Press conference of the President of the Government on the balance of the Legislature.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

27 December 2007 · Press conference of the President of the Government on the balance of the Legislature

Context
Zapatero held a year-end press conference on December 27, 2007, presenting a comprehensive balance of his government's actions over the full legislature ahead of upcoming elections.
Main themes
Legislative balance, economic growth, job creation, social dialogue, democratic quality, social rights and welfare, labor reform, infrastructure and innovation, climate change, Spain's international projection, budget transparency, public media independence
Duration
~90 min
98th percentile
Words
10,816
98th percentile
Sentences
387
97th percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
13.8
65th percentile
Syntax
3.25
77th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

387 sentences in 169 paragraphs

President.- Good morning to everyone.

As you know, during the course of the Legislature, I committed to appearing before the media at the end of each session period to present a balance of the Government's actions, assess the political situation, offer a perspective for the future, and, in particular, respond to any questions you may have.

I have fulfilled that commitment. This is the last act of compliance with this commitment, and I trust that this innovation has contributed to improving the democratic quality in our country, a democratic quality that in this Legislature has been boosted by numerous measures voluntarily undertaken by me or by the Government, such as, for example, the oversight of the President of the Government in the Senate, the renunciation of questions from the majority group to the President of the Government, the renunciation of the Accompanying Law, budget transparency, or the new situation of Radiotelevisión Española, which every day guarantees independence, plurality, and consensus.

In any case, today’s appearance is special and unique: it not only marks the end of the year but also signifies the conclusion of the Legislature. It is evident that until the date of the elections, we will continue to govern within the constitutional framework and addressing all the demands of citizens and the country.

Today, I want to provide you with a general balance of what this Legislature has represented, a fruitful legislature in improvements, changes, and reforms for Spain. Spain emerges stronger, Spaniards enjoy a higher level of well-being, the future of all is better prepared and more open to new opportunities, as a modern country.

These have been years of significant economic enhancement for Spain and its productive modernization; years in which more Spaniards, especially women, have accessed employment and in which more citizens have also exited unemployment; years of justice for many, of recognition and enjoyment of new rights; years of preferential attention to social groups that need it most: pensioners, workers earning the Minimum Wage, people with dependencies, or students in need of scholarships; years of providing the necessary physical and technological infrastructures so that in a short time we are among the leading countries; years of recovering from backwardness and preparing for the future with outstanding investments in Research, Development, Innovation, and Education; years of true awareness and real decisions to face the challenge of climate change, and years in which Spain, in its external projection, has unequivocally resonated with the majority will of the Spaniards.

In these four years, we have gone through a phase of intense and continuous economic growth, with an average of 3.7 percent annually. None of the major developed countries in the world has grown in these four years like Spain or increased its wealth like Spain. Moreover, this growth has progressively evolved towards a more productive model, essential to face the changes in a globalized economy that demands us to be increasingly competitive.

In short, Spain today is a much more powerful economy, and Spaniards have greater personal and family income, surpassing, for the first time in the democratic period, countries with which we have always been at a disadvantage. For the first time, we have surpassed one of the major European countries in per capita income, Italy, with the economic growth data from 2006.

No legislature like this one compares to any other regarding job creation, which is the primary objective of a welfare policy in a country: three million new jobs that have placed the unemployment rate in Spain at the lowest level in democracy. More employment, but also somewhat more stable employment thanks to social dialogue that has resulted in twenty agreements between employers, unions, and the Government.

Thus, it is the most fertile period of social peace and the most fertile period of social dialogue and agreements with employers and unions, which has been a determining factor in the economic, employment, and social policy advances we have made in this Legislature.

Permanent contracts have received, as a result of this policy of social agreements, an impetus of a magnitude not recorded in previous reforms. I want to remind you that since the start of the labor reform, 3,300,000 permanent contracts have already been signed. Since then, permanent employment has increased by 910,000 people, and temporary employment has decreased by 152,000, meaning that all new salaried employment created is permanent, and at the same time, temporary and precarious employment is being replaced by stable employment. Consequently, since the reform came into effect, the temporary employment rate has been reduced by two and a half points, down to 31.9 percent, in a trend of necessary reduction for the economy of Spain and, of course, especially for those workers with temporary employment.

This will also have been the Legislature of very important advances in social policy.

There have been supplementary increases of up to 30 percent in minimum pensions. Never in just one legislature has there been such a notable increase in minimum pensions, which have gained purchasing power and have constituted one of the essential axes of all action in economic and social policy by the Government.

We have contributed to recovering the loss of purchasing power of the Minimum Wage, which has increased by 30 percent in this Legislature. Today, we have approved the Royal Decree establishing the Minimum Interprofessional Wage at 600 euros per month, effective January 1, fulfilling the electoral commitment, the investiture commitment, and the agreement between employers and unions. In the period of these four years, the Minimum Interprofessional Wage has risen more than in the previous eight years. It has enormous value in terms of the Government's sensitivity and concern for those workers and Spaniards with the lowest incomes: minimum pensions and the Minimum Interprofessional Wage. In both groups, there has been the largest increase in this Legislature compared to any other Legislature in democracy.

Additionally, we have launched a new pillar of the Welfare State with attention to people in situations of dependency, with a provision for next year of nearly 900 million in the Budget; a Law of Equality between women and men, and support for access to housing, with a provision of nearly 1,400 million for next year.

But in these years, in addition to very strong economic growth, the creation of three million jobs, and these social policies for the sectors with the lowest incomes in our country, we have laid the foundations for the future, firm foundations and a correct course. It is a future in which Spain must be among the best. Therefore, spending on Education has increased by 122 percent, and investment in Research, Development, and Innovation has multiplied by two and a half times. Undoubtedly, this is the period of the greatest increase in investment in innovation in our country in this Legislature.

Spaniards, moreover, enjoy more rights today than four years ago. In this Legislature, very significant laws have been approved that have changed determining aspects of our collective life, laws that expand rights, such as the right to marry for homosexuals, the right to equality in the Equality Law, the rights of the self-employed, and new rights for the disabled.

