European Council of March 21 and 22, 2024.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

6 May 2026 · European Council

Context
Macron addressed press at the conclusion of the European Council on March 21–22, 2024, summarizing decisions on Ukraine support and European defense.
Main themes
Support for Ukraine, European defense and sovereignty, military aid and procurement, European unity, frozen Russian assets, European defense industry, strategic autonomy, Ukraine accession and financial aid, European Peace Facility, defense spending and investment, Versailles agenda, EIB defense financing
Duration
~57 min
95th percentile
Words
6,856
95th percentile
Sentences
348
96th percentile
Readability
50
64th percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
2.99
47th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 37%36%
  • Geopolitical 33%32%
  • Institutional 18%18%
  • Ceremonial 10%9%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

348 sentences in 64 paragraphs

Hello everyone. Ladies and gentlemen, I am pleased to see you again at the conclusion of this European Council, which has been intense with many structural issues for European sovereignty, but where the convergence that has emerged is, in my eyes, also a strong element of this Council itself.

We first had an exchange following a discussion with the Secretary-General of the United Nations, the President of the Parliament, and then an expression from President ZELENSKY.

We had an initial round of discussions on Ukraine and security and defense issues. After the Paris conference on February 26, our Weimar-format meeting in Berlin, which took place last Friday, the Europeans have clearly conveyed a message of unity and determination during this Council to support Ukraine, I quote our conclusions, for as long as it takes and as intensely as necessary, so that Vladimir PUTIN's Russia cannot win this war. This is a reaffirmation of our objective, but also a determination in terms of duration and intensity. There is unity among the 27 and a clear determination to support Ukraine on all fronts, over time, contrary to everything that has been said about a supposed European fatigue. On the contrary, more than ever, we have shown an awareness of what this war means for Europe. For us, it is a matter of security and, of course, it is the sovereignty of Ukraine that is primarily at stake. But also the security of all Europeans and our strategic autonomy in the long term. After the decision to open accession negotiations with Ukraine in December, and then after the agreement of February 1 to grant financial aid of 50 billion euros over 4 years to support reconstruction, we have focused European action on military support.

We have therefore decided to do more and differently, notably by mobilizing an additional 5 billion euros for our collective military support within the framework of the Support Fund for Ukraine under the European Peace Facility. This is good news and marks the reform of the EPF, which will evolve from a logic of arms transfer to a logic of joint procurement, primarily from the European defense industry. We have also decided to accelerate efforts to use the revenues generated by frozen Russian assets, including to direct them towards military support for Ukraine. The European Council has also decided to move forward to massively strengthen European defense capabilities. After years of underinvestment, we have collectively chosen to reverse the trend to strengthen the resilience of our armies' supply chains and prepare for the future. We indeed want to give Ukraine the strategic and industrial depth it needs, but also, in doing so, to give the European Union the strategic autonomy it aspires to. In March 2022, we set the Versailles agenda, which was precisely to define the content of this strategic autonomy in technological and military terms. We began under the German presidency and concluded under the French presidency the strategic compass. Today, Europeans are fully implementing these fundamental texts and accelerating efforts to reduce their dependence and enhance their capabilities. First, by clearly affirming the principle that we, Europeans, need to produce more and build a defense industry that allows us to supply ourselves, which is a small Copernican revolution since for the past few decades, we have lived with an implicit understanding that Europeans invested insufficiently but always bought from outside. In any case, we have acknowledged that this logic is changing, and we have equipped ourselves with ambitious and innovative instruments to develop the European defense industrial and technological base. The strategy for the European defense industry and the accompanying support program, known as EDIP, which has been presented by the Commission under the impetus of Commissioner BRETON, constitutes a solid foundation, first, to meet the commitments to increase defense spending and invest more and faster to also increase the access of the defense industry to public and private financing, including from the EIB. And to also encourage joint procurement programs and address capability gaps by promoting synergies between national and European defense planning, as well as with joint defense investments, R&D, and industrialization, joint markets, and strengthening the resilience of the European defense industry on innovation issues and others. Defense markets favoring access to industrial chains and joint investment in skills and training.

