Press conference of the President of the Government after the meeting of the Council of Ministers.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

29 December 2009 · Press conference after the meeting of the Council of Ministers

Context
Zapatero addressed a year-end press conference on 29 December 2009 following a Council of Ministers meeting, reviewing 2009 and outlining government priorities for 2010.
Main themes
Economic crisis and recovery, employment and job creation, sustainable economy strategy, social cohesion and protection, labor market reform, pact for education, Spanish EU presidency, political and social dialogue, fiscal policy, productive model renewal
Duration
~95 min
98th percentile
Words
11,407
98th percentile
Sentences
398
97th percentile
Readability
41
39th percentile
Grade
14.5
71st percentile
Syntax
3.44
91st percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
22nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

398 sentences in 167 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon.

In keeping with tradition, I appear before you at the end of this session period, which is also the end of the year, to take stock and set the objectives for the political action of the Government, the major priorities that lie ahead of us.

Allow me to tell you, as an introduction, what the basic objectives of the Government are at this moment, what the direction of the Government's political action is, and what the main political commitment of the Government to Spanish society is. All of these, both the objectives, the direction, and the commitment, fall within the overarching theme of this Legislature, which is none other than the economic crisis, the employment crisis, and economic recovery.

The objective of the Government is for us to move from recession to recovery in 2010, and the objective of the Government is for us to move from the loss, from the significant loss, of jobs to a moderation in job losses and to the recovery and creation of jobs in the latter part of 2010.

The direction of the Government's political action, in economic policy, is to advance with the utmost agility in the improvement, in the renewal, of our productive model to make the economy more competitive and more innovative. For this, we have three fundamental initiatives: the first is the Sustainable Economy Strategy, within which, as you know, we have the Sustainable Economy Law; the second is the social agreement between the social partners and the Government to improve, to renew, our labor market and to facilitate, in the economic recovery, the rapid creation of jobs; and, thirdly, the third major objective at the beginning of the recovery phase, which will be a recovery that will require effort, is to achieve a Pact for Education, a Pact for Education in which, as you know, the Ministry of Education is firmly committed. We understand that this agreement can be a solid foundation for the future of our country and that it is a significant social demand.

The commitment of the Government, along with the objective and the direction we must take in this 2010 in the economic situation of prosperity in our country, is the maintenance of social cohesion, the maintenance of social harmony, and social protection.

It has been a firm commitment since the first day of the Government I lead. Even during a very tough, very difficult time of economic crisis, the Government has maintained all its social commitments in matters related to social protection, unemployment protection: it has expanded unemployment protection; it has maintained the development of such important laws as the Dependency Law and has upheld the commitment to improve minimum pensions and, ultimately, the social rights that have been won in recent years in our country. That is a firm commitment that we will maintain throughout 2010 and throughout the entire Legislature.

After this introduction that frames the objective, direction, initiatives, and commitment, I want to refer in somewhat more detail to economic and employment aspects; but not only to economic aspects, as I will also refer to political dialogue, social dialogue, parliamentary stability, collective security policy in Spain, and finally, foreign policy; specifically, to the Spanish Presidency of the European Union.

Around this same time last year, making this same assessment, I stated that 2009 was going to be a difficult year economically and that we would continue to suffer job losses. Indeed, the crisis in 2009 has manifested itself in all its harshness, and we must keep in mind the magnitude, the scope, of what we have experienced and are beginning to slowly leave behind.

Let us remember that the international financial sector was on the brink of collapse, that the world economy in the first half of 2009 fell by 2 percent when in 2008 it was growing at rates above 3 percent, and that the decline in the eurozone reached minus 5 percent, exceeding the decline in our country. It is enough to provide another figure to see the magnitude of the international crisis we have experienced in the economy: global trade and industrial production have seen declines close to 20 percent and 11 percent, respectively, in 2009, and according to the International Labour Organization, the cost of the crisis in terms of employment will be around fifty million jobs lost.

Indeed, it has been a difficult year, a very difficult year, economically and, particularly, for those citizens who have lost their jobs. They are the Government's great concern and the Government's great responsibility.

As you know, according to the data from the EPA, in 2009 around one million jobs were lost; 50 percent in construction. This destruction was concentrated in the first part of the year, and in the second part of the year, with the EPA data from the third quarter showing a decrease in employment of 75,000 jobs, there has been a trend of moderation, a clear and significant moderation, in job losses. This trend will be maintained in the first part of 2010 and, logically, in the remaining data for 2009.

These are tough figures, very high figures, of job losses in 2009, which will require us, in the horizon of that recovery, of the capacity of the Spanish economy to create jobs, additional efforts and constant work so that tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands, of workers can have an expectation of recovering a job. Meanwhile, as I have stated, we will maintain all the conditions of social protection against unemployment.

To combat this tough year, this year 2009, the Government has had a powerful instrument, the PlanE. Thanks to the PlanE, as I will briefly recall, we have consolidated, protected, our financial system and the savings of citizens, which was a major concern at the end of 2008. Thanks to the PlanE, the Municipal Investment Fund, and the State Fund, we have maintained activity, employment, for nearly half a million people and over fourteen thousand small and medium-sized enterprises.

Thanks to the PlanE, we have compensated, to some extent, for the severe credit restriction, mobilizing fifteen billion euros from the ICO for more than three hundred thousand companies in our country, which means that 25 percent, a quarter, of the total financing received by companies and families has occurred through the ICO. Surely, as we know well, it has not been able to reach all the companies that have had and have difficulties; but the overall effort is an unprecedented effort of financing to companies and families from the Official Credit Institute, from the instrument that the Government has in the face of the lack of credit in our country as a consequence of the crisis in the financial system.

And with the PlanE we have been able to face situations in strategically important sectors that, thanks to the measures of the PlanE, maintain their activity and have a clearer future horizon. I refer, in particular, to the automotive sector, which thanks to the measures of the PlanE is currently showing positive data, or to the tourism sector which, as you know, has an extraordinary plan and an extraordinary Council of Ministers, and which is also beginning to show recovery data that are so important for the Spanish economy.

The PlanE does not exhaust all its effects, but these are the most outstanding.

