Excerpts from the interview with the President of the Government on the Onda Cero radio programme "Herrera en la onda"

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

3 January 2011 · Interview on the Onda Cero radio programme "Herrera en la onda"

Context
Zapatero was interviewed on Onda Cero's 'Herrera en la onda' radio programme on 3 January 2011, discussing Spain's economic challenges at the start of the year.
Main themes
Economic situation in Spain, inflation and consumer prices, GDP per capita and quality of life, unemployment, middle class hardship, Spain's position in world economy, government responsibility, Euribor and mortgages, deficit reduction, comparison with European economies
Duration
~66 min
96th percentile
Words
7,917
96th percentile
Sentences
425
98th percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
10.0
21st percentile
Syntax
2.68
12th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

425 sentences in 146 paragraphs

President of the Government . Good morning. I'm well and pleased to see you too.

(…)

C. Herrera . When you have time to go for your regular 10-kilometre run, which I imagine is not every day, one of the reflections you may have is that the Spanish people of today are aware that we are worse off, in particular the middles classes, or that the middle class is less mixed each day, each day they lose a part of themselves; and you have seen that prices have risen almost double the level of salaries. In other words, if our mortgages are affected by a rise in the Euribor any time soon, those of us who have mortgages - which is the vast majority - are going to feel the pressure even more. What do you have to say to those who are currently thinking that their way of life is getting harder and that you, the Government, are responsible for that?

President of the Government . I would make various observations. In the first place, of course, the Government is not responsible for the rise in petrol prices, which is one of the main reasons for the increase in inflation. It's true that I should remind you that underlying inflation, which includes the majority of consumable goods, stands at 1.2%, which is virtually the same as salary increases.

And I would make a more serious observation: in 2009, the Consumer Price Index fell far more than salaries. It was said that this was very bad for the economy and that we were close to deflation, because prices were dropping excessively.

And now, except for its relationship with energy prices, inflation is going to stabilise to a level that is more normal in Spain and which, at any event, has been improving compared with the most difficult times for inflation, which were precisely the times just before the economic crisis. Remember that we reached inflationary levels of four and even four and a bit percent, with salaries increasing by two or three percent.

I would like to remind you of one thing, because yesterday Mr. Herrera, I heard you make a particular reflection in your New Year speech…

C. Herrera . And did I speak favourably about you?

President of the Government . You made an analysis about the economy, Spain, and its position, which certainly requires commenting on, because in 2009 Spain was the ninth most powerful economy in the world. It is foreseeable that in 2010 we are overtaken in overall GDP terms by countries such as Brazil and Canada; we are always competing with Canada…

C. Herrera . India and the Benelux countries…

President of the Government . No; not the Benelux countries, no. Not at any level. Nor India… And you said: "We were told that we were closer to Germany and France…". Yes, of course, the problem is that you were mixing two concepts that can't be mixed: one is the overall GDP of an economy and the other is per capita income, GDP per capita, which is what establishes quality of life.

In terms of quality of life, of course we are the twenty-sixth country in GDP per capita, number twenty-six. Countries such as Brazil, China or India are in sixtieth or seventieth place; in other words, a long way off us. Although China has a much lower GDP per capita, that does not prevent the size of its economy being considerable.

What I in fact wanted to say was that since 2003, we have reduced our GDP per capita by eight points compared with England; six points with France and two with Germany. In other words, despite the crisis, and although in 2010 we are in a period, let's say a dip in this level of proximity, each year since 2003 our per capita income has drawn closer to these countries. And let me warn you that this will come about again and we will draw closer again as of 2013.

I think it is appropriate that we should state where we are as a country: our per capita income is above the European average and we come within the group of the top twenty-six countries in the world in terms of per capita income.

C. Herrera . But it is also true that we have an unemployment level double the European Union average; and that our deficit, despite being under control and even falling, is still excessive, while the German economy has growth of close on 4%, the French economy not so much, but we are there or thereabouts in a period which, while technically not a recession - because that is not the case - but almost of stagnation if we consider that growth forecast for this year, not by the Government but by international observers, doesn't reach 1% - I don't know if this represents growth or stagnation. We may have GDP per capita, as you rightly said, that is drawing closer to that of other countries, but at the end of the day what is really important is that the whole of the European Union is overtaking us…, well except Estonia.

