Press conference of the President of the Government after his meeting with the President of the Popular Party.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

22 July 2008 · Meeting with the leader of the opposition, Mariano Rajoy

Context
Zapatero held a press conference on 22 July 2008 after meeting opposition leader Rajoy to announce bipartisan agreements on counter-terrorism and justice reform.
Main themes
Fight against ETA terrorism, unity among democrats, government-opposition dialogue, victims of terrorism, rule of law, judicial reform, General Council of the Judiciary, legislative agreements, state security forces, removal of symbols exalting terrorism, criminal legislation reform
Duration
~56 min
95th percentile
Words
6,720
95th percentile
Sentences
208
90th percentile
Readability
40
35th percentile
Grade
15.1
77th percentile
Syntax
3.41
90th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

208 sentences in 101 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon. I want to inform you about the development and the outcome of the meeting I just had with the leader of the opposition, Mr. Rajoy.

As you know, I had summoned Mr. Rajoy to fulfill my commitment made during the Investiture Debate to carry out a government task with dialogue and to seek agreements with all political forces, particularly on state matters, with the main opposition party. That was the objective of this first meeting, and I can anticipate that I can make a positive assessment of its development and results.

It was a meeting with agreements and outcomes, which, without a doubt, is positive, from my perspective, for the functioning of our democratic institutions and, ultimately, for the citizens.

I will refer to those aspects that have been the central elements of the dialogue and the content of the agreements that have been reached. I will start with the issue that, in the thirty years of democracy, has represented the highest aspiration of Spanish society: the fight to end terrorist violence, the fight against ETA terrorism, which, as you well know, just gave us very positive news yesterday, as a result of the effective action of the Civil Guard, of the State Security Forces and Corps, with the arrest of the "Comando Vizcaya."

I want to reiterate today my satisfaction, my congratulations, and all my encouragement to the public servants who carry out such a crucial task for our collective security, which is to fight against terrorists and prevent violent actions.

Terrorism and the fight against terrorism have been the subject of dialogue and agreement; the subject of dialogue, of sharing analyses of the strength that the rule of law has to fight against violence, of sharing the objective of working from understanding in the fight against terrorism and, of course, of sharing support for all public servants in that task.

An understanding in the fight against terrorism between the Government and the main opposition party, which focuses on five principles: the principle of unity among democrats and of creating a shared strategy against terrorism; the second, support for the victims; the third, trust in the rule of law and support for the State Security Forces and Corps; the fourth, reaffirming a solemn political declaration that the only destiny of ETA is to desist from violence and that violence will never achieve any political objective; and, fifth, international cooperation as a shared task in that understanding in the fight against terrorism.

In addition, we have agreed to include in the Law of Solidarity with the Victims of Terrorism a provision regarding the need for all public administrations to adopt measures leading to the removal of shields, insignias, plaques, or other objects, such as street names, squares, avenues, parks, and any type of monuments, that exalt terrorism personally or collectively. Likewise, the Government will study with the Popular Party the criminal legislation to reform, in terrorist crimes and in defense of the rights of victims, the accessory penalties, the security measures against terrorists who are released from prison after serving their sentences, and the mechanisms for preserving the universal heritage present and future of terrorists for the full satisfaction of their civil responsibilities.

This is a commitment to work together and study formulas that complete and improve the legislation in the fight against terrorism and in support of the victims.

This is the principle of understanding and the criteria that integrate that understanding in the fight against terrorism.

You know that I have always maintained a principle, the principle of the necessity of unity among democrats in the fight against terrorism. I reiterated that principle in the Investiture Debate, and today we have materialized an understanding with the main opposition party. Logically, it is fundamental for that understanding and that unity among democrats to be real and effective; it implies sharing, it implies a relationship of understanding, of information, and it implies, as I have just referred to, concrete agreements in legislative matters.

I will also report on this principle of understanding to the rest of the political forces in the meetings I have scheduled with the Spokespersons of the Parliamentary Groups, so that they are aware of it and to invite them to share this principle, this understanding, which has, as I have just emphasized, a special, singular relationship with the main opposition party, as, from my point of view, it is logical that it occurs.

The second issue we have addressed is the issue of Justice and, specifically, what affects the situation of the General Council of the Judiciary, which has been too long without the renewal that should have been carried out legally by now.

