Press conference by the President of the Government and the Prime Minister of Lebanon

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

7 April 2010

Context
Zapatero held a joint press conference with Lebanese Prime Minister Hariri during Hariri's first official visit to Spain in April 2010.
Main themes
Spain-Lebanon bilateral relations, Middle East peace process, Lebanese national unity government, UNIFIL mission and Spanish troops, Union for the Mediterranean summit, EU rotating presidency, regional stability, political dialogue, Arab Peace Initiative, Israel-Palestine conflict
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,740
72nd percentile
Sentences
108
67th percentile
Readability
40
36th percentile
Grade
14.0
67th percentile
Syntax
3.04
53rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile
Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 53%53%
  • Ceremonial 22%22%
  • Institutional 13%13%
  • Economic 9%9%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

108 sentences in 49 paragraphs

President of the Government. Good afternoon. I would first like to say how glad I am to welcome the Prime Minister of Lebanon here today, Mr Hariri, on what is his first official visit to Spain.

This visit comes within the framework of a process to strengthen our bilateral relations and also provides us with the opportunity to reiterate Spain's firm commitment to political and institutional stability in Lebanon and our desire for a peace process in the region.

I must begin my comments on the situation in Lebanon by congratulating the Prime Minister on the formation of his national unity Government and for approval of its Ministerial Declaration through consensus in the Lebanese Parliament. We are paying great attention and providing strong support to the national dialogue process; to the process that must lead to widespread consensus among the Lebanese people regarding a monopoly on the use of legitimate force by the State.

I would also like to express my satisfaction and appreciation to the Prime Minister for the support received by General Asarta from the Lebanese authorities at the start of his mission leading UNIFIL, as well as for the support received by our troops, our more than one thousand soldiers, in southern Lebanon on the United Nations mission to guarantee stability and peace in the region.

Similarly, talks are being held, and we will continue talking at this bilateral meeting, on the Middle East peace process, both from the perspective of the Government of Spain and from the perspective of the rotating Presidency of the European Union, as well as from an EU perspective in general.

Please know that strong diplomatic efforts have been made in the region with the leading players in order to try and set this peace process in motion. I would like to highlight the central role played by Lebanon in this peace process; a central role because a united and stable Lebanon, a Lebanon with a new capacity for relations and cooperation with its neighbours, as seen in the process with Syria, is a factor that directly helps achieve progress on the difficult work involved in any peace process.

We know that when the political dialogue, or rather the lack of political dialogue, in favour of a peace process is what dominates the situation; Lebanon is one of the countries to most suffer from the absence of expectations of peace.

I should point out that there is currently widespread consensus among the main players from the International Community regarding what the peace process should consist of. The Obama Administration, the Quartet and the European Union have established a series of key aspects for this peace process and, of course, we hope that Israel will take the necessary steps to enable a period of dialogue to take place as soon as possible.

Another topic of conversation at our meeting today will be, within the framework for EU-Lebanon relations, the forthcoming Summit of the Union for the Mediterranean in Barcelona; a Summit at which Spain hopes to count on, and we are sure that this will be the case, the active participation of Lebanon. We hope that this Summit in Barcelona, as well as implementing and strengthening all that is meant by the process of the Union for the Mediterranean, will also be able to be a contributing factor that helps support political dialogue in the region and on looking ahead to peace.

There is basically a great understanding between Lebanon and Spain; there is great support from Lebanon to our troops in its territory; there is great support from Spain to unity and stability in Lebanon; there is a strong conviction on the part of Spain regarding the decisive role represented by Lebanon in the peace process; and there is widespread consensus within the International Community regarding the decisive aspects of that peace process we hope can begin as soon as possible.

Thank you for being here today. I welcome you and wish you all the best in your work, doubtlessly difficult work, of leading the Government of Lebanon. Thank you.

Mr Hariri. Thank you, President Rodríguez Zapatero. Ladies and gentlemen of the press, it is a pleasure and an honour for me to be here today, in your capital city.

The timing of my visit has been deliberately scheduled to coincide with Spain holding the rotating Presidency of the European Union. You have a crucial role to play at many levels; something I also said to President Rodríguez Zapatero during the excellent meeting we just held.

