PM Lee Hsien Loong at PA Kopi Talk at Ci Yuan CC

Singapore Lee Hsien Loong · Prime Minister of Singapore

23 September 2017 · PA Kopi Talk · Ci Yuan CC

Context
Lee addressed a People's Association Kopi Talk community dialogue at Ci Yuan Community Centre on 23 September 2017, speaking on race, multiracialism, and terrorism.
Main themes
Multiracialism, racial harmony, terrorism and self-radicalisation, Singapore's national identity, ISIS and regional extremism, minority rights and majority responsibility, Singapore-Malaysia separation, founding principles and constitution, social cohesion, community resilience
Duration
~80 min
98th percentile
Words
9,596
98th percentile
Sentences
617
99th percentile
Readability
54
75th percentile
Grade
9.5
15th percentile
Syntax
2.82
24th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
31st percentile

Translated from Multiple languages

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 45%43%
  • Institutional 36%34%
  • Geopolitical 12%12%
  • Ceremonial 7%6%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

617 sentences in 119 paragraphs

RACE, MULTIRACIALISM AND SINGAPORE’S PLACE IN THE WORLD

Good morning everybody.

Why Multiracialism

Race has been a fundamental issue for Singapore from the very beginning of our nationhood. In 1965, on the day we became independent, Mr. Lee Kuan Yew said Singapore is “not a Malay nation, not a Chinese nation, not an Indian nation. Everybody will have a place in Singapore.”

He said this to assure the minorities in Singapore that they would always be protected and not be treated worse than the majority. But he also said this to remind the Chinese majority never to oppress the non-Chinese, because they themselves had felt squatted upon when Singapore was in Malaysia. It was a two-part message – not only to reassure the minorities but at the same time, give a sober reminder to the majority not to overstep their bounds, and make life miserable for those who are not the same colour as them. Why was this principle so important to us? There are two parts to this answer.

First, this was the fundamental ideal over which we fought with the central government in Malaysia. Our founding fathers – Lee Kuan Yew, Goh Keng Swee, S Rajaratnam, Othman Wok – they believed passionately in the vision of a multi-racial society. Where nobody would be favoured or disadvantaged because of the colour of his or her skin. Where everybody would have equal opportunities, feel kinship and brotherhood with people of different races and religions, and share the same Singapore nationality. Malaysia was different. The UMNO leaders in Kuala Lumpur (KL) – the central government – wanted one dominant race, i.e. Malay Malaysians, to enjoy special rights, while the Chinese, Indians and other citizens would forever be in a subordinate position. We fought that, and disagreed with them. Eventually, we separated from them because it could not be settled.

The second reason we have to make a fundamental point about multiracialism is because Singapore is a Chinese-majority country, in a Malay-majority part of Southeast Asia. In the 1960s, 50 years ago, Singapore had already been perceived as a “Third China”. We were seen as a Chinese country, a proxy, a stooge for communist China, and not an independent player. If Singapore had been identified as a Chinese country, it would have caused problems with our neighbours. We would not have been able to live peacefully in Southeast Asia. So we had to make quite sure that people understood that we were an independent, multiracial country.

Therefore, our founding fathers made multiracialism the fundamental principle on which Singapore was founded, and enshrined it in our Constitution. They drafted the National Pledge, where we “pledge ourselves as one united people, regardless of race, language or religion”.

Terrorism

In Southeast Asia, race and religion do not only affect society and politics, but also terrorism and violence. This has afflicted many countries in Southeast Asia.

Hundreds of Indonesians and Malaysians have gone to join ISIS. A few have gone to the Philippines, while hundreds have gone to the Middle East. There are some prominent Malaysian and Indonesian terrorists who are with ISIS in Syria and Iraq – Bahrun Naim, Bahrumsyah, Mohammed Saffan. They may be in the Middle East, but they are in full contact with their people back in Indonesia and Malaysia. They use Facebook; their Facebook is more powerful than mine. They use Telegram; definitely more powerful than mine. They spread propaganda to cultivate and recruit more to their cause. With social media, they can give orders and mount operations. They tell their sympathisers: Come to the Middle East, or if you can’t do that, go to the Philippines or do jihad in your own countries.

We are not insulated from terrorism. Every month or two, the Internal Security Department picks up one or two Singaporeans who have become self-radicalised. They are not down and out, and neither are they from the Middle East. They were born and raised in Singapore, educated in state schools. But they have become self-radicalised. Most are men, but there are even some young women. They want to join the militants in Syria, and do something violent in Singapore.

So it is not a question of “if”, but “when” a terrorist attack might happen in Singapore. Which is why even at today’s event, you can see that we have put in place precautions around Ci Yuan Community Centre. It is a lot of work, and I understand that it is inconvenient to residents, but it is necessary. We have to take this very seriously, and fortify ourselves not just physically, but also as a society – psychologically and emotionally as one people. And that means we need multiracialism.

Multiracialism by itself will not stop an attack. It can still happen because even if 99.99 per cent of Singaporeans believed in multiracialism, there would still be a handful who do not. But multiracialism will help us cope with the day after a terrible attack has happened – when people are in shock, in pain, and feeling angry and fearful. It is very easy for an attack by terrorists – who act in the name of Islam – to cause a divide between Muslims and non-Muslims, and for us to become split as a society. Many people will be angry and scared. But if you have been working together at this through the IRCCs and SGSecure, and you have all our neighbourhood groups and religious leaders working together, then we can hold on together and let life go on as one people. That is why I recently held closed-door briefings to discuss the issue of terrorist threats. First for Muslim religious and community leaders, and then for a mixed group. The briefings were useful for them to understand how important and urgent the problem of terrorism is, and to get them on our side to help us to deal with it. They responded positively. I think we will have their full cooperation in working towards multicultural unity.

