carried out on the rehabilitation of repressed peoples and, what I believe is extremely important, real equality of the three languages: Russian, Ukrainian, and Crimean Tatar must be ensured. The preservation and development of the national cultures and traditions of all the peoples living here is an extremely important task.

Turning to history, I want to note the following. Crimea indeed occupies a special place in the history of our country, our homeland. The land of Crimea remembers both our triumphs and victories, but it also remembers the tragedy of the fratricidal Civil War and other woes. Here, at Perekop, blinded by mutual hatred, some Russians killed other Russians when, at the end of 1920, more than 150,000 of our compatriots were forced to leave their homeland.

But Crimea is also the poet Maximilian Voloshin, who called for reconciliation during the years of the Civil War, providing shelter in his home to both whites and reds. In recent months, I have received many letters from the descendants of those who left Russia after the revolution and the Civil War. They now live in all countries of the world – in America, Europe, and Australia. They live everywhere!

But I must note, and I speak about this with respect and love for these people, that in their letters there are words of support, faith in Russia, concern for the future of our country, and of course, for Crimea and Sevastopol. And these people have carried their love for the homeland through generations. This undoubtedly commands respect.

I believe that Crimea can be and today serves as a unique measure, and can play a unique, unifying role for Russia, becoming a kind of historical and spiritual source, another line of reconciliation for both reds and whites, so that we can finally heal the wound inflicted on our people as a result of the dramatic split of the 20th century, restore the connection of times, epochs, the unity of Russia's historical path, our national consciousness, and conduct a kind of cultural and historical therapy. And let us together, with the participation of deputies, representatives of parties, public and religious organizations, and cultural figures, think about how to implement this task.

Dear colleagues! We see today, unfortunately, the dangers of national and civil division, radicalism, and intolerance in Ukraine. The situation is becoming more dramatic by the day; the country has plunged into bloody chaos, into a fratricidal conflict. A large-scale humanitarian catastrophe has unfolded in the southeast, thousands of people have already died, and hundreds of thousands have become refugees, losing literally everything. It is a great tragedy.

We are closely monitoring what is happening there, raising these issues with the leadership of Ukraine, with the world community, and with key international organizations, and we will do everything in our power to ensure that this conflict is resolved as quickly as possible, so that blood stops being shed in Ukraine.

The Government of Russia has made a decision to limit imports from a number of countries that have imposed completely unfounded and illegal sanctions against Russia, as you know. But I want to emphasize that this is not just a retaliatory measure. This is primarily a measure to support domestic producers, as well as to open our markets to those countries and producers who want to cooperate with Russia and are ready for such cooperation.

At the same time, dear colleagues, whatever the external political and economic situation may be, for us now, as always, the main thing is our internal affairs, our goals, concerns, and tasks that the people of Russia, the citizens of Russia, set before us. We must focus on solving our national problems and tasks. Our future is only in our hands. We must ensure high-quality governance, the functioning of political and civil institutions. And most importantly, a high quality of life for citizens in Russia.

We must strengthen traditional values. By the way, in this choice, Russia is supported by millions of citizens not only in our country but also in many other countries around the world, including in Western countries, where these values are being actively destroyed in favor of current political circumstances.

We must ensure the successful development of the country, using our rich internal reserves. Create additional incentives for industrial and agricultural development, conditions for unlocking the creative potential of domestic producers, entrepreneurs, scientists, engineers, and workers.

All of this contributes to Russia's competitiveness and attractiveness. I repeat, we must calmly, dignifiedly, and effectively arrange our country, without isolating ourselves from the outside world, without severing ties with partners, but also not allowing anyone to treat us with disdain or condescension.

We must consolidate and mobilize. But not for wars or conflicts, not to confront anyone, but for hard work for the sake of Russia and for Russia.

It is very important to strengthen the cohesion of Russian society. Much depends on you, esteemed colleagues, on deputies, on politicians, on public figures. It depends on how convincing we will be in our conversations with our voters, with our citizens, how resolute and persistent we will be in implementing the initiatives, undertakings, and projects that we announce. The trust of citizens in power is the key, the most important, the most fundamental factor in our progress forward.

I want to thank you for our joint work over the previous period and wish you success. Thank you very much.

Dear colleagues, let us, as I suggested, get to work. We are, of course, ready, especially together with Dmitry Anatolyevich, to answer any of your questions. But I would propose that this be a substantive meeting, related to your proposals and ideas regarding the development of the country as a whole, and our joint work, primarily of a legislative nature, but also, of course, regarding the development of Crimea and Sevastopol.

Please, who will start?

S. Naryshkin: Vladimir Vladimirovich, I would like to first of all express, on behalf of my colleagues from the State Duma, our gratitude to you for the fact that our meeting is taking place in such a broad and open format and for the fact that the meeting is taking place here in Crimea, and you have already emphasized this, in Crimea, which 23 years ago, for various reasons, was essentially annexed, and now it is again part of Russia, an integral part of Russia, and now forever.

I think it is unnecessary to remind this audience that the task of reuniting Crimea united deputies from all factions of the State Duma, and the legislative formalization of this historically just step – in this, the deputies relied on both the Constitution of the Russian Federation and international law. And I am confident that even the most ardent critics and detractors will one day be forced to recognize that this step was taken both justly and, I repeat, on the basis of international law.

In the months following the reunification of Crimea, as you said, a whole series of laws (almost two dozen laws) were adopted, aimed at the consistent integration of Crimea into the legal space of the Russian Federation. And now our main task is the legislative support for the further socio-economic development of Crimea.

At the same time, of course, it is necessary to keep in mind that not only Crimea but also entire sectors of the Russian economy find themselves in new conditions – I mean external sanctions – and therefore we certainly need a systemic approach to the development and implementation of anti-sanction policies in close and operational interaction with the Government of the Russian Federation.

Undoubtedly, a number of legislative decisions will be required. At the same time, I would like to add that for us, the quality of laws is important, so that domestic law becomes increasingly stable, convenient for application, and understandable to people. This also applies to Russia's contribution to the development of international law, which today, more than ever, needs protection.

Since March, a working group has been operating in the State Duma to analyze legal acts and legislative procedures adopted in Ukraine. Experts note that the legal system of Ukraine is degrading. The amendments that were introduced by President Poroshenko to the Verkhovna Rada, amendments to the constitution, unfortunately, do not address the main and pressing issues that provoked the tragic confrontation in southeastern Ukraine. I mean, first of all, the issues of federalization and the status of the Russian language. Of course, this is an internal matter for Ukraine, on the one hand, but on the other hand, a whole chain of unlawful and illegitimate decisions and actions by the Kyiv authorities has led to a deep crisis, chaos, and, in essence, a civil war in a large European country.

Unfortunately, Western countries are responding inadequately to this. Obvious legal facts are being ignored, entire international institutions are failing, and unilateral and unlawful methods are being used, such as the sanctions against the Russian Federation. And it is clear that in such a situation we must be more united and cohesive.

It is only surprising that all this is happening in a year when we mark the 100th anniversary of the beginning of World War I. It would seem that historical memory should suggest that both unilateral actions and compromises are not only counterproductive but also dangerous. And I would like to remind you that both the entire modern system of international law and the modern architecture of global security have grown from the lessons of two world wars.

But at the same time, despite these difficulties, we must certainly maintain a dialogue with our Western partners, with parliamentarians from Western countries, especially since there are different politicians in Europe, both in the ruling parties and in the opposition. Therefore, we will continue to engage in dialogue with our colleagues, we will continue to speak the truth based on facts and specific legal arguments.

Thank you.

G. Zyuganov: Dear President! Dear colleagues!

Over the past 100 years, there have been six attempts to build a redoubt of various sanctions against our country, to deprive us of the opportunity to develop normally and to force us to submit to someone else's will. In fact, when the authorities showed character and will, and the people united and were one, we repelled all these sanctions and emerged even stronger, wiser, and more resilient. I am confident that such a resolution will come again now, but we have no right to relax.

In our memory, there was a default, when, with the help of foreign well-wishers, all financial and economic resources of the country were collapsed, but even then, even in those conditions, when a left-centrist policy was united and Primakov, Maslyukov, and Gerashchenko came together, these talented people pulled the half-dead country back from the brink of the abyss in a matter of months. At that time, a barrel of oil cost 10-12 dollars, and there were only 6-7 billion in gold and foreign currency reserves, which were not enough for pensions and scholarships in September.

Crimea has shown us how to solve problems in emergency conditions, and we must first of all welcome and thank the President. Our comrades and friends are present here – Aksyonov, Konstantinov, and Chaly, who united, came together, and all factions acted as one, and the people brilliantly came to the referendum and voted. Even against this will, the entire pack that seized power in Kyiv was unable to resist.

Crimea is an example and a lesson for us, and we must do everything to successfully implement the program that you announced today, Vladimir Vladimirovich. Our faction, the deputies are ready for this: we have traveled to all districts, all collectives, and looked at how problems are being solved. There are still many difficulties and problems, but they are solvable; we must support Crimea's efforts in financial, organizational, and legislative terms and make it a truly popular health resort. And for "Artek," I express gratitude to all of you – it is the best children's health resort in the world. And I assure you, you will see in the coming years how it will flourish and prosper.

Donbass is a lesson for all of us about what this semi-fascist, Nazi-Bandera power can do to its own citizens if it is allowed to do so. Therefore, we must think through a whole series of measures that would stop this extremely dangerous invasion both for the Russian Federation as a whole and for Crimea.

