Prime Minister Anders Fogh Rasmussen's speech at DI's annual day on September 26, 2006.

Denmark Anders Fogh Rasmussen · Prime Minister of Denmark

26 September 2006 · DI Industry's Annual Day

Context
Rasmussen addressed the Danish Industry (DI) Annual Day on September 26, 2006, outlining Denmark's competitiveness agenda and major economic reforms.
Main themes
Danish competitiveness, structural reforms, welfare state reform, globalization strategy, tax freeze policy, fiscal policy, public sector reform, business environment, employment incentives, economic growth
Duration
~51 min
94th percentile
Words
6,118
94th percentile
Sentences
346
96th percentile
Readability
59
85th percentile
Grade
9.4
14th percentile
Syntax
2.84
27th percentile
Vocabulary
1.90
3rd percentile

Translated from Danish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 60%58%
  • Social 17%16%
  • Institutional 14%14%
  • Environmental 4%4%
  • Ceremonial 4%3%
  • Geopolitical 2%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

346 sentences in 62 paragraphs

Thank you for the welcome and thank you for the invitation to once again be here at the Industry's Annual Day. And I am pleased to say right from the start that I completely share the title or motto of this Industry's Annual Day, "Mission Possible."

For it is a great mission we have embarked upon, but it is absolutely possible. We have set the ambitious goal that Denmark should be the most competitive nation in the world. Yes, it is ambitious, but it is not unrealistic. A number of international analyses already place Denmark among the 5-6 most competitive nations in the world. And we therefore have a good starting point. We have now set clear goals. We have presented a clear strategy. We are in the process of making a number of decisions. Now it is about putting it into action.

We have established a foundation that we believe is good and strong. We have created solid frameworks for Danish business. First of all, we have implemented extensive reforms in Danish society. A structural reform, which has municipal reform as its core, but which also includes a police and judicial reform, a reform of the tax administration's way of working, and other reforms of the public sector, which together constitute the largest reform of the public sector ever carried out.

Next, we have implemented a welfare reform, which means that we are gradually increasing the retirement age in Denmark. We are doing it with such notice that people can adjust to it. And there will be some who think it should have been faster, it should have been more far-reaching. But the bottom line is that it is the largest and most far-reaching reform of the welfare state that has been implemented since we have had a welfare state in Denmark.

And finally, among the major reforms, I would also like to mention the globalization reform, which has been presented as a comprehensive strategy with no less than 350 different proposals, which we are now fully engaged in implementing. And to finance this, there is now, following an agreement in the Folketing, a globalization fund of money, which starts with 2 billion and will be built up to 10 billion over the coming years until 2012.

This is the most comprehensive investment in Denmark's future that has ever been made. So we have created good frameworks. And then we have also created good frameworks for taxation with a stable and credible tax policy, which has as its core a tax freeze that was declared on the same day this government took office. A tax freeze that has been adhered to to the letter ever since. The tax freeze means that in each individual business as well as in each household, one can manage confidently without fear that new tax and duty increases are just around the corner.

I can well remember the 90s, when it was the case that every time a new budget proposal came, new tax and duty burdens awaited businesses in the range of 1.5 billion to 2 billion kroner each time. That time is over. Now businesses know what they have to work with. And it is of course clear that this contributes independently to increasing the willingness to invest. And in ordinary private households, it also increases the desire to manage.

So the tax freeze constitutes a stable and credible framework for both businesses and households. But we have done more than we promised. For we only promised a tax freeze. We have done more. We have implemented a tax reduction of around 10 billion kroner, which means that around 750,000 taxpayers have had their marginal tax rate reduced by 6 percent. And everyone in employment has received a special employment deduction, which means that it is now more worthwhile to take a job rather than be on transfer income.

This has again meant that ordinary wage earners have been able to experience an increase in their real wages, while wage increases have been kept at a moderate level. And this has again meant that Denmark has been able to maintain good competitiveness. And finally, we have established an overall economic framework for businesses that is solid and sustainable through a solid and sustainable fiscal policy. We have kept the increase in public consumption during the time we have been in government to just over 1 percent per year. This means that public consumption from 2001 to 2005 has grown by 22 billion kroner. That is just over 1 percent per year on average. But that is only half the rate of increase compared to what we experienced in the 90s. And what that means in practice is that the public sector's share of labor and purchases of goods and services, etc., has remained a relatively unchanged share of the country's total production, the gross domestic product. And this means that the private sector has been able to maintain its share, and not, as we have seen before, that the private sector has had to settle for a smaller and smaller share.

