Plenary session of the Eastern Economic Forum

Russia Vladimir Putin · President of Russia

5 September 2019 · Eastern Economic Forum plenary session · Vladivostok

Context
Putin addressed leaders and investors at the fifth Eastern Economic Forum in Vladivostok on September 5, 2019, highlighting Far East development and Asia-Pacific cooperation.
Main themes
Russian Far East development, Asia-Pacific economic cooperation, investment and business partnerships, regional infrastructure, Northern Sea Route and logistics, openness and innovation, long-term development strategy, natural resources, science and technology, international trust and dialogue
Duration
~187 min
99th percentile
Words
22,482
99th percentile
Sentences
1,251
99th percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from Russian

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

1,251 sentences in 394 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Battulga Khaltmaagiin Battulga! Dear Mr. Narendra Modi, Prime Minister of India! Esteemed Mr. Mahathir Mohamad and Mr. Shinzo Abe! Ladies and gentlemen! Friends!

First of all, I would like to address our foreign guests: both the leaders of the countries represented here and our foreign partners sitting in this hall. I want to thank you for showing such respect for Russia and for your attention to the development of relations between our states.

I hope, and I am confident, that all our work in these days will be conducted at the highest level and will yield results for all of us. I am glad to welcome you all to the Eastern Economic Forum.

Vladivostok is the capital of Primorye, and now also of the entire Far Eastern Federal District. The Far Eastern Federal District of Russia is hosting the leaders of the leading countries of the Asia-Pacific region, the largest investors, businessmen, representatives of civil society, and expert circles for the fifth time.

This year, we are welcoming over eight and a half thousand participants from 65 countries. Compared to the first forum, its representation has more than doubled. We see this as compelling evidence of the growing interest in the Russian Far East and the opportunities for cooperation that this, without exaggeration, colossal region offers.

The strength and competitive advantages of the Far East lie in its talented, hardworking, and energetic people, as well as its educated and goal-oriented youth. It is home to new centers of science, industrial growth, and industries of the future.

It boasts rich reserves of natural resources and extensive logistics capabilities – the Northern Sea Route and other trans-Eurasian routes. Finally, it is adjacent to rapidly growing economies, the most dynamic region in the world – the Asia-Pacific.

It is only natural that, when defining the long-term development strategy for the Far East in the mid-2000s, 15 years ago, we focused on maximizing the openness of this region and its close integration into the economic, transport, educational, and humanitarian space of the Asia-Pacific region, and, if we look broader, undoubtedly, of the entire world. We aimed at developing international and cross-border cooperation, investment and technological partnerships, and thus creating new opportunities, primarily for our citizens, for their lives and work.

This was indeed a significant, historic turn. I would like to remind you that in the early and mid-20th century, and then during the years of the "Cold War," many territories in the Far East, including Vladivostok itself, where we are today, had predominantly military significance and were, as we used to say, closed territories. This undoubtedly affected the development of these regions. In fact, there was practically no development in the social and economic sense of the word.

I want to reiterate: over the past years, the situation has radically changed, and we are proud that the Far East has today become one of the symbols of the openness of the entire country, of innovation and determination in removing various barriers to business and simply human communication.

Of course, we understand that such a result would hardly have been possible without strengthening the atmosphere of trust and constructive cooperation in the Asia-Pacific region as a whole. We are interested in ensuring that these positive trends continue to develop, so that our common region is safe and stable.

Our relations with India, China, the Republic of Korea, Malaysia, Mongolia, Japan, and other countries in the Asia-Pacific are built on the principles of respect and honest dialogue. And I am confident that they have great prospects, resonating with the growing role that the Asia-Pacific region is set to play in the coming decades. I believe that the distinguished foreign guests present here, our friends, agree with this.

Alongside openness, another key principle of our large-scale plans for the development of the Far East is their long-term nature and consistency. By concentrating resources and organizing this work step by step, we will increase our efforts. As we achieve our goals, we set new tasks for ourselves, striving for more.

Over the past fifteen years, we have already managed to create conditions for the Far East to enter a trajectory of accelerated growth. And these are not empty words; I will now provide evidence of this.

A good start for such work was the preparation for the APEC summit held in Vladivostok in 2012. At that time, we invested significant resources in modernizing transport, business, and educational infrastructure, and in improving the capital of the region as a modern, dynamically developing city, a city for people, as one of the scientific and educational centers of the Asia-Pacific.

Of course, we are aware that much remains to be done, but a lot has already been accomplished. Building on what has already been done and achieved, we will continue to launch large infrastructure, transport, and industrial projects and constructions in the region. At the same time, alongside steps to improve the business climate across the country, we have offered completely new, in many ways unique support tools for businesses in the Far East, aimed at enhancing global competitiveness.

I appeal to all colleagues who plan to invest in the Far East: please take advantage of these opportunities, study them once again. These are not promises – this is a practice that is already in place and working.

Thus, 20 territories of advanced social and economic development have been established in the region, with special conditions for organizing production, tax regimes, and government support measures. 369 residents have already been registered in these territories, having signed agreements for almost 2.5 trillion rubles and committed to creating more than 60,000 new jobs. These residents have already invested 344.8 billion rubles and created almost 20,000 jobs. This has already been done!

The free port regime of Vladivostok is in effect, covering 22 municipalities. Its goal is to assist in the integration of the Far Eastern regions into the economic space of the Asia-Pacific and to promote the development of high-tech enterprises.

1404 residents have taken advantage of the free port, signing agreements for almost 700 billion rubles and ready to create about 68,000 jobs here. And what has already been accomplished: 95.2 billion rubles have been invested, and over 10,000 jobs have been created. This is already a fact.

In total, thanks to the proposed support measures, since 2015, investors have invested 612 billion rubles into the region's economy, 242 new production facilities have been commissioned, and more than 39,000 jobs have been created. As a result, industrial production in the Far East has grown by almost 23 percent over the past five years. This is nearly three times higher than the national average.

The Far Eastern Federal University is becoming a center for new competencies, youth exchanges, and international cooperation, as well as bold experiments in education, science, and industries of the new technological era, and it is the venue where we traditionally gather and where we are now.

In the last academic year, 20,000 students studied at the university, including 3,500 foreign students from 74 countries. More than 200 foreign professors teach here.

Further development of research infrastructure is planned, including the construction of a megascience-class facility. And we can confidently speak about the future of the university as one of the key centers of the common educational space of the Asia-Pacific.

Dear friends!

At previous Far Eastern forums, we spoke more about the significance of the Far East for Russia, the plans and tasks for its development, and the tools for supporting business, and how to take advantage of these support tools. I briefly mentioned this now in my opening remarks.

However, we fully understand, and we just discussed this with colleagues over a working lunch, that without people, their energy, talent, and interest in achieving results, of course, no such goals can be achieved. Therefore, today in my opening remarks, I will pay more attention to issues of socio-economic development – specifically, the social program for the development of the region.

I believe this will be of interest not only to the domestic audience but also to our potential investors and companies already operating here, as it will mean that we will continue to create a favorable socio-political environment and attract the necessary labor resources for the development of the region.

So, yesterday, with the participation of the leaders of the Far Eastern regions, we discussed the tasks of a new stage in the development of the Far East. Its essence is to transform, to "convert" the economic achievements of the region in recent years into a social leap, a fundamentally higher quality of life for people.

This means we need to achieve changes in healthcare, education, and the improvement of cities and towns, changes that are tangible for millions of people. Moreover, citizens should feel these changes not in the distant future, as I have repeatedly said, not after years, but in the near term.

In this regard, I note that compared to 2005, the outflow of population from the Far East has decreased by half. We need to finally turn the situation around: the Far East should not lose people but gain them, along with their energy, strength, and initiative.

I will return once again to our conversation during the working lunch: we discussed this topic, and colleagues were asking me this question. Is there an influx, what is the outflow of the population from here? This is indeed an important question, both from a moral and ethical standpoint and from an economic one.

This region must be attractive to qualified specialists and, of course, to young people, who, as everyone knows, are the future. Moreover, the Far East is a very young region. It has good demographic potential, which is important to preserve and enhance. The total fertility rate here is higher than the national average.

Of the eight million two hundred thousand residents of the federal district, almost one and a half million are schoolchildren, university students, and college students. They win in sports competitions, international and all-Russian scientific Olympiads and contests.

For example, recently in Kazan, as you know, the World Skills Championship was held, and the "gold" of the World Championship in professional skills among juniors was won by ninth-grader Andrey Meshkov from Ulan-Ude. He excelled in the competency related to information technology. I congratulate him once again on this achievement. In short, as I have already said, smart, creative by nature, energetic people live here, capable of achieving the most ambitious goals.

Therefore, the first and key task of the new stage in the development of the Far East is to support the youth. To do everything possible so that young people have the widest opportunities here: to receive an education, to realize themselves in life and profession, to start a family, to raise children, and to contribute to the development of the Far East, which is dear to them.

First of all, we need to significantly increase the volume of modern housing construction, and it should be as affordable as possible. In this regard, we discussed this issue yesterday with colleagues, I repeat, the leaders of the regions.

I agree to launch a special mortgage program in the region, under which young families will be able to take out a loan to purchase an apartment or house in the Far Eastern regions at only two percent per annum.

We have recently introduced a preferential mortgage rate lower than the national average: at five percent. Colleagues convinced me yesterday that this is not enough. And I want to warn the leaders of other regions right away: we cannot do this across the country. Moreover, it would lose its meaning, because the goal of this measure is to attract precisely to the Far East people with education, qualified personnel, and so on.

I propose to launch this program already this year for a period of five years. I will explain why. First, we will need to carefully calculate the volumes of financing and their sources for the future, as these are ongoing powers. To extend it to the so-called primary housing market, that is, to newly constructed housing projects, as well as to individual housing construction for those citizens who have taken the so-called Far Eastern hectare.

As a source of financing, I propose to use funds from the state program for the development of the Far East and the Far East Development Fund.

The healthcare system must also be modern and accessible. This primarily concerns the primary, closest to people level of medical care, the equipping and informatization of clinics, hospitals, paramedic and obstetric stations, maternity hospitals, and perinatal centers, as well as the development of air ambulance services. This is especially important for the vast, boundless spaces of the Far East.

This work is already underway across the country, but here, in the Far East, we must create a truly effective healthcare system that meets, and perhaps even surpasses, the best standards and practices.

I understand that this is not a task for one day. But we need to start addressing it today, launching breakthrough pilot projects. Indeed, it is possible to create a medical cluster in the Far Eastern Federal District with a special regulatory framework, which would allow opening branches and subdivisions of foreign clinics without excessive formalities, attracting the best foreign specialists, and using medicines and methods that have already proven their effectiveness abroad.

Of course, this cluster must operate within the framework of Russian jurisdiction, and all nuances must be carefully worked out by the relevant government agencies, primarily, of course, the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation.

I have repeatedly stated that for the Far East, we must offer special measures, advanced mechanisms, and flexible tools that take into account the specifics of these vast territories and the needs of the people who live here. We have embarked on such experiments and innovations in the economy and attracting investments, and we have achieved, as I mentioned at the beginning of my speech, a very positive result. The same approach is needed in the development of the social sphere. I ask all federal agencies and all colleagues involved in the work on the development of the region to be guided by this logic, by the interests of the Far East, which essentially means the interests of the entire country, all of Russia.

An important step towards strengthening the common educational, cultural, and humanitarian space of the country should be a new cultural, educational, and museum complex in the Far East – here, in Vladivostok. But along with this, we need to fundamentally update the entire network of museums, libraries, theaters, cultural institutions, leisure facilities, and additional education across the entire Far East. We need to make them "alive," interesting, and modern centers of attraction for people of all ages, children, and youth.

We have just discussed this issue; I believe this is the third time I have mentioned our preliminary meeting: Prime Minister Shinzo Abe spoke about the great attractiveness and tourist potential of this region.

Of course, the creation of such a large all-Russian cultural and educational center with branches of our leading museums – the Tretyakov Gallery, the Hermitage, the Russian Museum, a branch of the Mariinsky Ballet and Opera – will undoubtedly, without any doubt, significantly increase the tourist attractiveness of Vladivostok.

But this is especially important for the cultural sphere, for rural areas, for small towns. In this regard, a few more figures. Out of 1,834 populated areas in the Far East, 1,614 are those where five thousand or fewer people live, and the distances between cities and villages sometimes reach hundreds of kilometers. This specificity must be taken into account. We also discussed this yesterday with colleagues, regional leaders.

