ZB

Zulfikar Bhutto Pakistan

Minister of Foreign Affairs of Pakistan

Born 1928 · Died 1979 · Pakistan · Speeches 1960–1965 · Wikipedia

WCTM · Deterrence

Speeches
4
Est. Time
4 hrs
Words
28k
Nationality
Pakistan
Born
1928
Died
1979
Biography
Zulfikar Ali Bhutto (1928–1979) was a Pakistani statesman who, as foreign minister from 1963 to 1966, led Pakistan's delegation to the United Nations and delivered forceful addresses on Kashmir. Born in Larkana, Sindh, and educated at Berkeley and Oxford, he founded the Pakistan Peoples Party in 1967 and went on to serve as president (1971–1973) and prime minister (1973–1977). Overthrown by a military coup, he was convicted of conspiracy to murder and hanged in Rawalpindi on 4 April 1979. Wikipedia ↗
Public voice archetype
WCTM

Deterrence

Threats and rivals abroad, met with order and cool argument.

  • N Nation 47% 53% World W
  • U Unity 30% 70% Conflict C
  • F Freedom 49% 52% Tradition T
  • H Heart 48% 53% Mind M

Tentative. From 4 tagged speeches, each read against comparable speeches: 50% is a typical speech of its kind. With so few speeches, a letter near 50% could change. How it is measured

Profile on the twelve indices

Other

The average of Zulfikar Bhutto’s 4 tagged speeches: the share of sentences carrying each option, each speech counting equally, leaving out the sentences that carry none of them (turn on Other to see them). Beneath it, the same for the other leaders of Pakistan (domestic peers, 75 speeches) and for the leaders of every other nation (global peers, 52,253 speeches).

Content

What the speaker talks about: the sphere of national life, the lever of national power, and how far the speech reaches in space and time.

Arena

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to.

Zulfikar Bhutto

Domestic Peers

Global Peers

  • Geopolitical 73%72%
  • Institutional 10%10%
  • Economic 8%7%

Capability

The lever of national power a sentence discusses, in the nine domains of the GINC National Capability Framework, grouped as hard, soft and economic power.

Zulfikar Bhutto

Domestic Peers

Global Peers

  • National Security 54%12%
  • Governance & Integrity 25%5%
  • Trade & Investment 15%3%

Scope

How far a sentence reaches beyond the speaker's borders.

Zulfikar Bhutto

Domestic Peers

Global Peers

  • Regional/global 62%56%
  • Bilateral 26%24%
  • Multilateral 9%8%

Horizon

Where in time a sentence points, on one ordered seven-step scale with the present at zero.

Zulfikar Bhutto

Domestic Peers

Global Peers

  • Present 44%33%
  • Near future 20%15%
  • Recent past 20%15%

Actors

Who is in the story and how they are cast: whose actions a sentence is about, the part they play, where the speaker stands, and the people against the elite.

Actor

Whose actions a sentence is about.

Zulfikar Bhutto

Domestic Peers

Global Peers

  • Nation 50%18%
  • Adversary 45%16%
  • Ally 5%2%

Role

The part a sentence gives its main character, as if the speech were a story.

Zulfikar Bhutto

Domestic Peers

Global Peers

  • Villain 39%10%
  • Victim 37%9%
  • Hero 24%6%

Stance

Where the speaker stands towards the audience.

Zulfikar Bhutto

Domestic Peers

Global Peers

  • Dominant 59%16%
  • Coordinate 22%6%
  • Deferential 20%5%

Populism

Whether a sentence pits a virtuous people against a corrupt elite, as the ideational school defines populism.

Zulfikar Bhutto

Domestic Peers

Global Peers

  • People-centrism 50%0%
  • Good-vs-evil 50%0%

Style

How it is said: the act a sentence performs, how sure it sounds, the feeling it appeals to and the moral value it rests on.

Expression

The speech act a sentence performs, after Searle's taxonomy.

Zulfikar Bhutto

Domestic Peers

Global Peers

  • Assertion 83%83%
  • Call to action 10%10%
  • Expressive 5%5%

Conviction

How sure the speaker sounds: the force of the claim, not its content or truth.

Zulfikar Bhutto

Domestic Peers

Global Peers

  • Medium 60%58%
  • High 34%33%
  • Low 6%6%

Emotion

The feeling a sentence appeals to in the listener, not the speaker's own state.

Zulfikar Bhutto

Domestic Peers

Global Peers

  • Fear 39%19%
  • Hope 29%14%
  • Anger 20%10%

Foundation

The moral value a sentence invokes to claim right or wrong, after Moral Foundations Theory.

Zulfikar Bhutto

Domestic Peers

Global Peers

  • Fairness 37%17%
  • Authority 24%11%
  • Liberty 23%11%

Volume

Speeches, sentences and words in the corpus by year.