Multiracialism in Singapore

Over the last 52 years, we made significant progress in becoming one people – regardless of race, language or religion. We take pride in our country, and in our identity. We have worked together, built together, mourned together, and celebrated together as one people.

But you must remember that what we have here is not something natural, nor something which will stay there by itself. It is the result of very hard work, a lot of toil and sweat, and the gradual education and bringing together of people. It was also because of the gradual inculcation of shared values and attitudes that we came to have the confidence, trust and mutual respect to make us one people. We brought people together and consciously created common spaces and opportunities. We used English as our common working language, while ensuring a place for our mother tongues. We mixed all races together in HDB estates, so that there are no enclaves or ghettos in Singapore. In schools, we recite the Pledge every day. We created GRCs so that in Parliament we will always have minorities represented. We came down hard on extremists – regardless of whether they were Chinese chauvinists or Malay, Indian or Hindu extremists – because they have to understand that this is what Singapore is, and this is how Singapore will act when racial chauvinists try to stir up sentiments against others.

Sometimes we think we have arrived, and that we can do away with these provisions and rules which feel like such a burden. But in fact, it is the other way around. It is precisely because we have these provisions and rules, that we have achieved racial and religious harmony.

We have not yet arrived at an ideal state of accepting people of a different race. Yes, we have made progress, but it is work in progress.

Last year, the Institute of Policy Studies (IPS) did a survey. They asked people what they thought about being with someone of a different race. First, ‘Are you okay with somebody of a different race being your colleague?’ No problem. ‘Are you okay with somebody of a different race being your business partner?’ Here, they have to think a bit more carefully. ‘Are you okay with a person of a different race becoming your daughter-in-law?’ Very difficult. But this is the reality. We are friends and citizens together but there are different circles of trust. One of these circles is being of the same religion and race.

IPS did a different survey with CNA and asked: ‘Are you okay with a person of a different race being President?’ The answer was: ‘I have to be more careful than having my colleague at the next desk work with me, but it is a bit easier than having a son-in-law or a daughter-in-law’. I think that is an honest answer. We are not completely colour-blind, and this makes a difference. It will influence our thinking and choices, either consciously or unconsciously. Therefore, it is harder for a minority – a Malay or Indian or Eurasian – to win an open election for president, than it is for a Chinese.

I think you can accept it when I tell it to you like this. But when you make these arguments outside, people get worked up about the reserved election. They wish this bias were not true. But I just give you one fact.

This time we had a reserved election. There were three Malay candidates who came forward, of whom two did not qualify – but they came forward. Then you look at the presidential election in 2011. It was hotly contested. A lot of people thought the Government needed to be checked. Was there a Malay candidate? Where were the Farid Khans and the Salleh Maricans? Why didn’t they come? It did not cross their minds? No. So why didn’t they come? Because they knew that in an open election – all things being equal – a non-Chinese candidate would have no chance. So you had Tan Kin Lian, Tan Cheng Bock, and Tan Jee Say. But you did not have a Marican, nor a Khan or any other Malay candidate. It is a reality. We have to know this, we have to manage this.

These are the big trends. Elections only happen once in a while. But even in our day-to-day lives, we have racial issues that we have to deal with. Minorities sometimes face discrimination when looking for jobs. Sometimes, landlords prefer not to have minorities rent a house from them. These landlords will give some reasons, but you know it is because they prefer to look for a tenant who is of a certain race. Racial stereotypes persist in conversations and jokes. If you are amongst close friends, it is okay. For friends who are not so close, it can cause misunderstandings. There was a recent incident where someone put up a decoration with a young Malay girl’s picture on a construction hoarding. It showed her wearing a tudung. And after that, somebody went and pencilled “terrorist” on the picture.

These are the realities we have to manage. The Chinese in Singapore may not realise it, because the Chinese are the majority race. They may think that Singapore has “arrived” as a multiracial society. You only get small reminders from time to time, when you go to a different country, and there you encounter racism. If you go to America or Australia or somewhere in Europe, you may know what it feels like to be treated as a minority.

The younger ones have only known peace and harmony in Singapore, and it is very easy to believe that race does not matter anymore. But this is not so. We have to know our blind spots, and make a special effort to ensure our minority communities feel welcomed and valued in Singapore. The Chinese community particularly must make a special effort to make the minorities feel welcome in Singapore.

Elected Presidency

This is why we amended the Constitution to ensure that minorities regularly have a chance to be the President, and to strengthen ourselves as a multiracial country. Just having multiracial Presidents will not in itself make Singapore a multiracial country. But it is one important symbol of what Singapore stands for, and a declaration of what we aspire to be. It is a reminder to every citizen, especially the Chinese majority race, that there is a role for every community in Singapore.

We have not had a Malay President since our very first President, Encik Yusof Ishak, more than 50 years ago. But I am very happy that we now have Mdm Halimah Yacob as our President. As DPM Teo said when we were attending her swearing-in, and singing Majulah Singapura: “It is a special feeling”.

We have spent nearly two years preparing to make this move. Ever since I raised the subject when Parliament opened in January 2016, we have been discussing and debating this continually. But it is only now that people are seized with it, after a reserved election in which only one candidate qualified.