Vladimir Vladimirovich, you have recently been pursuing, in my opinion, a policy of realism. It was first marked in Munich when you honestly told both America and all of Europe that "you are rolling a NATO tank against us, although we have essentially fulfilled all our obligations." Then you stated at Valdai the need to unite Russia's thousand-year history in unity, whether imperial, Soviet, or current, taking the best from all of it. Special attention was paid to culture, the Russian language, and the creation of a new history textbook, which our Chairman of the Duma is working on closely. And this is all part of the common effort.

In international terms, BRICS is increasingly uniting and strengthening financially and organizationally. And your last meeting with the President of Egypt (from Cairo, all the problems of the Arab world are visible) is of exceptional importance for strengthening our country's positions.

At the same time, without influencing the situation in our native and fraternal Ukraine, it is difficult to hope for a successful overcoming of sanctions as well. I recently read the ideas of the Russophobe Brzezinski. Even he came to the conclusion that to overcome the crisis in Ukraine, only a few decisions need to be made: lift sanctions against Russia, agree that Crimea has returned to its native harbor, to its historical homeland, do not drag Ukraine into the EU and NATO, and maintain trade and economic relations between Ukraine and Russia.

I absolutely agree that if we go down this path, the turmoil in Ukraine will end, peace will be restored, and this fraternal republic will develop successfully. But we must keep in mind and not be deluded by such a scenario and development of events. The United States today has a colossal debt – 17 trillion dollars. It is practically impossible to survive and digest it without at least a medium-scale war or the seizure of foreign markets.

The American market is comparable to the European market. The European market is also one of the most important for us. Our trade turnover with Europe is 440 billion dollars, while with the Americans it is only 26. Therefore, the Americans have set the task – at any cost to seize the European market, claiming that they helped Europe, there was a corresponding Marshall Plan, now Europe must make room, give up its market, and we, combining our potentials, will be able to burn our insane debts.

But to dig a trench between Russia and Europe, the situation in Ukraine is very convenient, and their leaders, their politicians, their military command a special operation in the southeast, recklessly bombing their own cities, digging this trench. Therefore, we must now mobilize all our capabilities to influence European sentiments; they are listening to you. Europe is frightened by this development of events because then they will have to receive gasoline, diesel, and gas on ration cards from the Americans. But in this regard, we may face even more serious problems in the coming years.

In this regard, it seems to me that we all need to think about a new financial and economic course. You outlined the main features in your last Address, but it is fundamentally important for us to work out a whole series of details. In my opinion, we must tell ourselves that the liberal model is contraindicated for Russia. It is flawed in its essence, it squanders our resources and personnel and does not allow the country to focus on the main problems. Think about it, one and a half million highly qualified specialists have fled the country. We need them, and we must think about how to bring them back. Many of them would return with pleasure.

This year we will sell raw materials worth about 16 trillion rubles, and only about 6 will go to the treasury. 10 trillion – we pay tribute to our foreign former patrons and local oligarchs. Absolutely unfair! As for capital outflow, everyone is concerned. Experts from the Government of Russia say that by the end of the year, it will be about 110 billion. This is another 5 trillion rubles, more than a third of the budget, and plus our debts, they are accumulating; this half-year will see 99 billion dollars and next year about 112. In total, 200.

And if we take offshore accounts (you spoke very harshly in your Address, saying that in 2012, 111 billion dollars were funneled through offshore accounts), we need to increase our pressure here. Bastrykin has prepared an excellent law on this topic, including on the responsibility of legal entities. But who is opposing it? It turns out Ulyukaev is against it, continuing to benefit those who siphon off huge capital from Russia.

You have very actively supported our idea of new industrialization, strategic planning, and industrial policy. The law is ready. I propose to the entire Duma and our comrades, we have agreed with all factions, to introduce it at the first September session and adopt it urgently; then much can be taken into account when forming the three-year plan. We have Gazprom, but there is a lot of gas, and very little industrial processing.

This is generally a colossal source of income! We have a million kilometers of pipelines, of which 700 thousand are either rotting or require repairs. Gas processing will allow us to produce super-class pipes and solve this problem for housing and utilities and others. This gives a colossal effect, and for Crimea, it is a real lifeline, and we could test our first results in Crimea.

I welcome your efforts in the defense industry. This is very correct. Thank you for the MiG-31; you made a historic decision. We had five regiments that secured the Arctic for us; the Arctic is our future. Everyone scattered, flew away; now there is an opportunity to form. But transport problems, problems with forests, villages, and construction are knocking on our doors, and we should work on this.

As for the village, we could have used this historical moment to make an effort. 41 million hectares are overgrown with weeds. Let's put them into circulation, let's work, let's not allocate 1 percent as usual for these purposes, but from the expenditure part of the budget. The Soviet country spent 20, America today spends 24, Europe – 33, and we again have 1.

10-12 is the minimum that will allow us to solve many problems. We could feed half the world with excellent products. As for Crimea (the Amlinskaya Valley) – an orchard 80 kilometers long, this is the best orchard in the world, vineyards, and everything else. We could invest, and everyone living there would be delighted. Konstantinov is nodding his head, agreeing and supporting, even smiling. So we could actively work in this direction.

And Dmitry Anatolyevich is here. Dmitry Anatolyevich, you see, if foreign policy is oriented towards state-patriotic ideas, strengthening security, sovereignty, the dignity of the Russian language, and culture, then the economic block of the Government cannot pursue a liberal policy; agrarians cannot engage in anything but solving the problems of the village; the Washington consensus cannot dictate conditions to us regarding the development of education and science. We have a great Russian, Soviet school, and much more. You need to solve this problem. We discussed it, and you were determined to address it.

And special attention to the regions: one trillion seven hundred billion in debt. If we do not help them, if we do not support the industry, it pays 40 percent of its money in taxes. In China, it’s a maximum of 25. We could reduce that and give the opportunity to update the production and industrial apparatus at enterprises.

In general, all these problems are solvable with political will, support from the President, and the collective efforts of our faction. Right now we will be forming the budget, and we are ready for very responsible work. And ahead of us, in September, are the elections. We are holding a meeting in Crimea, for which I thank you.

But we need to focus on the elections. I would gladly swim tomorrow, but we need to fly today. Let’s move the elections to October or March, and everyone will be satisfied, everyone will be satisfied. Therefore, I propose that this decision also be adopted at the meeting.

Today we have Komoyedov – the commander of the Black Sea Fleet, a birthday boy, and today is Honey Spas. Let’s congratulate our admiral on his birthday.

V. Zhirinovsky: We decided, as in the State Duma, that the CPRF, LDPR, United Russia, and Fair Russia will speak.

We can talk a lot about domestic politics, but it all ends badly when mistakes are made in foreign policy. A hundred years ago, the Russian Empire was a sweet treat; everything was great in the summer of 1914. We were drawn into war, and you know how it ended. By 1940, the Soviet Union was the second sweet treat, but we were drawn in again, and you know how it ended. The conclusion: for a thousand years, Russia has taken a defensive position; we wait for someone to attack us.

I will not go back a thousand years; let’s take Napoleon: he is waiting for the outcome of the war in Lithuania. The young tsar is not thinking clearly, sitting in St. Petersburg and allowing Napoleon to capture all of Russia, burn Moscow, and only then can we catch up with the French and eventually win. 1941: everything was clear; it was about to start, it was definitely going to start. Give the order to begin on June 20 and crush the Germans on Polish territory. No, we wait. Fear, inability, mistakes; therefore, this is very costly. That’s one point.

The second point. Russia flourished, was born, and can develop only in the format of an empire. Any republic – Soviet, federal, popular, democratic – is destructive. Therefore, until we determine the form of the state, we may even need to raise the question of restoring the empire. Who is stopping us? Spain restored the monarchy; nothing happened. We need to understand the format of development.

Here’s a simple example – the climate. I feel bad here; it’s hot for me. My climate is Arkhangelsk, Leningrad Oblast, even Vorkuta. Here I am suffocating. What should I do? Live where my body feels better. So it is with Russia. It feels bad in the format of a republic, in the format of friendship among peoples, in the format of options: liberalism is not needed, capitalism is not needed, socialism is bad. You cannot do that; you cannot solve issues this way. This country is a different country; we cannot be compared to anyone. Therefore, we must start first. And Stalin had a plan to start earlier and crush the Germans on Polish territory, but he lacked the resolve. Generals also suggested crushing Napoleon in Poland. Therefore, the option: development cannot proceed within the framework of a republic, it cannot proceed within this democracy, as we have: elections, parties, trade unions, elections in the fall, elections in the spring. What difference does it make? These elections are not needed at all. Who will choose whom? How do you know who these people are? We choose blindly. Do we even know who we are choosing? If earlier, under Soviet power, at least in the labor collective, we knew who he was, now a person comes and starts saying anything. Who knows him? No one.

Elections are a farce, invented in the West – a performance. There is one party, but for appearances, they come from the Democratic, from the Republican. In all of Western Europe, there is one party, but they stage a show for their voters. And why do we need to stage a show? We need power. Our economy can only be militarized. If we carry out the militarization of the entire economy, if we again bring our army to the western borders, I am not saying to go to war – just to have it stand here. It is standing beyond the Urals, somewhere in the south – we need to place the army here, a million, two million. They are cowardly; they are afraid; they need to be taken by fear, by the whip. We are the carrot: here is our budget. For ten years, the budget went there, to the West. We need to, we need to; it’s profitable, Kudrin explained to us that it’s profitable, and now what? Now they are hitting us in the face with our own money, so there is no benefit in sending money there or only engaging in trade here. The whole country is trading. Now we are starting to maybe build factories, so militarization, mobilization, strict propaganda day and night, so that they are afraid.