Alongside this, I must recall that we have also worked not only to alleviate, not only to confront the severe crisis, but we have worked on reforms of our productive model such as the Retail Trade Law, the reform of the services sector, or the reforms introduced in the housing sector to promote rental, rehabilitation, and protected housing, to assist in a change of model in our development in the housing sector.

Therefore, the Spanish economy is at a moment of transition; a transition from recession to recovery, which will be confirmed in 2010 and which we hope, because this is the ultimate goal, will be able to produce jobs in the latter part of the year; to generate net employment.

The PlanE has served to contain, to alleviate, to protect, and to safeguard important sectors of our economy for the future; but the Sustainable Economy Strategy is the means the Government has to give impetus to recovery and to the reforms of the productive model, to make it more competitive and more innovative. The PlanE contained, essentially, measures to stimulate activity, and the Strategy for Sustainable Economy aims to accelerate the renewal of our productive model.

Now the great priority is to recover activity and confidence, to stimulate demand, and to proceed firmly, decisively, and quickly with modernizing reforms so that in that final part of 2010 we can indeed achieve the great aspiration of Spanish society, which is to create jobs.

You know that, within the Sustainable Economy Strategy, a major pillar of that Strategy is the Sustainable Economy Law, a Law that we will submit on January 8 to the General Council of the Judiciary and the Economic and Social Council, and immediately afterwards to the Council of State, and in February we will submit it to Parliament, so that it can come into force in the summer.

Today in the Council of Ministers we have approved the Fund for Sustainable Economy, valued at twenty billion euros. It is the great financial lever to accompany the change of productive model, to assist in the investment of companies in innovative sectors with adequate financing. As you know, it was presented yesterday by the Economic Vice President.

Likewise, alongside the ICO Fund, as you know, we have the Municipal Fund for Employment and Local Sustainability, a fund of five billion euros that will allow Local Administrations to contribute, in a relevant way, to that change of productive model; to improve technological endowment, infrastructure, and energy-saving and efficiency capabilities in our Town Halls, which are, as you know, the great instruments contained in the Sustainable Economy Law.

Therefore, the direction, after the PlanE, is the Sustainable Economy Strategy. The direction, after combating, alleviating, and mitigating the severe effects of the economic crisis, especially in employment, is to promote, boost, and assist in the economic recovery that is beginning and for this economic recovery to be vigorous as soon as possible to create jobs again.

Allow me to make a consideration, as I announced earlier, about cohesion, about political dialogue, and parliamentary stability.

You know that I have sought from the very first moment at the head of the Government to carry out our project with the imprint of dialogue and cooperation; dialogue in the political sphere, in the social sphere, in the institutional sphere, and in the sphere of the various public Administrations. Behind that imprint, that principle, is an objective, which is to help and lead political stability, social stability, and cohesion in our country.

And we can say that, despite the very harsh economic crisis, despite the very serious difficulties we have faced, that principle has been maintained, the principle of dialogue has been maintained, and the objective of cohesion, stability, and social peace has been maintained. This is extraordinarily important for our country, because the whole of society, which I know is suffering very severely, especially a part of it, the consequences of the crisis, has demonstrated a sense of responsibility, especially the social agents, and with this sense of responsibility, they are helping extraordinarily to the Government and to our capacity for economic recovery.

As you know, we have dialogued with practically all the sectors, and there are many, affected more clearly by the crisis. I previously referred to the automotive sector as one of the perhaps clearest examples: there has been great dialogue with the unions and with the companies that has allowed us to agree on viability plans, maintain activity, and guarantee the future of our plants in Spain.

Just yesterday, I held a meeting with representatives of agricultural organizations, with a sector that also suffers very clearly the consequences of the crisis due to the retraction and demand of falling prices. And yesterday I expressed, and today I want to reiterate publicly, the conviction that today more than ever the agriculture and livestock sector is a strategic sector for our country. It is so in a conviction around what is a sustainable economy and also, in the face of the risks of climate change. For this reason, we have agreed with the agricultural organizations on an emergency plan that will be launched in January, which will address financing problems, which will address price issues, which will affect the situation of certain products, because we are going to provide specific support, and I hope that it can be a factor of confidence and expectation for a sector that is going through serious difficulties but which is, I insist, of great importance.

Social dialogue has been a fundamental channel for us to integrate and to combine efforts in favor of prosperity in our country and social welfare. You know that in the last legislature we signed twenty agreements in the field of social dialogue, and you also know that in the summer we did not succeed, that in July we did not reach an agreement on social dialogue to act positively and incorporate changes, reforms, in the labor field. We are hopeful that the recovered, open process of dialogue between employers and unions, certainly also with the participation of the Government, will facilitate a social agreement in the labor market in the first quarter.

And in the political, parliamentary political sphere, I must highlight that the Government, through its political initiatives, through its capacity for dialogue and with the invaluable and notable work of the Socialist Parliamentary Group, has been able to develop its political program during 2009, reaching agreements, some of them of great importance, for the functioning of our country that had been pending for some time.

I must remind you that so far in this legislature we have already approved 38 laws and 23 Royal Decree Laws. I want to highlight for its importance the Budgets for 2009 and 2010, with growing support, which demonstrates the Government's capacity for dialogue, also the collaborative attitude of different political groups, and, of course, they represent a framework of stability so necessary to face the crisis and economic recovery.

I must remind you that we have approved laws of the importance of the financing of the Autonomous Communities. This issue was one of the major topics of national debate in 2009, and there were even many hypotheses, many predictions, about whether we could reach a great agreement, and today we see that one of the pending issues in recent years has been forged with an agreement that, in the end, all the Autonomous Communities have accepted, and we have a new model of the autonomous financing system that is stable, more equitable, and that benefits all the Autonomous Communities. Or laws such as the Immigration Law, also of great importance, or the Audiovisual Communication Law, or the laws that regulate the free exercise and access to service activities, or the Law on Sexual Health and Voluntary Termination of Pregnancy, to name the most relevant.

In short, we are carrying out our political program, our Government agenda, with support and parliamentary stability. And this, to a large extent, is due to the collaboration of different political groups and, of course, to the attitude of dialogue with the Government.

I wish to refer, as I mentioned earlier, to another major area of general policy of interest to our society, such as collective security, public security, where, as you know, the Government has always placed a very special interest.