President of the Government . But we have to have some kind of objective criteria. If per capita income is at the level that I have just mentioned… Per capita income is the overall wealth of a country generated over the course of a year, divided by the number of inhabitants, and that, in a country like Spain, whose population has grown considerably compared with other EU countries… Hence, the growth in wealth enjoyed between 2003 and 2008, which has now slowed down. The brakes have been put on this growth and on drawing closer to these countries in 2008, 2009 and 2010, but this will be recovered in time.

But some of the figures I have mentioned: our deficit is going to be slightly above the European average in 2011, while our level of debt, which is a decisive parameter, is twenty points below the European average.

C. Herrera . … as regards GDP.

President of the Government . Of course twenty points as regards GDP - that is how it is measured. That means we are well below Germany and France.

What is - and that is where it is, and moreover this is the most serious - the most negative and worrying differential? The unemployment level, the unemployment level that has always been practically double the European average in Spain in times of crisis, and which, consequently, is a serious structural problem that has shown its ugliest side now.

But just look at the most important figure: out of almost two million jobs lost during this crisis, which is an extremely high and very serious figure, and the first to say this is the President of the Government: 70% are jobs that directly or indirectly depend on the construction industry, or the construction activity, or its ancillary industries, or on real estate services. This is indicative of our most serious imbalance and I should say that is also going to be the hardest area to put right.

I believe that economic growth is going to be positive in 2011. We are going to end 2010 with a figure for the last quarter that almost represents positive growth, as forecast by the Government - at the time the analysts forecast worse figures; we also believe that in 2011 this growth will be consolidated, that we may be able to create a certain amount of net employment in 2011 overall, but we will be far from seeing the job creation that we need, that we want; this will be slower and more progressive as the economy recovers.

C. Herrera . Unemployment figures, as you know and as I imagine you have known for some days now, show that recorded unemployment has increased by 4.5% in 2010. Theoretically December is a good month for employment, isn't it, usually?

President of the Government . Normally December is a bad month for employment. Unemployment almost always rises in December. I believe that it hasn't fallen since 2004, and with the exception of a few years between 1996 and 1999, unemployment traditionally rises in December. In other words, if unemployment falls in December this is a good figure.

C. Herrera . In other words, unemployment has increased in 2010 overall by 4.5% to stand at 4,100,000 people on the dole. We are talking here about figures from the INEM.

President of the Government . About recorded unemployment.

C. Herrera . About recorded unemployment.

President of the Government . Why didn't you mention the figure for December?

C. Herrera . Because I don't have the figure at hand. But I'll look for it now.

By sector, unemployment fell in December for agriculture by eight thousand people and in the service sector by twenty or thirty thousand people - I can't see them properly because I don't have my glasses on straight; but there are those that say that unemployment can't rise any more because there aren't any more jobs to lose.

President of the Government . Oh please! There are more than seventeen million people working in Spain. Just look at that figure,

Mr. Herrera : there are more people in work in Spain than when I came to Government in 2004. I bet that surprises you?

C. Herrera . There are also more on the dole.

President of the Government . I bet that surprises you

C. Herrera. Yes.

President of the Government . And what does that figure tell you? That figure tells you that over the last few years Spain has increased its population by five or six million people and that, in particular, its active population has increased.

And while it is true, of course, that there are many more people unemployed, it is also true that 2007 was the best year under my Government, and unemployment only stood at 7.9%. And I should remind you that despite all those people out of work at the moment, we have the highest level of social protection for the unemployed ever, with 75% of people receiving some kind of benefit, support or aid in their situation. This is the highest level of cover for those unemployed ever.

C. Herrera . With the exception of the long-term unemployed. There are families with all their members on the dole. Has that always been the case?

President of the Government . Yes, of course, but it's never mentioned. This surprises me. In the same way as no-one talks about the 426 euros in aid.

C. Herrera . I wanted to talk about that, the 426 euros in aid, because there are families that only received that 426 euros in aid. Aren't there other cans that can be opened, other subsidies that can tapped into, so that those people who only received this form of aid can continue receiving it?