In this period, we have promoted and Parliament has approved 167 laws: 33 organic laws and 134 ordinary laws. I would like to remind you of some, the most significant based on their nature.

In the area of economy and employment, we have approved the Law on Sustainable Development of Rural Areas; a tax reform reducing taxes on personal income tax and inheritance tax; the Law on Measures to Boost Productivity; the Law on Prevention of Tax Fraud; the Law for the Improvement of Growth and Employment, which is the Social Agreement; the Land Law; the Law on Defense of Competition; the Law on Regulation of the Hydrocarbons Sector; the Law on Regulation of the Electricity Sector; and the Law on Public Sector Contracts.

In the area of social policies, the Dependency Law; the Statute of the Self-Employed Worker; the Social Security Reform; the Law on Insertion Companies; the Statute of Spanish Citizens Abroad; the compatibility of Minimum Widow's Pensions and the SOVI, and health measures against tobacco.

In the area of innovation and modernization, the Law on Electronic Administration, the Law to Promote the Information Society; the Law on Biomedical Research; the Law on Environmental Responsibility; the Law on Air Quality and Protection of the Atmosphere; the Law on Natural Heritage and Biodiversity; the Organic Law of Education; the Law on University Organization; the Law on Reading, Books, and Libraries; the Law on Trade and Greenhouse Gas Emission Rights; the Law on Digital Terrestrial Television; and the Law on Forests.

In what we could call the area of coexistence and democratic quality, the Law against Gender Violence; the National Defense Law; the Military Career Law; the Law on Troops and Sailors; the reforms of the Civil Guard and the National Police Corps; the new Law on the Public Prosecutor's Office; six reforms of Statutes of Autonomy: Andalusia, Aragon, Castile and León, Catalonia, Valencia Community, and the Balearic Islands; the Equality Law; the Historical Memory Law; the Constitutional Court Law; the Reform Law of Radiotelevisión Española; the Film Law; the reforms for road safety; the Law regulating marriage for homosexuals; the new Separation and Divorce Law; the International Adoption Law; the rectification in the Registry of changes of sex, or the Law on the Statute of Public Employees, as well as the laws on Assisted Human Reproduction Techniques and the Medicines Law or Special Regime Laws for the cities of Madrid and Barcelona.

All of this, all these laws and the different actions of the Government, have allowed Spain to experience a significant change in these four years; a change that, above all, has reached the citizens, to the daily lives of citizens, to their living conditions, to the improvement of their living conditions, to well-being, to having more social support, more rights, and more possibilities because, when we came to power, GDP was growing at 2.6 percent, and now it is growing at 3.8 percent. Therefore, the pace of wealth creation has increased significantly. Investments in capital goods that anticipate the future of an economy, its strength, were growing at 4.3 percent, and now they grow at 11.2 percent. Exports were growing at 5 percent, and now they grow at 8 percent. The unemployment rate was 11.5 percent, and now it is 8 percent. The employment rate was 60 percent, and now it is 66 percent. The number of employed was 17,600,000, and today there are 20,500,000 employed in our country. And productivity was growing barely at 0.3 percent, and today it grows at 0.8 percent, confirming the positive evolution of the composition of our growth.

Real wages were growing at least 0.4 percent, and today they grow at 1.4 percent in relation to their ability to gain purchasing power, according to the latest National Accounts report.

In 2003, public accounts were in deficit, 0.35 percent; in the four years of the Socialist Party's Government, we have had a surplus. And I can guarantee you that in 2007 we will close public accounts with at least a surplus of 1.8 percent; undoubtedly, a surplus that most of the more advanced economies in our environment would desire.

The Minimum Wage was 460 euros on January 1, 2004, and on January 1, 2008, it will be 600 euros.

The retirement pension with a dependent spouse in 2004 was 485 euros; in 2008, it will be 659 euros. The widow's pension for those over 65 in 2004 was 412 euros; in 2008, it will be 529 euros. And the Social Security Reserve Fund, despite this notable effort to raise minimum pensions, has increased from 19 billion euros to 52 billion euros that it will have in 2008, thus showing more commitment to minimum pensions, which have improved like in no other Legislature, pensions that are still low, as we all recognize, and at the same time, a notable saving, a very powerful increase in the Reserve Fund, the Social Security piggy bank.

Between 2004 and 2008, there has been a change in policies supporting childbirth and reconciling family life with work life. Today, more than 170,000 fathers have already enjoyed the fifteen-day paternity leave that we established in this Legislature, and to date, 159,000 families have received the birth benefit of 2,500 euros approved in this last year of the Legislature.

Nearly 90,000 people have already been evaluated as dependents and therefore have the immediate prospect of receiving the appropriate benefit, assistance, support from the Public Administrations.

To modernize Spain in this Legislature, 42.5 billion euros have been invested in infrastructures. In 2004, there were 1,100 kilometers of High-Speed Rail; in 2008, there will be 1,800 kilometers and nearly 2,000 under construction. I want to remind you that we are currently the country in the world with the most kilometers of High-Speed Rail under construction.

In 2004, there were 1,550 kilometers of highways and motorways, and in 2008, 1,900.

Protected housing, the support for more real protected housing for Spanish families that have a strong demand for housing, has grown by 60 percent. Each year during this period, in this Legislature, 60 percent more protected homes have been initiated in Spain.

I cannot resist giving a very specific figure, which for me is an expression of the orientation of a Government, from the perspective of its vision of the economy and its vision of the future: Research, Development, and Innovation in 2004 represented an investment of 2.9 billion euros; in 2008, 7.6 billion euros; an increase of 260 percent. It is the largest increase that the Budget has received in a specific area during this period.

In short, the legislature that is now concluding has been a vibrant one, as befits a democracy like ours; a legislature of changes, reforms, economic progress, employment, social policies, rights and freedoms, and technological and innovative strengthening of the country to face the challenges of the future.

It is a legislature in which there have been moments of tension and, undoubtedly, in which many of the reforms and advances have been the result of that tension.