The first thing I want to address is the fight against ETA terrorism. As you know, the terrorist group ETA is under constant pressure and is undergoing a permanent process of weakening thanks to the work of the State Security Forces and Corps and the success of the direction of anti-terrorist policy.

This year, there have been 124 arrests of members of the terrorist group ETA, to which we should add twenty more members of "kale borroka." From here, I wish to express my congratulations to the State Security Forces and Corps.

Also this year we have witnessed the murders, the vile murders, by ETA of three public servants whom I want to remember here: Eduardo Puelles, Carlos Sáenz de Tejada, and Diego Salvá. And, with them, all the victims of terrorism.

We will only have full satisfaction when ETA disappears, when ETA ends. That will be the only satisfaction that can be had in the full anti-terrorist struggle. But I must tell Spanish society that the strength of democracy, the cooperation of political forces, the cooperation with the Basque Government, and the successful work of the Ministry of the Interior are increasingly reducing the possibilities of the terrorist group ETA, despite the fact that at any moment it may attempt a cowardly criminal action; that is its trajectory; but the direction of anti-terrorist policy is yielding important fruits.

I also wish to refer to citizen security, road safety, and the policy against illegal immigration. At other times, these were frontline issues in public opinion debate.

Regarding citizen security, I must say that we are consolidating one of the lowest crime rates in the European Union: 47 offenses per thousand inhabitants, compared to the European Union average, which is 70 offenses per thousand inhabitants. The cause of these good results is the progressive increase in the number of State Security Forces and Corps, police officers, and civil guards, and the increasingly professional work of their members.

The field of road safety has been, as you know, one of the great priorities for this Government, because it is one of the fields in which we have seen the most lives tragically lost year after year and increasingly until just a few years ago. We can congratulate ourselves on the results achieved in 2009. These results are not measured in figures but in human lives. I will give you just one illustrative piece of data: for the first time since 1963, the number of fatalities on the road during the summer period has fallen below four hundred. It is the best result in 46 years when the vehicle fleet in Spain was 1,700,000 vehicles, compared to the 31 million vehicles we have at this moment. I wish to highlight that the results are extraordinarily encouraging and that it demonstrates that effective, intense, sustained political action produces such positive results.

In the field of collective security, I should, as I mentioned earlier, refer to the policy on illegal immigration, which in some of my appearances of this nature has been a central theme, also to express our satisfaction because the arrival of illegal immigrants during 2009 has been reduced by half compared to 2008: we have gone from fourteen thousand to seven thousand. We are winning the fight against illegal immigration after having suffered, as you know, especially in 2006 and 2007, extraordinarily difficult years. And this is being done thanks to a broad deployment of cooperation policy with the countries of origin, most of them African countries, and with a reinforcement of all personal and material means in the fight against illegal immigration. We will not let our guard down; we know that there may be a moment of resurgence; but, fortunately, a matter of great depth and great concern is heading in a very appropriate direction.

Finally, I will refer to foreign policy with a statement that is relevant, just a few days before the start of the Spanish Presidency of the European Union, in fact two days, in my opinion: 2009 has been a year of consolidation of Spain's position in international relations and foreign policy. We are stronger in the world than we were a year ago.

This has had a clear confirmation, which is our consolidation in the G-20, even the invitation we received to attend the G-8, and it will also have its confirmation in the development of the rotating Presidency of the European Union because in this Presidency, in this six-month period, we propose, and aspire to achieve; a strengthening of the European Union, above all in the economic governance of the European Union, in the cooperation of the Twenty-Seven in economic policy and job creation; a strengthening of the European Union through a rapid, agile, and dynamic application of the Lisbon Treaty, as well as the strengthening of the position of the European Union in the international context, in various regional areas, especially Latin America, especially North America, and especially Africa and the Mediterranean area.

During these six months of the Spanish Presidency of the European Union, we will strengthen Europe, we will strengthen Spain in Europe and in the world, and we will strengthen economic recovery and the maintenance of a more innovative, more stable economy with greater capacity to compete in a globalized world. That is the task that lies ahead of us.

Let me, in conclusion, make some announcements about our immediate calendar, about the calendar that weaves the course in the fight against the economic crisis and in favor of economic recovery, which is the phase we are currently in.

You know that the Sustainable Economy Strategy and the Sustainable Economy Law included a series of commitments to be developed during 2010. I will refer to a series of them, which already have dates and will occur during January and February. I will stop there so as not to make the list too long.

On January 8, as I told you, we will send the draft Sustainable Economy Law to the advisory bodies and we will approve the new Civil Registry Law, which is also a law of reforms, modernization. On January 15, we will approve a first package of Royal Decrees for the application and development of the so-called Omnibus Law. On January 22, we will approve labor measures, which we will submit for consideration by business and union organizations at the Social Dialogue Table. On January 29, we will approve the reform measures for the Social Security and pension system, which we will take to the Toledo Pact Table. And on the same day, January 29, we will approve an Austerity Plan for the General State Administration, on which the Government is already working very intensively at this moment.

It is, therefore, about making the initiatives for reform, modernization, and fiscal consolidation a reality with fixed commitments; a fiscal consolidation that is essential to secure growth and in which the Autonomous Communities and Local Entities must necessarily participate, for which the Government will promote various initiatives.

This is the work plan for January. As you will see, we are going to start with a great content of initiatives and reforms; but in February we will address other measures of significance and relevance: the new Law on Science, Technology, and Innovation; the Law on Marine Environment Protection; a Social Inclusion Plan and an Action Plan against Tax and Labor Fraud.

This is the immediate action calendar for the next two months.

In short, the Government is firmly committed, and it will do so rigorously, to one course: the course of promoting economic reactivation; of making a more competitive, more innovative economy; of carrying out the necessary reforms at this moment, which is the right moment, and, of course, committed to the protection and social cohesion. All of this has a great objective, which is the great concern of the Government and Spanish society: to create jobs as soon as possible.

From here, of course wishing you a happy new year, I submit to your questions.

Q.- Mr. President, I wanted to ask you about the latest news the Government has regarding the situation of the Acció Solidaria cooperators if they know anything about the injured person and what expectations there are at this moment.

President.- You have heard me say on more than one occasion that this is a difficult and delicate issue, like any kidnapping, and that the way for all of us to contribute to a positive outcome, which is none other than the release of the three compatriots, is prudence, discretion, and responsibility.

