Rajoy demands Puigdemont to renounce independence and avoid greater evils.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

5 October 2017

Context
Rajoy addressed a journalist interview on October 5, 2017, demanding Catalan leader Puigdemont abandon independence plans and return to constitutional legality.
Main themes
Catalan independence crisis, return to legality, unilateral declaration of independence, dialogue and mediation, rule of law, national unity of Spain, Puigdemont and Generalitat, King's address, Parliament of Catalonia, political normality
Duration
~32 min
85th percentile
Words
3,897
85th percentile
Sentences
177
86th percentile
Readability
51
67th percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
3.09
59th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
15th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 52%46%
  • Geopolitical 19%16%
  • Economic 17%15%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Social 4%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 12%

177 sentences in 60 paragraphs

Mr. President, all of Spain is very, very concerned these days about the events in Catalonia, and logically, you are even more so. Do you see any possibility of a solution to this crisis?

President.- Yes, but the best solution, and I believe we all share this, is a return to legality, which means that all those individuals and leaders who have decided on their own and at their own risk to liquidate the law and place themselves outside of it must return to legality. This involves abandoning the project to make a unilateral declaration of independence and complying, as all citizens do, with legal provisions. This is what can prevent greater evils from occurring in the future, and this is what society as a whole is asking for: the editorials of the media, business leaders, trade unions, millions and millions of citizens from Catalonia and the rest of Spain.

If you ask me, do you have a solution? Yes, and the best one is a prompt return to legality and the affirmation, as quickly as possible, that there will be no unilateral declaration of independence because that will also prevent greater evils.

J.A. Vera.- Mr. Iglesias called you yesterday and conveyed his willingness to mediate between the State Government and the Generalitat. Do you see any possibility that this could be an appropriate avenue?

President.- Look, this is not a problem of mediation. You referred to Mr. Iglesias… and many other people, many with good intentions. But this is not a problem of mediation; this is a problem of complying with the law, and what those who are not complying with it must do is comply. From there, we would already be living in a situation of normality. We could talk, we could dialogue, and we could reach agreements, in Parliament or outside of it. What this is fundamentally about is returning to legality and returning to a situation of normality, and that can only be done by those who have violated the law and who have established a situation of this nature.

But, of course, mediating on the unity of Spain... The unity of Spain is not subject to any mediation or negotiation. Therefore, what I hope, as I pointed out earlier, is a return to legality, which is a return to normality. And from there, we can talk, dialogue, in Parliament, in one way or another…

J.A. Vera.- You know, Mr. President, that you are accused by certain sectors of being a person who does not want to engage in dialogue on this matter. In reality, if that return to legality were to occur, would you be willing to meet again with Puigdemont?

President.- I have always expressed my support for dialogue. However, I am not in favor of dialogue to violate the law or dialogue to liquidate national unity because I believe there is nothing to discuss on that matter, nor do we have anything to negotiate.

From there, if Mr. Puigdemont positions himself within legality, we would obviously be in a different situation; but I believe that the first dialogue Mr. Puigdemont must engage in is with the deputies of the Parliament of Catalonia, whom he did not allow to express their opinions in those two plenary sessions that took place on the 6th and 7th, when in a matter of hours he decided to eliminate the Spanish Constitution from Catalonia, the Statute of Catalonia, and approve what is a new constitution, the Law of Transitoriness.

That is the dialogue that must be recovered: first, the dialogue in the Parliament of Catalonia and respect for the rights of all deputies, and then, the dialogue, first and foremost, with the Catalans who have been divided to a truly dramatic situation, as we have seen in recent days. That is the first dialogue.

J.A. Vera.- The President of the Generalitat said last night that the King has disappointed many Catalans. What do you think of the criticisms that have been made of His Majesty the King regarding the fact that he did not explicitly mention the word "dialogue"?

President.- The King has made a magnificent intervention and has done what is expected of a head of state. What he has asked for, essentially, is what the vast majority of Spanish society is asking for, which is that we all, starting with the leaders, comply with the law, because this is a rule of law and we all have the obligation to do so, and certainly, the leaders have even more reason to do so.

The King asked for a return to normality. The King was critical of the situation that has arisen in recent times due to some individuals in Catalonia because, quite simply, liquidating the Constitution of a country that has existed for forty years, which has been agreed upon by all, in three hours, by a minimal majority and without having the competencies to do so, is absurd.

