"Andalusia needs a change to create jobs."

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

8 March 2015

Context
Rajoy gave an interview ahead of the 2015 Andalusian regional elections, arguing that the PP represented the only real option for change and job creation in the region.
Main themes
Andalusian regional elections, political change in Andalusia, PP electoral strategy, job creation and economic growth, Socialist Party dominance in Andalusia, rise of minor parties like Ciudadanos and Podemos, economic crisis and recovery, structural reforms, social discontent, defense of Spain's achievements, public services and pensions
Duration
~40 min
90th percentile
Words
4,770
90th percentile
Sentences
301
95th percentile
Readability
68
97th percentile
Grade
7.5
3rd percentile
Syntax
2.85
28th percentile
Vocabulary
1.94
5th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 40%31%
  • Economic 38%29%
  • Social 12%9%
  • Geopolitical 5%4%
  • Ceremonial 5%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 24%

301 sentences in 98 paragraphs

- In the case of the Andalusian PP, we are facing a paradoxical situation. In 2012, the expectations of government were very broad, and the first three months of the central government spoiled those hopes of Javier Arenas. Now we find ourselves in the opposite case; there is a recovery, but the Andalusian elections will be held first. Do you think the option for change is beginning to fade in Andalusia?

- No, what I believe is that the only real option for change in Andalusia is the PP. And, moreover, it has already been so in all the provincial capitals, in the large municipalities, and in the councils. The only option for change in Andalusia is the PP, evidently.

- So, what has happened?

- We have experienced a very large economic crisis, and it is the large parties that suffer. I am absolutely convinced that this is transitory. We aspire to achieve the best possible results and for those who gave us their trust to renew it.

- Why do you think it is so difficult to dislodge the Socialist Party in Andalusia, which has been in government for 35 years? What happens in Andalusia that does not happen in the rest of Spain?

- Look, for now, the PP has managed to win against them. In the municipal elections, by a significant margin, in the national elections, and in the regional elections, which we also won. I mean that the PP has been taking steps in the right direction, working with a lot of intensity, a lot of effort, and, you know, it is about doing things better and better to achieve that. Andalusia is the only region in Spain where there has never been a change of government. And it probably needs a change of government, and a government like ours that can implement structural reforms that can help economic growth and job creation. It is important. What Andalusia needs are three things: economic growth, employment, and the solidarity of the rest of the Spaniards. And, honestly, I believe it can be done.

- Would you say there is a clientelist regime in Andalusia? Is that something your party has said?

- I am not going to get into that. I have never said it, and I say what I think.

- The Andalusian elections are a bit of a laboratory for what might happen in Spain in 2015. And we are seeing minor parties, like Ciudadanos, that without having tradition or territorial presence in Andalusia are gaining ground. Is Ciudadanos the Podemos of the PP?

- I believe that the Andalusian elections are not a laboratory for anything; I sincerely believe that. And in Spain, people behave electorally very differently depending on the elections and the regions. Each region of Spain has its own idiosyncrasy. You know, there is a basic rule in democracy, which I apply to myself, and that is absolute respect for what the people decide. Therefore, this is not a laboratory for anything. And as I said before, Podemos or other political forces, previously it was UPyD, or Ciudadanos, are forces that can channel social discontent at a certain moment, but in the end, they are not governing parties. This is my opinion.

- To the point of putting the constitutional system at risk?

- No, the constitutional system is not at risk in our country. Just look at how normally we made the change in the Head of State a few months ago. We do not realize it, but in the last 40 years, Spain is among the countries where per capita income has increased the most. This is a truly incredible fact; the problem is that we have a certain tendency to punish ourselves and to say how badly things are going. I will give you an example that is very easy to understand. When we had the Ebola problem in Spain, a nurse was treated in the Social Security system, and she recovered. And the Spanish taxpayer paid for it. On the same day, a nurse in the U.S. entered a hospital with a bill of $500,000. We have 65 million tourists a year. And why do they come? They come because there is sun, there are beaches, because it is beautiful, because the food is good, and also because there are good public services, security, and infrastructure. So, let’s speak well of Spain. Can it be improved? In everything, without a doubt. But let’s speak well of Spain. Sometimes, we are always focused on the negative.