The intention declared by Spain to make every necessary effort to achieve peace in our region when Spain took over the Presidency has brought hope to us all. However, the clock ticks on and time is something that is not on our side.

For more than sixty years, the Palestinian people and the Lebanese people have been the victims of injustice. Our lands have been occupied. Despite that, we have still held out our hand to collective peace through the 2002 Arab Peace Initiative.

We support moderation and we believe in diplomacy. However, we have only been met with injustice and another failure would be intolerable. There is ever-increasing extremism being caused and propitiated by the lack of a solution to the Palestine-Israel conflict.

Furthermore, that lack of understanding has no borders.

We hope and believe that Spain can lead the position of the European Union in this peace process and that the rest of the world will follow.

I would like to give my thanks to the people of Spain for having sent their men and women to Lebanon to contribute to the UNIFIL mission it now leads. UNIFIL is truly maintaining stability on our southern border.

During my conversation with the President, I informed him that I am here today with a group of Lebanese business leaders who represent our private business sector because we also wish to strengthen private sector ties between our two countries. We believe that conditions are now also favourable for Spanish investment in Lebanon. We also wish to find like-minded attitudes here in Spain.

I also wish to thank the President for his support and for Spain's contribution to the development of a whole range of sectors in Lebanon. We wish and ask for that support to continue.

Ladies and gentlemen from the press, security and stability should not simply by a temporary luxury for the people of Lebanon but must rather be considered as a permanent necessity. My country is a manifestation of the true values of democracy: liberty, diversity and co-existence. This can only be achieved with peace in the region that gives Palestinians the right to return to a State of their own, with its capital in Jerusalem. We are committed to making that happen and it seems we have found a true partner on this mission in Spain.

Q. The two of you have spoken about re-launching the Middle East Peace Process and now, with the Spanish Presidency, this is one of the priorities. I would like to ask you, Mr Rodríguez Zapatero, whether there is any news regarding all those talks being held by Spain to try and arrive at the Summit of the Union for the Mediterranean in Barcelona with anything more than just hope. Is there anything you can tell us about that?

Also, if you will allow me to ask a question on domestic policy, I would like to hear your assessment of what has been happening in recent days, after the content of the "Gürtel affair" summary was released, affecting the Partido Popular. The latest news is that Mr Bárcenas has stepped down from his position as party treasurer and also as a militant. I would like to know whether you think that is enough or whether he should also leave his seat in the Senado [Upper House of Parliament] and whether you believe that the Partido Popular, and its leader, Mr Rajoy, in particular, is responding as the seriousness of the case might require.

President of the Government. In response to the first question, the news is that we are working on this issue constantly and that next week, here in Spain, we will be working on trying to unite positions and restart that dialogue, Minister Moratinos in particular.

You must know that there has recently been a serious problem, the issue of the settlements, which has slowed down what could have been the recommencement of dialogue. You must also know that the Summit of the Union for the Mediterranean has an agenda that is fundamentally based on the development of economic and environmental collaboration and on intercultural, social dialogue between the European Union and all the countries surrounding the Mediterranean. However, it is clear that if this Summit is one of political success, it would be a good framework in which to help and take steps towards providing incentives and stimulation for dialogue on peace in the region.

I told Prime Minister Hariri that from my point of view, from the point of view of the Government of Spain, we stand at a historic moment for the achievement of such an agreement because this is a time in which the International Community and a large part of the Arab world have a well-defined position and widespread consensus. Furthermore, we trust in the efforts being made by President Obama.

In response to your other question, I will say that, as I have already stated on other occasions, we must respect any issue subject to judicial decisions. I believe that is the logical attitude to be maintained, one of responsibility, by the President of the Government. There are many issues subject to judicial proceedings and I believe I should be prudent, cautious, and respect the work of the Justice System.

On matters of political assessment, there will be another time for that; I don't think this moment of institutional representation with the Prime Minister of Lebanon is the time to speak of such matters.

Q. Prime Minister Hariri, up to what point or at what level can your conversations here, in Spain, contribute to consolidating bilateral relations between Spain and Lebanon?

Mr Hariri. Bilateral relations between Spain and Lebanon have, historically and politically, always been very good. I believe that, in terms of the economy, Spain and Lebanon must mow do everything within our power for bilateral progress between the various business communities of our two countries to become a reality.

