Press conference of the President of the Government and the Prime Minister of the Hellenic Republic
José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Zapatero held a joint press conference in Madrid with Greek Prime Minister Karamanlis on July 12, 2009, ahead of the Spanish EU Presidency.
- Main themes
- Illegal immigration, Spanish EU Presidency, economic crisis and recovery, EU institutional reform, Treaty of Lisbon, FRONTEX and border control, readmission agreements, Union for the Mediterranean, Spain-Greece bilateral relations, G-20 and European Council agreements, Lisbon Strategy renewal
- Duration
- ~27 min
- Words
- 3,281
- Sentences
- 119
- Readability
- 39
- Grade
- 14.4
- Syntax
- 3.17
- Vocabulary
- 2.11
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
119 sentences in 58 paragraphs
President.- Good morning. In the first place, I am very satisfied for having the Prime Minister of Greece, our friend Kostas Karamanlis, and his delegation here, in Madrid, to attend this working meeting we will resume later on and which has focused on the economic situation, on the evolution of the economic crisis, on the relevance of the Spanish EU Presidency and on the issues that Greece deems more relevant for that Spanish EU Presidency.
As to the crisis and the economic situation, we have agreed that according to the prudent, moderate forecasts, the prospects concerning the evolution of economy are less negative right now - as compared to the first quarter - and we must face two main tasks:
firstly, implementing, consolidating all the agreements set forth by the G-20, by the European Council and approved by the Commission in order to stabilise and strengthen the financial system and in order to guarantee its future; secondly, bringing about economic recovery - which we think will start by 2010, during the first half of 2010 - according to a more sustainable, solid economic growth. Hence, during the Spanish EU Presidency, the renewal of the Strategy of Lisbon will be the main axis for enhancing and promoting economic recovery.
We have also decided that if the Treaty of Lisbon is ratified in the end by all the countries involved -as you all know, the referendum in Ireland will take place next 2 October--, the Spanish EU Presidency will also have to implement the new Treaty. This is particularly relevant as far as the institutional balance between the main EU authorities, the new President of the Council and his relationships with the European Parliament and the Commission is concerned.
And, the main issue we have been dealing with, the issue we have decided to work on intensely over the next few months, until the Spanish EU Presidency starts, is the question of immigration and, more specially, illegal immigration. During the last European Council a new Resolution, promoted by different countries and, mainly, by Greece, which focused on the increase of illegal immigration entering through the Eastern Mediterranean into Greece, Italy and other Mediterranean EU countries.
As you all know, over the last few years, Spain has had to fight illegal immigration entering mainly through the Eastern Mediterranean and through the Atlantic more firmly, with more decision and setting up more conditions, and the results have been progressively more favourable from the point of view of illegal immigration, from the point of view of the return of illegal immigrants to their countries of origin, of the strengthening of border control and of political cooperation with the countries of origin of immigrants.
We have decided to create a new space, to open up a new space of political consensus about illegal immigration from the Mediterranean over the next few months, during the first stage of the Union for the Mediterranean. That space, in our opinion, must be based upon two main pillars, namely, the countries of origin and transit for immigrants, and the countries of destiny of illegal immigrants. Without firm cooperation, the goals cannot be attained. That will be the first stage.
The second will take place during the Spanish EU Presidency. During the Spanish EU Presidency we intend to strengthen three main areas of political action as far as illegal immigration is concerned:
reinforcing and enhancing FRONTEX, the media and the resources in FRONTEX; then, strengthening, enhancing, carrying out and forming stable EU structures and actions concerning readmission agreements with third countries; and, finally, implementing an immigration policy supported by a diplomatic policy, a policy of presence and association with the different countries of origin. there can't be an efficient immigration policy if we lack a policy of association with the countries of origin and transit, and as far as the different migratory flows are concern, the same situation can be spotted:
we must face the challenge of the migratory flow from Eastern Mediterranean, we are going to do it and we are going to do it cooperating with the Government of Greece and with the rest of the most directly affected Governments.
Furthermore, we have talked about the bilateral relationships between Spain and Greece, and we will keep doing so. Our relationships are very good. We have so many things in common:, at the economic level, we have a growing relationship; at the cultural level, we have a flowing relationship and at the political level we agree almost always. If there are two countries that see eye to eye in all the debates of the Council of the European Union those countries are Greece and Portugal; Greece-Spain-Portugal, Portugal-Greece-Spain. Our countries usually have a shared approach to the different problems.
I would like to thank you again for being here, Kostas, and welcome. You know that our Government appreciates you and we are interested in starting up a fertile cooperation with Greece to solve the common and the bilateral problems.
Mr. Karamanlis.-
Journalist. - I have a question for you both. In the recent elections both your parties came second because the opposition parties won by quite a large margin. Do you think this is a warning for the national elections?
I also wanted to say that both countries have a very large deficit. Are you considering adopting measures such as new rates and new taxes to help resolve this problem?
Mr. Karamanlis.-
President.- As for the first question, we should take into account the electoral results each time, but each electoral process has its own goals and aims. My party has won the last two general elections and, in fact, we intend to win the next one too, just as we have done in the different municipal elections, sometimes with more votes, sometimes with fewer votes.