- But it is true that there is social discontent in Spain that, at least for people of our generation, we had not known until now. - The discontent is justified. In the legislature from 2008 to 2011, 3,400,000 jobs were lost in Spain. And then in 2012 and 2013, we continued to destroy jobs. But let us not forget that in a situation like this, Spain has been able to pay nine million pensions without ever lowering them. Spain has maintained a public healthcare system that is among the best in the world. A public education system in a very difficult moment. And we have held on. The key to what has happened here is that we lost 70 billion euros in revenue. And, of course, when you lose 70 billion euros in revenue, you have to adjust.

- Mr. President, returning to the Andalusian elections, you never explained why you chose Juan Manuel Moreno Bonilla as a candidate.

- He was chosen because that is what the majority wanted.

- The majority of your party?

- Yes, the majority of the party, of course. But there is a second reason, and that is that he had a huge desire to fight in Andalusia. This man was here, in Madrid, relatively comfortable, he was Secretary of State, he was doing things well, he had political experience. And he gave up everything because he wanted to fight. He really had a huge desire. And in life, that is very important, because when one goes to places without desire, they end up dragging their feet. He is a man who has fought, who has enthusiasm, and I have a lot of confidence in him.

- In the end, you did not include Javier Arenas in the government, which is what many of us thought you would do.

- I have an excellent political relationship with Javier Arenas that has lasted many years. We were both deputy secretaries general of the PP, and we have a great personal friendship, which is a different thing from the political relationship.

- In the case of Andalusia, whether the PSOE or the PP wins, it seems that there will not be absolute majorities. It seems we are going to have a more divided Parliament. Would you be more in favor of a PP-PSOE pact or a PP-Podemos pact?

- You know that I do not usually anticipate events.

- What I want to say…

- Let’s see, everyone presents themselves for election with the goal of winning. I would be lying to you if I did not say that I am happy with the absolute majority in Spain. I believe this has allowed us to make reforms that otherwise would not have been possible. Well, there are places where there are coalition governments, like in Aragón, where we are with the PAR, or in Asturias, where there is no coalition but we are supporting the Socialist Party. I believe it is good, and it is what has worked in Spain, that there is one party governing and one party in opposition. That is what has been in Spain; sometimes it has been positioned in the center-right, other times in the center-left, and it has worked, it has provided stability. Now, from now on, we will see how events unfold. But I think it is always good to respect the one who wins, which is what did not happen in Andalusia three years ago.

- Supporting the most voted list.

- I always find that very positive.

- But that is it: in this case, the most voted would need support.

- I hope that it will be us.

- Do you not think we lack a coalition culture? That part of public opinion views this negatively, as a distribution of seats?

- I, being the vice president of the Xunta de Galicia, had to govern like that, and then we, in the first national legislature, in 1996, had a coalition with three political forces in Congress. And the PSOE also had them in the last stages of Felipe González, with parliamentary agreements.

- I say this because, from the parties themselves, the accusation made against the other is, "are you going to pact with Podemos…".

- I do not know what the Popular Party will do in Andalusia, but I believe that it will not make a pact with Podemos.

- And do you think the national PSOE is looking for a pact with Podemos?

- Well, I do not know. I also should not meddle with Mr. Pedro Sánchez. I do not know; I suppose he will do it because he believes it is very positive for him. Sometimes I think there is a race among the different parties to see who can get more involved with me.

- You got very upset with Pedro Sánchez in the State of the Nation Debate.

- I did not get upset. I made an intervention trying to explain how the nation was, looking to the future. It was a serious intervention, not because I made it, but it was serious and well-constructed. Well, Mr. Sánchez, who said nothing, was told that what he had to do was to say all the atrocities in the world to me, even in the replies he brought written. In my life, I have never gone with a written reply anywhere, but, well, those are things that need to be given the importance they deserve.

- You called him pathetic.

- Well, the problem is not what I called him, but whether what I called him was true or not. But we will not get into more details.

- In Andalusia, there is the impression, in certain financial and economic circles - which tend to be more inclined to right-wing thinking than to left-wing thinking - that right now the useful vote for Andalusia would be for Susana Díaz. And it would be for two reasons: first, because it would mean stopping Podemos, and second, because the Andalusian PP is not sufficiently prepared to govern in Andalusia. I am not asking for an evaluation, just a comment.