There was some unhappiness. I can feel that; you do not have to tell me. People think we may be going backwards, towards racial politics. But actually the reality is the opposite: We are making necessary changes to strengthen our multiracial system, in order to continue to progress as one united people. If we did nothing, it was very likely that we would not have had a Malay president for a very long time. After a while, the minorities in Singapore would start to feel left out, and understandably so. The Chinese majority might also become less sensitive to other races. This would weaken our sense of shared nationhood for all Singaporeans.

When we created the elected presidency about 25 years ago, we knew that we might have trouble electing minority Presidents. In fact, Malay Singaporeans at that time immediately sensed this – that it would be difficult to have a Malay President in future. But at that time we had to address the more pressing issue – how to find good candidates to be President. So we decided to observe and see how things developed. Now after 25 years, it is time. We know how things have developed, and how they are likely to be for quite a long time to come. We think we know what to do in order to mend this problem.

We should not be shy to acknowledge that in Singapore, the majority is making a special effort to ensure that minorities enjoy full and equal treatment. We are not unique in making special arrangements for our Head of State. It is necessary in many multiracial countries. They make deliberate arrangements – either constitutional rules or conventions – but they have some kind of rotation or special representations for the minorities. Canada’s Governor-General alternates between the French-speaking and English-speaking communities. In New Zealand, they have minorities too. They have had a Governor-General of Indian descent, and the current Governor-General has Maori blood. These examples do not happen by chance. In these countries, they specifically looked for distinguished individuals from minority communities to be the Head of State. Switzerland – an ideal country, 900 years of nationhood – they have got Swiss Germans, Swiss French, Swiss Italians, and their President rotates between these three groups. Because if you just have an open election, the Swiss Germans would probably win every time. That is why we have to make arrangements.

How did we have Encik Yusof Ishak as President? It was not an election, but a choice. How was the choice made? Mr. Lee Kuan Yew specifically looked for a distinguished Malay. Why? Because he wanted to show Singaporeans and the Federation of Malaya that we can work with the Malays, that we are part of Malaya, and we are one Malayan society, and not a Chinese society. So he asked Encik Yusof Ishak, who agreed and became our Yang di-Pertuan Negara, and later our first President.

Today, our Presidents are chosen by election. But we need to have mechanisms in place so that minorities have a chance. How did we do that? The Constitutional Commission recommended a hiatus-based mechanism, with reserved elections for the Presidency. This meant that if there was no Malay President for a long time, the next election would be reserved for a Malay. No Indian President for a long time, and the next election would be reserved for an Indian. In fact, for good measure the Commission said that if there was no Chinese President for a long time, then the next election would be reserved for the Chinese. Actually, there was no need to do so for the Chinese. But the Chinese community felt that if you did not also make provisions for the Chinese, something was not right under the sun. So we did it, and this shows you just how sensitive and necessary the mechanism is.

Conclusion

Did I know that this subject would be a difficult one? That it would be unpopular and cost us votes? Yes, I knew. If I do not know that these are sensitive matters, I cannot be in politics. But I did it, because I strongly believe, and still do, that this is the right thing to do.

There is nothing natural about where we are – multiracial, multi-religious, tolerant and progressive. We made it happen, and we have got to protect it, nurture it, preserve it, and never break it.

President Halimah said at her swearing-in ceremony that she could understand why people did not like the reserved election. And like them, she looks forward to the day when we no longer need it, and Singaporeans naturally and regularly elect citizens of all races as President. I too hope that we will eventually not need such a mechanism to ensure minority representation. But we are not there yet, and it will take a long time to happen.

In climbing towards that ideal state, we need guide-ropes and guard-rails to help us get there and to prevent us from falling off along the way. The reserved election for the President is one such guard-rail.

After the swearing-in, I posted a picture on Instagram of myself, President Halimah and Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon. A Chinese, a Malay, and an Indian – only in Singapore. During the F1, one international visitor from Brazil saw the picture and commented on it. He said it was most amazing what we have in Singapore. He could not imagine it happening anywhere else.

In fact, it is amazing. It shows what Singapore is – multiracial, meritocratic, one flag, one people. That is what makes us Singaporean. It is not just resonant rhetoric, or a warm, fuzzy feeling. We have to live it out daily, in little ways and big. You have a neighbour of a different race, and you can celebrate each other’s festivals. Share pineapple tarts, kueh dadar and murukku – many reasons to break your diabetes vows! But it is also much more than that. It is about having colleagues and true friends from different races whom we laugh and cry with. It is about being able to accommodate one another and to work through our differences. It is about having the honesty to recognise that our multiracialism is not yet perfect, but having the courage and determination to take pragmatic steps to get there, step by step. That is how we will continue to expand our common space, strengthen trust, and become one people, one nation, one Singapore.

Thank you.

“Race, Multiracialism and Singapore’s Place in the World”

Since our independence, race has been an important issue that Singapore has faced. In 1965, on the day of independence, founding Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew said: “Singapore is not a Malay nation, nor a Chinese nation, nor an Indian nation. In Singapore, everyone will have equal status.”

The purpose of his statement was to assure the minority communities in Singapore that their status would always be protected and that they would not be treated worse than the majority; at the same time, it served as a reminder to the Chinese majority not to oppress the non-Chinese, as they themselves had once been oppressed when Singapore joined the Federation of Malaya. This conveyed two important messages – while reassuring the minorities, it also sternly reminded the majority not to overstep their bounds and not to let those of different skin colors live in misery. Why is this principle of governance so important to us? There are two reasons.

