Speech by PM Lee Hsien Loong on the Report of the Committee of Privileges

Singapore Lee Hsien Loong · Prime Minister of Singapore

15 February 2022 · Parliamentary debate on the Report of the Committee of Privileges · Parliament of Singapore, Singapore

Context
Lee addressed Singapore's Parliament on February 15, 2022, debating the Committee of Privileges report and broader principles of democratic governance and parliamentary integrity.
Main themes
Parliamentary democracy and norms, integrity and values in politics, Committee of Privileges report, role of Parliament, public trust in institutions, accountability of MPs, Workers' Party conduct, democratic governance in Singapore, founding ideals and generational change, norms of parliamentary conduct
Duration
~143 min
99th percentile
Words
17,099
99th percentile
Sentences
936
99th percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
10.1
21st percentile
Syntax
2.98
45th percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
48th percentile

Translated from Multiple languages

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 84%81%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 5%4%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

936 sentences in 312 paragraphs

Mr Speaker Sir,

According to the Order Paper, we are debating what actions Parliament should take, having received the report of the Committee of Privileges (CoP).

But as the Leader of the House told us just now, the broader issue before us is how democracy should work in Singapore. What are the institutions, the norms, the values, that are essential for our democratic system to function properly? How do we apply these general principles to specific cases, like the one before us now, so as to protect these institutions, norms, and values? And how can we secure our democracy for the future, so that it can long deliver happiness, prosperity, and progress for our nation? These are the three more fundamental questions that I wish to discuss today.

Bedrock of State Institutions

The quality of a country’s democracy hinges on its people’s values: what they judge to be right or wrong, what they deem important, the causes they espouse, the ideals they embrace. Whichever example you look at, at whatever point in history, you will find that good and functioning democracies have clear, strong norms. These norms are upheld both by the governed and those who govern them, or those who aspire to govern them one day. That is how healthy democratic systems can elect good, incorruptible people with the right values, and drive a virtuous cycle where good democracy begets good governance, and good governance begets good politics.

This cycle must be underpinned and sustained by strong institutions. Parliament sits at the apex of our system of democracy. It is where the most important matters of state are discussed; laws are enacted; supplies of money are voted, with the Government setting the direction and proposing policies, while answering to the public through Parliament, and the Opposition holding the Government to account, while also being a government-in-waiting should the ruling party lose the support of the people. To fulfil its vital role, Parliament must be respected, and its members, processes and proceedings must be trusted.

Clear norms and incorruptible values are essential to protect the dignity and standing of Parliament. The system cannot work if the standing of Parliament is called into question. This is why we need to set the right norms of conduct among Parliamentarians, and guard them carefully. Tell the truth always, and do the right thing by Singapore, even when it is hard or awkward – in fact especially when it is hard or awkward. If something goes wrong, or something wrong has been done, own up and take responsibility – do not hide, dodge, or spin further lies, to obfuscate and cover up the original fib. The right norms can only be upheld by people with the right values because norms are not merely social conventions that people comply with for appearance’s sake. They have to be expressions of internal values that people believe in and hold dear.

MPs must be people with integrity at their core, who speak and act in an upright manner, always putting duty before self, and country before party. And our highest duty – our ultimate loyalty – is not to our party, but to Singapore. That is why when taking office, MPs swear “to bear true faith and allegiance to the Republic of Singapore”. In fact, this applies to everyone engaged in Singapore politics, MP or not. As Workers’ Party (WP) cadre Ms Loh Pei Ying, who was Mr Pritam Singh’s former assistant, told the Committee: “It pains me greatly, but to me, beyond anything else, it’s important to be truthful to my country”. I believe every member of this House will agree with her.

Our democratic system also depends on the people of Singapore – voters – endorsing, insisting on and backing the same norms and values. So, they can discern for themselves – as Ms Loh did – when something is wrong, and hold accountable those in power, or aspiring to power, when their actions fall short of these high standards. That is how a democracy can function properly.

Public Trust

Inculcating voters and their leaders with the right values is the work of decades. It takes unremitting effort and passion, and it does not always succeed.

Most countries are founded and start off on the basis of high ideals and noble values. But more often than not, beyond the founding leaders and the pioneer generation, over decades and generations, gradually things change. Things start off with passionate intensity. The leaders, who fought for and won independence, are often exceptional individuals of great courage, immense culture, and outstanding ability. They came through the crucible of fire and emerged as leaders of men and nations. They are the David Ben-Gurions, the Jawaharlal Nehrus, and we have our own too. Imbued with enormous personal prestige, they strive to meet the high expectations of their peoples to build a brave new world, and shape a new future for their peoples, and for their countries. But beyond that initial fervour, succeeding generations often find it hard to sustain this momentum and drive. They start out as healthy democracies, with idealism and zeal. But over time, the tone of the society changes. All too easily – a slip here, a blind eye there, a fudge, a trim – and gradually things go downhill. The texture of politics changes, respect for politicians declines. After a while, the electorate comes to think this is the norm, and you cannot expect better. So, standards get debased, trust is eroded, and the country declines further.

Many political systems today would be quite unrecognisable to their founding leaders. Ben-Gurion’s Israel has morphed into one which can barely form a government, despite four general elections in two years. Meanwhile, a stream of senior politicians and officials in Israel face a litany of criminal charges, some have gone to jail. While Nehru’s India has become one where, according to media reports, almost half the MPs in the Lok Sabha have criminal charges pending against them, including charges of rape and murder. Though it is also said that many of these allegations are politically motivated.

What is to prevent Singapore from going down the same road? Nothing. We are not intrinsically smarter or more virtuous than other countries. Modern Singapore does not come born with a fail-safe mechanism.

Our founding fathers did their best to build strong foundations and institutions. Even after the Barisan Sosialis, which was then the main opposition party, decided to vacate its seats in Parliament in 1966 and left the field entirely to the PAP, our founding fathers maintained our Parliamentary democracy and multi-party system. As Mr Lee Kuan Yew once explained, at that time, with the PAP completely dominant, he could have changed the Constitution and made this a one-party state. But he deliberately chose not to, because he knew that without the need to contest and win elections, the governing party would over time become complacent and flabby, and that would be disastrous for Singapore.

So the founding fathers took the more robust way. They kept politics contestable. They built up institutions – Parliament, the judiciary, the civil service, the police and armed forces, and later the elected President and the Council of Presidential Advisors – to enable Singapore to operate on a more resilient basis, not dependent on a few key people pulling all the levers, pushing all the buttons, making everything work. Still, to operate these institutions you need good people, and they needed to recruit, train and deploy ministers, MPs, judges, civil servants, experts in many fields. People of ability and commitment, with a sense of public service, and above all with honesty and integrity, whom Singaporeans could rely upon to do their duty, put Singapore first, and make this country succeed. And that is how the system we have today came to be.

It is incumbent on all of us – each succeeding generation – to protect and build upon this system that we have inherited. This requires us to uphold integrity, enforce rules and standards, apply the same rules equally to everyone, make sure nobody is above the law. If we can do that – consistently, persistently, unflinchingly – then we have a shot at making things work. People can trust our leaders, our systems, and our institutions. Our democracy can mature, deepen and grow more resilient, as both the governed and the governing embrace and express the right norms and values. Singapore can continue to flourish. But if we allow ourselves to slacken – loosen standards here, just a bit; overlook a lie there, just this time – the virtuous cycle will stutter and start to fail.

What is the key factor that keeps this virtuous cycle going, that keeps Singapore on the up and not on the down? It is Trust. On his 100th birthday, former US Secretary of State George Shultz reflected on this. This was a year and a bit ago, December 2020, he wrote an op-ed upon reaching 100 years old and he said it one of the most important lessons in his long life, that: “Trust is the coin of the realm”. “When trust was in the room,” he wrote, “good things happened. When trust was not in the room, good things did not happen. Everything else is details.”

We saw how this worked in the COVID-19 pandemic. Trust was a key factor why some countries did better than others. I have been saying this for two years but recently there was a study published in The Lancet, a British medical journal, which confirmed this, studied multiple countries and found that countries with high levels of trust and together with low corruption saw lower infection rates and higher vaccine coverage. Because the people’s trust in government, and their trust in each other, made much more difference to the outcome even more than the resources spent on healthcare, and even whether they had a universal healthcare system or not, what mattered most was ‘did they trust each other? Did they trust their leaders?’ Singapore is fortunate to be one of these high-trust societies. We have tried to build upon it during the pandemic, but it is something that we have today because we have nurtured it for decades and built it up patiently, assiduously, step-by-step, never allowing it to be eroded, and therefore, having this with us when we go into battle – an enormous asset.

The opposite happened in other countries, for example in the US and the UK. In the US, trust in the political system has all but broken down. Three-quarters of Republican voters have been made to believe the last presidential election in 2020 was stolen, that Mr Biden is not a legitimate President and Mr Trump should be the President today. How do you uphold a system, when a large segment of the population is convinced the elected government is illegitimate? Every issue is politicised; government becomes gridlocked; the country suffers. That is the key reason why many Americans refuse to be vaccinated, or to wear masks; why they revolt against measures to keep themselves safe; and why they have suffered so many COVID-19 deaths. Or look at the ongoing uproar in Britain about the “Partygate” scandal, in Westminster, the “Mother of Parliaments”, no less. The scandal has been attributed to “failures of leadership and judgment” in an official government report. By ignoring its own rules, the current UK government has caused a severe breakdown of trust, and lost credibility in its COVID-19 controls.

Singapore may be a high-trust society today, but nothing guarantees that we will always remain one. It is essential that we steadfastly maintain our high standards, ensure that we have leaders who embody the right values, call out wrongs when wrongs are done, mete out punishment when punishment is due, preserve the sanctity of our institutions, never take the public trust for granted, and never allow lies, half-truths and falsehoods to become the accepted norm in politics.