It is such that around 30 percent of total employment in Denmark is public employment. And now I have heard that there are some who believe that the solution to a number of problems is to allocate more money and hire more in the public sector. I would like to say that if one goes that way, then one has not understood how the economy works at all.

Because if we, in a labor market where there is already a shortage of labor, began to hire even more in the public sector, it would mean that there would be fewer resources in the private sector to create the production, and thus the values, that must finance the public sector and the public services that we all want and that must be at a high level. And therefore, it is not a solution to demand more money or more employees, because it would simply undermine the basis for financing the entire welfare system.

Demanding more money and more employees is not a visionary proposal for the future of the Danish welfare state. It is primitive and devoid of ideas.

Look, things are going well in Denmark, as Henning Dyremose also pointed out. Employment is at a record high, unemployment is the lowest it has been in 30 years. We have surpluses all around. The foreign debt is gone, and we are starting to build wealth abroad. We are repaying public debt faster than we had anticipated. But I would like to remind you that we still have a significant public debt. In fact, the public debt is just under 500 billion kroner. I mention this because I can hear in the public debate that some believe that when there are these considerable surpluses, they can simply be converted into larger allocations and more employees in the public sector. But that is not how it works. A large part of the surpluses we have is due to the fact that things are going well right now, and we have extra income. But everyone knows that you cannot finance permanent expenses with temporary income.

And we still have a debt that we need to pay down, which was built up in the past. And therefore, there are not all the many funds that some apparently have misunderstood. We need to have good, we need to have really good public services in Denmark. I will return to that. But I just have to say that we need to keep the annual growth in public consumption within a narrow framework to ensure that there are sufficient resources in our economy for the private sector to generate the funds needed to finance all that welfare service.

But we can rejoice that things are going well. That exports actually account for 50 percent of societal production. And it is growing, despite the fact that we have a booming domestic market. This has previously been a major problem. That when things were really good in the domestic market, it affected exports. But fortunately, we are now experiencing this as a different situation. There is still activity in exports, even though there is also activity in the domestic market. And that is truly uplifting. And for the second year in a row, an international think tank has declared Denmark to be the society in the world with the best business climate.

So yes, things are going well. But that must not lead us to rest on our laurels. It would be the most dangerous thing if we believe that because things are going well now, we do not need to do anything. We need to take action, and we need to take quite a bit of action because globalization constantly exposes us to new challenges. Therefore, we must set new goals. And I will now present 5 of the new goals that we need to set, and where there must not only be talk of political intentions, but very much about political action in the very near years.

The first, which is also very urgent, is to ensure that there is more labor available in Danish society. I completely share the view of Dansk Industri that this is here and now the most important task we have: It is to secure enough hands to ensure the production that is needed in Danish society. And we must do this both by bringing more labor from within the country and by bringing more labor from abroad. From within the country, we must ensure that the too many immigrants who are unemployed get jobs. The good story is that since 2001, there has actually been an increase in employment of 20,000 immigrants from non-Western countries. But the bad story is that it is under half of the immigrants from non-Western countries who are employed. And it is clear that there lies a great resource just outside the door. Humanely, it would be good for them to get jobs, and economically, it would be healthy for Danish society if they got jobs.

The goal we have set as the medium-term goal is that by 2010, 6 out of 10 immigrants from non-Western countries will be employed. And that will create 25,000 more jobs on that account. And the instruments to achieve this are that it must pay to work. We have initiated various initiatives. It is to require that one can speak Danish properly, because that is a prerequisite for being able to get a job and keep it. It is reforms of education, including vocational education, so that there are more practical pathways to vocational education for young people who may prefer to work with their hands rather than with books.

It is a new four-party agreement with the parties in the labor market to get more immigrants into workplaces. This is what we call a hands-on integration effort, where we directly go out and engage with the unemployed. We lead the individual into the company, where a mentor takes over the task of getting the individual trained in the company.

