Interview with the President of the Government on the program "La Mirada Crítica," from Tele 5.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

31 August 2008 · Interview on the program "La Mirada Crítica" on Tele 5 · Tele 5 studios

Context
Zapatero was interviewed on Tele 5's 'La Mirada Crítica' on August 31, 2008, addressing the Spanair crash and Spain's economic crisis.
Main themes
Spanair plane crash tragedy, government response and accountability, air safety investigation, economic crisis in Spain, ministerial transparency, workers' grievances, judicial and technical commissions
Duration
~55 min
95th percentile
Words
6,550
95th percentile
Sentences
343
96th percentile
Readability
58
84th percentile
Grade
9.8
18th percentile
Syntax
2.83
25th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
38th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

343 sentences in 180 paragraphs

President.- Good morning.

Mª T. Campos.- Welcome to these Tele 5 studios and, specifically, to this set. I thank you for granting us this interview today, which is the day we eagerly begin a new phase of this informative program, a political information program that has become emblematic on Tele 5. It has been almost ten years of "La Mirada Crítica." So thank you very much.

President.- I wish you much success in your task.

Mª T. Campos.- Thank you very much.

If it hadn't happened, we would have started this interview talking about the economy, which is what most concerns Spaniards in the latest surveys; the issue of the crisis has displaced other topics that were usually among the concerns of Spaniards. However, suddenly, tragedy struck us, the Spanair plane, and when lives are at stake, I believe there is no more important topic than that. If you agree, I would like to start with that.

The Vice President of your Government, Mrs. Fernández de la Vega, said after the Council of Ministers on Friday, "we will act with all rigor, we will know what happened, and the Government will act accordingly."

President.- Indeed, it has been a great tragedy. 154 people have lost their lives, causing great pain for their families, for all Spaniards, and, of course, in the face of a tragedy of this magnitude, we must know the causes and circumstances.

I do want to convey a message of confidence. We have an air navigation system that meets the highest safety standards of European countries and those in the world with the most demanding systems. This tragedy has occurred, and we must get to the bottom of all its causes and circumstances. For that, there is a commission that is established in a stable and permanent manner, a technical investigation commission, and it will get to the bottom of the causes. There is also a judicial action, and, of course, the Government will logically prioritize and rigorously attend to what the Commission says and, of course, also what the corresponding Court may say.

Mª T. Campos.- We will have to wait for the investigation and what the Commission says to act with knowledge of the facts, right? We should not be frivolous about these things, because many times responsibilities start to be demanded that, by the way, are already being demanded of your Government, specifically of the Ministry of Development. There is also a rather unpleasant letter for the Minister of Development from the workers of Spanair, which is a bit of the latest news on this topic.

President.- I understand the workers of Spanair, who must undoubtedly be very affected people, with very intense pain, because they have felt this tragedy very directly.

It is true that they express in the letter their complaint because the Minister informed Parliament of a fact that occurred in the moments leading up to the accident, which was the possibility that the company considered changing the plane. The Minister has been attributed some strange intention. I must tell the workers of Spanair that absolutely not; it is simply an exercise in transparency and information.

I want to emphasize that the Minister appeared a week after the tragedy, that she appeared with all the data, and that fact had occurred. And I want to add next: it has the importance it has, because it is true that this is a hypothesis that is sometimes considered, which is not uncommon, when some plane has some problem. The company always, or many times, has another plane ready. With this, neither the Minister, of course, nor anyone, has wanted to cast any shadow of doubt over anyone's actions. This must be very clear. But surely the workers...

Mª T. Campos.- Yes, but what they have said is somewhat harsh, isn't it?: "we feel humiliated, beaten, and defamed by a member of your Government."

President.- Well, that is not true. They should not feel that way, because it is not true. That exercise of transparency, that information, like all actions, all facts, and all communications, as it should be, that happen in Barajas, are recorded, are recorded, and it seems to me that a Government should provide information about everything that has happened. If they have interpreted that, we deeply regret it. It is not so. It is the exercise of information, and we will have to wait for what the independent investigation commission determines about the causes and circumstances.

But I understand that the workers of Spanair have a special pain. This is a company that has habitually passed all safety tests and inspections, I want to emphasize that. Now it has had this tragedy, and we will have the calm to know what has happened and, if necessary, act.

