Statement by President Lula at the event on the sidelines of the United Nations General Assembly "In Defense of Democracy. Fighting Against Extremism"

Brazil Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva · President of Brazil

24 September 2024 · Event on the sidelines of the United Nations General Assembly "In Defense of Democracy. Fighting Against Extremism"

Context
Lula addressed a sideline event at the UN General Assembly on September 24, 2024, co-organized with Colombia's President Petro, to defend democracy against extremism.
Main themes
Defense of democracy, right-wing extremism, fake news and disinformation, social inequality, global democratic crisis, colonialism and coups, racism and xenophobia, multilateral cooperation, totalitarianism, workers' rights, diversity and pluralism
Duration
~28 min
80th percentile
Words
3,367
80th percentile
Sentences
201
89th percentile
Readability
55
75th percentile
Grade
9.8
18th percentile
Syntax
2.88
31st percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
44th percentile

Translated from Portuguese

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Ceremonial 36%36%
  • Institutional 22%22%
  • Social 20%20%
  • Geopolitical 10%10%
  • Economic 6%6%
  • Technological 5%5%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

201 sentences in 96 paragraphs

In several countries around the world, democracy is facing extreme risks, and it is at risk not in the democratic contest, but it is at risk due to a denialist extremism that denies institutions, denies the organizational values of society, a denialism that does not recognize unions, that does not recognize social organization and that uses social media as a way to sell, as if they were true vandals, fake news. Spreading lies, spreading rumors, spreading hatred in society.

So, in a conversation with President Petro [Gustavo Petro, President of Colombia], we had the idea to call for a meeting, and the moment was here at the United Nations meeting, so that we could bring together people who wanted to participate with us in this democratic debate.

Previously, we thought it would be difficult to hold such a meeting, but what we are realizing is that it is extremely necessary that this be just the first of many meetings we will have to hold to discuss democracy. Because the truth is that democracy, as we know it and as it was built, especially after World War II, is losing a lot of ground.

And one of the things we can do is discuss the reasons why democracy is having problems. Where did we go wrong? What did we fail to do? What did we not fulfill? And it is a new challenge for us. So, I want to thank the presence of all of you, from the heart.

Some people are missing here who could not come. Comrade Olaf Scholz [Chancellor of Germany], just yesterday, we had a meeting and he could not be here. President Biden [Joe Biden, President of the United States of America] was invited to come here and, obviously, he could not attend. I invited Macron [Emmanuel Macron, President of France] to participate in this meeting and he said he would come, I don’t know if he will come, but he said he would come to this meeting. And I even have a bilateral meeting with him tomorrow.

Well, I don’t know if my partner Pedro Sánchez [President of Spain] has anything to say at the opening, because afterwards I have a word and then we will have to open the floor to all the comrades who are here. The idea is that we have to have a very controlled time, right? I learned in these G20, G7, BRICS meetings that we travel 18,000 kilometers to speak for three minutes.

But we can have about four minutes, three or four minutes, for each one to express their first opinion. And then we will discuss what sequence we will give to this event. Who knows, maybe Chile will invite us to hold one there in Santiago, Chile, so that we can also rotate. Or if we will always do it on the occasion of the United Nations General Assembly meeting.

Well, I have a small speech. The initial idea is that, in addition to greeting Pedro Sánchez, I want to thank the ministers who are accompanying, each comrade who is here. Here I am with my wife, I am with Minister Esther [Dweck, Minister of Management and Innovation in Public Services], I am with Minister Sonia [Guajajara, Minister of Indigenous Peoples], I am with Minister Vinícius [Marques, Minister of the Office of the Comptroller General], two senators of the Republic, plus a press advisor, plus comrade Celso Amorim [Chief Advisor of the Special Advisory of the President of the Republic], plus the ambassador of Brazil, plus the ambassador in Washington. In other words, my delegation is extremely large, very large, in a demonstration of the credibility of this meeting.

So, I will give a small speech, then I will pass the word to President Pedro Sánchez, and then we will pass the word to you.

First, I want to thank those who responded to the invitation that President Pedro Sánchez and I made for this meeting.

I do not intend to present here a comprehensive diagnosis of the threats we face.

But it is undeniable that democracy is living its most critical moment since World War II.

