Statements at the meeting with the members of the Assembly of Experts.

Iran Ali Khamenei · Supreme Leader of Iran

17 March 2005 · Meeting with the members of the Assembly of Experts

Context
Khamenei addressed the Assembly of Experts in March 2005, discussing leadership oversight, disaster response, and the integrity of Islamic mourning practices.
Main themes
Assembly of Experts, religious leadership oversight, disaster management and preparedness, mourning ceremonies and religious practices, self-flagellation controversy, clerical responsibility, superstition in religious practice, revolutionary governance
Duration
~31 min
84th percentile
Words
3,736
84th percentile
Sentences
117
70th percentile
Readability
38
31st percentile
Grade
15.6
81st percentile
Syntax
3.41
90th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
39th percentile

Translated from Persian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 31%31%
  • Social 27%27%
  • Institutional 21%21%
  • Ceremonial 14%14%
  • Economic 6%6%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

117 sentences in 30 paragraphs

In the name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful

First of all, we welcome the esteemed gentlemen and thank Almighty God for granting us the opportunity to hold this important and significant assembly once again, where its members can discuss the issues of their concern. We express our gratitude for the advisory and very important remarks made by Mr. Mashkini (may his blessings be upon him) and for the report presented by Mr. Amini.

As His Excellency Ayatollah Mashkini pointed out, this session is truly an exceptional one; both because of the composition of this assembly, which includes scholars and religious leaders as well as many officials from various sectors and some high-ranking officials of the country, and also because this assembly has been chosen by the people with these characteristics; this is a very important point. The people, through their votes, have gathered you in this assembly for a very important purpose and responsibility - for which there is no alternative center in the country - and that is to determine the leadership of the system and to oversee the correctness of the leadership's path over time. With this idea and motivation, the people have chosen this assembly, which they trust; therefore, this assembly is exceptional both in terms of being elected by the people and in terms of possessing many of the aforementioned high and noble characteristics.

Regarding the two or three points that Mr. Amini mentioned in his remarks - which I also noted in the final statement of the session, where these points are briefly mentioned - I would like to make a brief remark.

Regarding the issue of preventing disasters, there is criticism directed at those responsible for this matter. Of course, one cannot blame anyone for earthquakes, snow, and floods; however, it is reasonable to expect officials to manage affairs in such a way that the damage from these disasters is minimized and that the recovery and remedy work in response to these disasters becomes easier. Some thoughts have been put forward, recommendations have been made, and gatherings have been held for this purpose; but the speed of action must be greater than this. Of course, work has begun in the area of dilapidated and vulnerable structures; these structures did not come into existence in ten or fifteen years; unfortunately, they reflect the quality of our local and traditional construction. Fortunately, access routes are now better and easier than before; there are airports and land routes - which is also a blessing of the revolution and the efforts of officials - yet we have had and still have this criticism, and we will continue to remind and emphasize it.

The issue of mourning ceremonies, which was mentioned, is very important and largely pertains to ourselves. There is no doubt that in some cases, untrue, incorrect, and superstitious statements are made during mourning ceremonies; however, even if we assume that no incorrect statements are made in that sense, when a correct but weak statement is made without reference to a valid source, or when a statement is made that undermines people's faith and does not resonate with the audience's beliefs, this is also harmful. Today, we have so many issues in the country. A very important platform for propaganda is these mourning sessions, the Hussainiyahs, and the mourning processions. From this platform, the highest teachings and the most urgent and necessary matters can be expressed; but if we divert this to imaginary or baseless things, it is by no means beneficial.

The statement is correct; it is not a new statement; it is our constant message; however, there is a point here that must be noted. We have heard and seen in some cases that individuals have pointed out this flaw, or rather this danger, and have expressed it. Naturally, some minds may not be able to grasp this meaning; they have become accustomed to this practice in action; this is not very important; it is subject to influence; but suddenly, from a point within the clergy and from reputable centers of the clergy, a supportive voice for that erroneous practice has been raised; this must be addressed; otherwise, expressing, justifying, and reprimanding is not difficult.