I once said one phrase to the Finns – in two weeks, the military budget of Finland was increased by 30 percent. One of my phrases – and the budget increases by 30 percent. We will set up propaganda so that we bankrupt them, so that they are afraid that tanks are moving towards Kyiv, tanks can reach Brussels, we can occupy you in a day, capture, destroy; we must declare that we have new weapons. Their missile systems are of no use to us; they do not threaten us; we need to test new weapons. We must understand that the plan "Barbarossa-2" is signed, and are we waiting for June 22? No, now we must start on June 20. How and where – that is decided by the military, the General Staff, and everyone else, but we must finally understand what kind of world we are in. They laugh at us; they mock us; the Russian language is banned all over the world, and what are they doing today? They are killing Russians. You sit and watch: we drive them away and will not let them come to you as refugees. And we will shoot them, we will execute them, we will bomb maternity hospitals, hospitals. And you send humanitarian aid. What is this – Russia? For the tsar to send humanitarian aid to the Serbs a hundred years ago? He sent the army! That was a mistake, but the army went. If it weren’t for the Bolsheviks, our army would have been in Berlin in 1918.

Now we are modern Russia; we are finally taking the right steps, starting first. Well, where are we rushing to in Afghanistan? These are our allies – the Muslim world. Another mistake of Russia – we have always gone west. We have no friends or allies in the West. We need to go south, but go in peace, as allies. And the only right thing Lenin did was the first treaties of friendship – Afghanistan, Iran, Turkey. That’s it! All the rest are imperialists.

In 2001, Vladimir Vladimirovich, when the attack on New York happened, you called us to the Kremlin, the leaders of parties and factions. You asked: "What to do?" Everyone told you: "Get under Bush," – except for me. I told you: "Show solidarity with the Muslim world, tell them – do not be afraid, no one will bomb you, Russia is with you!" I was the only one who said this, and the transcript is in the Kremlin.

Today we are turning to the Muslim world. Egypt, Erdogan (Turkey), we are strengthening ties with Iran. Fourteen years have been lost! Who are these advisors in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, who are these advisors in your entourage who give you orientation towards the West? I came, Chubais is the head of the Administration: "Come on, a great deal with Iran, money." – "No, we will earn with the Americans, we will help, we will cooperate in space." Well, we cooperated in space!

Chubais is an enemy. This is monstrous! How can there be an institute named after Gaidar, a fund named after Gaidar, a fund named after Yeltsin, Yeltsin Street, a bust to Yeltsin? He gave away the whole country in one night! He drank away the whole country on December 8, 1991. And they erected monuments to him! You should know this too.

We cannot live under this white-red-blue flag. This is a trade flag, this is the flag of Vlasov, the flag of Kerensky. We need the black-yellow-white flag of the Russian Empire. Under this flag, we achieved the maximum success.

We need a different name for the state, a different name for your position – supreme ruler. If you do not want "emperor," let’s say "supreme ruler." Although "Emperor Vladimir the First" would sound good. Then they will respect.

Maybe we should also return the anthem "God Save the Tsar!" "The Union of the Ages" united the peoples, while the peoples spit in our faces every day. This would be a magnificent anthem: "Save your leader, save your country; it is your only one." And with this anthem, the Russian army indeed marched forward and won.

We entered Afghanistan with the army; that should not have been done. We began to conduct an offensive policy under Brezhnev, and they were afraid. But if we entered, we should not have left! One mistake – we enter with weapons; another – we leave. We should not leave: dig in and sit. If helicopters are shot down – there’s no need to fly helicopters; sit in the catacombs! Bury yourself with tanks! Set up diversions everywhere. Arrest them all at night. Shoot them all at night. And people like Najibullah would be sitting in Afghanistan today. Today!

Therefore, everything can be done, as today in Ukraine. What do we have, no means that can destroy an entire column of tanks in 15 minutes, an entire column of armored personnel carriers in 15 minutes, demolish entire streets in cities? And all this is the current armament of the Russian army. Why not test it and show what our army is capable of? It is not necessary to introduce it. What is the whole world doing? The Americans, the American army is fighting? Volunteers are fighting! And we could have millions of volunteers fight there, release them from prisons, create penal battalions and say: "Not a step back! Here is Luhansk, Donetsk, and further – to Odesa and Transnistria!" And they will plow everything day and night, just to avoid returning to our prisons.

Therefore, the direction is south, not west. We got this cursed Poland; we have been dealing with this Poland for so long, and Poland is making Ukraine just as hostile, Poland has made the Baltics hostile. Why do we need this Poland? We defeated Napoleon! Why did we leave Paris? Our army would still be standing there today, and there would be no war at all. We left Berlin; our army would be standing there today. That is, this should all be the policy that the Russian Empire and the Soviet Union conducted. I am not making anything up; I am taking all the best that was in Tsarist Russia and in the Soviet Union, when not a single gun was fired in Europe until the Russian tsar gave his consent! When a bad performance started in Paris, the tsar called and said: "Do you need 100,000 new spectators in your Paris theater?" They understood and shut up; the performance was canceled. When, Vladimir Vladimirovich, Alexander III, and England provoked a war between Russia and Turkey, he was informed, and he struck like this: "All the treasury for war!" It reached London, everything stopped. The tsar said one phrase: "All the treasury for war!" A powerful hand like that – the table almost cracked, and quickly the spies reported to the British ambassador. And he: "Everything, everything, we are doing nothing, everything is fine, there will be no war." They must be afraid, afraid every day and every hour! We need a different Minister of Foreign Affairs! We need a Minister of Propaganda. There are good ministers; maybe they are working. But there are things where there should be people of a special caliber, so that he says and half of Europe, so to speak, is afraid, their legs are shaking. Therefore, we must turn to the Muslim world, although there are already many anti-Russian regimes there. We could have cooperated with Saddam Hussein, with Gaddafi, and we could have befriended Islamic Iran long ago.

In 2000, the LDPR said: "Recognize the Taliban government." You recognize it, and the whole world recognizes it 15 years late. But if they had recognized it then and preserved it, instead of overthrowing it, there would not have been that flow of drugs. They destroyed all drugs, and they did not need Central Asia. They needed Pashtunistan. We need to have orientalists everywhere. Our East is burning; the Eurasian space is ours, and forget about Poland. And tell the Baltics that there are so many NATO tanks and planes that in the event of a major war, we cannot guarantee the existence of these states. I have already said this. They are all running around and trembling; they are all afraid.

In conclusion, understanding that Sergei Mikhailovich wants something, the "left" always wants something, there will be questions. That is, the structure of the country, its shell, how it functions naturally, is of great importance. Now we are not natural. We fought against the propaganda of homosexuality among children. But when will we fight against the propaganda of the perverted structure of our own country? The tsar would not have tolerated this, nor would the Soviet power. What kind of country have you created in terms of structure, economy, culture, and so on? They are all mocking us today. This has never happened: neither under the tsar would anyone have dared to kill Russians anywhere, nor under Soviet power. They all disrespected us – they were afraid. We need to create new bases, a new fleet, so that everything "boils, hums, rumbles," and to air-drop our investigators, arrest everyone who commits crimes there. My last phrase: "Can our commanders not tear foreign uniforms on Russian bayonets?!"

Why are you not standing up, LDPR? Why are you sitting like lost souls? I said for everyone to stand up. You clap poorly. I will take note of you. You see how they are afraid, Vladimir Vladimirovich. Even in one party, thanks to me, they came, and they are all afraid, what if it’s not right, what if Vladimir Vladimirovich says: we don’t need this, and they will run to sign up for United Russia.

No, no, yours will not run; I already know. But since we still have a broadcast and a television recording, I want to say: everything that was said by Vladimir Wolfovich is his personal opinion. It does not always coincide with the official position of the Russian Federation. But it ignites beautifully.

V. Zhirinovsky: Freedom of speech.

Yes, we have freedom of speech.

Please.

V. Vasiliev: Dear Vladimir Vladimirovich! Esteemed colleagues, all participants of the meeting!

I want to thank you now, Vladimir Vladimirovich, for this meeting taking place at such a high level, that we were all able to gather here and inform you that, as you mentioned in your speech, the United Russia faction has been working here with people, with citizens, with voters, although Crimea did not elect the lower house, the highest legislative body of the country. Therefore, we are fulfilling (by the way, all factions, as far as we can judge, are doing this too) our duties to the new citizens of our Russia.

During the short time we have been here, in addition to what has been and is being done constantly, meetings have been held with 20,800 residents of Crimea at 228 different venues – at factories, in institutions, in the fields. There was a very frank, direct conversation. And I must say that almost all questions were clarified in your response. People are asking the very questions: how will they live going forward, how will the management system work. Many express concern about the participation in the management system because the region has developed, or rather existed, as part of Ukraine for a long time. And today, of course, the level of development in Russia is different, and much will depend on who will work on the program you mentioned, which, by the way (we used it at all meetings), was the basis of our responses and the absolute understanding of all the audiences we met with. So, we need to look at what already exists, apparently. First of all, there is an amazing experience, although it also raised doubts for some – Sochi. Today there is a program, there are funds, there is an incredible energy of the people that can be realized precisely in this program. There is an expectation, and this program for Crimea can have a very powerful effect overall. By the way, what is interesting is that ordinary people, Vladimir Vladimirovich, are asking: “How does Russia feel about allocating such large sums to us?” This is a very important point; people think about this, ordinary people, and say: “We would really like to,” – and we talked about this too, including with the police authorities, with law enforcement, – and much depends on how effectively these funds will be spent. It is clear that there is federal control, and we, of course, as the parliament, all factions, will help, control, and ensure within our powers. But if we succeed, the whole country – and we talked about this in the teams – will see where the money went, and what we talked about, the valley will supply apples to all of Russia, we will receive wonderful agricultural products, and not only that, we will rest here at a high level, and we will not have to go to distant foreign seas – this is already happening. This is great energy, great strength. And therefore, of course, there is such a proposal – we discussed it in the faction, perhaps in terms of assistance, a lot of work is being done by the Government, Dmitry Nikolayevich Kozak, in particular, we had the opportunity to meet with him here. To think about whether our young personnel, whom you mentioned and who are now coming to power during the elections, both in the executive and legislative branches, could be given the opportunity to intern in our teams, in our regions that are leading in Russia today, where there is much to learn, at the level of human immersion in the real situation. This, by the way, will help solve another problem that those who work here feel well. Many markets that Ukraine closed to producers, we can open in Russia, and it is good to do this, again, in such direct human immersion, personal dimension. So we thought it necessary to bring this topic up for discussion in your presence.