In Brazil and the United States, totalitarian forces have promoted violent actions to challenge the results of the polls.

In Latin America, fake news erodes trust and affects electoral processes.

In Europe, an explosive mix of racism, xenophobia, and disinformation campaigns puts diversity and pluralism at risk.

In Africa, coups d'état demonstrate that the use of force to overthrow governments still reflects the remnants of colonialism.

Understanding why democracy has become an easy target for the far right and its false narratives is a shared challenge.

Extremism is a symptom of a deeper crisis, of multiple causes.

Liberal democracy has proven insufficient and has frustrated the expectations of millions.

It has become just a ritual that we repeat every 4 or 5 years.

A model that works for big capital and abandons workers to their own fate is not democratic.

A system that privileges white men and fails black women is immoral.

Abundance for a few and hunger for many in the 21st century is the antechamber to totalitarianism.

Our struggle is to make democracy once again perceived as the most effective path to the conquest and realization of rights.

To restore hope to millions of the dispossessed of globalization, we need to put the economy at the service of the people.

This does not mean ending the free market, but rather recovering the role of the State as a planner of sustainable development and as a guarantor of well-being and equity.

Freedom of expression is a fundamental right and one of the central pillars of a healthy democracy, but it is not absolute.

It finds its limits in the protection of the rights and freedoms of others, and of the political order itself.

Digital technologies help promote and disseminate knowledge, but they also exacerbate the risks to civilized coexistence among people.

Digital networks have become fertile ground for hate speech, misogynistic, racist, xenophobic discourses that victimize people every day.

Our societies will be under constant threat as long as we are not firm in regulating platforms and the use of artificial intelligence.

No technology company or individual, no matter how wealthy they are, can consider themselves above the law.

They need to be held accountable for the content they circulate.

There are new challenges ahead of us for which we have not yet found answers.

The far right has also become electorally viable by organizing the discontented around an inverted identity discourse. They blame migrants, women, and minorities for today’s problems.

And they do this by straining the limits of democratic institutions.

Yielding to these narratives is falling into a trap.

Retreating will not appease the violent spirit of those who attack democracy to silence and strip away rights.

There is no contradiction between social cohesion and respect for diversity. Pluralism strengthens us.

Democracy in its fullness is the foundation for promoting peaceful, just, and inclusive societies, free from fear and violence.

It is fundamental for a world of peace and prosperity.

History has taught us that democracy cannot be imposed.

Its construction is unique to each people and each country.

To restore its legitimacy, we need to recover its essence, and not just its form.

Social participation is one of the main paths to strengthening democratic identity.

Democracy is not a pact of silence.

We need to listen to social movements, students, women, workers, entrepreneurs, racial, ethnic, and religious minorities.

Protecting those who defend human rights, the environment, and democracy is also essential.

The Brazilian experience shows that the balance between the established powers and the resilience and strengthening of institutions are crucial in protecting these principles.

Only a revitalized democracy will allow us to address the dilemmas of our societies and the contemporary world.

Thank you, comrades.

I now pass the word to comrade Pedro Sánchez.

[Statement by the President of Spain, Pedro Sánchez]

President Lula: Well, thank you, Pedro Sánchez. Now we will start to hear our comrades who are here. The idea is that the comrades, in the most democratic way possible, express themselves in four minutes. I would like to pass the word, first, to our dear Prime Minister of Barbados, Mia Mottley.

[Statement by the Prime Minister of Barbados, Mia Mottley]

[Statement by the President of Cape Verde, José Maria Neves]

President Lula: José Maria Neves. I now pass the word to our dear comrade, the President of the Republic of Chile, Gabriel Boric.

[Statement by the President of Chile, Gabriel Boric]

[Statement by the Prime Minister of Canada, Justin Trudeau]

President Lula: Well, now, thank you, comrade Trudeau. Let’s now call our comrade, the President of the European Council, Charles Michel.

[Statement by the President of the European Council, Charles Michel]

President Lula: I would like to invite the Chief Secretary of the Government of Kenya, Musalia Mudavadi, to speak.