I believe that both Spain and Lebanon have a lot to offer, especially because Lebanon has a growing economy. During a very difficult time for the global financial system, a situation being faced by the entire world at the moment, Lebanon is currently experiencing growth of 8%. I think it is very important that Spain should know that.

We believe that these bilateral talks should not only be of a political nature but also economic, and both sides could benefit from this relationship. Furthermore, this would also guarantee political relations between our two countries even further into the future.

Q. I have one question for each of you. I would like to ask Mr Hariri whether you fear, after the recent confrontation in the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, that it is possible we will see a return of emerging violence in the region.

And I would like to ask the President of the Government whether, after publication of the involvement of Judge Garzón, you share the opinion coming out of various sectors that this transmits a bad image for democracy and the Spanish Justice System. I would also like to know whether you share the opinion of your Third Vice-President who describes the involvement of the judge as "absolutely incomprehensible".

Mr Hariri. We are always talking about peace. We do not want to start wars, not even when thinking about the West Bank or the Gaza Strip. That was started by the Israelis, not by the Palestinians.

In our talks with President Rodríguez Zapatero and with other leaders from the International Community, we always say that Israel needs to be told the same thing: you can start as many wars as you like in the Middle East but, at the end of the day, there can only be one political solution to this problem. One cannot avoid a final political solution in the region.

The Israelis have to understand that weapons and destruction only breed hate and extremism. A political solution, with as much consensus as there is in the International Community between the United States, Europe and the Arab world, for moving towards a fair peace in which Palestinians can return to their country with their rights intact, in which Palestinians can have a final status in their country and where the Arab Peace Initiative can be applied; that is the only way for progress to be made in the region.

Of course we have our worries, our concerns, but we have spoken with President Rodríguez Zapatero and with other leaders, and we have said that we clearly do not want there to be problems in the region. It is always Israel that is trying to start little wars here and there in the region to obstruct the peace process.

President of the Government. I feel I must express a general concept regarding the question you have asked me. I know that there is a different opinion to suit everyone about legal decisions such as the one we have heard regarding Judge Garzón; I'm sure it is, and will continue to be, the subject of great controversy.

We live in a State of Law that needs to be preserved and the responsibility of the President of the Government, my responsibility, is to respect the action taken by the Justice System. I think that is the right thing for me to do for the proper functioning of a State of Law, above and beyond any individual opinion that one person may express.

The Government respects the action taken by the Justice System and, if we trust in the State of Law, we must also trust the responsibility I think is appropriate when the issue at hand relates, as this one does, to something with wide-ranging public opinion and that will be the subject of extensive and intense debate.

Therefore, I respect the Justice System, above and beyond individual opinions that are, of course, free in any democratic system; I respect the Justice System and responsibility.

Q. Prime Minister Hariri, Spain currently holds the Presidency of the European Union. What role can it play in enhancing the peace process and what role can it play, alongside the United States, in the region?

Mr Hariri. Obviously, being President of the European Union is not an easy task. I think that holding the Presidency of the European Union today holds serious political and economic importance. What Spain is doing right now is working to move forward with the peace process in order for such a process to emerge. The United States has also manifested its clear commitment to the peace process and I believe that the opinions of President Rodríguez Zapatero and the United States Administration are very close to one another in terms of making progress on that process for peace.

What we must understand is that a failure in this peace process means an implosion in the Middle East and means extremism would flourish throughout the region. And what President Rodríguez Zapatero has been doing, working with Minister Moratinos, has been to insist and urge the Israelis to reach an agreement with the Palestinians. That is precisely what is happening now and it is extremely important that the European Union, the United States and most of the International Community push forward with that agreement between Palestinians and Israelis.

However, I also clearly stated to President Rodríguez Zapatero that any failure in this process will result in a situation for the region that would be extremely hard to overcome. We need the International Community to be credible and we need a process to be begun that can be believed in by the Arab world.

Nineteen years have passed since the Conference in Madrid; we have been waiting a long time. The entire world knows what is needed in this process: Israel needs to move on and I hope that, with the Spanish Presidency and with this United States Administration, something will happen soon.

President of the Government. Thank you.