President of the Government . I will repeat the figures: we have the highest level of social protection for the unemployed ever: with 75% of those out of work receiving aid. Secondly, the 426 euros of aid, I should remind you, was of an extraordinary nature and it has been extended on three occasions. It never existed before in Spain for those people who, after having received the contributory benefit for unemployment and the subsidiary benefit, were left without any benefits at all. There have always been tens of thousands in this situation in Spain, always, but no-one ever remembers them, ever. This has been the first Government to remember those who have lost their subsidiary benefit. Why? Because the crisis was very tough and jobs were being lost on a very serious basis and there were very few possibilities to find another job.

What shall we do now, where jobs aren't being shed in the same way as in 2009? We are going to turn this policy of beneficiary aid into an active policy, a training policy. That is what we are going to do for those who cease to receive a subsidiary benefit: turn to a more active policy, because now and in 2011 there are going to be more possibilities to find a job.

I should remind you that when we talk about unemployment figures, and this is sometimes forgotten even in the political debate, we are not always talking about the same people. They are not the same people on the dole. One million new contracts are signed in Spain each month. In other words, there are many people who are on the dole who subsequently find a job opportunity, who work for a while and who are then out of work again. There are others, it is true, who should concern us more - the long-term unemployed - and we want to create specific policies to help them; policies that have this ability to enable their insertion in the job market, to facilitate activity through training and qualifications.

C. Herrera .- You have gone from wanting to recreate capitalism to adopting… I know that you are going to say that you have adopted lots of social measures, but it is also true that you have adopted lots of measures aimed at social cuts. What crises of conscience does that have for you?

President of the Government . I think that this is a misquote, since the idea of recreating capitalism came from Nicolas Sarkozy. I never…

C. Herrera . A very good friend of yours, by the way.

President of the Government . Yes indeed, but with another ideological perspective. I never spoke about recreating capitalism. What I did say on more than one occasion is that a deregulated financial system generates certain pathologies that were devastating for the economy and that, hence, the financial system needs regulating; something which, by the way, has taken place; it has been regulated, it is better supervised, more controlled and financial products have been avoided which, at the end of the day, as in the case of the sub-prime mortgages, only generated what they generated.

During the mandates of the Government I lead, social policies and social expenditure has increased by 50% in Spain; the social policies of the Welfare State. I am going to explain this shortly in Parliament because I have decided to request an appearance and I am going to quote some figures so that they are brought to light, not in order to blow this Government's own trumpet but rather so that the country is aware of them and can value what we have all achieved.

For example, our expenditure on education now amounts to 5% of GDP; in other words it is at the average level of the European Union. During my time in Government, expenditure on education has risen by 48% and, for example, there are four hundred thousand more young people receiving a grant. That is social policy: four hundred thousand more young people receiving a grant. And the average benefit of these grants has risen from 570 euros to almost 900 euros. And, for example, pre-school education, from three to six years of age, is now 100% financed by the public authorities and infant education, from birth to three years of age, is now available to almost four hundred thousand children and financed by the public authorities.

That's how, I insist, the investment in education has increased by 48%. Has that happened during the crisis? Not only has that happened, but education, which is a high priority, a great investment in the future, has again increased in the 2011 Budget, and grants have also increased in this Budget.

I could also talk about healthcare, which now amounts to 6% of GDP. Can anyone doubt that that public health in a country in the major cornerstone of our Welfare State? Does anyone doubt its quality, or the universal nature or that Spanish healthcare is free of charge, or that it is acknowledged as a great healthcare system?

C. Herrera . You seem to be giving me a parliamentary answer…

President of the Government . No, I am giving you an answer that is not in the headlines, that is not quoted on a daily basis but that is at the root…

C. Herrera . You're not letting me get a word in edgeways.

President of the Government . That's impossible, you're very good at speaking up in an interview, but I would like to point that out.

In the same way as with education and healthcare, we have created the Long-Term Care Act. When we spoke earlier about social policies and families in need, Mr. Herrera, I am sure that we were all pleased that today there are six hundred thousand people who receive a benefit or a service because they are unable to on their own account, and that, even in this crisis, this serious crisis, in 2011 there are 130,000 people who are going to receive, for the first time, a long-term care benefit, and they are…

And we could go on to talk about housing, the social improvement in housing, and paternity and maternity benefits, because we have doubled the aid to the family in terms of reconciling it with work.