Mª T. Campos.- What can a Government do, I thought when facing this interview with the President of the Government, in front of a private company if, naturally, it is a hypothesis that this company hides data; if, for example, in a moment of crisis the regulations are taken to a minimum instead of a maximum, or if having a plane on the ground means losing many millions and they decide to fly it, even if they comply with the regulations, but as I say, a regulation of minimums and maximums? Now perhaps all this that is happening is because they are scared and are complying with the regulations to the maximum, right?, and that is why some pilots are turning back, people are scared, and in other cases they would not have turned back. What can the Government do about this?

President.- The fact is that the regulations regarding air navigation are demanding regulations, with very exhaustive controls and rigor, and it is so due to international regulations and European regulations, regulations that, moreover, in our country are reinforced. Regardless of the business and economic circumstances that each company has, those regulations are complied with and are rigorous and demanding. Therefore, we should not establish...

Mª T. Campos.- Is the Government in a position to oversee the day-to-day compliance of that regulation by private companies? Can you assure us of that?

President.- Absolutely. There are hundreds of people dedicated to inspection, to demand, and to controls, but not only in Spain, because sometimes we have a vision that only looks at ourselves. Spanish companies and these Spanair planes fly all over the world and in Europe they are subject to inspections and random controls, just as we inspect other companies here in Spain when they land or when they are in our territory.

Therefore, there is a permanent system of control and inspection to guarantee, as much as possible, hopefully we could say one hundred percent, hopefully some country could say it, what is the safety of travelers in air transport.

Mª T. Campos.- That the safety of air traffic is not in question...

President.- Not at all.

Mª T. Campos.- ...not only regarding the safety of citizens, but because, as the Minister of Development said in her appearance the other day in Congress, air transport is also something important in our economy, right?, in a tourist country.

President.- It represents more than 7 percent of the Gross Domestic Product; that is to say, a very important contribution, as in other countries of the world. Moreover, it is worth remembering that, despite having had this tragedy that has caused so much pain, it remains a very safe mode of transport compared to other means of transport that we all know.

Mª T. Campos.- To conclude this topic, what feeling do you have after having been with the victims, Mr. President?

President.- It is a feeling that is hardly transferable. When one is the President of the Government in the face of a tragedy, when one experiences the pain of a circumstance of this nature, one feels it very closely, one feels it as if it were one's own. Talking with the families, trying to console them and trying to give them an explanation and, of course, the maximum support is for me an obligation. I can assure you that it seems to me the most important task a Government can do: to try to preserve the safety of our compatriots as much as possible and, secondly, to support the families who lose their loved ones in a tragedy of this nature.

I can also say that the families I had the opportunity to speak with those days, both at Ifema and in the hospitals, showed great fortitude and exemplary behavior. It is true that also in these situations, in a tragedy that the whole country has felt, one sees how the character of our country is, and I have seen with pride the reaction of solidarity; how professionals, firefighters, people from health services, volunteers, psychologists, and Administrations have poured in; how solidarity arrived from all places and how a country was very, very close to the tragedy we had experienced.

That is an aspect I also want to highlight, because the character of a society and a country is also measured in these very painful circumstances.

Mª T. Campos.- Let us move on to the topic of the economy, if you agree, Mr. President. You took time to acknowledge the crisis, at least with that word. The opposition said, "the Government is doing nothing." Did you take too long to make decisions, looking back now?

President.- I have explained this many times. The first Council of Ministers after the elections approved a package of economic measures in fulfillment of electoral commitments and focused on the economy, such as returning six billion euros to citizens through the income tax with the measure of the famous four hundred euros. From day one, we have done nothing but take economic measures.

Some have wanted to focus only on a debate about the appropriate word for the situation of stagnation, slowdown, crisis, economic deceleration that Europe, all of Europe, is experiencing. I want to remind you that the eurozone has had a decrease, that is to say, it has not grown in the second quarter, and in Spain we have grown a little, and that the whole of the European Union has not grown in the second quarter of this year and that Spain has grown a little. Therefore, we have an international context of economic slowdown.

We have taken measures to support families, to support companies to help their financing, because there are serious difficulties due to the whole circumstance of international financial markets, which come from the United States, and also structural reforms.

Now we have ahead of us a few months with difficulties, a few months that we must face with...