Therefore, the King has said very sensible things. The vast majority of Spaniards felt reassured by his words and fully embrace them. Not to speak of dialogue? It is understood: dialogue is something that is practiced every day in Parliament and that is practiced every day in democratic regimes. What cannot happen is a dialogue under the threat of blackmail, and much less when we are talking about national unity.

J.A. Vera.- Mr. President, the former Vice President of the Socialist Government, Alfonso Guerra, made statements yesterday that have been widely circulated in the media in which, among other things, he labeled the Government of the Generalitat as "fascist" and "coup-plotting." Do you share Mr. Guerra's opinions?

President.- I am not going to get into name-calling. The only thing I want to do is thank Mr. Guerra, who is a person who served as Vice President of the Government for some years, for his loyalty to the Spanish Constitution, in which he participated, and his loyalty to Spain, which is his nation.

J.A. Vera.- Mr. Guerra, Mr. President, also said that one of the problems is that your Government, and specifically you, "do not know -- he said verbatim -- how to make decisions" with the speed that is supposed, or some people say, should be taken. You are also being reproached by some sectors, Mr. President, for trailing behind the independence supporters and not taking the initiative. Does the Government plan to act to prevent a unilateral declaration of independence from Catalonia, or will it wait for the Generalitat to declare that independence before acting?

President.- I will tell you one thing: we will not allow under any circumstances the independence of Catalonia, and I can already tell you that this will not happen. You can have total and absolute certainty.

From there, what needs to be done, how and when we need to do it is something that many people have opinions about; the majority of people, with good intentions. They have different opinions: some believe that a decision must be made, others think that another must be made, some say it must be made before the plenary session on Monday in the Parliament, others after… In other words, there are opinions for all tastes. However, I tell you that we will not allow the independence of Catalonia and that this will not happen, and that the Government knows perfectly well what it will do in any of the scenarios, how it will do it, and when it will do it, because it is our obligation.

Therefore, I ask for calm and for there to be confidence in the Government on an important issue, where we handle a lot of data, a lot of information, and where it is clear that we coincide with the vast majority of people.

That will not happen. From there, opinions are free. I talk to many people, they give me their opinions, some are different and others are in another way; but rest assured that the Government knows perfectly how to handle this situation.

J.A. Vera.- And do you believe, Mr. President, does the Government believe, that there is any solution that could be better than applying Article 155?

President.- Absolutely. The best is a return to legality and for those who have trampled over it to position themselves where all normal people in advanced and civilized democracies are. To say that there will be no unilateral declaration of independence and, I insist, to do it as quickly as possible. That is the best solution because it is the one that returns us to normality and is in the hands of those who have broken the legality and those who have liquidated the situation of normal functioning of any democracy.

J.A. Vera.- In any case, Mr. President, and I apologize for insisting, are you willing, if necessary, to apply Article 155 of the Constitution? In this regard, I remind you that some say that if it is done after the proclamation of independence, what is called the DUI, next Monday, which is when it is said it could happen, we would be too late if that application is made afterward.

President.- What I tell you is that we will not be late to any place because the independence of Catalonia will not occur. We will not allow it. From there, I insist, there are many opinions: some believe it should be done before; others, after; others, never, and others that other decisions should be made. But it is logical because it is a matter that concerns, that matters, that affects, and that people feel. We are talking about our nation, Spain, our country, and many people have ideas and convey them to the Government; but they must trust the Government.

We have all the data and know perfectly what needs to be done. Everything is open to opinion, but what is important is to achieve the objective, and the objective is to return to legality, to return to normality as quickly as possible and, of course, to continue, as for so many centuries, being one of the most important countries in the world and living together.

J.A. Vera.- You know that Mr. Rivera and his party, Ciudadanos, have proposed the application of Article 155 to call elections in Catalonia. Do you think that could be a good solution?

President.- That is one of the many suggestions that have been made to me; he made it to me personally. Then others came to me who told me exactly the opposite and others with a different approach. We are, as I tell you, at a moment where it is logical for everyone to have their opinion and their criteria. Everyone knows or thinks that what needs to be done is, logically, what they defend. But, well, it is undoubtedly an opinion that I respect and that I consider; but it is one more, in this case made by a political representative, among many others. But there are people, I insist, who have a radically different approach.

What I hope is that the Government, which we are working on, gets it right. I believe we will do so, and I hope to have support from Mr. Rivera's party, from the Socialist Party, from other political forces, and from the whole of Spanish society.

J.A. Vera.- You know, Mr. President, that the State Security Forces have been accused of having acted with excessive harshness last Sunday, and on the other hand, these same State Security Forces are being harassed, so much so that in some places they are even being pressured to leave the places where they are residing. Two questions in this regard: Do you recognize any error in the State's actions last Sunday? Secondly, will the State Security Forces have to leave the places where they are in Catalonia?