We have addressed two issues in relation to Justice: first, we have adopted a series of agreements on the modernization of Justice and on new measures against the most serious crimes; on the other hand, we have agreed on the renewal of the General Council of the Judiciary.

Regarding the modernization of Justice, that agreement incorporates four points, which are: the implementation of the Judicial Office throughout Spain, the massive incorporation of new technologies in the service of Justice, the promotion and extension of rapid criminal and civil trials, and the incorporation into the Law of the Charter of Rights of the Citizen before the Administration of Justice and the strengthening, consequently, of the rights and attention to the victims of crimes. Those are the measures in favor of the modernization of Justice.

As I mentioned, there is another group of measures related to the most serious crimes, which are as follows: the inclusion in the Law of Solidarity with the Victims of Terrorism of the obligation of all Administrations to adopt the measures referred to the removal of shields, insignias, plaques, and other objects or mentions, which I just referred to a moment ago and which, logically, affect the fight against terrorism and the legal reforms in the field of Justice; in addition, to jointly address the tightening of penalties for sexual crimes and the creation of a register of sex offenders. These are two concrete blocks of agreements in terms of measures against the most serious crimes.

I can also announce that today we have agreed that in September we will proceed with the renewal of the General Council of the Judiciary. In September, fulfilling the procedures established in our legal system, both parties will ensure that Parliament renews the General Council of the Judiciary. There is already an agreement, which is logically the important thing, that will materialize in September, and that will be the moment when the names, the members, of the people who are to be in the Judiciary Council will be known.

Likewise, in a matter of great significance due to the importance that the institution represents, we have agreed to proceed with the renewal of the magistrates of the Constitutional Court, which at this moment, and as a result of legal provisions, need to be renewed. There are five magistrates, four corresponding to the Senate and one to the Congress of Deputies. That will also occur immediately after the month of August, at the appropriate time, in accordance with the regulatory provisions of both Chambers.

Therefore, I can also announce that there is an agreement for the renewal of the Constitutional Court, which, from my point of view, constitutes very good news for the strength of the institutions and for the proper functioning of the institutions, and, of course, in a singular way, for the decisive role that our Constitutional Court plays as the guarantor and highest interpreter of the Constitution. This agreement will reinforce the stability of the Constitutional Court and, therefore, we will be in a position to open a phase of strengthening the institutional position of the Constitutional Court.

Finally, I do want to mention that we have had a long dialogue, which at times has turned into a debate, about the economic situation and the prospects for the evolution of the serious difficulties that our economy faces. I conveyed to Mr. Rajoy directly what our forecast for the evolution of the economy was and what our principles of action are, the concrete measures we have taken and those that, if necessary, we can take in light of the evolution of the economic situation. And I offered to maintain an open dialogue about the economic situation through the economic Vice President and the economic team of the Popular Party, which I hope can be concretized.

I reiterate something that you have heard me say on some occasions in recent days and that I conveyed to Mr. Rajoy about the economic situation, the position of the Government, and the policies of the Government in economic matters.

First of all, I conveyed to Mr. Rajoy, just as I want to do before all of you, a principle of confidence in the Spanish economy. The Spanish economy is going through and will go through a period of difficulties, but the Spanish economy, the Spanish society, is strong. The best elements that confirm that strength are in our growth of per capita income, in the growth of the number of citizens who are working, in the good health of public accounts, and in the process of modernization and capitalization that the Spanish economy has undergone.

In the face of the situation of difficulties, principles of the Government, criteria of action: austerity and solidarity; that is, rigor in economic management and maintenance of social policies. This translates, as you already know, into betting on an economic recovery based on productive investment, and hence our effort to maintain investment in infrastructure, in technological capital, and in research and innovation; this translates into being rigorous with public accounts, as we will be in the exercise for the Budget of 2008 and for the Budget of 2009, in accordance with the forecasts that the economic Vice President will make public; and this translates into maintaining our system of social protection, social cohesion, social welfare, for the unemployed, for pensioners, and for families; in short, for workers, for those sectors that are undoubtedly most affected by the slowdown of our economy and by the strong deceleration in job creation.

