Press conference by President Emmanuel Macron at a farm in Martinique

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

27 September 2018 · Press conference by President Emmanuel Macron at a farm on chlordecone pollution · a farm, Morne-Rouge

Context
Macron addressed farmers and officials at a farm in Morne-Rouge, Martinique on September 27, 2018, to confront the decades-long chlordécone pesticide contamination crisis.
Main themes
Chlordécone pollution, environmental scandal, state responsibility and reparation, occupational diseases, scientific research and transparency, agricultural sector impact, Martinique and Guadeloupe, public health, soil and food contamination mapping, collective accountability
Duration
~13 min
44th percentile
Words
1,509
44th percentile
Sentences
67
44th percentile
Readability
47
53rd percentile
Grade
12.3
49th percentile
Syntax
3.02
50th percentile
Vocabulary
2.27
65th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Environmental 42%42%
  • Economic 20%19%
  • Social 18%18%
  • Institutional 14%13%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

67 sentences in 31 paragraphs

Morne-Rouge – Thursday, September 27, 2018

THE PRESIDENT: I just wanted to say a few words after the explanations and exchanges we have had, and I really want to thank each and every one of you, and thank you, Madam, Sir, for your welcome, Madam Mayor, for your welcome in your municipality.

We were able to have – as you have seen – a very rich and fruitful exchange, I am sure, because we will focus on follow-up and results.

But I wanted to come – I also thank all the state services mobilized here – to come to your farm to talk about the issue of chlordécone and finally face the facts.

Chlordécone pollution is an environmental scandal that has affected Martinique and Guadeloupe for forty years. Chlordécone has been used in several other territories, but in a much less intensive manner and with different consequences. All of this is the result of an era that is now over, where it must be said that environmental awareness was less than it is today. It was also the result of collective blindness. From which we must draw the strength to fight today against similar logics.

In essence, for years, if not decades, we collectively chose to continue using chlordécone, where other territories had stopped much earlier.

We did this also because the state, local elected officials, and economic actors accepted this situation, to say the least, accompanied it during this period, considering that stopping chlordécone would threaten a part of the farms in Martinique and Guadeloupe.

The state must take its share of responsibility in this pollution and must move forward on the path of reparation and projects. Collective reparation first, this is the meaning of the action plan implemented over the past ten years for scientific research, prevention, controls, and decontamination with real progress that has been made – I want to acknowledge all those involved – which means that today when an individual, for example, wants to know if there is chlordécone in their garden, it is the state that covers this test, it is the ARS that pays for it.

Of course, we will continue this, and I hope that the plan will be sustainable, that we can increase transparency and public knowledge each year, I will come back to this.

Then, there are individual issues, and here too, the question that arises – to put it frankly – is that of individual reparation, when it is possible. The state of scientific knowledge, which is ours today, allows us to observe the presence of chlordécone in the human body. But it does not allow us to certify that this presence has an effect on human health. However, we presume a link with premature births, delays in brain development, and other pathologies. But there is currently no established scientific evidence…

So, I would not be responsible to say there is individual reparation for all these cases, because it is not proven.

In general, we will continue to invest in scientific studies in an independent and transparent manner, to pursue these elements that would allow us to attribute certain pathologies to the presence of chlordécone in the human body. I wish that each time, there would be transparency meetings conducted by the ARS on progress in this area.

However, it is possible to advance further on the issue of occupational diseases for people particularly exposed to the molecule. I have requested that the tables of occupational diseases be updated based on scientific knowledge, prioritizing the impact of the chlordécone molecule, particularly for all those who have worked for years in the banana sector who have been much more exposed to this issue.

INSERM and ANSES will present their work by next March. Social partners will begin their work based on these expert opinions to deliver them as quickly as possible. The procedure for opening the register of occupational diseases will be initiated by the Government, starting October 2, for the general regime of occupational diseases and October 9 for the agricultural regime.

We will continue to move in this direction transparently, with scientific opinions being rendered and shared with the entire population.

Next, there is what is called the Chlordécone Plan, this multi-year plan that is essential to support economic actors and the entire territory. The state's action on the ground will be increased to 3 million euros per year, which is a 40% increase over two years. The priorities of this plan in Guadeloupe and Martinique will be to increase soil controls – you said it perfectly, President – food controls, and to complete the mapping of polluted areas.

I want to be clear here: on all agricultural exploitation areas, we must do this mapping to ensure transparency. But I also say to all our fellow citizens, it is because we are doing this mapping, this work of transparency, that we can support farmers to produce well in all territories.

We are here in an exemplary farm that shows that in all territories of Martinique and Guadeloupe, we can produce, we can do agriculture. But we must have done this mapping and transparency work to ensure that the right productions are made in the right territories.

I also wish that within the framework of this plan, we can support the establishment of young farmers, but also mechanisms for investment compensation for farmers who are victims of certain choices, precisely because of this mapping and their lands.

The revival of research on soil decontamination is also essential. Previous studies launched by the BRGM have not yet identified viable solutions. New research will be launched, particularly on biological decontamination. We have mentioned it; we already have mechanisms that exist for animals that allow for rapid decontamination. We must be able to do this and advance on soil decontamination, on the decontamination of plants.

Preparatory work for a Fourth Chlordécone Plan will be initiated by summer 2019, with broad consultation based on the model of the symposium that will take place in a few days and which will also allow, transparently and scientifically, to present the recent progress made.

Next comes the question of maximum residue limits. This is a subject that we must also face. We know that for certain species, there is a limit that is reduced to zero. For others, particularly cattle, we have tolerances that are currently higher. The new thresholds in the very short term will be stricter, in accordance with ANSES recommendations. But more broadly, I have requested that, under the supervision of the prefect, we have a profound transformation today of our collective organization.

First, we must much better control the presence of chlordécone and therefore the maximum residue limits for all foods, including and starting with imported foods. Today, there is a competitive bias related to the fact that we have this control over elements produced in the territory, but not on certain regional elements that can also be damaged. Therefore, in the control plan, we will implement this.

Second point, I wish that, collectively, we inscribe our efforts to move towards "zero chlordécone" in food. This is the only thing that makes sense. I cannot responsibly tell you whether the threshold should be 25, 30, or 40. We must aim for zero. This is exactly what you have done here by changing your structures.

So, this requires taking the time to support all our sectors, to invest, not to indemnify, but to transform, to redirect our sectors and allow everyone in the territory of Martinique, as well as in Guadeloupe, to produce quality food without chlordécone. It is feasible, it is feasible, we have seen it for absolutely all vegetable productions, if we respect the characteristics of the soils. It is feasible today for all animal production, and I emphasize this point, thanks to recent advances that will be presented at the symposium.

Simply, there must be a transition, there will be costs, and we will cover these costs within the framework of the Chlordécone Plan. This is only feasible if there is real control that protects all our farmers from unfair competition.

But I believe on this point that this objective of eliminating chlordécone from food is what we owe to all our fellow citizens and what we also owe to the agricultural ambition that we carry for Martinique as well as for Guadeloupe.

I deeply believe in the food sovereignty of the French Caribbean. This will rely on the launch and structuring of new sectors, on investment from the state, local authorities, and all professionals, on a change in collective mindset, and on our ability to ensure the best quality.

In this regard, this Chlordécone Plan is part of this ambition.

So, on this serious, serious issue, which obliges us towards all the generations we have exposed to this pollution, which obliges us towards all our fellow citizens who are currently exposed to environmental pollution, these are the decisions I wanted to announce to you and the actions we will undertake in the coming months and years.

Thank you.