I will not evaluate the different political actors. The Government has governed by fulfilling its electoral program. I began my term by fulfilling a commitment, the withdrawal of troops from Iraq, and today, at the end of this Legislature, we fulfill a new commitment: 600 euros per month in the Minimum Interprofessional Wage. That has been the tone of the Legislature: fulfilling commitments on major issues of foreign policy, such as the withdrawal of troops from Iraq and Spain's position in the world; fulfilling social commitments regarding pensions, the Dependency Law, the Equality Law, social dialogue, and the Statute of Self-Employed Workers, and advances to make a more productive and innovative economy.

What I do want to affirm today is a statement that represents a deep conviction: Spain has improved and has very good prospects for its future. We have advanced economically, in job creation, and in social policies more than those with whom we usually compete in our environment. We are stronger, therefore, as a country, and this allows us to face the future with confidence and a desire to bring about new reforms, new changes, and new objectives for this country.

Spain will continue to grow economically, will continue to create jobs, will continue to strengthen what represents its innovative capacity, and will continue to work, because that is what the vast majority of citizens want, to strengthen and ensure coexistence.

I want, to conclude, to share two reflections. The first is that we have completed the Legislature with stability. The electoral program has been fulfilled, the major laws are in the Official State Bulletin and are already in favor of the citizens; the most important reforms, too. We have had parliamentary support that has allowed us that stability and the fulfillment of the Legislature. To those supports, I want to thank them for their contribution and their willingness to engage in dialogue.

Secondly, the Government has worked with an open attitude and dialogue with all of society, with all political forces, and with all Administrations: Autonomous Communities and Town Halls. There are facts that unequivocally demonstrate this, such as everything we have achieved in the field of social dialogue, in which for the first time the three parties (Government, employers, and unions) have signed twenty agreements, or everything we have advanced in the capacity for dialogue with Autonomous Communities.

Personally, as well, but the entire Government has had a continuous vocation for dialogue with the Autonomous Communities. The best proof of the result of that dialogue is that there has been a very significant reduction in conflict between the State and the Autonomous Communities in the Constitutional Court. And, of course, I have a firm conviction that dialogue and democratic forms of respect in what represents political action, especially at this historical moment for our country and, in general, for what is and means political life in all types of relationships, is a great asset that we certainly preserve.

The presentation has been a bit longer than usual, but I hope you understand given that today we were taking stock of the entire Legislature.

Q.- I wanted to ask you for your assessment of the differences in the socialist video between the Castilian and Catalan versions, as in the latter the word Spain is omitted up to nine times.

President.- The truth is that I cannot give you my opinion because I do not know the video in question. I will give it to you as soon as I know it. I do not know it.

Q.- I wanted to know if you see the illegalization of ANV as imminent.

I also wanted to know if you regret anything in this Legislature and what your best and worst moments have been.

President.- Regarding Acción Nacionalista Vasca, I reaffirm: there is work being done by the State Security Forces and Corps, which are conducting a thorough investigation into the possible link of ANV with Batasuna; that investigation has a judicial seat and, of course, will also have the reference of the Attorney General's Office and the State Attorney's Office.

I have full confidence in the institutions of the Rule of Law, in those called to guarantee compliance with the Law, which logically act with respect to deadlines and with respect to the work of the State Security Forces and Corps.

I can assure you that no one will be above the Law. That is the conviction I express as President of the Government, knowing that the mechanisms of the Rule of Law work. If someone violates or has violated the Law, they will not be able to enjoy the rights that the Law grants for political participation.

I believe that at some point I have highlighted the mistakes that the Government has made. I do not know if there are many precedents for the exposure to the public of mistakes and the assumption of apologies by the Government. There are some that are notable; I recall at this time, as it was last year, on the 29th, before the Barajas attack at T-4, which cost the lives of two people. I expressed it with the utmost deference and solemnity in Parliament as a notable error, obviously. And not long ago, the Government expressed its assumption of responsibility for the error we made in the execution of High-Speed Rail to Barcelona.

To place the two, perhaps, most notable mistakes that have occurred. There have been others, but allow me not to exceed what represents such an undemocratic habit, of something that happens so rarely in democracy, although I think it is healthy, it does not cost anything, and, of course, it is fair that citizens have the right to have, when there has been an error on the part of the Government or a Ministry, it be recognized, apologies be made, and, of course, there be a willingness to try to ensure it does not happen again.

What is the worst and the best moment? The first thing I want to say is that I have a profound gratitude… My gratitude is immense, full, total, absolute, to the citizens who at one time gave me their trust to be President of the Government of Spain, which is perhaps one of the tasks, for me the noblest task, that can be carried out in public life in our country.

Therefore, having that democratic capital, one must have democratic strength, must have temperance, and must be aware of what that represents to try to ensure that your task is one in which complaints and even less lamentations have no place; yes, self-criticism and yes, recognition of mistakes. Why do I say this? Because being President of the Government entails a lot of responsibility, it means making many decisions, and therefore, the aspects that have not been fulfilled and the aspects that have not been fully realizable will always depend on the Government. I am not a political leader who likes to shift the ground of responsibilities to others. I think that is important.

I have had very good moments, as is logical, fundamentally those that involved laws or decisions that contributed to making life a little better for those who need it most in Spanish society.

Q.- A couple of questions of an economic nature. After the balance you have made of the Legislature, do you not regret that at the current moment there are indicators, such as inflation, at the highest level in these four years or the Euribor also at a higher level than in seven years, which significantly harm the purchasing power, the income, of families?

The second question is if you can give us a date for the "very soon" that the Minister of Development mentioned yesterday regarding the arrival of the AVE to Barcelona and if at any time you have considered a change in that portfolio during these times.

President.- I have not considered it, but in these times it would seem a bit absurd, wouldn’t it?

Inflation, which has had a rebound and will maintain that high level, according to the Government's estimate, until the beginning of spring, until March, is not the result, as is well known, of any action by the Government, but rather a consequence of a very strong rise in oil prices and also a strong rise in food prices due to a problem of supply shortages and increased demand in certain regions of the world that, as a result of their economic progress, are entering a consumption segment that had not occurred until now.