Are you aware that we have doubled maternity and paternity benefits, or housing benefits, or pensions, and that we have increased the purchasing power of minimum pensions by 27% during our mandates?

C. Herrera . Yes, but you have frozen pensions, civil servants' salaries have fallen and the newborn-cheque has been withdrawn. President of the Government. What you say about the civil servants is true, and furthermore, it is a big effort. And I am especially grateful to the response from these civil servants.

But what I would like to say to you is that our Welfare State and our social policies since 2004 have enjoyed significant growth in terms of education, healthcare, pensions, housing, paternity, maternity and unemployment benefits. We are maintaining all of this, even during this serious economic crisis, and that's why we enjoy strong social cohesion despite this crisis, because education, healthcare, dependency, housing benefits, unemployment benefits and maternity and paternity benefits are a very important social cushion for this country to have.

C. Herrera . So where have the one million people that Cáritas constantly attends to or the eight hundred thousand people that the Red Cross attends to come from? These are people who go to eat at welfare canteens because they have absolutely nothing. These people are no longer immigrants, those who are most exposed to the dangers of the lack of… These are now Spaniards.

President of the Government . And that's why we have a Social Inclusion Plan to which we contribute…

C. Herrera . These are now Spaniards, families and people who have always been Spaniards

President of the Government . The Social Inclusion Plan is for Spaniards; that's why we have a Social Inclusion Plan, which, together with the NGOs - by the way, some of those you have mentioned, collaborate very closely with the Government - is precisely centred around situations of social exclusion.

If you look at the data of the statistics from the National Statistics Institute on social exclusion, we are in an almost identical situation to that of the last few years. The upturn is minimal and the effort, not only on the part of the Government, but also of the local authorities - struggling as is natural to avoid these situations - is a very, very considerable effort.

That is why I say that, despite the serious economic crisis, this country has even managed to strengthen its policies on social cohesion and social protection over the last few years. And we must remember that - returning to the start of the interview - we stand as country number twenty-six in the world, out of two hundred countries, in terms of per capita income, with the European average, and that we are now faced with the major challenge of making reforms to the economy so that it is productive and we can continue maintaining the Welfare State and improving it when possible.

C. Herrera. If you agree, let's talk about the reforms to the economy because many people feel… In other words, the Government is more or less doing what it has to do, the only problem is that it has been done late. What would have happened if these measures that have been taken, which are tough and painful, since no-one likes the fact of having to reduce the wages of civil servants or freezing pension…?

President of the Government . I can assure you of that.

C. Herrera . I am certain of that. But, what would have happened if this has been done in 2009 or even at the end of 2008, when your Government and you, in particular, seemed as lost as Snow White in the forest?

President of the Government . I think the metaphor is a little over the top. I shall endeavour to be prudent.

If we put what has happened into perspective, although I know that from one day to the next it is hard to put things into perspective, the full force of the crisis really struck in autumn of 2008 when the large American banks started to fail and when the banks all over Europe - some failed - seemed like they were going to the dogs and that we were going to suffer an unprecedented crisis.

The first decision that we took jointly - because in Europe decisions are adopted jointly, and during this crisis, moreover, the international community has reacted on a united front through the G-20, where we are present, by the way, which was the mainstay of the banks - was to place the wealth of a country and the public resources at the service of the banks. Here, fortunately, not one of our banks failed and no public resources were put at their disposal, and we will be the country out of all the developed nations that has had to contribute the least resources to save its banks.

The second decision taken at a European level - and of course I cannot forget this because I have lived it on a daily basis, but you see that the analysts sometimes forget this; since the financial crisis caused a paralysis of the real economy - was fiscal stimuli, in other words, public expenditure; in other words, deficit; in other words, debt.