[Statement by the Chief Secretary of the Cabinet of Kenya, Musalia Mudavadi]

President Lula: Thank you, Minister Mudavadi. I would like to now call to speak our dear comrade from East Timor, Prime Minister Xanana Gusmão.

[Statement by the Prime Minister of East Timor, Xanana Gusmão]

President Lula: I want to invite the President Macron, President of France, to speak.

[Statement by the President of France, Emmanuel Macron]

President Lula: Thank you, President Macron. I would now like to call to speak the Under-Secretary-General for Policies of the United Nations, Guy Ryder.

[Statement by the Under-Secretary-General for Policies of the United Nations, Guy Ryder]

President Lula: Thank you, Guy Ryder. I would now like to pass the word to our dear comrade, the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Mexico, Alicia Bárcena. Who came here representing our comrade Andrés López Obrador [President of Mexico].

[Statement by the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Mexico, Alicia Bárcena]

President Lula: Thank you, comrade Alicia. Before calling the next comrade, this thing that Minister Alicia said about López Obrador is unbelievable, I don’t know if all of us here will be able to do it. Every day, for two hours, starting at 6 a.m., López Obrador calls the press. He calls all the press, whether it is television, radio, or internet, and spends two hours giving interviews, answering serious questions, responding to provocations. And, even if it doesn’t go to the mainstream press, it goes to the internet and he speaks the same way. For five years, every day, two hours a day with the press. It is the greatest phenomenon of a person who can withstand talking to the press for so long in political history. I hope Claudia [Scheinbaum, elected president of Mexico] does two and a half hours. Well, I would now like to call to speak comrade Luis Gilberto Murillo, Minister of Foreign Affairs of Colombia.

[Statement by the Minister of Foreign Affairs of Colombia, Luis Gilberto Murillo]

President Lula: Thank you, Gilberto Murillo. I would now like to call to speak the comrade representative of Senegal, Aminata Touré.

[Statement by the former Prime Minister of Senegal, Aminata Touré]

President Lula: Thank you, Minister Touré. I have here in my list the last speaker now. I am asking my advisor to check if the representative of Norway wants to speak. But another speaker here, I mean, is the representative of the United States, the Deputy Secretary of State, Kurt Campbell.

[Statement by the Deputy Secretary of State of the United States of America, Kurt Campbell]

President Lula: Well, I would like to now call comrade Tine Mørch Smith, representative of Norway. The Prime Minister was here, but had to leave. You can speak.

[Statement by the Norwegian diplomat Tine Mørch Smith]

President Lula: Well, we are reaching the end of this meeting. And I wanted to tell you that we will not be able to have a document from the meeting. It is not possible to create and approve a document. What will happen, in the end, will be a note from comrade Pedro Sánchez and me, summarizing what we were able to capture from the discussions that took place here.

I just wanted to say a few important things. First, a great concern about the impact of growing inequalities on trust in democracy as an effective form of government. You remember that I started here by saying that, possibly, we need to look not only at what is leading the far right to win elections and convince a portion of society, but also analyze where we went wrong. Where did democracy go wrong? Because the problem may indeed lie with us and we need to recover, because democracy, with hunger, with unemployment, with misery, with the beginnings of prejudice, is not possible. So it is necessary for us to study a lot.

The second thing is that we have numerous challenges belonging to the world of work in the digital area. The deepening of the precarization of workers, the lack of prospects for youth, the despair of older workers who fear for their pensions.

We also hear here this social dissatisfaction. It increases the appeal of easy and authoritarian solutions, presented by adventurers. Another aspect is the urgent need for the regulation of digital technologies and social networks, so that they fulfill their social function, instead of fueling hatred and violence, as they do now. We must remember that one of the problems of digital networks is monetization. There are people getting very rich spreading hatred, spreading lies, spreading falsehoods against others.

Also, I saw here many interesting ideas regarding the regulation of social networks. Thirdly, I noticed that many, like me, see a capture of identity agendas by the far right with the aim of attacking minorities and stripping them of their rights and freedoms. This, at least in Brazil, is a very high point. That is, the issue of abortion, the issue of quotas in universities, the issue of defending indigenous peoples, the issue of... All of this is a reason for the far right to spread hatred in society, especially when we talk about women's rights, women's participation. So, this is something we need to meditate on a lot.