In the last Legislature, there were five occasions when inflation was at 4 percent or exceeded 4 percent. Our country has always had a certain tendency to have inflation above the European average. We are practically at the same differential as has been habitual in history.

I know that this, logically, affects purchasing power; especially, it is objective, the purchasing power of those with lower incomes is more affected. But I believe that is why we can say that our concern is for those lower incomes, beyond the rise in inflation, but also taking into account the rise in inflation, with what I have explained during the presentation with the 30 percent increases in minimum pensions for three million pensioners or the 30 percent increase in the Minimum Interprofessional Wage. Undoubtedly, inflation most harms those with lower incomes, those representing the most modest incomes in our society.

On the other hand, I do want to emphasize that per capita income in Spain has increased considerably, reducing significant differences with other European countries; for this reason, we have surpassed Italy in per capita income, and, logically, this means that household income, disposable family income, has had growth; growth that is explained by the three million new jobs in this country, which are three million more people who have income than four years ago. Consequently, it is logical that households have more income above what can be the per capita income.

We have that perspective that inflation may begin to moderate with a downward trend next March. Even so, I want to remind you that wages subject to collective agreements have a revision clause, and of course pensions, depending on inflation, although, as we all know, inflation is not, evidently, a positive figure for the overall economy and also for the purchasing power of many families.

Q.- President, could you specify the "very soon," the measure of time in which…?

President.- The truth is that I have not answered it because I am not going to give you a date, obviously. I believe that the commissioning of the AVE to Barcelona should be when all the work that needs to be done, the construction work and the verification work, which corresponds to ADIF and RENFE, is naturally completed.

Q.- Another of the issues you mentioned when taking stock of the Legislature was the approval of some Statutes. I wanted to refer specifically to the Catalan one. In recent weeks or months, there have been discrepancies between the Catalan Government and the Catalan socialists, as they reproach you for not doing everything in your power to fulfill the development of the Statute. Furthermore, within Catalan socialism, they criticize you for not having enough federalist spirit and ask you to imprint that federalist spirit in the PSOE electoral program and in your government action. What would be your opinion or response?

President.- The reform of the Statutes must be viewed with a certain perspective. The Statute of Catalonia has been reformed after decades of what was the original Statute, the Statute of 1979, and it will deploy its effects, as is reasonable in such an important law, over time.

What I can assure you is that the willingness and dialogue with the Generalitat of Catalonia for the Statute to deploy its effects and for the provisions that imply new competencies and transfers to be applied are continuous. Just yesterday, the Ministry of the Interior concretized one of the new competencies of the Statute in the area of private security, and on January 10, there will be a meeting of the Bilateral Commission between the Government of Spain and the Generalitat, in which new competencies will be advanced.

I believe we need to have a certain perspective that reforms and the implementation of laws of such significance require study, dialogue, and concretization, and they affect multiple aspects of what represents Public Administration.

But I insist, let us give perspective to the balance of what the reform of the Statute of Catalonia represents and the reforms of all the Statutes that contribute to the improvement of self-government and enhance self-government in our country, which has yielded very positive results, especially for the economic and territorial cohesion of Spain. One only has to look at the latest data on regionalized growth from the year 2006, which shows that the distances between the economic growth of different regions are becoming smaller, and that there is a gradual convergence of the different income levels in our country, in a year, evidently, in which there has been very favorable growth for all Autonomous Communities.

Therefore, I have fulfilled the commitment to reform the Statutes, including the Statute of Catalonia, which will have positive effects for Catalonia. The reform of the Statutes of Autonomy, which has been particularly controversial and discussed due to the reform of the Statute of Catalonia, and which has generated moments of tension, when calm arrives, when it is applied, and when its concretizations occur, we will see that what it will do is contribute to the better self-government of Catalonia and that, of course, the whole of Spain continues on the only path I envision for this country, which is that of progress, coexistence, and social advances.

I believe that the position of what represents a constitutional vision of the State of Autonomies is well captured in the reform of the Statutes and is well reflected in the jurisprudence of the Constitutional Court, which ultimately is the voice that interprets, adapts, and modulates what represents the distribution of power between the State and the Autonomous Communities, and I do not think we should be or feel bound by certain concepts that, in practice, when it comes to their implementation in different decentralized countries, have very different models and results.

We have our own model; I insist, it has worked very well for a decentralized State to be more agile, more innovative, to provide opportunities to all territories, to be able to harness all energies, and, of course, to meet the demands for self-government that have historically been of great importance in our country, especially in some Communities.

Q.- Mr. President, a few days ago the Secretary of State for Economy suggested that there was room to lower the Income Tax and even the Corporate Tax in the next Legislature. I would like to know if you can specify this margin based on the reports you have received from the Economic Office or, if applicable, from the Ministry of Economy.

Secondly, if I may ask a more political question, I would like to know if it is in your plans to change the structure of the Government in the next Legislature, in the event that the PSOE wins the elections.

President.- Regarding the first question, I have just mentioned or announced that in 2007 we are going to close with at least a surplus of 1.8 percent in relation to the Gross Domestic Product; I say "at least" because it may be a bit more. This is very good economic news, it is very good news for investors, it is very good news for public finances, and it is very good news for the future.

We have made a tax reform in this Legislature to reduce the Personal Income Tax, particularly regarding labor income, and a reduction, which had not been done in twenty-five years, in the Corporate Tax to facilitate investment and job creation.

There is a commitment for the next Legislature that is explicit and concrete, which is the elimination of the Wealth Tax, which is a burden on our tax system and very few modern European countries still have a Wealth Tax, which also penalizes savings and, therefore, its elimination is advisable. It is also a good signal of the tax model we want to build.

Regarding the Personal Income Tax and the Corporate Tax, allow me to refer to the specifics of the electoral program, which I do not want to address in this appearance from the Presidency of the Government, but rather in what will be the electoral program, in another context, in another forum, preferably more party-oriented than government-oriented.