I must say that those who have the direct interest, the families, have had the information from day one, and the Government must be extraordinarily prudent when providing more information, new information. We will do everything necessary to facilitate the prompt release of the hostages and we will not do or say anything that could harm or delay that release.

Q.- Mr. President, I will return to the balance. I believe that 2009, if not, you correct me, has been the worst year of your time in Moncloa. You have said that, indeed, the figures have been bad and that in the first half of 2010 they will continue to be bad. My question is whether you contemplate that 2010 will be your particular "annus horribilis" or if 2009 has already been that.

And something more related to current events. You have also referred to ETA and the fight against ETA. Why has the Minister of the Interior made public the idea that ETA may carry out an attack or may kidnap, when you yourself have said that they can do so at any moment, and everyone knows that? Why has the Minister of the Interior, for the first time, made it public, with the consequent criticism, for example, from police unions?

If you allow me, one thing that I found lacking in your balance. You made no reference to political corruption, and I believe that everyone agrees that in 2009 there have been very striking cases that have created, for example, disaffection among citizens towards the political class.

President.- I have made a balance of the Government's action, not of the things that happen; of the Government's action.

2009 has been a difficult year for those who have lost their jobs. Any other consideration, for those of us who have government responsibilities, I believe has no significance. It has been a difficult year for those who have lost their jobs, very difficult, and for the Spanish economy.

I have confidence that 2010 will be better, and I face 2009 and 2010 with the same principles. The circumstances may be easier or more difficult since I have been at the head of the Government of Spain, but I will uphold the same principles, which are to guarantee social cohesion to the maximum, to support families that are facing the most difficulties, so that the weakest do not suffer the consequences of this serious economic crisis the most, and that the Government, your Government, your country, gives them all the support it can. These principles are those of 2009, those of 2010, those of 2005, and those of 2004, and I will maintain them.

And, of course, with all determination, I will carry out the reforms I have just outlined and also the will that we regain confidence in ourselves as a country, as a society. This has great value for economic recovery as well. We must regain that confidence because there are sufficient reasons for it: our trajectory in recent decades, the modernization of Spain, improvements in education, our international position... There are great reasons to regain that confidence and to start 2010 each day with more strength and more self-esteem, because this will undoubtedly contribute to a faster and more vigorous recovery.

That role of confidence must be led by the Government; it also involves all political forces and social agents, but also the Government. Confidence is that citizens, society, see a direction, a path, a project, and that is what I am trying to explain and outline before Spanish society. And confidence is that citizens know that our principles of support for social cohesion and social protection remain intact, because that also provides tranquility.

Regarding the announcement by the Minister of the Interior, it is part of the anti-terrorist policy. You can imagine that it is part of an evaluation that is shared, on the part of the Minister, with those who have the responsibility. Allow me to say that there are things that can be doubted, but that we have a capable, convincing Minister of the Interior who directs anti-terrorist policy very well is beyond doubt. Therefore, I know that the announcement he made responds, logically, to a strategy, and allow me to say that we must be cautious because, as is natural, the strategy, when we have the adversary we have, cannot be developed in all its depth. Speculations can be made, but it cannot be fully developed.

But, I insist, the announcement responds to anti-terrorist policy; an anti-terrorist policy that, by the way, we are having very good results with, because there is very good direction in anti-terrorist policy and because we have great public servants.

Q.- What has prevented you, Mr. President, from ending the year without an interview between you and Mariano Rajoy?

In this same line, what makes you think that there will be a Pact for Education, as you have placed among the three main objectives for 2010, given that it seems, from the outside, that that dialogue between you and Mr. Rajoy does not exist?

President.- There is a matter that is purely a matter of timing and that has to do with the Pact for Education. I believe that the meeting with Mr. Rajoy, which will take place, should come at the moment when we can give a definitive push to the Pact for Education and when we evaluate what has happened and what the situation of the dialogue around the Pact for Energy is, because these are two specific things to which we must respond, both the Government and the opposition.

You know that progress has been made in the dialogue on Education, and just yesterday there were advances. I will evaluate those advances in order to proceed with the invitation to the leader of the opposition, which, as you know, is always an act that I find it convenient to prepare well and in which I feel very comfortable facilitating everything that can be dialogue and cooperation. It will take place and will depend on progress in the education issue, although we will logically talk about many other things, especially the economic crisis, fiscal consolidation policies, and the Sustainable Economy Law. The agenda will be broad.

Q.- Mr. President, I had two questions. The first is in relation to some words this morning from Joaquín Almunia, who said that it will take a decade to reabsorb the jobs lost in the last two years. I wanted to know if, considering how confident you have been today that 2010 will end the year with job creation, you agree with Joaquín Almunia on that perception.

On the other hand, I wanted to know your personal position regarding the "Faisán case" and whether you agree with the National Court Prosecutor's decision to archive the case. I ask you in another way: in these moments when the anti-terrorist alert is heightened, do you think that citizens can understand that something as serious in a democracy as a leak, a tip-off to the terrorist group ETA, is not being investigated?

President.- I do not know the statements of Mr. Almunia and, therefore, I will not make an assessment. In any case, talking about ten years from now always has its difficulties.

Regarding the second question, let us respect the action of Justice, and, of course, the first one who must respect it is the President of the Government. There is a procedure, and each of the actors in the judicial framework freely establishes their positions, and it will be substantiated according to the law. Certainly, it should not be the President of the Government who makes any assessment in this regard.

Now, I will add that I believe that there are things that can be discussed and others that are indisputable. The tenacity, strength, character, and determination of the Government to combat ETA and achieve decisive results in the fight against terrorism are irrefutable evidence.

Q.- Mr. President, I wanted to address economic issues. You have spoken about the priority of social dialogue and about reforming the labor market. Will this labor market reform address issues that hindered the agreement in June, such as, for example, the modalities of hiring and the reduction of social contributions?

A second question. You have also spoken about Government initiatives for the Autonomous Communities to join the goal of reducing the deficit. Could you explain what kind of initiatives these will be and whether they will affect slimming down the structure of these Autonomous Communities a bit?

Finally, among the priorities you have mentioned for the coming months, you have not mentioned the reform of the Late Payment Law, which is one of the main difficulties that companies currently face.