And what I would also like to say. You spoke, and colleagues also touched on this topic, that a number of legislative acts have been adopted, we have those that concern the agricultural complex, those that concern economic development, you mentioned this, and my colleagues spoke about it, and Sergey Evgenyevich. I do not want to waste precious time on this, but I want to note one thing.

Despite the disagreements that have been voiced and will probably be voiced again, we have, and my colleagues mentioned this, a unified understanding that Crimea has united us. We vote, we make decisions. And, Vladimir Vladimirovich, when you spoke about this, I am convinced that in today’s Duma there will be no problems of inter-factional understanding and interaction regarding these important laws that we are discussing today, which we know and represent well.

There are several problems that are at the forefront. Money will come now, land will need to be allocated, housing will need to be built, facilities will need to be constructed. Many issues will have to be resolved manually. Recently, at the Government meeting, Dmitry Anatolyevich demonstrated such an approach when the Ministry of Finance critically expressed its opinion regarding the volumes for specific areas of funding and noted that there is expert opinion about overestimation in two or more times in some areas.

Dmitry Nikolayevich reported on the work of the reconciliation commission, and a very correct decision was made, I believe, not to stop the commission, in terms of the program, it is very much awaited, it is needed “yesterday.” But the amounts should be determined in each case specifically, for each facility publicly, with the involvement of experts. This is a good mechanism, as it seems to us, and it should be applied in these matters as well.

As for the issues that essentially hinder development, and there are many of them – this is the issuance of documents to citizens, this is the work on issuing, by the way, a simple, seemingly straightforward matter – transport documents for vehicles, many people addressed these issues at meetings. And many others. Here we just need to gather and resolve, and work until we solve them. We cannot delay.

And we, for our part, the deputies, not only collected all the numerous appeals and will work with them in committees, in the Duma, but we will also work, of course, and coming back here, answering before those teams before whom we spoke together with our candidates for what we have done, so that we are not ashamed. As in February, remember, we came, met with people, and today no one is ashamed. Thank you, Vladimir Vladimirovich, people appreciate this very much.

And what is very important? The people are in a very good mood. People are ready to endure much more, understanding that the situation will be significantly better. And what you said today, Vladimir Vladimirovich, is very important, that our task, and here I want to argue with my colleagues, especially to contradict Vladimir Wolfovich, is not to scare people and the world and arm ourselves, but to become stronger and create a more comfortable environment and better conditions for our population. This is a clear policy, for it the majority of Russians always vote.

At the same time, I cannot help but express a few points on important issues that have been raised here from the perspective of our faction.

First. What is happening in Ukraine is precisely attempts to follow foreign recommendations and simple solutions, irresponsibly following them before their own people. Why did we come here? To consult with the people. Who told you that they want a big war? Is there anyone here? Tell me, did anyone say? After all, they have refugees living there, they are losing loved ones, they understand this. I heard something else: “Will you not abandon us if they continue to pressure you?” – “We will not abandon you,” I said.

But changes are happening with us, they have occurred, we have become more patriotic, we have become more united, we have begun to think more about how the weak and least protected feel in the country. By the way, my colleagues mentioned that the political sector seems to have increased too much. But, on the other hand, look at how this affects other processes. We have a different situation in the country. Those who want to manifest themselves in political work have such an opportunity. And, as they say, everyone can. And if this is not for long, as colleagues say, one-day wonders, well, they will die like one-day wonders. Those who prove themselves in action will win.

And a very important point, it concerns the work of the Government. You know, the path we have taken is not ideal, but it is our path, and every step has not been easy for us – there have been successes, there have been failures, everything has happened. And now to throw it all away and rush there – that is the question. By the way, this path has led us to the point where we can now speak like this; we are the fifth largest economy in the world.

Vladimir Vladimirovich, I would like to emphasize, I find your remark about our readiness to cooperate, to fulfill our obligations, very important, and the fact that you recently launched drilling in the Kara Sea is evidence of that. Russia has always upheld its obligations, especially in the interests of our partners. We can do a lot. The whole problem is that the leaders, primarily of European states, acted based on (and this was also mentioned) instructions from Washington, without consulting their own people. Now, it seems, they will have to consult because they will be losing jobs. The anti-sanctions that have been adopted, which, by the way, especially the peasants in Russia support warmly, will lead to the point that by autumn I do not know where our traditional suppliers and producers of fruit and vegetable products will take their goods. And they will have to answer to their voters for these steps. It seems that sobering is coming, and here, I think, we should act consistently and not succumb in any way.

This exists, it happens, well, how much longer can it go on, they are killing people. You talk to people: they are killing defenseless people, women, the elderly, children nearby, relatives are being killed. We are ringing all the bells, Russia, and diplomatic methods, well, the President is constantly working. We have already reached the point where the chairman of the parliament, members of parliament are not allowed to work in Europe with the parliament. Parliaments should find solutions. We have reached this point. Now, it seems, they have also begun to understand that, apparently, it will not work like this. One point of view. Well, how can this be? So, I would very much like to draw attention to the fact that there were such harsh proposals, decisions that, for some part of the people, especially in a certain situation, strangely find a response, and there were applause, isn’t that true?

Therefore, the first thing I would like to support. That we can do a lot today to use this energy of unification, the energy of the feeling that we can do a lot together for our people and for our country, but to use it primarily for peaceful purposes. This is the first. It is clear that we need to protect peace, and this has been demonstrated to us. Those who are unable are not taken into account. This is also clear. And this is being done. And, by the way, everyone present here voted for the budget. By the way, colleagues, while criticizing the Government, remember: the last budget was voted on by everyone. This is a rare case. Everyone voted! It was convincingly reported, wasn’t it? Convincingly! And it seems to me that our greatest danger is to act emotionally, to go on emotions. And what is most concerning, and this cannot but worry us, is that our society is also radicalizing under these conditions. People see injustice, first of all, which is happening every day not only in Ukraine, but in the world. Now, with great difficulty, a humanitarian convoy has been directed to people who have nothing to eat, and there are no basic medical supplies. People are simply being finished off there, and they are not even allowing the convoy in. This outrages people, it is clear. And in this situation, such calls find supporters, and they are becoming more numerous. Some want to return to the past. But it will not be possible to return to the past! We need to make today better, which is what the conversation was about. And our faction, our party will firmly stand on this position.

I would like to thank everyone once again and say a big thank you to the deputies of the State Duma and especially our faction, who have honestly done their work. Colleagues, we will continue to engage in this, helping the people of Crimea, our friends, to solve the most complex tasks.

Thank you.

S. Mironov Mironov Sergey Mikhailovich, head of the faction of the political party "Fair Russia – For Truth" in the State Duma: Dear Vladimir Vladimirovich! Dear colleagues!

It is very important that our meeting today takes place in a place of historical events of recent times. Looking back, we are once again convinced that the return of multinational Crimea to Russia was absolutely the right, the only possible decision. Crimea and the Hero City of Sevastopol are an integral part of Russia. And this is a fact today. And forever these two subjects of the Russian Federation will be Russian territory. There is no other way.

Dear Vladimir Vladimirovich!

I want to thank you for the unique format and, of course, for the uniqueness of the place where the meeting is taking place today, because such a meeting of the President of the Russian Federation together with the Chairman of the Government, with the factions of the State Duma, and here are present the acting heads of the executive authorities of two subjects of the Russian Federation, our colleagues – both Aksyonov and Menyaylo, of course, this is a unique format. And for this, thank you separately.

I would like to talk about what is happening on the international stage, what is happening with our closest, most blood-related neighbors in Ukraine. Today, double standards reign on the international stage: ignorance and fanaticism. The verbal escapades we hear from high-ranking officials of the United States of America are simply shocking. From international tribunes, probably, lies have not been told like this since Machiavelli. And today it is considered some kind of international norm.

I would like to express my opinion regarding the so-called Western sanctions. This is primarily an attempt to humiliate our country, to put it in some place that is seen from Washington, to indicate our place somewhere in the gallery of the geopolitical theater. It will not work! Russia is not the kind of country that can have conditions dictated to it. And it is not the kind of country that can be told its place. Russia is one of the most powerful centers of a multipolar world, and this is indeed a fact today.

The scale of the sanctions is hardly dependent today on any hypothetically possible concessions on our part. Here, rather, there is a feedback: the more accommodating we are, the harsher the sanctions may turn out to be.

Today, one of the key tasks for our entire country, primarily for the leadership of the country and the Federal Assembly, is to maintain stable development and modernization in the face of increasing pressure from the United States of America and its satellites. Our country must emerge from the current international crisis strengthened in every respect, primarily in the economic sphere.

Sanctions must not even minimally affect the implementation of the well-known May decrees of the President of our country. It is now clearer than ever that within the framework of sanctions, artificial problems can be created regarding access to the accounts of the Reserve Fund and the National Wealth Fund, which, as we know, are located abroad. The question of the need to abandon this practice, where a significant portion of our revenues is taken abroad and kept in foreign banks, has always been criticized by our faction. And today, the inefficiency of such a policy is, in our opinion, obvious. We need to seriously work on bringing all our assets back home; it is time to gather the stones.