First, we clashed with the central government of Malaysia over this fundamental belief. Our founding fathers, Lee Kuan Yew, Goh Keng Swee, S Rajaratnam, and Othman Wok, steadfastly upheld the belief in establishing a multiracial society. In this society, no one would receive special treatment or be disadvantaged because of their skin color. Everyone would have fair opportunities, and people of different races and religions would respect and love one another, sharing a common national identity. Malaysia, on the other hand, had different views. The leaders of the United Malays National Organization (UMNO) in Kuala Lumpur, who were part of the central government at the time, wanted to establish a Malaysia dominated by Malays, where Malays would enjoy privileges while Chinese, Indians, and other citizens would forever be in a subordinate position. Our founding leaders opposed this approach and had disagreements with them. As the differences could not be resolved, Singapore eventually separated from Malaysia and became independent.

The second reason we must uphold multiracialism as a principle of governance is that Singapore is located in a region of Southeast Asia where Malays are the majority, yet it is a country where Chinese are the majority. About 50 years ago, in the 1960s, Singapore was seen as a “Third China,” perceived as a Chinese country, a proxy and puppet of communist China, rather than an independent nation. If Singapore were identified as a Chinese country, it would create problems with our neighboring countries. We would not be able to live peacefully in Southeast Asia. Therefore, we must ensure that people clearly understand that Singapore is an independent multiracial country.

Thus, our founding fathers established multiracialism as the fundamental principle of Singapore’s founding and enshrined it in our Constitution. When drafting the National Pledge, they emphasized: “We pledge ourselves as one united people, regardless of race, language, or religion.”

Terrorism

In Southeast Asia, issues of race and religion not only affect social and political aspects but also lead to terrorism and violence. Many Southeast Asian countries have been deeply afflicted by this.

Hundreds of Indonesians and Malaysians have gone to join ISIS. A few have gone to the Philippines, while hundreds have gone to the Middle East. There are some prominent Malaysian and Indonesian terrorists who are with ISIS in Syria and Iraq – Bahrun Naim, Bahrumsyah, Mohammed Saffan. They may be in the Middle East, but they are in full contact with their people back in Indonesia and Malaysia. They use Facebook; their Facebook is more powerful than mine. They use Telegram; definitely more powerful than mine. They spread propaganda to cultivate and recruit more to their cause. With social media, they can give orders and mount operations. They tell their sympathisers: Come to the Middle East, or if you can’t do that, go to the Philippines or do jihad in your own countries.

We are not insulated from terrorism. Every month or two, the Internal Security Department picks up one or two Singaporeans who have become self-radicalised. They are not down and out, and neither are they from the Middle East. They were born and raised in Singapore, educated in state schools. But they have become self-radicalised. Most are men, but there are even some young women. They want to join the militants in Syria, and do something violent in Singapore.

So it is not a question of “if”, but “when” a terrorist attack might happen in Singapore. Which is why even at today’s event, you can see that we have put in place precautions around Ci Yuan Community Centre. It is a lot of work, and I understand that it is inconvenient to residents, but it is necessary. We have to take this very seriously, and fortify ourselves not just physically, but also as a society – psychologically and emotionally as one people. And that means we need multiracialism.

Multiracialism by itself will not stop an attack. It can still happen because even if 99.99 per cent of Singaporeans believed in multiracialism, there would still be a handful who do not. But multiracialism will help us cope with the day after a terrible attack has happened – when people are in shock, in pain, and feeling angry and fearful. It is very easy for an attack by terrorists – who act in the name of Islam – to cause a divide between Muslims and non-Muslims, and for us to become split as a society. Many people will be angry and scared. But if you have been working together at this through the IRCCs and SGSecure, and you have all our neighbourhood groups and religious leaders working together, then we can hold on together and let life go on as one people. That is why I recently held closed-door briefings to discuss the issue of terrorist threats. First for Muslim religious and community leaders, and then for a mixed group. The briefings were useful for them to understand how important and urgent the problem of terrorism is, and to get them on our side to help us to deal with it. They responded positively. I think we will have their full cooperation in working towards multicultural unity.

Multiracialism in Singapore

Over the last 52 years, we made significant progress in becoming one people – regardless of race, language or religion. We take pride in our country, and in our identity. We have worked together, built together, mourned together, and celebrated together as one people.

But you must remember that what we have here is not something natural, nor something which will stay there by itself. It is the result of very hard work, a lot of toil and sweat, and the gradual education and bringing together of people. It was also because of the gradual inculcation of shared values and attitudes that we came to have the confidence, trust and mutual respect to make us one people. We brought people together and consciously created common spaces and opportunities. We used English as our common working language, while ensuring a place for our mother tongues. We mixed all races together in HDB estates, so that there are no enclaves or ghettos in Singapore. In schools, we recite the Pledge every day. We created GRCs so that in Parliament we will always have minorities represented. We came down hard on extremists – regardless of whether they were Chinese chauvinists or Malay, Indian or Hindu extremists – because they have to understand that this is what Singapore is, and this is how Singapore will act when racial chauvinists try to stir up sentiments against others.

Sometimes we think we have arrived, and that we can do away with these provisions and rules which feel like such a burden. But in fact, it is the other way around. It is precisely because we have these provisions and rules, that we have achieved racial and religious harmony.

We have not yet arrived at an ideal state of accepting people of a different race. Yes, we have made progress, but it is work in progress.

Last year, the Institute of Policy Studies (IPS) did a survey. They asked people what they thought about being with someone of a different race. First, ‘Are you okay with somebody of a different race being your colleague?’ No problem. ‘Are you okay with somebody of a different race being your business partner?’ Here, they have to think a bit more carefully. ‘Are you okay with a person of a different race becoming your daughter-in-law?’ Very difficult. But this is the reality. We are friends and citizens together but there are different circles of trust. One of these circles is being of the same religion and race.