- I have known that old trick for many years because it was exactly the same one I experienced in 1996; and then, whenever municipal elections were held in Andalusia, they would say: "Well, of course, if not, IU will come in and we have to give it to them." No. The PP is the only change in Andalusia. Here, being with strategies and tactics does not make sense.

- They are talking about that again.

- I have said that in Andalusia, 575,000 jobs can be created and bring it to the employment level of the rest of Spain. And that is the biggest. That is the battle that needs to be fought. This idea of whether they come in, take away, give to Podemos… let’s see, at this point in my life, I am playing for the biggest. And I believe that in Andalusia, a political change is good; it is good to apply reforms like those being applied at the national level. That is real change.

- Earlier you spoke of Pedro Sánchez. Do you think Susana Díaz would be a candidate with more state character than Pedro Sánchez?

- No, I do not want to get into that.

- In the meetings you have had with Susana Díaz, has there been a sense of state?

- No, I will not talk about Susana Díaz or Mr. Sánchez because I might come up with some malice, but I think it is not relevant.

- Year 2015, an electoral year, first Andalusia, then the municipal and regional elections, and finally, Catalonia. It seems that things have changed a lot electorally in Catalonia, and I do not know if anyone has told you that in the end, you were right.

- It is impossible for anyone to say that I am right about anything.

- There is a strategy that has worked for you, that of not getting excessively nervous, that of not changing the Constitution to accommodate nationalists.

- I believe we acted with firmness and proportionality. Honestly. And I think we must make an effort to understand each other, to talk. I am willing to make that effort. And the only limit I have is the unity of Spain, national sovereignty, the fundamental rights of citizens, and equality and solidarity among Spaniards. Those are my only limits. Now, a Prime Minister cannot be asked to authorize a referendum to liquidate national sovereignty. Neither I nor anyone else would accept it, regardless of the party; in life, never.

- Do you still not see constitutional reform?

- No, and I will explain why. The priorities of this legislature have been the following: first, to address the crisis; second, to resolve the serious problems that some public administrations had, which could not go to the markets, and that is why we created the Autonomous Liquidity Fund and the payment to suppliers. That was crucial because if a region fell, the country would fall. This is not seen now, but that was exactly the case. The third issue was Europe, which is where the real reform of the Spanish Constitution and others is taking place. Just look at the fiscal pact or the banking union. The Bank of Spain no longer supervises the large banks. And then, I give you a fourth argument. When one wants to reform the Constitution, one must know for what purpose. That is fundamental. And see what support one has. And, of course, reforming the Constitution to try to stop the problems that some wanted to generate for us in Catalonia, and that, moreover, they would not be satisfied, did not seem the most appropriate to me. I believe that at the political moment we were in, that was not good. I believe that the Constitution can be reformed, but I also believe that it is not the great priority of the Spaniards. Now, I have always been open. I have talked about this with the PSOE, about a federal model, of course, but, you know, what is that? I mean, what does that mean? More powers for the autonomous communities? Less? This is not a matter of slogans; it is a matter of content. And I know that many people have told me that I was an immobilist, but the facts show that this is not the case.

- Do you think that in the case of Catalonia, there is nothing more to be done but to let the elections come and let that new Parliament emerge?

- I believe that at this moment, at the point in the legislature we are in, it does not make sense to open that type of debate. The great objective of what remains of the national legislature is to consolidate the recovery and create jobs. There is no other; we are no longer for other stories.

- There are third elections for this year, the call for which depends exclusively on you. I suppose it will be this year.

- I do not do acrobatics.

- Why do you mention acrobatics?

- Well, I will explain it to you. This year, in Spain, if we were serious, there should be two elections: the municipal and regional elections, and the general elections. And if you want to bring the others forward, put them with the municipal ones. What is this about having four calls? It would have been better to have just two, but anyway.

- Because the accumulation of elections, does it interfere with or harm the economic recovery process?