In particular, we need to adapt our all-Russian programs "Rural Doctor" and "Rural Teacher" to the conditions of the Far East. We may consider increasing payments for doctors, paramedics, and teachers who come to work in small populated areas in the Far East, specifically and exclusively for the Far East. Compared to the existing payments across the country, I propose to double these payments for the Far East as a whole.

And of course, we must think about the future. It is connected with today's young people, schoolchildren, who love their region and want to live and work here. We must give them the opportunity to receive a quality education regardless of their families' income and material conditions.

I believe we should expand the practice of providing targeted and budget-funded places in Far Eastern universities for certain critically needed specialties, so that young people can study both at the state's expense and at the expense of potential employers, and be assured that they will be welcomed at their future workplaces, and that employment issues will be guaranteed to be resolved.

And of course, young people and people of all ages should have every opportunity to access distance education, as well as telemedicine, information resources, and electronic services, digital platforms, and services that open new horizons for creating and conducting business.

I would like to remind you that today more than half of all internet users on the planet live in the Asia-Pacific region. And our Far East must meet the level of digital infrastructure and standards in this area that are currently being set in the world, including the penetration of high-speed internet. I ask the Government to take this requirement into account when implementing the national program "Digital Economy of Russia." I repeat: we need a digital environment here that is commensurate with the scale of the challenges of our time and the rapid technological changes in the world.

In this regard, our second most important strategic task is that the Russian Far East must become one of the global centers of high technology and competencies, new industries and sectors, and thus a concentration of advanced, quality jobs for qualified specialists. And first and foremost, of course, for the residents of the Far East, for those citizens of Russia who live here, in these territories. This is our principled position.

There is a foundation for this. Here, on Russky Island, a powerful innovation cluster is being formed. A complex of the space industry is being developed around the new Russian cosmodrome Vostochny. The region is actively developing aircraft manufacturing, gas processing, and chemistry; the creation of the shipbuilding complex "Zvezda" is ongoing.

Undoubtedly, we intend to focus on increasing the export of deep-processed products. This is also our principled position, which I would like to draw the attention of domestic and foreign investors, residents of the TORs and the free port of Vladivostok.

Thus, we are increasing export duties on round timber, for example, but at the same time, we are ready to support those who are willing to invest in wood processing facilities. This includes creating a regime of maximum facilitation for the export of finished products, including to third-country markets. In the same logic – preferences and support in exchange for deep processing – we will consistently move forward in other areas, including marine resources and minerals.

As for the conservation and prudent use of forest resources – this is a crucial topic. We plan to consider it separately on a national scale at a special meeting of the State Council.

We understand that creating a powerful scientific and industrial center in the region is a colossal challenge. At the same time, considering that this is also a field of opportunities, it is very broad here. And in this regard, of course, the bar for the effectiveness of our measures and decisions must be set accordingly. This primarily concerns the economy of the future, supporting young teams that implement breakthrough ideas and solutions. Around the world, it is precisely startups led by young people that are today the most powerful driving force of technological development.

In order for the number of startups not just to increase, but to grow, to transform into medium and then large companies, it is necessary not only to provide legislative support. A regulatory environment is needed, but also effective financial instruments. In this regard, I propose to create a special venture fund in the Far East. We discussed this yesterday as well: I agree with this proposal. I ask the Government to propose specific solutions. Moreover, there are also sources of funding available here.

And finally, the third strategic goal that we set for ourselves. It is also quite ambitious and addresses the global environmental agenda, the challenges faced not only by Russia but practically the entire planet. It concerns the development of the Russian Far East as a global natural and tourist center, a kind of international experimental platform where approaches to solving the most important question for all will be tested, namely – how to ensure harmony between economic activity, the development of ecological tourism, accessibility of nature for people, and the preservation of unique ecosystems.

Even today, the stunning beauty of the nature of the Far Eastern territories attracts hundreds of thousands of tourists. In 2016, the region was visited by 5.2 million people, including 750,000 foreigners, and last year, it was already seven million, including about one million citizens of foreign countries. Among the true natural "gems" of the Far East are Lake Baikal, the Kronotsky Nature Reserve in Kamchatka, the Alkhanai National Park in Transbaikal, and many other territories.

In total, the region has 64 specially protected natural areas of federal significance. I would like to note that I have already instructed to determine and register the boundaries of all reserves, national parks, and other protected areas. I ask to expedite this work across the country, and in the Far East, this needs to be done first and foremost, as a priority.

At the same time, we need to more actively launch public-private partnership projects in the field of tourism. We should invite responsible investors and offer them a special system of benefits while strictly adhering to the criteria and rules of ecotourism.

And of course, we need modern information services so that people can quickly and conveniently obtain all the necessary information: where and when they can go, which tourist route to choose, and foreign citizens can also apply for a visa. By the way, it is here, in the Far East, that the electronic visa system was introduced for the first time. It has significantly simplified the formalities for foreign tourists and entrepreneurs. Over the past two years, more than 140,000 such visas have been issued.

All the development tasks we are discussing, and most importantly – the new, modern standards of quality of life for people require a completely different level of mobility. For the Far East, this primarily means a developed network of air transportation, affordable ticket prices for flights within the region, to Siberia and Central Russia, and abroad.

By 2024, 40 airports in the Far East will be reconstructed. To expand local air transportation, we intend to actively engage the capacities of Far Eastern aviation plants in Ulan-Ude, Komsomolsk-on-Amur, and Arsenyev for updating the fleet of regional and local aircraft and helicopters.

And what I would like to add: the priority for all aviation companies in the world is safety and comfort. For carriers operating in the Far East, another priority should undoubtedly be the accessibility of tickets. I think it would be right for airlines that are ready to expand their presence in the Far East to conduct responsible and reasonable pricing policies to receive preferential access to transportation on other most profitable routes and directions.

We discussed this with the Minister of Transport yesterday. I hope he hears me today as well. In general, such a system is already working in practice; it needs to be consolidated. I understand this is not a very market-based measure, but for this region, it is justified. But we need to think about how to formalize this normatively.

Dear friends!

We are setting ourselves ambitious tasks for the development of the Far East, and large, significant goals always imply partnership and the unification of efforts. We are focused on such cooperation and are open to all who are interested in it. We believe in the future of our cooperation, in the future of the Far East of Russia.

For success – as in all our vast country – we need the consolidation of society, the participation and involvement of every person, the readiness to contribute their part, their work, energy, and knowledge to the common result. We have this mindset, and therefore all plans, even the boldest dreams, will surely become a reality.

I wish the participants and guests of the forum fruitful work and all the best.

Thank you for your attention.

S. Brilev: Vladimir Vladimirovich, one clarification, in your speech you practically combined in one sentence the new "gems" of development: the Vostochny cosmodrome, the plant in Komsomolsk-on-Amur (although formally old, but currently producing the most modern aircraft), the Zvezda plant, and the TORs. So you assume that foreign investments can also come to such facilities as Zvezda, the cosmodrome, and the aircraft plant?

Of course.

As for the aircraft plant, they are already there. We know well, and the whole world knows our so-called "Sushki" (Su fighters): both the Su-30, Su-34++, and Su-35, and now the fifth-generation Su-57 is already coming out. The Sukhoi Superjet is produced by us in collaboration with Italian and French partners. We are working there; we are open in this regard. We have nothing to hide. Although no, we do have something.

S. Brilev: That's exactly what I mean.

We reliably keep what we must keep to ourselves for now. But at the same time, there are all opportunities for modern effective cooperation.

As for the cosmodrome, this is not a military cosmodrome. We are currently resolving the question of who should build the next phases, but in general, this cosmodrome is primarily for launches for civilian purposes. Therefore, we not only believe that we can work there together with foreign partners, but we are interested in this and will definitely involve them in this cooperation.

We have joint projects with India in the field of space; we are actively working on these programs with the People's Republic of China; we have good cooperation with the European Space Agency, and we hope that this will continue to develop; we are working with the United States. How many launches we carry out in the interests of our foreign partners, including in the interests of the United States… These launches are expected to be largely transferred to the Vostochny cosmodrome. Therefore, I do not see any direction that could be closed to our foreign partners. On the contrary, we are interested in attracting them, including for Zvezda, which you mentioned.

We were just at Zvezda with Prime Minister Modi yesterday. The most modern large-tonnage ships will be built there, both for services in the shelf zone, in the Arctic, and for transporting liquefied gas, oil products, and other cargo. And we talked with the Prime Minister yesterday; we will even look for the possibility of joint work; perhaps some ships will be partially built with us. International cooperation in the world thrives when organized this way. Some will be built with us, and some will be completed at shipyards in India.

Our well-known leading company, Rosneft, owns one of the largest oil refineries in India and recently acquired a controlling stake. And its area of responsibility includes one of the major ports in India. Therefore, we have many interconnected areas of cooperation. There is not a single closed topic; on the contrary, we are interested in attracting our partners.

S. Brilev: Before giving the floor to the Prime Minister of India, I would like to emphasize that Vladimir Vladimirovich has just shared with us a little about what they discussed privately yesterday. You had a private meeting yesterday. So perhaps the Prime Minister will also continue on this topic. I looked before the start of this panel: theoretically, an Indian businessman decided to come to Vladivostok to make an investment. The nearest route – a transfer through Korea – takes about 18 hours, but usually it’s 22-23 hours. It is clear that the speed of movement between India and the Russian Far East via the maritime routes proposed by Prime Minister Modi, between Chennai and Vladivostok, will be different, but at least direct connections are emerging, and it seems we are witnessing how this is happening right before our eyes.

I invite the Prime Minister of India, Mr. Modi.

N. Modi: Your Excellencies, President Putin, President Battulga, Prime Minister Abe, Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad, dear friends, good afternoon!

It is a great honor for me to participate in this plenary discussion alongside you. The atmosphere here is truly special, unique, a friendly atmosphere of Vladivostok. The morning sun rises here first and only then illuminates the rest of the world, charging it with energy.

And just as I am absolutely convinced, the discussions taking place here today will spread their positive influence and energy not only to the Far East but will indeed energize the entire world and ensure a better existence for all humanity.

I would like to express my gratitude to my friend President Putin for giving me the opportunity to participate in such an important event. President Putin invited me here even before the elections in India. 1.3 billion Indians expressed their support and faith in me, just as you did by sending your invitation. Thus, we have truly placed the stamp and proof of President Putin's faith in me.

The fact that President Putin also invited me earlier to the economic forum in St. Petersburg confirms our cooperation. We have been everywhere – from the heart of Europe, in St. Petersburg, to the farthest edge of Russia on the Pacific Ocean, to the Far East. It is indeed an exciting journey. Vladivostok is the place where Eurasia meets the Pacific region. It is here that we have unique opportunities opening up in the Arctic region and in the development of the Northern Sea Route.

About one-third of Russia is in Asia. And the Far East is precisely the point that allows strengthening the Asian identity of this great country. The size of this region is almost twice that of India, but the population of this region is only 16 million people. However, this region is indeed rich in natural resources, various minerals, oil, and gas. The people living in this region have worked very hard for a long time, they have shown courage and the ability to innovate. That is how they have been able to overcome all the challenges posed by the wild nature of this land. And of course, it is a unique combination of science, art, culture, sports, industry, innovation, and the spirit of adventure. It is hard to find any other sphere of human activity in which the residents of the Far East, and the residents of Vladivostok in particular, have not achieved success.

At the same time, the residents of this region create unique opportunities for Russia, as well as for its friends and partners. The people of this region have been able to transform a region that was once covered by permafrost into a thriving region. This is the foundation for a wonderful future.

Yesterday, together with President Putin, we visited the exhibition "Street of the Far East." I was very impressed by what I saw: the amazing diversity and talents of the people living in this region, as well as the technological innovations taking place here. I truly saw a great number of opportunities for cooperation and joint progress.

Dear friends! The relationship between the Far Eastern region and India is not new; it indeed has a long history. India was the first country to open its consulate in Vladivostok. And even long before that, there was deep mutual trust between our countries. Even during the times of Soviet Russia, when there were serious restrictions on contacts with foreign citizens, Vladivostok was open to Indians.

As for our cooperation, our development, a very large number of goods and products were sent to India precisely through Vladivostok. And today, the tree of this partnership continues to grow and take deeper roots. This tree truly supports the prosperity and well-being of the citizens of our countries.

India has already made a number of effective investments in the energy and natural resources sector, directly in the diamond industry, as well as in oil fields in Sakhalin. This is a wonderful example of utilizing Indian innovations.