President.- The changes in the labor model will focus on collective bargaining; on promoting hiring for young people, which is undoubtedly the segment where the most job loss has occurred, and on addressing the duality of the labor market and precariousness. But I must say that we do not contemplate any issues related to contributions in general at the beginning of this dialogue, social contributions—you know that was put on hold in July—nor do we consider that the issue related to hiring modalities, at least as it has been raised by some parties, in this case by the business representation, is the central issue for modernizing our labor market.

But the agenda of topics will be a broad agenda; the Government will put them on the table as a factor of initiative, mobilization, or debate in the realm of social dialogue, and, undoubtedly, there will be other proposals, both from the representation of employers and from the representation of trade unions.

Now, we want this to develop during the first quarter; if it were in February, better than in March, to agree on reform measures as soon as possible.

Regarding fiscal consolidation, austerity plan, measures from the Autonomous Communities... The economic crisis has caused the public accounts of our country to go from surplus to a significant deficit; a deficit that we must correct and that we will correct, because we will fulfill the commitment to reach 3 percent in 2013, as set by the European Commission. We have more tranquility; the situation of the debt is less pressing, although we also need moderation policies, because the increase in the last two years has been notable, although we are twenty points below the European average.

As you know, public spending in Spain is very decentralized, and practically 50 percent of public spending is carried out by Autonomous Communities and Municipalities. And in a plan of austerity, of spending control, all Administrations must contribute. The Government will be the first to commit to a very demanding austerity plan for the State Administration, very demanding, and from there we will put initiatives so that the Autonomous Communities also incorporate this path, this commitment, in the coming years.

What initiatives, our friend intelligently asks? I wish, first, to talk with the leader of the opposition about this issue before putting them on the table; but, logically, the measures will have to be within the framework of our legal system, and our legal system establishes the principle of political autonomy, with a guarantee of the availability of public resources by the Autonomous Communities. Therefore, it will be the political path that we must explore, and it will be the path of incentives that we must deepen to engage the Autonomous Communities and Local Corporations in that principle of austerity and correction of public accounts.

Regarding the Late Payment Law, I have not detailed the relationship, but of course it remains on the agenda of commitments, expressly incorporated, moreover, in the Sustainable Economy Law.

Q.- Mr. President, I wanted to ask if you could specify a little more when you plan to meet with Rajoy. You indicated that you intended to see him before the end of the year. Why has it been that you have not called him in the end?

On the other hand, in the educational issue, you talk a lot about the State Pact and it seems that you have relegated to a second plane another State Pact that you intended to promote, which was the energy one. Why? What are the reasons and points of friction, if any, between the opposition and the Government?

Finally, an assessment. You have said that Spain is stronger abroad. I wanted to ask you if events such as the management of the "Alakrana" kidnapping or the "Haidar case" have not affected that assessment; if they have not tarnished Spain's image abroad.

President.- And the ships kidnapped from countries like Germany and others? Does anyone really think that this tarnishes the image of Spain, the image of a country? What it shows is the growing spread of organized crime, especially in some areas of some continents, and one of them is the growing spread of piracy. Does anyone think that because a couple of Italians have been kidnapped, like our hostages in Mauritania, that affects the prestige or image of Italy or France?

Q.- I mean the management.

President.- And the management? Well, the management has been that they are here safe and that they were released in a reasonable time. Comparisons are not valid. But what can be asked of a Government? To achieve the release of hostages, and it has been achieved. And the only thing that, logically, we have received in the realm of foreign policy or European policy, from friendly countries, is support, as we give support to any country that suffers such a harsh and difficult circumstance as this.

No. Allow me to say that those are rather lamentable attempts, by whoever said it, to say that it affects the external image of Spain; quite lamentable.

You have given another example, which is the case of Aminatu Haidar. Spain received that problem and it has also been resolved well, and it was not easy. We all know the circumstances, the context, and what lies behind Aminatu Haidar's hunger strike. It was not easy, and it has been resolved. Aminatu Haidar is in El Aaiún, as she wanted, and our relations with Morocco remain very good.

Therefore, I understand that this, on the contrary, rather than weaken, strengthens resolving issues in this way. And do not make me give examples of what it means to "weaken."

Q.- I had a couple of economic questions. You referred in the January agenda to the proposals, the measures, that the Government will put forward for the reform of the pension system and Social Security. I do not know if you can give us any advance on those proposals; for example, whether the fifteen-year period that currently governs the calculation of pensions, which has been a topic of recent debate, will be addressed.

I would also like you to assess the perhaps slow pace at which the restructuring process of the financial sector is being addressed and to know if you think that this pace, slow or not, may be influencing or delaying the normalization of credit to families and companies.

President.- We will announce the proposals in the area of Social Security reform at the time I indicated earlier. We will not advance debates.

In relation to the financial system and the restructuring of small and medium entities, which are the ones called to undergo this process, I must say that we have a regulatory framework and a restructuring fund, which was the result of a great parliamentary agreement, in this area yes, an agreement between the two major parties; we have the Bank of Spain, which directs and leads this process, and that was the wish of all political forces, and we find it reasonable that it is the Bank of Spain that sets the times and rhythms. And also, as is natural, the will of the savings banks themselves and the desirable collaboration of the regional governments, given the legal nature and institutional position that the savings banks have.

But the pace is determined by the direction of the Bank of Spain itself and the support, the willingness, of the different entities. We must have confidence in the Bank of Spain and we must demand that all entities collaborate with the paths and timelines that the Bank of Spain determines. If you ask me for a more precise estimate, I believe that we should have a good part of that restructuring process cleared by around spring.

Credit conditions. The conditions of credit depend, to a large extent, on the expectations of economic activity. Financial entities will provide more credit to the extent that they believe they will have the capacity to be repaid and to obtain the appropriate profitability, and, secondly, due to the situation of the entities themselves. But, fortunately, a good part, the majority, of our financial system is solid in terms of its solvency and has the capacity to provide credit. Of course it does. The problem is whether that credit, in the opinion of the financial entities, offers sufficient guarantees given the tone of the economy. That is the double problem we have.

Therefore, as the public sector has more capacity to take risks because it does not seek profits, we have mobilized everything we have mobilized from the Official Credit Institute: 14,000-15,000 million euros. It is an amount that we commit from the public sector, that we put at risk, and with it we help to finance companies and families.