I must say that, from my point of view, in the debate we had on the economy, Mr. Rajoy did not provide any ideas that could be considered novel and, of course, that have or could have any significance for the evolution of our economic policy and our economic situation. I conveyed to him and explained that rigor, work, and social policy are the three keys to being able to face the period of difficulties that we are going to go through and to prepare for the economic recovery that, without a doubt, the Spanish economy will have, in which I have full confidence.

I have given you a summary as concise as possible, but I am sure that your questions will enrich what is the balance of this meeting, which, I insist, from my point of view, has been positive.

Q.- President, I would like to ask you a couple of questions. On the one hand, these five principles in the fight against terrorism that you and Mr. Rajoy have agreed upon, will you also convey them to the rest of the Spokespersons of the Groups who will come to Moncloa next week, and would an anti-terrorist pact be renewed, instead of just between two, with everyone? How will that matter be resolved?

On the other hand, in economic policy, I would like to know if in that debate you had with Mr. Rajoy, for example, the news today from the Ministry of Housing where the Minister herself announced that they will buy public land, that they will make public land available. Did you discuss that with Mr. Rajoy, and did he mention anything to you?

President.- Regarding the first question, I have just referred to the principles of understanding between the Government and the Popular Party in the field of anti-terrorism. I believe that, after what we saw in the last Legislature, it is extraordinarily important that we have materialized these five principles of understanding and those two legal reforms to which I have just referred.

You can already understand that this has been the result of weeks of work, carried out by spokespeople from the Government, from the Parliamentary Group, and from the Popular Party. That work has been positive. I want to acknowledge those who have participated in it because we have reached a consensus on those principles of understanding.

Of course, I will explain to all political forces those five principles of understanding and those two reforms, from the security, strength, and tranquility that having the agreement between the main opposition party and the Government of Spain entails. It is about making the unity of democrats as real and broad as possible, from the principles of trust and understanding, which is what the vast majority of Spanish citizens want, in my view.

Secondly, the Minister of Housing has announced today, in fact, that through the Ministry, through the public body known as SEPES that manages land, we are going to proceed, through legal channels and the appropriate competitions, to the purchase, to the acquisition, of land for an amount of three hundred million euros. The objective is very simple; the objective is to expedite and meet the goals for the launch of the official protected housing that we have committed to.

We have a very strong commitment to promote and support official protected housing. For this, in many places, land availability is needed and, therefore, the goal is for the Government to make land available to economic agents and to Communities and Town Halls to build official promotion housing, which, as everyone knows, are those homes that allow citizens to buy a home in a more accessible way.

I believe I have heard at some point that the Popular Party was against this measure. It is true that this is not a novelty, because the Popular Party has never been very supportive of protected housing. We are firm supporters of protected housing because it is a social policy in housing that benefits citizens.

Q.- Has Mr. Rajoy said anything specific to you about this issue?

President.- No. He will surely say it himself.

Q.- I had a couple of questions. Regarding the modernization of Justice, I notice that among the agreed points, the chapter on decentralization does not appear: strengthening the Superior Courts of Justice, Autonomous Councils, etc. I would like to know if this means that there is no agreement, but that the socialist government will carry it out despite the opposition of the Popular Party; or if this agreement presupposes that this issue is set aside sine die.

Secondly, I would like to know if, in the context of comments on the economic situation, they have talked about the prospects of reaching an agreement on autonomous financing this year so that it comes into effect next year, after the rejection generated by Mr. Solbes' proposal among all the Autonomous Communities.

President.- The agreement on content regarding Justice is the one I just referred to and affects the modernization of Justice and the reform regarding very serious crimes. That does not mean that we cannot dialogue about legislative reforms or the completion of legislative reforms that are underway in other areas, but what we have agreed on is this. It is directly intended to make Justice more effective, more agile, and therefore respond to the expectations that society has of having a Justice that works better. We contribute to this with this agreement on modernization, which we will fulfill, and also by renewing the Council of the Judiciary, which is an institution that, logically, has important competencies for the functioning of Justice.

Secondly, we have not talked about autonomous financing. You can understand that the density of the topics was already quite broad, and the only thing I must say about this is that the Government has fulfilled its commitments: one, it has fulfilled presenting a document for the reform of financing, that is, it has fulfilled launching the reform of autonomous financing; it has fulfilled by calling everyone and is fulfilling by dialoguing bilaterally.

