Democracy under the test of social networks and algorithms - President Emmanuel Macron facing the readers of La Dépêche du Midi.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

12 November 2025 · La Dépêche du Midi

Context
Macron addressed readers of La Dépêche du Midi in Toulouse on November 12, 2025, to discuss threats to democracy from social media and AI.
Main themes
Democracy and social networks, algorithms and artificial intelligence, press freedom and independence, regional daily press, digital transition, GAFA and big tech, youth and democratic participation, republican values, technological innovation, disinformation
Duration
~169 min
99th percentile
Words
20,271
99th percentile
Sentences
1,091
99th percentile
Readability
59
86th percentile
Grade
9.6
16th percentile
Syntax
2.92
36th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
12th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 42%41%
  • Institutional 17%16%
  • Ceremonial 17%16%
  • Technological 13%12%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Economic 6%5%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

1,091 sentences in 204 paragraphs

Mr. President of the Republic, it is both an honor and a pleasure to welcome you here to La Dépêche du Midi, one of the last independent and family-owned titles in the French press, which is indeed run by my family, since, 150 years ago, the workers of the Sirven printing house, the prefect over there, frustrated by the somewhat biased information from the prefect displayed on the gates of the prefecture, decided to create a newspaper.

Thus was born, on October 2, 1870, La Dépêche du Midi, which was a workers' cooperative, founded naturally on the values you can imagine, since those who brought it to life, I provoke them intentionally, because at that time, we were more likely to be eating curé rather than baptismal fonts. But those who brought it to life were anarchists, and thus was born this newspaper which, very quickly, radiated throughout France, which, very quickly, managed to create an image and uphold values that are still ours today and which align with the theme of this meeting, since it is a humanist, republican, European newspaper, and it is a newspaper that continues to fight for its values, we do not hide them, even if naturally, things have evolved.

La Dépêche, I was saying, always led the fights, but this was not only the case in 1870, where ultimately our history is consubstantial with that of the Republic. This was the case in all the great moments of history. Maurice Sarraut, assassinated by the militia and the Gestapo, who was the director of the newspaper. My father, Jean Baylet, and Albert Sarraut were deported to Neuengamme, and they only returned in May 1945. So, it is a newspaper that has a beautiful history, ultimately, if I dared to exaggerate a bit, which merges with the history of France.

But it is a newspaper that, naturally, continues to evolve, like the press, and the press, Mr. President of the Republic, needs your support. We are undergoing transitions to digital, we are facing the GAFA, we are facing artificial intelligence. This debate not only allows us to welcome you here, but it also allows me to send you the message: continue to support us, it is crucial for democracy and the Republic that there is a free, independent press, and that it can, beyond our contingencies, continue to thrive, it is absolutely crucial, desirable, and indispensable.

Before giving you the floor, if I may express it that way, I want to thank all our readers who are here, who responded to our invitation. Well, we cannot say that it was not done a bit quickly. But that is how Emmanuel Macron operates, he had me called on Monday evening to say that he wanted to see us for lunch at the Élysée on Wednesday, where we do, and the following Saturday, his services called Jean-Nicolas to say:

well, the President will be here on November 12.

Here, we are in the paper stock. Everything had to be moved and this room invented, which we have the impression is a gala venue, but in reality, it is an industrial space in which we worked last night, and in which we will work tonight as well. Nevertheless, thank you all, despite the speed, for being present. Thank you to our teams, to Jean-Nicolas, who coordinated everything, to Nathalie, who assisted him, to the workers of the printing house, who moved all the rolls. These rolls weigh 1,000 kg each. They moved everything so that we could welcome you with the honors due to the high rank of the President of the Republic. Mr. President, we are truly happy to welcome you.

Good debate, and thank you for choosing Toulouse, and thank you for thinking of the press. I will not conclude, of course, without greeting our colleagues who are here and who arrived after you, as well as our colleagues from the regional daily press. Good debate, Mr. President of the Republic.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much, Mr. President, dear Jean-Michel, thank you very much for these words, for the welcome. Thank you to all the teams of the group for having organized this debate in record time and for having arranged this room. Thank you, ladies and gentlemen, for being here in your ranks and qualities, as we say, to avoid listing all the titles of each and every one.

I will perhaps tell you in a few words why I proposed that we have these debates and why, indeed, about a dozen days ago, I wanted to see the regional daily press as a whole. We are starting, in essence, a cycle of discussion here.

It is clear that something is happening, not just in our country, but in our democracies, with social networks over the past few years and now artificial intelligence on top of that. So, we are a country of technology, innovation, and science, and therefore, we are right to embrace these changes, to try to have actors of these changes, to be at the heart of these technological transitions. And we are.

But at the same time, we cannot ignore that something is not happening in the functioning of our democracies and for our youth, our young people. These are, in essence, the two subjects that I am keen to advance.

So, in recent years, we have tried to move things forward. I say in recent years because, in essence, there are a few milestones that have marked the years that have just passed. Around 2015, it was the moment when social networks expanded globally and entered our lives, and when the major networks we know were used much more massively by both young and older people. So, we have about 10 years of hindsight.

Then, we have 2020, the COVID crisis, which changed our relationship with social networks even more profoundly, because we were plunged, if I may say, into the solitude of confinement, because there was, at the same time, a desire to be informed, and because also, the time spent on screens and networks, we see it in all the statistics, from the youngest to the oldest, has profoundly transformed. There has not really been a return to the past.

During the past decade, things have changed very deeply. So much so that at the moment I am speaking to you, we have young generations who are informing themselves much more through social networks than through traditional media, even if you have had, your group, like all your partners and sometimes competitors, digital practices to go on these networks, to disseminate information, but it now goes through these networks and through AI, we will undoubtedly return to that, and the time spent on screens has skyrocketed.

For young people today, we are at about 4 hours and 40 minutes daily, daily. Which means that when we think about our programs, and in front of Mr. Rector, you can say, I will add an hour of civic education in the week. If you are fighting against content to which your children are exposed for an average of 4 hours and 40 minutes a day, good luck.

This is a reality that has completely transformed in recent years. So, we saw a few years ago that this was starting to pose problems. We tried to regulate, to change things. I say this before we debate to tell you that we are not starting from scratch. As early as 2018, I launched something called Tech for Good, meaning that we took the major platforms and said, we want to cooperate with you, for example, to fight against terrorism.

At first, we were not even followed by colleagues, despite the successive attacks. There was, in 2019, the Christchurch attack in New Zealand. We launched in Paris in May 2019 the Christchurch Call. This allowed us to achieve the removal of terrorist content online within an hour. You can imagine that it took more than two and a half years of struggle and that this so-called golden hour is rather respected, but there are still weaknesses in the system.

We then tried to engage things to protect children online, to ask platforms to moderate, to remove content, but on a voluntary basis. As part of what we did with the Paris Peace Forum, we created a child protection lab. And then, under the French presidency, in 2022, we established two major directives: the directive on digital actors, known as DMA, and the directive on digital services, known as DSA, to regulate and begin to establish a form of responsibility for these platforms. We started to establish a form of grammar, if I may say, to say, a bit like press titles, when there is hateful, anti-Semitic, racist content, it is your responsibility to remove it and we can pursue you. What I observe, after the vote, is that this takes time, we launched in 2022, we finalize in 2023-2024, we have the basis but we have not yet managed to finalize many cases based on these directives, because it is very slow, very long, and it is being attacked, directly, today, politically, by the major American players. You have, in the speeches of the American president, major American companies, speeches that say: "these Europeans want to regulate us," it is a fight against, pardon the anglicism, free speech.

We are currently in a situation where we have done all this, but we can see that it is not enough. 1) all studies show that our children, our teenagers are increasingly disturbed by these networks. I had set up a commission that delivered its conclusions in 2022, chaired by Mr. Bronner, on lights in the digital age, which showed all the problems regarding education, the relationship to knowledge, to science, and a screen commission that delivered its conclusions last year.

There has been a lot of international work, Mr. HART and others, the great researchers, all this shows that we have among our young people more and more problems with attention disorders, more and more eating behavior disorders, more and more difficulties in accessing knowledge due to these overexposures to social networks. We can return to this, and we will return to it in the debate, that is why I do not want to be too long, but now, there is a scientific consensus to say that for young people and adolescents, it is not good.

The second thing is that we see that all this is shaking up the life of our democracies. The relationship to knowledge, to science, we saw it a bit in the debates during COVID, we see it again today. We have seen recently, in the elections that have taken place, how social networks became agents of either interference or a bit of democratic degeneration. What happened in Moldova or Romania in recent months has been very well documented. We can return to this as well in the discussion. And so, we cannot pretend that this does not exist.

Social networks disrupt our relationship to the formation of our public opinions, to elections, and therefore to our democratic life. Because there are hidden actors behind, there are algorithms whose logics we do not necessarily know, and there can be behind, and there are also, techniques of interference, interference from foreign powers that can be at work and come to disrupt our democratic sovereignty.

For all these reasons, it was necessary to sound the alarm. Indeed, the press itself is directly impacted. You see it, not just in your electorate, but in the unfair competition, if I may say, that is made by these networks where, in a way, in the capture of values they can make, whether it be networks or major actors in artificial intelligence who, because they aggregate demand, we will first ask them, take the value when they then redirect to content pages that are not theirs. But they are the ones who will have monetized all this.

For all these reasons, I wanted us to have these debates, and I thank you for seizing them, for many of you had started them, and we have had these in recent years, perhaps in a somewhat informal or disjointed manner, and the goal is that we try to build a national consensus by the end of the year, so that at the beginning of next year, we can make the right collective decisions to face these challenges, both for our young people and for the proper functioning of democracy.

There you go, I do not want to be longer, but I wanted to recall in a few words where we come from and what the nature of the problem is, what we are doing. The goal is to move towards concrete decisions at the beginning of the year 2026. Now, I am at your service. But thank you very much, President. Thank you to you, to all your teams, for the mobilization, the work done, and for organizing this debate.

Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you for these introductory remarks that will facilitate the discussions, as everyone now has the same level of knowledge on the subject. I was supposed to give an introduction, but yours is much better. So, I will step back. The President of the Republic will respond to the maximum extent that he can. There are many of you, but we have limited time. In any case, feel free. We were talking about free speech earlier. This is exactly the spirit of this meeting. So this meeting, in fact, "Democracy Under the Test of Social Networks," we decided to break it down into three chapters. We will first address conspiracy theories, particularly through the lens of health. You mentioned it, Mr. President, because the COVID crisis has been a revealing factor of conspiracy theories.