That is to say, elections are different each time. We must listen to citizens and try to understand them, but our party will try to win the next elections, of course. As for the deficit, we are going through an extraordinary stage because we are living an exceptional economic crisis, it is the hardest one since the Great Depression back in the 20th century, and it demands a fiscal thrust, which has provoked a deficit.
The economic crisis would rather probably have worsened were it not for the fact that the different Governments made a fiscal effort. Yet, this extraordinary effort must be limited in time. We need to have healthy public accounts.
The Government of Spain has a plan to recover the Stability Pact which consists in keeping the deficit under 3% in 2012, and we are going to make it, just like when we obtained a surplus in the public accounts during the period of economic growth.
Thus, the deficit is necessary right now and we must reach the deficit rates contemplated in the Stability Pact by 2012.
Mr. Karamanlis.-
Journalist. - I have a question for each of you. My question for the Greek Prime Minister is about the Union for the Mediterranean. You have spoken about the importance of this Spanish initiative for both our countries, and I would like to know whether Greece has any intention of taking advantage of Spain's presidency of the European Union and setting up definite initiatives to re-launch this initiative, which is sometimes misunderstood by our Northern neighbours in the European Union. That's the first question.
I have a couple of questions for the Spanish President.
Mr Rodríguez Zapatero, I would like to know whether the agreement on the financing model for the Autonomous Regions that you reached this weekend can level out your Government's path in terms of future parliamentary combinations to be approved, such as the Budgets in Congress. What do you think about the Partido Popular's criticism of some autonomous regions, some of whose presidents have already threatened this new system with resorting to any legal means available?
Mr. Karamanlis.-
President.- As for the questions you have just asked, mainly that about regional financing, I must say that the Government has passed a model that will get a consensus, a good model of regional financing. This model leads to greater social and territorial cohesion:
greater social cohesion because it increase the resources for health care, education and social services, and that means more social cohesion; and more territorial cohesion because the system becomes fairer: the per capita financing in the different Autonomous Regions is averaged. It is fairer, it favours territorial cohesion and it is more integrating for our country.
As to the criticism, the thing is that we have carried out a debate and we keep discussing it with the different Autonomous Regions. I think that most of desires, the proposals put forward by the different Autonomous Regions ruled by the People's Party so far are contemplated in the model.
But there is one thing I fail to understand and I think they should explain it: either they support Montoro's theory or they support, for instance, the theory of the President of Valencia; because Montoro says "no more money for regional financing, because that brings about deficit" and the PP Regions, most of them, say:
"we want more money". They should make up their mind. These two postulates are rather contradictory and, hence, I conclude that there is certain confusion, or an incoherent strategy, or they are saying "yes" and "no" at the same time to the same project. They must make up their minds.
Furthermore, as to some of the resources you are referring to, because I know you are talking about Madrid, I must tell the President of the Community of Madrid that are completely wrong in this regard; citizens, all citizens in Madrid and in the different Autonomous Regions are contemplated by this model, which is updated for the first time on a yearly basis and which is based upon the 2007 data, because that was when the last liquidation was carried out, as usual, because those are the real data we have to carry out the simulation, the so-called base model; which is updated on a yearly basis as far as our population is concerned.
Hence, I think that the Community of Madrid has already been explained all this. They should not keep searching for an excuse.
I think that the fact that this model as such has not been questioned is particularly relevant. The model has not been questioned during the presentation.
Some Autonomous Regions might say that they want a bit more; which means that the debate will focus on specific issues that do not affect a model of regional financing that, as I said, guarantees greater social cohesion because citizens are going to be provided with more resources for education and health care; and more territorial cohesion because there is a greater integration, more balance and equity from the point of view of the per capita financing, because the Autonomous Regions have been averaged, unlike in the previous model.
I think that the regional financing model, that this proposal will get the necessary parliamentary majority and the Government will keep promoting dialogue and agreements - just as we have been doing so far, during the last year of our Legislature -, and I think that parliamentary stability will be easier. Thus, we will have to wait and see. It is rather probable, yet, as usual, it will demand a lot of work from the Government and a high receptivity from the different Parliamentary Groups.
But we have observed our commitment. During the Debate on the State of the Nation I said that the 15 July, at the latest, we will be holding the Council on Fiscal and Financial Policy. The declarations and the overt agreement expressed by the President of the Generalitat yesterday are particularly important, it is important because this model is a broadly accepted one. It is important for Catalonia to feel at ease with this new financing model. you have heard me say on many an occasion that Catalonia's financing was not adequate considering its relevance and I have also said that a region whose contribution to the country and whose wealth are so high cannot remain below the average, as was the case.
Whatever is good for integration in Spain, whatever is god for Catalonia, Andalusia, Extremadura, the Canary Islands or the Balearic Islands to support the model, is good for the future and is also good for the operation of the regional system, which, as you all know, I never cease to praise.
And, by the way, the model is very good for Galicia. And I say this overtly because one of the most favourable decisions has to do with Galicia, because the dispersion and density of its population have been taken into account, specifically, and also because it will also receive something due to its bilingualism.