The Autonomous Communities have expressed their opinions, and now we enter the phase of more dialogue and negotiation, as has always happened when the model of autonomous financing is reformed.

The Government has firm criteria and principles on how the model should be. Among those firm criteria is, of course, respect for the Statutes of Autonomy and the Organic Law of Financing of Autonomous Communities, and the Government is also open to dialogue, to listen to suggestions, criteria, initiatives, and to be able in that process, which is multilateral and bilateral, to reach an agreement on autonomous financing, for which we are going to work and which I trust we will successfully conclude, knowing that we are facing a debate where, as is logical and natural, each Autonomous Community will defend its interests based on its needs.

The Autonomous Communities in our country have a diversity from the point of view of their per capita income, their population configuration, or from the perspective of many different issues. Therefore, we will take the time necessary for dialogue and negotiation.

Q.- President, I would like to ask you about two issues. On the subject of Justice, aside from agreements such as, for example, toughening penalties for very serious crimes, which seem obvious and no one could oppose such a thing, or modernizing the judicial system, to which no one could oppose either, I would like to know if you have talked about a topic that could indeed raise problems, which is the names to preside over the main bodies, for example, the General Council of the Judiciary and the Supreme Court, which is the same President, before the judicial year opens solemnly on September 15. That is, have you already discussed those names or is there already a shortlist or a group of names likely to garner the consensus of the main political groups?

I would also like to know, on the economic issue, if you have the impression that Mr. Rajoy found the recipe you presented sufficient or satisfactory, in such a way that you believe it would be possible to reach a grand economic pact, not only with the PP but with other political groups, something that has even been compared to the Moncloa Pacts; or if, on the contrary, that is going to be the great battleground and opposition, at least until the middle of the Legislature.

President.- Regarding the first, we have not talked about names. We have talked about criteria and, as the criteria are agreed upon, the agreement will materialize; and the names, in due time. But I can guarantee you that the agreement will be finalized in September.

Secondly, I have made an effort to explain to you what the analysis of the economic situation was and the measures that the Government has underway, and the evaluation of the possible future evolution of our economy.

From what we have learned over the past few weeks, the Popular Party seems to have ideas that it has put on the table or measures that have come up at some point in the dialogue related to a strong reduction of public spending, up to 2 percent, and with a proposal to lower the Corporate Tax, which, by the way, has just occurred; therefore, I believe it is a measure that is already underway. And, as I said, they have made certain suggestions regarding housing or have opposed what is the process of purchasing land by the Ministry of Housing.

In the end, the only issue that is the subject or can be the subject of discussion is the restriction of public spending by only increasing it by 2 percent next year. I have even seen them evoke the measures of 1996, when they came to power. Notice that at that time the public deficit was 4.7 percent of GDP and now we barely have a few tenths, as the Secretary of State for Budgets and Expenditure has just reported.

I must tell you that the Government is not in favor of that restriction of spending because it would affect, at least, some of the following matters: either the remuneration and the increase in the remuneration of public employees, and we are going to maintain the increase that is agreed upon with public employees; or it would affect the capacity and the need for minimum pensions and the increase of minimum pensions, and we are going to maintain the criterion of increasing minimum pensions; or it would affect the development and application of the Dependency Law, and we are going to maintain the commitments for the development of the Dependency Law. It would affect issues as relevant as these, I insist, when we have a budgetary situation, from the point of view of the health of public accounts, that is within the best times of democracy.

On this, we do not agree. I have said it: rigor, yes, and we are going to apply it in the vast majority of budgetary items; but solidarity and, therefore, maintenance of social policies. That restriction of public spending that the PP points to would approach two billion euros and the remuneration evolution, for example, of public employees is eight hundred million euros. When it is said that spending is going to be restricted and cut, it must be said from where.

We have just signed an agreement on Justice where the Popular Party has requested that spending on the functioning of Justice be increased. This is Chapter one and Chapter two, as everyone can know; that is, personnel expenses or operating expenses. Therefore, what cannot be done is to ask with one hand to lower public spending and with the other to ask to increase spending on Justice or for all provincial capitals to be connected by High Speed, as they have included in some of their proposals in Parliament.

That is to say, a little coherent work must be done and what is coherent, in light of how our public accounts are, is to have rigor and austerity in the majority of budgetary items, except those that affect social policies and you know which ones are for the Government: housing, dependency, birth aid, minimum pensions, and also remuneration of public employees.