Dear friends! President Putin's commitment to the development of the Far East and his unique vision creates unprecedented opportunities not only for this region but also for Russia's friends and partners around the world, such as India. President Putin has stated that the development of the Far East is a national priority for the 21st century. The holistic approach of President Putin is indeed inspiring. These amazing efforts are aimed at improving all aspects of people's lives: the economy, education, healthcare, sports, culture, communications, trade, and various traditional crafts.

A great deal of effort is being made to improve all these aspects of people's lives simultaneously. On one hand, the region is completely open to investments, and on the other hand, a huge amount of attention is being paid to social development. I was very impressed when I heard about this vision, and I fully share President Putin's vision. India wants to work hand in hand with Russia to develop this exciting journey and this wonderful vision.

From my experience, I can say: the rapid and balanced development of Vladivostok and the Far East, in accordance with President Putin's vision, guarantees success because it is a very realistic vision, a very down-to-earth vision, based on the valuable resources contained in this region, as well as on the boundless talent of the people who live in this region. This vision truly reflects the respect and love that President Putin demonstrates towards this place and the people who live here. And together with President Putin, we are working on creating a model that will represent collective efforts to ensure inclusive growth.

We are working to achieve our goal, namely, to become a 5 trillion dollar economy by 2024. India is developing very rapidly. It also has a lot of talent, and a partnership of this kind with the Far East region is a historic opportunity that allows us to say: "One plus one equals eleven."

Dear friends! It is with this motivation that we have been able to carry out completely unprecedented work in preparing and holding the Eastern Economic Forum. Four ministers from Indian states and a huge number of business leaders are present here. Our delegation met with the President's envoy for this region, as well as with eleven governors of the Far Eastern region, and with business leaders from Russia. It is precisely this kind of format of meetings between businessmen from India and Russia that occurs regularly. There was a large delegation of businessmen from India that came to the Far East. And I can say that our efforts have paid off; they have yielded wonderful results.

About 50 business agreements were signed in various sectors: from energy to healthcare, education, training, mining, and woodworking. And we expect that as a result, we will be able to secure investments of 5 billion dollars.

Dear friends! In order to continue helping the Far East develop, India will provide a credit line of 1 billion dollars. This is a completely unprecedented measure when we provide such a special credit line to another country. And I can assure you that the Government of India is working very actively in this direction directly in the region, in East Asia.

Today's announcement of the provision of a credit line will be our starting point from which we will grow and develop in the Far East. I am absolutely convinced that this step will also give new momentum to the development of economic diplomacy and regional development in our friendly countries. Without a doubt, we will remain active partners in our priority cooperation.

Dear friends, the values of Indian and Asian civilization teach us that we should take from nature exactly as much as we need. We believe in the necessity of preserving and rationally using natural resources. It is in such harmony with nature that our civilization has existed for centuries. That is how we have developed.

Dear friends, the Indian diaspora lives in many countries. Every time I meet with the leaders of these states, they praise the hard work, discipline, and commitment of Indian citizens who live in their countries. Indian companies and businessmen make a significant contribution to the development of many regions around the world. It is there that they create wealth. But at the same time, Indians and Indian companies have always treated the cultural peculiarities of each country where they are present with great respect. I am absolutely confident that the funding, hard work, and talents of Indian citizens will contribute to the rapid development of the Far East.

In order to achieve the best results from India's participation in this economic forum, I would like to invite all 11 governors of the Far East to come to India and visit our country.

Dear friends! President Putin and I have set ourselves a very ambitious task of developing cooperation between our countries. We have indeed been able to expand the dimension of our cooperation and diversify it. We have been able to take our relationship beyond just cooperation between governments. These are concrete projects between private companies in various sectors. We have elevated them to a new level; they are not limited to specific cities, they cover many regions, and thus we have been able to encompass all aspects of cooperation within our special and privileged partnership. Together we can overcome distances and spaces. Together we can dive to the depths of the ocean to find the path to prosperity.

Dear friends! Very soon we will enter a new stage of cooperation in the region of India and the Pacific, when ships will begin to sail between Vladivostok and Chennai, when Vladivostok will become a springboard from which to jump into the Indian market, Southeast Asia, at that time the Indo-Russian partnership will become even stronger and will prosper even more. And then the Far East will become a point of contact, on one side, of the Eurasian Union, and on the other side, of an open and inclusive region – the Indo-Pacific region. This is how we can create a foundation for cooperation based on the principles of the rule of law, mutual respect, and territorial integrity. This is how no one will interfere in the internal affairs of other countries.

Dear friends! The famous writer and philosopher Leo Tolstoy was greatly influenced by Indian Vedas and Vedic texts. And Tolstoy really liked one quote, I will quote it in the original. But if translated, Tolstoy says the following: "Everything that exists as one, people call one, but they use different words for this." And this year the whole world celebrates the 150th anniversary of the birth of Mahatma Gandhi. Tolstoy and Gandhi left a unique legacy, each of them. Let us be inspired by this common legacy of India and Russia, and let us together leave an even more powerful legacy after us. Let us inspire each other's successes, let us work together in this region and ensure a stable and reliable future for the whole world. This will be the beginning of a new chapter in our cooperation.

Every time I come to Russia, I feel only love, friendliness, and respect for India. And today is no exception. I will take home this unique gift, amazing, priceless emotions, and the determination to deepen our cooperation.

I would like to thank my dear friend President Putin. Every time we meet, we meet with open minds, open to new ideas, and truly open hands.

Although yesterday was a very busy day, President Putin was able to spend many hours with me, meeting and talking in various places. And until one o'clock in the morning, we were together yesterday. Such commitment reflects not only President Putin's trust in me, it is indeed love, love primarily for India.

And today I learned another similar cultural trait between India and Russia. In my home state of Gujarat, when we say goodbye, we do not say "bye-bye," we do not say "goodbye," we say "avajho," which means: "please come back," "see you soon, come back soon." And in Russia, you say "do svidaniya," which means the same.

So, I say goodbye to all of you. Thank you very much.

S. Brilev: Vladimir Vladimirovich, can the eleven governors of the Far East arrange for travel expenses?

Let them go to the accounting department.

S. Brilev: Mr. Prime Minister, I have a sub-question for you right away regarding the news. Unfortunately, there is a reason—unfortunately—why Russian-Indian trade turnover may increase further. It concerns the latest news, literally from the last day, when both Indian citizens and Indian companies fell under the latest package of anti-Iranian sanctions from the United States. As I understand it, these are precisely the companies involved in oil trading. What do you have to say about this?

N. Modi: You are a good journalist; you have formulated your question interestingly.

There are relations between India and Russia in many areas, and they are developing very well. In the field of oil and gas, we have investments, investments in Russia, and Russian companies are also actively working in India, transferring technology and producing defense products. There are no obstacles of any kind between our countries.

The question you asked is a journalist's question. I believe there is a lot of discussion in the world about this issue. These sanctions that are imposed on any country—what is the impact of these sanctions on the country? That is one question. But due to these sanctions, there is also an influence on other countries in the world. What is the impact on the overall global economy? The world is concerned about this, and there is much talk about it.

S. Brilev: Let's return to the Iranian topic, because we cannot pass by it, a little later. But for now, we still have a part related to official speeches. And the President of Mongolia, who was just received by Vladimir Vladimirovich, please, President Battulga, I ask you to come to the stage, to the podium, to the tribune.

He can also speak at the podium. Look at how he looks; after all, he is a world champion in sambo.

S. Brilev: Therefore, instinctively, you speak like that.

H. Battulga: Esteemed President Putin! Esteemed Prime Minister Abe! Esteemed Prime Minister Modi! Esteemed Prime Minister Mohamad! Distinguished ladies and gentlemen!

As the head of state, I am participating in the Eastern Economic Forum for the third time, which is being organized for the fifth time. This forum has become an authoritative platform for negotiations and a platform for the development not only of the Far East region but also for activating cooperation between the countries of the Asia-Pacific region. A good tradition has been established during this forum to organize meetings of leaders from many sectors who exchange opinions and establish partnerships.

I would like to share my thoughts on the issues of new opportunities for accelerating the growth of our economies, which have become the theme of the current forum. Our citizens today can quickly exchange information through social networks, which requires us, as leaders, to work more responsibly to make the economy of higher quality, reduce poverty levels, and ensure rapid development. There are already technologies and pragmatic economic solutions to ensure a good life for our citizens. I urge you to think about the possibilities of eliminating the problems and obstacles before us to achieve this goal.

For example, it is necessary to particularly support projects and businesses that work on implementing advanced solutions in the regions, such as the shared economy, interconnectedness, and resource optimization. There is also a need to take measures today to help them overcome emerging problems and bureaucratic obstacles. I will fully support initiatives in this direction; however, I believe that in solving some regional economic problems, we should distance ourselves from politics.

Ladies and gentlemen! It is pleasant to note that President Putin of Russia was recently on a visit to Mongolia. And as a result of his visit, we elevated our bilateral relations to the level of comprehensive strategic partnership. We strive for Mongolian-Russian economic cooperation to become a model to follow.

For Mongolia, which is landlocked, the Far Eastern seaports of Russia are of great importance for developing trade and economic relations with other countries of the world and attracting foreign investments. I would like to express my gratitude once again to President Vladimir Putin of Russia for facilitating favorable conditions for transit transportation on preferential terms, taking into account the peculiarity of our geographical location.

In order to utilize these opportunities, the Government of Mongolia has decided to open a trade representation of Mongolia in the city of Vladivostok. I am confident that this decision will make an important contribution to expanding our trade and economic relations.

As part of our policy to activate trade, economic, and investment cooperation with the countries of the Eurasian region, we proposed to jointly work on signing a free trade agreement between Mongolia and the Eurasian Economic Union. We are confident that the free trade agreement will play an important role in reducing tariff and non-tariff barriers that exist in trade, as well as in fully utilizing our economic and investment potentials.

In order to actively participate in regional integration processes, Mongolia attaches great importance to aligning our infrastructure projects with those of Russia and China and enhancing their efficiency. On this basis, we are jointly implementing a program to create an economic corridor between our countries. With the implementation of the economic corridor program, we can elevate regional cooperation to a new level and give an impetus to the active development of business. Therefore, we are working to activate the activities of the Mongolian-Russian-Chinese joint mechanism.

Last year, I proposed to create a mechanism for coordinating activities to establish an energy supergrid in Northeast Asia. Over the past year, the Mongolian side has completed the development of this issue and held a series of events within our region. It is pleasant to note that as a result of our activities, the state company responsible for electricity, networks, and investments is cooperating in developing the feasibility study for the projects involved in creating the grid and preparing the necessary work for the production, delivery, and sale of electricity. The Mongolian company "Erdenes Mongol" and the Russian company "Rosseti" signed a cooperation agreement in this area.

In our Northeast Asia region, there are four major electricity consumers. Mongolia has the opportunity to provide cheap and stable electricity supplies. Thus, this will positively affect the economic competitiveness of our region, and citizens will have the opportunity to use electricity at affordable prices.

Also, the President of Russia expressed support, and the Chairman of China promised to study Mongolia's proposal for the construction of a gas pipeline from Russia to China through the territory of Mongolia.

Ladies and gentlemen, in addition to all this, Mongolia is pursuing a policy of encouraging the production of export-oriented products to increase trade volumes with partner countries, diversify products, and support the export of value-added products, creating favorable conditions. For example, this year, the government of the country approved a model investment agreement, working on updating investment agreements concluded with other countries. This model agreement fully complies with the principles of global sustainable development, largely protects the rights of investors, and considers environmental protection and social development in a comprehensive manner while ensuring economic growth. Therefore, I would like to emphasize that the doors to Mongolia are open for those who are interested in working in our country and cooperating with us.

Ladies and gentlemen! Mongolia wants to be active. Together with our partners, within the framework of law and order, we will actively create value and fairly share our fruits. The foundation of developing mutually beneficial economic cooperation, based on mutual respect, fair competition, and free trade, is regional peace and strengthening stability. Our goal is to develop cooperation based precisely on trust.

I wish you success in the work of the forum! Thank you for your attention.

S. Brilev: Vladimir Vladimirovich, at one time, if you remember, you gave me an interview in the Ussuri taiga, and since then I have traveled a lot around the Far East and neighboring countries. I was recently in Mongolia, and I was told about the Mongolian epic, which the President just very diplomatically interrupted in the middle.

The epic concerns the fact that Russia, China, and Mongolia (a country with a lot of sunlight and winds, where alternative energy can also be developed, in addition to traditional—coal, oil, gas) came up with this story of supplying electricity to those countries that are its consumers: both Koreas (there are certainly some problems with North Korea now) and Japan.