The current situation forces us to more actively utilize internal sources of growth in Russia. Today, Russia, paraphrasing Kant, must first and foremost be a country for itself, not a country for others. Today, we live in the fifth technological order, one of its most important technologies is working with mass consciousness; there is a struggle for the minds and souls of people. The significance of the information space in the modern world is hard to overestimate.

A vivid example. Western Ukraine has never had sufficient economic resources and potential, but, as it turns out, for 20 years they have been building up an ideological potential with a negative sign, but it is indeed an ideological potential. The result is known: extreme Russophobia, brought in from outside. If we do not reclaim and develop our information space, it will undoubtedly be occupied by others. The vacuum in the minds and hearts of people, especially the youth, will inevitably be filled by external forces, and we need to work very seriously on this.

Russophobia has today become the calling card of many Western politicians. I am convinced that Russia must respond clearly and firmly to all its manifestations; it is time to honestly say: Russians today are the largest divided people in Europe. We cannot remain indifferent and must respond harshly to any manifestations of Russophobia, especially if it escalates into direct violence against our compatriots. I will say it plainly: we need to keep our finger not only on the pulse but on the throat of those who allow themselves to make Russia and Russians the number one enemy, and this should be a practice not only internationally but also in parliament and simply a practice for all citizens of our country.

We support the idea of considering the fight against the threat of fascism and neo-Nazism anywhere on the planet as one of the main strategic national priorities of Russia, regardless of who these ideas and waves originate from. This provision must be enshrined in the National Security Strategy.

Our country, which bore the full weight of the fight against fascism during the Great Patriotic War, during World War II, and suffered the greatest losses from this "brown plague," has every right to do so. In any part of the world where fascism, social nationalism, or radical nationalism raises its head, Russia must respond by all available, reasonable, and effective means.

We regularly hear very belligerent statements from Kyiv: these gentlemen are either planning to hold a parade in Sevastopol or are directly declaring an impending war with Russia. We see that there is an additional call-up to the Ukrainian army, we see that the length of service for reserves is being increased, a war tax is being introduced, and so on; cooperation with NATO is being intensified.

Dear Vladimir Vladimirovich!

The Kyiv regime is clearly preparing for a large war. Under the patronage of the United States of America and under the guidance of American instructors, it may embark on any military adventure. At the same time, it is clear that their goals are not limited to the desire to suppress the just uprising in eastern Ukraine. Given the geopolitical specificity of Crimea and its territorial isolation, it is necessary to create a separate command on the peninsula, stationed by a grouping of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation.

And one more thing, Vladimir Vladimirovich. You made a strategically correct decision: to double the number of Airborne Troops over the next 4-5 years. As a senior sergeant of the Airborne Troops, I am absolutely convinced that in the future, a Crimean airborne division must be established, stationed in Crimea.

Due attention must be paid to the development of military infrastructure and equipping the grouping of forces with modern weapons and military equipment, so that the Kyiv regime, despite its fervor, does not even entertain the thought of turning history back.

Today in Russia, it is very important for all of us to maintain the internal unity that arose in society after the return of Crimea home. At the same time, the events taking place in Donbas present our society with a very difficult choice. I am convinced that Russia needs to take a tougher stance towards the Kyiv authorities. We must support the struggle of the citizens of Ukraine for their right to self-determination. As I have already publicly stated, our party officially recognized the Donetsk and Luhansk People's Republics immediately after the referendums on May 11. The lack of a clear position on our part today deprives us of full opportunities to protect peaceful citizens, does not allow us to achieve an end to the bloodshed and mass destruction of the population. There must be a clear response from Russia to the shelling of Russian territory from Ukraine. This is, in fact, an act of aggression. A citizen of the Russian Federation has already died, there are wounded, our property is being destroyed. The aggressor must be destroyed by a retaliatory strike. We believe that it should be only this way.

Dear colleagues! Given the unprecedented behavior and actions of the West, it is time to develop new doctrines for the internal and external policies of the Russian Federation. They must be a reasonable response to modern challenges and threats. We are for Russia, we are for the multinational Russian people and for those who have risen today against the lawlessness of Ukrainian oligarchs and neo-Nazis! Today, this is our joint task, the task of all responsible politicians in Russia. How we solve it will determine the future of our Motherland.

Thank you for your attention.

Dear colleagues! I don’t even know if there is any point in commenting on anything, but I will say a couple of words anyway. As we approach a very important moment (not now, but in general in our work), we will have to adopt the budget in the fall, approve it; this is a complicated process, as usual, ultimately resulting from compromises between sectors, between individual spheres of our life. Some priorities have already been voiced here; I generally share them, without such extreme assessments, but nevertheless. We talked about the need for further development of agriculture. The Chairman of the Government has already mentioned that, taking into account the decisions made regarding import restrictions, we will certainly create not only this preference for our agricultural producers, clearing the market for them. I must tell you, and there are people here who are professionally engaged in this, you know that recently there has been a constant request from our agricultural producers, primarily regarding the market: give us a full, solid opportunity to develop our own market. But such an opportunity is being created. Of course, as expected, another question immediately arises: help us materially as well. This is a legitimate question. In fact, this is the right way to frame the question. And I repeat, we have discussed this with colleagues in the Government, and the Government will now prepare such an additional support program for agriculture.

Now regarding the militarization of the economy. You know, we had complete militarization in the Soviet Union. We need capable, modern, effective, compact Armed Forces. That is why we have created a program until 2020. We are building it differently across various segments, but it is an ambitious goal and requires huge money – 20 trillion rubles. We still need to master this money, and I assure you that we are talking about the most modern weapons, often about such offensive and defensive systems that other armies in the world do not yet possess, and we will also delight our partners with ideas and their concrete implementation, considering the systems I mentioned.

Some things are already known, and known in the field of strategic offensive weapons; I mean nuclear deterrent forces. There are some things we are not yet talking about, but we will, the time will come. Work is ongoing, intense work, conducted by our engineers, designers, scientists, and workers. In general, I must say that we must first do all this. This is not militarization, but as you understand, it is a very serious additional impetus for the development of the defense industry, it is orders and additional money for modernization – 3 trillion, which you all know about.

Now regarding the principles of our foreign policy. It must still be peaceful. Vladimir Wolfovich said that the tsar did not send humanitarian aid to the Serbs but sent an army, and then immediately added: "of course, that was a mistake." You know. Let’s learn not from our mistakes but from others'. We have already made many mistakes and will make more, so let’s not allow ourselves to make obvious mistakes. Although I cannot help but agree with those who spoke about the fact that all our partners in the world must understand that Russia, like any other large, powerful, sovereign state, has various means and methods to ensure its national interests, including the Armed Forces and armed means. But this is not a panacea, and we do not intend, you know, like some people, to run around the world with a razor and wave it. No. But everyone should know that such means are also in our arsenal.

Now regarding whether we will refuse or not. Here, colleague Vasilyev spoke, Vladimir Abdualievich. But of course, how can we? It is like refusing from ourselves. This is impossible; the decision has been made. It is irreversible.

And now, please, your questions, proposals, ideas. Please.

Yes, I apologize. Here, I think, Sergey Mikhailovich just spoke about the military component in Crimea. I want to inform you: the Ministry of Defense has prepared additions to the armaments program and a separate program for the creation and development of a military grouping in Crimea, and I have already approved this program. It will not be excessive; it will not be costly. We will not saturate it with excessive personnel or excessive armaments. But this program fits organically into all the plans for the development of our Armed Forces, including considering its territorial component.

Please.

E. Mizulina: Dear Vladimir Vladimirovich! Dear Dmitry Anatolyevich!

In December, it will be two years since the adoption of the so-called "Dima Yakovlev Law." You supported the Duma on this law. And I would like to thank you very much for that. Life has shown that the decision was correct, timely, and just. And this is especially evident now, when there are mass violations of children's rights in southeastern Ukraine.

The deputies remember that when we adopted the "Dima Yakovlev Law," many international organizations and the media literally harassed and branded the Duma, accusing it of inhumane and cruel treatment of orphaned children. Where are these defenders of children's rights now? Why is the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child silent?

It is completely obvious that this silence is connected only with one thing – there is nothing to say! For it is clear to everyone: Ukraine is violating all international obligations, at least regarding the civilian population and children. At the same time, both the USA and the leading Western countries effectively consider the gross violation of international law acceptable.

I regret to say, but we are all witnesses today to the rapid devaluation of international law. Today, international law effectively operates when it is beneficial to the USA and leading Western countries, and it turns into nothing, into dust, when it is not beneficial to them. I regret to say, but I think it is correct to conclude that today both Russia and the international community as a whole are facing a global challenge. We will have to answer a fundamental question – do we maintain our commitment to the supremacy of international law or not? I want to remind you, dear colleagues, that the post-war period introduced the principle of the supremacy of international law.

Colleagues, this is a principled moment, fundamental – about the supremacy of international law. After all, the supremacy of international law is a concession by the state of part of its national sovereign powers to an international organization; it is a way of intervening in internal affairs. And do you know that this principle was first directly enshrined in the Basic Law of post-war Germany in 1949 precisely as a means of controlling international organizations over national authorities? In this regard, we propose and ask you to express your position on three important issues.

First, regarding Russia's withdrawal from the jurisdiction of the European Court of Human Rights, the denunciation of the European Convention and its protocols. It should be honestly acknowledged that today the European Court of Human Rights is not a symbol of justice; it has turned into a primitive tool of political pressure on Russia. Moreover, it is a channel for interference in Russia's internal affairs through judicial decisions.