C. Herrera . Keynes.

President of the Government . Exactly, a Keynesian response, because everyone remembers what happened in the Great Depression: which in its first phase, in the thirties…

C. Herrera . I'm not sure that Keynes had much to do with…

President of the Government . What history remembers is that the first reaction to not give a public response in the Great Depression of the 1930s meant that it lasted for ten years, and until Keynes came along and said "public investment, public expenditure", the recovery didn't take off. I know this is arguable but the truth is that the European response and the G-20's response were to encourage public stimuli, what we did here, which moreover came from a situation of public resources… The major paradox of this crisis is that the State was in a situation of great solvency, of a surplus, of low debt when this crisis started, and where the Spanish economy had problems is in relation to private debt.

C. Herrera . Which we can now say includes public debt, which also…

President of the Government . No. Public debt, when the crisis started, was at 33-34%. The famous differential with the German bond was favourable to Spain! Our public accounts were…

C. Herrera . And look now… All private debt ends up affecting public debt.

President of the Government . And what does that mean? It means that we were in the situation with Germany, that we are currently in the same situation and that we have the capacity to recover once again.

But let's go back to the initial question. Response to the economic crisis? Public expenditure and more public expenditure - we are carrying out Plan E, we are supporting the automotive sector and industry - so that the economy and employment do not drop any more, except the construction sector where I refused to make any kind of intervention because we were fully aware that this had hit rock bottom. This was the worst situation at its very heart, and although this was painful, as it has been and still is, we had to end with the oversized nature of the construction sector in our country, which had generated a very serious real estate bubble.

What's happening? What is happening is that public expenditure in all the economies in the Eurozone in a specific manner has reached such a level that it is causing increases in debt, and the markets, which are those that cause this debt, are saying "be careful!", particularly when the situation in Greece arose. Greece has played a decisive role in this whole process. Why? Not only because Greece had very high public debt, nor an unsustainable deficit, but rather because its accounts hadn't responded to the reality. This destroyed confidence in the markets, which is the most important aspect; in other words, "am I dealing with a debtor who is really saying that his affairs are in order or not?". This resulted in the stress tests on the banks. Why? Because there was no confidence in the markets. And which countries has this affected most? Precisely those countries that have private debt as a result of the real estate bubble.

But when, in May, I had to take fiscal adjustment measures, this was not as a result of the Spanish economy as such, but rather the result of the circumstance that had been caused in the Eurozone.

We had a lighter deficit reduction plan, without these cuts. And now Mr. Herrera will ask me if we could have made this cuts sooner.

Why, if they weren't necessary at that time? Cuts need to be made when they are necessary, when you reach the conclusion that they are in fact necessary. Why would I reduce civil servants' salaries in a preventative manner? I don't believe that is a good way to govern. Afterwards it is always said that…

C. Herrera . I will tell you why, if you will let me. Because generating confidence in those who have to lend us money, those who have to lend money to the Government, in other words to all Spaniards; generating confidence is anticipating solutions to certain problems. When we look behind the problem, investors prefer to invest the money in other areas that they think will be a safer bet. If you wish to call them speculators, then let's call them speculators; but at the end of the day they are the people who lend us money and trust in our ability to repay it. If they don't trust us to repay the money in the conditions on which it was loaned, they don't lend it, or they ask for a much higher interest rate, because they understand that there is no confidence or because they understand that the things which need to be done are not being done.

That is why I asked you if this lack of confidence in Spanish consumption, in domestic consumption - there are people with a job, money and security who don't dare to spend their money - and this lack of confidence in the debt market, which may sometimes result in turmoil, as happened in May and November, and who knows if there is more turmoil coming our way, is something that's your responsibility. Do you take some kind of responsibility or have you reflected on this personally; that they don't trust you?

President of the Government . Of course my responsibility is the maximum responsibility in the country, both in the good times and the bad. When you are the President of the Government, you have to assume that you will face certain difficult circumstances and that you will have to take decisions.

You have not, for example, emphasised the fall in civil servants' wages. It is arguable, with the benefit of hindsight, that if the consequences of Greece had not taken place, we would not have had to implement this. And so someone could have said that "you lowered civil servants' wages unnecessarily", because that was not a factor in itself that determines confidence.

There are two things in the markets about which I believe, Mr. Herrera, you might say that I am right: one, that your information, the information of many investors, is limited because this information is in flux, it is continually changing and it is in abundance; two, that there are also investors who play to win in the short term, while there are others who have a different perspective.