Mª T. Campos.- Just a few months?

President.- A few months, according to the forecasts.

Mª T. Campos.- Or a few years?

President.- The forecasts and, of course, what everyone and all international organizations point out is that we will return to a growth path in the second half of next year. These are all forecasts.

Mª T. Campos.- Forgive me, I am going to note that.

President.- Yes; but, I emphasize, these are forecasts, because it could be that we start to grow earlier or that this growth could be delayed somewhat. Why? Because it depends on factors that are not directly within anyone's reach. For example, the price of oil. It is evident that if the price of oil continues to moderate and trends downward, as in recent months...

Mª T. Campos.- How would that mitigate the crisis?

President.- That has a fundamental factor, which is that it moderates inflation, prices will rise less, which is very good for the whole economy, very good for families, and can open the door for interest rates to fall, which would be...

Mª T. Campos.- Do you already know tomorrow's CPI?

President.- Undoubtedly, what the CPI represents has just released the August data, the preliminary data is a reasonable and positive figure, because we have decreased four tenths. If the trend of oil remains as it is...

Mª T. Campos.- Has that already been reflected in that CPI?

President.- It has been reflected. Four tenths, from 5.3 to 4.9 percent. If that trend continues, we could end the year below 4 percent, which would be very positive for the whole of families, for purchasing power, and, of course, also for that open door to what represents a possible decrease in interest rates.

But I want to say that we have this European context, and in light of this situation, the Government is facing it with two fundamental ideas: one, solidarity, and two, reforms. Solidarity in times of difficulty with those who are unemployed, which is the Government's main concern: employment and jobs; and solidarity with the lowest incomes: pensioners and the Minimum Interprofessional Wage. Two, reforms. For what? So that we can increase productivity and, when economic growth returns as a result of international circumstances, we can grow well...

Mª T. Campos.- Excuse me, President, I still have many questions and very little time. So, I wouldn’t want to leave some things unsaid and have you say them, of course.

What would you say to those who say that you place a lot of emphasis on social spending, but that social spending is unproductive, that the four hundred euros, I tell you as I hear it said on the street, is money thrown away and that those who should be supported are those who create wealth and provide jobs?

President.- Normally, those who speak like this about social spending do not have any need for social spending. Last Friday, in the Council of Ministers, we approved the Early Childhood Education Plan for children from zero to three years old to finance three hundred thousand places for families in this country with one objective: to reconcile work life and family life.

There are people, without a doubt, who can afford a place in Early Childhood Education or nurseries for children from zero to three years old, but there are many families who cannot afford it. And if we can, and we can, from the Government initiate this new phase after having secured funding for three to six years for all the children in our country, and now we are starting from zero to three years for Early Childhood Education, which is also very good for the overall education of a child, a young person, or an adolescent, we are going to do it.

Social policies are productive because extending the possibility for young people with scholarships to access education makes a country more productive, and allowing families with lower incomes to have more access to housing makes a country more productive. And Spain can make that effort of solidarity. I insist, at this moment we are going to maintain social policies, but my main concern is employment, the unemployment that has started to rise after a few years of extraordinary job creation.

Mª T. Campos.- The most pessimistic predict it will reach 14.5 percent, and then there are the alarmists who say it could reach 20 percent. Where do you stand?

President.- Let’s put things in perspective. Year 2000, when Aznar said that the economy was a miracle, that it was the best economy as it functioned, and the unemployment rate...

Mª T. Campos.- You said that you left the country that had the best period in its history.

President.- I will clarify that...

Mª T. Campos.- I want you to answer that, if we have time.

President.- ...because in the year 2000, a year of great economic euphoria, the unemployment rate in Spain was 14 percent, 13.9. Now we have it at 10.4 percent. That is to say, although the unemployment rate is increasing in this last period, in these last months, the unemployment rate is in the low, very low parts of what has been the democratic period. In fact, with my Government, a few months ago we reached the lowest unemployment rate of the entire democratic period: 8.4 percent.

Mª T. Campos.- The difference would be that before we were going down and now we are going up.

President.- But, of course, it is very different to be in a situation of 16 percent unemployment, and from there to rise, than to be in a situation of unemployment from 8 and to rise to 10, 11, or 12 percent. It is completely different because, logically, we have already gained spectacular ground in favor of employment and in favor of work.