CoP

That is what is at stake as we deliberate Parliament’s response to the Committee of Privileges report. Ms Raeesah Khan lied in Parliament – twice on 3 Aug last year, and a third time when questioned two months later on 4 Oct. Subsequently, she admitted to lying to Parliament. To deal with this breach of Parliamentary privilege, we convened the CoP. Ms Khan was called up, as were other witnesses. The CoP deliberated extensively, before reaching a reasoned conclusion: that Ms Khan was guilty, and should be fined for each occasion she lied. I hope all Members can agree with these findings and the penalty to be imposed on Ms Khan.

But in the process of the CoP’s deliberations, two other significant issues arose. The CoP has drawn them to Parliament’s attention and suggested to Parliament how to deal with them. First, whether the three WP leaders – Mr Pritam Singh, Mr Faisal Manap and Ms Sylvia Lim – had instructed Ms Khan to continue with her lie in Parliament. If they did, this is surely as serious or more serious a misconduct as Ms Khan speaking an untruth in Parliament. Parliament will need to deal with this, but only after we have cleared the second, even graver matter. This graver matter is, as the Leader explained, whether after having taken solemn oaths to tell the truth, the three WP leaders told untruths to the CoP, in order to cover up their instructions to Ms Khan to continue lying. It became clear to the CoP that there were striking contradictions between what the three MPs claimed to the Committee were their honourable intentions, and the hard evidence of what they actually did, or very often, failed to do. And there were serious inconsistencies even between the accounts of the WP leaders.

Being untruthful under oath is no small matter. It means lying, despite solemnly affirming you will tell the truth. In this case, not once, not twice but repeatedly, over many hours of extensive questioning, and on several days. The CoP’s assessment is that these untruths were not accidental or incidental errors, but deliberate, premeditated acts, done with a definite intent to mislead and to deceive. They are not just breaches of Parliamentary privilege, but if proven in court, they amount to perjury – lying under oath. And perjury is a serious criminal offence.

So, there are two distinct problems. One, whether the three MPs instructed Ms Khan to lie; and two, whether the three MPs themselves lied under oath. Both, if established, reflect very badly on the WP leaders, and in particular, on the Leader of the Opposition. Both issues, if not dealt with properly, will dishonour Parliament, and bring this august institution into disrepute. Some ask: “Wasn’t Ms Raeesah Khan the one who lied? Why are the WP leaders being treated more harshly?”

As the Leader of the House noted just now, if the Committee is right, then Mr Singh and his fellow WP leaders themselves lied and presented untruths to the CoP. They lied under oath to protect themselves, to cover up their role, and to push the blame solely onto Ms Khan, claiming that she and other witnesses, like Ms Loh, had lied to the CoP. This is indeed more serious than what Ms Khan did, if it is so. By lying under oath, they sought to frustrate the CoP process. They displayed the same kind of misconduct that the CoP was set up to address. They betrayed the trust reposed in them as MPs – not least Mr Singh, the Leader of the Opposition. This, I hope Members appreciate, if true, is a very grave matter.

So, MPs must decide what Parliament will now do about this. Can we pretend nothing happened? Or if that is too much to stomach, given the strong evidence laid out by the CoP, perhaps we lower our standards just a little, note that untruths were told, but argue that it was after all not so serious a lie, and no harm was done?

If we do either of these things, we too would become complicit in dishonouring and demeaning Parliament. We must take the transgression seriously, and act on it. And I am glad that is the conclusion the CoP has come to and recommended to the House.

What alternative choices did the CoP have? It could have recommended to Parliament to administer a token slap on the wrist. But that would show that we were taking a very serious matter rather lightly. Worse, by lowering our norms, we would be telling Singaporeans that it is really not so bad for elected leaders to lie. Alternatively, the CoP could have recommended that Parliament itself metes out an appropriately heavy penalty. This is something that Parliament has the power to do. But had the CoP recommended that, and Parliament decided on the penalty itself, the Opposition would surely have cried foul, and accused the PAP of using its majority to persecute the Opposition. In fact, they are already insinuating this, as a smokescreen to obscure the real issue – that the WP had lied while under solemn oath.

I believe therefore, that what the CoP recommends is thus the best way forward. Since a criminal offence appears to have been committed, let Parliament refer the matter to the Public Prosecutor. Let the Public Prosecutor consider the evidence afresh, let the system work. If charges are filed, Mr Pritam Singh and also Mr Faisal Manap can defend themselves in court. The Court will have to be satisfied that their guilt has been established beyond reasonable doubt, and if they are innocent, they have nothing to fear.

I commend this course of action to the House. And if I were Mr Singh, I would vote in favour of both motions. Fine Ms Khan, because she is guilty beyond doubt. In fact, Mr Singh’s own party member Mr Dennis Tan, who was on the CoP, thinks she should be fined more heavily for the second offence. And if Mr Singh maintains that he and his fellow WP leaders have done nothing wrong, he should also vote in favour of referring his own case, and that of Mr Faisal Manap, to the Public Prosecutor. Indeed, he should demand a court trial, in order to have the full opportunity to defend himself, vindicate his reputation, and clear his name. That is what I would do if I were Mr Singh.

Regrettably, pro-Workers’ Party voices on the social media have taken quite a different tack. Before the matter can be conclusively determined, if necessary in court, they are doing their best to confuse the issues and rouse sympathy. They are asking the public to clear their names of the three MPs, suggesting that referring their case to the Public Prosecutor is political persecution. What they are really saying is this: Don’t look too carefully at what Mr Singh did, just remember who he is: He is the Opposition that you voted for; He is the Leader of the Opposition. By virtue of his position, he should not be referred to the Public Prosecutor; and any action against him must, by definition, be politically motivated; because who he is is more important than what he has done – even if he may have committed a crime.

Some people may be taken in, and sympathise with this story. They say, why not just let the matter rest? Can’t we find a compromise solution? After all, it would be easier for the government not to have to pursue this matter against the three MPs. We have a full enough agenda. But, Mr Speaker, as long as the PAP is the Government, we will not shy away from doing whatever is necessary to uphold the right norms in this House, and to imbue Singaporeans and their leaders with the values critical to sustain trust in the system, and critical to our success.

Mr Singh succeeded Mr Low Thia Kiang as Secretary General of the Workers’ Party. Mr Low served for a very long time – 30 years as an MP, 17 years as party leader. He sat opposite me, where Mr Singh now sits. Mr Low was a formidable political opponent, but he was a patriotic Singaporean. He set a different tone for the WP. He said he hoped the WP could help to build a First-World Parliament for Singapore. He must be saddened that, instead, this is what his successor has done.

Because what has happened is a betrayal of what WP claimed it stood for. But judging by Mr Low’s public comments, he is confident the party can ride this out. And it need not be a setback for our democracy either, provided we hold Mr Singh and his colleagues accountable for dishonouring the standards of this House, and also for possibly breaking the law.

Future of Singapore’s Democracy

Mr Speaker, we are all engaged in the same project – to build up Singapore’s democracy and create a political system that will serve Singaporeans well for many years to come. And to do that, we must uphold the right norms and reinforce the right values.

I know Singaporeans want to see more political contestation, and I accept that. I expect that this is the way Singapore will go, in the longer term. That is how every parliamentary democracy evolves. And it was precisely because I recognised this, that on election night in 2020, after the WP won a second GRC in Sengkang, I offered to make Mr Singh the Leader of the Opposition, and equip him with the resources and support to play his role. That is the way a responsible Government can help a credible, responsible Opposition to emerge, and contribute to the maturing of our political system. But the office of the Leader of the Opposition carries certain responsibilities – setting the tone for opposition MPs, enforcing standards of conduct on his own party, and above all, maintaining his own integrity and keeping himself beyond reproach. The Leader of the Opposition does not have a blank cheque.

Mr Speaker, integrity is the linchpin of democracy. The stakes of today’s debate might have been lower if the Opposition were a negligible presence, as they were from 1966 until the 1980s. The PAP was overwhelmingly dominant, the public generally had low expectations of opposition parties and politicians, the tone of the country and its governance was set by the PAP, and the high standards that the PAP imposed on itself. But with Singapore heading towards a more contested landscape, the competence and honesty of the Opposition is no longer an inconsequential matter. The question of “what are the right values and how should we uphold them?” becomes of fundamental importance for both the Opposition and the governing party.

Every election henceforth would be about who wins the mandate to run this country. If the system is working properly, the governing party will be re-elected so long as it remains honest, competent, and trusted. If the governing party falls short, and Singaporeans come to deem an opposition party more honest and incorruptible, more competent, and more trustworthy, then the governing party should be voted out, and that opposition party should be voted in, to form the next government. We cannot assume that the PAP will always continue in government. Nor can we assume that the WP, or some other opposition party, or any other opposition party, will always stay in the opposition.

I do not know when, or how, there will be a change of governing party in Singapore one day. My job as party leader is to make sure the PAP governs well to the best of its ability, so that it retains the mandate of the people for as many elections as possible. But my duty as the leader of the country is also to maximise the chances that whichever party wins future elections, it will uphold and be held to the same high standards of proper conduct and honesty as the PAP, so that our democratic system can continue to operate properly, whichever party is in charge, and would not go down the drain because a small island city-state like Singapore – the only one in the world like this – needs a strong, effective and good Government, whoever leads it.

With our lives and future at stake, everyone participating in the system must be held to the same standards. There can be no excuses, no double standards, and no pardoning of inexcusable behaviour, just because the offending party portrays itself as the underdog.

Mr John Major, the former British Prime Minister recently made a speech, triggered by Partygate, I am sure, lamenting the state of British politics today. It was a cri de coeur, a cry from the heart. Let me read you a few excerpts: “There has been cynicism about politics from the dawn of time. We are told that politicians are ‘all the same’, and this untruth conditions electors to condone lies as though they were the accepted currency of public life.” “But politicians are not ‘all the same’. And lies are just not acceptable.” “To imply otherwise is to cheapen public life, and slander the vast majority of elected politicians who do not knowingly mislead.” “But some do – and their behaviour is corrosive. This tarnishes both politics and the reputation of Parliament. It is a dangerous trend.” “If lies become commonplace, truth ceases to exist. What and who, then, can we believe? The risk is … nothing and no-one. And where are we then?” “If trust in the word of our leaders in Parliament is lost – then trust in government will be lost too.”