And may I also appeal to the great responsibility in each individual Danish company to ensure that more immigrants get jobs. When there is now a sigh over the lack of labor, it is very obvious that companies should take the labor that is just outside the door: Namely, the many immigrants who today are unemployed.

We must of course also ensure that those who receive transfers from the public due to unemployment are actually available for the labor market. There must be effective job placement by municipalities, unemployment funds, and job centers. And there must of course be an obligation for the individual to accept the job that is offered. We had the case that it was difficult to find enough newspaper delivery people. And I heard one who apparently had an academic education and had been unemployed for many years say that she did not believe that with the education she had, she was obliged to take a job as a newspaper delivery person. But I must say that a job is a job. And there is nothing in Danish society that is called "meaningless" work. And we must have social benefits and unemployment benefits at a decent level in Danish society. But it must also be a contract, a welfare contract, where in return one is obliged to take a job when a job is offered.

Some of you will of course say that if we are to get more working hours out of this at home, we must also lower the tax on labor income. I would be disappointed if Dansk Industri did not say something about that today. And you have done so.

In that regard, I can only refer to the government program, which has two points. The first point states: It is the government's goal to continue to lower the tax on labor income. The second point states: This will happen when there is room for it. And there is not right now. And we will have to see when there will be. But no one should be in doubt about what the government's intention is, for I also believe that it is easier to get people to accept, for example, to work overtime rather than take time off if the overtime pay is not taxed as heavily as it is at the moment.

I do not think there can be any doubt about that. But I also believe that everyone here will agree with me that one should not gamble with the Danish economy. And therefore, there must of course be a solid economic room before one continues down the path that we have already initiated in the last election period with a reduction in the tax on labor income. But no one should be in doubt about what the political goal is. It is a matter of timing and economics.

As far as the domestic situation is concerned. But we also need more labor from abroad. And there are especially four initiatives that we are in the process of implementing: The Eastern Agreement has been liberalized. And in fact, it is the case that there is free access to the Danish labor market for workers from the new EU member states, provided that they come and work under normal Danish collective agreement conditions. Then there is free access. And in fact, since the scheme came into effect, 12,000 have received work and residence permits. And now we are liberalizing it further, and one day it will completely disappear.

The next point is that the Minister of Employment has introduced a new 13-point plan aimed at making it easier to attract and hire foreign employees. I know this has been thoroughly discussed today. And it underscores that the government shares the desire for it to be easier to bring labor to Denmark from abroad.

Thirdly, we have decided to expand the existing job card scheme. It was us who introduced the job card scheme in 2002, allowing people we particularly need in Danish society to come here and work. In fact, the number of people who have come to Denmark under the job card scheme has tripled since we introduced it in 2002. So it is a great success.

And finally, fourthly, we will introduce a special green card scheme, which means that we will grant residence permits to particularly qualified foreigners through a special points system with the aim of seeking work in Denmark. This is a scheme inspired by other countries, for example Canada, where I have been informed that 150,000 people annually obtain work based on such a green card scheme. If we translate that to Danish conditions, it would correspond to about 25,000.

So we are taking and have taken a number of initiatives to make it easier to attract the necessary qualified labor from abroad. And I would like to say that there is so much talk about Denmark becoming a closed society due to the government's strict immigration policy, etc. I find it very thought-provoking that at the same time as we have indeed reduced the number of people coming here as a result of asylum and family reunification, reducing it to less than a third of the level in 2001, we have actually doubled the number of residence permits for people coming to work and study.

So what I want to say with this is that Danish society is open to people who want to work in Denmark, study in Denmark, and generally contribute constructively to Danish society. We need them, we welcome them. So that is the first necessary increase in labor here in the country.

The next point is to create world-class education. It is not enough that we need more labor; we also need to be better educated. We need this, among other things, so that we can better handle the new jobs that will replace the old ones that are being phased out. For that will be the future society; old jobs will be phased out, new jobs will be created, and we need to be better educated to handle the new jobs. And we will work broadly to improve education. We will address the Folkeskole with a higher academic level, and not only a higher academic level, but also ensure that children and young people have creative abilities, as we will also need that greatly in the future society. We will ensure constant academic progress through tests that will serve as a pedagogical tool for teachers. We are implementing a reform of teacher education aimed at a higher academic level, and we are also implementing a management reform in the Folkeskole to ensure visible leadership.