But the suppliers are ready, and the potential buyers, as I understand it, are not. And at this point, our guest from Mongolia somehow interrupted his story, characteristically, however, moving on to the topic of the lack of sufficient trust.

President Battulga, what did you mean?

H. Battulga: We have three countries that produce electricity. We have a lot of energy coal; more than 30 percent of the consumers of this electricity are in Japan, Korea, and China. If we positively resolve the issue of North and South Korea, the security on the Korean Peninsula, then the question of electricity supplies automatically arises. As I said, we have developed a feasibility study, and here we are ready to cooperate with Rosneft.

There is a ready feasibility study for the construction of a power transmission line, which we conducted together with China. I hope that Korean-Japanese relations will improve soon. We think we will sell 1 kilowatt for less than 8 cents. I believe this is a very good price for both the population and the producer.

S. Brilev: So, a kilowatt is cheaper. So, the price issue, as I understand it, is not so much about Russian-Japanese relations, but rather about Korean-Japanese relations, in terms of getting this electricity to flow.

I just wanted to highlight this story because it tells a lot about the incredible potential for cooperation. But nevertheless, despite the excellent relationships among the participants of today's plenary session with each other, there may still be a lack of sufficient trust between our countries. This is just another "checkmark" that I wanted to put down regarding what we will talk about later; it is very interesting and characteristic.

But the person who has done a lot to truly increase trust in relations with Russia is Prime Minister Shinzo Abe of Japan.

I ask you, Mr. Prime Minister.

S. Abe: Mr. Prime Minister Modi! Mr. Prime Minister Mahathir! Mr. President Battulga!

The fact that we are all gathered here together, including, of course, President Putin, impresses and inspires me greatly. And how about you?

In the geography of our presence here, I see one continuous line—a kind of swift current that connects the Arctic Ocean, the Sea of Japan, the South China Sea, and the Indian Ocean. Such a powerful maritime wave. And I want to emphasize the following thesis now.

Ladies and gentlemen!

The fact is that we are here representing our future; it is here, within us, together with us. It is here that our unlimited opportunities lie. This year, I came here precisely to talk about what awaits us in the future, about our opportunities in the future, exclusively about our future and our possibilities.

Esteemed ladies and gentlemen!

I want to quote a very well-known quatrain: "You cannot understand Russia with your mind, you cannot measure it with a common yardstick; it has a special stature—one can only believe in Russia." That is, this is the only way to be together with Russia; otherwise, it will not work with Russia.

Now, let’s try to replace the word "Russia" in this famous poem with the word "Japan." One can only believe in Japan. In what, what to believe? I have three theses on this matter.

First, Japan is the vanguard. I mean that we in Japan were the first in the world to face many problems, such as an aging population, which everyone will face sooner or later.

The second thesis, continuing the first: Japan is solutions. We have various solutions for all these diverse problems that everyone faces.

And the third thesis: Japan is a partner. This is a country that you can all trust. Once the Japanese promise something, they will invariably fulfill it from generation to generation.

Esteemed President Putin! Vladimir!

Distinguished ladies and gentlemen!

Perhaps not all of you know, but this time our meeting with President Putin was already the 27th. I would like everyone to know this well. And I would like everyone to understand very well that Mr. Putin and I have shared so many meals together that our relationship, it seems to me, can be called one where people have eaten a pood of salt together. I would like everyone to clearly realize this.

And there is something that I think everyone will agree on. It concerns the 12 national projects. These are all the activities that President Putin is consistently promoting. We in the Japanese government are well aware of these projects, and I also know because we have studied them well. Why did we study them?

Because we wanted to think about the areas in which and how Japan could most effectively cooperate with Russia. And every time we meet with President Putin, I always say that our countries, their relations have limitless possibilities. And it is precisely to understand what is needed to unlock these possibilities, to maintain relations between our countries in the future, that we have paid attention to the activities that Russia is currently conducting.

Please take a look at the presentation we have prepared. It contains 12 Russian national projects and the content of the Japan-Russia cooperation plan consisting of eight points: healthcare, demographics, quality of life index, urban environment, environmental improvement, small and medium-sized businesses, labor productivity, and employment support.

Notice how all the points of the Russian plans that connect with our cooperation proposed by Japan are linked by red lines. And these eight points of the bilateral cooperation plan are what we have chosen in the hope that they will help address the problems and state issues that exist in Russia.

I would now like to present to you a brief preliminary report on the implementation of these plans. This will be a short video lasting about 2 minutes and 40 seconds.

(The video is being demonstrated.)

In fact, I am the producer of this video. Thank you very much, gentlemen.

I am curious, what did you find most interesting in this video? Honestly, I was most impressed by how the woman started walking quickly without a cane. There was a study on the walking speed of Japanese people, and it turned out that 75-year-old Japanese now walk at the same speed that people did 10 years ago at 65.

So it turns out that Japanese elderly and senior citizens in our country have effectively become 10 years younger over these 10 years. I can vividly imagine that in this way, Japan's assistance will help more and more Russian grandfathers and grandmothers walk freely.

When I think about this, I can't help but smile. Japan really wants to demonstrate and show such a bright future and endless possibilities of our cooperation to ordinary Russians. We very much want to do this.

Now I would like to touch on somewhat larger topics. There was mention of a large waste processing plant. I would like to talk about that. In general, waste management is one of the issues that President Putin emphasized in his annual Address to the Federal Assembly.

I want to draw your attention to the fact that a Japanese company from the Hitachi Zosen Corporation group received an order in July of this year to build a waste incineration plant in the Moscow region with a capacity of 7,600 tons per day.

If 7,600 tons of waste are incinerated per day, this plant will generate electricity consumed by one and a half million people. Thus, it can be calculated that incinerating waste will cover about 10 percent of the electricity demand in the city of Moscow.

Another point concerns Japanese automotive companies. All of them are currently showing great interest in Russia. Toyota Motors plans to invest an additional approximately 20 billion rubles in its plant in St. Petersburg by 2028, and at the same time, striving to spread the so-called Toyota Way production philosophy, the company is working on improving the production lines of its suppliers and enhancing the qualifications of the personnel at these plants.

One of the largest Japanese truck manufacturers, Hino Motors, is already building its plant in the Moscow region. This plant will produce medium and small trucks, with a production volume of about two thousand units per year.

Last year, President Putin and I visited the Mazda Sollers plant here in Vladivostok. This plant began producing engines in June of this year. As I understand it, its annual capacity will be 50,000 engines per year, and for Mazda Sollers, this is an important plant in terms of their global strategy.

And now for the most exciting topic. This topic is the very dynamic development of the project for the supply of Arctic LNG to Asian countries on ice-class tankers with transshipment in Kamchatka, that is, with transshipment to conventional tankers.

I spoke about this last year, but at that time the project was still in the planning stage. Now, at this plant, in the design and construction of which our Japanese companies participated, gas production has already begun on three lines, and its export is already underway. In June, the first gas shipment to our country, to Japan, took place.

One of the largest maritime transport companies in Japan, Mitsui OSK Lines, is already using three ice-class tankers to transport Yamal LNG for export.

The "Arctic LNG-2" project. In June of this year, a decision was made regarding investment in this massive LNG project with a production volume of about 20 million tons per year by Mitsui and the Japan Oil, Gas and Metals National Corporation (JOGMEC). Thus, Japan is becoming one of the main participants in the project and will likely become a buyer of LNG from there.

After the tankers pass Kamchatka, icebreaking will no longer be necessary, so LNG can be transshipped to conventional tankers. And it is in these projects that we see the very continuous line I have already mentioned: the free open Indian Ocean, the Arctic Ocean, which Russia is now actively exploring—all connected by it. And it turns out that for the first time in human history, these two maritime regions are being connected into one, creating a huge logistics highway.

These examples I have provided are just a small part of the real picture. Over these three years, the number of commercial projects created as a result of our cooperation has exceeded 200.

I am not Fyodor Tyutchev, but I can repeat that with Japan, it cannot be done any other way. There is only one way to build relationships with Japan—through faith and trust. Trust and faith arise between people, and trust connects people. For a year now, unprecedented cultural exchanges have been ongoing between Russia and Japan throughout our history.

And in June of this year, President Putin and I decided to extend the dynamics of these exchanges across the entire territory of our countries. So from 2020 to 2021, we will hold a year of interregional and sister city exchanges between Japan and Russia. This means that representatives of both countries will now organize exchanges between regions, including between sister cities.

By the way, the number of people in Japan who want to visit Vladivostok is currently growing. Honestly, I think one of the factors is that I visited Vladivostok myself. I don't know if that's the case or not, but in any case, the number of Japanese tourists heading here has indeed increased, particularly among young women.

Therefore, the two largest Japanese airlines are now launching direct flights between Tokyo and Vladivostok. Everyone working in Russian companies and scientific institutions that have any relation to the eight-point cooperation plan between our countries can now obtain multiple-entry visas valid for up to five years starting this month. In addition, we will simplify the visa process for students at Russian universities to encourage more of them to come to Japan.

Dear ladies and gentlemen!

This year, a new emperor ascended the throne in Japan, and the name of the era has changed. The beginning of this new era will be marked by a major event: on September 20, the Rugby World Cup will begin. And, imagine, the first match will be between Japan and Russia.

Of course, I believe in Japan's victory in this match, forgive me, Vladimir. But I sincerely wish maximum success, of course, to the Russian team. In fact, I wouldn't mind if Russia won against all other partners except our Japanese team.

Also, next year, Tokyo will host the Olympic and Paralympic Games. So now is precisely the moment to link our future with Russia. I want to address all of you with these words. Japan and Russia should create the future together right now.

I believe that Japanese and Russians, sharing the joy of joint labor, in a situation where the youth of our countries rejoice in life together, are creating for the first time in history the opportunity for us to see one dream, to dream together, and for this to become a good tradition.

Vladimir, you and I see the same future, so let us move forward towards it. President Putin, let us do this for the sake of Russian youth, for those Japanese who are now building this future with their own hands.

Next year marks 75 years since the end of the war. It has been 30 years since the end of the "Cold War." In 1956, our countries firmly promised each other to build relationships based on the principles of peace and good neighborliness, no longer waging war against each other and not considering each other enemies.

And now we are accelerating our movement, quickening our steps, to move in the same direction towards mutual development in various fields: trade, economy, foreign policy, culture, and sports. And, more than ever, joint economic activities on the four islands and people-to-people contacts are advancing.

And through our efforts, a new image of new cooperative relations between Japan and Russia is now being created. And the next step on this path is the conclusion of a peace treaty, which is our historical mission. We can no longer keep waiting for those people who want to and will live in the future.

Vladimir! Let us do everything together to continue moving towards this goal all the time until we achieve it, to keep moving forward. Let us take responsibility before history, let us conclude a peace treaty and thereby open the way to the boundless possibilities that exist for the peoples of our countries. Such a connection between Japan and Russia will soon be able to change the region. And I am confident that it will significantly change the whole world.

Dear ladies and gentlemen present! All Russians!

I would like you to spread your wings of imagination and envision what new enormous opportunities Japan can bring to your future. Let us all together create history, let us together open the path to the future.

Thank you very much.

S. Brilev: Strictly speaking, a year ago on this stage, it was proposed to conclude a peace treaty by December 31 of last year.

I, Mr. Prime Minister, although I am just the moderator, will allow myself to add one detail to your very bright speech: what wonderful kimonos the Chinese masters are preparing in honor of the Russian team going to the Olympics.

And it is all the more regrettable when, against the backdrop of such progressive, truly remarkable movement in Russian-Japanese relations, some nonsense arises. And I want to tell you about one example of such nonsense, I don't know how it translates into Japanese, but I hope the translators caught the nuance of this word, namely about one person who is in this hall.

I don't know, perhaps after this I will certainly not see a visa, but I went to Iturup over the past year and met a couple of very interesting people there. One of them is a large fishery businessman, Alexander Grigoryevich Verkhovsky, I saw him in the corridors here, he is from the southern part of the Kuril Islands. He has business relations with Japan, and he cannot obtain a Japanese visa. Do you know why?

Because he wants to obtain a Japanese visa, and the Japanese consulates say: "You don't need it, you (in our terms) are from the northern territories." He says: "No. I am a citizen of Russia, I live in Iturup, I want to go to Japan, give me a visa." They tell him: "We cannot give you a visa."

As far as I know, the Japanese consulate has already corresponded with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan twice, and this is the situation. Perhaps we could somehow simplify the rules regarding what, I swear, seems to be nonsense, which is an obstacle to the development of such wonderful relations that you have just described?