John Major’s is a Western view, but in Eastern society too, norms and values are crucial, in fact even more than in Western philosophy, because Western philosophy says checks and balances, but Eastern philosophy says your virtues, your moral standing – that is what give you the right to govern. In Confucian thought, there are four social guidelines (四维) that hold a state together: rituals, righteousness, probity, and shame (礼义廉耻). Probity, or desisting from corruption, is about upright behaviour; it is a norm that can be enforced using laws. But shame, a reaction to wrongdoing, is a moral disposition; it is about one’s own sense of right and wrong, whether we know we have done the right thing, or we know we have fallen short, even when nobody said so. That has to come from within ourselves, from our own values, and our own consciences. Absent that sense of shame, people may comply with laws for fear of punishment, but they will lack the moral compass to do the right thing simply because it is the right thing to do, and to take responsibility when they have fallen short of the standards expected of them.

What I personally find most disappointing in the WP narrative and in their response, including in this House today, is the complete absence of any admission that the three MPs have done anything wrong. There is no contrition.

Mr Speaker Sir, whether you take a Western or Eastern view, if lack of shame becomes the public norm, our political system will break down, progressively and irreversibly. The public will mistrust not only individual leaders, or particular political parties, but the whole political system. And this has happened too often elsewhere.

If that happens, what do you do? What can you do? How can democracy function when there is no one we can trust to put in charge? How do you put Humpty Dumpty together again? How do you restart from zero? Press reset? A democracy not founded on integrity stands on shaky ground, and will sooner or later totter. If instead of trust being “the coin of the realm”, as George Shultz puts it, lies become “the accepted currency of public life”, as John Major said, all the sound and fury of contestation and debate will signify nothing good for the country.

As Singapore politics grows more competitive, we must make sure that the competition is honest, impartial, and above-board. Where the system runs properly, and our institutions remain sacred and respected by all. Where good people work together constructively to serve Singaporeans, wherever they stand on the political spectrum. And, most basic of all, where Singaporeans can trust those who represent them to conduct themselves honestly and honourably, and act on behalf of the public, and of Singapore.

Closing

Mr Speaker, the CoP report is long and detailed, but the core issues are few and stark. We have scrutinised Ms Khan’s actions, and its rights and wrongs. She has admitted her wrongdoings, and will be punished appropriately for them. We thought the matter could be closed off straightforwardly. But there turned out to be a much larger problem. Online, people call this Raeesah-Gate, after Watergate. And just like in the original Watergate affair, while investigating Ms Khan’s transgressions, the CoP unexpectedly stumbled upon a cover-up by WP leaders, even more serious than the original offence. The CoP did not expect this. But now with the findings before us, it is our responsibility, Parliament’s responsibility, for the MPs to take the necessary and appropriate course of action.

Mr Speaker Sir, trust is crucial for democracy to work well. Being truthful is fundamental to establishing trust. Honesty is non-negotiable. If you tell lies, how can the public trust you? If someone in a position of responsibility tells lies, and visibly gets away with it, how can the public trust the system? And if Parliament condones lying among its own members, how can Singaporeans trust the institution of Parliament? If we let flagrant, egregious transgressions pass, it will erode trust in our leaders, respect for Parliament, and support for our whole political system, and Singapore will be heading for trouble.

As the longest serving Member of this House, I feel a greater responsibility for this than most. When I first entered this House 37 years ago, Mr Lee Kuan Yew, Mr S Rajaratnam, Dr Toh Chin Chye, Mr Ong Pang Boon, Mr E.W. Barker and Mr Jek Yeun Thong were still Members. Six of the 10 who signed the Separation Agreement on 9 August 1965. I have witnessed first-hand how the founding generation built up this place, handed it to us in good shape. For me, this is a sacred trust. And it should be a sacred trust too, for every MP. We must all never fail to serve Singaporeans to the best of our ability, responsibly and honestly, and uphold this institution of Parliament, as the foundation of a robust and healthy democracy.

I call on all Members in this House, old and new, government and opposition, elected and nominated, to weigh the facts, vote with your conscience, and join me to do your duty to Singapore.

Mr Speaker Sir, I support the motions.

We must all never fail to serve Singaporeans to the best of our ability, responsibly and honestly, and uphold this institution of Parliament, as the foundation of a robust and healthy democracy.

PM Lee Hsien Loong

Efforts to Preserve Institutions, Parliamentary Authority

Integrity among political figures is essential to uphold the democracy desired for this country, said Prime Minister Mr Lee Hsien Loong, during his speech in Parliament yesterday in the debate on the report of the Committee of Privileges (CoP). The following is an excerpt from that speech.

Mr Speaker,

We are debating what actions Parliament should take, after receiving the report from the Committee of Privileges (CoP).

However, as the Speaker has informed us, the broader issue is the function of democracy in Singapore.

What are the institutions, norms, and values that are important for a democratic system to function well?

How do we apply these general principles to specific cases, such as the one we are facing now, to protect the institutions, norms, and values? And how can we safeguard democracy in the future, so that it can create happiness, prosperity, and progress for our country? These are the three fundamental questions I would like to discuss today.

Foundation of State Institutions

The quality of democracy in a country depends on the values of its people: what they consider right or wrong, what they deem important, the struggles they support, the aspirations they hold.

In any example seen, at any moment in history, you will find that a well-functioning democracy has clear, strong norms. These norms are upheld by both the governed and the governors, or those who aspire to govern one day.

This is how a democratic system can select good individuals who are not negatively influenced, who adhere to good values and drive a virtuous cycle where good democracy produces good governance, and good governance will produce good politics.

This cycle must be maintained through strong institutions. Parliament is at the pinnacle of this democratic system.

It is the space where important national issues are discussed, laws are enacted, the use of public funds is debated, with the government setting the direction and proposing policies, while answering the public's questions through Parliament, with the Opposition holding the Government accountable, which also becomes the government if the current ruling party loses public support.

To play its important role, Parliament and its members must be respected, and its processes and proceedings must be trusted.

Clear norms are essential to protect the dignity and position of Parliament.

This system cannot function if the position of Parliament is questioned.

That is why we need to establish the right norms of conduct among Members of Parliament, and uphold them well. Always tell the truth, and do the right thing from Singapore's perspective, even if it is difficult or awkward - especially if it is difficult or awkward. If something undesirable occurs or is done, it must be acknowledged responsibly - do not hide, evade, or twist to confuse or cover up earlier lies.

Good norms can only be upheld by individuals who possess good values because norms are not merely social conventions that people adhere to just for appearances. They should be an expression of the internal values that are believed and held by individuals.

Members of Parliament (MPs) must consist of individuals with integrity, who speak and act rightly, always prioritizing their duty over themselves, and the country before the party. And our foremost duty - our primary loyalty - is not to the party but to Singapore.

That is why MPs pledge "to bear true faith and allegiance to the Republic of Singapore."

In fact, this is stipulated for all involved in Singapore politics, whether they are MPs or not.

Workers' Party (WP) staff, Ms Loh Pei Ying, who was a former personal assistant to Mr Pritam Singh, told the Committee: "It is a sad thing, but for me, it is important to be honest to my country." I believe all Members of Parliament agree with her.

Our democratic system also relies on Singaporeans - the voters - who support, advocate, and uphold the same norms and values. So they can discern for themselves - as Ms Loh has done - when something is amiss, and hold those in power, or those aspiring to power, accountable when their actions do not meet those high standards. This is how democracy can function well.

Public Trust

Instilling good values in both voters and leaders has been an effort spanning decades.

It requires significant effort and interest, and it does not always end in success.

Most countries are founded and begin on the basis of high aspirations and noble values. However, typically, unlike the founding leaders and the pioneering generation, over decades and generations, circumstances change gradually.

It usually starts with high intensity. Leaders who fought for and successfully achieved independence are special individuals with high courage, their own culture, and extraordinary capabilities. They have faced great challenges and emerged as leaders of the citizens and the nation.

They are like David Ben Gurion, Jawaharlal Nehru, and we also have our own leaders. With high prestige, they strive to meet public expectations to build a new world and shape a new future for their citizens, and for the country.

However, after that initial spirit, the next generation usually finds it more difficult to maintain that momentum and spirit. It starts as a healthy democracy, with idealism and enthusiasm.

But over time, the tone of society changes. Minor faults can easily affect that state. Political forms change, and respect for politicians diminishes. After that, voters will think that this is the norm and they cannot expect anything better. As a result, standards become lower, trust erodes, and the country deteriorates.

Many political systems today may no longer be recognizable to their founding leaders. Israel, governed by Ben Gurion, has transformed into a country that can hardly form a government, despite having four general elections in two years.

Meanwhile, a group of politicians and senior officials in Israel face various criminal charges, some of whom are imprisoned. The country of India, governed by Nehru, has become a country where, according to media reports, nearly half of the members of parliament in the Lok Sabha have faced criminal charges including charges of murder and rape.

There are also many allegations that these charges are politically motivated.

What can prevent Singapore from falling into the same situation? Nothing.

We are not smarter or better than other countries. Modern Singapore was not born with mechanisms that ensure it survives failures.

Our founding leaders did their best to develop a strong foundation and institutions. Even after the Socialist Front, which later became the main opposition party, decided to vacate its seats in Parliament in 1966 and hand over completely to the PAP, the founding leaders sought to maintain parliamentary democracy and a multi-party system.

As Mr Lee Kuan Yew explained earlier, at that time, with the PAP being dominant, he could have amended the Constitution and made Singapore a one-party state. But he deliberately chose not to do so, because he knew that without the need to compete and win elections, the ruling party would become complacent over time, and this would harm Singapore.

For that, the founding leaders chose a more robust way. They ensured that there was a need to compete in politics.