We must now move forward and dedicate the necessary resources, beyond the 1.5 billion euros decided on February 1 in the revision of the multiannual financial framework. There are several proposals beyond the current budget of the Union, including eurobonds, the use of revenues from frozen Russian assets, or, as today, asking the EIB to adapt its lending policy to the security and defense sectors to increase investment and trigger more private investments. We have asked the Commission to assess all these options for mobilizing financing to have proposals by June. And it is in June that we must finalize innovative financing and additional funding to increase this collective defense spending effort.

The second major topic that was discussed is that of the Middle East. Regarding Gaza, I commend here the clear and united message from the European Council on the urgency that is ours, with the call for an immediate and lasting ceasefire and sufficient humanitarian access in the face of the imminent risk of famine in Gaza, which is unjustifiable. The unconditional release of all hostages, including our three compatriots. I reiterate here, France does not abandon its children, and we stand with them and their families. We have collectively urged the Israeli authorities not to undertake ground operations in Rafah, which would only worsen an already catastrophic humanitarian situation, as more than a million Palestinians are displaced in Rafah. This message, we carry to the European Council and in all international forums. This is why, since October, France has mobilized to ensure that the Security Council takes its responsibilities. The Security Council must now speak out on an immediate ceasefire and humanitarian access. After the veto imposed by Russia and China a few minutes ago, we will resume based on the French draft resolution at the Security Council and work with our American, European, and Arab partners in this direction to find an agreement.

The European Council also recalled the need to continue work on the reforms that the European Union needs for itself. In parallel, and even independently of the enlargement process, and in accordance with the guidelines we set in Granada. This work will be included in a roadmap by summer. Based on the Commission's assessment of the progress made, the European Council also decided to acknowledge the opening of accession negotiations with Bosnia and Herzegovina, with the understanding that this opening will be effective once certain conditions are met. This decision sends a clear signal; the future of the Western Balkans is, in our view, within the European Union, and we are determined to consolidate the European anchoring of Bosnia and Herzegovina so as not to leave them alone in the Balkans in the face of the appetites and influence of foreign powers. In a country marked by the scars of war that received the signal sent by Europeans with enthusiasm last night, it is now up to the Bosnian leaders to implement the necessary reforms if they want the accession process to advance quickly. This is a process based on the own merits of the candidates. We expect tangible progress from Bosnia on preserving a favorable environment for civil society, media, freedom of expression, improving the functioning of the judicial system, and combating corruption and organized crime.

This morning, we were also able to draw conclusions on agriculture. And this Council has allowed us to respond very directly to the European crisis of our agricultural model that has manifested in many countries, including France. And I want to thank the President of the Commission and the Commission for acting quickly to respond to the requests we made as early as February, which have had very concrete responses. First, around the issues of simplification. Indeed, the proposals made by the Commission last week regarding what are called the environmental conditionalities of the CAP allow for reducing the administrative burden related to controls and offering more flexibility to farmers. And thus, in very concrete terms, what was requested regarding pastures, what was requested regarding fallow land by France has been addressed in the responses given by the European Commission and are real elements of simplification and great pragmatism that will affect our farmers, that touch our agriculture right now. It is also a way to reaffirm our confidence in farmers to better support them in the transition to an agriculture that meets the challenges of climate and biodiversity, which simultaneously ensures our agricultural and food sovereignty and must be implemented in a much simpler and more flexible manner on the ground. And so, in essence, I reiterate here, for our agriculture, the message must not be to abandon all our anchors. That would be a step backward. We want to ensure a transition that is essential for our agricultural model. We are committed to our food and agricultural sovereignty, but we want to do so with much more pragmatism, flexibility, and adaptability on the ground. And the responses provided by the Commission go in this direction. At France's initiative, the European Council has requested and obtained to move forward without delay on 4 concrete areas. First, to adopt all short- and medium-term measures to lighten the administrative burden and simplify the CAP, in very simple terms, that is pastures, fallow land, and other issues. Second, to strengthen the position of farmers in the agri-food economic chain to ensure them a fair income. This is what I had called a European EGAlim. And so, very concretely, in the proposals from the Commission that will be implemented immediately, there is the intention to ensure a fair income for our farmers, to combat unfair practices and European purchasing groups, and to also have an observatory for the proper functioning of prices in the chain, from production to processing to distribution. The third element is to ensure fair competition, based on rules in international agreements as well as in the internal market. It is this desire for fair competition that we advocate and that our farmers demand. Fourth, it is to guarantee a protective balance for European agricultural sectors regarding autonomous trade measures for Ukraine. And we have had conclusions that will allow us to respond to the requests that were made by Poland, several other countries, and also our own, which will allow for regulatory measures in certain sectors in the face of the excesses we have observed, which destabilize. For example, in the poultry, egg, sugar, or soft wheat sectors, we have regulatory measures that will allow us to better control things while allowing the Ukrainian agricultural sector to function, but without speculative practices or destabilizations.

