Press conference of the Prime Minister after the European Council meeting.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

28 October 2010 · Press conference of the Prime Minister after the European Council meeting

Context
Zapatero addressed a press conference on October 28, 2010, following the European Council meeting, summarizing key agreements on EU economic governance and crisis mechanisms.
Main themes
EU economic governance reform, permanent crisis mechanism for eurozone, Stability and Growth Pact, public debt rules, macroeconomic surveillance, European semester, G-20 Seoul Summit, financial sector reform, IMF reform, climate change and Cancun Conference, tribute to Marcelino Camacho, EU external summits
Duration
~31 min
84th percentile
Words
3,738
84th percentile
Sentences
131
75th percentile
Readability
39
33rd percentile
Grade
14.9
75th percentile
Syntax
3.29
81st percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
39th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

131 sentences in 62 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon.

Allow me to dedicate a few words of tribute and expression of my sorrow for the passing of Marcelino Camacho before I refer to the conclusions of the European Council. These words must begin by extending condolences to Josefina, his widow, and to his family, which I want to convey on behalf of the Government.

Marcelino Camacho dedicated his entire life to working for workers and devoted a good part of his life to conquering democracy, freedoms, and trade union freedom in our country. He deserves our deep appreciation, our sincere recognition, and a collective tribute for a person who has been a great testimony of coherence and who has contributed so much to the modern democratic era of our country.

The European Council has had a significant impact. You know that we are in a phase characterized by important changes in the conception of what has come to be called the economic governance of the European Union; changes aimed at consolidating, advancing, and deepening a common economic policy and a greater strength of the foundations around the monetary stability of the entire Union and, in particular, of the eurozone.

The European Council has agreed to create a permanent crisis mechanism, a preventive mechanism to ensure the financial stability of the eurozone. The President of the Council, in accordance with the adopted agreement, will carry out a phase of consultations from now until December so that the Council can adopt a definitive decision on the structure of the mechanism, as well as the necessary limited modification of the Treaty with the idea that it comes into force in mid-2013, which is when the mechanism we adopted last May will expire.

With this decision, we take a substantial step in common economic governance, a common economic governance that we will begin to implement before the summer of 2011, with a series of initiatives that reinforce the stability and economic governance of the European Union. Among which I will highlight the following:

- The existing rules on the level of deficit are complemented and improved with new rules on the level of public debt. This is essential to ensure the sustainability of public finances across the Union.

- Compliance with the Stability and Growth Pact is strengthened with the introduction of new sanctions and incentives, both in the preventive part and in the corrective part. I must recall, today yes, that in January 2010, at the beginning of our semester as rotating Presidency, I expressed my favorable opinion on the introduction of these incentives and more sanctions to help achieve our common objectives. Today the European Council has confirmed this direction and, in my opinion, it will be very positive for the economy and stability of the countries of the European Union.

- The decision-making process in matters of prevention and correction is endowed with a greater degree of automaticity. This will allow for a faster functioning of the procedures, although the Council always reserves political control over it. In particular, the criterion of reverse qualified majority is established for all sanction procedures.

- For the first time, we can say, an economic surveillance mechanism on macroeconomic imbalances is introduced, based on an annual analysis of the main indicators that we will have to determine.

- Likewise, the coordination of economic policies within the Union is intensified, particularly with the introduction of the European semester, synchronizing macroeconomic fiscal supervision and the structural reforms promoted by the Europe 2020 Strategy.

In addition to these agreements regarding the economic governance of the European Union, the Council has addressed the upcoming G-20 Summit, to be held in Seoul, where the European Union will express the need for the G-20 to adopt an ambitious message regarding the concrete implementation of agreed measures within the framework for strong, sustainable, and balanced growth; to complete the agenda for reforming the financial sector, which is quite advanced, and to realize, to culminate, the reform of the International Monetary Fund which, as you know, constitutes another of the new pillars of that renewed international financial system as a consequence of the crisis and the process, let us say, almost constitutional of the G-20.

Similarly, climate change has been addressed regarding the need to achieve significant progress at the upcoming Cancun Conference, which should serve as another step forward. On some occasions, we have expressed that the process of combating climate change is exactly that, a process that must go step by step. Cancun must be one more step towards that binding global agreement within the framework of the United Nations.