The second segment will focus on the media because we are at the headquarters of La Dépêche du Midi, and indeed, we have been addressing conspiracy theories and fake news for quite some time now, so we will tackle this subject and we will welcome your perspective on this theme.

Then, of course, education, the training of young people, you also mentioned it, Mr. President, training in critical thinking and discernment in order to achieve the best possible digital citizenship.

The first segment will be on social networks and conspiracy theories. We decided to enter through the medical spectrum. So why? For several reasons. First, Toulouse is a city of knowledge, knowledge in both singular and plural. We have more than 9,000 researchers in Toulouse, over 140 public and private laboratories, and we also have the Oncopole, which was established by Jacques Chirac at the time to concentrate cancer research here in Toulouse. We have a very strong pool of research, particularly in medical research. COVID, as you also mentioned, revealed behaviors, a distrust towards caregivers, towards scientists, which has called into question the effectiveness of vaccines. So all these issues led us to first address conspiracy theories through this medical lens.

To set the ideas, we will present some key figures. Look at this screen. We will see the numbers that appear. It is quite enlightening. 35% of French people claim to believe in conspiracy theories. One in three French people. 40% of French people adhere to at least one scientific falsehood, for example, that vaccines are not effective, and 60% of healthcare professionals say they are facing an increasingly distrustful public regarding medical information. We see that this greatly complicates the task of caregivers, which is to provide care. Because now, before treating, one must convince; one must expend energy to convince patients of the treatments that will be proposed to them. So, we will rely on a local testimony for each segment, because we are rooted in the regional daily press, in our territory.

Pauline BOUIC

Yes, indeed. So, Professor, thank you. Professor Julien Mazières, indeed, you are an oncologist-pneumologist at the CHU of Toulouse. You have certainly faced this first wave of COVID at the hospital. You are also present on X, formerly Twitter, where you have a community of scientists following you. And you are also very much questioning the fight against misinformation and especially the respect for freedom of expression.

Speaker

Pneumologist, oncologist at the CHU of Toulouse, responsible for the respiratory pathways department. So I was on the front line for everything related to the COVID epidemic. Also, a member of the University of Toulouse, whose president is next to you, a researcher at Inserm, and a member of the CHU.

My job in care, teaching, and research, I do it, I have always done it, but we have added something new, which is communication, accompanying what we do, a communication that was previously quite simple, which was to publish, discuss in fairly traditional media. Now, we have moved to something more complicated, and it involves mastering the social networks in which we are. So I am indeed very present on Twitter, and at the moment when everyone left, for the reasons we know, I stayed, not because I adhere to the philosophy of Twitter, but because I think that if we leave space for conspiracy theorists, there is no longer scientific truth, so I stayed, a bit against my will, it’s hard to read, I admit, Twitter, but well, I stayed.

Now, I will start by citing a few examples that have happened to me in terms of conspiracy theories and then try to open up the discussion a bit. As a pneumologist during the COVID pandemic, we had a medical and scientific approach. We conducted scientific work while our services were overwhelmed by patients, and we made a first publication where we looked at the state of patients four months after COVID infection. We saw that 60% still had symptoms and 40% had radiological anomalies.

I tweeted it in English, everyone said okay. I tweeted it in French suggesting vaccination. And then there were 300,000 responses. I have them on my phone, I made some screenshots, I won’t quote them all. There were insults, there were "take off your coat," there were "you’re a sellout of Inserm," just things like that. At that moment, I thought, what do I do? Do I let the wave pass or do I respond? I was still a bit young and naive. I responded to almost everything. Well, from the moment there were at least more than 50 followers for each account. And that multiplied the responses, meaning that I ended up with a total of 5% positive and scientific responses versus 95% catastrophic, insulting responses leaning towards conspiracy theories. It’s true that it’s quite disturbing, and we are helpless as doctors to fight against this misinformation.

Another example that is different and perhaps even more serious, as a pneumologist, I fight against tobacco and against the communication made by the tobacco industries towards young people. So I try to dismantle the communication from Philip Morris, which punctuates each of its tweets with a hashtag, a world without tobacco. I don’t know if you can understand the cognitive inversion that a company whose business is to sell cigarettes would use #a world without tobacco or a world without smoking. They are explaining that they have moved to electronic cigarettes, but it is to make people even more addicted since they keep nicotine as a vector to habituate people. You see that it’s still very complicated to position oneself, and I even received a message where Philip Morris told me: "We do more than you for the anti-tobacco fight." I read it in front of medical students, since I was teaching that morning when I received it.

At that point, we say to ourselves that we are quite helpless to respond to all this. That said, we are doctors and researchers, so we value critical thinking. We must not be in a vertical, descending, unique truth. So we must still leave space for criticism, for discussion of all truths, including vaccines. We are open to discussion.

So how do we find the right balance? Where do we place the cursor between, since we are talking about democracy, not being in a unique truth, which is a sign of totalitarianism, but being able to discuss everything we find, thus a truth that is still a bit plural to be able to be in the critical spirit that is the basis of democracies. We must juggle with that, and it’s quite complicated.

So, when I can’t manage, I know you love philosophy, I will revisit some philosophers. I think we can still find some small answers on this. The first is, does truth exist? Because philosophers did not talk about fake news, but they talked a lot about truth. It’s true that already, Plato spoke of truth as a goal. I think we must aim for truth as a common goal. But once we say that, we are still in something that is not complete, because if we look at what Montaigne said, and we are well placed to say it here, "truth here, another truth on this side of the Pyrenees," or what Paul Ricœur said, who is a philosopher you like, that we think, we always philosophize from somewhere, that means we are never neutral. We must indeed introduce both that truth exists and that it must be our common goal, but also that truth can be contested, that we must accept a plural truth and that in any democracy, there must therefore be a possible discussion.

We now come to how to do it? That’s where it gets a bit complicated. I think we will open the discussion on this. We understand that the only way to get out of this is dialectics, communication, and therefore we must find a space in which we can discuss. Dialectics, the ancient Greeks said, the Socratic truth, is that truth is the sum of what we will say today and not what a single person has said. That’s very good; we need to restore a space for dialectics. The problem is, do social networks allow us to do this dialectics? I think it’s a bit complicated because social networks are conditioned to be seen, to keep us connected, 4 hours and 40 minutes a day, as you said, and for that, if we only put truths, people do not stay connected. We need to put things that annoy them, that make them contest, that make them anxious, and for that, social networks are enriched with fake news to keep people captive. What is this space? I don’t know, we will talk about it together.

Moderator

A space to be created, perhaps.

Speaker

So, I think there are spaces. There are books and libraries. Bringing bookstores back to the city, there are already quite a few, but libraries for people who have less money to buy books, moments like this one where we will all talk while respecting what the other will say. I think there are still possibilities for debate where everyone can propose their opinion, defend the truth, and thus democracy, fight against totalitarianism and against fake news.

Speaker

Thank you, thank you for the invitation and thank you, Mr. President, for taking an interest in and bringing to the forefront this subject that is so important. First, in illuminating remarks, I find that the leaders of La Dépêche are very modest. You are very modest because you are here, Mr. President, in the nuclear heart of Toulouse. From Toulouse, but also from Occitanie, and this Occitanie, this Southwest, you know, has a temperament of courage and resistance. This newspaper perfectly embodies that. Dear Jean-Michel, I would like to remind you that, a few days after AZF, we found ourselves side by side on the plane returning to Paris, and you explained to me that, while you were facing the means at hand, you did everything to ensure that the newspaper was published the day after AZF, and it was published. That is courage, and that is resistance.

Over a longer period, this newspaper has shown resilience and courage in the face of conspiracy theories. It has maintained its stance. It has never given a voice to those who promote conspiracy theories. We cannot say the same for many news channels and radio stations. La Dépêche has held the line, and I want to commend it for that.

So, this subject is of utmost importance, and the great mistake would be to think that it is not. And yet, I was still on the phone yesterday with Professor Mathieu Molimard, who was appointed by the previous Minister of Health, Yannick Neuder, on a mission and on a report on the conspiratorial drifts in health, he, Dominique Costagliola, Hervé Maisonneuve, and he told me that they had interviewed more than 120 people and that the only ones they could not interview were politicians.

Either because they consider it unimportant, or because they believe there is too much of a voice reserve to take too strong a position. That is really the wall against which we will hit. So, as you said, COVID has been a tremendous accelerator of conspiratorial drifts, particularly in health and medicine. The very basis of conspiracy theories is often the drifts on science and medicine. Why?

First, at the beginning of COVID, conspiracy theories were artisanal. It was a few well-known individuals, whom we had known during the H1N1 flu, who began to launch far-fetched theories. Then, they industrialized this response. They created associations, they created real structures that brought them a lot, a lot of money. They had lawyers who conducted class actions, who won millions of euros from it. There were false press outlets like France Soir, a well-known conspiratorial blog, which really carried this and spread it.

We were attacked. We were, in a way, a small group of doctors and researchers. We had made a shadow

At the scientific cabinet at the time to combat this conspiracy theory. We were threatened, threatened with death. I personally had a bodyguard for two years, I received thousands and thousands of death threats, received bullets at the clinic I manage, an independent clinical group, one of the last as well. I received hundreds of thousands of threats, the hashtag Marty has been at the top of the Twitter trends in France several times, especially over the weekend, and we faced it.

We faced it. We faced it why, Mr. President? Simply because we are doctors and our role is to uphold public health, no matter the cost. No matter the cost. Why has it spread and why is the very basis of conspiracy theory scientific and anti-medical conspiracy? The trust rate of the population towards doctors is 90%, and it does not vary year after year. The trust rate in political leaders is 9%. This means that the population trusts doctors ten times more than political leaders, and we see the importance that a foreign nation can have in destabilizing and trying to break this trust between the population and doctors, since once again, trust in the medical population is a pillar of democratic stabilization.

When we attack doctors, we weaken this pillar and thus weaken the nation. On any subject, we attack doctors. So, we can clearly see that Russia, in particular, today, in the hybrid war it is waging against us, promotes this communication by funding a number of structures, which I mentioned, that have industrialized this attack, that have industrialized this manipulation.

So, we will have to fight. We will have to fight, and it will be done differently than through words. First, we must have absolutely no, but absolutely no, indulgence towards those who communicate false scientific doctrines that endanger the population. When one takes the responsibility of spreading false information and does so through associations or structures that have been founded for that purpose, one endangers people's lives and that must come at a very high cost, a very high cost.