They developed institutions - Parliament, the judiciary, the civil service, the police, and the military, and later the President elected by the Presidential Advisory Council - to enable Singapore to operate more resiliently, not relying on a few powerful individuals who seek to control everything.

However, to ensure that these institutions operate well, good individuals are needed, and they must select and train ministers, MPs, judges, civil service members, and experts in various fields.

Individuals with the ability, commitment, and spirit to serve and do all that honestly and with integrity, so that Singaporeans can place their hopes in them to perform their duties well, prioritize Singapore, and ensure its success. And this is how our existing system was established.

Efforts to Protect and Build the System We Inherit

It is our duty - every generation to come - to protect and build the system that we have inherited. This requires us to uphold integrity, enforce rules and standards, apply the same rules equally to everyone, to ensure that no one is above the law. If we can do this - consistently, diligently, without wavering - then we have a chance to make something work.

This will enhance public confidence in our leaders, our system, and our institutions. Our democracy will mature, deepen, and grow more resilient, when both the governed and the governing embrace and express the right norms and values. Singapore can continue to thrive.

But if we allow ourselves to slacken - loosening standards here; overlooking lies there, just this once - this virtuous cycle will falter and begin to fail.

What is the key factor that maintains this virtuous cycle, placing Singapore above and not below? It is Trust. On its 100th birthday, former U.S. Secretary of State George Shultz reflected on this.

This was over a year ago, in December 2020, he wrote an article upon reaching the age of 100 and stated that among one of the most important lessons in his longevity was: "Trust is the coin of the realm." "When trust is in a space," he wrote, "good things happen. When trust is not in that space, good things do not happen. The rest is just detail."

We saw how this played out during the Covid-19 pandemic.

Trust is the main factor why some countries perform better than others. I have been saying this for two years, but recently there was a study published in The Lancet, a British medical journal, that confirmed it, examining several countries and finding that countries with high levels of trust and low corruption rates had lower infection rates and higher vaccination coverage.

Because of the trust of the people in the government, and in each other, the outcomes are more than the resources spent on healthcare, and whether they have universal healthcare systems or not, what matters most is 'do they trust each other?'

Trust in Leaders

Do they trust their leaders?

Singapore is fortunate to be one of these high-trust societies. We have tried to build it during the pandemic, but it is something we have today because we have nurtured it over decades and built it patiently, diligently, step by step, never allowing it to erode, and therefore, having this trust when we are at war - is a tremendous asset.

The opposite is true in other countries, for example, in the US and the UK.

In the US, trust in the political system has been shattered. Three-quarters of Republican voters believe that the last presidential election in 2020 was stolen, that Mr. Biden is not the legitimate President and that Mr. Trump should be President today.

How do you uphold a system when a large portion of the population believes that the elected government is illegitimate? Every issue is politicized; the government becomes paralyzed; the country suffers.

That is the main reason why many Americans refuse to get vaccinated, or wear masks; why they rebel against measures to keep themselves safe; and why they have experienced so many Covid-19 deaths. Or look at the ongoing uproar in Britain over the "Partygate" scandal, in Westminster, which is considered the "Mother of Parliaments."

The scandal has been linked to "failures of leadership and judgment" in an official government report. By ignoring its own rules, the current UK government has caused severe damage to trust, and lost credibility in its Covid-19 control.

Perhaps Singapore is a high-trust society today, but this does not guarantee that we will always remain so.

It is crucial for us to steadfastly maintain our high standards, ensuring we have leaders who practice the right values, call out wrongdoings when they occur, impose penalties when punishment is warranted, uphold the sanctity of our institutions, do not take lightly the trust placed in them by the public, and never allow lies, half-truths, and falsehoods to become the accepted norm in politics.

Committee of Privileges (COP)

That is what is at stake as we discuss Parliament's response to the report of the Committee of Privileges. Ms. Raeesah Khan lied in Parliament - twice on August 3 last year, and a third time when questioned two months later on October 4. Then, she admitted to lying to Parliament.

To address this breach of Parliament, we convened a COP. Ms. Khan was called, along with other witnesses. The COP discussed extensively, before reaching a reasonable conclusion: that Ms. Khan was guilty, and should be penalized for each time she lied. I hope all Members can agree with this finding and the penalty to be imposed on Ms. Khan.

But in the process of the COP discussions, two other important issues arose. The COP has brought Parliament's attention to these issues and suggested ways for Parliament to address them.

First, whether the three leaders of the Workers' Party (WP) - Mr. Pritam Singh, Mr. Faisal Manap, and Ms. Sylvia Lim - directed Ms. Khan to continue her lies in Parliament. If they did so, this would certainly be misconduct as serious or more serious than Ms. Khan's false statements in Parliament.

Parliament needs to address this matter, but only after we resolve the second, more serious issue. This more serious issue, as explained by the Leader, is whether the three leaders of the Workers' Party (WP) told untruths to the COP after taking an oath to tell the truth, to cover up their instructions to Ms. Khan to continue lying.

It became clear to the COP that there was a significant contradiction between the claims of the three Members of Parliament to the Committee to prove their noble intentions, and the strong evidence of what they actually did, or often, failed to do. And there is a serious contradiction between the explanations of the leaders of the Workers' Party (WP).

Not speaking the truth after taking an oath is not a trivial matter. It means lying, even after earnestly asserting that you will tell the truth. In this case, not once, not twice but repeatedly, for hours of in-depth questioning, and over several days.

The COP's assessment is that these lies are not unintentional mistakes or side issues, but deliberate, planned actions, done with a clear intent to mislead and deceive.

They not only violated Parliamentary Privilege, but if proven in court, it is equivalent to perjury - lying under oath. And perjury is a serious criminal offense.

Two Distinct Issues

So, there are two distinct issues.

One, whether the three Members of Parliament directed Ms. Khan to lie; and two, whether the three Members of Parliament themselves lied under oath. Both, if raised, reflect poorly on the leaders of the Workers' Party (WP), and specifically, on the Leader of the Opposition.

Both issues, if not properly addressed, will tarnish the reputation of Parliament, and undermine the standing of this great institution.

Some ask: "Isn't it Ms. Raeesah Khan who lied? Why are the leaders of the Workers' Party (WP) being treated more harshly?"

As the Speaker has stated, if the Committee is correct, then Mr. Singh and his fellow leaders of the Workers' Party (WP) themselves lied and presented untruths to the COP.

They lied under oath to protect themselves, to cover up their roles, and to shift the blame solely onto Ms. Khan, claiming that she and other witnesses, like Ms. Loh, had lied to the COP. This is indeed more serious than what Ms. Khan did, if true.

By lying under oath, they sought to undermine the COP process. They committed the same misconduct that the COP was established to address. They betrayed the trust placed in them as Members of Parliament - not least Mr. Singh, the Leader of the Opposition. This, I hope Members appreciate, if true, is a very serious matter.

So, Members of Parliament must decide what Parliament will do about this. Can we pretend that nothing has happened? Or if that is too heavy to bear, based on the strong evidence presented by the COP, perhaps we lower our standards a little, take note that untruths have been told, but argue that it is not actually such a serious lie, and does not endanger anything?

If we do either of these things, we will also be complicit in undermining the dignity and lowering the stature of Parliament. We must take these breaches seriously, and act upon them.

And I am pleased that this is the conclusion that has been reached by the COP and recommended to the House.

Options for the COP?

What alternative options does the COP have? It could recommend to Parliament to impose a light penalty. But that would suggest that we are taking something very serious rather lightly.

Moreover, by lowering our norms, it is as if we are telling the people of Singapore that it is not so bad for elected leaders to lie.

Alternatively, the COP could recommend that Parliament itself impose an appropriate penalty. This is something that Parliament has the authority to do.

But should the COP recommend that, and Parliament decides the penalty itself, the Opposition will surely vehemently reject it, and accuse the PAP of using its majority to persecute the Opposition. In fact, they have already made this claim, as a way to obscure the real issue - that the Workers' Party (WP) has lied while under oath.

Therefore, I believe that what the COP has suggested is the best way forward.

Since it appears that a criminal offense has been committed, let Parliament refer the matter to the Public Prosecutor. Let the Public Prosecutor reconsider the evidence, let the system work. If charges are filed, Mr. Pritam Singh and also Mr. Faisal Manap can defend themselves in court.

The court must be satisfied that their offenses have been proven beyond a reasonable doubt, and if they are innocent, they have nothing to fear.

What options does the COP have? It could suggest to Parliament to impose a light action or merely reprimand. But this would give the impression that we are trivializing something serious.

Worse still, lowering our norms and telling the people of Singapore that it is okay for elected leaders to lie. Alternatively, the COP could also suggest that Parliament impose a heavy fine.

This is indeed within the jurisdiction of Parliament. But should the COP suggest this and Parliament then decides on the fine itself, the Opposition will certainly condemn and accuse the PAP of using its majority power to persecute the Opposition. In fact, they have already hinted to obscure the real issue - that the WP has lied even while under oath.

However, I believe that what the COP has suggested is the best for the future. Since a criminal offense seems to have been committed, let Parliament refer the matter to the Public Prosecutor. Let the Public Prosecutor reconsider the evidence, so that the system can function.

Can Defend in Court

If charges are brought, Mr. Pritam Singh and Mr. Faisal Manap can defend themselves in court. The court will ensure that their offenses can be proven beyond any doubt, and if they are innocent, then there is nothing to worry about.

I recommend this action to Parliament. And if I were Mr. Singh, I would vote in support of both motions. Impose a fine on Ms. Khan, for there is no doubt that she is guilty. In fact, Mr. Singh's own party member, Mr. Dennis Tan, who sits on the COP believes that Ms. Khan should be fined more heavily for her second offense. And if Mr. Singh still feels that he and his fellow WP leaders have done no wrong, he should also vote in support of the motion to refer his own case, and also Mr. Faisal Manap's, to the Public Prosecutor.

In fact, he should request a trial in court to fully have the opportunity to defend himself, rather than have his reputation tarnished and preserve his good name. That is what I would do if I were in Mr. Singh's position.