The Council, and you can see how rich it was, also addressed the issue of migration. Our common priority is the implementation of the pact on asylum and immigration and the robust and effective European framework that we have put in place. It allows for safer external borders with mandatory procedures and also rapid return procedures with principles of solidarity and responsibility clearly implemented. This pact has been accompanied by a strengthening of our operational means for border management, combating criminal networks, human trafficking, or emergency responses to crises, and the European Council has clearly supported efforts to intensify our dialogue with countries of origin and transit. This is the whole meaning of the comprehensive strategic partnership that the European Commission has just signed with Egypt. And the European Union is now in a position to use all the levers at its disposal to obtain more cooperation.

We finally had a Eurozone summit this morning. It allowed us to revisit the major challenges facing our Europe. And fundamentally, the discussion focused on what I see as the triple challenge that Europe faces economically. First, if we look at the figures over the past 20 years, there has been a decline in wealth creation compared to the American continent, which is clearly linked to underinvestment in high technologies and innovation, and a lack of diffusion of innovation in our economy, resulting in lower productivity gains than in the American continent. The second element is the fact that we are facing essential financing shocks: climate transition, digital transition, artificial intelligence, and defense financing, which will require additional investments, while the main factor behind the decline compared to the United States is already the lack of public and private investments in the European continent compared to American competitors. Then, the third element is that the European model is currently experiencing a crisis, obviously linked to the disruption of its energy model, a direct consequence of the war launched by Russia, and to Chinese overcapacities, even though it was an important export market for our Europe. This situation compels us to move much faster and more forcefully towards the need for public and private investment in innovation and productivity-creating sectors. That is why we have mandated COREPER to advance on the capital markets union, which, as you know, unfortunately is progressing far too slowly. And so, we obtained an agreement at our request for a clear mandate for the April Council, as it is at the heart of the competitiveness of the European continent and particularly of the Eurozone.

The second thing is to revisit regulatory elements concerning financial actors that are currently blocking equity investment, particularly from our large insurers. And then to advance beyond what we have already done regarding the actions of the European Investment Bank, to move forward on this much stronger and more proactive investment union that will be at the heart of our discussions. I could return to this point in the questions. But in my view, it is one of the absolutely fundamental points for the future of our European Union economically in the months and years to come. I would like to conclude this report by thanking my colleagues, the Taoiseach of Ireland, the Prime Minister of Bulgaria, and the Prime Minister of Portugal. This was their last council around the table with us. And coming from very different political situations, I would like to pay tribute to the actions and commitment of these three colleagues and also express my support, particularly for the outgoing Bulgarian Prime Minister who has faced a difficult domestic political situation. And I want to commend the courage with which he has led reforms and actions in his country. I will now answer your questions.

Journalist

It has been a month since you called for a European awakening to help Ukraine in the face of Russia's hardening stance. Yet, the 27 have only committed to examining all options for financing arms to Ukraine. Are you disappointed by the timidity of some countries, including Germany and the Netherlands, regarding the possibility of making European loans to buy arms for Ukraine? And furthermore, do you have a reaction to the extremely violent remarks made by the Vice President of the Duma who said he "wants to kill all French soldiers who come to Ukrainian soil" in response to your recent statements and who also made homophobic remarks about your Prime Minister? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Well, regarding the remarks, I will not engage in a series of comments and responses. I think their indignity is sufficient not to comment on them. I will simply express my astonishment at such nervousness and lack of composure among Russian officials. It says a lot about the collective situation of the leaders of that country. As for our collective action, I want to argue the opposite of your reading. Indeed, as early as February 16, I tried to qualify the situation, perhaps in a darker way than many saw it and than we ourselves saw it in France until then. This is what I called the necessity of a wake-up call, on February 16, with President ZELENSKY. This was linked to the very rapid evolution of the situation on the ground and the rather negative geopolitical uncertainties for the Ukrainians. Not due to a lack of investment or commitment from Europeans, but rather due to uncertainties elsewhere. On February 26 in Paris, during the conference on Ukraine, we marked significant advances. A new coalition for our deep strike capabilities, the endorsement by all countries of the Czech initiative which until then had been met with skepticism and which allowed us to work collectively around it. And five concrete actions on Ukrainian soil: demining, Belarusian borders, support for Moldova, defensive cyber action, and co-production on Ukrainian soil. And I reopened what we called strategic ambiguity at the end of this council. There have since been more and more countries joining those. The Weimar format meeting we had last week allowed us to mark the union, unity, and determination of Poland, Germany, and France. And for the first time, in a text of a European conclusion, we do not simply say that we will support Ukraine as long as necessary. We formally state that we will support it as intensely as necessary. This clearly indicates that we are ready to act in response to any action taken by the Russian aggressor, which is a real change in approach.