Another thing that slows us down is the lack of scientific culture, you mentioned it, but it is also the lack of scientific culture among parliamentarians. I think we need to require parliamentarians to have scientific training when they face a health crisis. We can no longer have parliamentarians who relay false science thinking it is correct. And then, we must admit, there are many parliamentarians who relay this because there is an electoral reservoir and that this electoral reservoir can lead them to advance by upgrading their political ranking. We saw that in the United States, the QAnon movement significantly contributed to the election of President Trump. And we have the same thing today in France, we have small political movements, Philippot, Asselineau, Dupont-Aignan, who have largely taken with them the most extremist conspiracy movements, those who have called for our decapitation. And then, we have the far right and the far left playing a very unhealthy role in this and who do not dare to take strong positions against those who wage war against us, the war inside and the war outside.

It is good that you are finally addressing this issue. You have not been exempt from faults. The fact of having somewhat endorsed Professor Raoult has made us lose a lot of time. Professor Raoult who was at the origin, you know, of falsified studies, of the use of a dangerous unconventional treatment in COVID. I mean, at some point, we need to put a stop to all this. We need to clean up at the IHU. But these are very symbolic examples that science is waiting for.

Mr. President, once again, thank you. Thank you for this fight that you are going to lead. Take it to the end. Take it to the end. Do not be afraid to overturn the table. Do not be afraid to have a strong and hard discourse because conspiracy theories, anti-science drifts, are today a form of terrorism. Thank you.

Speaker

I am a nurse in polyvalent intensive care at Rangueil Hospital in Toulouse. I have been a nurse for a long time, so I have a bit of experience as a caregiver. And I would like to share a bit of our feelings as caregivers in the face of conspiracy theories. We were greatly impacted by the COVID period. We were present, we really had teams that came together. We saw the vaccines arrive as a potential solution, as a light at the end of the tunnel, a bit, in the face of COVID. And then, we saw all these debates, all these controversies about vaccination. As a caregiver, I speak for myself, but also for most of my colleagues, we were very impacted because we did not understand. There was a lot of misunderstanding at the beginning. There was also a lot of anger for a while. There was a lot of sadness especially because unfortunately, we found ourselves a few months later with people in intensive care beds who were in concerning states of health with, of course, vital prognoses at stake, as we all know, and then with a feeling of saying: we might have been able to avoid all this if these people had been vaccinated.

Of course, some people were not vaccinated out of carelessness, perhaps, but we still had some conspiracy theories a bit, we had people who were convinced that vaccination was useless, their families, who could sometimes be vehement and sometimes aggressive towards caregivers and oppose certain treatments. So, it was complicated for us, complicated to face and try to provide quality care, to provide care a bit professionally, to remain professional in all this in situations of misunderstanding and sadness too since, unfortunately, there were many situations that ended tragically sometimes for the patients.

The second point I wanted to address was in terms of information to families and patients. We see more and more families or patients who go looking for information from the media, from social networks, from the web, without it being necessarily verified sources, with patients or their families, because unfortunately, in intensive care, we have a lot to do, as caregivers to families, who will be misinformed or have bad information. We know that as a family, when we are in really desperate situations a bit, we need to cling to more positive things. If the information providing positive things is accessible, we will go towards that, even if it is not the most verified.

We are confronted with this daily, with families who become a bit distrustful of the medical field, towards caregivers, despite the information that doctors, that medical teams can give them. I think it is important for caregivers, doctors, everyone, to try to guide, to educate people to seek reliable, verified information, particularly in health matters, and then to accompany these people towards information that will allow them to be really, really clear about the pathologies of their loved ones and to be able to adhere to care projects. For us caregivers, it is important to first have the families' adherence to care projects.

We are also fortunate to have doctors who are available, who are informed, who communicate. All decisions, all things are made in a somewhat collegial manner, with opinions often sought from other specialties. People really need to trust medical teams and caregivers really need to help people to seek information from reliable sources as they exist. An opening to this would perhaps be to try to have methods or things to push these people, methods of assistance to push these people towards somewhat verified and official sources of information.

Speaker

I am a doctor, I specialize in medical pharmacology and I work at the Drug Information Center of the Toulouse University Hospital and in pharmacovigilance.

We were on the front line during the COVID period, on the question of medications during COVID, on the question of vaccination, the side effects of vaccines, on efficacy, the question of the benefit/risk balance. These questions related to misinformation continue. More recently, we have the theme of the question of paracetamol and the risk of autism.

My field experience regarding information on medication shows that this misinformation, in fact, is a risk factor, it is a risk factor in health. Just as we have cited tobacco, alcohol, it is a risk factor. That is to say, what is a risk factor? It is that when we are exposed to this risk factor, we lose a chance for our health. When we are exposed to tobacco, there are risks that increase. When we are heavily exposed to alcohol, there are risks that increase. So, these are risk factors. This is potentialized, and we see it every day through social networks, of which we know the mechanism is addictive, an addictive mimetic mechanism, which is also therefore a risk factor.

When we potentialize misinformation and social networks, we potentialize, for us, two risk factors, two risk factors in health. What is said about risk factors, of course, is evaluation, education, that is very important. Our role at the Information Center at the Toulouse University Hospital is training, education, and evaluation of this information. But it is also perhaps, and this is the question I want to ask you, Mr. President, the question of the limit. Is there a place for prohibition? And I think particularly of the most vulnerable populations, children, especially on the question of social networks.

Should we ban social networks? At what age limit? I think, I give my opinion, I think yes, because they are risk factors. Do we expose our children to alcohol or tobacco?

Speaker

So, on this subject of conspiracy theories, how can France strengthen its information sovereignty against foreign platforms that shape public opinion? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you for starting with this subject. I would like to take a step back to say what we are talking about. Because, when we talk about La Dépêche: you buy an issue, you subscribe, there are additional revenues with legal announcements or advertising, but the core of the business, I choose to pay for information. So then, I know there are journalists. We will come back to that, I believe it is the second theme you mentioned, but I have an economic model that I understand and that is transparent for everyone. And then afterwards, I will have information, I will have editorials, and this is true for daily press, regional, national, weekly press. This is how we forge public opinion in our democracy.

For some time now, we have been talking about social networks. So, we should not caricature. You have said it very well. There are good things in social networks. That is to say, the fact that we can express ourselves, hear voices, have contestations, have dissenting opinions, have access to this or that alert that we would not have without social networks. Wonderful, it is an achievement of the networks. That is why we have, in a way, all adhered. The fact that it opens up now, that it circulates, that researchers, thanks to the networks, exchange with colleagues from the other side of the world or with another discipline they did not know, there is a beautiful story of social networks. And let us never forget that before these networks, the Internet was born from a scientific perspective and a desire for international cooperation.

But if I come to the social networks as we have been discussing, they do not make money by providing information. It has no value in social networks. They make money by selling individualized advertising. If we return to the basis of what the economic model is, we understand what their interest is. And so, all of us, what do we produce? Content, data, preferences, but we do not bring them money. When we write a message on Twitter, I would even say that we cost them in dissemination, it is microscopic, but they will make a lot of money because they will sell to advertisers who, by doing so, will leave the press or other forms of announcements because we will tell them: I can sell your advertising in a much smarter way because I know a lot about these people through my networks, because I follow them. I know what video they will watch at a certain time, I know what amuses them, what interests them.

For some time now, we have been talking about an information infrastructure as if it were an information infrastructure, but it is not. These are platforms for exchanging videos or messages, but their goal is to sell personalized advertising to advertisers and make a lot of money from it. Once we frame it this way, and this is not a value judgment against them, it is their business model. What then maximizes this business model? It is not that you have the smartest ideas to exchange on social networks, that there is maximum excitement. And here too, it is proven, documented. They design and build their algorithms so that you spend more and more time on these networks, that you have more and more excitement, and therefore they can push more and more content that they can monetize.

You find yourself in a space that we treat as an informational space, but whose objective is to sell personalized advertising and which will itself design its own functioning to create excitement. This means that the merit order within this network, at the very bottom, is the argument. Because argumentation does not create excitement. I enjoy discussing with you today, we will do it for two hours, you too, you enjoy reading books. I hope so. I think what was said earlier is very accurate. But that is not what will create the most excitement. There is a basic addictive principle that is being constructed. Argumentation is weaker than emotion. And positive emotion is weaker than negative emotion. In fact, look closely: on social networks, what maximizes is negative emotion. And so, I reiterate this right from the start of our discussion, it would be a miracle if it were different at this point, because we have been saying for some time how we should have a rational scientific discourse, fueled by critical thinking and by science, in a space that is constructed to do exactly the opposite.

We must draw the consequences ourselves, even if we have become super dependent. That is the point we are at. So, to get straight to the point, as they say in another region and for other clubs, not rugby, but football, regarding your question, I think there is now a scientific consensus that we must protect our children and our teenagers. Because precisely, when they go on these networks, they create a lot of dependency, they increase screen time, we have major issues with attention. I speak under the supervision of the scientists who are here. We do not know completely, to be rigorous, there are few scientific studies that have shown direct causalities. But they establish correlations so systematic that we can see that a good policy is to draw the consequences from it.

We have attention problems, we have learning problems, we have issues of sedentariness among our young people and teenagers that are linked to screen time exposure. They will play differently and will therefore be much less mobile, which is terrible for public health prevention. We have enormous problems with eating disorders, for example among young girls linked to social networks, because they are increasingly exposed to image references that present a completely fantasized model of women, of bodies, and which create terrible traumas for adolescent girls. We have an epidemic of eating disorders. And we also have behavioral issues among young boys because, through social networks, they access pornographic content at a much younger age, regardless of the precautions taken by parents. At a time when we have been fighting for years for gender equality, the change in relationships, it is proven that more and more young people and teenagers are accessing their relationship with women, with women's bodies through pornographic content at a very young age.

You have behind it a host of other disorders that arise from social networks. The correlation between the increase of these disorders among young people and everything we see regarding mental health is very well correlated with the expansion of social networks, and particularly certain networks that have very sophisticated algorithms, which create much more dependency. For all these reasons, the "Screens" Commission established it, the scientific consensus shows it, I believe we must move towards, indeed, a ban on social networks until a certain age. There is a consensus today that there should be no screens before the age of 3, it is very harmful. We should avoid screens as much as possible before the age of 6. We will probably return to this in the third part, but in education, we need to limit screens much more than we have thought. And for example, the Scandinavians who had gone very far with all-digital or all-screen are now going back.

On social networks, we need to protect, the debate exists: 14, 15, 16 years old, we will need to finalize that. But we must protect our children. And we are rather trying to build a coalition in Europe for that. In parallel, we will return to it, we need to educate them. That is key. Then, in adulthood, what you said about scientific conspiracy theories and anti-science discourse is key. It is based on the great bias I just described. In fact, what you also described are testimonies of loneliness from those who still choose to go on these networks and resist a dominant movement that goes in the opposite direction. So what can we do? How can we help you in the face of this? First, I think there is a huge contradiction, there are two major misunderstandings or misinterpretations in the public debate today.