Finally, the Council has addressed in its final part the preparation for the upcoming European Union Summits; among others, those with the United States, Russia, and Ukraine.

Q.- President, to what extent have the risks assumed by the European Union in introducing a reform of the Lisbon Treaty, even if limited, been evaluated within the Council, when it has not yet been a year since its entry into force?

What has become of the proposal brought by Chancellor Angela Merkel to try to limit the right to vote within the Council to those who do not comply?

President.- Yes, you can imagine that the need for a Treaty reform, albeit limited, has been the subject of extensive debate among the Twenty-Seven, because the processes of reform, of amendment, of the Treaties have in different countries processes that in some cases are complicated.

Since it is a reform that will be limited, through a very simple procedure, although it has a significant impact, there has also been the necessary consensus to say that it must be addressed.

You know that without that Treaty reform that consolidates the permanent crisis mechanism, some countries have constitutional problems and, therefore, to prevent a constitutional problem from arising in any country, the Treaty must contain an explicit reference to that crisis mechanism; a mechanism that, as I have explained, must be outlined by December, based on a proposal from the Commission.

You know that we currently have a, let us say, provisional mechanism that has been articulated through bilateral loans from the eurozone countries for a specific country, for Greece. We will know in December, and approve, the Commission's proposal in this regard.

Secondly, regarding the highest level of sanctions that can occur based on a country's actions, I must say that the debate was also intense and that from the formula proposed by Germany to the more reluctant position regarding affecting voting rights, as expressed in general terms, there was a work of consensus proposals, which is reflected in the text and was approved by all. In that consensus proposal, in which Spain actively participated -- let us say that the formula is, to a large extent, a proposal from Spain -- what is established is that in a situation where a country can permanently jeopardize the monetary stability of the eurozone, the President of the Council, only for those cases, must carry out a reflection with consultations with all countries on the possibility of considering the suspension of that country's participation rights in matters affecting monetary stability.

Consequently, the President is invited to make an assessment; secondly, it speaks, in general, of participation rights; thirdly, very limited or limited exclusively to rights that affect issues related to monetary stability.

We will wait until December for the President to make this analysis and present us with his conclusions. I must say that from the atmosphere observed by a good number of countries, it is unlikely, rather very difficult, that such a drastic, strong situation as the deprivation of voting rights will be established, except in very exceptional circumstances, although we must wait for the debate in December, a situation so drastic, so strong, as the deprivation of voting rights. But, I insist, we will see the possibilities that President Van Rompuy puts on the table after the reflection and after the consultations.

In short, the message established is one of greater rigor, demand, and powers in the hands of the European Union; powers and faculties to prevent risks that in the fiscal situation or in the situation of a country may cause contagion to the entire eurozone. And I believe these are very important advances.

If the preventive and corrective part works, and we must make it work with the new powers that are placed in the hands of the Commission and the Council, we should reasonably never reach the scenario we have just discussed; that is, a serious permanent lack of stability caused by a country not complying. And I hope it will be so.

Q.- Chancellor Merkel said in her press conference that there have also been advances in an agreement on competitiveness and how it will be measured. Last week, Vice President Salgado told us that Spain had managed to ensure that in the analysis of competitiveness, the responsibility of the current Government would not be taken into account, but how those competitiveness shortcomings are corrected. I do not know if you can explain a little what the agreement consists of.

A second question. Is Spain in favor of the idea of ordering bankruptcies of countries through the introduction of private initiative?

Regarding Cancun, there is now talk of a multi-stage process; but international opinion had hoped that the process would close in Copenhagen and now it is in Cancun. Does the Council not recognize that this process may be stalling and that we may be arriving late to the meeting on climate change?

President.- I will start with the end, regarding the fight against climate change. It is true that there were great expectations in Copenhagen; but it is no less true that, except for the European Union, which arrived with a strong commitment on the essential aspects in the fight against climate change, this was not the general tone of the major international powers that are involved, along with the European Union, in the fight against climate change.

Consequently, we must adopt a path of going step by step, conquering commitments. In our opinion, in the opinion of the European Union, that path should be faster, more forceful, and with more effective commitments. But it does not depend solely on the European Union.