Regrettably, the voices of the Workers' Party supporters on social media have taken a different stance. Before this matter is decided, if it needs to go to court, they are earnestly trying to confuse the issue to gain sympathy. They are asking the public to clear the names of all three MPs by saying that referring their cases to the Public Prosecutor is a form of political persecution.

What they are really saying is: Don't look too closely at what Mr. Singh has done, remember who he is. He is the Opposition that you chose. He is the Leader of the Opposition.

By virtue of his position, he should not be referred to the Public Prosecutor, and any action against him could be interpreted as politically motivated; because who he is is more important than what he has done - even if he may have committed a crime.

There may be some who are influenced and sympathetic to this narrative.

Why Not Drop This Case

They say, why not just drop this case? Can't we find some compromise solution? Moreover, it would be more pleasant for the government as it would not have to pursue action against the three MPs. We have a full agenda. But, Mr. Speaker, as long as the PAP is the Government, we will not hesitate to do whatever is necessary to uphold the norms in Parliament and instill in the people of Singapore and its leaders the critical values necessary to maintain trust in the system and that are critical to our success.

Mr. Singh succeeded Mr. Low Thia Kiang as the Secretary-General of the Workers' Party. Mr. Low served for a long time - 30 years as an MP and 17 years as party leader.

He sat in front of me in the seat that Mr. Singh occupies now. Mr. Low is a capable political opponent but he is a patriotic Singaporean.

He placed the WP in a different position. He said he hoped the WP could help establish a First World Parliament for Singapore. He must certainly be saddened now to see what has been done by his successor.

Because what has happened is a betrayal of what the WP stands for. But based on the comments made by Mr. Low, he is confident that his party will be able to emerge from this crisis.

And it also does not have to be a setback for our democracy, as long as we ensure that Mr. Singh and his colleagues are held accountable for their actions that demean the Parliament and possibly violate the law.

The Future of Singapore's Democracy

Mr. Speaker, we are all dealing with the same project - to build Singapore's democracy and create a political system that can serve the people of Singapore well for many years to come. And to do this, we must uphold the right norms and strengthen them with the right values as well.

I know the people of Singapore want to see more political competition, and I accept that. I anticipate that this is the direction Singapore will head in the long term.

That is also how parliamentary democracy evolves. And precisely because I acknowledge this, on the night of the 2020 election, after the WP won its second GRC in Sengkang, I offered to appoint Mr. Singh as the Leader of the Opposition and equip him with the resources and support for him to carry out his role. This is how a responsible Government can help create a credible and responsible Opposition and contribute to the maturity of our political system.

But the position of Leader of the Opposition carries certain responsibilities - to determine the stance of the opposition MPs, to enforce the standards of their own conduct, and more importantly, to uphold their credibility and maintain their own honor. The Leader of the Opposition cannot act arbitrarily.

Mr. Speaker, credibility is like a stake for democracy. The stakes for today's debate might be lower if the presence of the Opposition is not significant, as it was from 1966 to the 1980s.

The PAP dominated completely, the public also did not have much hope for opposition parties and politicians, the pattern of governance was also determined by the PAP and the high standards practiced by the PAP.

But with Singapore moving towards a more competitive landscape, the ability and integrity of the Opposition are no longer trivial matters. The question of "what are the right values and how should we uphold them" becomes a crucial pillar for both the Opposition and the ruling party.

If the ruling party fails and the people of Singapore find the opposition party to be more honest and incorruptible, more capable and more trustworthy, then the ruling party will be ousted, and the opposition party will be elected to form a new government.

We cannot assume that the PAP will continue to govern.

Likewise, we cannot assume that the WP or other opposition parties will remain as the opposition.

Ensuring the PAP Governs as Best as Possible

I do not know when, or how, there will be a change of ruling party in Singapore one day. My duty as a party leader is to ensure that the PAP governs as best as possible, so that it retains the people's mandate for as many elections as possible.

With our lives and future at stake, everyone participating in this system must adhere to the same standards. There can be no excuses, no bias, and no forgiveness for unforgivable behavior, just because the guilty party portrays itself as the underdog.

Mr. John Major, the former Prime Minister of Britain, recently made a speech, which I am sure was triggered by Partygate, regarding the political situation in Britain today. It is a cri de coeur, a cry from the heart.

Allow me to read some excerpts: "There has been a cynical view of politics for a long time.

We are told that politicians are 'all the same', and this untruth obliges voters to accept lies as if they were currency in public life."

"But politicians are not 'all the same'. And lies cannot be accepted."

"To say otherwise is to cheapen public life, and to slander the vast majority of elected politicians who do not deliberately mislead." "But some do - and their behavior erodes. This tarnishes both politics and the reputation of Parliament. It is a dangerous trend." "If lies become commonplace, the truth no longer exists. Then what and who can we trust? The risk is … nothing and no one. And where are we now?"

"If trust in the words of our leaders in Parliament is lost - then trust in the government will also be lost."

John Major's views are from the West, but in Eastern societies as well, norms and values are important, even more so than in Western philosophy, because Western philosophy prioritizes checks and balances, but Eastern philosophy emphasizes your values and moral standing - that is what gives you the right to govern.

In Confucian thought, there are four social guidelines that unify the state: ritual, truth, honesty, and a sense of shame. Honesty or avoiding corruption is about upright behavior; it is a norm that can be enforced using the law. But a sense of shame, the reaction to wrongdoing, is a moral inclination; it is about one's own feelings of right and wrong, whether we know we have done the right thing, or we know we have failed, even if no one says so.

Our Values

It must come from within ourselves, from our own values, and our own conscience. Without that sense of shame, people may comply with the law out of fear of punishment, but they will lack the moral compass to do the right thing simply because it is the right thing to do, and to take responsibility when they fail to meet the standards expected of them.

What I personally find most disappointing in the WP narrative and in their responses, including in this House today, is the complete lack of acknowledgment that the three Members of Parliament have done something wrong. There is no remorse.

Mr. Speaker, whether you take a Western or Eastern view, if the lack of a sense of shame becomes the public norm, our political system will be progressively and irreparably damaged.

People will not trust not only individual leaders, or specific political parties, but the entire political system. And this has happened too often elsewhere.

If that happens, what do you do? What can you do? How can democracy function when there is no one we can trust to be accountable? How do you put Humpty Dumpty back together again? How do you start over from scratch? Press the reset button?

A democracy that is not based on integrity is easily shaken, and sooner or later will collapse. If, on the contrary, trust becomes "something to be valued," as George Shultz said, lies become "the accepted currency in public life," as John Major said, all that is heard and the anger seen in contests and debates will not bode well for the country.

As Singapore's politics becomes increasingly competitive, we must ensure that competition is honest, unbiased, and sincere. Where the system operates correctly, and our institutions remain pure and respected by all.

Where good people work together constructively to serve the people of Singapore, wherever they may be on the political spectrum. And, most fundamentally, where the people of Singapore can trust those who represent them to behave honestly and honorably, and act on behalf of the public, and Singapore.

Conclusion

Mr. Speaker, the COP report is lengthy and detailed, but the core issues are few and clear. We have examined the actions of Ms. Khan, as well as her rights and wrongs. She has acknowledged her mistakes, and will be punished accordingly. We think this matter can be closed. But it is clear that there is a bigger problem. Online, people are calling this Raeesah-Gate, after Watergate.

And just like in the original Watergate affair, while investigating Ms. Khan's misconduct, the COP stumbled upon a cover-up by the WP leaders, even more serious than the original wrongdoing. The COP did not anticipate this.

But now with the findings before us, it is our responsibility, the responsibility of Parliament, for Members of Parliament to take the necessary and appropriate actions.

Mr. Speaker, trust is essential for democracy to function well.

Being honest is fundamental to establishing trust. Honesty cannot be negotiated. If you lie, how can the public trust you? If someone in a position of responsibility lies, and blatantly escapes from it, how can the public trust that system?

And if Parliament allows lies among its own members, how can the people of Singapore trust the institution of Parliament? If we allow blatant and major violations to pass, it will erode trust in our leaders, respect for Parliament, and support for our entire political system, and Singapore will head towards problems.

As the longest-serving Member of the House, I feel this responsibility more acutely than most. When I first entered this House 37 years ago, Mr. Lee Kuan Yew, Mr. S. Rajaratnam, Dr. Toh Chin Chye, Mr. Ong Pang Boon, Mr. E.W. Barker, and Mr. Jek Yeun Thong were still Members.

Six of the ten who signed the Separation Agreement on August 9, 1965. I have witnessed how the founding generation built this place, handing it over to us in good condition. For me, this is a sacred trust.

And it must be a sacred trust as well, for every MP. We all cannot fail to serve the people of Singapore as best as we can, responsibly and honestly, and uphold this institution of Parliament, as the foundation of a robust and healthy democracy.

I urge all Members in this House, both old and new, government and opposition, elected and nominated, to weigh the facts, to vote with your conscience, and to join me in fulfilling your duty to Singapore.

Mr. Speaker, I support the motion.

What are the key factors that allow this virtuous cycle to continue, enabling Singapore to thrive rather than decline? That is trust. Former U.S. Secretary of State George Shultz reflected on this during his centenary celebration. In December 2020, he wrote a letter to the editor on his 100th birthday, stating that the most important lesson of his long life is: "Trust is the hard currency of nations." He wrote: "When trust exists, good things happen. When trust is gone, good things do not happen. Everything else is just a sideshow."