IPS did a different survey with CNA and asked: ‘Are you okay with a person of a different race being President?’ The answer was: ‘I have to be more careful than having my colleague at the next desk work with me, but it is a bit easier than having a son-in-law or a daughter-in-law’. I think that is an honest answer. We are not completely colour-blind, and this makes a difference. It will influence our thinking and choices, either consciously or unconsciously. Therefore, it is harder for a minority – a Malay or Indian or Eurasian – to win an open election for president, than it is for a Chinese.

I think you can accept it when I tell it to you like this. But when you make these arguments outside, people get worked up about the reserved election. They wish this bias were not true. But I just give you one fact.

This time we had a reserved election. There were three Malay candidates who came forward, of whom two did not qualify – but they came forward. Then you look at the presidential election in 2011. It was hotly contested. A lot of people thought the Government needed to be checked. Was there a Malay candidate? Where were the Farid Khans and the Salleh Maricans? Why didn’t they come? It did not cross their minds? No. So why didn’t they come? Because they knew that in an open election – all things being equal – a non-Chinese candidate would have no chance. So you had Tan Kin Lian, Tan Cheng Bock, and Tan Jee Say. But you did not have a Marican, nor a Khan or any other Malay candidate. It is a reality. We have to know this, we have to manage this.

These are the big trends. Elections only happen once in a while. But even in our day-to-day lives, we have racial issues that we have to deal with. Minorities sometimes face discrimination when looking for jobs. Sometimes, landlords prefer not to have minorities rent a house from them. These landlords will give some reasons, but you know it is because they prefer to look for a tenant who is of a certain race. Racial stereotypes persist in conversations and jokes. If you are amongst close friends, it is okay. For friends who are not so close, it can cause misunderstandings. There was a recent incident where someone put up a decoration with a young Malay girl’s picture on a construction hoarding. It showed her wearing a tudung. And after that, somebody went and pencilled “terrorist” on the picture.

These are the realities we have to manage. The Chinese in Singapore may not realise it, because the Chinese are the majority race. They may think that Singapore has “arrived” as a multiracial society. You only get small reminders from time to time, when you go to a different country, and there you encounter racism. If you go to America or Australia or somewhere in Europe, you may know what it feels like to be treated as a minority.

The younger ones have only known peace and harmony in Singapore, and it is very easy to believe that race does not matter anymore. But this is not so. We have to know our blind spots, and make a special effort to ensure our minority communities feel welcomed and valued in Singapore. The Chinese community particularly must make a special effort to make the minorities feel welcome in Singapore.

Elected Presidency

This is why we amended the Constitution to ensure that minorities regularly have a chance to be the President, and to strengthen ourselves as a multiracial country. Just having multiracial Presidents will not in itself make Singapore a multiracial country. But it is one important symbol of what Singapore stands for, and a declaration of what we aspire to be. It is a reminder to every citizen, especially the Chinese majority race, that there is a role for every community in Singapore.

We have not had a Malay President since our very first President, Encik Yusof Ishak, more than 50 years ago. But I am very happy that we now have Mdm Halimah Yacob as our President. As DPM Teo said when we were attending her swearing-in, and singing Majulah Singapura: “It is a special feeling”.

We have spent nearly two years preparing to make this move. Ever since I raised the subject when Parliament opened in January 2016, we have been discussing and debating this continually. But it is only now that people are seized with it, after a reserved election in which only one candidate qualified.

There was some unhappiness. I can feel that; you do not have to tell me. People think we may be going backwards, towards racial politics. But actually the reality is the opposite: We are making necessary changes to strengthen our multiracial system, in order to continue to progress as one united people. If we did nothing, it was very likely that we would not have had a Malay president for a very long time. After a while, the minorities in Singapore would start to feel left out, and understandably so. The Chinese majority might also become less sensitive to other races. This would weaken our sense of shared nationhood for all Singaporeans.

When we created the elected presidency about 25 years ago, we knew that we might have trouble electing minority Presidents. In fact, Malay Singaporeans at that time immediately sensed this – that it would be difficult to have a Malay President in future. But at that time we had to address the more pressing issue – how to find good candidates to be President. So we decided to observe and see how things developed. Now after 25 years, it is time. We know how things have developed, and how they are likely to be for quite a long time to come. We think we know what to do in order to mend this problem.

We should not be shy to acknowledge that in Singapore, the majority is making a special effort to ensure that minorities enjoy full and equal treatment. We are not unique in making special arrangements for our Head of State. It is necessary in many multiracial countries. They make deliberate arrangements – either constitutional rules or conventions – but they have some kind of rotation or special representations for the minorities. Canada’s Governor-General alternates between the French-speaking and English-speaking communities. In New Zealand, they have minorities too. They have had a Governor-General of Indian descent, and the current Governor-General has Maori blood. These examples do not happen by chance. In these countries, they specifically looked for distinguished individuals from minority communities to be the Head of State. Switzerland – an ideal country, 900 years of nationhood – they have got Swiss Germans, Swiss French, Swiss Italians, and their President rotates between these three groups. Because if you just have an open election, the Swiss Germans would probably win every time. That is why we have to make arrangements.

How did we have Encik Yusof Ishak as President? It was not an election, but a choice. How was the choice made? Mr Lee Kuan Yew specifically looked for a distinguished Malay. Why? Because he wanted to show Singaporeans and the Federation of Malaya that we can work with the Malays, that we are part of Malaya, and we are one Malayan society, and not a Chinese society. So he asked Encik Yusof Ishak, who agreed and became our Yang di-Pertuan Negara, and later our first President.