Next, we will focus on youth education, including vocational education. The goal is that all young people should have a youth education in Denmark. At the same time, we want to ensure a high status for vocational education. Among other things, we believe that vocational education should also serve as a springboard to further education and not a dead end. We want, as I have already said, more pathways to vocational education, so there are also pathways for those who are more practically oriented. And we need to secure a sufficient number of internships. Fortunately, this has improved recently. In fact, there have been 5,000 more real internships in companies, and I would like to thank the business community that has helped to provide these internships. But let me remind you that this obligation also applies in times when the economy may not be doing so well. It is not acceptable that the access to internships is so dependent on the economic cycle that no one is taken in during certain periods, and then there is a shortage in other periods. The business community has an obligation here to ensure a reasonably stable number of internships for young people.

Higher education must be improved. We have set the goal that over half of a youth cohort should have a higher education. We are now creating stronger university environments through larger, more powerful units, including building elite environments at universities. We want funding for universities to be allocated more based on documented results. And I would also like to call on the business community to take more graduates from universities. This is a relatively new thing in Denmark. It is going a bit better than it has, but it is not good enough. And I actually believe that the business community has an interest in taking in more people with a bachelor's degree as their background.

We need to do something about adult and continuing education. We must prepare for a society with lifelong learning because we cannot assume that because we receive an education and a job in our youth, we can maintain that until retirement age; on the contrary, the norm will be that we will need to change career paths at some point. Therefore, there should be adult and continuing education opportunities available, I might say, at any time. And I would say that the next collective bargaining negotiations in the private labor market will be a test of this. It will be a test of the willingness from both the employee side and the employer side regarding whether they really want to do something about adult and continuing education. The employee must show the willingness to demand it, and the employer must show the willingness to pay for it. And this is a usual negotiation that we will not interfere with in any way.

I will say that I prefer the Danish model, but I also want to send the signal that something needs to be done in this area. Because adult and continuing education is about ensuring that Danish society becomes flexible enough in the coming years so that everyone is ready for change. Ultimately, good adult and continuing education is also an advantage for the company's competitiveness. And it is the means to include everyone; we must also include those who today have the shortest educations.

This brings me to the third point in the strategy. We must make Denmark a leading knowledge society. The goal is for Denmark to be a society that brims with ideas. And we must be quicker to translate ideas into new production and thus new jobs. We have set the goal that by 2010, we in Danish society, both private and public sectors combined, should spend at least 3% of the country's production (gross domestic product) on research and development, of which one percent will be public research. Funds have now been allocated for this, and we will achieve that goal.

I want to say that it is not enough just to pour more money into the endeavor. We must ensure quality, we must ensure focus and prioritization. And therefore, we must invest more in natural sciences and engineering in the coming years. In Finland and Sweden, for example, they train 2 to 3 times as many PhDs in natural sciences and engineering as we do in Denmark. So not only do they spend more money, but they also prioritize more strongly. We need more competition for research funds to ensure high quality. The goal is that by 2010, half of the public research funds should be allocated in free competition based on quality. We can learn a lot from Finland and Sweden in this regard. And we need to have stronger and better collaboration between the private and public sectors when it comes to research and development.

The fourth point is that we must make Denmark the most innovative society in the world. This applies to both the private and public sectors. The private sector is already aware of the need for innovation. We must strengthen this by enhancing the entrepreneurial culture, starting already in education—entrepreneurship should be an integrated part of our education from Folkeskole to higher education. I believe we should also develop education in innovative management. We must promote growth entrepreneurs. Because it is not enough just to start new companies. We are actually quite good at that in Denmark. What we are not so good at is getting them to grow. We can learn a lot from, for example, the USA. We need to reduce the barriers that currently exist for companies to grow. We need to create new forms of financing that can help stimulate the growth of newly established companies.

But may I turn to the public sector, which must also be an innovative sector in Danish society in the coming years. The public sector actually makes a significant contribution to the competitiveness of Danish society. And we need to strengthen that in the coming years. When we have a flexible Danish labor market, it is because we have a good social security system for those who become unemployed, which means that we have virtually no restrictions placed on employers when it comes to hiring and firing employees. Unlike other countries. It is the very famous flexicurity model that gives Denmark unique flexibility in the labor market and therefore a powerful contribution to our competitiveness. A model that is envied in other countries. But it is largely the public sector that helps ensure that flexibility.