We witnessed this truth during the COVID-19 pandemic. Some countries managed the crisis better than others, and trust was the key factor. I have reiterated this point for over two years, but a recent study published in The Lancet, a British medical journal, confirms it. The report studied multiple countries and found that those with high levels of trust and low levels of corruption had relatively slower infection rates and higher vaccination rates. Because people trust the government and trust each other, it has a more significant impact than how many resources are invested in the healthcare system. Compared to whether a country has universal healthcare, whether people trust each other and whether they trust the government are the decisive factors. Singapore is fortunate to belong to this category of high-trust societies. We continued to strengthen mutual trust during the pandemic, but what we enjoy today is the result of decades of patience, diligence, and step-by-step progress, never allowing any erosion, which has created this tremendous asset we rely on in our fight. In other countries like the United States and the United Kingdom, the opposite has occurred. In the U.S., trust in the political system has nearly collapsed. Three-quarters of Republicans have been convinced that the results of the 2020 presidential election were stolen, that Mr. Biden is not the legitimate president, and that Mr. Trump should be the current president. When a significant portion of the populace believes that an elected government is illegitimate, how can you sustain the entire political system? Every issue has become politicized, government operations have become paralyzed, and the nation has suffered. This is also why so many Americans refuse to get vaccinated, refuse to wear masks, and resist measures aimed at protecting their safety, leading to so many infections and deaths. Or look at the ongoing "Partygate" scandal in the UK, which occurred in Westminster, the "mother of parliaments." The official investigation report attributed the scandal to "failures of leadership and judgment." By ignoring the rules they set, the current UK government has severely undermined trust and lost credibility in its pandemic response.

Singapore may be a high-trust society today, but there is no guarantee that we will continue to be so. We must steadfastly maintain high standards, ensure our leaders embody the right values, promptly point out mistakes, impose strict penalties when necessary, uphold the dignity of our system, never take the trust of the people for granted, and never allow lies, false statements, or fallacies to become accepted political norms.

Privilege Committee

This is where our debate on the Privilege Committee report in Parliament becomes a matter of survival. Ms. Raeesah Khan lied in Parliament, lying twice on August 3, and a third time when questioned two months later in October. She later admitted to lying to Parliament. To address this abuse of parliamentary privilege, we established a Privilege Committee. Ms. Khan and other witnesses were summoned to testify. The committee conducted extensive deliberations before reaching a well-considered conclusion. The conclusion is that Ms. Khan is guilty and must be fined for each instance of lying. I hope all members will agree with the findings of the investigation and the punishment for Ms. Khan.

However, during the committee's investigation, two other important issues emerged. The Privilege Committee has brought these to Parliament's attention and suggested how Parliament should handle them.

First, three leaders of the Workers' Party—Mr. Pritam Singh, Mr. Faisal Manap, and Ms. Raeesah Khan—are alleged to have incited Ms. Khan to continue lying in Parliament. If this is true, this misconduct is comparable to or worse than Ms. Khan's false statements in Parliament. Parliament must address this, but it must first clarify a second, more serious issue. That is, as articulated by the Leader of the House, the three Workers' Party leaders made false statements to the Privilege Committee after swearing to tell the truth, in order to cover up their instructions to Ms. Khan to continue lying. The committee clearly found striking contradictions between the noble intentions claimed by these three members and their actual actions, or more often, their inactions. Even among the Workers' Party leaders, there are serious inconsistencies in their statements. Dishonesty after taking an oath is no small matter. It means lying, despite solemnly swearing to tell the truth. This time, not once, not twice, but repeatedly over several hours of questioning across multiple days. The committee's assessment is that these false statements were not accidental or incidental errors, but deliberate, premeditated actions aimed at misleading and deceiving. Such behavior not only violates parliamentary privilege but, once confirmed by the courts, is equivalent to perjury—lying after taking an oath, and perjury is a serious crime.

Therefore, there are two distinct questions here. First, did the three members instruct Ms. Khan to lie? Second, did the three members themselves lie after taking an oath? If both are confirmed, it would put the Workers' Party leadership in a very difficult position, especially the Leader of the Opposition, Mr. Pritam Singh. If these two questions are not properly addressed, it will bring shame to Parliament and tarnish the reputation of this solemn and noble institution.

Some may ask, "Wasn't it Ms. Khan who lied? Why are the Workers' Party leaders being treated more harshly?"

As the Leader of the House just pointed out, if the committee is correct, it means that Mr. Pritam Singh and his other Workers' Party leaders lied and provided false testimony to the Privilege Committee. They swore that what they said was true, yet they lied to protect themselves, to cover up their own wrongdoing, and shifted all the blame onto Ms. Khan, claiming that she and other witnesses like Ms. Loh lied to the Privilege Committee. If this is indeed the case, it is certainly more serious than Ms. Khan's error. Lying after taking an oath obstructs the proceedings of the Privilege Committee. They also exhibited the same improper behavior, which is precisely what the Privilege Committee is meant to address. They violated the trust entrusted to Members of Parliament—especially the Leader of the Opposition, Mr. Pritam Singh. I hope all members understand that if this is true, it is a very serious matter.

Therefore, members must decide how Parliament should now handle this matter. Can we turn a blind eye and pretend nothing has happened? Or, if this is unacceptable, based on the strong evidence provided by the Privilege Committee, perhaps we can slightly lower our standards, acknowledging that someone lied, arguing that it is not a big deal and has not caused any harm?

If we decide to take one of the above approaches, then we will also become accomplices in belittling Parliament and bringing shame to it. We must take wrongdoing seriously and take action. I am pleased that this is the conclusion reached by the Privilege Committee.

What other options does the Privilege Committee have? It can suggest to Parliament to lightly reprimand the wrongdoers. However, that would show we are treating such a serious matter lightly. Worse still, lowering our standards would mean telling Singaporeans that it is not a big deal if elected leaders lie. Another possibility is that the Privilege Committee suggests that Parliament impose appropriate severe penalties on its own. Parliament has the power to do so. But if the Privilege Committee suggests this, allowing Parliament to decide how to punish, the opposition will certainly cry foul, accusing the People's Action Party of using its majority to persecute the opposition. In fact, they have already insinuated this, using a smokescreen to obscure the real issue, which is that the Workers' Party swore to tell the truth but actually lied.

I therefore believe that the Privilege Committee's recommendation is our best way to handle this. Since it now appears that someone may have committed a criminal offense, let Parliament hand the matter over to the prosecutors. Let the prosecutors reconsider the evidence and let the system work. If the prosecutors decide to prosecute them, Mr. Pritam Singh and Mr. Faisal Manap can defend themselves in court. The court must be convinced of their guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. And if they are innocent, then they have nothing to fear.

I commend the actions proposed to Parliament. If I were Mr. Pritam Singh, I would support both motions. To fine Ms. Khan, because she is undoubtedly guilty. The fact is, Mr. Pritam Singh's fellow party member, Mr. Chen Show Mao, who is also in the Privilege Committee, believes that she should be punished more severely for her second offense. And if Mr. Pritam Singh insists that he and his Workers' Party leaders did nothing wrong, he should vote to refer his case, as well as Mr. Faisal Manap's case, to the prosecutors. The fact is, he should call for a court trial, seeking the opportunity to defend himself, clear his name, and restore his reputation. If I were Mr. Pritam Singh, I would do so.

Unfortunately, the pro-Workers' Party voices on social media are heading in a different direction. Before this matter is resolved, if necessary, it must be determined by the courts, they are trying to confuse the issue and garner sympathy. They are asking the public to exonerate the three Members of Parliament, suggesting that referring their cases to the prosecutors is political persecution.

What they really want to say is: do not scrutinize too closely what Mr. Pritam Singh has done, just remember who he is—he is the opposition party you voted for, he is the Leader of the Opposition in Parliament. Because of his position, he should not be subjected to investigation by the Attorney-General's Office; any action taken against him must be for political purposes; because who he is is more important than what he has done—even if he may have committed a crime.

Some may believe and support such a narrative. They say, why not let it go? Can't there be a compromise solution? After all, the government has many things to deal with, wouldn't it be easier not to pursue the matter against the three Members of Parliament? However, Mr. Speaker, as long as the People's Action Party is in power, we will not shy away from any necessary action to uphold the proper norms of Parliament and instill in Singaporeans and their leaders the values that are crucial for maintaining the people's trust in the system and for our success.

Mr. Pritam Singh succeeded Mr. Low Thia Khiang as the Secretary-General of the Workers' Party. Mr. Low served for a long time—he was a Member of Parliament for 30 years and the party leader for 17 years. He sat across from me in Parliament, in the position Mr. Pritam Singh now occupies. Mr. Low was a formidable political opponent, but he was a patriotic Singaporean. He set a different tone for the Workers' Party. He said he hoped the Workers' Party could help Singapore build a first-world Parliament. He must be saddened by what his successor has done.

Because what has happened contradicts the ideals espoused by the Workers' Party. But from Mr. Low's public comments, he seems confident that the Workers' Party can weather this storm. This need not become a stumbling block for our democracy, provided that Mr. Pritam Singh and his colleagues take responsibility for their tarnishing of parliamentary standards and potentially illegal actions.

The Future of Singapore's Democracy

Mr. Speaker, we are all engaged in the same endeavor—to build Singapore's democracy and a political system that can serve Singaporeans well for many years to come. To achieve this, we must adhere to the right norms and reinforce the right values.

I know Singaporeans want to see more political competition, and I accept that. In the long run, I also anticipate that this is the direction Singapore should take. This is how every parliamentary democracy evolves. It is precisely because I recognize this that on the night of the 2020 election, after the Workers' Party won a second group representation constituency in Sengkang, I proposed that Mr. Pritam Singh be appointed as the Leader of the Opposition in Parliament, to provide him with the resources and support he needs to play his role. This is how a responsible government can help the emergence of a credible and responsible opposition, thereby contributing to the maturation of our political system.

However, the position of Leader of the Opposition also carries certain responsibilities—to set the tone for opposition members, to require his party to adhere to a code of conduct, and more importantly, to uphold integrity and be above reproach; the Leader of the Opposition does not receive a blank check.

Mr. Speaker, integrity is key to democracy. If the strength of the opposition can be ignored, as it was from 1966 to the 1980s, then the stakes of today's debate would be minimal. If the People's Action Party holds an overwhelming dominant position, the public would generally not have overly high expectations of the opposition and opposition members. The tone of the nation and its governance would be set by the People's Action Party and the high standards it imposes on itself. But as Singapore moves towards a more competitive environment, the capability and integrity of the opposition become significant. The question of "what are the right values and how should we uphold them" becomes fundamentally crucial for both the opposition and the ruling party.