I want to remind you that there are twenty million people working in our country today, which four years ago were eighteen million, not reaching eighteen million, and therefore we have much more employment, we have much more capacity to support people who lose their jobs, because unemployment protection is covered for 85 percent of those who lose their jobs, and we have much more social strength to support those who have difficulties, which is the main objective.

Mª T. Campos.- Do we have money for all this?

President.- We have resources thanks to the fact that we have had a surplus.

Mª T. Campos.- What do we have left from the surplus? What do we have left from the surplus?

President.- The surplus is for that.

Mª T. Campos.- They say that by the end of the year it will be gone, I have read. I don’t know.

President.- That is what it is for, to support those who have the most difficulties. One saves to say: I have saved, and the savings I have, when there is a difficult circumstance, I dedicate it to supporting people who may have problems with employment, to pensioners, to scholarships, to housing assistance, and to maintaining an active social policy that is productive.

Moreover, I believe it is very convenient that we maintain that great collective success of our country, which is the agreement and social dialogue between employers and unions.

Mª T. Campos.- You have a lot of hope in the social pact, don’t you? When will it be? Next Wednesday?

President.- It is fundamental. In this time it is fundamental for employment. Next Wednesday we have the first meeting already, let’s say, operational, of contents, which will be focused on the response to the increase in unemployment and the response to reform Vocational Training. In all this, I believe that the country as a whole must have a perspective and a collective and solidary effort.

What is the great priority we have to face in the coming months? The challenge of employment, the risk of increasing unemployment. Therefore, the unions and employers are fundamental parts; the Government, too. The Government will take initiatives with unions and employers to fight and mitigate what represents the loss of employment at this moment in our economy.

I want to involve the political groups, the Parliamentary Groups, in all of this. That is why I want to announce that I will request an appearance in the Congress of Deputies, immediately, to inform about the economic situation, about the economic measures we are taking, and, very especially, about the policies in favor of employment. I will request it today to have a new debate.

Mª T. Campos.- For you to go, President?

President.- Yes, of course.

Mª T. Campos.- Appearance on the economic issue.

President.- Exactly, on the economic moment, the measures we have taken, and policies in favor of employment. Especially, I would like it to be a great debate on support for employment creation policies, which is undoubtedly the great objective we have at this moment.

Mª T. Campos.- How far will the confrontation with the PSC on the issue of financing go?

President.- I have no confrontation with the PSC.

Mª T. Campos.- Rajoy said this weekend that you went to Catalonia as an arsonist, a firefighter, or I don’t know what.

President.- Political criticism admits everything: but, of course, Rajoy, after what he did in the last Legislature collecting signatures all over Spain against Catalonia, against its Statute and saying what he said, well... Come on! Let’s be serious.

Mª T. Campos.- The PP now says that the Statute must be complied with in this.

President.- Let’s be serious in the debate. Why are we talking about reforming autonomous financing? We are talking about this because all the Communities are asking for it. It is that, of course, the great contradiction of the PP... They say why this debate now; but I, since I sat as President of the Government in La Moncloa and received the autonomous Presidents, the ones from the PP, first; they have asked me for more money for education and for health. In fact, it is no longer remembered, but in the last Legislature we already had an agreement to give more money for health to the Autonomous Communities in a Conference of Presidents. We made an injection of money from the State to the Autonomous Communities.

Why do the Autonomous Communities demand more resources? Fundamentally, because of the evolution of the population increase which, logically, causes more economic effort, especially in the two major services they provide: education and health.

Therefore, first reflection. Everyone wants to reform autonomous financing and improve.

Mª T. Campos.- It is legitimate, of course.

President.- Yes, but what this means is more money for education and for health.

In other words, the debate on autonomous financing is not an abstract debate of bureaucracies or Governments, no; it goes directly to what affects citizens: that we have better hospitals, that we have fewer waiting lists, that we can have better educational centers or more technology in our educational centers. This is the debate on autonomous financing, because it is done by the Autonomous Communities.

Catalonia has had a presence and leadership in this matter for some time, and this appeared in a very concrete way in the Statute of Catalonia. What do I want to say about this? That the Government of Catalonia, the Government of Montilla, has reasons to want and demand a reform of the financing model. Why? Because in Catalonia there has been a very large increase in the population, one million in recent years, and there is pressure on education and health. Two, does Catalonia contribute to the whole? Yes, and I want to say it publicly, just as other Communities exercise a solidarity effort to the whole.