S. Abe: Regarding what you just said, there are various tasks and problems that need to be overcome, and for this, we must solve this real problem and conclude a peace treaty, which we have been talking about all the time. In this regard, together with President Putin, we are discussing the joint declaration of our two countries from 1956, that is, in accordance with this joint declaration of 1956, we must solve these problems and accelerate the process of concluding a peace treaty. This is a common understanding.

As for the visa issue, I also touched on this point. Regarding joint economic activities on these four islands, some so-called model projects have begun to be implemented, and throughout this implementation, we need to simultaneously overcome all the problems we face, and for this, we need to conduct very concrete discussions and negotiations between Japan and Russia. That is, we are looking to the future and solving issues. As for visas in general between our two countries, each side will take measures. In any case, it is about easing the so-called visa system. We are currently implementing this. Regarding the speed of implementing such measures, I hope that in the future this speed will increase.

S. Brilev: Perhaps, as an exception, you could grant Alexander Grigoryevich a visa? According to Japanese law, he does not need it, but he says: "No, I am a citizen of Russia. Give me a visa."

S. Abe: I cannot speak for one specific person. I do not have the position to respond to that. In any case, to resolve such issues between Tokyo and Moscow, intensive negotiations are being conducted.

S. Brilev: I apologize to the Prime Minister of Malaysia, to whom I must give the floor. Just as we touched on such a topic, I do not want to drop it. Vladimir Vladimirovich, I want to ask you a question regarding what I saw in Iturup.

You know, there are many Japanese graves there. And it is very good and very right that the long-standing problem has finally been resolved, and groups of descendants of those people who rest there can now visit these graves without a visa.

When I was there, I walked around and counted a few things. It has been 75 years, as Shinzo Abe just mentioned, but it has been 75 years since Russian people lived there. And now there are Russian graves, I don't know, fewer or more, but comparable to the number of Japanese graves that exist.

I was lucky; I had the opportunity to ask you this question recently, after the "Direct Line," regarding the Russian flag: should we lower it or not? I do not want to repeat anything in this case. I wanted to ask you a slightly asymmetrical question: how can we imagine this, that is, in the case of a theoretical transfer of the islands, would we then need to transport Russians on special visa-free flights to pay respects at Russian graves?

What I am getting at is that perhaps this is an unsolvable problem by conventional, ordinary means. There is too much that has accumulated here. I can see the schoolchildren from the village of Reidovo on Iturup, who are now waiting for the opening of a new school, right before my eyes. So is it even worth touching this issue? Perhaps we should come up with some unusual option that world history may not have known?

When I was in Japan a few years ago, I publicly recalled the history of these territories. Once, Russia considered them completely its own and voluntarily transferred all these islands as a sign of friendship with Japan by the decision of the Russian Emperor. Then came the well-known tragic events of 1905, the Russo-Japanese War, and the situation on Sakhalin arose. Then World War II happened. This is a complex history with numerous components.

But there is a humanitarian factor. And I cannot but agree with Shinzo that as long as these issues remain unresolved, everything must be done so that people who have a connection to these territories do not feel like victims of geopolitical events of past years. And we, based precisely on humanitarian considerations, are not only responding to these people, to the requests of the Prime Minister of Japan, but we are doing this in an exclusive manner. Not everyone knows this, and not everyone understands the nuance of this exclusivity. It lies in the fact that we are not just creating the opportunity for Japanese citizens to visit these islands, but we are also doing this on a visa-free basis. This has a political component as well, because the Japanese government does not want to issue visas to its citizens for these islands. We understand the delicacy of this situation and are simply accommodating.

Of course, it is very strange for us that Japan, for example, does not issue visas to a specific citizen, but, say, to all Crimeans. Where is Japan, and where is Crimea?!

We understand such kind words that one should believe in Japan, and we truly believe; it is indeed a kind and very good wish. But there are many questions related to the conclusion of a peace treaty. They do not lie solely in the realm of bilateral relations, unfortunately for us. There are military and defense-related issues, security issues. And here we must take into account the position of third countries and Japan's obligations to third countries, including the United States. And besides such kind words, there are also those, I remind you, that originated back in the 1920s and 1930s: a kind word is good, but a kind word and a Smith & Wesson work much more effectively than just a kind word. We understand this well, know it, and must take it into account.

So, in answering your question, I say that at first glance, it seems so simple; in reality, this whole problem has been passed down to us from the past. But we truly, both I and Shinzo, want to solve it. And, no matter how difficult it may be, based on the 1956 declaration, as the Prime Minister said, we will move towards a full resolution of all our relations and strive for the conclusion of a peace treaty.

Shinzo Abe: May I add to what President Putin said?

After Mr. Putin said those words, we then met immediately in Singapore and came to a common opinion that we take the 1956 joint declaration as a basis. But at the same time, as I mentioned in my speech, former residents of this island can now visit these graves and these islands by plane, and they can also visit those areas or regions that just a few years ago they could not visit. And the trust relationship between our two countries has, I believe, been significantly strengthened or enhanced because of all this.

And regarding visas, you raised the question. In order to solve all these problems, at the business level, we are indeed thinking everything through; we have various ideas. And regarding the adjustment of the visa system, we are implementing this gradually. And I see progress that was not there before.

Yes, if I were to put myself in another place or position, you asked such a question, if I were in another position, then I believe that we must think about people from the perspective of humanity. This goes without saying.

Sergei Brilev: Let's return to this a little later, perhaps. And now I would like to additionally introduce a new guest of the Eastern Economic Forum, the Prime Minister of Malaysia, Mr. Mahathir.

When most of those present here were either observing life or still in school, I was in the second grade when Mr. Mahathir first became Prime Minister of his country, in the early 1980s. He is one of the most experienced politicians on this planet. Then he decided to take a short break, but recently returned to the premiership (and we agreed in advance that I have the right to say this in the introduction) at the age of 93, in his 94th year.

M. Mahathir: Your Excellency President Vladimir Putin, President of the Russian Federation! Your Excellency Prime Minister of India Narendra Modi! Your Excellency Prime Minister of Japan Shinzo Abe! Mr. President of Mongolia Khaltmaagiin Battulga! Dear guests, ladies and gentlemen!

First of all, I would like to thank the Government of the Russian Federation and, of course, personally President Putin for the invitation to participate in this forum here in the Far East. Indeed, this is the first time I am participating in this forum, and I am very interested in what is being discussed and has already been discussed on this platform.

Now, having listened to President Putin's speech, I realized that Russia is seriously intent on developing its Far Eastern region. We have always had the impression that Russia does not pay enough attention to the Far Eastern territories. But now we really see that this interest is quite specific and very serious. And for us, this means the designation and opportunity to open new markets for Malaysia.

Malaysia is a country that actively engages in trade and is constantly looking for new markets. If a new market appears and develops, it means the potential for trade growth increases. But I must admit that most Malaysians know very little about Vladivostok. We only know in general that it is a cold part of Russia, but practically no Malaysians have ever visited this city, at least as tourists or as businessmen with trade purposes in this part of Russia. But now it is quite clear that there is potential for the future if Russia is indeed seriously intent on developing this region. Since we know very little about this region so far, it is extremely important for more active outreach to be conducted, to tell more about the opportunities of this area, so that Malaysians can better know this part of the country, become eager to come to Vladivostok, and visit the region as a whole.

We know that tourism is one of the effective ways to develop a country. And in Malaysia, tourism is developing very successfully; the population of the country is 32 million people, but 29 million tourists arrive each year. This is not very much if you compare it to the number of people visiting Venice or Egypt. But for Malaysia, tourism is a very serious item in the budget, and tourism has a significant impact on the overall development of the country.

And our task is to develop tourism, and the best way to do this is through proper positioning and advertising of unique places that can be visited. And there are a huge number of unique places in the world that everyone should visit. But if a new place appears where one can see something fundamentally new, it is always exciting. And I think that Vladivostok can offer such unique opportunities for tourism development. And I have no doubt that Vladivostok will be able to attract tourists from Malaysia and other countries with a tropical climate.

Malaysia is located in the center of Southeast Asia, and from Malaysia, you can easily travel around Southeast Asia, especially within the ASEAN group. But in order to really want to come here, I think the most important factor in attracting attention can be various events and activities.

Mr. Abe has already mentioned the wonderful Rugby World Cup that will be held in Japan and the upcoming match between the Russian and Japanese national teams. I believe that sporting events are very important for attracting attention to the region. If this game were held in Vladivostok, I have no doubt that a huge number of tourists would come from Southeast Asia; everyone would be interested in watching this game. It is like watching a game between two huge giants. In Southeast Asia, there are many small countries. Physically, Malaysia is a small country, and our population is quite small. Therefore, such a game certainly represents great interest for the citizens of Malaysia and many other countries in the region.

Malaysia has become attractive to tourists also thanks to sporting events. We decided to host and build a Formula 1 track, as well as to hold a series of cycling races as part of the Tour de France. Since we held these two sporting events, we have consistently attracted a large number of tourists. But, more importantly, we see that Malaysians themselves are truly becoming passionate about car racing and cycling. Today in Malaysia, you will see a huge number of cyclists practically everywhere on any day, despite the rather humid climate that is not very conducive to physical activity. We still see that Malaysians are starting to truly love sports. In particular, Formula 1 has attracted a large number of tourists from all over the world.

The most remarkable thing about both the Formula 1 races and the Tour Langkawi is that these events are covered by about 300 television channels from around the world. If you were to ask these channels to advertise some specific events, they would demand a fortune from you. Three minutes of airtime costs about a million Malaysian ringgit. But within the framework of these two sporting events, we received coverage of our events for three days during Formula 1 and ten days during the cycling race, with various corners of Malaysia shown on screens all over the world. This is how we received excellent advertising and promotion for the country, allowing us to attract both tourists and investors. And at the same time, there is no need to pay for such advertising. Although, of course, we had to spend money to bring such serious sporting events to our country.

Therefore, I would say that this region of Russia would be very attractive to Malaysian tourists if such mega-events were held here. And Malaysians travel a lot and willingly. The number of outbound tourism from Malaysia each year is very significant. Malaysians are constantly looking for new places they can visit. I am quite confident that at this rate of development, the Far East will attract a large number of Malaysian tourists. But, of course, we are ultimately talking not only about Malaysians but also about tourists from all over the world.

Development is a concept that is close to Malaysia. When Malaysia became an independent country, it immediately became a very poor country, without industry. The only attractive business was in rubber, palm oil, and tin production. But we wanted to become a truly developed country. And so we set ourselves the goal of attracting investments. Malaysia had no technology, no capital, no know-how in the management of large companies, and no special competencies or knowledge of the global market. And it was through attracting foreign direct investment that we suddenly became a truly industrialized country. And today, Malaysia can be viewed from this perspective.

But, of course, in addition to this, it can be said that the income of the population has grown, and the country itself has begun to actively develop thanks to the efforts of investors, including from the private sector. And I am quite confident that Malaysian investors will likely come here to the Far East.

I just recently returned from Cambodia; I was in Phnom Penh. And in Phnom Penh alone, there are 3,000 Malaysian businessmen; they live and work there and make a significant contribution to the development of Cambodia. I am quite confident that, at least to a lesser extent, Malaysian investors can also come to this region and make their contribution to the growth and development of Vladivostok.

In Malaysia, there are a number of hotel chains, and Malaysian hoteliers are actively operating around the world. Not long ago, a Malaysian hotelier acquired 20 hotels in Iceland. It is hard to imagine that Iceland can be a very attractive destination for tourists, but a large number of people are now heading to Iceland to see the Northern Lights and this stunningly clean, eco-friendly, but very snowy country. And the very name of the country "Iceland" (and neighboring Greenland) is intriguing. And look, Greenland seems to be called the "green country," but it is so white, while Iceland is a green country but is called "Iceland," meaning snowy and icy. So, the Malaysian hotelier decided to invest in Iceland.

In fact, I will be heading to Kyoto very soon, directly from this event. In Kyoto, we have also built a new hotel, a hotelier from Malaysia. Hotels are absolutely necessary and important if you want to attract more tourists. Hotels of different levels, not only five-star hotels, which are certainly popular, but also three-star hotels, which are also in high demand. And this is where our experience and competencies from Malaysia come into play. We would be very happy to share them.

We were pleased to hear that Russia intends to develop the Far East. And Russia is one of the few countries that is simultaneously in Europe and Asia. The second such country is Turkey. But Russia has a unique geographical position, truly representing a bridge between the West and the East, between Europe and Asia. And I believe that this position will help Russia play an important role not only in Europe but also in the Far East.