But, I insist, we must keep pace with the Bank of Spain, with the utmost collaboration from the entities, and I hope that in the spring -- it would be a reasonable moment -- we can have most of the path cleared.

Q.- Mr. President, now that it seems that the ruling on the Statute of Catalonia is about to be made public, I would like to know if you fully trust that the term "nation" can be maintained in the preamble, as well as the Catalan national symbols, as currently stated in the text of the Estatut.

I would also like to know if, once the ruling is made public, you do not think it would be time to consider how the system for electing a court, such as the Constitutional Court, could be transformed, given that it is continuously accused of being highly politicized.

Secondly, right now the economic outlook, although you are trying, logically, to present us with more optimistic or confident perspectives than those of the past year, the truth is that they are not very good, and this is also linked to a series of continuous surveys that are coming out, in which a clear decline in the electoral prospects of the Socialist Party is observed. I would like to know if, as of today, you remain firm in the possibility of running again as a candidate in the 2012 elections.

President.- I will start with the second question and leave the Constitutional Court and the Statute for later.

A report from the Bank of Spain has just been made public; it is not that I have made any statement here outside the context of reality in which it is evident that activity is improving in most sectors and that the decline in employment is moderating. The Bank of Spain says so. I believe that this will be confirmed with the Gross Domestic Product data for the last quarter and that it will consolidate at the beginning of 2010 regarding the Gross Domestic Product, regarding economic activity. And I have distinguished that it will take us more time and more difficulty to return to a process of recovery, of net job creation, which we place in the last part of 2010.

But we do trust in recovery and we believe that we are currently in the transition from recession to recovery. It will be a slow recovery, with difficulties, because the crisis has been very harsh, but recovery nonetheless. And that can help, will undoubtedly help, the factor of confidence to which I referred earlier and which is so important.

Obviously, that has nothing to do with the polls or what happens in 2012 and the candidacy of the Socialist Party. The polls that concern us are those that concern the Spaniards at this time, that is, what Spaniards say worries them, which is unemployment. That is the only poll that concerns me, the only one, and I am very little concerned at this moment about voting intentions.

And, of course, if that concerns me little, imagine that I do not have a minute in my agenda to think about 2012. I am only focused with all my strength, my energy, and my desire on winning economic recovery, on leaving the crisis behind and returning as soon as possible to creating jobs. That is my only concern and I would dare to say it is my only obsession. Everything else is absolutely, at this moment, minor and will not have any importance, and will not be a topic of debate, moreover.

Constitutional Court. You ask me if I trust -- I believe that was the expression -- that the term "nation" in the preamble and the national symbols will be respected. I am not a magistrate of the Constitutional Court, I do not know what happens in their deliberations and, therefore, I do not know what they will say about these two aspects. It seems quite evident to me.

I can say what my opinion is, which I expressed with my vote. I believe that the preamble has no taint of unconstitutionality and with my vote I expressed that the national symbols also fit perfectly within the framework of the Constitution because, ultimately, they are the symbols of the nationality of Catalonia, as the Statute states, which is the definition used by the Constitution to refer to the naming possibilities of the Autonomous Communities: regions and nationalities. And the national symbols are of the nationality of Catalonia. In my interpretation, when I approached this article when I had to express my opinion on it with my vote, I had this position, which is, for me, clear and evident.

Q.- Mr. President, I wanted to ask you a question linked to this last topic you were discussing, obviously. I would like to ask you what expectations you have for the upcoming Catalan elections, to what extent you believe that their result may affect your own mandate as President of the Government and your own parliamentary stability, which you just spoke about, and also to what extent you believe that this ruling from the Constitutional Court on the Estatut may affect precisely these elections.

President.- Regarding the ruling, this is a mature country, it is a country that enjoys a consolidated constitutional system for three decades and the ruling will logically produce comments, some more favorable, others less favorable; but the ruling will not mark a before and after regarding the Statute of Catalonia. What I do hope is that it will be a significant ruling.

It is a matter of great importance for our institutional model and for the State of Autonomies, and I wish, as President of the Government, that it is a ruling of conceptual depth and rigor, because there has been so much debate about certain concepts and about certain options of the Statute that this process of clarification to which we can demand the highest conceptual level will be good.

But our system is a mature system and I believe that the effects of the ruling, whatever it may be, will be effects that will be perfectly assumed by all political actors, both by those who have challenged all or almost all of the Statute, and by those of us who think that the Statute is constitutional. Surely, we will all have to make an effort to accept it. Of course, the Government will do so without any problem and I hope that the same will be said and done by the fundamental protagonist of this challenge, which is the one who has challenged, the Popular Party, Mr. Rajoy. He is the one who has challenged a very high number of articles and must be in the attitude of logically accepting the consequences of the ruling.

Regarding the effect on the Catalan elections of October 2010 or on governance, I honestly find it difficult to make a prediction about that, about the effect of the elections. My opinion on how those elections will go, I can tell you: I believe they will go better for the PSC than it seems and, therefore, for some less well than they think. And if you ask me a follow-up question, which I will ask myself, why? Because I believe that Montilla and the PSC have seriousness and coherence, which, in a Catalan political context, which everyone knows is really lively, are demonstrating seriousness, coherence, and a predictable project. That is why I am convinced that the PSC and Montilla will fare better in the October elections than it seems.

Q.- Mr. President, regarding the kidnapped compatriots, although you have said and asked for prudence, can you at least tell us if there is cooperation with the other two countries concerned by their nationals, which are Italy and France? Has there been coordinated or even joint action?

On the other hand, regarding the dialogue, which you have expressed as part of your project or essentially as a guiding principle that follows you, it has been shown that there are great difficulties with the Autonomous Communities governed by the Popular Party, as seen in the Conference of Presidents. Will you ask Mr. Rajoy to do what he can so that this dialogue with the Autonomous Communities governed by his party can take place, because you have already mentioned several reforms that are, I would say, essential?

Also, do you share with your Minister of Development, Mr. Blanco, whether the President of the CEOE, Mr. Díaz Ferrán, should continue in his position or not...? What you should share or not with Mr. Blanco is whether you are also disappointed with the attitude or behavior as a businessman during the crisis of Air Comet.

Finally, if you allow me, your opinion on the so-called Download Law.