Therefore, we need to move to a model in which, improving all Communities - notice that what the Government proposes is "let's make the reform and all Communities will improve," we can reach a balanced agreement and I can assure you that this agreement will come. Every time the financing model has been reformed, there has been a time of debate, with each one defending their positions, as is logical; but we will reach an agreement.

Mª T. Campos.- Well, let it be so.

For the opposition, you are the cause of all evils, something that also resonates in certain sectors of the citizenry, right? Because you see the press and you read the cartoons. Do you have a sense of humor? Do you think the treatment given to you is unfair?

President.- No. I think it is logical, in democracies that today are very competitive, that the criticism from the other parties is directed at those who are in Government, that is, at those who have had the majority trust of the people. That the press is critical is its task, it is the task of political control or the control of those who have nothing more and nothing less than the responsibility of the citizens.

But we have just had elections. It has been a few months, the citizens have spoken, we had the support of more than eleven million Spaniards and then...

Mª T. Campos.- Now, excuse me, you have had a drop in popularity and the intention to vote has decreased, but they say that, as of today, if there were elections, you would win again by a small margin.

President.- Well, surveys are very attractive, but elections are every four years. That said, it is advisable to have a little calm.

Mª T. Campos.- Since you won until now, many things have happened.

President.- We have just had an intense campaign, we voted in March and, of course, the Spaniards have given me a trust that I appreciate extraordinarily, which commits me to them, commits me to their well-being and commits me to improvement every day and the fight against the various problems we have.

It is normal for other parties to try to compete because they want to win; but they have not won, for now. So, that is normal.

Mª T. Campos.- But you do not recognize anything, because almost all the Presidents we have had in recent democracy in their second Legislature are accused a bit of getting into their bubble and not being sensitive to criticism, not even from their own? Have you reached that point?

President.- We must overcome the clichés. The truth is that what is said about the Moncloa syndrome does not...

Mª T. Campos.- Do you do a self-examination?

President.- Every day.

Mª T. Campos.- Do you recognize mistakes?

President.- Every day. I evaluate and self-criticize, and I listen. Moreover, I listen to my collaborators and read the media.

What I do know is that I have a responsibility. My responsibility is to fulfill the electoral program with the citizens and to go in that line within the circumstances that arise.

For example, it is true that I have criticisms, sometimes, because I do not make a commitment to increase nuclear energy in Spain; just to give an example. I have criticisms, but my electoral program has committed me to the citizens that I would not make a commitment to increase nuclear energy.

Mª T. Campos.- But, perhaps, one can rectify later, because...

President.- Yes, but for me, honoring the word given is important.

Mª T. Campos.- If we run out of nuclear energy...

President.- I have criticisms because we maintain an intense social policy and I have criticisms for the 2,500 euros, for the aid of 2,500 euros to families that have a child. I have been criticized, but I do not think any political party is now proposing to eliminate them. Well. Agreed.

The fundamental contrast of political action in democracy...

Mª T. Campos .- They laugh off the 2,500 euros and the 400, I tell you, because I am picking up the voice of the street for you. They laugh and say: "this 400 euros is money thrown away and so on."

President .- They have every right. Undoubtedly, for someone for whom 400 euros means nothing, it may give rise to a joke. For someone 2,500 euros… I can tell you that there are many people who thank us for it, because this is the first Government that has implemented a family policy to support childbirth with 2,500 euros. More than four hundred thousand Spaniards have already received this since the measure was introduced, more than four hundred thousand families, and for me it represents a policy of support for families, a social policy.

We maintain social policies because we live in a country that must look out for those who have the most difficulties, for those who do not have everything, and also know how to endure the criticisms, sometimes, of those who have many things.

Mª T. Campos .- But sometimes, clichés resonate a lot. In the last Legislature, the issue of terrorism and the issue of "Spain is breaking," which I don't know if Spain has broken something, or if it hasn't broken anything, or if it is breaking, or if it is not going to break…

President .- It seems rather that it is not.

Mª T. Campos .- It seems rather that it is not, says the President.

President .- Nor had we surrendered to ETA.