On your second question, first we have to win in order to make changes in the Government or not. Believe me, that is my objective at this moment, and therefore, there will be time to reflect on that. I can tell you that I am satisfied with the functioning of the Government and its structure.

Q.- Mr. President, in your initial presentation, I do not know if deliberately or not, you did not mention the fight against terrorism, which I believe has also been one of the highlighted issues of this Legislature that is now concluding. My question is whether, now that we know the date of the general elections and we are almost in pre-campaign, can Spanish citizens expect that the two major political parties, which have been at odds over this issue throughout this Legislature, will reach some kind of agreement, as the Head of State requested just a couple of days ago.

Then, I would like a specific assessment of that assessment made by the Basque Government, which compares the attacks of the terrorist group ETA with some judicial sentences.

President.- Regarding the first issue, when I began my career as a political leader of the opposition, after being elected as Secretary General of the Socialist Party, one of the first things I did was propose the Pact for Liberties and against Terrorism with a philosophy: that terrorism, the fight against terrorism, which is an attack on all democrats, on all the rights of all democrats, should be outside the party contest and political controversy. That was my attitude in the opposition, I fulfilled it faithfully, and it has been my attitude as President of the Government.

But it is evident that it does not depend only on the President of the Government. Moreover, for that attitude of unity and consensus to be effective, as the vast majority of Spaniards wish, it depends a lot on the task and attitude of the opposition. This is easily understandable by all citizens.

What does a Government desire in anti-terrorist policy? To have the support of all parties. I gave it. When I had the responsibility of the opposition, I gave all the support without asking for anything in return, and I wish for any future President of the Government, whoever it may be after March 9 or whoever it may be in the future, to have the support of the opposition in the fight against terrorism. It is good for the fight against terrorism and good for the country.

If I do not incorporate what represents anti-terrorist policy, it is precisely out of coherence with that position. When I was the leader of the opposition, whenever I took the podium in Parliament and referred to terrorism, it was to support the Popular Party, the Government of the Popular Party. I believe that is how things should be, and I hope that things will be that way in the future.

Regarding the other question, it is evident. There are absolutely unacceptable comparisons. I refuse to believe that one can make what we can consider a comparison. Absolutely unacceptable and unusual.

Q.- Mr. President, I would like to continue with the issue of terrorism. Indeed, you have skimmed over it in your assessment, and it has been one of the most important aspects of the fight against terrorism. I would like to ask you if you win the next elections, with a view to a new legislature, do you believe that the door should be reopened to dialogue with ETA? And also what would you do if ETA raises the possibility of a truce again, but does not mention the surrender of arms at any time.

President.- It does not seem reasonable at this moment to contemplate future hypotheses or possibilities. What I can assure you, and I have stated, is that there is no expectation of dialogue with the terrorist group ETA, none. I can say it again: no expectation.

Q.- Mr. President, you said some time ago that perspective would be needed to know or assess the effects of the peace process. I wanted to know if, after the months have passed, you consider that your prediction has been fulfilled or disproved, and clarify what effects you were referring to.

On the other hand, there has been a pending issue in this Legislature, which has been the constitutional reform. I wanted to know if it is your intention to recover it in its entirety, if you will renounce any of its points, aside from the inclusion of the European Constitution, obviously, and if you would be willing to include the proposal from the Council of State to delimit the competencies to close the autonomous model.

President.- Regarding the first, the perspective in assessing what these four years of anti-terrorist policy represent will surely be the subject of debate in the electoral campaign, and of course, I refer to that moment.

Regarding the reform of the Constitution, it is easy to understand that the reform of the Constitution is a matter that requires consensus with the two major parties due to the quorum needed for it to be enacted. Therefore, as there has been no intention or desire to reach that majority and to form a consensus around the constitutional reform, there has not been. That is to say, it is not strictly a government program that can be fulfilled by the will of a government; for that, one must have a parliamentary majority.

It is true that now the Popular Party is proposing, in principle, some reforms of the Constitution; there are some that I do not share, others can be discussed. Let us hope that the coming Legislature gives us enough calm to be able to talk about it.

Q.- A debate has arisen in recent days about the limitation of mandates of the President of the Government. I do not know if you want to make any commitment in this regard.

On the other hand, you assured that before the end of the Legislature you would speak about the future of the nuclear power plants in operation and the future of nuclear energy. As I believe there will not be many opportunities left, I would like to know if you plan to say it now.

President.- There are still opportunities, and therefore, I regret to disappoint you; but regarding the future of nuclear energy, I will express my opinion before the end of the Legislature, but not today, as I am already addressing many topics.

Regarding the first question, I will do the same as I did four years ago: I will ask for the trust of the citizens for what can constitutionally be a period of government: four years. And, whenever that corresponds, from my point of view, that is what must be done. Each one will know what they do. I asked four years ago for the trust for four years, and I am extraordinarily grateful that they granted that trust. Now I will ask for it for the next four years.

Q.- Allow me to return to the issue of terrorism. You have already reminded us that you solemnly assumed that you made a mistake with your words last year, but I would like to ask you for a broader reflection on what has happened this year. And twelve months later, what is your assessment of the prospect of the end of violence?

Also, with the elections approaching, do you personally think that ANV will be able to present itself for the elections or not? Do you think that the Batasuna environment may seek some other way to present itself for the elections?

President.- Since I took office as President of the Government, I have worked every day to end terrorist violence or to minimize terrorist violence. For me, it is the first duty of a President of the Government to try to save lives, to try to eliminate violence, terror, murder, extortion, and bombs from our collective life. The first objective: to end violence or to minimize terrorist violence.

The assessment, I insist, as from my point of view cannot and should not be subjected to partisan confrontation, will be made by the citizens, who are the ones who have to assess how a Government has tried to end violence or how it tries every day to ensure that there is the least violence, to reduce the operational capacity of ETA and to detain the maximum number of terrorists, and how others have behaved.