There is a first misunderstanding, I would say scientific-democratic, it is the confusion between critical doubt and distrust. Critical doubt is a good thing. That is to say, I am taught something, I learn a piece of knowledge, and then through the test of facts, other experiences, it is the very basis of scientific research, I speak with a lot of humility under the supervision of experts and practitioners, but that is the test. You cited many philosophers, it is what Popper himself describes in science. It is that I must doubt even what I have known to show, and that is how knowledge will advance. That is the good doubt, if I may say so. It is the one that does not call into question the knowledge I have acquired without reason, but which says: in light of an experience, a counter-verification, I will begin to see if the theory I have learned is indeed correct.

But there is a methodology to do this. It should not be confused with distrust. Distrust is the collapse of trust in all content. It is to say, since it is an authority that has given me this content, whether scientific or political, it is a good thing and it is an act of resistance for me to start doubting this scientific content. Distrust, which can be a critical reflex in democracy when it becomes systematic, becomes rather a massive instrument of foolishness. As long as we continue to confuse critical and methodological doubt with systematic distrust, we will continue to regress. It is a real problem, and it is linked to what? To the fact that there is in our societies a form of collapse of all forms of authority. I am not satisfied with the figures you provided on political distrust, it is a very bad thing. It is true, there is more and more democracy, some resist better, but it is not good because politicians, we can like them or not like them, but there is a selection process, we vote. So have more trust in your politicians, because if you do not like them, you can vote against them. That is the principle of democracy.

The principle of scientific discourse is that the people who put it forward have a legitimacy recognized by their peers. What goes with this difference that needs to be restored between critical doubt and distrust is that we need to recreate hierarchy in the public space. It is not a dirty word. Because we need to recreate principles of authority. It is also true that there are legitimate, democratic organizational authorities, there are scientific and academic authorities. You mentioned Paul Ricœur earlier, he had a very beautiful phrase in May 68, when young students came to contest and said: "But where do you derive your authority from?" He had this admirable phrase, he said: "I have read more books than you." The authority of a scientist comes from years of study, recognition by their peers, and works that are recognized by their peers in an academic dialogue. It is not the same as someone who says: "I met Ginette who had a problem with her vaccine." If we put these two voices on the same level, we are doomed. And so, we need to recreate scientific authority by asking: "Where do you speak from?" This is absolutely fundamental.

Once we have said that, what should we do concretely? First, fight step by step, as you said very well, in the real world as in the digital world, against all these voices. There are legal bases, the endangerment of others' lives, and there is the activation of scientific peers. I did not legitimize Professor Raoult. I consulted everyone, but I take responsibility for not having made a political decision to prevent him from acting. I asked that his peers be able to do so and that there be scientific investigations, because that is the order in which we need to act. Many media outlets, not yours, as the doctor pointed out, have relayed these statements as if they were statements of truth, taking on a colossal responsibility. Because they pushed people, as you described, to pursue treatments that were not verified by colleagues scientifically, that had no basis, and to take risks. But there have been many others. I think that, behind this, we need to restore a system of accountability. Accountability for those who relay these statements and accountability to restore hierarchy. This is absolutely fundamental. For me, that is the first point. We need to be able to carry out these actions, these prosecutions, and protect.

The second thing is that we need, in a way, to protect our space, the space in which our compatriots will inform themselves to provide what is necessary and the right response to what you all described earlier. And so, we need to revisit the question of anonymity. In a democratic space, we need to ask the question of anonymity, because it is not the same if it is a professor of surgery, medicine, or public health who speaks or an ordinary person. The question of individual responsibility and the responsibility of platforms must be raised. If someone says anything that endangers the lives of others, I will pursue them. But if they do it in the columns of La Dépêche, I will pursue the one who has responsibility. Today, on platforms, it is very slow, very complicated, almost impossible, even if the so-called "DSA" directive has started to put it in place. We need to recreate accountability.

The third point is that we need to equip ourselves with mechanisms to have visibility on algorithms, that is to say, towards what these algorithms will push me. If they constantly push me towards false information, that is not possible. Fourth, we need to put a system in place, we have the foundations, but that is what we want to accelerate, to remove these false contents and impose moderation responsibilities on these social networks and platforms. Fifth point, we need to hunt down fake accounts because behind it, when you are told, and this is the great risk, and that is why it ignites, you have these networks with all the training flaws I mentioned. But when you have a million people reacting to a piece of information, it becomes information. So, journalists are obliged to look at it as information because a million people reacted. It is commented on news channels, it is sometimes picked up in the press. It becomes a fact.

But is this million that reacted, is it a million real accounts? I cannot say. Because we do not know the difference between real and fake accounts. Everything we do in light of our democracy, which is key to the foundation of science in our country, is exactly the technique used by those who wanted to undermine democracy in Romania. You may have heard that a few months ago in Romania, they canceled a first round of presidential elections; that is no small matter, "canceled." They just released the report. No one knew the candidate two months prior. He was at the top of all networks, TikTok, X. In the middle of his campaign, he became a star. They prepared fake web pages for a year; it was something industrialized. Scientific conspiracy theories were one of the verticals used. Because they saw, they found in the people who went to these sites a vulnerability. So they could seek out people who were, in a way, more open to false information, to questioning the established order because they were visiting these pages. They used that as fertile ground, and then, behind it, they viralized the creation of their candidate.

What we are saying is not science fiction; it is not theory. It was a year ago in Romania. The report has been released; it is public. We have just worked on it. Here are the answers we must provide on this issue. Obviously, the other answer is to strengthen training in critical thinking and science. And so, a ban, in my opinion, on young people and teenagers, training in critical thinking; we will return to this in the third part.

For the last question, you posed it very well in terms of sovereignty. Everything that is posed to us is a weakening of what a scientific nation like France had acquired; we are seeing setbacks in public health because of this. I will give you an example, under the control, once again, of our scientists, very simple: it is vaccination against forms of cancer, particularly the papillomavirus and others. These forms of cancer affect young girls and young boys, which is terrible. We have a vaccine that has been established. Countries like Australia have conducted vaccination campaigns for the younger population, and we have seen cases of cervical cancer in young girls, particularly oral cancers in young boys, collapse thanks to vaccination. We launched a campaign in middle schools. There is a very different rate between young girls and young boys, but we launched a campaign. We are seeing, despite our communication efforts, things regress. The tests we conducted show that it is exposure to scientific conspiracy theories from families that say: "I read on the Internet or on social media that this vaccine causes this or that for my children." While we have an established vaccine, and we have other countries that are ahead of us, and we know that, through science, we could protect our teenagers and future adults from cancers, we have families that do not adhere because of this. It is terrible because it represents a massive setback in public health. It indeed undermines our sovereignty.

This is where I make the link with the last point because if we want to weaken the country, we must go through there. The porosity to false information, if we do not restore critical thinking, regulation, the fight against fake accounts, and visibility on algorithms, makes you hyper-vulnerable to powers that are ready to go in this direction and who are, guess what, powers that do not allow this to happen in their own countries. Russia uses this. To cite an example that might seem more entertaining, when we had all those controversies about bedbugs. There was a viralization of this subject that became the top national topic for weeks, and we showed it very well; VIGINUM, which is the independent agency that monitors this, showed it because there were millions of fake accounts pushed by the Russians that promoted this issue. It caused quite a stir for some. It became a topic where tensions were rising everywhere, a huge issue of informational vulnerability, because in the world we live in, conflicts are becoming increasingly hybrid.

When we see that we can destroy the credibility of a government through false information, you lose your sovereignty. Russia uses it, and great powers like China also use it, which, by the way, does not allow social networks to be opened to its population, or when it created TikTok, it used TikTok for its own population, a completely different TikTok at home. It is an educational program with limited hours during the day that only presents scientific content. We have a huge issue of sovereignty, and that is what we are saying: beyond the scientific issue, it is a geopolitical issue because it is a vulnerability. Everything we are saying is that our social networks are like an agora where we would all be there, wearing hoods, and where the one who shouts the loudest is more likely to be right, and where the one who insults the other becomes likable. Because if you were all hooded, maybe one of you would start insulting me. The relationship to authority would no longer be the same. I would not know if one of you is a medical professor or something else. That is exactly it. The Internet, we accept that. Social networks, X, we accept that.

Here, we have a debate that is respectful. We can agree or disagree. We can be criticized. I can try to respond to you. But there is respect, there is listening, because the key to debate is precisely respect and listening. And we know where we are speaking from. Do we still want to consider that the way our young people inform themselves and how public debate is structured in the nation is an unregulated space for speech, where everyone is hooded and where the one who distributes the microphone is not chance or Mr. or Mrs., but an algorithm that is held either by a Chinese power that knows what it is doing with us, or by Mr. Musk, of whom I have understood has some political ideas. That is what is happening today. In fact, that is what we have chosen.

So, you will continue to fight, but behind that, you will continue to have, as long as we do not regulate this, a room with people in hoods, where everything is done to ensure that the one who shouts the loudest and insults the most carries the others along. We just need to be aware of that. If we are aware of that, we will build consensus to say: yes, we need to regulate. This is the very last point on this debate. There is a huge confusion that is twin to the one I mentioned between methodical doubt and systematic distrust. This is what is currently settling around "free speech." It is not freedom of speech to say anything at any time, to hurl insults, to no longer regulate anti-Semitism and racism, and to leave the regulation of speech to blind algorithms. These people are making us believe that they are the free speech. In the same way that when you have media starting to say: "freedom of speech is being able to give a voice to a lunatic who says anything, on the pretext that he does not say the same thing as the authorities," that is not freedom of speech. Freedom does not exist if there is no responsibility alongside it. Because otherwise, it is the freedom of the strongest. The freedom of speech on social networks is the freedom of the strongest.

I will end on this note. The press we have, where did it come from? From the laws of the Third Republic that established rules for this press. It ensured their freedom, it built the foundations of pluralism, but it also established responsibilities, including the editorial responsibilities I mentioned. All of the 19th century before that did not have these responsibilities clearly established, and the press was the press of the strongest. It belonged to the richest. There was neither the ethics that goes with it, which is today that of journalists, nor pluralism, nor the system of responsibility. There is no freedom without responsibility. Today, it is the Wild West on social networks. So, it cannot last.