Q.- President, I wanted to ask you if after this interview you consider that four years of tension have come to an end and that the lost trust in the leader of the opposition has been recovered.

President.- Regarding the second question, trust or distrust is given and taken away by the citizens, and I will always respect those whom the citizens and the party, in this case, which is the main opposition party, have at the forefront. It has been my characteristic in my public career. I have always had respect and have always been willing to dialogue with whoever was the President of the Government until 2004, with Mr. Aznar, and, when I was elected President of the Government, I have always had all the willingness to dialogue and respect, which is a democratic principle, with the leader of the opposition. I believe it is good for democracy and that citizens value it.

It has been ten times that Mr. Rajoy and I have met, including today, always at my request or almost always convened by me. Today's meeting has been, I have said, positive.

Having an understanding in the fight against terrorism is very important, much more after having lived through a legislature where terrorism was a central issue in the confrontation and in political opposition.

Having an agreement to renew the bodies of Justice is positive and we have achieved this in the hundred days since the Government began to function, because, as everyone can imagine, there is a lot of work from many people to reach these agreements. Therefore, it is positive.

Does this augur, anticipate, a more serene political climate, as citizens want? My opinion is that yes, and we all must contribute to make this "yes" an unequivocal "yes." I will do my part, and of course the Government and the Socialist Party will, and I hope and trust that the Popular Party and Mr. Rajoy will do so as well.

Q.- President, since you have told us that you have not agreed on names for the renewal of the judicial bodies, but rather on criteria, I would like to know if you could reveal those criteria that you have agreed upon for the renewal.

President.- There has been some criterion that is always put forward when we are talking about choosing people who will occupy responsibilities of such institutional importance, and there has been one that I have suggested to Mr. Rajoy as a reminder that, of course, the Government will apply faithfully: the first is the criterion of maximum professionalism to fill those positions and the second criterion that I have suggested or reminded Mr. Rajoy is that we present a balanced proposal between men and women. No one should be surprised that I have been the one to remind this fact. We are going to do it and I hope that the Popular Party will do so as well.

Q.- First, I wanted a clarification, because you have talked about signing a declaration on anti-terrorism. I wanted to know if this means that you are going to sign a new Anti-Terrorism Pact, a document, a paper.

On the other hand, regarding the renewal of institutional bodies, I wanted to know what the distribution of power you have agreed upon is, because this was one of the things that precisely made the agreement unfeasible. I wanted to know if the PP maintains the blocking minority in the CGPJ.

Regarding the renewal of the Constitutional Court, has the PP accepted the Senate's election in which the autonomous parliaments participate?

President.- Regarding the first, I do not believe I have spoken at any time about a signature; I have spoken of an understanding that is concretized in five principles that constitute a declaration. I will tell you that I believe it is the best demonstration of the trust with which we have worked and with which we approach that democratic unity against terrorism that, concerning the Popular Party and the Socialist Party, the main opposition party and the governing party, is a reinforced unity against terrorism.

Therefore, the understanding is concretized in those points and in the meeting, in the word, in the agreement we have had and in the joint work that will be carried out regarding shared information and communication of initiatives between the government officials in this matter, between the Minister of the Interior and the person responsible for this matter from the Popular Party; who, by the way, have already been working these last few weeks and have done positive work that has yielded evident results.

Secondly, the names, since I have spoken about the criteria, and the composition of what will be the Council of the Judiciary and the judges that need to be renewed from the Constitutional Court will be known in September, as is natural and logical. It would be, I believe, procedurally absurd at this moment to advance further in that direction. The only thing I tell you is that there is an agreement, that is what is important, and that the agreement will materialize and much more when we have to specify and propose the names in the appropriate process.

Q.- Mr. President, just a clarification. You said a moment ago, at the beginning of your speech, that Mariano Rajoy, when he was talking about the economic difficulties and the slowdown of our economy, had provided some novel idea and it seemed to me...

President.- No. That he had not provided.

Q.- Ah, sorry. I understood that he had contributed. It was just to reveal to us precisely what it was. Clarified then.

President.- No, no.