The strategic discussion also allowed colleagues to share their reading of the situation and its gravity, and I think that is useful. It was never a question during this council to decide on additional funding because we have just done that, and I want to particularly defend my Dutch and German colleagues. Germany is the country in Europe that, from a bilateral perspective, provides the most funding; it should not be singled out. On the contrary, we should commend the effort being made. We have therefore had our bilateral supports. France has done so itself through the agreement we signed on February 16 with Ukraine. We supplemented it with funding for reconstruction, the 50 billion and various aids. And we have supplemented it in recent days with the European Peace Facility and a pocket reserved for Ukraine. So, we have not ceased in recent weeks to increase bilateral and joint funding for Ukraine and to provide visibility. What we want to do now is to say: if we need to go much further, if we need to provide even more depth, if things were to deteriorate, if other funding beyond European funding were to fall short, we need to be ready and have more radical and innovative solutions. That is what we want to do between now and June at the latest. And that is the mandate we have given to the Commission and the Council to reflect on. We will continue the work, particularly in Franco-German cooperation, on this subject. So things are progressing well, and the progress of recent weeks is considerable in terms of unity and especially in increasing our posture.

Journalist

On the agricultural issue and the restrictions on imports of Ukrainian agricultural products. You said there was an agreement among the 27 today, informal but to extend the restrictions, particularly on wheat, is that what you said, and also to extend the reference period to 2021?

If that is the case, what do you say to the comments, particularly from Ukraine, which says: "there is a bit of double talk since on one hand, you say, as you have repeated, support on all fronts for Ukraine. But now, we can clearly see that we are going backward and that we are still taking away revenue from Ukraine."

I have a second question. Madam VON DER LEYEN is therefore campaigning for the EPP group to be the next president of the Commission, since she is the EPP candidate. Will France take positions against what is in the EPP program, the Rwandan model for imports, things like that, in the campaign for the European elections? So, can you support her?

Emmanuel MACRON

So, on the first question. First, this is not our council on the details you mentioned that is formally competent. But, as you know, the text that was at the trilogue has been suspended. And so, very clearly, we have expressed this desire. There was an agreement on a text that was particularly requested by Poland and several others, on which we were, I believe, rather a mediating element, but which allows us to indeed send the signal that we need to combat excesses. Our wish is that we can reopen the text in the coming hours and find an agreement to, as you have very well pointed out in your question, have a coherent reference period and on cereals, be able to have safeguard measures that include categories that were not included until now. Let me explain. You know, we had emergency measures on sugar, eggs, and chicken that were taken to facilitate access to these products… in Ukraine, on the European market. What we have particularly noticed in recent months is that production has skyrocketed, and therefore there was a behavior of overproduction using this access and destabilizing the European market. And that is where we need to find a balance. We want Ukraine and Ukrainian producers to continue exporting in a more difficult context. That was the initial objective, and we maintain it. But we do not want a few producers, because behind them, there are also some particular interests. Sometimes, by the way, these are producers or large European groups that will take advantage of this agreement to produce in Ukraine and re-import with less stringent production rules on our soil. And so, there is a diversion of the opening we have mentioned, and we can see it in the volumes that I invite you to look at in the commission's reports. We have volumes that have multiplied by five or ten in certain categories. So, that is why we indeed want to have a reference period that takes the year 2021. Because in 2023, things had already taken off, which allows us to say, you have easier access to the European market up to a certain level that roughly corresponds to what you were doing before the war. But for the additional volumes, we are putting in place braking mechanisms because we see that some are taking advantage of it. This is very coherent, and it is entirely defensible. I explained this very well to President ZELENSKY because it is also what makes the European perspective for Ukraine and its own candidacy acceptable. Because today, Ukraine does not produce under European rules. We have given it a facilitation linked to the war. But we are eroding the acceptability of Ukraine and Ukrainian producers everywhere in the European market because it is not fair. On the question of cereals, it is a bit different. They had been subject to opening measures since 2019. Now, it is the activation of what we call safeguard clauses. And so, we indeed wish that soft wheat, in particular, which had been mentioned several times in the texts circulating, be included in these safeguard measures. There you go, it’s a bit technical, but I think it is entirely just and proportionate.