I believe that it contributes to a good understanding of democratic life if each one presents their reasons. I am presenting mine. As a duty, as the first democratic duty, I have worked every day to put an end to violence or to minimize terrorist violence. And I can assure you that the only thing that was not in my mind in that task, nor is it nor will it ever be while I have political responsibilities, is any personal or political calculation. In this matter, it is the only thing that has never been in my mind. Each one has their convictions and their way of being, while being aware that it logically represented risks.

The truth is that for ANV to be legal or illegal, or for ANV to be able to present itself or not, or groups close to Batasuna, to the elections, what matters is the opinion of the Law, because we are in a country that is a State of Law. That is, logically, the opinion and the decision that will be decisive.

The Government fulfills its task, which is to support and urge the State Security Forces and Corps to investigate and inform those who, if applicable, may subject the legality and respectful behavior towards the rule of law of any political formation, in this case of ANV, or of any candidacy in elections.

Q.- In the Legislature, very sensitive initiatives were approved such as the Statute, which has already been discussed, the Resolution in Parliament regarding ETA, the Education Law, or the Law on same-sex marriage with the rejection of the Popular Party. What I wanted to know is whether you consider that democracy has entered a new stage in which consensus is not a sine qua non condition for continuing to advance and if there is a new conception of parliamentary agreements.

A second question. There is a commitment of yours that cooled in the Legislature, which was the reform of the Abortion Law. I wanted to know what has happened and if, appealing to Cervantes' language, you have run into the Church.

President.- I will start with the end. It does not seem that this is a credible issue after, as you have mentioned, some of the modernizing laws and the extension of rights that the Government has implemented.

I have referred to this on some occasions. There is no provision for legislative modification regarding voluntary interruption of pregnancy. We are always open to reflection, but it is not in my will or my idea to propose a reform of the Law on voluntary interruption of pregnancy.

Consensus and dissent are the two axes on which democracy operates. However, I want to make some clarifications that I find appropriate. The core consensus is the constitutional consensus; that is the great consensus. From there, as in all democracies, there is a rule, which is the rule of the majority and the rule of the minority. Those who carry out an electoral program fulfill their obligation to the citizens. They must have an open attitude towards dialogue with those who naturally oppose, but those who naturally oppose must also have an open attitude towards dialogue.

I have the perception that the vast majority of Spaniards think that the Popular Party has not been particularly open to reaching agreements with the Government in these four years. This has been a trend practically from day one. They have been, rather, involved in other matters.

Q.- President, I would like, if you allow me, to insist on a previous question. I would like to know why that reform of the Abortion Law will not be carried out now. What are the reasons why the Socialist Party no longer considers it so urgent and, above all, what explanation did you give to the women of the party and also to many men who were asking for that reform and that extension towards a law of deadlines?

Then, as a second question, looking back with the passage of time and with some detachment, was the episode in Santiago de Chile good, counterproductive, or did it aggravate what many considered to be an excessive public debate around the King during this year?

President.- I will start with the end. At the Summit in Chile, I believe that both the Head of State and the President of the Government did what we had to do, which was not to accept that a Head of State harshly disqualified a former President of the Government of Spain, out of commitment to democracy and respect for the rules in our relations.

Regarding the first question, I have reiterated it, logically. There are not sufficient reasons to support a reform in that direction. That is the argument regarding the application and social consensus around that Law. There are no reasons. It is not to say "it will never be done," but as of today, there are no reasons.

Q.- President, a couple of clarifications on things you have already been responding to here. First, you commented on the error of your statement from a year ago, but getting to the heart of that statement, I would like to ask you if, after everything that has happened and many of the decisions the Government has made, especially in recent months, and some of the police actions that have been carried out, you believe that at this moment we are better or worse than a year ago in the fight against ETA and in the Government's objective to end violence.

On the proposal made by Mr. Rajoy regarding the limitation of mandates, as he has made a somewhat generic assessment, I will be more direct in the question. He says that you are running for four years, and I wanted to know if you are running for the last time to seek four years of Government.

President.- Regarding the first, I know that your question is not intended to induce me to make a mistake, but... I know, I am aware of that, and therefore, I do not think in that direction.

The Government and all the institutions of the rule of law are putting all means to prevent and repress terrorist violence and those who, in one way or another, participate or support actions of that nature.

I said before that surely the electoral debate will include the perspective of anti-terrorist policy. I refer to that moment. What I can assure you is that I have all the determination, all the firmness, and all the confidence to carry out a policy that, as I said before, minimizes ETA's operational capacity and opens the way for the end of terror and horror.

Regarding the other question, I refer to what I have already said. It is very clear. Moreover, in a parliamentary democracy, it seems to me that it is the logical course. I present myself, as I did four years ago, to ask for the trust for the next four years, and for now, my goal is to obtain it.

Q.- My question is related to today's Council of Ministers. I would like to know if a new transfer from the Tagus to the Segura has finally been approved and what is the agreed amount.

President.- Yes, there is a transfer of 48 cubic hectometers.

Q.- President, I wanted to ask you two questions about the balance of the Legislature. One, I wanted to ask if you assume any responsibility for the breakdown of consensuses during this Legislature, including the terrorist one, but not only the terrorist one.

Secondly, you have said that the entire socialist program has been fulfilled, but I wanted to ask you about a very specific but important chapter, which is Justice. The vast majority of the laws committed in that program have not been approved, and many of them have finally stalled in Parliament, including a commitment with which that chapter opened, which was that all processes involving citizens would be resolved within a maximum of two years. I wanted to ask you if you assume that this part has not been fulfilled and if you will recover all that in the next electoral program.

President.- It is true that we have already assumed it as a discourse typical of the political moment and of what this political period has been, but I insist that the great consensuses are in the Constitution.

If we look at the facts, we have reformed six Statutes of Autonomy during this period, and in five there has been consensus. Therefore, there is a much higher percentage of consensus than dissent in the reform of the Statutes of Autonomy.