Q.- Mr. President, a curiosity. When you have now confirmed that public land will finally be purchased through SEPES, those of us who cover economic news are aware that Martinsa-Fadesa is the owner of the largest amount of public land in this country at the moment in terms of real estate; either the first or the second. So, I want to know if you do not fear that this will be interpreted as a covert aid, finally, to real estate companies; whether covert or overt, if it is a change of criteria, if these three hundred million are expandable and if, as more bankruptcies among real estate companies are expected this autumn, the three hundred million are expandable.

Secondly, regarding the issue of an economic State Pact that has been raised, and Mr. Duran i Lleida already did so in his last intervention in Congress, I would like to know if starting in September, when the State Budgets are already being negotiated and, according to national and international forecasts, the economic climate worsens, your position on a possible State Pact, whether it be the old Moncloa Pacts, new ones, old ones, is categorically negative or if you do not rule it out. With whom do you think, if not, to approve the Budgets?

President.- Regarding the first point, I have already explained it before and, moreover, the facts will support the proposal that the Minister of Housing has announced today, it is about mobilizing land for protected housing and, therefore, it is about making a push, an acceleration, so that more families can access housing and so that, logically, the sector builds those houses, among other reasons, because of the amount, which is for the entire process and which is the initial amount. We will see how it works, because I believe that prudence always advises these things.

It will be verified that absolutely nothing has to do with the situation of any real estate company, where we have already established what our principles are clearly and in an eloquent way with the facts.

Secondly, the Government has a task regarding economic policy which is to achieve the maximum possible understanding and agreements. If you ask me what is, in order of priorities, the most important objectively, even recalling what the Moncloa Pacts were, although the situation is so different, the social agreement, because in those Pacts the social component, the social component of employers and unions, was decisive; it was the most decisive.

That is to say, the first task, because I believe it is the most important, is to achieve a social agreement with employers and unions. That generates trust, generates commitments and generates social peace, social understanding.

Secondly, the Government is open, of course, if we are also going to have a budgetary debate, to consider initiatives and proposals that we deem reasonable and that, moreover, respect our political commitments to citizens. The main political commitments I have with citizens are the commitments of social policy, which have to do with the fact that I will not accept any labor market reform if there is no agreement with the unions and employers, and that I will maintain my commitment to raise minimum pensions, to develop the Dependency Law and to maintain housing assistance.

These are commitments to the citizenry, social commitments, that I will maintain, and moreover we can maintain, and the Government will demonstrate that they can be maintained, despite the fact that some, I do not know if it is because they would like to or for another reason, could question them.

We will maintain social policy out of conviction, out of commitment to the citizenry and because, moreover, we can do it, because we have managed public accounts well.

We will always be open to other proposals and, regarding specific proposals, to reach agreements. Hopefully in the budgetary process that can be as broad and extensible as possible; but the Government, of course, will apply the principle of coherence and the principle of coherence has to do, among other things, with what I have just referred to: one cannot, on the one hand, ask for a restriction of public spending and, on the other, increase public spending. In the budgetary debate, with the amendments in hand, we will see what agreements we can reach and we will see the coherence that we all can and must maintain. Of course, the Government will maintain it, the one I have just mentioned. It is a very determined course.

Q.- Now that the parliamentary session has ended and we are facing an economic crisis more serious than it was three months ago, I would like to know if you maintain the theory that the Government can continue, let’s say, its parliamentary path autonomously, as it started the Legislature, or do you think, come September or October, it would be better to have a pact with CiU, a stable pact, that guarantees that you do not have to live through the scares that you have experienced parliamentarily this June.

President.- It is true that in the last Legislature we did not have a majority by ourselves in Parliament; now we have five more deputies and, as this is a Government and a project that makes dialogue one of its main hallmarks, we know that the effort of dialogue that the Government makes and will make will allow us to carry out and develop our political project and have the necessary support.

Q.- You have referred to what I am going to ask you, but I want to do it directly. Can it be said that with today’s meeting the tension that characterized the previous Legislature has been buried?

Secondly, you have already said that they have not talked about autonomous financing. In some way, have they talked in this meeting about the territorial issue, which was also one of the most confrontational topics of the last Legislature?