Journalist

[Off-microphone remarks].

Emmanuel MACRON

So, there has been no discussion on this subject. I am not going to do the work of the ministers, collaborators, and Parliament. But in my opinion, we are not far from this agreement. I think it is achievable, and that would help to resolve many difficulties that exist, not just in Poland, but in many European countries and here as well. That is what we are defending. In any case, that is the spirit of the text made by 27. Now, I will not commit to the details. Our wish, in any case, is that in the coming hours, we can reach this balance. After that, I will try to clarify the institutional context. The President of the French Republic does not participate in the European campaign, and France is not in this campaign. So France, as a voice, will not take part in all of this. And that is, by the way, the difficulty that everyone must be vigilant about. I would say the President of the European Commission herself, because we are in charge of institutions larger than ourselves, which lead us to have positions that manage the general interest. This is especially the vocation of the European Commission. And so there will be… each major European party will have positions to defend. And you know, I believe I understand that European political life is complicated sometimes because even those who support the EPP in France do not support Madame VON DER LEYEN. So it is more complicated than we would like to believe. So in the end, it will still be… We will see.

But all this to say that there are things that are in the EPP program that the actors of Renew and Renaissance in France will be able to defend. There are things with which we disagree, like the Randers model, to name just that example. There are things we care about: climate objectives, social transition, but also innovation, simplification. But there will be a European campaign that will take place. This must respect the proper functioning and the end of this term. And I know that both the heads of state and government, the President of the Commission, the President of the Council, and the President of Parliament will ensure this. And after the elections, in light of them, we will have institutional choices to make. There you go.

Journalist

I will rephrase my question. Do you think it is good that the President of the European Commission is the President of a party?

Emmanuel MACRON

I have always expressed my doubts about what we call the Spitzenkandidaten because we are not a system, I have already said, there are no transnational lists, and that is how we are. This hyper-politicizes a function that, institutionally, does not respond to that: it must have the validation of Parliament, but it is not the emanation of Parliament, that is the first point I care about. And the second thing is that the presidency of the Commission has a vocation to defend the general interest and therefore, it should not be over-politicized. Which, by the way, it must be recognized, has not at all been the case with this outgoing Commission. That is why I do not want to comment on the individuals or the functioning of the parties. I simply want to have statements that I believe are factual about both our texts and their spirit, and we must preserve them. I care a lot about what the Commission carries, that is to say, that it is the custodian of the European general interest and in doing so, it must rise above both parties and countries. That is its role in the game. And then the parties express themselves within the European Parliament with their competencies, their functioning as provided by our texts, and the countries defend their voice within the Council.

Journalist

Hello Mr. President. I would like to bounce back for a moment on my colleague's question. The spokesperson for the Kremlin has acknowledged for the first time that they are in a state of war and no longer speaks of special operations. How do you react, and do you fear that the Russians will go even further after adopting this semantics? My second question: yesterday, the Senate rejected the ratification of CETA; does your government plan to submit it to the National Assembly before the European elections or avoid this step and let the provisional application of the agreement continue at the European level? In the opposition, some fear a democratic denial. Thank you very much.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you for these two questions. Listen, I think the word that was used this morning, for which I remind you that not long ago in Russia, those who spoke of war were put in prison, apparently marks a dialectical change the day after the elections and goes in the direction, first of what is the reality on the ground; first and secondly, of a hardening, and I did not wait for these statements to qualify it because it is a reality. But it also says something on which we must all be lucid. And that is what has precisely founded the resurgence that I have called for and the choices we are making. Anyone who thinks that Russia will stop at Donbass and Crimea is mistaken. And by using this term, it also opens up uncertainty about Russia's military objectives. But I believe everyone shares this. I heard President BIDEN say pretty much the same thing a few days ago: "who thinks they will stop there." And that is why I continue to call on each and every one of us to think carefully. If we think that, if we see them doing this, we do not have much interest in waiting to react in the right proportion.