Consequently, there are some who may be wrong or not; but this dialogue with the markets, this "dialogue" shouldn't necessarily simply be saying about what they want, which is to make money, many of them in the short term, that I have to say that they are right.

I believe that you have to give demonstrations of confidence, evidence of security, of course, and know how to react, like with everything, because every government would like to have a crystal ball to see six months into the future, for example, of what is going to happen in China. If inflation continues to rise in China and if the potential real estate bubble in China continues to grow and this generates a risk to the world economy, the scenario might be different.

What is difficult to demand, in my opinion, of any government is that it foresees what is going to happen in the economy a year before it happens, taking into account, as we have seen in this crisis, that phenomena rear their head in different forms and that everything is interrelated. What can be demanded of a government is that it reacts in the right way, and above all, that it reacts on a long-term basis. And at this time, when I am perfectly aware that Spanish society is still not confident about the future of the economy but that Spanish society values that its government has taken tough and difficult decisions, and we have taken them…

C. Herrera . Do you believe it values them?

President of the Government . Values what? It knows, I mean, that it values, of course…

C. Herrera . Subtle distinction between values and knows.

President of the Government . What I am saying is what you see, that their eyes have a glint, isn't that right? That is animates them.

The Government is aware that the economic measures taken have been criticised by a good part of our society, and the Government knows that society is still not confident about the economic future; but I would say - and since this will fortunately be recorded here, we should put it in perspective - that, when in 2013 we are economically growing above the European average, we will surely stop and look back, we will analyse what we have done and we will say, as a country, not as a government, that thanks to the reforms, to the difficult measures and the effort made at this time, we were able to recover growth and prosperity. And that is what is important to me.

I have been through these situations already in the Government's actions in other areas, when policies were made in a certain manner which overall, in the short term, resulted in rejection, uncertainty and a lack of confidence, but which in the long term clearly showed that the objectives were attained.

I know that today Spanish society is making an effort and that we have to earn confidence; but I can assure you that the course if the right one. It is the course of reforms to become more productive, which has been the problem that has caused us to be so indebted and which has meant that the crisis has been so serious in Spain.

C. Herrera . The economic aspects, particularly the macroeconomic aspects, are often hard to be seen as attractive to the audience; but there is a reflection that I would like you to make about the things that are still on the 'to do' list, because you yourself have recognised that there are still reforms to be carried out. Have you thought about co-payment for healthcare?

President of the Government . No, at no time, because it is a measure which, when it takes place… It is true that the majority of countries have some kind of formula whereby its citizens contribute to the healthcare system. However, the analyses of this reality and of this contribution make it clear that the saving is minor while having a great risk of discouraging health prevention. Hence, we are going to maintain our health system, a system in Spain which I believe is one of the freest systems of all those you might care to look at…

C. Herrera . Free, no, we pay for it through taxation. President of the Government. Yes, of course. But there is no system of contributions outside of the public accounts, of the general interest, of taxation. It is a very fair system, very progressive and one which undoubtedly favours those on the lowest incomes. But it is not only free and universal, moreover, it is a very high quality service with a great level. It is recognised by the international community as one of the most powerful healthcare systems. So, no co-payment.

C. Herrera . No co-payment. Furthermore, I would ask you for a succinct summary of the following two aspects: the restructuring of the savings banks, which seems to be essential; I would like to know how much this is going to cost. I would ask you if this is one of the arguments that creates most uncertainty among certain foreign investors.

And, secondly, how can we reduce the deficit to 6%, which is our commitment, taking into account the deficit reduction of the autonomous regions in an election year, when politicians love to spend and not make cuts?

President of the Government . I will begin with the deficit. Of course we will reach a deficit of 6% in 2011, in the same way as we set the objective to reduce the deficit in 2010, the year that has just ended, of 9.3%; and today I can assert that we are even going to improve on that deficit reduction that we had set as the objective.

Let me tell you that the autonomous regions are aware of the situation, and they are going to meet their targets even though it is an election year. For example, the Region of Murcia had exceeded its deficit target in respect of GDP, and presented an ambitious plan to reduce its GDP, and it presented this in an automatic manner through a decree law. Of course the Government is closely watching each and every autonomous region with a constructive attitude - note all of them, without looking at party politics. Hence, the deficit will be met of 6%.