Moderator

Before we begin, I believe there is a participant who could not join us this morning and who still wanted to send you a message. He recorded a video. I suggest we listen to it.

Hello Emmanuel. Great to see you again since that incredible summit in Egypt. You know, I read a lot of newspapers, the best ones, believe me, but the very first one I pick up every morning, even before the New York Times or the Washington Post, is La Depeche du Midi. Fantastic paper. They go after fake news like nobody else. Very important. They're doing a tremendous job for democracy. Have a good day in Toulouse, my great friend!

Moderator

Of course, this video is fake. We would love for them to read us all the way to the United States. In any case, it was to show you that today, a video manipulated by artificial intelligence can appear as information, but is not. On the contrary, it is a lie.

Perhaps looking at some figures to fix ideas together; 82% of the French declare misinformation as a threat to democracy. So, apparently, public opinion is well aware of it. Local media remain the most credible, with 66% of people trusting them versus 28% for social networks, which shows that the source is still quite positive. 41% of those under 35 primarily inform themselves via social networks and no longer necessarily through traditional press. 83% of 15-20 year-olds trust traditional media. There is still hope. Only 8% trust social media. Perhaps deep down, they know that social media is a risk. 3,300 newspaper closures since 2005 in the United States, which also shows a change in the economic model that we will discuss with you, Jean-Nicolas Baylet. You are the general director of La Dépêche, of the Dépêche group, and you are also the director of publication, which means you are criminally responsible for the information published by your websites and the print newspaper. Today, the relationship between media and GAFAM, which relay information, is twisted. Finally, we feel the pressure as a press owner. Today, how has your economic model evolved on this point?

Jean-Nicolas BAYLET

Mr. President, ladies and gentlemen, first of all, I would like to restore a truth. The video you just saw is real news. Donald Trump reads La Dépêche du Midi every morning, you understood that. Mr. President, you have perfectly introduced my remarks, so I will address our readers so they can understand what has happened in our industry since the arrival of social networks. In reality, before social networks, our journalists, men and women, produced information and then disseminated it. With the arrival of social networks, we have been completely intermediated by platforms that today decide what information you will consume and, in doing so, capture a very significant part of our revenues. The press in France consists of 13,500 journalists. This is about 70% of the entire journalistic profession. We do not manipulate 13,500 journalists; we do not manipulate such a mass. It is a bulwark for our democracy. However, a bulwark without an economic base is a bulwark that collapses, of course.

The figure that was on the previous slide marks what has happened in the United States, which is ahead of us. In the United States, 3,300 newspapers have disappeared since 2005. Everywhere newspapers have disappeared, mainly local newspapers, there has been a regression of democracy. Why? Because yesterday, we all consumed the same information, and the media functioned that way. You all had the same newspaper; you all had a common piece of information on which you could debate. Today, we are all locked in algorithmic bubbles, as the President of the Republic recalled. The objective of social networks is absolutely not the search for truth. The objective of social networks is to capture your attention as best as possible to monetize it. To do this, they play on a simple factor, which is emotion. Emotion at all costs. They lock you into what will make you react positively, or rather negatively, as you pointed out, Mr. President. They convey hatred; they convey violence, and they do all this in total absence of regulation.

The press, since the 19th century, has been regulated by the law of July 29, 1881. Defaming someone is a criminal offense. As for social networks, they can convey any information they want without being bothered. Moreover, there was an important link missing in the chain of social networks since today, they can disseminate information. It was the possibility of creating this information. Artificial intelligence is arriving in this context. Artificial intelligence consists of magnificent technologies that we ourselves use in our daily work. But it is also tools that will allow the creation of information from scratch. And fundamentally, we now face complete and fully constituted industrial machines of disinformation, since they can produce information, disseminate information, and choose this information with algorithms of which we know nothing, without journalists, without verification, without a search for the truth. So, what should we do?

We must act, of course. We must act in several ways. The first is to impose transparency. To impose and frame these algorithms. But what on earth is in these algorithms that we cannot see? We need to know what is behind these algorithms. We must impose this transparency. The second is that we must educate, not only our youth but the entire population. We must all maintain this critical spirit to say: when I consume information, be careful, there are always multiple perspectives to a story. This is what we strive to do. We do it in the way we conduct our profession; we provide different viewpoints. Seek out different perspectives. Do not remain trapped in your algorithmic bubbles. Finally, the third is that we must guarantee the press an economic model. If there is no economic model, there is no more press. And if there is no more press, democracy retreats. And if democracy retreats, freedom disappears. Thank you.

Moderator

Thank you, Jean-Nicolas Baylet. We have a question in the front row.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. In your opinion, what is the impact of billionaires on the press and media in the world, and in France in particular, such as Bolloré who owns media like CNews and Europe 1, or Xavier Niel who owns Le Monde, and the newcomer who is buying media to influence political debate, Pierre-Édouard Stérin with his Périclès project, who is trying to modify political debate and democratic voting in France?

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. Indeed, I was a journalist for 17 years here before embarking on a new professional life, and I witnessed the arrival of Twitter, in 2006 I believe, which was a wonderful tool for information for journalists, a fantastic communication vector for politicians, but also for doctors, scientists, and which allowed citizens to get closer to knowledge, to abolish distances that might otherwise exist. And then, Elon Musk bought it. It became X. Indeed, we have all seen the evolution of this tool. You spoke of Musk's political vision; we know what he is doing with it today. You also spoke of blind algorithms. They are not necessarily as blind as that, since they are shaped to propagate this libertarian vision that is Musk's, with all the political stakes that come with it, which are far removed from the values of liberty, equality, fraternity that are ours. We also know that X today is used to feed Grok, Musk's generative AI, which is the most degenerate AI, not generative, but the most degenerate that exists on the system today, on the network, and which will tomorrow feed Grokipédia, which will compete with Wikipedia, which will be a new dissemination of knowledge. But what knowledge? And so, I ask you a direct question: wouldn't it be time today for the Élysée, for you, to set an example and leave X? I know, I heard what the doctor said earlier, about being here, fighting anyway, trying to carry this little torch, the banner of true scientific knowledge or true political speech. But for me, it's a bit of a lost cause today. We also know the Brandolini's law which states that it takes ten times more energy to dismantle a fake news story, to restore the truth, than the energy it took to spread it.

For me, it's a lost cause. And if you set the example, there are cities, the City of Paris for example, the region of Nouvelle-Aquitaine, the Brittany region, that have left, the CFDT, the École polytechnique, that have closed their X accounts. If you make this decision, for me, it would be a strong symbol, it would serve as an example on a global level. You have also taken initiatives in a conflict that we have heard about recently, of course. That could be another initiative. And in any case, I find that it would have panache. And you could also perhaps carry this message on other platforms. There are other networks that exist, more responsible. Perhaps a French network as well, why not? We talk about sovereignty. I won't go on longer, but here is my question, Mr. President.

Speaker

Mr. President, hello. I am fundamentally a hacker. I acquired Tchap when it came out; you may remember. I founded, five years ago now, a company called Predicta Lab, which aimed to combat disinformation. We talked about regulation, we talked about society, we talked about health, we talked about many subjects. But we did not talk about technical solutions. I am a man of action. I pay tribute to all the people who watch over you and protect you every day. When they have a threat, we respond with action, we respond with a solution. We have worked for five years to find solutions to disinformation.

You spoke of an economic model. The private sector does not have an economic model to combat disinformation. No one pays for that. That is the first issue. The second issue is that if we seek to combat disinformation, the crux of the matter is data. We need access to data. And I set up Predicta Lab. Subsequently, I went to see the Prime Minister's services to see how they worked, how they fought, particularly during the Yellow Vests crisis, on this issue. The response was that there was no response. We were going to take reports from different startups, we compared what came out and tried to draw conclusions. The basis is that today, we do not have the data. We do not have access to the data because the platforms either regulate access to data for certain researchers, to certain datasets. They will choose who they will give it to. And today, we do not have that data. Without that data, we will not have a response. Today, VIGINUM produces reports, you mentioned them, which are extremely relevant, well-provided, rich, but too late. One month, two months, six months later, it's over. We need a technical solution today that is capable of responding in real-time to threats. And our adversaries, we talked about industrial industries. Today, cybercriminals, industrial disinformers, states, because we have been beating around the bush for a while, we have enemies. We are at war. We are at war. And in this informational war, but not only, I also had the chance to go to Ukraine to see the solutions, since they are also suffering, among other things, from these issues; they have solutions. We have things to learn from Ukraine today. We need technical solutions, we need that data, and above all, how to stimulate the private sector?

Today, good wills like mine, good wills and names, I have many, good wills, there are plenty, that lack resources and lack political will. Because tomorrow, if you stimulate, if you choose a candidate, a champion, if you provide the means, if you use your political strength to push the platforms by saying to him, you give him the data, he will be able to work within a regular, framed framework, there is no problem. But we need to be able to support the private sector on these issues today. Today, the only ones who are fighting against disinformation are associations, particularly at the Brussels level; you will have 10 infolabs. You will have people who will make efforts of this type. But overall, the private sector does not have an economic model to combat disinformation, because not only does no one pay, but access to data is not possible.

Speaker

Mr. President, hello. Hello everyone. I am a doctoral student in social media strategy in electoral campaigns at the University of Toulouse. Perhaps in scientific research, we take the example of Barack Obama's electoral campaign as a successful example of an electoral campaign thanks to social media, and then we talk about other campaigns. But we rarely question the power of these digital platforms and that politicians also participate in this power. Is this power for you, for the digital platforms, a myth? Or do you think today you can also bear a small responsibility, you as all politicians, for participating in this power and giving this momentum to the digital platforms? Another question as well: do you also think that a candidate in the next presidential election could win without using social media? And why? And one last piece of information that, if you allow me, I would like to invite you to my thesis defense on December 10.

Journalist

Mr. President of the Republic, a word first about this place. President Baylet mentioned it. We talk about the dematerialization of information from our social networks, and you are here in our paper room, the columns of paper on which verified, controlled information is printed every night. And if I dared, and I dare, I would compare these columns of paper to pillars of democracy. There you go. On interference, on the subject of interference. Yes, indeed, we, the media, even regional media, are mobilized on this issue. It is a phenomenon that we take seriously, a phenomenon that we talk about. And while preparing my intervention, I did a little check on our site. I typed "Russian interference" into the search bar of our La Dépêche du Midi site, where we have 37 pages of 20 occurrences each that come up. This is indeed proof that all regional media, as we are, and national media from a digital perspective, we talk and we question ourselves and we inform our readers about this risk of interference.