Second. It is necessary to urgently amend the law on international treaties. We need a mechanism for the denunciation of ratified treaties if they violate Russia's interests at least by the fact that our partners to these treaties do not fulfill their international obligations.

And thirdly. The question arises regarding Article 15 of the Constitution, which proclaims the supremacy of international law. I know, Vladimir Vladimirovich, your position on not touching Chapters I and II, and I shared this position until the situation in Ukraine. Today, I think this position is somewhat outdated. Moreover, it is not necessary to rewrite the Constitution; it itself allows for the possibility of making only specific amendments to Chapter I or II. All of this can be sufficiently outlined in the law on the Constitutional Assembly.

Your opinion, Vladimir Vladimirovich, is needed not for confrontation, but for joint action, aimed at preserving the lives of children and the lives of all people who consider themselves part of the Russian world.

Thank you. I apologize for taking your time.

Regarding changes to the Constitution, you know my attitude towards this document; the entire country relies on it, our whole life. And it seems to me that we need to approach this very carefully. We need to study each specific case very thoroughly at an expert level, working through all these issues with the public, but extremely cautiously.

We have a balanced document. There, as in any living organism, something will decrease, and something will grow where it is not needed. Therefore, very carefully. This does not mean that we have received this text as it is for all time and that we should not think about how to improve our Constitution. Of course, this can be done, and we need to think about it. I just urge you to treat this matter with extreme caution.

Regarding the European Court of Human Rights. Yes, indeed, I agree, it makes many politicized decisions that are far from the purpose for which it was created – it does not regulate legal relations and does not protect any rights, but simply performs some political function.

One vivid example is when Russia was fined for something related to Transnistria. We had absolutely no relation to this; a person was held in prison in Transnistria, and Russia was fined for it. Complete nonsense, an absolutely unlawful decision, but it nevertheless took place. In principle, of course, this is possible, but for now, we are having various discussions and maintaining dialogues with them. But if such a practice is strengthened, it may be possible, but this issue is not currently on our agenda.

And now regarding the mechanisms for denouncing treaties. I simply do not quite understand whether we need any special mechanisms for denunciation. The United States unilaterally withdrew from the Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty, and that was the end of it. No matter how we persuaded them. And that’s it. They acted, as they believe, based on their national security considerations. And we will do exactly the same when we consider it beneficial and necessary to ensure our interests.

L. Kalashnikov: Dear Vladimir Vladimirovich, my last name is Kalashnikov, from the Communist Party faction; I am engaged in international issues both in the Duma and in my party. Remembering how several months ago, my comrades and I were here, long before the referendum, we saw, Comoyedov was there too, we saw the filled eyes of the people, the questions, and we left just as the so-called polite people appeared – the people gave them that name.

As we were leaving, we saw how people breathed a sigh of relief on the peninsula. You will receive many words of gratitude; these words are well-deserved, but my question concerns the international situation and is posed in connection with what our party has always understood and understands now. In 2012, you remember, Mrs. Clinton, while being Secretary of State, announced that a set of measures was being created to counteract Russia, referring to the creation of a customs space, an Eurasian space, a Customs Union. And we understand: what is happening today in Ukraine is a link in that very chain; they do not hide this either. You, in starting to answer my colleague's question, said that we can, when it comes to the security of our country, think about denunciation, including bilateral relations. In this regard, I would like to ask you a question. We have long been saying, and not even in connection with the recent events, that the need has arisen to withdraw from the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty due to the fact that we are developing many intermediate and shorter-range missiles – first. Second – START. Agreements that we voted against from the very beginning, understanding that they would violate it, including the preamble, which speaks of the interconnection, you remember, of missile defense and strategic offensive arms. The Americans set an example for us: they withdrew from the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty as soon as we, Russia, weakened. We could also exercise this right – that’s one. And another example presented to us by the US allies is Pakistan. When US troops mistakenly bombed a checkpoint several years ago instead of Afghan troops, they immediately halted transit, the southern transit of US troops and US weapons through their southern transit.

We have a similar transit – transit concerning NATO member countries, which we concluded on a bilateral basis. Perhaps it is time to suspend this transit as well, since it does not serve our interests. In 2014, when the Americans leave there, we will have another hotspot due to their fault in the south. By the way, you may not be told, the famous "Baker-Shevardnadze Line" of 1992 has still not been ratified in our Duma. And that is also a question, and why not raise it in the Duma? You see, we did not ratify the charter and received 50 billion through some court. It seems to me that the time has come for us to reassess the existing agreements in legislative terms, and to do so within the framework of existing international law.

Thank you.

You briefly mentioned the problem, of course, we are here, Crimea, and I can only say the following about this. I have said many times, but I will take advantage of your speech and question to say that, of course, there was and is no annexation of Crimea. We did indeed use our Armed Forces, but only to allow the people living in these territories to express their opinion about their future. Perhaps, for the first time, a full-fledged plebiscite, a full-fledged referendum on vital, fateful issues for the people living in this territory was held here. Therefore, to speak of any illegal actions is, at the very least, absurd, simply ridiculous. We simply asked the people what they wanted. If this is not democracy, then what is it? And what is democracy at all if it is not the power and opinion of the people? Therefore, these accusations are completely empty, having no basis whatsoever. But that is just by the way.

Now regarding the treaty on intermediate and shorter-range missiles, a legitimate question. Why? We signed this treaty with the United States. Only we and the United States limit ourselves in the production and possible use of this type of weaponry. But for the United States, this is absolutely unimportant. They have Canada as a friendly country on one side, and Mexico on the other, and that’s it. But we have a completely different situation. Intermediate-range missiles are not produced; this type of weaponry is only developed by us and the US. But we have a different situation: North Korea, the People's Republic of China, Pakistan, India, Israel, Iran – practically all countries in the world are working on this type and class of weaponry. And if the development of this class of missiles, say, in China or India does not cause us any concern, because these are friendly states, and I am sure that the level of relations we have achieved with China or India will last for a long time, considering the specifics and prospects of international relations, for a long historical perspective. But the development, say, of this class of weaponry in Pakistan cannot but cause us certain concerns, because, to be frank, we understand that this is still a country with such a complex political regime, and unfortunately, with an unstable political regime; what will happen there, how the situation will develop, in whose hands these types of weaponry will end up, especially since it is a nuclear power. And there are also questions on the other sides, on many. But we are limiting ourselves. But we are, of course, thinking about this, analyzing. Today, we are in a position to ensure reliable, absolutely guaranteed security with the systems we have and those we are developing. But this is not a trivial question.

Now regarding Afghan transit. Should we terminate the relevant agreements with the United States? You know, there was a lot of noise about the possible use of the airfield in Ulyanovsk, if I am not mistaken? And I know that your faction, the Communist Party, was categorically against it. But nothing happened; it is not actually being used. Zero! Usage – zero, nothing at all. That’s the first point.

Secondly, we should never act on the principle of – to spite the conductor, I bought a ticket and did not go. That is, we cannot do anything to our own detriment. We are interested in the situation in Afghanistan developing in the right direction, stabilizing. And if some countries, including NATO countries or the United States, invest resources in this, spend money on it, that is their choice, but it does not contradict our interests. Why should we interfere with them?

Do you want us to fight there again? No, probably no one wants that. Therefore, we try, if we see unlawful actions against our country, we think and look for answers. But they should not be to our detriment, but only to our benefit. Just as we are doing now and as the Government is doing in connection with the restriction of the import and supply of food products. Absolutely!

You see, if this had been four years ago, we would not have done this either. Because our agricultural producers were not ready to supply the necessary products to the market. Look, ten years ago, we imported 360 thousand tons of chicken meat from the US, which they called "Bush legs." Last year, I believe, we imported only 200 tons. Why? Because complexes have been created that do not exist in Europe, poultry complexes – wonderful, modern, efficiently functioning.

We have significantly increased the production of so-called red meat, primarily pork. But we have not yet ramped up the necessary volume of beef production, because the production cycle is longer. If for pork it is 5–6 years after capital investments, for beef it is 8–12 years. And more investments are needed. We simply have not had the time.

But we are already in a position to supply the domestic market with enough products and of such quality that will mostly satisfy demand. And today we have taken these actions. I cannot say that they are catastrophic for our partners, but they are sensitive, painful. But I believe that we acted justifiably.

First of all, we did not violate WTO rules and our agreements within the WTO. They are now trying to sue us there; I do not know if they have already formulated their claims or not, but in our agreement on joining the WTO, we stipulated that in case of ensuring interests in the field of national security, we have the right to impose restrictions. After Western countries – the US and Europe, Australia, Canada, Norway – imposed restrictions, including financial restrictions against Rosselkhozbank, well, what does Rosselkhozbank have to do with our disputes, say, around Ukraine?

They restricted this financial institution's access to credit resources from international banks. This means they are essentially creating more favorable conditions for their goods to operate in our market, and therefore our retaliatory actions are quite justified. It is not only about Rosselkhozbank; Sberbank also finances agriculture to a significant extent, as does VTB, and so on.

Therefore, our actions are: a) legal; b) justified; c) not detrimental, but beneficial to our economy and our producers. We must seek precisely such levers, precisely such actions that will not be detrimental to us. Perhaps it would be nice to pinch, but if it is detrimental to us, it is better not to do it for now. Let’s act on that principle.

I. Drozdov: Dear Vladimir Vladimirovich!

The sanctions imposed against Russia are not just an unfair tactic in economic and political struggle; they are a change of the rules of the game during the game itself, that is, it is cheating, and for cheating, in general, throughout history, people have been hit on the head with something heavy. But, as you rightly said, we do not need it to be worse for them; we need it to be good for us. A number of proposals.