- Well, I hope not, but what helps the economy is stability. But, well, I believe that at this moment the economy is cruising at a good speed. For the first time, external factors are helping us, and that is good: the euro exchange rate, the price of oil, even some decisions from the ECB.

- Mr. President, we saw in the CIS barometer that somehow the economic recovery is not yet being felt on the streets. Even the President of the European Commission, Jean-Claude Juncker, clarified that, even if there is recovery, the crisis will not be over until we overcome unemployment figures that are still very serious.

- Let's see, the two statements are compatible. That is to say, in Spain there is an economic recovery because last year, for the first time in six years, we grew by 1.4% of GDP and for the first time in six years, net jobs were created: 450,000 people found work. There are also data that show that this recovery is real: the increase in consumption, investment, the recovery of car sales, mortgages, and housing. But having said that, we will not have reached the great national objective until we end unemployment. In the State of the Nation Debate, I said that in Spain we need to have 20 million jobs again. That can be achieved, and that is the goal.

- You did not set a deadline, but you spoke of creating a million jobs between 2014 and 2015, and there would be about two million left.

- Last year, 450,000 jobs were created, growing by 1.4%. This year, in which the growth forecast is 2.4%, it should be around 550,000. So, between the last two years of the legislature, 2014 and 2015, a million, and from then on, if we do things right and continue with the reforms, the rest can be created until we reach 20 million in the next legislature.

- But the feeling on the street is that those jobs are not of good quality. The jobs being created are not the jobs that existed before the crisis.

- The first thing to make clear is that creating 450,000 jobs is a good thing. And the second is that I, of course, am not satisfied. And I believe that we need to return to 20 million jobs and that it can be achieved. From there, 75% of the people who work in Spain have a permanent contract, and it is good to be aware of that. That is to say, we are in a better situation than we were a few years ago. What we also have now are part-time permanent contracts, which we would like to gradually turn into full-time permanent contracts for those who want them, but I think the important thing is to have employment and that this employment is good. But it is very complicated to achieve everything at once because we have been through a truly terrible time in Spain.

- Were you surprised that in the unemployment data for February, which was quite good, construction rose so much?

- Well, look, I was not surprised because construction reached truly dramatic job loss figures. But I announced last year that in 2015 construction was going to grow. Well, I did not announce it; it was the data from the Bank of Spain itself, and I had some conversations with the sector, and they told me that they were indeed going to grow, and in fact, the increase in Social Security affiliates has been very positive.

- And what is your assessment of the fact that registered unemployment in Spain as a whole decreased while it increased in Andalusia?

- Regarding Andalusia, I would like to say several things. One I already mentioned, and another I will tell you now. The objective I set for Andalusia, and which I believe can be achieved by doing things right, is that 575,000 jobs must be created. In fact, last year more than 100,000 jobs were already created. So, it is possible to achieve that in this time, between these two years and the next, the 575,000. But there is a challenge that I believe should be the great objective of Andalusia, but of everyone: the Government of Spain, the Andalusian Government, the municipalities, the business organizations, and the unions. Andalusia must make an effort to reach the level of the rest of Spain in unemployment. That is to say, we need to set a growth of another half a million additional jobs, and that is the objective we are going to work on.

- And why do you think it is so difficult to achieve that convergence? We maintain a differential of unemployment with respect to Spain of 10 points, but also in a nearly traditional way.

- We must be ambitious, and when some policies do not work, we must make others. Nowadays, employment depends on many things: it depends on what the Government of Spain does, it depends on what the regional governments do, and on society itself, that there are entrepreneurs, people willing to take risks, that there is credit. I believe that by working together and pulling in the same direction, we could achieve the objective.

- The President of the Junta has asked you several times for a special plan from the central government for Andalusia, precisely because of that unemployment differential.

- We have dedicated a lot of resources to Andalusia in terms of unemployment in these three years of the legislature. It is 2 billion euros, and all our policy has been dedicated to job creation. Now, of course, it is a bit harsh that the money for active employment policies in Andalusia is not dedicated to that. I am not going to enter into controversies, but that last year the vast majority of the funds dedicated to active employment policies were not spent seems to me, well...

- And why was it not spent? Could it be that the Junta is an administration somewhat intervened judicially due to the ERE case?