Are we directly concerned? Are we threatened? No. Why? Because the PQR, which is still the leading French media in terms of traditional and digital distribution, if indeed we add up all our distributions, this power, if misused, could indeed cause considerable damage to a country like France and to democracies in general. Simply, we are also, and this is our strength, a local media. We know our readers, our readers know us, we know who we are talking about. When we cover municipal election campaigns or local election campaigns in general, we know the candidates, and it is true that we are perhaps less vulnerable than other media to the question of interference. This link with the territory is a strong, unique link that must be preserved. And then, the second particularity, which is notably that of La Dépêche du Midi, is that we are an independent media. And an independent media from the great financial powers, and here too, this independence is a guarantee of seriousness for our readers. So yes, indeed, we talk about the issue of interference in our columns, we alert our readers. No, we are not a media directly threatened by this phenomenon.

Speaker

Yes, thank you. Hello, Mr. President. Indeed, I believe, and we see it, and we will continue to see it, no field is spared by social media. There are good things for social media. And unfortunately, the field that I will try to embody a bit today, and which is a pillar of democracy, is that of justice.

And we cannot say that in this area, social media are doing extremely good things. Now, I know that for years, you have been very well accompanied by a Minister of Justice who was nothing less than an excellent colleague, and so I know that you must have obviously addressed these questions with him.

We can, we, observe in our practice, I know there are other lawyers, a former bar president, my partner, in the room, particularly in criminal matters, we are very helpless in the face of social networks. So, we are not facing the media because we have learned, we lawyers, to defend outside the courts. We have learned to defend in the media and we have means to, in quotes, I put it in quotes, control the media since we can. If I want to, Jean-Nicolas, I can indeed pursue you legally, I won’t do it, because La Dépêche du Midi does a wonderful job, but in any case, I have means to put pressure on you and I have the means to pursue you. Social networks, for obvious reasons, we cannot do that, they are anonymous. We have legal actions, you mentioned them a little earlier, Mr. President, but they are so difficult to implement that we cannot advise them, of course, to clients who come to our offices.

So, what is the difficulty of social networks in relation to justice? We saw it in the Jubillar case, but in other cases as well, it is that social networks are everything that justice is not: immediacy, absence of contradiction, absence of verification, factual elements, meaning we are exclusively in emotion. And I listened to you carefully earlier, you indicated, I noted it, Mr. President: “the argumentation on social networks is weaker than emotion.” I noted it, it’s always good to quote a guest’s phrase. So, I noted it because it is extremely true. To the extent that what we have observed is that an intimate conviction has been forged on social networks in this case that has nothing to do with the intimate conviction required, you understood it, before assize courts, with an opinion that has been formed, and with social networks that render justice completely unnecessary. Let me explain. On social networks, what is magical is that you can have an accusation in record time without having to go through the police services. Behind it, you have no investigation, so that is much simpler. You have people who comment, who give their opinion, they are not witnesses, they are just people who want to give their opinion, no verification of this opinion, of course. And then behind it, you have a guilt in record time that will depend on the emotion of one and the other and you have — and this is the best part, I think, and you understand that I am being ironic — an immediate sanction, which is a social sanction, which is sometimes a professional sanction. And so it makes the passage through justice completely unnecessary. And I will perhaps conclude with an example. We have had in our offices, in our firm, people who come to see us, who, through the hashtag, for example, “#balancetonavocat,” will come and say: well, I have many people accusing me, Master Martin, it’s my partner, Master Franck, you have to defend me. Well, yes, but we cannot defend you, there is no complaint. We do not have the means to defend you, we can do nothing until we return to the judicial process. So, apparently, we need to ask questions, I don’t know.

Speaker

I have a question. I have a question, but you have already answered it a bit. I believe that the solution may lie in lifting anonymity, because when one is not anonymous, one tends to say much less nonsense. And perhaps also in seeking and facilitating responsibility on social networks, since when one is not anonymous and when one is responsible, well, one tends to say much less nonsense.

Emmanuel MACRON

I will answer quickly, because we have already covered a lot of things, and I think the framing that was done on the media and social networks was very comprehensive. Regarding the first question that was addressed to me, it was about, fundamentally, the presence of multimillionaires or billionaires in media ownership. It is a fact, you are right. Is it a sign of good health? No. It is the exact consequence of what was described by the Director General, namely that the economic model is in crisis. And so we have more and more press titles, by the way, newspapers, radios, televisions, that are being bought by people whose agenda is not exactly to sustain a press title. And that is a problem.

But we are returning to a model that is actually very similar to the one we knew in the 19th century. And so the great risk is that we have media ownership for the purposes of influencing opinion and not simply for information. Even if we know very well, and we have a clear mapping, it is normal that there are different opinions among titles. Simply, it is the information that predominates. So, what do we have as an antidote to this? First, we have journalists and their editorial teams. And so I think that there are several of the titles you mentioned, to which you referred, that, although owned capitalistically by billionaires, do not have their editorial line dictated by these billionaires because they have an independent editorial team, they have a Charter that guarantees this independence, and they can object. And so, in the organization of titles, there are things that protect you. Nevertheless, it is not enough in the current context. So, we started with the Estates General of Information, there are texts in preparation. We need to try to go further and therefore better protect press titles against this concentration. And the most structural response is to recreate the viability of an economic model. That is what you said in your introduction, that is to say, to bring back a bit of the economic model that has gone towards social networks, towards these large platforms, towards AI that has captured advertising revenue, towards these titles so that we can preserve pluralism and have a model that works on its own and does not have very rich people who need to settle in to keep it alive.

On cybersecurity, we have mentioned it less, but it is obviously twin to everything we are saying, and it is key. Thank you for being committed to it. I do not rule out what you invited me to do, which is to exit these networks. I think that in any case, it can only make sense in an overall process. So, I do not rule it out today. It is not what I will do tomorrow morning and I will not make an announcement today. I think the priority is first to fight the battle internally for me and to try to obtain these elements of regulation and visibility.

It is in the context of this battle that we will need to see if, indeed, we will go that far. But in any case, it is something I am reflecting on with great attention, believe me, and that I do not rule out at all. But I think the battle is more comprehensive, and I do not want to simply make a move, even if I do not underestimate the impact it could have. Thank you very much, Sir, for what you said. You are absolutely right. By the way, I will make sure that the team that is here connects well with you. If I had to tell you what action track I see, regarding your two questions that are twin, it is that, fundamentally, when I said that algorithms are blind, I said they are blind to us. But you are right, the algorithms are very clear, they are in the hands of the people who hold them and with presuppositions that are either completely capitalistic or capitalistic and ideological. When I say we need to make them transparent, it is the simplest response, because we are not in a position to regulate them. It is too complicated for public power. We can regulate them as we regulate certain operators, I would say, like insurers who carry out billions of operations to ensure that there is a specification with which they comply. And that is a bit what we started with the DSA. On the other hand, what we need to succeed in doing is to open them up, to require them to share information in real time and to allow actors who are selected by the regulator to use this information to process it and, you give it to them. And that is the right formula. And so, for me, in the regulation we need to put in place, we need to create an economy that is exactly what you described, that is to say, of those who have created the processing capabilities so that there is transparency on these algorithms and this information.

Today, there is none. And today, there is even something that is very incestuous that is starting to take shape, which is the Grok mechanism that you described. However, it is not the one who uses the algorithm who can, behind, claim to be the one who regulates them, it is the moderation model that he puts in place with his own artificial intelligence that regulates you that, behind, will use it to explain what is true and what is false. That is a privatization of our cognitive space and our relationship to truth. If we do not want to privatize it, as we have done in history, it is the whole history, by the way, of competition policy in the United States with Standard Oil, where we, in recent decades, must say: the one who manipulates so much data about us, does not have the right to do something with it. And so, in my eyes, the right regulation is that the one who manages information does not have the right to do paid online advertising, it is not the same profession. Or it must be transparent for me and limited in terms of purchasing power, and the one who accumulates this information must share it with trusted third parties, whose economic role and action, and process it so that the citizen has access to it. Because you do not have bias, you, when you process an algorithm, if you give me the reality and the biases on this algorithm. You will draw your money from what I am willing to pay you for this transparency. And that is exactly what we need to do. And by the way, all our economic life has been structured like that. It is the way to defend the public interest.

I will not make you promises like some say, even if it is not here that I would dare to do so, being Bigourd for my part. On the power of digital platforms, it is real, we have just described it for a while. I think the dilemma for all political leaders, there are three different behaviors.

There are, as was described by the doctor earlier, those who will be complacent with false information in an electoral manner, it is unacceptable. There are those who completely withdraw from it, today, they are marginalized. And there are those who try to fight within it, but above all try to do what we have been saying for a while, that is to say, to change the rules of the game to reduce their power, because their power has become exorbitant and threatens the very structures of our democracy, that is where we are. I cannot tell you if a candidate can win without social networks, or at least that it can be a free choice. What I know is that we must do everything, hence all the work that is being done, so that it is not social networks or a few who will have the best organized or most interested use of social networks who can win this election.

What we have seen in several democracies is that there was a very strong bias for a few ideologies and people who were very close to certain platform holders, and we see that there is a complacency today and an orientation of some of these social networks. On interference, you have perfectly described things and I believe that it does not call for remarks from me, except to say that, after all, we are all subject to forms of interference because powers can attack the basis of information. And even if the proximity, everything you described, protects, the capacities for interference are multiple. So, they can be done through cyber actions on your own platforms, and we all have this vulnerability, in any case, it evolves each time, but it can also be done through the raw material you manipulate every day, even if, depending on it, you have more means, by the proximity and independence that is yours, to act.

Finally, Master, you are absolutely right about things. I have already mentioned it a bit. I think that in any case, there cannot be legal systems and judicial systems that function like ours, as in any democracy, if we do not go to the end of a system of holding accountable those who either threaten the organization of the judicial system, or utter anti-Semitic, racist, discriminatory content, that is to say, if, fundamentally, we consider that an important space of dialogue and life in society has exited the law.

And so today, the lifting of anonymity is part of the responses in my eyes. The ability to pursue much more quickly and effectively is part of the response. And the ability to pursue platforms much more simply and quickly, as one can do with press titles, is the only way they can engage in real moderation. And for a year now, let’s be clear, we have seen a regression in moderation from these platforms. I am worried, and I just want to finish on this point, about what you said regarding the legal professions, which corresponds to what the doctor and the professor said about the medical professions. Today, it is becoming a public trial in real time. And you see that all of this brings us back, I would say, very far back from an anthropological point of view. It is like a process, if I may mention it, of decivilization that we are experiencing. The process of civilization involves many things that have taught us decency, respect, the exchange of words, the structuring of a democratic space, respectful and otherwise. And now, as all of this is being reinstalled, I said it to make the metaphor: we are in balaclavas, there are no more rules of the game, it is the one who shouts the loudest who is right. These are systems of very high gregariousness and violence, meaning we are seeing crowd phenomena that stone in a matter of hours. So afterwards, we can always fight the battle, but the harm is done. And you were right to remind us of the time and energy required, and that is what you do every day to remove false information. I do not want to live in a system where, in a way, we go backward, that is to say, where we reward gregarious behavior, where we reward collective violence and what it can trigger.