First. Is it not time for us to switch to national currency – the ruble – in settlements for energy resources supplied from Russia?

Second – in the field of food. Maximum import substitution – yes, it will require significant investments. I am ready to confirm your words now. I am elected from the Stavropol Territory; the LDPR faction entrusted me with work in Crimea. And believe me, the poultry produced in the Blagodarnensky District, pork in the Krasnogvardeysky District of Stavropol, beef here, in the eponymous Krasnogvardeysky District of Crimea, is no worse, and in terms of environmental characteristics, much better than foreign counterparts. Yes, we need to invest money, and if our farmers feel care not just in words, I think we can feed not only Russia but half the world.

Third. Where import substitution is impossible – maximum strengthening of cooperation with our partners in BRICS. You have already done a lot in this direction, and many industries should be switched there.

And finally, the fourth point. The genocide of our population continues. I mean tobacco, beer, energy drinks. A unique situation has developed, in essence – there is a monopoly on everything I just mentioned, but the monopoly is by no means of the Russian state or even of private Russian capital. It is almost a 100 percent, over 90 percent, monopoly of Western companies. In other words, they are poisoning, so to speak, our children, while some Philip Morris is making colossal profits.

Therefore, I understand that the ideal solution – and we have talked about this many times – would be, of course, state regulation on many issues. But as of today, we are ready to introduce a bill as early as the beginning of next year, so that in all these companies at least 51 percent of the capital belongs to Russia, or state capital, at worst – private.

As for energy drinks, this poison should be banned altogether. A law that I submitted along with my colleagues from our faction and other factions has been hanging in the Duma for a year and a half. Regions, in the absence of this law, have already gone down this path – Kuban, Stavropol, Chechnya, Karachay-Cherkessia have already banned all this poison on their territory, saving our youth.

Vladimir Vladimirovich, I would like to hear your opinion. Thank you.

Now, regarding the trade of energy resources for rubles. I also believe that this would be correct. And we must strive for this. The question is that this is not a simple story.

For example, oil is traded on exchanges, on global platforms in dollars. This has been the case for several decades. And this is global practice. Breaking this global practice is quite difficult. Moreover, our companies that carry out this trade are also interested in receiving dollars or euros. But oil trade is conducted exclusively in dollars.

But this is a one-sided monopoly of the dollar in this type of activity. In my opinion, it is detrimental to this sector of the global economy. And we need to act carefully in this regard. We are already trying, where it is possible, feasible, and in line with our interests, to negotiate with some countries about trading goods, including possibly energy resources in national currencies. For example, with the People's Republic of China, we are negotiating trade in rubles and yuan – a complicated process. This needs to be done gradually, step by step, slowly. But the first steps are already being taken.

We are discussing this issue of trading various types of goods, various commodity groups within BRICS, which you mentioned, the organization you just referred to. We have even signed relevant agreements to expand trade in national currencies. I repeat, this requires time and very good expert development. We will do this gradually, and the fact that we would like to transition to trading in our national currency in certain segments of the global market is an obvious fact.

Now regarding the quality of our agricultural products. Of course, it is better, that is 100 percent, you don’t need to be a fortune teller to see that. But, unfortunately, this mass production of food products in many industrially developed countries relies on chemicals, on pharmaceuticals that livestock are fed to prevent them from getting sick, on various growth stimulants: the faster the animal grows, the quicker the turnover, more money can be earned. But this is harmful.

Look at the obesity problems in some countries. It’s a nightmare! This is also related to nutrition. And our domestic products are naturally much higher in quality and better. But the question is only whether there is enough of it. You see, I have already mentioned that this production cycle, say, for beef, is lengthy and requires quite significant investments. This is being done now, large complexes already exist and will continue to develop.

Regarding the development of relations with BRICS, I have already mentioned. We have signed two very important documents now in Brazil: on the creation of a joint bank and on the creation of a pool of reserve currencies. This is an extremely important thing. These are just the first steps. The bank – it is clear, a financial institution that should be used for the development of our economies. But no less important is the creation of the second institution – the pool of reserve currencies.

This means that Russia, China, Brazil, South Africa, India, we must direct part of our gold and foreign exchange reserves into this pool. Russia plans to direct 30 billion dollars there. This is being done for various reasons, primarily to enhance macroeconomic stability in our countries, including in Russia. And of course, also to guarantee the safety of our gold and foreign exchange reserves.

Here, colleagues have already mentioned this problem. I want to say that this is indeed an important issue. Vladimir Wolfovich spoke about the huge national debt, say, of the United States, and this is the main global reserve currency – the dollar. What will happen to it then? I think our American partners do not know this for sure, and what can we say about other countries in the world! And our gold and foreign exchange reserves are largely denominated in US dollars. Therefore, the creation of such an institution as a pool of reserve currencies within BRICS is an extremely important initiative.

And now regarding some goods you mentioned – tobacco, alcohol. You know, we must pursue a position of de-alcoholization of the population, fight against smoking. But by no means should this be done as it was in Soviet times, when they fought against drunkenness, when they uprooted vineyards, here in Crimea, surely everything was uprooted, in Krasnodar Krai everything was uprooted. Did this lead to less alcoholism? I think not.

They simply started drinking denatured alcohol, started distilling moonshine, and so on. There are no simple solutions here. Comprehensive work is needed. We need to promote a healthy lifestyle, develop sports, and not only elite sports but also mass sports. We need to always provide people with some alternative. And we must also fight against smoking carefully.

But if we simply raise prices, we often discuss these issues in the Government, we apparently have your supporters who say: “We need to raise excise taxes fivefold, tenfold.” But people will not smoke less if we do this with a snap of the fingers. They will just smoke all sorts of garbage. That’s all. We need to work calmly, rhythmically, and explain. If we raise excise taxes, then gradually.

As for foreign investments, I cannot agree with you at all here. We must still create conditions in Russia that will always give our investors – both foreign and Russian – a clear signal: in Russia, they do not deceive, or, as is said in certain circles of the intelligentsia, “they do not abandon.” And if a person or a company comes with investments, they must be assured that no one will take away these investments, that these investments are guaranteed by the policy of our state.

I urge all of you to regard this component in exactly this way, because only in this way can we increase trust in our economy and attract the necessary investments not only in the production of tobacco or alcoholic products but also in all other sectors of the economy. Because if we send just one wrong signal in one sector, we will immediately feel negative consequences in other sectors. But this does not mean that we should not fight against smoking. We can do this with the help of tax policy, and with explanations, and some restrictions – all this is possible, let’s discuss it professionally and calmly together.

Yes, regarding the ban on energy drinks. You know, I am closest to your position here, I also do not want it to sound like we will ban everything tomorrow, but I would act more decisively here than we have acted so far, that’s true.

A. Makaryov: Dear Vladimir Vladimirovich!

The measures of economic pressure on our country today are objective and unprecedented. Even during the years of the “Cold War,” the United States did not allow themselves such things, while the blows are being dealt to the most sensitive areas of our economy, understanding that this complicates the state’s fulfillment of social obligations, accordingly, the hope is that this will generate discontent among the people and ultimately destabilize the situation in Russia.

It seems to me, however, that this is not the main goal; it is merely a means, just as it is a means to put a valve in front of our gas to Europe, and the serious goal is the global economic dominance of the United States worldwide, and this economic dominance is the main goal. But if such a goal is primary, and I think there is no need to explain in this audience that the displacement of our relatively cheap gas, the replacement with expensive gas from the United States – this is not just new markets for sale, although, of course, they do not hurt anyone.

This is primarily to make European products uncompetitive compared to American ones, so in this case, we cannot say that sanctions will cease, that they have exhausted their limit on sanctions and then Crimea is just a pretext, while the situation in Ukraine, dying people – this is essentially a bargaining chip in the hands of politicians who are pursuing this policy. Therefore, it seems to me, and here probably everyone agrees, that we need to focus today on relying on our internal reserves, on the internal reserves of our economy, finally, on our business. Unfortunately, in that chorus of voices that are currently discussing our possibilities, mainly two are being discussed.

The first is to spend the accumulated reserves. The second is to raise taxes. Perhaps this can also be done, but honestly, I would like to hear your opinion on this matter. It seems to me that this will only give a short-term effect. However, unfortunately, very few stimulating measures are being proposed.

For example, the most important task that you set – de-offshorization. We are looking at the bill that has been prepared. Strictly speaking, this is a choice for business between an English prison and “Butyrka.” First of all, the choice itself is not very appealing, but the main thing is that it does not solve the problems of de-offshorization. And there is no need to scare business anymore; business has long understood (not all, perhaps, yet) that in fact, capital in our country is much more protected and better protected than in any other place on Earth. I apologize, today those who did not listen to you ten years ago are biting their elbows when you said how much dust they would have to swallow to get money out of offshore accounts. And if, excuse me, there are still some “frostbitten” individuals left, for that, there is still “Butyrka” and the Criminal Code.

Perhaps we should think about stimulating measures after all. You mentioned part of this today: support for rural areas and so on. I will not take up time now; I know there are many questions. I would like to hear your opinion. How would you, for example, feel about the idea of, say, a tax amnesty aimed at allowing people to declare their money that is abroad, pay taxes, and even more – to stimulate those who not only declare and pay taxes but also return money to the country and invest it in the development of our economy? That is, to focus not on fear (strictly speaking, in fact, they scare us, so why should we scare ourselves), but precisely on stimulating measures? I would very much like to hear your opinion. Once again, thank you for the opportunity to ask this question in Russian Crimea.