With Russia's participation in the development of the Far East, I think all residents of the Far East, including Asians, will feel all the benefits and advantages of such activities aimed at developing this part of Russia.

I came here to learn more about this region of Russia. I want to know what other plans there are for the development of Vladivostok. All I know about Vladivostok is that it is a rather cold city. And when my plane landed yesterday, I was shocked to see that it is not cold at all here; the temperature was about the same as it is now in Malaysia – 24-25 degrees. So my only impression of Vladivostok turned out to be incorrect. It is important to know that not everything we believe is true. It does not always snow here. Although, I think that probably when it does snow here, the city looks truly beautiful.

But the very fact of learning that Russia can be a very warm and friendly place can already be an important factor of attractiveness for Malaysians and people from Southeast Asia.

I want to say that the relations between Malaysia and Russia have always been good. I met with President Putin a long time ago; we have met many times in various formats. We have never missed an opportunity to hold bilateral talks; we have always found time. It seems to me that this is true; bilateral talks and bilateral relations truly develop the connection between our countries.

When Russia first presented its combat aircraft in Langkawi at the international exhibition showcasing maritime and aviation solutions, we indeed saw that the interest in Russian products was very high, and a number of deals were concluded. Therefore, Malaysia is indeed a wonderful market for promoting its products because you can be sure that you will attract the attention not only of Malaysia but also of many other countries in Southeast Asia. Without a doubt, this also applies to the production of equipment. And the sales volumes of Russian products have increased over these years. We hope that this cooperation will grow and deepen, primarily in the field of education. There is a proposal to create a university that will focus specifically on the space industry and engineering research. And this would be a very serious contribution to the education system of Malaysia.

Malaysia is already today a hub for international education. We attract a huge number of international students to Malaysia. It seems to me that there are some students from Russia as well. We have students coming from Africa, Central Asia, and many other countries. And if Russia continues to promote and develop education in this region, especially in engineering competencies and the aerospace industry, then, without a doubt, Malaysia is the place where a university should be established.

We had long discussions with President Putin this morning. And I believe that we were able to discuss a large number of areas where we can cooperate. And I see only advantages, mutual advantages from closer relations between our countries.

I thank you once again for the opportunity to participate in this forum, and I hope that as a result, we will see a deepening of cooperation and friendship between Malaysia and Russia for the benefit of our peoples.

Thank you very much.

I would like to say just a couple of words in connection with the speech of the Prime Minister.

Under his leadership, Malaysia has indeed transformed into a very interesting developed economy, a promising country. And when about 12 years ago (time flies) the Prime Minister was leaving his post and assumed that he was ending his political career, we met in Malaysia at his home, his wife invited me. It was a very warm meeting. I went home out of respect for my then-colleague, despite the fact that his political career, as he and I believed, was over. Since then, much has changed, but the Prime Minister's attitude towards our country has not changed.

He was one of the initiators of Russia becoming an observer in the Organization of Islamic Cooperation. I believe that his influence as one of the oldest political figures in the world, as one of the leaders of the Islamic world, undoubtedly extends beyond his country. Therefore, I am very pleased that he maintains such a good attitude towards Russia and came to us today. I ask the audience to once again warmly welcome him.

S. Brilev: Prime Minister, by the way, what do you think is the maximum age for being in politics?

M. Mohamad: At the moment, we have raised this age limit to 95 years.

S. Brilev: Vladimir Vladimirovich…

I am not quite there yet.

S. Brilev: Fortunately, we have just heard the speeches of the session participants; I wanted to emphasize that the composition of the participants of the Eastern Economic Forum is expanding. I was very pleased to hear Spanish being spoken in the corridors. We met with Laureano Ortega, the special representative of Nicaragua for relations with Russia. This is the first participation of Latin Americans, as far as I know. Laureano asked me to convey greetings to you, Vladimir Vladimirovich, from his father, President and Commander Daniel Ortega. But I also cannot help but notice that Ukrainian investors have appeared in the hall. Here is Mr. Medvedchuk, an investor. Vladimir Vladimirovich, when will the exchange take place?

I think Mr. Medvedchuk will now torment me on this issue. I know that he is particularly concerned about several individuals who are in places of deprivation of liberty in the Russian Federation. It has been quite difficult for us to make decisions regarding specific people, these specific individuals. However, based on humanitarian considerations, we are approaching the finalization of negotiations that we are conducting, including with the official authorities. So I think this will become known in the near future.

S. Brilev: The prospect of some exchanges with Ukraine, further negotiations – this is, in a way, a compass (I will allow myself to use this expression) in relations with those countries, let’s say, the G7 countries. What’s next, after the exchange, Vladimir Vladimirovich, possibly in the Ukrainian direction, between Russia and Ukraine?

I believe that in the historical perspective, this is inevitable, in my opinion: there will be a complete normalization of relations because we are two parts of the same people, I have said this many times. As for the near-term perspective, it will largely depend on the current Ukrainian leadership.

S. Brilev: Are we expecting something by the end of the week, or is it better not to talk about timelines now…

No, I have already said that we will finalize our negotiations regarding exchanges. I think it will be quite large-scale. And that would already be a good step forward towards normalization.

S. Brilev: Mr. Abe, I wanted to ask you in this regard. When I just said: “the G7”. We all heard the report that President Trump was, at the last G7 summit, something of an advocate for the Russian Federation and Vladimir Putin. You observed this from the inside. Without violating any obvious rules, since it is a closed club, perhaps you could tell us how it went?

S. Abe: As for the G7, there used to be the G8 – there was a discussion about the fact that constructive influence on the international community is of great importance. But, as President Putin knows well, because he participated in the G8, there are such rules: you can only quote yourself, so you cannot quote other leaders. Therefore, I cannot say what exactly President Trump said there, for example. But I personally said that for solving international problems, Russian influence, Russian constructive influence plays an important role. Therefore, I raised the topic of the possible return of Russia to this format.

S. Brilev: If invited, would you go, Vladimir Vladimirovich?

Where?

S. Brilev: To the G8. I believe the next one will be in the States. Although, it will be right in the middle of Trump’s election campaign.

At one time, the next G8 was supposed to take place in Russia.

S. Brilev: In Sochi, yes.

We are open. If our partners want to come to us, we will be happy. It was not us who postponed it, but our partners postponed it. If they want to restore the G8, please. But I think it is clear to everyone today, and President Macron recently said publicly that Western leadership is coming to an end. I cannot imagine an effective international organization that operates without India and without China.

Any formats are always beneficial; it is always a positive exchange of opinions, even when it takes place in heightened tones, as I understand it was this time at the G7; it is still useful. Therefore, we do not refuse any format of cooperation.

S. Brilev: Mr. Modi, if such an invitation were to be extended: to expand the G7 to (how many more – Russia, India, China) the G10, would you go to the G10?

N. Modi: Yes, in principle, we support the idea of a multipolar world. And like-minded countries support us in this regard. People meet and gather in various formats to discuss issues of global significance. Each forum has its own importance and significance. This time I had the opportunity to participate in the G7 summit as an observer. And whatever role we played as an observer, we fulfilled it quite well.

Nevertheless, the question at hand, if I were asked this question within the framework of the G7 forum, whether I would like to be part of such a forum, I think it would be necessary to respond appropriately: yes or no. But in response to your question, I do not think that this is actually appropriate.

I recently spoke, that is, it was not me who spoke, but President Erdogan of Turkey spoke to me; he, reacting to the whole situation, said: “Why didn’t you raise the question of Turkey being included in this composition?” I think that after Turkey acquired the S-400, it is reliably protected from the sky, of course, and Turkey's work in such a format would also be in demand and appropriate, considering its role in international affairs and in the region.

S. Brilev: In fact, I understood from the last two remarks of the Prime Minister of India and the President of Russia that the G20 is the format that quite effectively addresses the tasks at hand. Right?

Today, perhaps, this is the most representative international organization dealing with the coordination of positions in the economic sphere.

S. Brilev: Don’t be surprised by my next question, but I hope it will serve as an interesting bridge. My question is for the President of Mongolia.

There is one suspicious coincidence. The call from President Trump to President Putin came on the day you were in Washington. Did you suggest this to Trump?

He, he, definitely.

S. Brilev: Well, tell us.

H. Battulga: There is some misunderstanding between large countries, and during my visit to America, I said that we live on one planet, Siberia is part of this planet, part of the large global world. Siberian forests are burning. I told him (the American president): “Why don’t you call and express your condolences, your sympathy regarding this? We live on one earth. Siberia is the lungs of our planet. These lungs are burning. Why don’t you express your sympathy?”

S. Brilev: So the suspicions were not unfounded.

I used to work where I understand the ongoing events.

S. Brilev: Vladimir Vladimirovich, there was recently communication with Trump, and now the idea of the G8 has been mentioned again, something, somehow. Where to start? After all, so much has really accumulated in relations over the past few years.

I looked at the statistics. Last year, 40 people, only private citizens of the Russian Federation, were arrested at the request of the United States in third countries, just last year. January 2019 – citizen Makarenko. I do not know what he is accused of, but the fact remains. Now I saw, now I will find, Korshunov in Naples, almost the United Engine Corporation.

Is it easy to step over this? How to start renewing dialogue against such a backdrop?

This is a very bad practice; they complicate our intergovernmental relations, I speak without any jokes, without irony. We often see no grounds for such unfriendly actions. Moreover, I have every reason to believe that this is sometimes related to competitive struggles. There may be some criminal manifestations, but our law enforcement agencies should cooperate better; we need to sign the relevant intergovernmental documents, agreements on how to act. However, some of these documents do exist.

S. Brilev: We have, since 1999, I believe, an agreement on legal assistance?

There are some documents, but they are not actually working. They could be updated.

But partly this is also related to competitive struggle. For example, in the field of aircraft manufacturing. I have already mentioned that we are developing a very good aircraft, a very good, competitive, medium-haul MS-21. It is a clear competitor to the Boeing 737. But they took and included in the sanctions list the products for wing production. It has nothing to do with defense. Nothing! We will do it ourselves; cooperation would simply be appropriate, and we were ready to purchase the relevant American materials, just as they buy a large amount of titanium from us and produce Boeings from our titanium. We will do it anyway. It will take time; we thought it would take about two years, but probably less, about a year and a half. It is already flying with us. And we will have these materials. But perhaps it is partly good because we will have our own materials, and we will not depend on anyone in this regard.

Now regarding the specific individual you mentioned who is involved in engine manufacturing and works in the engine manufacturing corporation—there are accusations and hints that he was involved in stealing some secrets. We have heard these accusations regarding the People's Republic of China. We do not know what is happening there; I think it is mostly fabrications, but here we know for sure. This United Engine Corporation has developed a new Russian engine; it took a long time, and this is our first high-tech product in the last 28 years. And it was developed by our engine manufacturing corporation, specific enterprises with very good competencies and skilled personnel, with world-class science. Yes, we signed a contract with an Italian company for consultations. This is absolutely natural global practice. This is open commercial work with European partners.

Now supposedly our American friends claim that some Americans have moved to work in this company and stole something. But if they stole, let them deal with it, but what they stole is of no use to us because everything is done with our own hands and our own minds, the minds of our specialists. Consultations, some joint work on modern high-tech products—this is absolutely natural, open, public work.

Therefore, I believe that in this case we are definitely dealing with attempts at unfair competition. This does not improve our relations.

S. Brilev: Those of us who want good in the relations between Russia and the West, nevertheless, after all these years, are looking closely at the details. And I promise that we will literally return to the economy, which is designated as the title of this forum, but still one more, if you will, military-political question.

I want, of course, to take advantage of Prime Minister Abe's presence in this regard. On August 27, many world agencies, in particular the Agence France-Presse, reported on the upcoming supply of American missiles for missile defense to Japan.

Against the backdrop of the end of the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty, all that is now known even to non-specialists about the peculiarities of launchers in Romania and Poland, excuse the long explanation, but if someone has forgotten, against the backdrop of the fact that the Gorbachev-Reagan treaty was concluded regarding Europe, but the Soviet Union destroyed all its such missiles in Asia, this may change the missile configuration in Asia.

Two questions, Vladimir Vladimirovich. If anyone else among the participants wants to comment, we would naturally be grateful. First. Your vision of a possible mechanism for control, limitation, however you want to call it, of missile affairs in Asia, will it be necessary, especially with the emergence of American missiles? Second. I promised to return to this topic when you mentioned it. Here it is, perhaps, the very turning point. How do you negotiate with the Japanese against this backdrop? You have already mentioned this American military aspect. Here it is, perhaps, an example at least.