Speaker

So, why are we talking about education? Because education is important. Young people today navigate without filters, without discernment, on social networks that push them information that is not always verified, unfortunately. So, how do we train the citizens of tomorrow in information? How do we give them the necessary discernment to navigate knowledgeably on social networks?

We will look at some figures, as usual, to clarify the ideas. 70% of 11- to 18-year-olds use at least 3 social networks intensively. One in five middle school students has already experienced cyberbullying. This is another dimension of social networks that should not be overlooked. And 80% of French people believe that access to social networks should be banned for children under 14.

Mr. President, this is the topic we discussed earlier. So, always the same mechanism, we will rely on a local witness.

Speaker

So, indeed, I have been teaching for 15 years, and I have observed changes in the way my profession occupies me, which I will present to you from a personal perspective, at the risk of a bit of caricature.

First, students are increasingly fatigued, struggling more and more to concentrate, which is confirmed by studies, as noted by recent studies, which, as you said, Mr. President, link this to a growing use of social networks, but, as you also specified, a link does not necessarily mean causation, and that is worth exploring.

I also observe, at the same time, a rise in school anxiety, particularly in high school, especially since the implementation of continuous assessment in 2019 for the baccalaureate. A recent study shows that in 2023, 53% of high school students report feeling stressed, even outside of exam periods, which can weigh on their capacity for discernment. And then, I also observe students who are more connected to information, more curious about what is happening in the world. This may also be related to the use of social networks. 80% of 11- to 17-year-olds connect daily, and 66% of them seek information there every day. This is not without risks, as we know that false information spreads 6 times faster on platforms like X than verified information. And this has been stated by many. It is because algorithms favor content that captures the viewer's attention, that plays on emotion, that polarizes, even if it distorts reality and traps us in filter bubbles.

A small aside, do not overly blame the younger ones, as studies also show that they are much less likely to share false information than their elders. But social networks, indeed, by spreading misinformation, contribute to undermining the trust we can have in traditional information channels, media, researchers. And it is partly what led me, 4-5 years ago, to begin a work of demystifying pseudo-historical statements on social networks, which requires presenting the methods of historians, whose expertise, like that of other researchers, is absolutely essential to combat misinformation. And so, I do this with the following perspective.

The idea is to help as many people as possible, along with other videographers, of course, to distinguish ethical work, based on a transparent method, from a narrative that instrumentalizes the past to, for example, whitewash the genealogy of certain political families. Follow my gaze. I receive some threats because of this, but it seems to me that the most serious danger lies in the accumulation of hacks, which the academic world is subject to, statements that cast suspicion on the academic world to better free oneself from its conclusions, to better circumvent reality.

We must, of course, Mr. President, as you said, take a critical look, a critical doubt, on research. But be careful of everything that fuels distrust, be careful of statements that would accuse, for example, the academic world of being guilty of splitting the Republic in two, as you said, Mr. President, in 2020. The school is also, of course, precious for fighting against misinformation. It offers and relies on numerous tools to do so, media and information education, disciplines that develop useful skills, critical analysis, documentary research, experimentation, but it also faces a number of limitations.

Not all teachers are trained to combat misinformation. When one does not belong to the digital generation, one can legitimately find it dangerous to address the question of the limits of social networks in front of students who are hyper-connected. The structural increase in the use of contract teachers means fewer teachers in proportion who are likely to be trained in these issues. We also have problems of disparity in access to digital equipment from one territory to another. Addressing these issues takes time since the heaviness of the programs does not always allow it, Mr. President. And there is also the question of human resources, which is affected by the declining attractiveness of the profession, salaries still below the OECD average, and unfilled positions every year at each school year start.

Mr. President, to conclude, I believe that training future citizens in discernment requires teaching them that a truth must be proven and that a mistake must be acknowledged. We often hear that school is a sanctuary, but it is not a fortress. When students finish their classes, they continue to educate themselves in the ethics of truth by observing their parents, by observing public figures. And from what they tell me, Mr. President, recent sequences, particularly those from Bétharram, undermine their trust in the ability of political leaders to tell the truth, and they are not alone. 88% of French people, according to ELABE polls in 2025, believe that political leaders are not honest. And Mr. President, it seems to me that this specific point should not be a blind spot in the reflection you are beginning, at the risk, otherwise, of undermining the school's ability to transmit an ethics of truth. I therefore have two questions, Mr. President.

First question: Will you give the school the means to achieve your new ambitions? Second question: Will you enshrine in law the exemplary nature of public speech as an enforceable standard, as the Welsh are currently doing?

Speaker

I am 17 years old and I am a student at the Or Torah high school, in the final year. So, Mr. President, in your opinion, are democracies still capable of protecting their citizens against the trivialization of racism and anti-Semitism on social networks? An anti-Semitism that, unfortunately, my classmates and I regularly face and whose intensity has significantly increased over the past two years.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. At a time when everyone is confronted with sometimes misleading information, as we have said during these two hours of debate, should we not make digital discernment a great national cause, on par with reading? Thank you.

Speaker

I am in the final year. As we have seen, we have seen that many high school students are very stressed due to, in particular, the reforms that took place in 2019 and that their screen time has significantly increased. I wanted to ask you what measures you plan to take to prevent students from being trapped in filter bubbles that could increase anxiety?

Speaker

I am currently in the final year and I am therefore taking the specialty course in CGSP. In this specialty, we are fortunate to work more on our critical thinking, particularly on current events or even on historical facts. But this work allows us to strengthen our discernment and thus to warn and protect ourselves against misinformation. But unfortunately, this is not the case for all high school students. So, how could we expand this teaching to all students?

Speaker

This question is also related to the second theme. Do you think we should teach in school how to recognize content produced by AI and how to protect ourselves from it? Thank you.

Speaker

I am an elderly woman, but a former school doctor. And it is in this capacity that I ask the question. The question of meaning has been posed to me throughout my 44 years of professional life. And it seems to me that this is an important question and that everything that is said or requested should be accompanied by this question of meaning, but in a simple and pedagogical way. There you go. Thank you.

Speaker

More than a question, I would first like to bounce back on what you said regarding the economic model of social networks. You explained it very well. And at the base of this economic model is the ability to capture the attention of our youth. And there, unfortunately, I must say that I feel we are losing the battle. Because the attention of young people has turned away from knowledge. Simply because knowledge has become accessible. It is just a click away. And this is where I see a fracture beginning to establish itself, between those who will have their GPS to navigate this ocean of accessible, free knowledge, and the others.

And so, instead of remaining on the defensive, my reflection is to say, ultimately, why not use the same weapons as social networks, namely algorithms, namely digital technology, namely mathematics. We have good mathematicians in this country, to try to support our young people, especially those who are unfortunately distanced from the codes of school, since we know today that a number of homework help platforms, funded by parents, use artificial intelligence to the point of having AI tutors, today, accessible.

The National Education system, I believe, should develop a tutoring plan using artificial intelligence within a framework, for example, that could be educational cities, because there is a fracture that is beginning to establish itself and it is a battle that is not yet over. Perhaps we can still have our final word.

Speaker

I represent the FCPE Occitanie and the CESER Occitanie. So, I participate in this as a representative of the Federation of Parents' Councils. And I was thinking while listening to the debate that it was really great to have been here this morning, that you know the issue well and that reassured me. And I also thought that as parents, we are alone and at the same time, there are many questions about how to best support our young people and that I was very happy to hear these young people tell us a bit more.

And regarding everything you said, I thought why not suggest to him to turn the vicious circle of platforms into a virtuous circle. Why not seek to establish a label for an educational platform that could help us build education in critical thinking as well, and why not also seek funding, because you saw, it is not today the federation that asked you for resources. But we know well that it is the nerve of war, so it was also important to think about it.

My question is short. Do you think that social media should be banned for young people under the age of 15 in relation to education and social media on this issue? Thank you.

Speaker

Well, Mr. President, many questions from young people. Thank you. Young people, you are great. It is up to you to answer all these questions and concerns, Mr. President.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. First of all, regarding the observation, we made it at the beginning, you all articulated it well, you reminded us, even if we need to continue to consolidate things and establish all the causalities, I believe there is now a convergence of views to say that social media, at least in high doses as we have today for the youngest, is not a good thing. And we have, in a way, a generation that has suffered from all this, one or two, if I may say, that has gone through this without any real guidance being given, without any public discourse. And it is true, to reiterate a point that was made, that we have also left many families alone, as you just said, and many young people alone.

I have been struck in several debates that I have started or that I have had in recent years with young people, to see the great difference we have between our high school students and our middle school students. But what is terrible is that we have high school students who actually have much more maturity than we might have thought or than we had at their age, because they have sometimes experienced excesses in middle school. And so, they went through a moment where they themselves, in a way, saw that they were spending 5 hours, 6 hours and asked their parents or their teachers to regulate them and went back. But it still involves real suffering. But what is said about cyberbullying, which often continues bullying at school — and here, I will not go back over everything we have done collectively in recent years to fight against all forms of bullying — everything I could say earlier or what was recalled by Mr. must lead us to protect.

So my first point, which is a clarification if it was not one regarding the last question, I think we need to move towards, indeed, a digital majority age — and we have built a legal framework that allows us to do this — and impose on platforms to verify age to ensure. And we are indeed rather on 15 years old, before 15 years old, we do not have digital majority, and therefore, we cannot go on these networks.

I think that today, there is rather a consensus, this is what comes out of the screen commission, etc., and this is what I hope we can move towards. The debates will enlighten us and we need a sufficient number of European states to do this. But in the legal architecture, I do not want to be technical, that we have built, Europe recognizes that it is up to each country to define its digital majority, and it has built, especially since last July, thanks to this famous directive on digital services, the possibility of making age verification mandatory on networks. And we know how to do it technically, this is what has been done for pornographic sites, for example. So, we impose on them to verify whether it is below or above 18 years old.