Then, on the Senate vote. First of all, it is a vote that has no consequences on the provisional implementation of CETA. Secondly, the government will have, with the National Assembly, to define the timetable, and they will do so in due form. I do not think at all that this has anything to do with any democratic denial since there has already been a vote that was made, and we have today a text that is progressing among the 27.

I just want to remind a few factual elements that can still shed light on the democratic debate since we are talking about democracy. First, I discovered that the socialist senators had joined the communist senators and republican senators to reject this treaty. I remind you that CETA was signed by a socialist government in France; signed. I remind you that then, in order to ratify it, we did an unprecedented work of improving this agreement with a parliamentary commission, a work that was led, among others, by Nicolas HULOT, with a commission of experts that allowed us to include in CETA provisions that resemble mirror clauses that we are asking for. This means that we obtained with Canada the beginning of these new generation agreements that we defend, which, for example, required Canada to follow the same rules as us on how to feed and process their meat, which, for Canadian beef, was a real issue because there was a distortion; we obtained these rules. So that is the framework. The people who today fight it with their hands on their hearts are those who signed it, and everyone forgets that we have largely improved it. Then, we set up a monitoring and evaluation mechanism, and I call on the French agricultural world. Is CETA good or bad for our agriculture? Look at the figures; the report is extremely clear. It is very good for milk, it is very good for cheese, it is very good for wine, it is very good for all key categories. And where there were risks because we put in mirror clauses, there was a fear about beef; they have been inhibited. So it is a very good agreement. And we are lucky to have reliable, loyal partners who believe in our relationship with Canada because those who could take resolutions against CETA would be Canadians, with us. I want them to know that we are serious people, but we must base ourselves on the facts. We can want to send a message to say: unfair trade, we are against it. Agreements when they are not well protected, when there are no mirror clauses, we will be against it. That is my position on Mercosur as it is defined today. But putting all trade agreements in the same bag is demagoguery. Why do I regret this vote, and why do I think it does not help the cause? First, it does not help our agriculture in principle, and it does not help what is our model; there is no French agriculture if there are no possible exports. So we must not go towards false ideas collectively. We must also have the courage of reality and a certain spirit of moderation. The text will progress, but after that, it is a European text that involves the 27, and I simply hope that the votes and positions of each and every one will be based on figures, on reality both on the genesis of this text and its improvements, and the reality of what it produces.

Journalist

Hello Mr. President, the public finance figures in France are not good. A significant deviation is expected to be announced on Monday for 2023. However, you have made this a matter of credibility in Europe. Will France be able to do without a new tightening this year? And furthermore, do you completely close the door to a taxation of superprofits, as some figures in your own camp have mentioned? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

So, on the point you mentioned, it is quite true, and by the way, the government did not wait for the official figures since I remind you that the first government seminar that was held by the Prime Minister precisely focused on the issue of public finances. So the Prime Minister is fully aware, along with his government, of the situation and has taken it head-on from the beginning. The situation is quite simple to characterize. There has been an acceleration in the second half of 2023, of a very strong slowdown in the European economy, especially in the eurozone. There has been a German recession in 2023; France avoids recession, but the end of the year, especially November-December, more than expected, has led to a drop in activity, which means that the deterioration of public finances is mainly linked to a loss of revenue. It will be qualified next week in detail. We will need to understand the ins and outs. That is why, without waiting for these results, under the authority of the Prime Minister, initial choices have been made to reduce state expenditures. We will need to qualify the magnitude of the adjustment that needs to be made, and then it will need to be complemented by all useful actions in public spending so that we can face this situation.