President.- It seems that things have changed, it is evident. We have not talked about any territorial issue; we have talked about a matter that has a certain territorial implication, which is the Dependency Law, regarding its development, and we have also agreed on the convenience of continuing to talk. Obviously, in the fight against terrorism we have moved from a situation of clear confrontation, where we lived the opposition around this issue, to a situation of understanding. Therefore, there is an important difference; but it is normal, because citizens have voted between these two moments.

You know that my conception of democratic political life always has a beginning and a final place that explains everything, and things are explained because citizens vote and give mandates to political parties, which must attend to them. And, in my opinion, on March 14 a political mandate was given to those who won the elections and to those who lost them, which was a clear mandate for more dialogue and more understanding. It is the citizens. Beyond personal attitudes or circumstances, it is the citizens. That is the greatness of democracy.

Q.- I would like to know your opinion on whether the Government can do more than it is doing and the measures it has already adopted to facilitate the injection of liquidity into the financial system in light of the difficulties that companies and banking entities are facing, and if you have addressed this specific issue with the leader of the PP.

President.- Yes, we have discussed it at some point. I have already expressed my view. I believe we must let the market economy function. Some countries have taken measures regarding liquidity. I invite you to check the results. Surely, they have not been what was sought.

Of course, and I have said it many times, out of a principle of responsibility and conviction about what should be done in the economy, we will not mortgage the future of public accounts or the Treasury. We are not going to do it. It would be, in my opinion, a mistake.

We are fully aware that the financial crisis originated in the United States with the subprime mortgages has caused a difficult situation in the financial market. It is much more costly to access credit and liquidity but, of course, if someone thinks that the remedy lies in making the public sector intervene or invade the market, I sincerely believe that the facts have shown that it is not true and that it would be... not even bread for today and hunger for tomorrow. There would be no bread for today and, of course, hunger for tomorrow.

Q.- Mr. President, you have said that things have changed. I would like to know, in your opinion, who has changed, the Government or the opposition?

Then you spoke about the purchase of land, which has nothing to do with the rescue of Martinsa, but would you accept that the purchase of land has a positive indirect effect of injecting liquidity into Martinsa?

Finally, can you explain why the ICO has granted a loan to Reyal Urbis and did not do so to Martinsa?

President.- The second question, to be honest, I do not know and I cannot answer you. I am not aware, as you can understand, of the loans that, always with rigor and seriousness, the ICO grants and has, moreover, an established tradition in that direction.

Regarding the measure, I have already said it indirectly and I will say it more clearly now: it is three hundred million euros. If you know the sector well and know what it represents or the difficulties as a consequence of the investment and the indebtedness that the real estate sector has, you will realize that it does not have a relationship nor does it have that objective.

By the way, I must say that we must have, as the Government does, the utmost concern for what may happen in the real estate sector; but I must remind you that we have, and that is extraordinarily important, because perhaps it is the greatest asset we have to face this situation and to emerge strengthened when the economic recovery comes, an extraordinarily solid financial system. We have the large banks that are among the strongest banks in the world at this moment and that is an asset that we must preserve, because it will give us a great boost in the context of recovery of the cycle.

Q.- I do not know if you have discussed this, Mr. President, but wouldn’t it be advisable for the two major parties to have a common action to curb the temptation to hold a consultation by Lehendakari Ibarretxe?

Secondly, since this is the last question, if you allow me, I know that you have not agreed on the solutions, but have you agreed on the diagnosis of the economic situation?

President.- We have analyzed what the economic situation is. Basically, I have given you a series of data on the evolution we foresee regarding the major macroeconomic figures and employment, and the starting point of that dialogue has been precisely liquidity, based on the observation that Mr. Rajoy has made to me, which I share, of the difficulties that companies may have. But there has not been, let’s say, a common analysis in depth by both parties of the economic situation because, more or less, we all know what the difficulties we have are, the risks we are facing and what affects families and what affects purchasing power. We have also talked about the evolution of oil prices, etc., etc.

Yes, we have talked, and it has been until now a forgetfulness I have had, about the Ibarretxe Plan, indeed. We have talked about the Ibarretxe Plan from a climate of clear understanding and sharing, and thus we have materialized the resources to the Constitutional Court for the High Court to declare unconstitutional the law that intended to enable that consultation by Mr. Ibarretxe. We have both agreed on the unconstitutionality, on the unfeasibility and that, logically, such a consultation will not be held. There is a clear coincidence in that area.

Thank you very much to all.