So, we can say, if neighboring countries do not follow, there are VPNs, I speak under the control of people more expert than I am, but if we manage to engage as many as possible, at least we create something. But above all, we no longer leave families alone. Because the day we ban under 15s, there is no parent who cannot know. Once we have said that, and I will try to address the questions in a logical order, I do think, and that was the third question, that we had a problem understanding it. At the same time that we ban, we must educate. And so, you are absolutely right to say that what we are building is a capacity to educate.

So, we already have some elements. I speak under the control of rectors, former rectors, teachers who are here, and we have already put in place elements on critical thinking. We already have, precisely, in civic instruction, civic and citizen questions, things that exist. We have in certain majors, certain options, more training. This was what one of your colleagues mentioned. Nevertheless, what we are doing in parallel is to strengthen in middle and high school the training in critical thinking and therefore the training to distinguish between the true and the false, to have a method, to understand precisely everything we have been discussing for some time about the Internet, to train on artificial intelligence, even if that also requires that there be technological transparency, because you can be trained to distinguish the true from the false, and when you are sometimes confronted with an AI that is very well made, if you have not imposed rules that state whether it is written by the AI or by Sora or Sora 2, you can be fooled. But in any case, our objective, at the same time as we would ban for those under 15, is that there is enhanced training in critical thinking, in the ability to discern, in the methods, precisely, to be able to support the youngest.

And in this context, obviously, then, it goes far beyond the question of youth and it is somewhat related to what we were saying earlier, we must not simply educate, but we must toughen our texts, which we have started to do in the fight against racism and anti-Semitism. In truth, these texts exist. We have penalized racist and anti-Semitic remarks and behaviors. The great difficulty is, for the reasons we have mentioned, it is very hard to prosecute, first because there is no responsibility, in any case, there are several actions and several lawyers who have launched actions against the platforms that allow these contents to exist. What do we do today when faced with an anti-Semitic attack? And you rightly said that they have increased a lot in recent months, not just in France, but in France too. In truth, in almost all Western democracies. 1) We have the Pharos platform that we have set up, which is supposed to see the site. I know, they are not numerous enough.

So even if they use AI, they go much further and they multiply. But above all, we have a problem with the responsiveness of the platforms. And so, today, one of the points on which we are strengthening the game is to better equip Pharos, to toughen the texts and to penalize much more quickly a platform that does not remove content. But today, by law, we have created a system where normally the platform reports that there is an anti-Semitic content that must be removed. Is this done in 100% of cases? No.

The second point, then, we take actions against individuals. We obtain them, but it is very slow, the lifting of anonymity. So, all this is saying: we have the foundations, but they are not efficient and operational enough. So, the fight we must wage in parallel and what we will do is to be much more radical in imposing, indeed, a system of responsibility, control, removal of these contents. And what we must do is that we must remove them immediately and we must pursue immediately. But I assure you, we will not give up on this fight.

On cognitive bubbles and anxiety. On this, if we ban social media for those under 15, we solve this problem. If at the same time we educate and support the entry into social media and critical thinking, what we will seek to do is to have adolescents and then young adults who, being better educated, will realize that there is this risk of bias related to the algorithm and others.

So, our idea also, our will, is to educate, but not just our young people. We can see that we have a civic-citizen issue to re-educate everyone on the risks of a non-transparent algorithm, to equip ourselves with the right regulation and to have trusted third parties, and therefore, to get everyone out of these cognitive bubbles. The key will go through training, education, but also through the prohibition before a certain age where one cannot have this perspective. I insist on one point. We have been talking about social media for a while. But you mentioned filters in your question. Even the messaging systems we sometimes use, and we will need to go into this level of detail in the coming months, they create these bubbles. I will give you a very simple example. WhatsApp is not, formally speaking, a social network. It is a secure messaging service. It turns out that we use WhatsApp, sometimes even teachers use WhatsApp to communicate with parents, and sometimes there are student groups. With, now, the AI operator that is in WhatsApp, try the experience, by the way, it immediately submits questions to you. It submits filters. Are you stressed, do you have a problem with your next assignment? And so, you are already in a cognitive bubble, and the interaction with the artificial intelligence on WhatsApp that your young people may have is already this filter that you mentioned. And so, in the regulations that we will have to put in place, we will have to address this point to protect against this risk. In this context, alongside the prohibitions and support, there is education, and you have recalled it.

Today, the fight is totally asymmetric. Because even if we add this or that hour of teaching, when we see the exposure time, we are losing. So, that is why we need to regulate and remove for the youngest, we need to protect, we need to make this digital pause much stronger, not just at school. We have done this, there, on mobile phones in middle school, and we are in the process of implementing it, but at home too, through this prohibition. This requires, as you said, to continue things. So, you asked me two questions. The first, on the school and its means, yes, we must continue. What we have done over the past three years is just the beginning of a catch-up. So, we have made the largest increases for teachers since 1990. We have made the largest increases with the teacher pact and with the base that has been increased for everyone. Is it enough to settle all accounts? The answer is no, because you said it.

So, in fact, we simply have a system, I do not want to be technical and this is not the debate of the day, but we had a form of collective pact that no longer works. The collective pact was: we hire you, you are much less well paid than your colleagues. There is a vacation system that works differently than for your colleagues, and you have an average retirement that is younger and better than your colleagues in Europe. That is no longer enough to be attractive enough and it is no longer accepted. And that is why we started to increase our teachers, but it is a catch-up effect, that we have put in place the pact to also engage more, that we must continue all this work. Alongside that, the heart of the battle for success is the training of teachers. And my response to your second element is that beyond the contractual or statutory question, which is a question that is justified, even if the feedback is not always the same on the ground, and if we have teaching models where you have contract teachers throughout their careers, the Singaporean model which is always taken as an example, there is no status as such. There are very different models with medium-term contracts. The key, and it is shown in all studies, is the training of teachers. And it is true that we had sacrificed this training far too much in recent decades. And for me, it is the heart of what I will be able to do in the next 18 months. It is precisely what we have put in place to much better train our teachers, among other things, in these practices, because if we do not train teachers, we cannot ask them to practice it. And so, what is being put in place right now and what must be deployed is absolutely fundamental to succeed in this fight.

Behind all this, therefore, I believe I have also answered on the expansion of education to students. I wanted to perhaps, in answering the question also about the meaning of what you said, say how we can complement all this. Social media is not just a bad thing. I have been saying this for a while. We must regulate, we must protect, but at the same time, the artificial intelligence that we have talked about incidentally, if we put it at the service of a project that is ours, can have many virtues. And today, when I look at our education system, there too, studies show that it is becoming increasingly unequal because we have, for certain programs where there is selection in the first cycle of university, more and more families accessing private preparatory schools or private education.

Can we accept this sustainably? No. At the same time, we see that tutoring, which is done using a mix of human beings and artificial intelligence, is what allows students who are sometimes struggling to have the best opportunities to return to an average level or even go beyond that through better individualization of teaching when they have difficulty acquiring certain skills or when differentiation is needed. And so, this is also a message of optimism for the younger ones who are here and for all of us; if we use artificial intelligence well, putting it at the service of obviously scientific projects, but also educational ones, it is something that can help our school to improve significantly, to enhance educational performance, and to improve student support, but it must be in service of a humanistic vision of our school and used wisely. We have launched research projects with the Collège de France and others. There are also several experiments being conducted. This is what we are currently incubating, but the goal is that we can gradually disseminate it, because it will also be a lever for very profound transformation for everything we are discussing. And so, here too, we have a source that should allow us to move forward.

Now, I would like to conclude on the question of meaning in perhaps a more positive way. Everything we are discussing and doing is not lost if we mobilize and share together, well not everyone because unanimity is not a solution, but if consensus is created, a deep conviction is formed, that there is a path towards the better. I believe it was one of you who spoke about reading. All of this should remind us that one of the key points for both learning and our emancipation is reading. AI, like social networks, is a wonderful example that we can become very intelligent by reading a lot, because they are just reading machines. These models that fascinate you are just reading machines. Simply, we must not let others do it for us. And so, putting reading back at the heart of family education and teaching is, in my eyes, a key point, because it is what allows us to build.

The second point, the whole struggle we have been discussing: the functioning of our democracy, the protection of our children, and how we help them learn to become informed citizens, the independence of our country and protecting ourselves against interference, is exactly the existential struggle of the Republic. And so, the meaning to give to everything we are doing is exactly the meaning of the republican adventure. We must learn to recreate Republicans. So yes, we need to reinvest in our schools and the training of teachers. Yes, we need exemplarity. I do not know the Welsh model, so I will look into it. But in any case, from the moment we recreate a model of responsibility, you have heard me say this for a while, I am very much in favor of it; I believe that all those who hold authority must be exemplary. And so, I will look at the Welsh model. You have my commitment, in any case, that we need to have a system where, if we call into question the responsibility of those who lie, those who hold authority must be exemplary.

So there is no misunderstanding here. But everything we have been saying for a while is about learning to recreate Republicans. And so, the foundation is to have a school that transmits certainties and knowledge before critical thinking. Secondly, that transmits critical thinking. Thirdly, a society that protects its children before a certain age, I think 15 years. Then, a society that believes in science and progress. This is how the Republic was constituted, which protects its information infrastructures by shielding them from the property of a few or from economic systems that are not compatible with democracy, and creating the means and ways for a free forge of public opinion.

We will have agreements and disagreements in respect, but ensuring that each side is confronted with opinions, but will have a relationship to truths that will be established through a dialectic and verification processes that are transparent. What is currently threatened, because we are allowing it to happen, is simply the foundations of our Republic and our democracy. And so, the struggle we are engaged in, from the youngest in school, through the fight for science, the press, and the functioning of democracy in elections, is a struggle that has much to do with the struggle of the first Republicans.

I do not want to be longer, but that is why today's debate was very important to me. It will continue to be held. All the suggestions and remarks you may have made, I have aggregated them in these coming weeks, and I will report back, also in a very transparent manner, so that we can then develop, at the beginning of next year, something that is the subject of the broadest consensus, but that allows us to move forward and be this great Republic, this great democracy that is France. In any case, I thank you, and I thank the group La Dépêche for its welcome, the organization of this work, these debates, and the work done every day for more than 150 years.

Speaker

On behalf of the entire community of La Dépêche, I express our pride in having organized this debate. It was of very high quality, and I want to thank each and every one of you; it is a privilege, and you, Mr. President of the Republic, who have responded as you know how to do to all the questions. I think our great elders, Jaurès, Clemenceau, Gambetta, Jaurès wrote the letter, as we have talked a lot about school, Jaurès wrote the letter to the teachers in La Dépêche du Midi, but they must be proud of us, and we are very proud to have received you and to have organized this magnificent debate. Thank you all.