The savings banks. We have gone through a restructuring process of the savings banks, we have gone from 43 savings banks to 17, and the legal-institutional process has been consolidated. We now have to consolidate the operating process, the structural process of reducing the capacity of the system.

We have to carry out new stress tests on the financial system, and this will be done, because transparency is fundamental to clearly show the situation of strength of the savings banks, their exposure to the real estate sector, their risks and, as the case may be, if they need to increase their capital, some of them, by some amount, preferably by private investment, private capital - to this end we have modified the law, in this case through agreements with the PP. Should any of the savings banks, which in any event will be minimal, need to resort to the FROB, and I would remind you that the FROB, which draws on public funds, it is not a gift, but rather these funds are loaned at an interest rate of 7.5%...

I know that this is now impossible to explain and I don't know whether, one day, I might be able to explain this to my grandchildren, because what will stay in people's minds is that the Government gave money to the banks and helped the banks.

However, what the Government has done is guarantee bank issues and purchase assets to that subsequently the banks can re-purchase them. Through these transactions, public funds are increasing, we are making money. But I know it will be impossible to say "I didn't lend money to the banks, but I earned money through this process". The public sector has not lost a single euro helping the banks in Spain. It is going to gain in terms of resources and euros. I am very interested in stressing that.

And as regards the savings banks, I insist, the stress tests and maximum transparency before the markets. That is what we are going to do in the short term: a new series of stress tests so that those entities which, after the mergers that have taken place, have to increase or improve their capital, do so preferably with private capital, through the markets, because our financial system has shown that it functions efficiently - proof of that is that we haven't had any go bust, nor have we had to inject public capital - and in the future they will see profits. And, if any of them are unable to do so, they will receive aid from the FROB, but this will be limited. The most important thing is that the markets know that our homework is being done as regards the financial system, that it is solvent, that there are plans and that, moreover, the Bank of Spain continues doing a good job of surveillance, in the same way as over the last few years.

(….)

President of the Government . (…) I am the first person in this country who appreciates that a business owner with a struggling business, or a worker who has lost his job, or someone who doesn't know how he is going to get to work next year looks straight away to the President of the Government and holds him responsible. I believe that is absolutely normal. I endeavour to explain what we are doing and I endeavour to transmit with assurances that this extremely tough economic crisis will be overcome, that in only a couple of years we will see stable growth once again and that in five years the reforms will be complete, as I mentioned the other day, which should be carried out through consensus and agreements. Some have…

C. Herrera . Pensions is one.

President of the Government . Exactly. Pensions are a key reform.

C. Herrera . But don't take too long to do this, to set them underway. I don't exactly know as regards the Greeks, but the day after tomorrow those Irish who were 64 and a half years old and on the point of retiring are going to have to wait another two years. In other words, not those who are fifty. We are going to wait for many years to do that.

President of the Government . If you will allow me to briefly explain the matter of the pensions, because your listeners will be very interested in this as it affects all our citizens.

Spain currently clearly spends less public funds on retirement pensions than the European average and we are going to have, both now and in the coming years, a situation, as a result of demographic growth that is the following: in 2025, 2030 or 2035, if we do nothing, we will have public expenditure on retirement pensions of around 3% of GDP, in other words, thirty billion euros more than the European average. In the next twenty-five years.

Why? Because that is when the largest generations in the history of Spain are going to retire, which includes me, those who were born from 1956 to 1966 or 1970. Many Spaniards were born during that time and, moreover, we have had few children, because the birth rate during the democracy and with development has fallen radically.

That is the explanation and it is easy to understand. In 2025 or 2030 there will be many people receiving their retirement pension and, since it is not reasonable that this is paid through raising taxes, in other words, through social contributions, it is necessary to save. Why? So that we can continue to receive ever better pensions. And the way to save is to spend more time in the labour market, because currently the average age for people to exit the labour market in Spain is 62.8 years of age while the legal age is 65.

And so, we need to increase the legal age of retirement, in the same way as Germany and England have done. Why?