President.- The first issue, regarding the three kidnapped individuals and the countries that are collaborating, is sensitive; therefore, I must be prudent and it must be understood. I have said it on some occasions: what I say and, above all, what the President of the Government says, reaches all corners. But I can tell you, not speaking about this case, but about other similar cases we have had, that there is always great collaboration from many countries, as is natural. This is how it works in international relations.

Autonomous Communities. Yes, I want to talk to Mr. Rajoy about public accounts, the Austerity Plan, and the collaboration of the Autonomous Communities in that objective. I believe it is an essential issue, moreover, after having heard Mr. Rajoy so many times in the Parliament asking for austerity and talking about controlling public spending. I believe that the way is, as I said before, the political way and the level, regarding the issue at hand, is the highest level, that is, between the leader of the opposition and the President of the Government. And I will do so.

Regarding the President of the CEOE, I want to be especially cautious at this moment and I will not make any personal assessment. We are in a phase of social dialogue, the difficulties that their companies are going through logically concern the Government and the Government tries to help, as with all companies. But I should not make any value judgment about his trajectory or about his future in relation to the institution. It is a matter of the institution, the CEOE, that the Government must respect, and especially the President of the Government, and I respect.

Regarding the issue of downloads, I must say that there is no news. On the 8th, in the Draft Law on Sustainable Economy, the formula will go that we will send to the consultative bodies. In other words, it will be known on January 8.

Q.- Mr. President, a couple of questions and some clarification about your future meeting with the leader of the opposition. Yesterday, Minister Gabilondo said that he hoped to have that agreement in two months. I would like to know if that is the horizon for the meeting, that is, if the meeting will be to seal the pact in that horizon, or if, on the contrary, it will be before to promote it.

On this same aspect, I would also like to ask you if the Government is willing to include the issue of language in the Pact, as the PP requested yesterday, or, on the contrary, prefers to set it aside.

Finally, a more general question. I wanted to ask you, at the end of the year and looking back, if there is anything particularly in the management of the economic crisis, although I invite you to talk about other aspects as well, that now, looking back, you would have done differently this year.

President.- There is no set deadline for when the meeting will take place. I wish it could be as soon as possible, but, as you must know, this type of meeting always requires a favorable prior climate. There needs to be a certain preparation, a certain predisposition. I have never wanted, nor will I do so, to make an unexpected call to the leader of the opposition; there must be a framework or context, and this is what, logically, we need to work on, and Mr. Rajoy knows this.

It is true that the issue of education does seem important to include in that meeting at the moment we can say that progress has been made.

And I do not want to prejudge either language or any other issue. I believe that the Minister of Education was open yesterday to the issues raised by the Popular Party. We are open, beyond entering into any specific topic at this moment.

Regarding what we have done, I believe we have made a tremendous effort to contain the severity of the crisis, to assess and set the course for what needs to change in the Spanish economy, beyond this context of financial crisis that, logically, would have affected us under any circumstances given the international dimension.

If you ask me if I have ever thought of something I did that I shouldn’t have, no. Of what I have done, in general terms, I would surely make the same approach again: maintaining social protection, a strong effort of public investment to stimulate demand, and sectoral support for the various business areas facing more difficulties.

But, if you are going to say "he made no self-criticism," if possible, I want to avoid that headline. So I will tell you that, if on some occasion, as could not be otherwise, and everyone imagines it, I thought we were not very accurate, and I was not very accurate, when we had that futile debate about whether we were in crisis or not and whether we were in a slowdown, because, evidently, that could have caused, after seeing and verifying the intensity of the crisis, a misleading perception in public opinion and misleading in the citizenry.

Yes, I have reflected on that in a self-critical manner. And it is true that one always finds oneself in this situation with a certain contradiction, which surely many citizens will understand. When you have the highest responsibility at the head of a country, you must try to convey a certain degree of confidence; confidence in our possibilities, even to face difficulties. There you always run the risk of being considered optimistic or lacking realism. You always move in a terrain that is difficult to balance, although I must say that I will always be closer to those who deeply believe in Spain and, therefore, are closer to the side of confidence and optimism, than to those who believe little in our possibilities. And I think this with any government, whether it is a Socialist Party government or a Popular Party government.

I have always had, I have today, and I will have tomorrow, confidence in our possibilities, even though we have a hard and bad stage, as we have had and as we are having with this crisis.

But, well, that debate about whether crisis or slowdown was not an accurate debate.

Q.- President, in the late 1970s, political forces reached an agreement to address the economic crisis and, among other things, to prevent the nascent democratic institutions from being harmed at that time. According to the polls, this year of crisis, those institutions have already been harmed; the political class is seen as a problem for most Spaniards, and you, as President of the Government, have suffered significant wear and a loss of trust. I wanted to know if you regret, in some way, not having attempted a sort of re-edition of the Moncloa Pacts, precisely because of this aspect I mention regarding the impact on political institutions.

Another issue that has nothing to do with it. After the failure of the peace process, you said that you did not regret it because you believed it would bear fruit. I wanted to know if the debate that has opened in ETA-Batasuna is, in your opinion, a consequence of that and if you believe it is in your hands to do something to ensure that this debate reaches a good port for the interests of Spain.

President.- On some occasions, I have expressed that the Moncloa Pacts responded to an exceptional historical moment, which was to consolidate democracy, to emerge from dictatorship, and to pull together in a very difficult economic circumstance.

That in the face of the economic crisis we are experiencing, the severe recession, the more points of agreement there are, the better, and we have had some in the financial system. I wish to have others in other areas, such as education; but in other topics, there are ideological differences. It is important to be clear about this because, moreover, it is the essence of democratic pluralism. There are ideological differences. I am convinced that the Popular Party would never have expanded unemployment protection, as we have done. In fact, they have not proposed it, and, in fact, when there was a small crisis in 2002, they cut unemployment protection.

These are ideological differences in the economic field. They do not believe that the public sector should go out to boost the economy in a moment of severe economic crisis; they believe that the market functions well without regulation, and we believe that the public sector can and should, under certain circumstances, stimulate economic activity when private activity is paralyzed, and we understand that what can function the worst is a financial market without regulation, without rules, without supervision, and without control, as has been demonstrated. There are differences.