What matters to me is to keep the anchors of our macroeconomic strategy. The core of it is reindustrialization and job creation. I have often said, if France had the activity rate and employment rate of Germany, we would have almost no public finance problems. So we need to keep this line. That is why pension reform, unemployment insurance reform, France Travail, apprenticeship reform, senior regime reform: that is the key, along with reindustrialization and investment; we need to keep it. Budgetary seriousness, and therefore we need to maintain our adjustment, with two anchors, the reduction of the debt-to-GDP ratio by 2026 and getting back below 3% in 2027, which is what we have committed to our European partners and which is good for the country while being compatible with this strategy.

And at the same time, we need to continue to maintain our good spending, if I may say so. It is the investment spending in training, the growth model, innovation, and industrialization. It is the investment in our public services, which we have greatly rearmed and which protect us externally or within our borders, including those who educate and care for us. If we keep these anchors, we have a coherent strategy, and there is a path on this. That is what the government will announce next week, and it will have to express itself. I will not preempt the technical solutions on either side.

Journalist

But to complete it, does that mean more savings this year or next year?

Emmanuel MACRON

I told you, it means that we need to see that the savings that have already been affected are part of this whole, of which we need to see the magnitude, the reason for this deviation, and to see where it comes from and who contributes to it.

Journalist

But are you ready for new savings this year?

Emmanuel MACRON

Public spending is not made up only of state spending.

Journalist

Mr. President, would it be possible to return to Gaza? If I understood you correctly, I believe you said that France will submit a new resolution to the UN. How could this new resolution succeed? Will it be written differently?

And a second question about eurobonds. We hear messages in the corridors for and against. Do you feel that the discussion is progressing, that Fruugo and Germany are a bit more positive about it?

Emmanuel MACRON

So, regarding Gaza, we have a draft resolution, which is quite right, that we are submitting and working on with several partners. I believe that this draft, if it is, as we have started to work on it with several regional partners, particularly from the Arab world, can lift the vetoes that have been expressed on the American proposal with a silence procedure. Nevertheless, what is important to note is that the United States of America has changed its position and has clearly expressed its willingness to now advocate for a ceasefire, which is a good thing for us and for the advancement of the project that is ours, and I remind you that we have been improving the text year in and year out, but that we have been pushing within the Security Council and the various resolutions for several months now. So, it is through the procedure and what we associate with it that we hope to be able to advance this text. In any case, I think this is a very important element.

On eurobonds, it is a proposal, but first, we need to move beyond the usual divisions because it is a proposal that has been made by what is normally referred to as a "frugal" state. It clearly shows the commitment of that state and the profound change that goes along with the context. I say that France's disposition has advanced in this direction. I think that is a good thing. After that, we always get into the technicalities. And so, I think that in the coming weeks we will converge. We need to define innovative instruments that will allow us to raise money in the markets to finance potentially larger war efforts than those we can finance bilaterally or through existing mechanisms. It could be eurobonds, but that term creates difficulties in several countries; this is not new. It could be mechanisms like those we had during Covid, which we built in a Franco-German manner and then endorsed by 27, which was, by putting a state guarantee, to have a common capacity for borrowing in the markets. It could be other technical mechanisms. I think the end goal is shared, that is to say, the objective of responding to this potential need. From there, we now need to work and work rather by seeking convergences than by explaining the division in a forum. So, I am not worried. I think there is a common will, there is a real convergence. And I tell you, the dynamics of the last few weeks show that the awareness is there. The convergence is there, so we will get there. I do not want to preempt the instrument; for me, it is of secondary importance. There needs to be, in any case, a common capacity to raise money in the markets.

I will take perhaps one last question?

Journalist

Hello Mr. President. I had a small follow-up to my colleague's question on Gaza. With whom precisely, you say the Arab countries? Is it only the Arab countries and which ones? And then, how ultimately to avoid a veto that seems to always come from somewhere? What is the way... it is still very narrow. What path can we take?

Emmanuel MACRON

Listen, I do not want to reveal everything about the work of our permanent representative in New York. But the work that has been ours for several months is on this subject of advancing with, in particular, a resolution made with the Jordanians; we have done a lot of work with the Emirates, etc. Advancing with several other Europeans. There has been for a long time an American reluctance. It has now been lifted. There is an alignment on a good basis of our text thanks to what has happened in the last few hours, and that is a good thing. I think that the fact that several countries in the region, including those I have mentioned and regional diplomacies with which we are working, can convince China and Russia not to veto, there you go. So, I think that would be useful as a collective effort.

There you go, ladies and gentlemen, thank you for your attention.

Good luck to all!