Childcare, well, how could one get a labor market to function with high labor participation from both parents if we had not organized childcare collectively? Infrastructure, of course, has something to do with competitiveness, whether one can get around on the roads and not be stuck in traffic, and that trains run on time, etc. And there is work to be done here, but these are examples of how public efforts can contribute to competitiveness and that what the public sector does matters.

The same goes for education. It is clear that a well-educated population is more competitive than a less educated population; here, too, public investments can play a significant role. And I have already talked about research and development as a means to improve competitiveness. So the public sector makes a powerful contribution to competitiveness in a society.

The long-term challenge we face, however, is that there will simply be problems recruiting a sufficient number of employees for the public sector. Just as there will be for the private sector. The public and private sectors share this fate. I can say that over the next 10 years, 200,000 public employees will retire. That is 1/4 of those employed in the public sector. So forget all that talk about politicians wanting to cut the number of employees. That is not at all the problem. The problem in the coming years will be to recruit a sufficient number to solve the tasks. And I can illustrate this with a number. Here in 2006, the number of 25-year-olds is 63,000, while the number of 60-year-olds is 78,000. This tells us that the cohorts coming in now are so small that there will be competition for labor between the private and public sectors. And that is also why those who believe that the solution to the challenges in the public sector is simply more money and more employees do not understand the challenge we face in the coming years.

And that is why we need a quality reform, where we get more for our money, so to speak. We need to be better at measuring and documenting what the public sector does. Today, we are very good at measuring how much money we spend, but not very good at measuring what results come out. We need to be better at measuring results, we need to be better at measuring quality. We need to be better at measuring satisfaction.

And this leads to my belief that a salary reform should be implemented in the public sector. I honestly believe that if public employees at an institution make a constructive and positive contribution to new organization, better quality, cost reduction, or whatever the result may be, they should also see that reflected in their paychecks. There is far too much rigidity in the public sector regarding this. Far too much equality that makes people afraid of performance-based pay. We need to be much more open about this, and we need to reward public employees who contribute in this area. And I also honestly believe that the salaries of leaders in the public sector should to some extent reflect results. They do not need stock options, but one could say that a portion, the upper portion of their salary, should depend on, for example, user satisfaction, employee satisfaction, and costs. If there is good satisfaction in relation to costs, then that should be reflected in their paychecks, and if there is poor satisfaction, then that should also be reflected. I believe there are incentives in that.

And we should also be better at helping each other with best practices. Why not say that the 20% who perform best according to these goals help the 20% who perform worst? We need to have choice, so that users can choose something else if they are not satisfied with what they receive.

And a quality reform also means ensuring that there is enough money for investment. Investments in better quality. For example, it has been shown that if you invest in so-called handheld computers in home care, there is more time for care and attention for the individual, because you reduce the administrative burden. There needs to be funding for that.

In the same way, there needs to be money to maintain public facilities and buildings instead of letting them become dilapidated. But far too often we see that investments are sidelined because operations and transfers crowd out the money for investments. And we simply have to do better in the coming years.

So I would like to say here, I do not intend in any way to enter into a race about who can promise the most money to the public sector. There will be more money for public services in the coming years, but there are also tight constraints on what the economy can bear. And those who believe that it is just a matter of money do not understand what the challenge really consists of. There is simply a need for a completely new vision. There is a need for interaction between the public and private sectors. We must think of the two together – and say that what the public sector does is largely also part of the business sector's competitiveness. And therefore we need a collaboration and a partnership between the public and private sectors. See them as one, so to speak.

And finally, point 5. There is a need to tackle the new challenges we face in energy policy in an offensive manner. We are in a relatively comfortable situation in Denmark because we extract plenty of oil and natural gas from the ground. And we are actually the only EU country that is now more than self-sufficient in oil and natural gas. So far, so good. At some point, it will run out. And it is important that we do not become dependent on supplies from areas of the world that are, to say the least, politically unstable.