It should not be the case that when a true matter is stated in a center and a responsible and enlightened cleric expresses it, suddenly, with the delusion or temptation that the essence of the mourning for Imam Hussein has been questioned, a movement arises; as we saw in the case of self-flagellation. In our view, self-flagellation was and is a clear violation of religious law; we have announced this, and many great figures have supported it; but then we saw that from various corners, some were acting contrary to this! Even if self-flagellation is not problematic and not forbidden, it is not obligatory; why is there motivation for these sometimes superstitious practices in certain places? Even those that do not have a purely superstitious aspect at least have this much that in today's world, in today's communications, in the prevailing global culture, and in the rationalities that are currently prevalent in our homes and among our youth, it will provoke an inappropriate reaction. These are not clear religious matters that we can say we must express them regardless of whether the world accepts them or not; at least these are questionable matters. Please think about this issue and take action. This cannot be achieved merely by the reference you made in the session's statement.

I also mentioned in the previous session that you should issue a resolution regarding such matters. The Assembly of Experts is a reputable and significant assembly; so many personalities have gathered in this assembly; regarding an issue that you consider important, issue a resolution so that it can be disseminated; at least the people of Iran should know that your opinion regarding a certain issue is this; even if some act or do not act. We mentioned this point in the previous session, and the gentlemen welcomed it; but it was not acted upon in this session either!

Of course, the issue of Chaharshanbe Suri is another matter and requires a different approach; however, regarding these two clear and obvious issues - one being natural disasters and the necessity for officials to address and provide aid and prevention so that human casualties and financial losses are minimized, and the other being the issue of mourning ceremonies - you can issue a resolution and request this from the leadership - there is no harm in that - request it from the officials. The issue of mourning ceremonies is entirely relevant to you; sign under this matter and show that you have an opinion and concern regarding this issue and that you want this work to be done.

I would like to say a few words regarding current issues. Of course, as I have been informed, the gentlemen have also addressed current issues in their pre-agenda speeches. Today, the fundamental issue of the country is the challenge of the Islamic Revolution and the Islamic system with enemies whose manner of dealing reveals their panic. Let me state that the current political and propaganda approach of the United States and the West towards the Islamic Republic of Iran - which is characterized by a harsh and aggressive tone - is not a sign of the enemy's power; it is a sign of the enemy's inability to confront the pure tree that has taken root, risen, and branched out. The fundamental reason for this is that in the materialistic world and in the atheistic and materialistic international system, when a unit based on divine principles and monotheism emerges, they will be incompatible with it; this is a natural and inevitable phenomenon; it is like marking an area with a specific engineering and taste, but someone who, for example, is riding a tractor and does not accept this marking, is moving in a way that he deems correct, disrupting their markings and calculations.

The conflict is over Islam; it is not over individuals or the type of government and democracy; otherwise, today the West knows that in this region, one of the most popular systems is the Islamic Republic; this is undeniable. The Islamic Republic, which from top to bottom, all its actions are based and documented by the people's votes, its first-rate influential figures are elected by the people, and the presence, support, and affections of the people are its fundamental backing, is unparalleled in terms of some aspects of being popular, not only in the region but in the world. Even most of the democracies in the world do not have such popular support and multitude of hearts behind them, but we, thank God, do; the enemy sees this as well. Therefore, the issue is that when Islamic thought and the Islamic foundation reach the stage of action and intend to establish a governing system, this will be incompatible with the markings and calculations of the prevailing material order of the world; this is a natural and inevitable phenomenon. No matter how much we correct the political appearances and propose de-escalation and the like, it does not eliminate their fundamental problem.

They also know that this new Islamic order will not be limited to one country; because the Islamic community is a large community. There are now approximately one and a half billion Muslims and dozens of Islamic countries; all of these share principles and foundations with the Islamic Republic. The desires and affections of the nations favor the Islamic Republic - they know this - and they know that if this system can free itself from the burden of problems and raise its voice to the world, then this model will have effects in other parts of the world that are very important to them, contrary to their wishes.