Therefore, every election will be about who wins the mandate to govern this country. If the system is functioning properly, the ruling party will win as long as it maintains integrity, capability, and trustworthiness. If the ruling party fails to do these, and Singaporeans believe the opposition is more honest, cleaner, more capable, and more trustworthy, then the ruling party should be ousted, and the opposition should be brought in to form the next government. We cannot assume that the People's Action Party will always be in power, nor can we assume that the Workers' Party or certain opposition parties will always be in the wilderness.

I do not know when or how the day will come when Singapore will have a change of ruling party. As the leader of the People's Action Party, my duty is to ensure that we do our utmost while in power to earn the people's mandate in as many elections as possible.

But as a national leader, my duty also includes ensuring to the greatest extent possible that in future elections, regardless of which side wins, it will adhere to and uphold the same high standards of integrity and ethics as the People's Action Party. This is how our democratic system can function correctly, and no matter which side takes control, it will not be in vain. Because a city-state like Singapore—one of a kind in the world—needs a strong, effective, and well-governed government, regardless of who leads it.

Since the stakes involve our lives and future, everyone involved in this system must adhere to the same standards. Even if the party that makes mistakes portrays itself as the victim, it cannot use that as an excuse to apply double standards or seek absolution for unforgivable actions.

Former British Prime Minister John Major recently delivered a speech prompted by the "Partygate" scandal. I am sure he was expressing heartfelt concerns about the state of British politics, a cry from the heart. Let me read you some excerpts: "There has been a cold cynicism about politics since time immemorial. We are told that politicians 'are all the same,' and this is an untruth. Voters can tolerate lies as if they are an acceptable currency in public life." "But politicians are not 'all the same.' Lies are unacceptable." "To suggest otherwise is to demean public life and slander the vast majority of politicians who do not deliberately mislead voters." "But some do, and their behavior is corrosive. It tarnishes the reputation of politics and Parliament, and it is a dangerous trend." "If lies become commonplace and truth ceases to exist, then what can we believe in and who can we trust? The risk is... that nothing and no one can be trusted. What situation will we find ourselves in?" "If we lose trust in the leaders in our Parliament—then trust in the government will also evaporate."

Major represents a Western perspective, but in Eastern societies, norms and values are equally crucial, in fact, even more important than Western philosophy, because Western philosophy speaks of checks and balances, while Eastern philosophy believes that it is your virtue, your moral standing, that grants you the right to govern. In Confucian thought, there are four social virtues (the Four Cardinal Virtues) that hold the nation together: "propriety, righteousness, integrity, and shame." Integrity in public service, rejecting corruption, is being upright; this is a norm that can be enforced by law. However, a sense of shame, the perception of wrongdoing, is a moral view that concerns an individual's sense of right and wrong, whether we know we are doing the right thing or not, even if no one says so, our values and our conscience will tell us. Those without a sense of shame may comply out of fear of legal punishment, but they will lack the moral compass to do the right thing—simply because it is the right thing to do, and when they fall short of the expected standards, they must take responsibility.

What disappoints me most is that the Workers' Party, in their narrative and responses, including today in this Parliament, has shown no acknowledgment of wrongdoing by the three members, nor any sign of remorse.

Mr. Speaker, whether from a Western or Eastern perspective, if a lack of shame becomes an acceptable norm in public life, our political system will gradually and irreversibly collapse. The public will not only distrust individual leaders or specific parties but the entire political system. This situation has occurred too frequently in many places.

If this happens, what will you do? What can you do? How can democracy function if there are no trustworthy individuals to hold accountable? How can the broken "Humpty Dumpty" be put back together again? How do we start from scratch? Press the reset button? A democracy not built on integrity is shaky and will eventually collapse. If trust is not, as George Shultz said, the "hard currency of nations," then lies, as John Major said, become "the currency that circulates in public life," and all the noise of arguments and debates will not benefit the nation at all.

As political competition in Singapore intensifies, we must ensure that the contest is honest, fair, and transparent. We want the system to function properly, the institutions to remain sacred and respected by all. We want capable individuals to work constructively together to serve Singaporeans, regardless of where they stand on the political spectrum. And most fundamentally, Singaporeans must be able to trust that those who represent them act with integrity, with a sense of honor, and that all actions are for the public and for Singapore.

Conclusion

Mr. Speaker, the Privilege Committee's report is long and detailed, but it contains only a few obvious core issues. We have carefully examined Ms. Raeesah Khan's conduct and its rightness or wrongness. She has admitted her wrongdoing and will receive appropriate punishment for it. We thought this matter could be concluded straightforwardly, but it has revealed a larger issue. Online, some have referred to it as "Raeesah-gate," drawing parallels to Watergate. Just like Watergate, while investigating Ms. Khan's wrongdoing, the Privilege Committee unexpectedly uncovered cover-up actions by the Workers' Party leadership, which are more serious than the original offense. This was unexpected for the Privilege Committee. But with this investigation result, it is Parliament's responsibility to ensure that Members of Parliament take necessary and appropriate action.

Mr. Speaker, for a democratic system to function well, trust is essential. Sincerity is the foundation of trust, and honesty leaves no room for negotiation. If you lie, how can the public trust you? If those in positions of responsibility lie and can escape punishment in plain sight, how can the public trust this system? And if Parliament condones its members lying, how can Singaporeans believe in the parliamentary system? If we easily overlook blatant and egregious errors, it will erode people's trust in leaders, respect for Parliament, and support for our entire political system, and Singapore will get into trouble.

As the longest-serving member of Parliament, I feel a greater responsibility in this regard than most. Thirty-seven years ago, I first entered this Parliament, when Mr. Lee Kuan Yew, Mr. Rajaratnam, Dr. Goh Keng Swee, Mr. Wong Peng Soon, Mr. Bakri Musa, and Mr. Yeo Ning Hong were still members. They were six of the ten signatories of the Malaysia-Singapore Separation Agreement on August 9, 1965. I have witnessed how the founding generation of this nation built this place and handed it over to us intact. For me, there is a sacred trust in this. Each of us Members of Parliament should also view it as a sacred trust. We must absolutely not fail to dedicate ourselves, fulfill our duties, and serve Singaporeans with integrity; we must uphold Parliament as a strong and sound foundation of democracy.

I call on all members, new and old, from the ruling party or the opposition, elected or appointed, to weigh these facts, vote with your conscience, and fulfill your responsibilities to Singapore alongside me.

Mr. Speaker, I support both motions. Thank you.

However, good people are needed to run these institutions. Therefore, it was necessary to bring together ministers, members of parliament, judges, government officials, and experts from various fields, to train them and place them in positions. They must be individuals whom Singaporeans can trust to prioritize duty and Singapore, with qualities such as energy, dedication, a sense of public service, and above all, integrity and respect. This is how our current governance system was established.

It is the duty of all of us to protect and continue to build upon this governance system that we have inherited. We must do this with integrity, establishing rules and standards, applying the same rules equally to everyone, and ensuring that no one is above the law.

If we can do this consistently, without interruption and without hesitation, we can achieve orderly functioning. The people will have confidence in our leaders, processes, and institutions. When those in power and those governed adhere to the right practices and values and express them in their actions, democracy will mature, take deep root, and develop resilience. Singapore will continue to prosper.

But if we allow ourselves to become complacent, if we relax standards here and there, thinking just this once, and if we let lies go unchallenged, the flawless cycle will begin to falter and fail.

What is the key reason for this flawless cycle that ensures Singapore remains at the top?

That is trust.

Singapore can today be seen as a community full of trust. However, there is no guarantee that this situation will last forever. It is essential that we have leaders who will point out mistakes with the right qualities, impose penalties when necessary, safeguard the sanctity of our institutions, and not take the public's trust for granted, allowing lies, half-truths, and false pretenses to become accepted practices in politics. It is crucial that we firmly establish our high standards.

Events leading to the inquiry by the Committee of Privileges

As we discuss what action Parliament should take regarding the report of the Committee of Privileges, these matters are at risk.

Ms. Raeesah Khan lied in Parliament. She lied twice on August 3 last year, and a third time two months later when questioned. Later, she admitted to lying in Parliament.

To address this breach of parliamentary privilege, we established an inquiry committee. Ms. Khan and other witnesses were called to testify. After thoroughly investigating, the inquiry committee reached a conclusion with justifiable reasons: Ms. Khan is guilty, and she should be penalized for each instance of her lies.

However, during the inquiry, two other significant issues arose. The inquiry committee has brought them to Parliament's attention and proposed ways to address them.

Firstly, did the three leaders of the opposition party—Mr. Pritam Singh, Mr. Faisal Manap, and Ms. Sylvia Lim—encourage Ms. Khan to continue lying in Parliament? If they did, that would also constitute a serious or even more serious breach of conduct. Parliament must address this, but only after clarifying the more serious second issue.

As the Chair explained, after taking an oath to tell the truth, did the three leaders of the opposition party mislead the inquiry committee by concealing their encouragement for Ms. Khan to continue lying?

The inquiry committee found clear contradictions between the high-minded intentions described by the three members of Parliament and what they actually did, or in many instances, failed to do. There were even serious contradictions between what the opposition party leaders said.

Speaking untruths under oath is not a trivial matter. It is an act of lying after having sworn to tell the truth. In this case, it was not once, not twice, but repeatedly established over several hours of inquiry that lies were maintained.

These lies were not accidental or circumstantial; they were premeditated statements made with a firm intention to mislead and deceive, as assessed by the inquiry committee. These are not only breaches of parliamentary privilege but, if proven in court, would constitute perjury under oath. Giving false testimony is a serious crime.

Therefore, there are two distinct issues. One is whether the three members of Parliament encouraged Ms. Khan to lie; the second is whether the three members of Parliament lied under oath.