C. Herrera . This has caused more than one problem in France.

President of the Government . Yes. So that by 2025 or 2030 our public expenditure on pensions reaches the European average; public expenditure on retirement pensions that amounts to 10% of GDP. That is where we need to be. Does that seem reasonable? Yes. Can we do this progressively and "gently"? Yes, because, and I insist, today our public expenditure is lower than the majority of European countries on pensions. In other words, today our situation is better, but we suffer from the peculiarity that, by the time we reach the year 2025 or 2030, we are going to hit a peak in public expenditure, and then paradoxically, as a result of our demographic growth, by 2050 - I know it's a long way off but a serious country needs to plan for the future - we will return to a much better situation and hence, it is foreseeable that those who retire in 2050 will have much more generous pensions.

C. Herrera . This has caused more than one serious problem in France, as I said, and let's not even mention Greece. In Spain, the most serious effect or possible effect would seem to be the threat of the trade unions to organise another general strike. I don't know if they are saying this wholeheartedly, half-heartedly, to do damage or in earnest. You know them well and deal with them often, do you think they will organise another strike?

President of the Government . I have a great deal of respect for the trade unions. We are trying to make them understand and encourage them to contribute proposals to the pension reform project, with the legal retirement age set at 67 on a flexible basis, depending on the number of years worked and on the type of job; but with one undeniable fact, and that is what I have just explained, that over the next twenty or twenty-five years our public expenditure on pensions is going to soar. Hence, we have to do something now, but we can do it progressively.

Under our plan, the fixed retirement age of 67 will not take effect until 2027. From now to 2027? On a progressive basis: there will be those citizens who retire at 65 and one month, at 65 and a half, at 65 and two months on the path we are taking. We can do this and what I would like is that it arose from a broad consensus, because in order to have a pension system, to maintain the public system and so that we can continue to improve minimum pensions, which is a major effort at solidarity that this country should make - for example, pensions for widows over the age of 65 have increased by 84% under this Government - we need to be solvent.

This is also important, why? Because what investors, the markets and international bodies most look at is the way our greatest public expenses are planned, and pensions are always the highest public expense. Just look at the figures I have given you, and what we are going to spend on retirement pensions by 2025 or 2030, the same as on education and healthcare together. In other words, pensions will be the greatest expense. So everyone is looking at us and asking "and how are your pensions planned?". For that reason, the strongest countries already have the retirement age set at 67: Germany, England and Sweden. They have been working on this for some time now.

C. Herrera . In three minutes, because I imagine you have other things to do than attend to me…

President of the Government . I now have a meeting precisely about the financial system.

C. Herrera . Ah! Not with the Chinese gentleman who has come to buy our debt?

President of the Government . No, that's tomorrow.

C. Herrera . Is he the one who is going to buy our debt?

President of the Government . China has traditionally bought Spanish debt. It is an investor; just like Japan, although Japan assuredly buys more. What is important is that the second largest world economy at this time is confident as regards Spanish sovereign debt and, moreover, that we can reach other agreements on economic matters. The economic confidence of China is currently important, and fortunately…

C. Herrera . That is why I said two or three questions, because it is clear that we haven't talked about international politics, of the rascal who is the Venezuelan Ambassador, who has now finally left. Why do we have to put up with so much from these people?

President of the Government . Who?

C. Herrera .- The rascal who is the Venezuelan Ambassador. This is a personal opinion.

President of the Government . Like with all the Latin American countries, beyond who the specific Ambassador is, we endeavour, with our ups and downs and our difficulties, and with Venezuela there are… The Government of Spain must try, with all the Latin American countries, to have a minimum policy that is favourable.

Why? Because our interests are there, it is our language and our sphere of influence in the world, and we do this with all the Latin American countries. This has been done, in general, during the whole period of democracy. I believe this is a policy of State, beyond that of a mere circumstance of a specific ambassador.

(…)

C. Herrera . Choosing a candidate, a substitute… who would you favour? Blanco, Rubalcaba, Carmen Chacón?

President of the Government . I like all of them. The other day I heard you say to Rajoy, "it doesn't matter whether it's one or another" and as I was listening, he said: yes, it's true that it doesn't matter; but it doesn't matter because maybe he won't win, which is more or less the line that Rajoy tends to take.

(…)

C. Herrera . It was very nice to see you.

President of the Government . Thank you very much.