Today, our Presidents are chosen by election. But we need to have mechanisms in place so that minorities have a chance. How did we do that? The Constitutional Commission recommended a hiatus-based mechanism, with reserved elections for the Presidency. This meant that if there was no Malay President for a long time, the next election would be reserved for a Malay. No Indian President for a long time, and the next election would be reserved for an Indian. In fact, for good measure the Commission said that if there was no Chinese President for a long time, then the next election would be reserved for the Chinese. Actually, there was no need to do so for the Chinese. But the Chinese community felt that if you did not also make provisions for the Chinese, something was not right under the sun. So we did it, and this shows you just how sensitive and necessary the mechanism is.

Conclusion

Did I know that this subject would be a difficult one? That it would be unpopular and cost us votes? Yes, I knew. If I do not know that these are sensitive matters, I cannot be in politics. But I did it, because I strongly believe, and still do, that this is the right thing to do.

There is nothing natural about where we are – multiracial, multi-religious, tolerant and progressive. We made it happen, and we have got to protect it, nurture it, preserve it, and never break it.

President Halimah said at her swearing-in ceremony that she could understand why people did not like the reserved election. And like them, she looks forward to the day when we no longer need it, and Singaporeans naturally and regularly elect citizens of all races as President. I too hope that we will eventually not need such a mechanism to ensure minority representation. But we are not there yet, and it will take a long time to happen.

In climbing towards that ideal state, we need guide-ropes and guard-rails to help us get there and to prevent us from falling off along the way. The reserved election for the President is one such guard-rail.

After the swearing-in, I posted a picture on Instagram of myself, President Halimah and Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon. A Chinese, a Malay, and an Indian – only in Singapore. During the F1, one international visitor from Brazil saw the picture and commented on it. He said it was most amazing what we have in Singapore. He could not imagine it happening anywhere else.

In fact, it is amazing. It shows what Singapore is – multiracial, meritocratic, one flag, one people. That is what makes us Singaporean. It is not just resonant rhetoric, or a warm, fuzzy feeling. We have to live it out daily, in little ways and big. You have a neighbour of a different race, and you can celebrate each other’s festivals. Share pineapple tarts, kueh dadar and murukku – many reasons to break your diabetes vows! But it is also much more than that. It is about having colleagues and true friends from different races whom we laugh and cry with. It is about being able to accommodate one another and to work through our differences. It is about having the honesty to recognise that our multiracialism is not yet perfect, but having the courage and determination to take pragmatic steps to get there, step by step. That is how we will continue to expand our common space, strengthen trust, and become one people, one nation, one Singapore.

Thank you.

“Race, Multiracialism and Singapore's Place in the World”

Since our independence, race has been an important issue that Singapore has faced. On the day of independence in 1965, our founding Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew said: “Singapore is not a Malay nation, it is not a Chinese nation, it is not an Indian nation. In Singapore, every person will have equal status.”

The purpose of his statement was to assure Singapore's minority communities that their status would always be safeguarded, and that they would not be treated worse than the majority community; while also reminding the majority Chinese community not to oppress non-Chinese, as they themselves had been oppressed when Singapore joined the Federation of Malaysia. This conveyed two important messages – while soothing the minority communities, it also sternly reminded the majority community not to overstep boundaries and not to allow those of different skin colors to live in suffering. Why is this principle of governance so important to us? There are two reasons.

First, we clashed with the central government of Malaysia over this fundamental belief. Our founding leaders Lee Kuan Yew, Goh Keng Swee, S. Rajaratnam, and Osman bin Mohamed Ali steadfastly upheld the belief in establishing a multiracial society. In this society, no one would receive special treatment or be disadvantaged because of their skin color. Everyone has a fair opportunity, and people of different races and religions respect and love one another, sharing a common national identity. Malaysia, on the other hand, had different views. The leaders of the United Malays National Organization (UMNO) in Kuala Lumpur, who were the central government at the time, wanted to establish a Malaysia that prioritized Malays, where Malays would enjoy privileges, while Chinese, Indians, and other citizens would forever be in a subordinate position. Our founding leaders opposed such practices and clashed with them. As the differences could not be resolved, Singapore ultimately separated from Malaysia and became independent.

The second reason we must uphold multiracialism as a principle of governance is that Singapore is located in Southeast Asia, which is predominantly Malay, yet it is a country with a majority Chinese population. About 50 years ago, in the 1960s, Singapore was seen as the "Third China," regarded as a Chinese nation, a proxy and puppet of Communist China, rather than an independent country. If Singapore were identified as a Chinese nation, it would create problems in our relations with neighboring countries. We would not be able to live peacefully in Southeast Asia. Therefore, we must ensure that people clearly understand that Singapore is an independent multiracial country.

Thus, our founding leaders established multiracialism as the fundamental principle of Singapore's nation-building and enshrined it in our Constitution. They emphasized in drafting Singapore's national pledge: “To pledge ourselves, regardless of race, language, or religion, to build a democratic society.”

Terrorism

In Southeast Asia, issues of race and religion not only affect social and political aspects but also lead to terrorism and violent activities. Many Southeast Asian countries have been deeply affected by this.

We know that hundreds of Indonesians and Malaysians have gone to join the Islamic State. Some have gone to the Philippines, but most have gone to the Middle East. A few Malaysian and Indonesian terrorists are particularly notable; they have gone to Syria and Iraq to join the Islamic State, such as Bahrun Naim, Bahrumsyah, and Mohammed Saffan. Although they are in the Middle East, they still maintain close ties with partners in Indonesia and Malaysia. They use Facebook and Telegram, engaging in various propaganda to cultivate and recruit more extremists to join their ranks. They can order their members to carry out attacks through social media. They call on sympathizers: come to the Middle East! If you cannot go to the Middle East, then wage jihad in the Philippines or in your own country.

