Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

10 September 2008 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions during a government control session in Spain's Congress on September 10, 2008, addressing piracy threats to Spanish vessels in the Indian Ocean.
Main themes
Piracy in the Indian Ocean, security of Spanish-flagged fishing vessels, EU coordinated naval response, UN Security Council Resolution 1816, Spain-France leadership on Somalia, parliamentary accountability, diplomatic efforts, international military cooperation
Duration
~13 min
47th percentile
Words
1,603
47th percentile
Sentences
61
40th percentile
Readability
41
39th percentile
Grade
13.9
66th percentile
Syntax
3.23
76th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 32%31%
  • Geopolitical 29%28%
  • Institutional 22%21%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

61 sentences in 27 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josu Erkoreka, of the Basque Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, until April of this year, the serious security problem affecting Spanish-flagged tuna freezer vessels operating in the Indian Ocean was, for the Government, little more than an eccentricity of Deputy Erkoreka and his Parliamentary Group, who insist on bringing original matters to the Chamber.

When the hijacking of the "Playa de Bakio" occurred, the Government's attitude began to change slightly. Then you started to acknowledge that when my Parliamentary Group warned about the possibility of such incidents occurring, it was not fabricating stories, but rather drawing attention to a real and very serious risk. At that point, you did take action and began to deploy a diplomatic effort that until then you had spared.

Subsequently, in appearances on May 22 and June 10, the Ministers of Foreign Affairs and the Environment committed before their respective Committees to implement an international security device in the Indian Ocean starting in July. When July arrived, the Minister of Defense declared before the media, in an interview published in the press, the immediate deployment of an international naval force in that area; but a week later, everything fell through without any explanation from the Executive, beyond some pretext or some hesitant and confusing excuse.

We requested the appearance of the Minister of Defense in Committee to explain the reasons, and we were denied. Your Group opposed it. What is happening, Mr. President? Are you doing nothing and do you not want to provide explanations for it?

President.- Mr. Erkoreka, the Government would never consider an initiative of Your Honor as an eccentricity, I assure you. We are aware of the problem, and I also acknowledge that you have had a constant sensitivity regarding this issue.

I can assure you that the Government has been deploying action in the area that we understand is truly operational, which is at the international level, to provide protection to the vessels operating in the Indian Ocean under the Spanish flag. We are working especially within the European Union to coordinate a common action of various military, naval, and air units.

This action is based on a coordination cell under political control and strategic direction of the Political and Security Committee. Spain has expressed its willingness to lead the cell and has offered a naval officer, a Captain. On September 15, the Council of General Affairs and Foreign Relations of the European Union is expected to make a decision on the implementation of this common European Union action for protection in the Indian Ocean.

In addition, the Spanish Government is carrying out initiatives in other areas. I can inform you that on July 31, a meeting was held in Madrid with representatives of countries that might be interested in participating in a military operation in the area, and we have also laid the foundations for Spanish-French leadership, in this case, in the process of implementing Security Council Resolution 1816, with the joint declaration on piracy and in support of peace and stability in Somalia that was developed at the last high-level cross-border meeting that took place last June.

In short, Your Honor, we continue to work to achieve an international force that provides protection. A force solely from our country, given the magnitude of the area to be protected, would be very unoperational, very ineffective. We need the cooperation of more countries, and we will not stop until we achieve it.

Mr. Erkoreka.- I thank you for the explanations that had been denied to us until now. I assume you are informed that the fishing situation is worsening in the area. Look, exactly one week ago, there were seven hijacked ships in the Gulf of Aden and up to 103 hostages. Tomorrow we could find ourselves with a "Playa de Bakio" II, which I hope does not catch the Government off guard, with its arms crossed and looking the other way.

My Parliamentary Group, Mr. President, is fulfilling its duty by bringing this issue to the Chamber and will continue to do so as many times as necessary until we are heard and the objectives we have set are met. We hope that your Government and you, as its President, will also fulfill your duty.

Mr. President.- I reiterate what I expressed a moment ago. We understand your sensitivity well, we recognize your continuous work on this matter, and the Government will do everything within its power, in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, in the Ministry of Defense, and in all areas, to achieve that protection, because we share your concern.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Yesterday you appeared here to inform us about the situation of the Spanish economy. You confessed that you had no new measures to offer and, moreover, you told us that you came here to generate confidence. While you were speaking, we learned that the European Commission stated that Spain would enter recession very soon.

In the opinion of many, your intervention yesterday only served to generate more doubts and unease among citizens. That is why I ask you if you really know what the economic situation of Spanish families and companies is, if you believe that your intervention yesterday helped to provide them with tranquility and to generate confidence in your future actions, and if you are willing to rectify, govern, and take measures that are truly effective to address the serious situation of the Spanish economy.

Mr. President.- Mr. Rajoy, you will understand that I am not going to evaluate yesterday's debate. There are already people who have that task, to evaluate the debate, and of course, this is an extension of yesterday's debate, extensions that you always enjoy in the debates we hold.

I will refer to the support we provide to families and companies, to reiterate to you so that you may perhaps listen and take into account the things that the Government is doing in support of families and companies, which we know are going through a difficult situation at this moment.

Through the deduction of four hundred euros, we have returned 6 billion euros, through the income tax deduction, to families to help them with their loss of purchasing power. Minimum pensions: we are going to raise them by an average of 6 percent to improve the purchasing power of those with the lowest incomes in our society. We are going to allocate 1.2 billion euros for dependency in this same fiscal year, which is an important support for families in difficulty. We are going to increase the amount of scholarships for 2009 by an average of 6 percent and we are going to advance in the free provision of Early Childhood Education for children aged zero to three years, allocating for this purpose one hundred million euros for the first time since the State Government. Likewise, we guarantee unemployment benefits for 85 percent of those who lose their jobs in this difficult circumstance.

Therefore, support for families, support for the lowest incomes, and support for social policies, as we have done in this Legislature and also in 2009 despite the economic situation. Support for companies, with ICO lines to support their financing, through various guarantee channels of 3 billion euros; support for companies with the reduction of the Corporate Tax and new lines, which I mentioned yesterday, for the real estate sector and, of course, to promote rental.

In short, support in all areas for families and companies, within the budgetary margins that the Government has to do sensible things. Not empty words, not a lack of ideas; concrete actions. That, of course, alleviates the situation of families and companies somewhat, but does not solve it.

Mr. Rajoy.- You say you are doing many things, but those things are not producing any effect, Mr. President, because what Spaniards say on the street is that prices are rising and that there are many difficulties to make ends meet. They say that mortgages are rising, that many people are losing their jobs and that many others fear losing theirs, and that companies have many difficulties accessing credit.

This cannot be fixed with cosmetic measures or by reading the successive Royal Decrees that you are approving in the Council of Ministers. You have wasted a lot of time, you have not done things well. Now it is becoming a problem, and I want to say one thing: every time you speak, you generate more concern among all Spaniards, and if you continue like this, it will be impossible to recover the path of growth in the Spanish economy.

My duty, and I fulfill it, is to demand that you govern, to demand that you take effective measures, and do not say that you cannot, because then you are surplus. Yes, things can be done as they were done in other economic crises that Spain has gone through, and if you do not do it, if you do not take measures, distrust will grow, and we will emerge from the crisis much later and much more damaged.

I have presented you with a broad package of economic measures, and things can be done. I ask you to at least be humble, not to be arrogant, and to listen to what those who were able to address an economic crisis and ensure a period of growth in Spain like we have not seen in many years have to say.