- I do not know why it was not spent, but the other communities did spend it.

- Mr. President, there is a request that has been made a lot from Andalusia, which is the reform of the regional financing system. There was also a commitment at that Conference of Presidents to at least test how this was going.

- Yes. Let's see. The regional financing agreement of 2009 had my vote against it. It could not be done in this legislature. Plain and simple because we did not have money. For that reason. The priority was what it was, and it was what I told you. The priority was the crisis, and second, to resolve those problems of the Autonomous Liquidity Fund and payment to suppliers. So it is like so many things in life: a ruler has two things to make decisions about, their priorities and their times.

- In the next legislature, will we see a change in the financing model?

- Yes.

- And do we have any criteria?

- No. It is very premature... The most important thing about the regional financing model is that there is an agreement. That is the most important thing. Because then everything is open to opinion. Everyone believes that they have not been treated as well as others. But that happens to all 17. There is no other way to solve it than with an agreement. The fundamental thing is that we do not lose the concept of solidarity among Spaniards. And I believe that is the great principle that must be preserved in Spain.

- Sometimes, you have referred from the podium of the Congress of Deputies to the condition of former presidents Manuel Chaves and José Antonio Griñán. Do you also believe they should resign since they are under indictment?

- The pace of the debates is set by the opposition. That said, if we want to talk seriously about this issue, the first thing is that all those who have been involved in corruption cases must be removed by the parties; second, we must let the judges and courts act, and they are doing so; they are independent. And third, we must pass laws, and I believe that an important effort has been made in this legislature to prevent it and make it more difficult. But I want to add that I believe that sending a bad message by trying to disqualify the entire political class is not good. I have been in this for many years, I have seen many people from many parties who are as honest and decent as anyone else. And this dynamic of presenting the political class as something abominable seems to me to be unfair and also false.

- But, Mr. President, Spain has a problem. In its image projection, it has a problem with corruption.

- Yes, Spain has a problem with corruption, but Spain is very well viewed abroad today. I also do not want to get into things that have happened in other countries, but that is a topic on which we must make an effort, where the level of demand must be higher, but where there must also be a certain balance and an attempt to be fair when making a global assessment.

- But do you think that this has been exaggerated in Spain by the media?

- No, what I believe is that there are a lot of people, the vast majority, who are dedicated to this doing what is in their power, which they can evidently make mistakes, to do things well. That there are people who have done things they should not have done and who are corrupt. That the courts are acting. That the parties must be demanding and make it difficult for corruption.

- After these four years, have you not had the temptation to throw in the towel, to give up?

- Well, no. That is to say, I have been in political life for years and I have some experience. I have lived through difficult circumstances from a political point of view. I was in opposition for eight years. And for me, it was an honor to become the President of the Government of Spain. It is true that I did not expect to find what I found. I knew things were bad, but within 10 days I had to raise taxes. And then, in July... Now things are seen differently, but enduring the enormous pressures to avoid having to request a bailout was not easy.

- Did you always have it clear?

- I always had it clear. Because it was the liquidation of the economic sovereignty of a country.

- Were there people within our own country who pressured you in that sense?

- Certainly. A lot of people, but why should we go into details? There were some who had to lower pensions by 20%... right? Maintaining economic sovereignty was costly because we were all day focused on the new auction. It was not an easy moment.

- Despite having done all this, you have defended that the great social achievement of your Government was to avoid intervention. But a tough labor reform is coming, tax increases are coming... Is there a need for any more structural reform in the current situation in Spain?

- I will explain to you why the best social policy decision was to avoid the bailout. Because that allowed us not to lower pensions, something that others were forced to do.

- Would the situation allow for tax changes again in the next legislature?

- There may even be something in this legislature related to entrepreneurs. My way of being is not to have high taxes. Of course, the circumstances also condition the activity of a politician, right? The objective, what is it? To have employment. Because people work and pay taxes, and they also consume. And that is revenue. The drama, which sometimes we have not realized in Spain, of the years 2008 and 2009, was the increase in unemployment and the 70 billion euros that were not collected. We are talking about 11 trillion pesetas, an astronomical figure. Imagine what we could do with that amount.

NOTE: Interview published with the authorization of Grupo Joly.