In other words, in the end, democracy is a system that allows all criticisms…

Mª T. Campos .- But have you lost hope for peace? Because four years ago, in your first Legislature, you had great hope for peace, but now you have lost hope for peace.

President .- I have put all my effort into peace and all my effort into ending violence. And with dialogue and without dialogue, I have worked and continue to work intensively to see the end of violence.

Mª T. Campos .- But you no longer have, I repeat, hope of achieving peace.

President .- Those who have broken and broke the expectation of the end of violence have less hope. Those are the ones who have no hope at all, and we see every day how ETA commandos are falling, being arrested, and seeing how society and the State are becoming stronger and stronger.

Mª T. Campos .- Will Patxi López be Lehendakari with the support of the PNV and, if necessary, with that of the PP?

President .- First, the citizens have to vote. Patxi López is, in my opinion, a magnificent candidate for Lehendakari. I believe that Euskadi wants a peaceful change, which he represents; but from there, once the vote is held, dialogues and necessary agreements will have to be established.

Mª T. Campos .- Regarding Ibarretxe, do you think he will make an electoral banner of his plan and not let him carry out that consultation?

President .- First, we must wait to see who the candidate of the Basque Nationalist Party is for Lehendakari.

Mª T. Campos .- Ah!

President .- I know that the candidate from the Socialist Party will be Patxi López; in the Basque Nationalist Party, it is likely to be Ibarretxe, but we must respect…

Mª T. Campos .- But do you think it might not be Ibarretxe?

President .- No. They have not nominated him yet, as far as I know.

Mª T. Campos .- Are you saying this for a reason, because you have information that the PNV might change Ibarretxe?

President .- I say it out of democratic respect, simply…

Mª T. Campos .- Ah! To speak properly.

President .- …just as I would say about the PP, about Rajoy, thinking about the upcoming elections. Out of democratic respect, we must wait.

But what I do know is that, from Ibarretxe's plans, the consultation plan is a partisan plan that does not respond to any of the needs of Euskadi, that does not favor understanding, dialogue, or meeting, which is what the Basque Country needs. Therefore, it will not prosper, nor will it come to fruition.

Mª T. Campos .- And you will not back down from that.

President .- Absolutely.

Mª T. Campos .- And I believe there are many Spaniards who are with you on this, President.

Let's see if I have time for three things: You are going to Brussels today regarding the Caucasus, regarding Russia, Georgia. Is there, or can there start, or has a new cold war begun?

President .- We have the great responsibility to ensure that no hint of a new cold war occurs. It would certainly be a very negative situation. In other words, a wall fell, the Berlin Wall, and now there cannot be a new wall. We lived in a situation of confrontation between a realm of freedom and democracy, and a realm where there was no freedom and democracy; there was no confrontation between the West and Russia for being Russia, or between the East and the West.

Now there is a specific territorial problem, where there are surely responsibilities on all sides, which is the result of how the demolition of the Soviet bloc occurred, and the Caucasus has problems. We must put diplomacy, great politics, and serenity at the service of understanding, the restoration of situations, support for Georgia, but at the service of understanding and dialogue with Russia. And the European Union is the great international actor that can guarantee this.

Mª T. Campos .- This would be in line with the French President, Sarkozy, right?

President .- This afternoon we will discuss it. So far, President Sarkozy has made an effort that is commendable. He launched a peace plan with six points, and some of them have not been strictly fulfilled. Today we will evaluate it; but, of course, Spain wants this crisis situation in understanding with Russia and the crisis in the Caucasus to be resolved with the strength of the European Union, giving them support and giving maximum representation to European institutions, to the French Presidency, because it currently presides over the Council, and also to Javier Solana as the representative of foreign policy. Only the European Union can guarantee stability, understanding, and agreement with Russia in the Caucasus region, and we must reinforce that responsibility in today's Council meeting.

Mª T. Campos .- That is a good headline you just gave.

I want to have time to talk about Justice, one of the major issues also for the beginning of this political course, because there is an impression, with the renewals of the Supreme Court and the General Council of the Judiciary, of a kind of political plundering above what are the interests of citizens, and then what happens happens. Are you finally going to reach an agreement? Because the truth, forgive me for saying it, is that you discredit yourselves and the opposition as well.