Our position regarding the U.S. withdrawal from the Intermediate-Range Nuclear Forces Treaty is well known. There is no need to repeat it. We not only do not welcome this step, we believe that it is counterproductive and undermines the system of international security and arms control.

We have already publicly stated that we will not deploy, after the Americans tested such a missile (and we will produce similar missiles, of course), in those regions where American-made missile systems of this class of ground-based deployment do not appear.

What the head of the Pentagon stated about the U.S. intention to deploy them in Japan and South Korea does not please us; it upsets us and raises certain concerns. In fact, this has been the subject of our discussions with the Prime Minister repeatedly, even before the Americans produced missiles of this kind. If they are deployed in Japan or South Korea, we understand that this will be done under the pretext of countering threats from North Korea, but for us, this creates certain and significant problems because most likely these missile systems will cover a significant part of Russian territory, including in the Far East.

I would like to remind you that there are two very large military bases of ours for surface ships here, in Vladivostok, where we are now, and nuclear strategic missile submarines in Kamchatka. This is a serious matter. And, of course, we cannot ignore this. This will also be a factor in our negotiations with Japan and South Korea. We do not yet know the reaction of our Japanese and Korean partners in this regard. We did not discuss this with the Prime Minister today.

By the way, we have pointed out many times that the MK-41 launchers are capable not only of being used for interceptors in the missile defense system but also for launching strike missile systems. The Americans have always told us that this is not the case. But now they have taken and tested this system precisely with the MK-41 installation. That is, this is part of strike missile complexes. We were right, as in many other cases. I assume that we were misled. We are not mistaken in this regard, but we will be forced to respond adequately.

S. Abe: First of all, I want to say that in Poland or Korea, the missile defense system is deployed, but it belongs to the United States, and the U.S. manages it. In Japan, there is also its own missile defense system; it belongs to Japan, and Japan manages it. It is not managed by the United States.

As for the implementation of Aegis Ashore, we are currently considering such an opportunity, but it will belong to Japan, and the management will also belong to Japan. Therefore, this is sharply different, that is, fundamentally different, for example, from THAAD, which is deployed in Poland.

Regarding Japan's defense system. North Korea has deployed several hundred ballistic missiles. To protect against this, we decided to implement our own system. The launch of a ballistic missile is a violation of UN Security Council resolutions; this is carried out by North Korea, and this, of course, causes great regret. But in order to protect our country from such behavior, we are deploying our system.

As for the deployment of American missile systems on Japanese territory, such a proposal has not even been made by the United States. And what is currently deployed in Japan belongs to Japan; that is, it is Japanese property, and it is intended for protection. For example, it is technically impossible to launch a Tomahawk from this system; I want to make this clear.

The head of the Pentagon stated that the U.S. is negotiating with Japan and South Korea and intends to continue doing so for the purpose of deploying its ground-based missile systems of intermediate range there.

We, I repeat, have not yet conducted negotiations on this matter with Shinzo, but we will have time...

S. Brilev: Better, Vladimir Vladimirovich, do not say more. Otherwise, to the asked question, you had to tell what you...

...And at the level of the foreign ministries, we will still work on this.

S. Brilev: Thank you.

Perhaps we will return to the topic of security; it cannot be avoided for economic development, but still, I would like to talk about the economy. There was a very good session of the Valdai International Club within the framework of the forum, a representative of the World Bank spoke, and I really liked how he formulated it. He formulated that between, say, Russia and India, as well as between Russia and China, there is a lack of trade. That is, the existing capacities and productions would already be enough to trade with each other much more. Yes, the task has been set to increase from 10 to 30 billion, I believe, in Russian-Indian trade turnover. But this is still quite modest.

Prime Minister Modi, what would you see as examples of progressive development of Russian-Indian economic cooperation?

N. Modi: You asked a very contemporary question. There are colossal opportunities. Until now, we have been making efforts, using all our potential, all the diversity of tools, to achieve the best possible results. However, the current work is not enough. Both India and Russia realize this. Yes, we do not accept such a situation.

But if you remember, there was a time when relations between Russia and India were predominantly seller-buyer relations. We purchased weapons from Russia. And now, in addition to that, there are other sectors: diamonds, oil, the energy sector. The Russian Federation is investing in India. India, in turn, is investing in Russia; tourist flows between our countries are growing. In addition, political contacts and interactions have significantly intensified.

Russia is a long-standing partner of India, whom we trust. Now we have managed to break out of this "seller-buyer" scheme. We both sell and buy simultaneously, both countries. We are trying to develop our economic relations in almost all sectors, including in the Far East.

I came here not to give a lecture and leave. Before this, there were delegations, representatives of large Indian states, more than several hundred representatives of the business community. Before that, I was at the St. Petersburg Forum. We met with Russian businessmen in India. In other words, where there is potential, we highlight and identify it. We are trying to understand how we can complement each other to create added value, what other plans we can make.

I fully understand that we should not rest on our laurels if the World Bank report states that we have excellent trade indicators. Even if that were the case, I would not be satisfied; I would strive for more. President Putin and I, in addition to friendship, have something else in common. We never rest on our laurels; we constantly try to move forward, we do not settle for what we have achieved, we strive for better results. We have many issues that excite our enthusiasm or concern. And even despite this bank report, we are trying to strive for more.

S. Brilev: And one more question in that case about where to strive for more.

Diving into your speeches, I, of course, prepared and read, I noticed that you have one of your favorite topics—youth. One of the non-stereotypical, but deserved elements of modern India's reputation is that it is a superpower in software, computer technologies, and so on. But somehow this involuntarily connects one with the other in the mind—computer technologies and youth. For your youth and for the world's youth within this economic exchange (by the way, there was a separate youth session, but it was a little in another direction), what would you see: youth and economy—where, why?

N. Modi: Yes, you are absolutely right. India is a superpower, and in addition, it is a country with a huge youth population. But how to take advantage of this potential? How to move forward?

Last year, President Putin and I spent two days together. It was an unofficial meeting; we had no specific agenda at that time. We just met, and we went to a school that made a tremendous impression on me. And when President Putin came to India, I asked him to bring those kids from Sochi. And we gathered some amazing students from India. And we held a kind of hackathon—this is a marathon for ICT specialists, innovation specialists, to see what we can give to the world. It was a wonderful experiment.

Now Indian students will come to Sochi in turn. Such a wonderful exchange of ideas and technologies. Youth is a new force forming in India and around the world. By the way, we are one of the three most favorable places in the world for startups. The youth's minds are geared towards innovation, and we want such young people with innovative ideas to come together and achieve great results together. Of course, technology is the most important element of our modern life. Without technology, one cannot survive. So for the common good, we must look at how we can use these technologies together. If we combine the brain resources of India and Russia, we will be able to achieve impressive results.

S. Brilev: Vladimir Vladimirovich, the Prime Minister was referring, of course, to "Sirius" in Sochi. There are wonderful kids there. There are kids in ASI, but there is also that youth that has been taking to the streets in the last few Saturdays, for example. Is this youth your youth?

Listen, Shinzo mentioned that in Japan they have started to walk faster. That's good. Let's say, in Chechnya or Dagestan, they walk at the same pace as before, but the birth rate is three times higher than in Japan. The question is what to spend energy on. I believe that all of us, and especially young people, should spend energy on processes that lead to creation.

When people express their opinions, including during protests, as I have already mentioned, I believe they have the right to do so. And sometimes this leads to positive results because it shakes up the authorities, aligns them in the right direction so that they can more effectively address the problems facing the people. But it is essential to act in a positive manner, guided not by narrow self-serving or group interests, but by the interests of the country and the people, and to act within the established rules and laws. I have always adhered to this point of view, I continue to do so, and the practice of developments and events in the world and among our neighbors indicates that this is the correct approach.

As for "yours" or "not ours," I am convinced that these are people who, for the most part—there are, of course, different ones—but mainly they are people who are positively inclined, who want the country to develop, who wish to contribute to its development. The only question is for them to find their place in life. And it is the duty of the authorities to do everything possible to help them find that place and to apply the maximum of their knowledge and talent for the constructive development of the country.

Young people are always impulsive, active, and that is good. I repeat once again: it is only important that all of this is within the framework of the law. But I am confident that many of the people engaged in political activity will be in demand in the future, both in their professions and in the political sphere as well.

S. Brilev: Vladimir Vladimirovich, I recall the experience of my generation; I am 47. We, the guys, in the late 80s—I was still a younger schoolboy—but in the early 90s, we attended rallies. I remember very well the large Moscow rally against Article 6 of the Constitution. We all, students, went. The article of the Constitution dedicated to the fact that the Communist Party of the Soviet Union is the core of the political system.

We went to this rally precisely with these considerations. And when we reached this rally, it was on Zubovsky Boulevard, where, by various estimates, there were either hundreds of thousands of people or almost a million, suddenly someone from the podium said: "Politburo resign! Please raise your hands." And it felt awkward not to raise them; everyone seemed to be raising their hands, although we actually came for a different reason.

Young people can be easily confused at times. Maybe we should be a bit gentler with them?

Within the framework of the law, the same for everyone.

S. Brilev: Thank you.

We have not finished discussing several issues regarding security. And there are still several things we have not discussed regarding politics. Now, when I scanned the room, I once again noticed Mr. Medvedchuk and recalled President Zelensky's statement that the "Opposition Platform – For Life" party receives foreign funding. Vladimir Vladimirovich, have you seen this statement? What is your opinion on it?

No. I have not seen that statement. But if it was made, it means that the current authorities in Kyiv risk stepping on the same rake that the previous Ukrainian leadership, represented by the former president, Mr. Poroshenko, stepped on. If the current government begins to persecute the opposition, nothing good will come of it. This is, as far as I understand, a parliamentary opposition that has the trust of a significant number of voters, confirmed during democratic elections and voting. Therefore, it would be strange if there were any attempts to "tighten the screws" in this sense. They are not running around the squares demanding the impossible. They are working within the framework of the Constitution of Ukraine, within the framework of the law. In my opinion, it would be a grave mistake to attempt to hinder the realization of their constitutional rights.

S. Brilev: We have briefly touched on one very important, absolutely certain topic for everyone here. This is the topic of Iran, new anti-Iranian sanctions. What was it called? The third phase of Iran's exit from the nuclear deal. Mr. Abe, you recently visited Iran. By the way, it was very unexpected to see such a bright combination: Iranians, Japanese—a cocktail in itself is unusual. But you did not go there by chance. What is your perspective on the future of the Iranian nuclear deal, regarding your relationships with the countries involved in this discussion, as well as in this conflict, in the freedom of navigation? What is Japan's view on this topic?

S. Abe: As for Japan, we have long been communicating our own position to America, that we have our own position.

Regarding Iran and all the problems related to nuclear issues, I sincerely wish that all of this is resolved through negotiations.

Japan has historically friendly relations with Iran. Therefore, I believe and have always believed that we should indeed use, in a good sense of the word, our historically good relations. That is why I visited Iran and held talks with the President, as well as with Mr. Khamenei. He clearly stated that Iran does not produce and will not use nuclear weapons. He said this clearly; the supreme leader of this country stated it clearly.

As for the President of Iran, he said the following: "We will strive exclusively for dialogue, to resolve all problems through dialogue."

As for Japan, regarding our resources, we rely heavily on resources from the Middle East, and passage through the strait is very valuable and necessary for our country in terms of energy carriers. Ensuring the safety of the tankers that transport all of this to Japan is very important. Therefore, we need to make diplomatic efforts to ensure safety. France is making every effort, and Japan is also making every effort.

Regarding the future, we will actively use all these positive, historically established prerequisites, and I hope that all of this will be resolved. As for what is on the minds of those in Iran, we exchanged opinions on this, particularly with President Putin.

S. Brilev: Mr. Modi, will India be sending its naval forces to the Strait of Hormuz? This strait connects the Persian Gulf to the open Indian Ocean, through which Arab and Persian oil traffic flows.

N. Modi: The history of India is known to the whole world. The greatest contribution that India has made is that it has put in a lot of effort to establish peace throughout the world and has participated in peacekeeping operations. And to this day, India has always acted independently and has not undertaken any such actions. During the First and Second World Wars, which did not coincide with our agenda and did not align with our intentions, India also suffered losses, and 150,000 people died at that time. However, India has never associated itself with militaristic trends.