And therefore the goal must be that we say that at some point we must be able to manage without fossil fuels such as coal, oil, and natural gas. Yes, that is some way off in the future. But energy decisions are long-term decisions. And we have a good starting point for solving that challenge because we are one of the countries in the world that does the most when it comes to renewable energy. 15% of energy comes from renewable sources. Electricity, which comes 20% from wind. In terms of energy efficiency, we are one of the most efficient countries in the world. Over the last 25 years, the economy has grown by 50%, and energy consumption has not increased. And we are leading in the global market when it comes to selling wind technology.

So we have a good starting point. And what we need to do now is to continue to develop the use of renewable energy. It is to continue to develop energy efficiency and utilize the technology we have. It is in the transport sector to promote the use of green fuels, such as biofuels. It is to invest in research and development. And demonstration and trials in the energy sector. And finally, it is international energy cooperation. In the EU, we need to set ambitious goals. And we should also strengthen cooperation with the USA across the Atlantic on the development of new energy technologies.

Let me emphasize that now it is about ensuring that we get the most for our money. Here too, I want to say that I do not wish to enter into a competition about who can set the most ambitious goals. Because if I say 30%, someone from the opposition will just come and say 50. If I say 50, they will say 75. It is completely endless and totally meaningless.

No, what we need to do is to ensure that such an energy policy goes hand in hand with reasonable competitiveness. We must not undermine the competitiveness of Danish businesses and thereby destroy the Danish economy and stifle jobs. But what we need to do is to proactively utilize the technological lead we have in the energy sector. Of course, we cannot avoid that there is also some political regulation in the area. But it must be combined with using market mechanisms to ensure that investments in energy are made where it is most efficient. For example, as within the Kyoto agreement, where Denmark makes CO2-reducing investments in developing countries and Eastern countries and Asia, etc., because that way we get the most environmental benefit for the money.

And we need to use these market mechanisms also at the national level, so that it is not just political regulation, but that we largely use market mechanisms to ensure the greatest possible efficiency in our energy policy. I clearly distance myself from an environmental socialism that uses the green as a lever to ensnare the population in regulations and impose new taxes and levies on the population. When we talk about sustainable development, we do not just mean environmentally sustainable development, but also economically sustainable development. Energy must be a business for Denmark.

Let me conclude by saying that this strategy can only be realized if broad groups are involved. I was pleased that the Globalization Council presented such a comprehensive strategy as it did. I thank everyone who was involved in the work, all organizations, all individuals who participated.

But it is a broad responsibility to follow up. We need a partnership between the public and private sectors, and ensuring reasonable integration and employment of immigrants is also a responsibility for businesses. It is to ensure a sufficient number of internships for young people. It is also a responsibility for businesses. Ensuring a senior policy where older people stay longer in the labor market is also a responsibility for businesses. It is a partnership.

And I want to say to you that we will closely follow up to ensure that all these things are now implemented. Every year, the government will publish a competitiveness report, where we will see if the globalization strategy is being implemented and if it works.

The Globalization Council will continue to have a role in that process. I have seen in the public debate that some have expressed fears, perhaps criticism, that we have presented 350 proposals, but that there is a need for prioritization and tough management. I have seen it stated that it is good that we have now allocated a fund of 10 billion for investments in globalization purposes. But that it will probably just be reduced to a political proposal, like so many others. And finally, I have seen that we lack concrete proposals on elite universities, on growth entrepreneurs, on developing management skills in Danish society.

Well, I do not entirely agree with that fear and criticism. But I want to say to you, we are of course listening to everything that is said. And I want to emphasize three things.

First, we will maintain focus on what I have said here. Second, we will not squander the money. There must be focus and prioritization. It must be globalization-oriented. And finally, third, we will be open and listen to further proposals, if there are any. And therefore, my concrete proposal will be that we establish what I would call a collection round, where anyone who has supplementary proposals to what we have come up with can contribute. And send them to the Globalization Council, and we will process them there. Because we need as many ideas as possible and as many involved in the work as possible.

So I agree that it is Mission Possible! It is absolutely possible. We have a strong starting point. We have clear goals. We have laid out a clear strategy. And there is broad political and organizational support to implement the strategy. And there will be maintained political focus, closely on the follow-up of this.

But I want to say that I believe we will never reach a situation where we can say Mission Completed, for it will be an ongoing process, it is a continuous effort, so it will be under the motto, which is also my personal one: Never finished – always on the way!