In fact, their anger is directed at Islam, the Islamic order, and the Islamic movement. You can observe; in the last ten to fifteen years, we have witnessed that programs have been implemented in the country by governments; these were good programs. The issues demanded and emphasized by the governments are things that are also raised in global norms for the advancement of a country; such as knowledge, technology, development, five-year plans, foreign investment, and de-escalation; these are the things we have articulated over the years, and everyone has said them; they are not specific to a part of the system; from the leadership to the governments and officials, they have repeatedly expressed these; this indicates that the Islamic Republic is moving towards development within the framework of these headings. These advancements are naturally somewhat hopeful for the designers, policymakers, and strategists of international and global colonial policies. They think that the Islamic Republic will eventually enter the same line of conventional development that they have proposed and designed. For example, when the issue of global trade and entry into global markets is raised, this hope arises in them that perhaps the Islamic system will gradually be absorbed into the materialistic international system; if such an event occurs, all of its calculations will be in their hands. Suppose a country joins the World Trade Organization; the dominant and strong hand in the World Trade Organization belongs to them; policymaking belongs to them, and the greater benefit belongs to them; now, even if some profit comes to a certain country or government; but they are the ones who calculate. The same goes for various global policies; it seems that gradually this hope has arisen in them.

Of course, some internal statements also reinforced this hope for them; whether in cultural fields, political fields, or economic fields. The fact that the Islamic system appeared as a protester, and as the gentlemen themselves say, as an opposition to the global system, in a sensitive point in the world, actually diminished this. Suddenly, the twenty-year outlook document is presented as the policies of the system and the demands and policies of the leadership; then at the forefront of this outlook, it states that "Iran is a developed country," until it reaches this point: "with an Islamic, revolutionary, and inspiring identity in the Islamic world." It becomes clear that the disturbed dream that had created hope in their hearts is a meaningless dream. This means that all the five-year plans that will start from the year 1384 (2005) and will be based on the twenty-year outlook must be in this line and direction; all must genuinely pursue revolutionary Islam and Islamic Iran and be inspiring in the Islamic world.

We do not wish to be isolated in the Islamic world, and we are not isolated and will not be. Isolation, in its diplomatic and common sense in the world, is not as harmful as isolation from nations. Today, the United States, on the surface, is not isolated; its political and even military presence is felt everywhere in this region; but in reality, it is isolated; why? Because the nations, who are the decision-makers, are all disgusted and repulsed by the presence of the United States and its policies; this isolation is harmful. The Islamic Republic does not have this isolation in the Islamic world.

You can go anywhere in the Islamic world, and you will see that people's hearts beat for the Islamic Republic; this is a reality. The recent trip of our esteemed President to Bosnia is an example. How much popular connection do we have with Bosnia? How many people from Bosnia have come here? After the Dayton Agreement and the end of the Balkan wars, there was so much propaganda and activity against Iran there; the agents of the Islamic Republic were expelled from there, insulted, and accused in their propaganda, and everything was said about them; yet, the people of Bosnia welcomed our President in such a manner. He said that in the heavy snow of Sarajevo - where perhaps the snow had fallen up to near a person's knee - people had gathered densely in the streets to see the President of the Islamic Republic of Iran. He said that we went to the Ghazi Husrev-beg Library - where I had also visited during my presidency - our visit lasted about 45 minutes; but when we returned, we saw that people were still standing there. In the mosque there, people had gathered densely and were singing songs in Persian to welcome the President of the Islamic Republic of Iran! This reception is not related to individuals.

I had returned from Algeria and described the scene I had seen in that country to the Imam, saying that this reception was not related to me personally; it was a tribute to you. Now, neither I, nor Mr. Khatami, nor any of the officials of the country who go to other countries and are received in this manner are the focus; people do not know our individuals; they may know our names, but they know the revolution and the Imam; the same personality that shone like the sun in the sky of the Islamic world and everyone - whether enemies wanted it or not - felt it. Now they see a manifestation and a document of that distinguished personality. Wherever you go, the situation is the same.

One of our officials - I do not remember if it was the President or someone else - went to one of the Arab countries and received a good welcome. I said that wherever you go in the Arab countries, the situation is the same; if you go to Egypt, the gathering of people will be the largest; if you go to Sudan, it will be the same; if you go to other countries, it will be the same; of course, provided that the governments do not obstruct.

Today, throughout the Islamic world, the Islamic Republic is prominent; the reason is that it stands firm on its main word and slogan - which is Islam. When the Americans see the outlook document published and realize that the twenty-year outlook is about the emergence of a first-class developed country in the region in terms of technology and knowledge, with an Islamic and revolutionary orientation and essence, impactful and inspiring in the Islamic world, they seek to counter it. Of course, they cannot confront Islam.