Regarding the economic pressure measures you mentioned. They are indeed very crude and, in my opinion, ineffective and harmful. Their goal is to ensure this global dominance of the United States, that is true, I agree with you, to maintain this global dominance, perhaps even to create more favorable competitive conditions for themselves in global markets, a desire to push us a little away from the European market, to pull Europe a little away from us.

Indeed, as colleagues have said, we do not have 26, now 27 billion in trade turnover with the United States, but with Europe – 440. Do you feel the difference? Any movements in this regard are very sensitive for us and for Europeans. For the United States, they practically have no significance. Therefore, your assessment is absolutely correct overall.

But I want to draw your attention to the fact that we are constantly engaged in preparing and implementing stimulating measures. One can argue about whether something is still lacking, whether something needs to be added. But if you look at everything that the Government proposes in the economic sphere, it is practically all aimed at stimulation.

Take at least our additional plans for infrastructure development, including, say, in the east of the country, considering BAM, Transsib, and so on, or the additional ring around Moscow. These are all measures to relieve the “bottlenecks” in the economy related to infrastructure deficiencies. This is also a stimulating measure. The entire program for supporting agriculture is also a stimulating measure.

Yes, we did this earlier during the crisis of 2008-2009, perhaps more prominently, when we directly supported, say, the automotive industry, so that it would not collapse like a house of cards. But this was in the context of an acute crisis. Today, acting with such measures may not be very correct, because then we would be de-stimulating the base of our own development. But the fact that we must constantly think about these measures, I absolutely agree with you – about stimulating measures.

You asked how I feel about raising taxes on one hand and, on the other hand, depleting reserves. It’s bad, of course. I don’t want to deplete reserves or raise taxes. But the fact that the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Economic Development are in constant dispute with each other: whether to raise taxes or deplete reserves – this is a normal professional discussion. I just don’t want to take up everyone’s time right now to delve into it. We are dealing with this on a regular basis. Believe me, constantly.

Just like in ancient Rome, there was a senator who would say that Carthage must be destroyed, and he ended all his speeches with that. Similarly, when we gather, no matter the issue, we ultimately end up discussing this: what are the reserves, to deplete or not to deplete, to raise taxes or not to raise, and what is a tax maneuver, what does it mean? Is it just chatter or will it lead to a real increase in the tax burden on the economy?

I won’t go into detail now; I don’t want to raise the tax burden or deplete reserves, but it also seems wrong to just sit on a pile of money. However, it’s hard to blame us for this; I already mentioned these large infrastructure projects, for example, for the development of the East, but we plan to do this from the Reserve Fund, so the Reserve Fund is a "safety cushion," and it still needs to be maintained at a certain level. But just keeping these funds in foreign securities is also wrong; we hear this criticism, and if someone thinks we don’t pay attention to it, that’s not true. We respond accordingly.

As for the tax amnesty: in principle, it seems like an attractive idea; we conducted one not so long ago, a few years ago. I must tell you that the effect was not as expected; that’s the whole point. Both tax amnesty and all other amnesties – we need to be a bit more careful with this, because a person commits a crime, hasn’t even served half their sentence – and there’s already an amnesty, a year later – another amnesty, another amnesty. This, you know, disavows the state’s efforts, let’s say, in the fight against crime. The same goes here.

People evaded taxes, evaded – amnesty, three years pass – amnesty. I do not rule out that this is possible; I do not exclude it. And in principle, if we work on this at the expert level, if you in the Duma work on this issue and eventually come up with some legal legislative solution, I will sign that law. But we also need to think about the feasibility, to look at it from that side, the effectiveness, that’s what it’s about.

Please.

S. Goryacheva: Dear Vladimir Vladimirovich! Dear attendees!

It’s hard to accuse me of flattery; more often, on the contrary, I am criticized for being too blunt in my assessments. But today, on behalf of many, I wanted to thank you, President of the Russian Federation, for your consistent and persistent defense of Russia’s interests and prestige.

Today, the myths that the West supports democratic revolutions have already been dispelled. We see that civil wars unleash massacres, and it is primarily the defenseless who perish. How is this done? A part of the corrupt elite is bribed, and the bet is placed on marginalized youth. We see this in Ukraine as well. Moreover, they have even dusted off concepts like "Bandera-ism" and "Nazism," and the bloodshed shows no signs of ending, while Russia is blamed, when the focus should be on Kyiv.

Why am I saying this? Because it seems to me, and many others, that the potential of our youth is not in demand in Russia today. Look, every fifth Russian is a young person, but here unemployment is higher, there are more drug addicts among the youth, and more alcoholism. Unfortunately, every second young family does not have housing. And our program to support young families, to support young specialists in rural areas has already been completed by our valiant Government. By the way, the funds were not significant.

There are many problems. It seems to me that there is a mistaken common belief today that youth do not want to work. No, it seems to me that in this situation, the incentives are simply not created, because any work must be motivated, including the work of young people.

We have specific proposals. For almost 10 years, the construction market, the trade market, and the service sector have been monopolized by migrants. You can no longer hear Russian speech in the market. Why doesn’t our Government, together with regional authorities, create construction technical schools and markets in megacities? Why not train our youth there? Let them build housing for themselves and for us as well. All it takes is the will, and such a program is necessary. This can be done.

And the second thing I want to say. In the world, in developed countries, 20 percent of entrepreneurship is accounted for by youth. We have only two percent. Let’s study the experience of China, Japan, Germany, and other countries, how it was done there, and involve youth, especially perhaps in rural areas. It is very important to create such incentives. And there will also be motivation for youth to work.

Why is this very important? Because today there is a new ambassador in Russia. We know that intelligence services will be lurking around here. Let’s take the ground away from them. And let’s protect our youth by giving them the opportunity to work, to work honestly, and to support their families.

Thank you.

Regarding studying the experience and adopting the experience of other countries, including in working with youth, we certainly must do this and will study the experience. But there is a lot of negative experience there. There, drug addiction thrives, xenophobia often flourishes, and various other, not quite traditional… Well, you understand what I’m talking about. So that experience is not needed for us. But there is positive experience, of course. We must analyze it as a whole and take the best, undoubtedly. And take the best from our history, from our culture, and see what is being done in other countries.

Regarding other experiences related, say, to migrants. There is nothing to take from there. There are only problems. It’s worse than with us. They have already publicly announced the failure of the policy they have been conducting until now; they have said it publicly. For the Western establishment, this is a unique thing. No one could believe that five years ago anyone would dare to say such things. But now they not only talk about it but also try to do something. And everything turns out very clumsily.

We have the best experience because our country was originally formed as a multinational and multi-confessional state. We have a tradition not just of coexistence but of the mutual penetration of cultures and religions. And this is an extremely important historical background for us, which we must undoubtedly use. We have, say, almost 10 percent of the population that is Muslim, but these are not migrants; they are our citizens, you understand, they have no other homeland, and for the most part, they regard Russia as their great homeland. There is a small homeland, and there is a great one. And we must not discriminate against anyone. But at the same time, in local labor markets, we need to learn to regulate them in a modern way.

And you mentioned, say, entire sectors that are occupied by emigrants or migrants: the construction sector, markets, and so on. You know, of course, we need to open both secondary educational institutions and higher and vocational ones. And we need to teach and educate young guys and girls, and so on. All this needs to be done. But other regulatory measures are also needed. For example, in the construction sector, if it is more profitable for businesses to hire migrants for cheap, for little money, then no matter how many police officers you assign to each site, it won’t make any difference. They will still hire migrants. You understand? Therefore, we need sound economic measures. It’s not easy to come up with them.

The Mayor of Moscow, Sergey Semyonovich Sobyanin, proposed to expand this patent system and make it more flexible, adapting it to each region of the Russian Federation in such a way that we could influence the entrepreneurial community in hiring through economic means. In Moscow, the cost of a patent may be one thing, in Ryazan – another. And give regions the right to regulate flexibly and use this mechanism.

Let’s try to implement it and see what comes of it. But if (I’m addressing not only you but all colleagues) you have your own ideas, we would be very grateful for your proposals on what and how we should do in civilized, modern ways to improve regulation in this very sensitive area. I agree with you.

Dear colleagues, I want to thank you once again for our joint work in the first half of the year and for our meeting today. I really wanted us to gather in such an informal setting right here in Crimea. Your colleagues from the Parliament of Crimea and from the Legislative Assembly of Sevastopol came to Moscow during those fateful days, as I have already said. But I think many have also already been here in Crimea, but probably not all, and I really wanted you all to come here, walk around, communicate with people, feel the atmosphere, breathe this air, look at Crimea, at Sevastopol.

Because, you know, when you hear everything with your own ears and see with your own eyes, when you communicate directly with people, everything becomes clearer, fresher, more alive, and from this living perception of these subjects of the Federation, we will have the opportunity to respond more accurately to all the problems that have accumulated here, to make more precise decisions to resolve these problems – whether they are transport, energy, water, or any other.

And one more thought that I cannot help but mention in connection with Crimea. It has already been mentioned here, and people sometimes ask the question, why is it expensive, how does Russia view this?

Crimea, Sevastopol – this is part of Russia. And therefore, developing our country in any of its parts is absolutely normal. This is done, of course, for the citizens who live here, but at the same time, it is done for the entire country. This is not some kind of gift; it is our duty to develop all the territories of the Russian Federation.

And if some territories are lagging behind, we must pay more attention to them. We are doing this in relation, say, to the Far East, and our plans in this regard do not change. We are doing this concerning some subjects of the Russian Federation in the south of our country, and nothing changes here.

We must apply the same special approach to Crimea and Sevastopol for now, keeping in mind that they lag behind the average indicators of the Russian Federation in their social and economic development. But we will undoubtedly do this in the interests of all of Russia.

Thank you very much.