Hence, I hereby ask the Presidents of certain Autonomous Regions to reflect and join a reasonable model which the Government is going to implement if it we get a parliamentary majority, as I expect.
Journalist- A question for the President of the Government of Spain and for you, Prime Minister. It has to do with illegal immigration, which is the main concern of both countries. You, President Rodríguez Zapatero, said that it is necessary to buttress FRONTEX, which is one of the measures. Which measures, according to you, must be implemented to eradicate this problem; for instance, the creation of a network of European coastguard vessels? What should happen to those countries that refuse to accept the readmission treaty?
President.- Obviously enough, it is necessary to strengthen border control and in this regard FRONTEX is absolutely necessary. They need more means and more commitment from the EU countries. But, let me insist on this, if we want to control illegal immigration, it is essential to implement an association policy, a cooperation policy with the countries of origin and transit. We have already implemented it with Morocco, which is a main country of transit and origin in Sub-Saharan Africa, and we have a shared border vigilance policy.
In order to develop an efficient readmission policy we also need to implement political and diplomatic actions with the countries of origin and transit and we need the European Union to lead that action in order to attain higher repatriation quotas progressively.
Illegal immigration is a drama and all Governments want to avoid it, correct it and eradicate it; the countries of origin, the countries of destiny and the countries of transit. Hence, the European Union, which subscribed a Pact on Immigration under the French Presidency, must focus on the association, cooperation and agreement between all the countries involved - the countries of transit and origin - as one of its main foreign policies; and the list is very long.
Mr. Karamanlis.-.
Journalist.- I would like to ask Mr Karamanlis about immigration. The Spanish Government insists on the need to establish association and co-operation agreements with the countries that represent the point of origin of the immigration. As you have a problem with a particular country, Turkey, I would like to know if you are prepared to follow this policy of association and co-operation agreements with a country that is different from the others, since it claims to be part of the European Union.
I would like to press the President of the Government on the issue of regional financing. I would like to know whether the 35% of the additional 11,000 million in the system that has been awarded to Catalonia will ensure the parliamentary stability that the Government needs. Also, I would like to know how he interprets the words of the ERC's leader, who boasted of having virtually subjugated the State with this agreement.
Mr. Karamanlis.-
President.- I must say something else about financing. The Government will provide eleven thousand million Euros in four years, but the model, the new regional financing model, could involve a higher amount, depending on the evolution of the State revenues and of the revenues in the different Autonomous Regions, and that does not depend on the State contribution. Catalonia's estimates about the evolution of its revenues in 2010, 2011 and 2012 are quite reasonable, and it proposes a specific amount. And this is what all the different Governments are surely going to do.
Therefore, we must not mix Catalonia's estimates concerning the new model and that additional amount, those eleven thousand million Euros provided by the State, and the distribution of those eleven thousand million Euros which - I insist - will depend on the evolution of the population, and this seems to be an undisputable truth and, besides, it is based upon a principle of solidarity, because -evidently enough- the Autonomous Regions whose population has not increased or whose population has increased very little will receive more for those new inhabitants than those regions whose number of inhabitants has increased by one million or one million and two hundred and thousand persons.
Besides, let me remind you of the fact that it is necessary to compare homogeneous amounts. Catalonia has two competences and it will receive a third one, which entails a certain cost too, namely:
competences concerning security, which are exerted through the Mossos d'Esquadra; competences concerning prisons and the Suburban Railway Network -this is the third one-by 2011. Of course, the resources required to keep up these three specific competences and to update them cannot be compared to those of any other Autonomous Region. It is rather evident that if Andalusia had security competences and if it had to hire thousands of policemen, it would also receive more funds than now, because security is directly managed by the Government of Spain, by the State, through the Police and the Civil Guard.
I think that we should keep this in mind to avoid comparisons.
It is obvious that the model will have two consequences on Catalonia and on another Regions, and it might even have a more positive effect on some of them, considering the evolution of the last few years, more positive than in Catalonia; two consequences: firstly, it averages a Region that provides lots of resources and which was clearly beneath the average so far, this is the first consequence of this model; and, secondly, since there is more fiscal autonomy, for the Regions will receive 50% of the Income Tax, 50% of the VAT and 58% of the essential taxes, if the economy in Catalonia or in any other Region is dynamic, that is to say, if those revenues increase there, it will get more resources without affecting the rest of the country, the solidarity, the guarantee of the public services.
Thus, for instance, I was thinking of Madrid. Over the last few years, Madrid has had amazingly dynamic revenues. Hence, according to this model which entails greater co-responsibility, if that trend is maintained during the stage of economic recovery, it will also be a considerable thrust for Madrid, which - I insist - is very dynamic and has high revenues during the periods of economic growth.
Finally, the only financing agreement in our democracy that made it possible for a President of the Government to act as such was the one set forth by José María Aznar in the "Majestic" with Mr. Pujol back in 1996, for that financing agreement was intended to obtain the investiture. That was the only investiture agreement in our democracy.
I think I am faithful to our thirty year old democracy, I really think so, but this is how things go. And yet, back then, we read that it was a great integration process between the centre and the right wing in Spain.
Thank you very much.