We cannot escape the threat of terrorism. The Internal Security Department detains one or two self-radicalized Singaporeans every month or two. They are not destitute individuals, nor are they from the Middle East. They are born and raised in Singapore and have attended government schools. Yet, they still radicalize themselves. Most of them are male, but there are also some young women. They want to join armed groups in Syria and carry out violent attacks in Singapore.

Therefore, the occurrence of a terrorist attack in Singapore is no longer a question of “if,” but “when.” We must take the issue of counter-terrorism seriously; in addition to strengthening our counter-terrorism capabilities, we also need to enhance the psychological defenses of our society, uniting as one to combat terrorism. This means we need harmonious multiracial relations.

Multiracialism itself cannot prevent terrorist attacks from occurring. Even if 99.9% of Singaporeans believe in the importance of multiracialism, there will still be a small minority who do not agree. However, the idea of multiracialism can help us cope with various situations the day after a terrorist attack. When people are shocked, hurt, angry, and afraid, the terrorist attacks carried out in the name of religion can easily divide Muslims and non-Muslims and fracture our society. Many will feel anger and fear. But through inter-ethnic and inter-religious trust circles and the national homefront security plan, as well as cooperation between community groups and religious leaders, we will be able to maintain our multiracial society; everyone will unite to overcome difficulties and continue to live normally. This is also why I recently held closed-door dialogues with religious and community leaders to discuss the issue of terrorist threats. First, I spoke with Muslim leaders and community leaders, followed by leaders from other ethnic groups. The dialogues help these religious and community leaders understand that the threat of terrorism is an important and urgent issue, and they are willing to work with us to address this threat. The response from the leaders present was very positive. I believe we will receive their full cooperation in promoting multiracial unity.

Singapore's Multiracialism

Over the past 52 years, we have made significant progress. The people of Singapore, regardless of race, language, or religion, stand united. We take pride in Singapore and are proud to be Singaporeans. We work together to create a home, mourn together, and celebrate together.

But remember, what we have today did not come about naturally, nor will it be maintained naturally. It is the result of our hard work and the gradual education and unification of our people. It is precisely because we have gradually instilled common values and attitudes that our people have built confidence, trust, and respect for one another, standing united. We consciously create common spaces and opportunities to bring Singaporeans together. We use English as a common working language while ensuring that mother tongues are still preserved. We allow people of different races to live in the same housing precincts, ensuring that no single ethnic group dominates. In schools, we recite the pledge together every day. To ensure that there are representatives of minority races in Parliament, we implemented the Group Representation Constituency system. We take a tough stance against extremists—whether they are Chinese chauvinists or Malay, Indian, or Hindu extremists. Because we must make it clear to them that this is Singapore, and when any racist attempts to incite emotions against other races, this is how Singapore responds.

We may think we have reached an ideal state where we can do away with these seemingly heavy regulations and provisions. But the reality is quite the opposite. It is precisely because we have these regulations and provisions that we can enjoy the racial and religious harmony we have today.

In this reserved election, three Malay candidates stepped forward to express their intention to run. Although two of the candidates did not receive the certificate of eligibility, they all expressed their willingness to participate. Let us look back at the fiercely contested presidential election in 2011. At that time, many believed that someone needed to oversee the government. Were there any Malay candidates running then? Did we see individuals like Tan Cheng Bock and Shahrir Samad? Why did they not step forward to run? Was it because they did not want to run? No. Then why did they not run? Because they all knew that under equal conditions, non-Chinese candidates had no chance of winning in an open election. The candidates who ran at that time included Tan Cheng Bock, Tony Tan, and Tan Jee Say. However, we did not see candidates like Shahrir Samad or other Malay candidates stepping forward. That is the reality. We must understand this clearly and address this situation.

This is the larger trend. Elections may occur every few years, but in our daily lives, there are also issues related to race that need to be addressed. Minority races sometimes face discrimination when looking for jobs. Some landlords are sometimes unwilling to rent their houses to minority races. They may give some reasons, but we all know that these landlords prefer to find tenants from specific ethnic groups. People also talk about stereotypes or impressions of different races when chatting or joking. If it is just a casual conversation among familiar friends, it may not be a problem. However, for unfamiliar friends, it may lead to misunderstandings. Recently, there was an incident where a temporary hoarding featuring a Malay girl wearing a headscarf was defaced with the words “terrorist.”

This is the reality we must face. Because the Chinese community constitutes the vast majority in Singapore, the Chinese may not notice or may think that Singapore has “achieved” the ideal state of a multiracial society. It is only when Singaporean Chinese go to other countries and experience racial discrimination that they realize the existence of racial discrimination. If you go to the United States, Australia, or certain parts of Europe, you will experience what it feels like to be seen as a minority.

The younger generation of Singapore has grown up in a peaceful and harmonious society, and thus may mistakenly believe that race is no longer an issue in Singapore. But that is not the case. We must be aware of our blind spots and make special efforts to ensure that our minority communities feel welcomed and valued in Singapore. Especially the Chinese community should work harder to make minority groups feel welcomed in Singapore.

Elected Presidency

This is also why we amended the Constitution: to ensure that every few years, minority races have the opportunity to become President, while reinforcing our identity as a multiracial nation. Although simply having a president from a different race does not make Singapore a multiracial country, it is an important symbol of our national belief and a declaration of our commitment to building a multiracial society. It reminds every citizen, especially the majority Chinese community, that every community in Singapore has a role to play.