In anti-terrorist policy, consensus is extremely important, but it is not true that there has been consensus in all periods. Of course, there was in the four years prior to my mandate, as a result of the Pact for Liberties and against Terrorism; but at other times in our democratic stage, coinciding also with the Popular Party in opposition, there were also serious dissents and criticisms towards anti-terrorist policy. Here, the only ones who have not respected a very constructive and positive guideline for democracy, which is not to make confrontation politics with terrorism, during this period have been the opposition.

In the area of Justice, fundamental objectives of our electoral program have been fulfilled: for example, the provision of one thousand new positions for judges and prosecutors; for example, the Law for the Prosecutor's Office, which I just referred to; for example, the modification of the Divorce Law; for example, the modification of various aspects of criminal laws; and, for example, the Law that recognizes and extends marriage rights to homosexuals. In short, a very important chapter of laws that are justice and that are rights and freedoms, and a provision of resources exactly fulfilling the electoral program of providing one thousand positions for judges and prosecutors.

Q.- President, forgive me for insisting on the issue of the limitation of mandates. I will not ask you again if you would opt for a hypothetical third mandate, but I do ask you about a proposal from the Popular Party that requests that this limitation to two mandates be established by Law. I would like to know if you think it is a good idea or, at least, an idea worthy of discussion.

President.- Everything can be discussed, but I do not know if now... They have had the entire Legislature to propose it, and suddenly, they bring it to the electoral program, well... We are in a parliamentary system and, logically, it has very, very specific characteristics. I can tell you that I find it of such value to ask for the trust of the Spaniards for four years, as I did four years ago, that I believe it is coherent, logical, and sensible to do so for each period for which you present yourself. But some may think differently; this is my way of thinking and my way of acting.

You have to govern for the time you are elected, and governing means many things also looking to the future.

Q.- Mr. President, as we are in a dialogue atmosphere typical of this Christmas season, I intend to be good in my questions. In the first of them, in the balance of the Legislature, you state on one of the pages --specifically, on page 135 that, unlike other previous or similar processes, between March 2006 and June 2007, there was no modification in penitentiary policy. Does that mean that cases like that of Iñaki De Juana Chaos did not refer to any type of penitentiary benefit or that it was exclusively for health reasons of the prisoner?

Second question. On Christmas Eve, for the second consecutive year, you held a videoconference with soldiers deployed on missions such as Lebanon, Afghanistan, Kosovo, or Sarajevo from the Palace of La Moncloa. Other Presidents or Prime Ministers of countries like France, Mr. Sarkozy, or Mr. Romano Prodi, or even the Australian Prime Minister, visited the troops in Afghanistan. For the past two years, I believe the last visit dates back to December 2005, you have not visited the troops on these missions. Do you intend to do so in the coming dates, or is it a pending task that we leave for the next Legislature?

Thirdly, and very briefly, I wanted to ask you if you have already written the letter to the Kings, in this case to Their Majesties from the East, and what you are asking for the year 2008.

President.- Regarding the first question, the text says what it says, and it is known that there was no penitentiary policy of transferring prisoners. And regarding the prisoner you refer to, I refer to what the judge of Penitentiary Surveillance stated. But, unlike other processes, and I will not insist on this because it is known, where more than a hundred prisoners were transferred, in this period it was not done. I do not evaluate it; I just state it.

Regarding the second issue, every year I have sent a greeting, a message, a thank you to all the troops we have abroad, who certainly carry out their task with dignity and exemplary; at the same time, I remember those who have lost their lives during this year in those missions, to which, without a doubt, the Armed Forces contribute in an exemplary manner, but also the State Security Forces and Corps.

As you have recalled, I have visited the troops in Afghanistan. It is true that I have the desire to visit the troops in Lebanon. There is only one condition to that circumstance, logically, which is the situation in Lebanon itself. I have always tried to have the maximum support, the maximum closeness, and to be very present in understanding, in the problems, and in the needs of the troops that carry out missions outside of Spain.

The letter to the Magi? No, I have not written the letter.

Q.- President, I wanted to refer to the future. If you are elected or are the majority force in the next Legislature, there are two partners who have been partners in this Legislature, which are PNV and CiU, who in recent months have made a strategic turn in their positions towards more sovereignty, let’s call it that. I would like to know to what extent you think this may hinder your investiture and your performance in the next four years.

In particular, regarding the PNV, I would like to know to what extent this attitude that the PNV has had since the election of Urkullu and the departure of Imaz, who was a person with whom you maintained a good political relationship and rapport, hinders the end of violence.

Then, I would also like an assessment of the situation in Pakistan, of the situation that country is going through after the assassination of Benazir Bhutto.

President.- Regarding the first issue, I must say that we cannot anticipate events. I can assure you that the Socialist Party will aim for a broader majority in the elections on March 9, and in the interest of the country as a whole and stability, I believe that the major parties should have or attempt to have a dialogue with both Convergència i Unió and the Basque Nationalist Party. We must also exercise sufficient caution when making assessments about their political positions, especially when there is an upcoming electoral confrontation and especially when Convergència i Unió is in opposition in Catalonia, and, of course, from my point of view, I believe it is an obligation for all of us, and for my part, it is a reasonable time to evaluate the management of the new President of the Basque Nationalist Party, Mr. Urkullu.

You know, I have expressed it on more than one occasion, that we had a fluid and positive dialogue with Josu Jon Imaz, whose determined personality to eradicate violence is something that everyone must recognize, and I hope that we can continue to have a positive relationship with Mr. Urkullu, the new President of the Basque Nationalist Party. But I believe we must have a certain margin of time to see the evolution of his management and, in any case, be more attentive to the facts than to the statements.

Regarding Pakistan, I have two assessments: a radical condemnation of the assassination suffered yesterday by the former Prime Minister of Pakistan and, secondly, to convey concern about the situation in Pakistan and in the region in general, and about what represents an increase in many areas of cruel, violent, fundamentalist terrorism, which cannot be overlooked by the reflection and action of the International Community.

We will provide all political and diplomatic support so that Pakistan walks only on the path of democracy and can, therefore, have a horizon of stability, which is essential for the region.