Secondly, we will wait for a proposal from the Commission regarding the mechanism, if applicable, for rescuing a country in crisis situations and we will wait for the reflection that the Commission will make on the role of the private sector. I must recall that the Conclusions speak of the "role of the private sector"; that is the exact expression. Therefore, it does not prejudge what the impact may be or not. This is also a matter of great significance and, in my opinion, before making a pronouncement that goes beyond, we must wait for the reflection and the proposal from the Commission, which will have and will judge with elements for it of great solvency and great solidity, as undoubtedly will be the collaboration and consultation with the European Central Bank.

The conclusions, which are largely the result of the "Task Force," are directly linked to a new stronger requirement on the Stability Pact and a new step for monitoring macroeconomic balances or imbalances and competitiveness. Undoubtedly, these are two very different levels. At the level of macroeconomic imbalances and competitiveness, we are in the realm of recommendations, of strong recommendations, of much more intense monitoring.

It seems to us that, as the Conclusions have been established, which, I insist, are a reflection of the Task Force report, it is reasonable. It is easier and more demanding for one government or another regarding the aspects related to the deficit and debt. Competitiveness is a field affected by many factors and, of course, much more debatable, although it seems evident that a strong euro requires a stable fiscal situation of the countries in the eurozone and greater convergence in competitiveness, and it is evident that that convergence in competitiveness means that all countries must place much more emphasis on competitiveness. Spain, of course.

We must gain productivity, which is the only way to gain competitiveness, and we will try to meet the demands and rise to the level of the recommendations that from this moment on the institutions of the European Union will make to the different countries and, of course, to Spain.

Q.- I had two questions of a national scope, if you allow me. The first is about the EPA. I would like to know if you consider or if the Government considers that the decrease in the number of unemployed reflected in today's EPA will be maintained.

Secondly, I would also like to know if you can deny that members of the Socialist Party of Euskadi have met with representatives of the illegalized Batasuna, and if you fear that these meetings or these suspicions of meetings could jeopardize the agreement with the Popular Party in the Basque Country.

President.- Regarding the second, I refer to the clear denial information provided by the Socialist Party of Euskadi. Therefore, I hope it will have no consequences, given that a clear and forceful denial has been made.

In relation to the Active Population Survey, with the data on unemployment and employment, first of all, this is a positive Active Population Survey, because unemployment has decreased and because seventy thousand people have found employment. But I must say that we have a difficult and long road ahead for the recovery of employment and the reduction of unemployment. We have expressed this many times, and today I want to reiterate it. It requires great tenacity, it requires implementing reforms, and it requires putting the economy into operation, at greater performance, and that, after the crisis we have suffered, is going to take work.

We must therefore be cautious when interpreting the data, although, I insist, they are positive and contradict some forecasts about what was going to happen this quarter. We hope that they will be confirmed, but we must remain very calm, because the task is arduous, very arduous. Furthermore, regardless of everything, the unemployment rate remains very high. Therefore, even though we have a certain reduction, we cannot express even a hint of satisfaction.

Q.- The Commission said it would put forward to the Council the proposal for a tax on financial activities; not on transactions, but on activities, on the profits of the banks, and that they would discuss it in relation to the G-20. What have you discussed about this?

President.- Yes, it is in the Conclusions and, logically, it will be a topic that we will bring to the G-20, and we will return to it in the Council in December. But, indeed, the Commission has conveyed it, in the form of Conclusions of the Council, in the part related to the G-20.

Q.- Mr. President, first of all, I apologize for insisting on a previous question, but I wanted to know what Spain's position really is, because the debate is already on the table, regarding the mechanism. What would Spain want from the mechanism? That is, are we closer to the German vision of a kind of Paris Club or do we share some reluctance from the European Central Bank?

Secondly, Spain has been very active, at least in speeches, in defending economic governance; but why is it one of the few countries not on the list of countries that have contributed something to this report in the "Task Force"?

President.- I am unaware of that list you refer to, but we have been contributing continuously through the Economic Vice President. You see, I just explained to you that in the Conclusions the final proposal on such a delicate issue as where we set the maximum level of sanctions has been a proposal that is fundamentally due to a Spanish initiative.

Where do we stand? There are things from the European Central Bank that seem reasonable to us and there are things from the German Government that seem reasonable to us, but fortunately, within the European Union, there is a working method that is the method of deliberation, of debate; often a debate among leaders within the Council. That debate has not yet taken place, it is expected to take place in December, and we must have the prudence to listen carefully to the European Central Bank regarding the rescue mechanism or the crisis situation mechanism and to all the Governments.