Another thing: racist, misogynistic, xenophobic narratives need to be contested by true democrats. Here in Europe, I feel, for example, that the issue of migration has left progressive governments without anything to say. Because when Trump gives a speech here in the United States, saying that the United States is for Americans, Europe is for Europeans, Germany is for Germans, the French are for the French, we forget that, possibly, the rich countries, over the years, have been the ones fostering the need for people to travel from one country to another, because if they had the conditions to stay in their countries, people would stay. And people would only travel for vacations and would then be welcomed because they would be consumers. These are crucial problems that we need to face, and it is a very expensive and very difficult debate.

We saw, in Brazil, when the companions from Haiti began to come to Brazil, as now many Venezuelans are going to Brazil, we are noticing how a part of society reacts, as if the immigrant is taking their job, taking their space. And this is a challenge we have to address. Even our former Chancellor, Angela Merkel, had serious political problems when she had the audacity to allow the entry of thousands and thousands of immigrants into Germany. This is another important thing.

I just wanted to say to you that I am very happy with this meeting, because I have already been president for the twelfth year. I have participated in progressive meetings, I have been invited, I have participated in meetings with various progressive presidents. But I think I even avoided using the word "progressive" to not ideologically separate people. Those who were not invited do not feel progressive. So I used the word "democrats," so that we can call people who are not from the left spectrum, from the progressive spectrum, but who are concerned about what is happening in the world, who are concerned about democracy.

I think, I want to start by thanking you for your participation. When I called President Macron, he could not even come to this meeting at the United Nations General Assembly. He, responding to a call from Pedro and me, came here. I want to thank you, Macron. I know it is difficult for us to have. I can imagine leaving East Timor and coming here for a meeting. It is not an easy thing; it is a delicate thing to do. But I want to thank each one of you. This is a first meeting.

I did not expect a better result than what we are achieving, because there are many people who often do not participate in meetings because nothing is decided, they cannot take home the answer they wanted, because sometimes the important thing about a meeting among politicians is, at least, for them to get to know each other. At least, for them to greet each other, because this is an important thing. Politics is this chemical relationship between human beings. Politics is not a matter of exact mathematics, because otherwise, we would learn in a university how to be the best politician in the world. And it is not there that we learn.

We learn in our coexistence with the society we represent. I always tell every politician that if they win an election and place the program that made them win the election at the head of their bed, and every day when they get up, they read what they promised during the campaign and go out to fulfill what they promised, certainly, we would have much more success.

The problem is that this does not always happen. And when this does not happen, the madness we are seeing occurs. The monetization of lies through digital networks. With people becoming billionaires, millionaires. What we are seeing in a country like Brazil, Macron, is those games on television, the betting game. Brazil has always been against, has always been against casinos, has always been against any type of gambling. Today, through a cellphone, gambling is inside the homes of families, inside the living room. We are now noticing, in Brazil, the indebtedness of poorer people trying to make money by betting.

And this is a problem that we will have to regulate because, otherwise, soon we will have casinos operating inside the kitchen of every house. We are even discussing a bill in which we will try not to allow cellphones in the classroom. It will be a difficult thing. I have said that perhaps I will be the president who will have marches of six-year-old, seven-year-old, eight-year-old children against President Lula because they want a cellphone. Because today, we are seeing mothers, when a child cries, instead of comforting them, they take and give them a tablet, give them a cellphone, to do anything.

In other words, we are realizing the gravity that this can represent. I honestly think we need to have a very transparent debate with society, listen to specialists, scientists, people who understand. But we need, at a universal level, it is not a solution for just one country, whether at the UN, the G20, or the G7, to have regulation. A regulation, because suddenly, you have a citizen who has become the richest in the world, who dares to challenge the constitutions of countries that do not agree with him.

Where are we going to stop? Where will democracy sustain itself? So, I think it is time for democrats to sit down, discuss, act, and make proposals, because democracy continues to be the best way for us to deal with the problems of humanity. So, I give the floor to my companion Pedro Sánchez.

[Statement by President Pedro Sánchez]

President Lula: One thing that Pedro and I can do is that we could send a summary, made by him and me, to each one of you. To see if we can faithfully portray what happened in this meeting. And thank you, thank you for everything.