If both are confirmed, it would reflect very poorly on the leaders of the opposition party, particularly the leader of the opposition. If both matters are not handled properly, it would undermine Parliament and tarnish the esteemed reputation of this institution.

Some ask, "Was it not Ms. Raeesah Khan who lied? Why are the leaders of the opposition being treated more harshly?"

As the Chair mentioned earlier, if the committee's conclusion is correct, then Mr. Singh and his fellow opposition leaders have lied to the inquiry committee. They have lied to protect themselves, to conceal their involvement, and to shift the entire blame onto Ms. Khan, claiming that she and other witnesses like Ms. Loh had lied to the inquiry committee under oath. This is, in fact, a much more serious act than what Ms. Khan did.

By lying under oath, they have obstructed the work of the inquiry committee. Whatever misconduct the committee was set up to investigate, they exhibited the same misconduct. They have betrayed the trust placed in them by the people regarding the members of Parliament, particularly Mr. Singh as the leader of the opposition. If this is true, it is a very serious matter.

Therefore, members of Parliament must now determine what action to take regarding this. Can we remain as if nothing is happening? Or should we, based on the strong evidence presented by the inquiry committee, slightly lower our standards and argue that even if untruths were told, they were not that serious and that no harm was done?

If we do either of these, we will become complicit in an act that undermines Parliament. We must treat this breach as a serious matter and take appropriate action. I am pleased that the conclusion reached by the inquiry committee and the recommendations made to Parliament reflect this.

What alternatives did the inquiry committee have? The committee could have recommended a warning to the opposition leaders. However, doing so would suggest that we are taking a serious matter lightly.

Worse still, if we lower the standards of our practices, we would be telling Singaporeans that it is not that serious for elected leaders to lie.

Alternatively, the committee could have recommended that Parliament impose a severe penalty. Parliament has the authority to do this. However, if the committee had made such a recommendation and Parliament had decided on the penalty itself, the opposition would certainly claim that the ruling party is using its majority to act against the opposition. The opposition has already indirectly indicated this to conceal the real matter of the opposition party leaders lying under oath.

Therefore, I believe that the recommendation of the inquiry committee is the best next step. Given that a crime has been indicated, Parliament should refer this matter to the government’s legal counsel.

Let the government’s legal counsel review the evidence and let the process do its work. If charges are filed, Mr. Pritam Singh and Mr. Faisal Manap can defend themselves in court. Their guilt must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt in court. If they are innocent, there is nothing to fear.

I recommend these resolutions to them. If I were Mr. Singh, I would vote in favor of both resolutions. Ms. Khan can be penalized because she is undoubtedly guilty. Mr. Dennis Tan, a member of Mr. Singh's own party who served on the inquiry committee, believes that Mr. Singh should also be penalized for the second offense.

If Mr. Singh and his fellow opposition leaders establish that they did not commit any wrongdoing, they should also vote in favor of the resolution to refer their case and Mr. Faisal Manap's case to the government’s legal counsel.

To protect themselves and to prove their innocence, they should seek a judicial inquiry. If I were Mr. Singh, I would do just that.

However, it is regrettable that the voices of support for the opposition party emerging on social media hold differing views. They are trying to confuse the issue and evoke sympathy as much as they can before the matter is resolved, if necessary, in court. They are telling the public that the three members of Parliament are innocent. They are claiming that referring this matter to the government’s legal counsel is a political tactic.

What they are really saying is this: Do not scrutinize what Mr. Singh did; just remember who he is: he is the opposition party you voted for; he is the leader of the opposition. Because of his position, he should not be brought before the government’s legal counsel; any action against him would be politically motivated; because, even if he did commit a crime, who he is matters more than what he did.

Some may believe this and feel sympathy for him. What if we just let this matter go? What if we consider a lenient resolution? After all, would it not be easier for the government to take no further action against these three members of Parliament? We already have full records.

However, as long as the People’s Action Party is in government, we will not shy away from doing whatever is necessary to restore the proper practices in this House and to cultivate the essential qualities of trust in our governance among Singaporeans and their leaders. These are indispensable to our success.

Mr. Singh accepted the position of Secretary-General of the opposition party from Mr. Low Thia Khiang. Mr. Low has served as a member of Parliament for 30 years and as party leader for 17 years. He sat where Mr. Singh is now sitting. Although Mr. Low was a formidable political opponent, he was a Singaporean with a strong sense of national pride. He led the opposition party in a different manner. He expressed confidence that the opposition party could help create a first-world parliament in Singapore. But he would be saddened to see what his successor has done instead.

Because the principles that the opposition party has espoused have been betrayed. Based on the comments made by Mr. Low, he remains hopeful that the party will overcome this situation. This should not be a setback for our democracy, nor should we hold Mr. Singh and his colleagues accountable for undermining the standards of this House and for the intended breach of the law.

The future of Singapore's democracy

We are all engaged in the same task. The task is to build Singapore's democracy and create a political system that can serve Singaporeans well for generations to come. To do this, we must restore proper practices and emphasize the right values.

Singaporeans want to see more competition in politics, and I accept that. I expect this to be the case for a long time in Singapore. Every democratic parliament evolves in this way. It is because I recognize this that, after the opposition party won the second group representation constituency in the 2020 elections, I immediately offered Mr. Singh the position of leader of the opposition, along with the necessary resources and support. A credible and responsible opposition party leading the way will help a responsible government contribute to the maturity of our political system.

However, there are specific responsibilities associated with the position of leader of the opposition. The leader of the opposition must guide opposition members of Parliament, establish standards for the conduct of their party, and above all, maintain their integrity and remain above reproach. The leader of the opposition cannot act however they please.

Integrity is the cornerstone of democracy. If the opposition's presence in Parliament had been less significant, as it was from 1966 to the 1980s, the importance of today's debate would have been diminished. The People’s Action Party held a dominant position, and there were generally lower expectations of opposition parties and politicians from the public. The country and its leadership were guided by the People’s Action Party and the high standards it imposed on itself.

However, as Singapore moves towards a more competitive environment, the capabilities and integrity of the opposition will no longer be disregarded.

From now on, every election will be about who will win the support to govern this country. If the system functions properly, the ruling party will be re-elected as long as it remains honest, capable, and trustworthy.

If Singaporeans decide that the ruling party has flaws and the opposition is more honest, less corrupt, more capable, and more trustworthy, they must vote for the opposition to form the next government instead of voting for the ruling party. We should not assume that the People's Action Party will always remain in government. Similarly, we should not assume that the Workers' Party or any other opposition party will always remain in opposition.

I do not know when, how, or if the ruling party of Singapore will change. As the party leader, it is my duty to ensure that the People's Action Party governs effectively to retain the support of the people in the upcoming elections.

At the same time, as the leader of the country, it is also my duty to increase the chances that whichever party wins future elections will uphold high standards of integrity and good governance, similar to those of the People's Action Party. Only then can our democratic system continue to function properly, regardless of which party is in power. Because in a small island nation like Singapore, it is essential to have a strong, effective, and stable government, no matter who is leading it.

Since our lives and future may be affected, the same standards must be expected from everyone participating in governance. There is no room for any double standards or excuses for misconduct, and there can be no forgiveness for unacceptable behavior.

What disappoints me personally, including what has transpired in this House today, is that all three Members of Parliament refuse to fully acknowledge their wrongdoing. No remorse has been expressed.

Whether viewed from a Western or Eastern perspective, if a lack of accountability becomes the norm, our political system will gradually and irreparably deteriorate. The public will lose faith not only in individual leaders or political parties but in the entire political system. This has often happened elsewhere.

If this happens, what will you do? What can you do? How can democracy function if there is no one trustworthy to hold office? How will you put Humpty Dumpty back together again? How will you start over from scratch? Will you press the reset button?

A democracy that does not base itself on integrity is bound to falter one day.

As Singapore's politics become more competitive, we must ensure that this competition is fair, unbiased, and transparent. The system must operate smoothly, and our institutions must be respected by all without blemish. Those who are capable, regardless of their position in the political arena, must work together constructively to serve Singaporeans.

At the core of everything, Singaporeans must be able to trust that their representatives will act with integrity and dignity, and will act on behalf of the people and the nation.

Although the report of the Select Committee on Deliberate Online Falsehoods is extensive and lengthy, it clearly addresses some key issues. We have examined the actions of Thiruvadi Kaan and determined what is right and wrong. He has acknowledged his mistakes. He will be punished appropriately. We thought this matter would end here.

However, it has become a significant issue. Online, in memory of the 'Watergate' affair, people have dubbed this matter 'Rayisa-gate.'

Just like the Watergate affair, the Select Committee unexpectedly discovered that the leaders of the ruling party had concealed the crimes of Thiruvadi Kaan. This is far more serious than the original offense.

The Select Committee did not anticipate this. However, since what the committee has uncovered is now before us, it is our responsibility, the responsibility of Parliament. Members of Parliament must take necessary and appropriate action.

For democracy to function well, trust is essential. It is crucial to be genuine in fostering that trust. Integrity cannot be compromised. If you lie, how will the public trust you? If someone in a position of responsibility lies and blatantly escapes accountability, how will the public trust the system? If Parliament tolerates its members lying, how will Singaporeans trust Parliament? If we allow blatant and shocking misconduct, the trust in our leaders, the respect for Parliament, and the support for the entire political system will erode, leading Singapore into a precarious situation.

As a long-serving member of this House, I believe I bear more responsibility than most. When I first stepped into this House 37 years ago, Mr. Lee Kuan Yew, Mr. S. Rajaratnam, Dr. Toh Chin Chye, Mr. Ong Pang Boon, Mr. E.W. Barker, and Mr. Jek Yuen Thong were all members. Six of the ten who signed the separation agreement on August 9, 1965, were among them.

I have witnessed firsthand how the founding generation of Singapore built this place and handed it over to us in good condition. For me, this is integrity without blemish. Every Member of Parliament must have integrity without blemish. We must never fail to serve Singaporeans with responsibility and honesty to uphold Parliament as a solid foundation for a healthy democracy.