Have we reached agreements in support of the financial system? Good. Can we reach an agreement in Education? That would be very positive. And, if there are other agreements on the issue of deficit containment and fiscal consolidation of the Government and Autonomous Communities, that would also be very favorable. But there are clear areas of disagreement.

That, beyond the willingness one has to pull together, and I do not judge the willingness of the Popular Party that leads the opposition to this Government alongside the Government in favor of the fight against the crisis. I do not judge it. It is perfectly describable, but I will not judge it. Now, beyond that willingness, there are fundamental ideological differences, as could not be otherwise.

The peace process? Undoubtedly, the peace process has had a weakening effect on the block that has supported fanatic and terrorist violence; undoubtedly. What do we do and what can we do to weaken that block even further? Something obvious: that they lose all hope, because they only have one end, one way out, which is to lay down their arms, to end the violence. That is what many of those who, in one way or another, have come to understand or support already know: that this is their only destiny. Therefore, all the firmness policy we have maintained also bears fruit, just as the peace process did.

Finally, I will make a consideration about the polls. Let us not draw conclusions from conjunctural data. Fortunately, we have a consolidated democracy and we have a democratic trajectory, in these thirty years, the result of the attitude of the citizenry, which has made us a modern, open, European country that operates under the rules of the rule of law.

There may be moments, in certain circumstances, that provoke, as is natural, dissatisfaction among the citizenry; but for that, in democracy, there are corrective elements, and we must also take into account that we are now living in a context of severe economic crisis that, without a doubt, affects, as could not be otherwise, the vital tone of the country. And we hope, I trust, that 2010 will be a process of progressive recovery. It will not be overnight, it will not be easy, but it will be a progressive recovery of that vital tone of confidence in our country. The Government must contribute decisively to this.

I know that we are the main responsible ones, I am very aware of it, and for that reason, I perfectly understand that the citizenry demands more from us and that the citizenry expresses, in the way it does, through opinion polls, the feeling it has. I understand it perfectly because the economic crisis is very harsh.

Q.- You have not included in your agenda of projects to be approved between January and February the approval of the new airport management model, of which I believe the Minister of Development, Mr. Blanco, has informed today in the Council of Ministers. I wanted to ask you about the timetable for processing and approval of that model, and for your opinion, specifically, on a proposal that generates rejections, for example, in Catalonia, because it does not meet the expectations of the Generalitat regarding a more autonomous management of that model.

President.- Which I find difficult to understand because, if we have not yet put the model on the table, why is it said that the model is met with rejection? Let’s wait.

I believe that the Minister of Development is doing a task to carry out a significant modernizing reform in our country, which is to improve our entire air navigation system and our airport system. It is a modernizing reform.

Indeed, if I have not given and have not referred to this issue, it is because there is still no concrete date for the presentation of the model; but, reasonably, it will occur within a timeframe that can perfectly be around the end of the first quarter.

We will seek maximum consensus, we desire maximum consensus, and surely, the model we present will not please one hundred percent of all Autonomous Communities; but we understand that the model that the Minister of Development is outlining is an adequate model and that a very good job has been done, as the Minister of Development does with the effectiveness that characterizes him.

Q.- President, a double question. On the one hand, I know you have said that the approval will be in February, but I would like, if possible, for you to give me a preview of the draft Science Law, which is supposed to have arrived today at the Council of Ministers.

On the other hand, and referring especially to the Austerity Plan you mentioned, I would like to know where the issue of local financing stands. I know that Minister Chaves has promised results for 2011, but considering the Austerity Plan, that regional financing is already resolved, and that the financing problems of the Town Halls are well known, what will these Town Halls do during 2010?

President.- I believe we have given a somewhat more favorable framework to the Town Halls in 2010, because they know they are going through difficulties. We have the five billion euro fund, a percentage of which can be allocated to current expenses. We had the 2009 fund of ten billion euros, so the Town Halls have not had to allocate a single euro of their resources, of their budgets, to investment because all the investment, and more than they usually do, has been made with state funds. And with the five billion euros from the fund for 2010, we are in the same scenario.

We have said that we will address local financing issues in 2011, but this issue has nothing to do with the Austerity Plan of the State Administration. When I refer to the Austerity Plan of the State Administration, I mean the General State Administration, that is, to those expenses that the Government of Spain directly incurs, so that we understand each other, because the financing framework for Autonomous Communities and local financing responds to other parameters, and we are not going to dispose, in the case of the Autonomous Communities or the Town Halls, of their own decisions. Our obligation is to guarantee them an adequate financing framework, as we have done with the Autonomous Communities and as we will do with the Town Halls in 2011.

We have not seen it today in draft form, and as we have said, we will approve it in February. It is an important law; the 1986 Law was very important, and, of course, if our commitment, like any modern and advanced country, is a firm commitment for the economy to be sustained in technological innovation and for science in Spain to truly start to be among the most prominent countries, because this is indeed a great historical subject since we have always been a country that has turned its back on science and has left science in second place, which we have begun to recover in just the last two decades, this Law will acquire great value.

We will make the Law by dialoguing with scientists, dialoguing with researchers, and dialoguing with the Universities. This is fundamental for the success of the Law, and in February we will present it.

Q.- Regarding the issue of airports, in the general lines of the new Plan, as they have been proposed, I wanted to know if regarding the weight of the Autonomous Communities there is still room for negotiation for this weight to be greater, which is what, for example, is demanded from Catalonia, which has been very vocal about this.

I also wanted to know if you agree with the Minister of Development's opinion that the air traffic controllers' sector is privileged and that their conditions should change.

President.- We need to modernize our air navigation system. The Minister of Development is determined to modernize the air navigation system in all aspects, including air traffic control. He will do it intelligently, but it needs to be carried out because we must also be competitive in the costs of air navigation.

Regarding the airport model, I have said that the Ministry of Development has been working on a model, it has engaged in dialogue with Autonomous Communities, and of course, it has spoken with the Generalitat of Catalonia, and I trust that the participation that they will have for the first time, under certain circumstances and at certain airports, will be well received and supported.

Will it be one hundred percent of what they demand? Surely not, as is almost always the case in all matters; but we are on the verge of a substantial change where historically, even in the major airports, which are logically called to this task, there has been no participation from the Autonomous Communities, and now there will be, and importantly, in the model that is being outlined and that the Minister of Development will present.

Thank you very much.