What is the perspective of the Government of Spain? Two principles that we consider fundamental: we would like it to be a permanent mechanism and that, beyond its bilateral articulation, it would have a consecration, a fund, and a European principle; above all, European.

Second, we are closer to those who are in a position of great caution when it comes to incorporating the private sector into the mechanism; a lot of caution. This message, without more, carries risks. Therefore, we will be in a position, in that sense, within the part that will express the most caution.

Q.- I would like to know if Spain would be willing to accept the possibility of deprivation of the right to vote, if that were, ultimately, Germany's condition to activate a new rescue fund.

Secondly, since we strongly support the proposals for the new economic governance and the monitoring of macroeconomic imbalances and competitiveness, I would like to know if you believe that, had it been in place a few years ago, I don't know if five or eight, it would have prevented the problems that the Spanish economy currently suffers.

President.- It would have prevented some of the problems, without a doubt. This would lead to a long explanation; but we must remember that at the birth of the euro, a common monetary policy was established, a European Central Bank, and it has the backing of the Stability Pact, but other macroeconomic pillars, which have been shown to affect and affect the economic stability, and therefore monetary, of the countries, did not receive the necessary attention nor was it considered that there should be requirements regarding those principles.

For example, for a time we thought that the external deficit -- it was a widely held opinion among economists -- of the countries that belonged to the eurozone was not a big problem as long as we were in the eurozone; that the euro was a great barrier, a great protector. However, it has been shown that a high external deficit, despite being in the eurozone, produces significant problems for economies.

On the other hand -- and this will continue to be an extraordinarily difficult issue -- the incorporation into the eurozone of some countries with low interest rates, as we have had, has generated a strong demand for credit in some countries, and therefore a strong indebtedness, which has also proven to be a very clear vulnerability at a time of crisis, and more than one crisis of the financial system.

This will be strongly present in the recommendations regarding macroeconomic imbalances and in the monitoring of macroeconomic imbalances. It was not there before. Therefore, it will help for the future.

In summary, the answer is: some of the most negative manifestations we have had when facing this financial crisis could have had a different situation if what we are doing now had been done at the birth of the euro. This is evident to me.

Regarding the deprivation of the right to vote, in my opinion, we will not be in that hypothesis. In any case, and I already expressed it within the Council, I believe that the European Union must have mechanisms, capacities, or responses more in line with what we represent as Europeans than to reach such an extreme solution. It should be very extraordinary and very limited to certain issues in a scenario that I do not think will occur.

Q.- I have two questions and the first is very simple. Will Ireland have to hold a referendum to accept the modification of the Treaty?

The second is a personal observation, which I would need you to confirm or dismiss. The creation of the euro entails a transfer of national sovereignty to common institutions. It seems to me that the new procedures established in the Stability Pact further limit national sovereignty in budgetary matters. That is why I want to ask you if you believe that none of these elements could have any hint of unconstitutionality.

President.- Regarding the second question, in my opinion, no. The great transfer of sovereignty was the creation of a common currency. If one reviews the classical literature on the characteristics of the modern state, it is always established as one of the three or four main elements the currency. Therefore, transferring from a state its currency to create a common currency, in this case to sixteen countries today, as is the euro, was already a great transfer of sovereignty.

What the European Union is doing now is not increasing the competencies of the European Union or strengthening or giving more transfer of sovereignty; no, what it is doing is strengthening the euro. And it benefits us all, it makes us more, in quotes, "sovereign and strong," if the euro is strong and if the euro is free from any risk, because the risk to the common currency is a common risk, which at one moment can affect everyone.

Therefore, I believe that what we are doing is perfecting the pillars of the euro, which have been shown to have some constructive defects. The euro has played a great role, it is a great project, it is a historic project of long reach, and I would dare to say that it is understandable that it was not perfect in its design from its birth. Now we are perfecting it and, of course, it will help a lot to the economic and monetary stability of all the countries that belong and of those that will join, because countries will continue to join the euro, which undoubtedly constitutes, along with the Common Market, the great hallmark of European identity.

Regarding Ireland, we will wait. I will not be the one to establish the constitutional requirements that may be needed for a reform limited by the simplest procedure provided for in the Treaties regarding that amendment to the Treaty, I insist, necessary to establish the crisis mechanism.

Thank you very much.