Q.- President, I wanted an assessment of this legislature regarding Education. Given the latest PISA report, I wanted to know if you believe that Spanish students are better prepared now than they were four years ago.

President.- We will know that when there is a PISA report in 2008, because, of course, the PISA report is made at the moment it is made, after the young people have seven years of training under the previous government.

I want to convey two ideas in this regard, which I have tried to express before and which I believe are very important for the whole of Spanish society. Our country is positioned, according to all international reports, in a group that we could call the middle group in terms of educational results of our young people or adolescents within the group of developed countries. We do not have great differences with other countries that have great economic strength and have had decades and decades of democratic systems and a higher educational level in historical terms.

If we are in the middle group with shortcomings and a need to improve in many areas, and there are countries that have been at a higher level of education and training of the population in general for twenty or twenty-five years, it means that during this time of the democratic period we have regained ground in terms of our educational level. Is it enough? No. Is there a need for a great effort? Yes. In what directions? In two, basically: to concentrate during the training period with more intensity in reading, mathematics, and languages; and, secondly, to support those students who have more difficulties. Why? Because the difference that separates us, which we have been slightly reducing but which still separates us from the majority of European countries, is the percentage of young people in Spain who have education beyond Compulsory Education.

Therefore, we need to ensure that many more people incorporate themselves, once they finish Compulsory Secondary Education, into what represents further education. For that, where should we focus our efforts? On those who have more problems, and that is why we have implemented a support and reinforcement program, the PROA Program, which is already in 2,500 educational centers, providing more individualized attention to those who have more academic difficulties; that is why we have implemented reading time in classrooms, because we need to improve in reading; that is why we have made an effort in mathematics, and that is why, from different angles, we are making an effort in languages.

When can we make a comparative, objective evaluation with the most advanced countries? I believe we logically need a time in which there is at least one generation that has lived with an educational system, with an educational level, similar to that of the countries with which we compare ourselves in international reports. I think that is quite logical to understand.

If Spain twenty-five years ago had illiteracy rates that were nonexistent in other European countries, our starting position was a more difficult starting position to compete. We are competing and we must improve. But it would be unthinkable that we would have had in these twenty-five or thirty years a change, an improvement in the economy, an economic growth, where we have practically converged with the European Union, if a great educational effort had not been made in our country; an effort that at the beginning of democracy was a democratizing effort through the extension of education to all citizens, especially in the field of the University.

If we adopt this perspective of seeing where we come from, comparing ourselves with other countries, an important effort has been made. Is it enough? No, because we can and must be among the best, also in educational results. We can achieve it.

Q.- Two very specific questions. The first is whether you are in favor of the digital canon and the second is to know what the Government's plans are regarding the Panamanian junker that is stranded off the coast of Cádiz.

President.- Regarding the second, we are making every effort to ensure control and monitoring with the authorities and, of course, to try to prevent any environmental damage or deterioration, and, if it occurs, to repair it, prevent it, and restore it.

Regarding the first, I agree to support intellectual property and the rights that derive from it, just as the most advanced countries in the world do and just as the vast majority of European countries do, because they have support for creators, which is a sign of a country that trusts in the capacity to create and in the ability to generate culture and education as one of the fundamental aspects.

The method we have is the established method, not now but for some time, and which is a consequence of a European Directive. Until someone proposes or does not propose a better method, I am certainly in favor of continuing to support creation and creators and everything that that represents, just as the governments and citizens of the majority of European countries do.

Q.- Returning to the digital canon, the report you presented today emphasizes or highlights that there are twenty-two million internet users and that 50 percent of households are already connected to the network. However, since last week, despite what you just mentioned, all forums on the Internet are declaring you to have lost the battle, even against the PP, which is apparently doing better. Is there any possibility, despite what you just said, that the digital canon will be changed or that some measure will be taken to mitigate the issue of the digital canon if you find alternatives before March 9? Will you not respond at any time to all those comments circulating that what is happening is that you fear the Society of Authors, the lobby, and the artists campaigning on television, rather than the internet users?

President.- What a ruler must look at is the general interest, and among the general interest is respecting the rights that derive from intellectual property. If someone puts on the table a system that guarantees the objective pursued by the digital canon, as is logical, it will be debated. That is what I can say, but I can assure you that, after some of the decisions we have made in this Legislature, for example from day one, I do not believe that this has anything to do with fear, but rather with a sense of responsibility.

Q.- President, I wanted to ask about the Spanish doctor kidnapped in Somalia and whether you will resume the reform of the Senate in the future.

President.- The second is quick, yes, and has a brief answer, right? I will start there. I have expressed on many occasions that it would be advisable; I add, it requires consensus. Until that occurs, we will not see the light. But making the Senate a chamber with more territorial representation would be appropriate.

Regarding the first, with the Spanish doctor and the Argentine nurse, we are making all the arrangements. The Minister of Foreign Affairs is in constant contact with the authorities of that country, we have sent the Ambassador of Kenya there, and, logically, given that it is a delicate situation, you will understand that I must be cautious regarding the immediate horizon. That is the task we are undertaking.

I also spoke yesterday with the President of Argentina, Cristina Kirchner, who was logically interested, to exchange opinions and make the utmost collaboration in order to secure the release of our doctor and the Argentine nurse as soon as possible.

Q.- President, I wanted to know if in this commitment to dialogue with CiU and the PNV that you have made, an offer could be included for them to join the Government.

President.- There is none… That is already a lot to deduce, right? I mean: beyond who governs, what is good for the country is that the two major parties, and I certainly believe it is advisable from the perspective of the Socialist Party, have a reasonable dialogue with Convergència i Unió and the Basque Nationalist Party.

I have not thought up to this moment about anything related to the formation of the Government. First, we have a very important appointment, which is March 9.

Q.- Simply, President, I would like to ask for your assessment of the statements made by the Bishop of Tenerife regarding abuse of minors, statements that have generated a lot of controversy.

President.- I prefer not to make it.

Thank you very much.