But regarding the security of the energy sector and our security, we have indeed relied heavily on Iran for energy security. However, in recent times, the problems that exist in this region have made us think about how we can avoid suffering from the side effects of the situation we are currently observing, to ensure that our security is not compromised, that tankers are not harmed, and that our vessels are not harmed. We have taken measures to ensure security. For our tankers, we have implemented security measures to ensure their safety. However, we will not take any additional measures; that is not our way—to go down a militaristic path. No one in the world is discussing our involvement in any negative way.

S. Brilev: Vladimir Vladimirovich, what about the Russian naval presence in that area? During Soviet times, it was quite significant.

Given the development of our Armed Forces and Navy from a military-technical perspective, this is not a problem for us. The question is that all these actions should be effective and lead to resolution, to an increase in the level of security in the region and in the Strait of Hormuz in particular.

A few years ago, Russia proposed the initiative to create an international mechanism involving almost all interested countries in the region and those who are interested in the normal functioning of these routes, with the involvement of Russia and Asian countries, the United States. In the future, it could even be possible to create a specialized international organization to address these issues. We are currently discussing this with colleagues, including our Chinese partners, and with others as well. We will see what this leads to. Without a doubt, Russia is interested in the situation de-escalating, not escalating further, and the actions of all participants in this process leading to calming the situation and resolving problems, including those surrounding the Iranian nuclear program, based on previously adopted international documents confirmed by the relevant resolutions of the United Nations.

S. Brilev: In that case, the last question on security. There is a curious change in the world regarding the fact that there are three nuclear powers in NATO: America, the United Kingdom, France, while in the Shanghai Cooperation Organization, there are already four: Russia, China, India, Pakistan. Of course, a lot depends on Russian-American agreements, including in the area of strategic stability. Vladimir Vladimirovich, what do you think: in the year before last, in your Address to the Federal Assembly, new types of high-tech weapons were presented, particularly hypersonic ones.

Hypersonic.

S. Brilev: Could they become part of some larger deal with the Americans?

Yes, we proceed from the fact that the existing instruments, and in fact only one of them remains, which is the New START treaty, limiting strategic offensive arms, this treaty is indeed concluded between Russia and the United States... Now the United States has put forward a new version, wanting to involve the People's Republic of China in this joint work, but the Chinese argue quite reasonably that their nuclear potential is much lower than that of Russia and the United States, and they do not understand what they should reduce if they already have fewer carriers and fewer warheads. This situation looks quite logical.

But let us not forget that the United States has not even joined the treaty on the prohibition of nuclear weapons testing.

S. Brilev: They did not ratify it.

They did not ratify it—meaning they did not join.

They are now talking about the possibility of placing weapons in space. These are all very serious challenges that humanity may face. Just imagine that above the head of each of us, and therefore each of them, some kind of weapon, perhaps even nuclear, will be constantly hanging in geostationary orbit. The flight time will be very short, and the means of protection will be very complex. And this could indeed change, it could fundamentally change the situation in the world in terms of security.

So far, our American partners have remained silent on all our proposals for continuing contacts in the field of disarmament, for curbing the arms race; in fact, there is nothing new here. The last time we met with our American partners was in Osaka, and the question was also raised about how it might be possible to account for our new modern weapons, including hypersonic strike missile systems, in the overall agreement, bearing in mind that so far no country in the world, including the United States, has such weapons. I told Donald: "If you want, we can sell it to you, and thus immediately balance everything." They, however, say that they will produce it themselves soon. They will probably produce it soon. But why spend money when we have already spent it, and we can get something from them without compromising our security, but with the aim of creating a situation of balance. But we can also talk about how and what can be accounted for, considering the number of carriers and the number of warheads. This is a special question. In any case, Russia is ready for this dialogue, for this discussion. But so far, we have not received a clear response from the Americans.

S. Brilev: Our session has been going on for quite a while. I suggest we now move on to perhaps the last major topic, but one that is certainly common. In fact, the way the President of Mongolia easily convinced Donald Trump to call you, Vladimir Vladimirovich, about the issue of forest fires is confirmation of that.

No matter how any of us feels about the nature of global warming (there are different versions, and that is not the point right now), we are witnessing unprecedented changes in the climate; they are simply evident. And it is not just that there is now satellite communication everywhere, signals come quickly, and we instantly learn about fires in the Brazilian forests or in Siberia. The point is that we are simply observing. Forgive me for a very down-to-earth example; I am a mushroom picker, and for the last two years, I have been picking mushrooms until October 20. This has never happened before, and there is clearly nothing good about it. Of course, it is good for me.

You are not the one setting the forests on fire?

S. Brilev: No, that is in the Moscow region.

The topic is very complex, but let me apply it to the participants of this session. For instance, it is good for Russia that the Arctic Ocean is providing more time for ships to pass through; ice is not forming. But at the same time, we understand that on the shore, due to the melting permafrost, the piles are starting to move. I witnessed this: in the Kola Peninsula, rivers did not freeze in time, reindeer herders cannot move their reindeer in time, and the reindeer do not provide enough meat. But there are also very global problems related to infrastructure.

The topic is common because, ultimately, Russian Arctic gas and oil will go along the new route mentioned today by the prime ministers of India and Japan. And the problems with the Siberian forests easily reach Mongolia. We have the Paris Agreement; one could say: what else is there to think about, let’s just implement it. But I have the feeling that we have reached a point where we need to do something more about this.

Let us start with the President of Mongolia, who, in fact, was the first to raise this topic with us today. What could we do together, seriously do together?

Khaltmaagiin Battulga: As I have already said, we live on one planet; these are all our problems, our mistakes. Today, waste has become a very large, global problem, air pollution, environmental pollution. There are companies with certain statuses that I think should contribute at least 1 percent of their total revenue to a common environmental protection fund. We have such experience: the majority of companies contributed 1 percent of their revenues to a children's fund. Therefore, I think we can create a global environmental protection fund and call on companies to contribute a certain percentage of their income, perhaps within the framework of the G20 or G7. We do not have another, backup planet. We must take responsibility for our common future.

Sergei Brilev: Prime Minister Modi, you have set the task, if I remember correctly, to make India the first country to fully switch to electric vehicles by 2030, but electricity will still have to be produced from coal, oil, and gas. What ideas do you have? How can we connect one with the other?

Narendra Modi: I understand that we are talking about climate change. I want to thank you for raising such an important topic. Today, everything that is happening in the world around us causes concern. At some point, our ancestors took measures to save our world, and everything we have today is the legacy of our ancestors. Therefore, we must also think about future generations and preserve our world for them so that they can inherit it and pass it on to other generations, as well as live happily. Mahatma Gandhi spoke about the principle of trust. It is in this spirit, in this trust, that we must think about the fact that we have been entrusted with this planet. We must not think about what we want; we should not try to deprive someone in order to meet our needs. We cannot apply this principle in our social structures. If we abandon this principle, we can resolve our problems.

We can think that technology can solve our problems if we work together. But in reality, we are talking about a change in the behavior of each individual person. People must know which path they should take moving forward.

Of course, we need to develop technologies. For example, during the 21st Conference of the Parties [to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change], we talked about creating 175 gigawatts of energy from renewable sources in India so that we could positively contribute to the fight against climate change. I can say that we have already largely transitioned to solar energy from this goal of 175 gigawatts from renewable energy sources, thus making a significant contribution to achieving this goal. The goal we set for ourselves is 175 gigawatts by 2022, and we will achieve it.

As for mobility, the world must think about how we can move towards electric vehicles, for example. We also talk about markets, about our businesses, and how they can use these technologies. But the question now is: can India further utilize solar panels? India can become a manufacturer of solar panels. And all the various nuclear power plants that we are currently building, and other energy facilities, we are nevertheless focusing on the production of solar panels because such panels are popular.

For example, the battery in mobile phones is already very small; it can function for a long time—24 hours, 26 hours. Mobile phones have also become very affordable. Solar panel technologies have also become accessible. Now, for example, we want to switch to clean cooking. 250 million households should already transition to environmentally safe cooking. We want to provide energy for these households, and we want solar energy to come to the rescue. We want to develop battery systems and also use methods for conserving and storing solar energy so that it can be used for clean cooking in the future. Therefore, we want to do a lot in this direction. We have invited companies to come to India and think about what can be done. Consider that we have 250 million families that need these batteries, this energy. If we take into account what a huge market this is, we can subsidize and work together with the electric vehicle market. I think these are huge changes, but they are necessary for us.

Sergei Brilev: Prime Minister Abe, my compliments to Japan, which still burns coal—and there is no smoke at all. You should see Japanese coal stations. This is what you need to spread around the world. This is also a question for you, essentially.

Shinzo Abe: Japanese coal technology is at the highest level, meaning that the efficiency of Japan's coal-fired power plants is 20 percent higher than the world standard. If we spread our coal power plant technologies to rapidly growing economies, we can reduce CO2 emissions by as much as Japan releases. Furthermore, we intend to use gasification and fuel cells together, and thus we would like to increase efficiency by another 40 percent.

From the perspective of achieving a carbon-free society, breakthrough innovations are necessary. In this regard, hydrogen will play a key role, as it will not emit CO2. In this regard, Japan was the first in the world to implement fuel cell vehicles, and now a hydrogen production plant is being built in Fukushima Prefecture. This is the largest plant using... And next year, during the Olympics and Paralympics, we plan to use this hydrogen to power vehicles.

The biggest problem with hydrogen is its cost, the high cost. But we have a long-term strategy that aims to reduce the cost of hydrogen production to the level of natural gas, that is, by ten times. We also have plans to implement CO2 recycling technologies, including using artificial photosynthesis technologies. Thus, Japan will lead in innovations using existing and cutting-edge technologies.

Sergei Brilev: Vladimir Vladimirovich, look at the unanimity on this topic. There has indeed been a lot of discussion today, not necessarily articulated, but everyone is completely united here. Perhaps the most promising story in the Northeast and indeed in Asia, which we should talk about, is ecology.

Ecology is very closely linked to energy. This is precisely what we are all discussing. But global warming also affects Russia, not least. I have already mentioned this at the G20; according to our data, according to international experts, warming is occurring 2.5 times faster in Russia than in the world as a whole. This poses certain threats for us, especially in the north, where, as you rightly noted, our settlements are built on piles on permafrost. And questions arise: what and how should we do in this regard?

We support all international efforts in this direction. As you know, we supported the Paris Agreement and took on quite serious commitments: to reduce emissions by about 70-75 percent from the baseline year of 1990. By the way, EU countries have taken more modest commitments from the same baseline year of 1990. They are committing to reduce emissions by 60 percent.

Now we talked about electric vehicles. Just now, international organizations recorded a sharp decline in electric vehicle sales for the first time in modern history. There are certain reasons for this. But our ecological problems are not only related to warming; they are also related to the use of gas motor fuel, the large number of these vehicles in major cities, and the use of various types of fuel, including coal, in the housing and utilities sector. All of this is included in the program we have prepared to improve the ecological situation in the country. This is one of the problems.

At the same time, I want to note that globally, the structure of Russian energy is one of the most "green" in the world. More than one-third of our energy comes from hydropower and nuclear energy, and more than 50 percent comes from gas, which, as you know, is the most environmentally friendly type of fuel among all hydrocarbons. And we are still a country rich in hydrocarbons; this is our competitive advantage, and we must never forget that we must effectively utilize this competitive advantage.

But, of course, we must not stand aside from the main trend; we must not ignore what tomorrow will bring; on the contrary, we must engage in modern, alternative forms of energy, including hydrogen energy. We are doing this.

In recent years, we have introduced 800 megawatts of capacity from renewable energy sources; we are working on this. By 2024, we plan to introduce over 4 gigawatts of capacity from alternative sources. Just now, with our Finnish partners, with the company Fortum, we have launched a very good wind farm, and we are also working on solar energy. Overall, we believe that this is an absolutely correct trend, and we will certainly do everything to implement our plans regarding ecological issues.

Sergei Brilev: Thank you very much.

Allow me, before I thank the participants of the session, to thank the people of Vladivostok. First of all, this city has provided a lot of volunteers for the forum; thank you to them separately. Secondly, it has become not only a platform for the forum but also a place where, dear delegates, please spend more of your money so that the city receives more taxes. And, most importantly, it is truly becoming, before our eyes, a new gateway to the Far East of Russia and to Russia as a whole. Therefore, a special thank you to Vladivostok and its residents.

And a special thank you to Prime Minister Abe, Prime Minister Modi, President Battulga, and President Putin for participating in this plenary session of the Eastern Economic Forum. Until we meet again.

Thank you.