President .- A nuance to the introduction of the question.

Mª T. Campos .- Yes; malicious, yes.

President .- The truth is that politics is, above all, the interest of the citizens, because it is what is common.

Mª T. Campos .- But this does not seem to be the case because, when one party is in government to place its own and the opposition to place its own…

President .- Justice needs to improve as a public service in our country, perhaps one of the public services that needs to improve the most, and gain in agility and effectiveness, which is quite evident to all citizens. The Government is certainly aware of this.

Now we have the opportunity because we need to reform the institution that governs a good part of the issues of Justice, which is the Council of the Judiciary. The parties must agree so that Parliament elects and renews its members, and we must look for people who are capable, professionals, and who guarantee their commitment to that action of reforming Justice and improving Justice.

Certainly, we must all go with the utmost willingness for the Council of the Judiciary to serve the general interests of Justice and have the least partisan component.

Mª T. Campos .- It has been said that the same person could continue as President.

President .- It does not seem so.

But I must make a nuance because, of course, Justice has a configuration, as is logical, of independent functioning. And this is true.

Mª T. Campos .- In theory.

President .- No, no. In theory, no; in practice. We have just seen it now with a case such as the prison permit of lawyer Emilio Rodríguez Menéndez. Penitentiary Institutions said "no" to that permit, an appeal was made to a judge, and a judge said yes. And there the Government and the Administration have nothing more to do but comply with what a judge says, which is the functioning of our system.

Then, when there is a serious or grave problem, citizens, as is logical, I insist, as is logical, look to the Government. I have lived it painfully and very closely with the parents of Mari Luz, the tragically murdered girl…

Mª T. Campos .- That is why you have to reach an agreement, because there are so many issues. Yesterday another woman was killed, and there are forty-something. The Gender Violence Law, which I don't know if it needs to be improved…

President .- The Law is supporting many women who suffer from abuse.

Mª T. Campos .- I say this as a woman so that, since I am told that there are two minutes left, you can also say something about this. Has the Gender Violence Law fallen short?

President .- No, it has not fallen short. I believe the Law is a law of support and prevention. It is supporting many more women, who previously did not have that support, who suffer from abuse. It has facilitated many more reports and many more restraining orders. What unfortunately persists are the criminal actions of a criminal machismo, repugnant, repulsive, and that, of course, harms us all as a society.

But the fight, the struggle, the awareness, the multiplication of efforts, and the sum of wills continue to be in the hands of the action and leadership of the Government. Therefore, we are going to have a Conference of Autonomous Presidents with the Government focused on the fight against gender violence.

Mª T. Campos .- I am pleased that we have almost completed the entire questionnaire I had, and I only have to ask you in the end if you remain optimistic.

President .- Absolutely.

Mª T. Campos .- Do you know there is a famous phrase that says: "the optimist is a poorly informed pessimist"?

President .- The task of Government must be faced with responsibility and confidence. Responsibility and confidence translate into knowing that your country and your society can face difficulties; that we have made, as a country, a great leap in well-being, modernity, freedoms, and presence in the world; that this advance, which has been a prodigious advance, has shown us that we have that capacity; that now we have economically a headwind; that we will know how to navigate with that wind, most importantly, supporting those who suffer from it, those who have the most difficulties, and that, as soon as circumstances improve, we will return to have…

Mª T. Campos .- Hopefully no hurricane comes.

President .- Hopefully the United States does not suffer, as it is at this moment…

Mª T. Campos .- That comes from there. Economic hurricanes started coming from there.

President .- This one has come from there. It has come due to a policy of lack of control in the financial system and has infected all of Europe.

Mª T. Campos .- The President is comfortable here, talking with me, but they tell me that you have to go because, otherwise, you won't make it to the Executive, nor will you make it to Brussels.

President .- I am always comfortable talking to you, of course, on this channel and trying to explain and convey to citizens my opinions, my decisions, and what is happening.

Mª T. Campos .- Well, thank you very much. Thank you, and I hope you give us good news for this course.

President .- No. You give us the news. There is everything. We do not give news; we govern.

Mª T. Campos .- That you give us good political information so that we can convey it in this last quarter that we now face in the new "Critical Look."

President, thank you very much.

President .- Much success and good luck.

Mª T. Campos .- Thank you.

President .- Thank you.