Since our first President, Yusof Ishak, Singapore has not had another Malay president for over 50 years, but I am glad that we now have President Halimah. As Deputy Prime Minister Teo Chee Hean described during President Halimah's swearing-in ceremony and the singing of the national anthem: “It is a very special feeling.”

We spent nearly two years reforming the elected presidency system. Since I raised the review of the elected presidency system in this Parliament last January, we have been continuously discussing and debating this issue. But it was only when the reserved presidential election mechanism was activated, and only one person qualified to run, that people became extremely concerned about this issue.

I can sense some dissatisfaction among the public. Some believe the government is reversing course and returning to the old path of racial politics, but the reality is the opposite: we are making necessary changes to strengthen our multiracial mechanisms so that we can continue to unite and move forward. If the government did not do this, it is likely that our country would not have a Malay president for a long time. After a while, Singapore's minority communities would understandably begin to feel neglected. The Chinese, as the majority community, may also become more insensitive to other communities, which would weaken the shared national identity of all Singaporeans.

When we introduced the elected presidency system about 25 years ago, we knew that electing a president from a minority race might be difficult. In fact, the Malay Singaporeans at that time immediately realized that it would not be easy to have a Malay president in the future. But at that time, we had to face a more pressing issue – how to identify the ideal presidential candidates. Therefore, we decided to observe the situation. Now, 25 years later, the time has come. We know how the situation has developed and the trends for the foreseeable future. We believe we know how to address this issue.

We should not feel embarrassed that our majority community has been working hard to ensure that minority communities enjoy full and equal treatment, as we are not the only country that has made special arrangements for electing a head of state. Such arrangements are necessary in many multiracial countries. These countries make deliberate arrangements through their constitutions or conventions to allow minority races the opportunity to hold national office in a rotational or special representative manner. For example, the Governor General of Canada is alternately held by French-speaking and English-speaking communities. New Zealand also has minority communities; they once had a Governor of Indian descent, and the current Governor General has Māori ancestry. These are not coincidental examples. These countries specifically seek out outstanding individuals from minority communities to serve as heads of state. In Switzerland, a country with a 900-year history, the presidency is also rotated among German, French, and Italian Swiss, because if there were open elections, German Swiss candidates would likely win every time. This is also why we must make arrangements.

How did Mr. Yusof Ishak become our President? He was not elected but appointed. Why was he chosen? Mr. Lee Kuan Yew specifically sought out an outstanding Malay individual to serve as head of state because he wanted to demonstrate to Singaporeans and the Malayan government that Singapore could work with Malays, that we are part of Malaya and Malayan society, not just a Chinese society. Therefore, Mr. Lee invited Mr. Yusof to become the head of Singapore (the self-governing state), and he agreed, later becoming Singapore's first president.

Today, we elect our president through an election system, but we need mechanisms to ensure that minority communities also have the opportunity to become president. How do we achieve this? The Constitutional Commission has proposed a reserved election mechanism based on intervals. This means that if there has not been a Malay president for a long time, the next presidential election will be reserved for Malay candidates; if there has not been an Indian president for a long time, the next election will be reserved for Indian candidates. In fact, the commission also suggested that if there has not been a Chinese president for many years, the next presidential election will be reserved for Chinese candidates. In fact, there is no need to make such arrangements for the Chinese community, but the Chinese community felt that it would be inappropriate not to make the same arrangements, so we accepted this recommendation. This shows the sensitivity and importance of the reserved election mechanism.

Do I know this will be a difficult issue? That it will be unpopular and lead to a loss of votes? Yes, I certainly know. If I did not know this was a sensitive issue, I would not be fit for politics. But I do this because I firmly believe it is the right thing to do, and that belief has not changed.

Our multiracial, multireligious, inclusive, and progressive society has not come about naturally; it has been built by us, and it requires our protection and continuous strengthening, and must not be undermined.

President Halimah said at her swearing-in ceremony that she could understand why some citizens do not like the reserved election mechanism. Like them, she looks forward to the day when we no longer need to rely on the reserved election system, and Singaporeans will naturally and regularly elect people of different races as President. I too hope that one day we will not need such a mechanism to ensure that minority communities have the opportunity to become President. But we are not at that stage yet, and it will take a long time to achieve.

In moving towards that ideal state, we need guide-ropes and guard-rails to help us reach our destination and prevent us from slipping. The reserved presidential election is one such guard-rail.

After the swearing-in ceremony, I posted a picture on Instagram of myself, President Halimah, and Chief Justice Sundaresh Menon. A Chinese, a Malay, and an Indian – a scene that can only be seen in Singapore. During the Formula 1 race, a Brazilian visitor saw the picture and commented that it is the most amazing thing we have in Singapore. He could not imagine such a situation happening anywhere else.

This picture is indeed amazing because it showcases the multiracial, meritocratic, and united spirit of Singapore. That is what makes us Singaporeans. Racial harmony is not just a resonant phrase or a warm, fuzzy feeling. We need to embody this in our daily lives in various ways. If you have neighbors of different races, you can celebrate each other's festivals, sharing festive treats like pineapple tarts, kueh dadar, and murukku. You might just forget your resolve to cut down on sweets for diabetes! But a multiracial society is much more than that. It is about having colleagues and true friends from different races with whom we share joy and sorrow. It is about being able to accommodate one another and work through our differences. It is about having the honesty to recognize that our multiracialism is not yet perfect, but having the courage and determination to take pragmatic steps to get there, step by step. That is how we will continue to expand our common space, strengthen trust, and realize the vision of one people, one nation, one Singapore.