I saw that the gentlemen of the Assembly of Experts had made correct and good remarks regarding the Greater Middle East in their pre-agenda speeches. The issue of the Greater Middle East is an American wish. The Greater Middle East they speak of means a large country in the Middle East centered around Israel. Of course, their intention is not to form a single government; no, they want the same governments that exist within the current geographical borders to remain; however, they want governments that are in the grip of the Americans; that the people appear to have elected them, but the Americans wanted them; just as happened in recent months in Ukraine and Georgia.

They want Israel to become a prominent center in this resource-rich and natural wealth-filled region; to allow the representative and base of Western material civilization to extend its reach in these countries; to use their cheap labor, to utilize their money, to expand their economy, to develop their agriculture, and in fact, to nourish themselves; like a tree whose roots enter the neighbor's house and feeds from there, while the fruit of the tree belongs to the owner of that house.

The plan from the Nile to the Euphrates, which at one time they announced they wanted to achieve through the might of military power, is now, in fact, being sought through the might of political and economic power. Of course, they will certainly not reach this goal; neither the Americans nor the Zionists and the usurpers of Palestine.

The nations are awake. We must be vigilant. The Islamic Republic must be awake. Our awakening is not just a slogan; we must be attentive. In determining governments, in electing the President - with only a short time remaining until the elections - and in selecting those who are to operate in the political arena of the country, we must be attentive. Each of the individuals and personalities and officials who are at the head of a working group are decisive; their faith, their determination and will, and their competence and capability are all determining factors. Suppose you have a criticism regarding a certain cultural issue, or if you have a criticism regarding a certain technical issue in the country, all of these return to various managements; not just the management at the top; no, sometimes the upper management is good, but the middle and intermediate managements - which require oversight and supervision from senior officials - sometimes do not allow the work to reach the desired outcome. Therefore, these selections are decisive. In these areas, we must enter with a sense of responsibility and consideration of the aspects, with open eyes and complete insight.

At the head of the work, there must be those whose faith in Islam and the Revolution and Islamic and revolutionary values is sufficient; they should not have doubts about the values of Islam, and their ability, enthusiasm, and capacity for movement and pursuit should be commensurate with all the work that the Islamic Republic has, so that, God willing, the country can progress.

These tasks are multi-generational. The goals and results we seek, we do not expect to be realized necessarily in a short time; however, we do expect that a movement will be created and a sense of progress will be felt. A person travels a path in one hour, and travels another path in twenty-four hours; but even the path that must be traveled in twenty-four hours, a person must feel in the first hour that they have progressed by the equivalent of one hour. We expect to feel movement and progress in all areas; in economic areas, in cultural areas, in value areas, in scientific areas, in the advancement of science and scientific depth, and in breaking the scientific barriers that prevent countries like ours from accessing the main scientific points and breaking the boundaries of knowledge and advancing; fortunately, in this recent area, our country is among the exceptional countries in terms of being good. Talents are good; capabilities are good; the power of scientific and technical innovation is good; we can make progress in these areas, and we have made progress, one example being the issue of nuclear energy.

We must ask the Almighty God to grant us success. Appreciate this esteemed assembly and the value of this very important gathering, and - as His Excellency Mr. Mashkini pointed out - make bold decisions commensurate with the duty and expectations from this assembly. You are a collective; in every area, whatever you think is necessary, make bold decisions and announce them. I have said it before, and I emphasize again; announce that our opinion is this. Issuing such statements is very good and necessary. Your previous statements have generally been good; this year, a solid, well-worded, and eloquent statement was issued; however, issuing a final statement of the conference is different from making a specific demand on a particular issue from you so that the people know that the Assembly of Experts wants this. Do not hesitate or have reservations about anyone you think is necessary to ask - from the President, from the leadership, from the Parliament, from the judiciary - present your opinions decisively and clearly.

The secretariat can also prepare issues for the next conference over time with the consultation of the gentlemen so that they can be addressed in that conference. A well-organized and effective secretariat can have a significant impact.

This assembly is based on the votes of the people; it is not a small assembly. Of course, the Almighty God must assist, guide, and help all of us, and make our gratitude for His blessings a ground for His mercy and additional blessings. We all need the pure prayers of His Holiness the Mahdi (may our souls be sacrificed for him). We hope, God willing, to be included in the prayers and compassionate attention of that great figure, and God willing, our work and progress will improve day by day.

And peace be upon you and the mercy of God and His blessings.