President.- I have already given the order that they do not leave any hotel. They will leave when they have to leave because, logically, the deployment was planned for a few days in some cases and for a little longer in others; but, of course, no one will leave, no one, due to the pressure of absolutely anyone. I find it an absolutely shameful and intolerable act. Therefore, you can have absolute certainty. I have given orders to the Ministry of the Interior stating that under no circumstances should anyone leave, unless, logically, they have to leave for reasons unrelated to threats.

I must say that the actions of the State Security Forces, the Police and the Civil Guard, on October 1st were exemplary actions. It is evident that there has been a great campaign, but it was an exemplary action. It was done and acted with rigor and professionalism. They have been harassed and provoked. It is very difficult to maintain composure in a situation like that when there were thousands of people in different areas of Catalonia. I must say, and I have conveyed this to their commanders and to the Minister of the Interior, that I am proud of the Spanish State Security Forces.

J.A. Vera.- Have you been surprised by the actions of the Mossos d'Esquadra? Have you lost confidence in this police force?

President.- The actions that some have initiated in Catalonia have led to an enormous division in Catalan society, an enormous division. They have also divided the Mossos, but they have done great damage to the image of the Mossos. The damage has been done by those who have initiated this entire operation and those who later sought to use them.

In any case, the Mossos were under the orders of the judicial authority; they were not under the orders of the Government on October 1st, and it is the judicial authority that will have to determine whether or not it agrees with the actions of the Mossos and who will have to make, if necessary, the decisions they deem most appropriate.

But, I insist, going as always to the greater point, their image has been damaged by those who have initiated this disloyal operation.

J.A. Vera.- Mr. President, are you willing, as requested by the Socialist Party, to review the Constitution for a better accommodation or a different accommodation of Catalonia within the State? In that sense, what is your opinion on the position that the Socialist Party has been adopting in recent moments regarding this crisis? Do you fear that a rift may open in the Socialist Party with decisions such as the one that has been made regarding the Vice President of the Government?

President.- I am not going to reproach those who essentially agree, which is to comply with the Law and defend the unity of Spain. Therefore, I will not reproach the Socialist Party, Ciudadanos, or other political forces that are acting in loyalty to the Law.

I believe that the request for censure is not fair; I believe it makes no sense; but, logically, everyone makes their own decisions.

You also raise the issue of reforming the Constitution. That is another of the proposals that have been made. Earlier, you asked me about the proposal made by Ciudadanos, and now about the proposal from the PSOE. There are many people. And we have talked about others who want a mediator. In short, this is a topic where, logically, everyone has their own criteria and position. I must say that what I am not in favor of is trading favors, and I apologize for using this expression. To say "let's appoint a mediator and now, in exchange for me making a decision, you make another," no, because the unity of Spain and compliance with the Law cannot be negotiated.

From there, I have never refused to talk about reforming the Constitution. Moreover, that initiative can be taken in the Cortes. Then, obviously, we will see the contents.

And I say this because I have never refused to talk about everything that our laws allow and using the procedures to change them, because laws can also be changed. But if we do not respect the Law, we enter the realm of arbitrariness, injustice, and, what is more dangerous, the law of the strongest, and that is exactly the opposite of democracy and the rights of citizens.

J.A. Vera.- Mr. Rajoy, in addition to the concern about the political situation in Catalonia, there is also concern these days about the consequences it may have in the economic sphere. We have seen a very strong drop in the stock markets, the risk premium is rising in a somewhat worrying way, and there is also the panic regarding the possibility of some problem with Catalan banks. Do you fear, Mr. President, that the economic recovery due to the Catalan crisis could go to waste? Do you not fear a capital flight in Catalonia?

President.- With absolute frankness, a situation of instability like this is very bad for the economy of a country. Anyone can understand that. In other words, nothing is worse for the economy than political instability. A situation of this nature is worse than political instability. And there are already some data that, indeed, I do not like and that are very negative. Indeed, there have already been companies that have decided to change their registered office, and we have read and seen that in the media over the past few days.

But, of course, when in a country some rulers decide to bypass legality, from there, things are necessarily going to get worse. It is impossible for nothing to happen, much less for things to get better. When the Law is bypassed, when there are riots in the streets, when the State Security Forces are harassed, when threats are made, as has happened with journalists, and when the opposition is not allowed to speak in Parliament, a situation is generated that evidently brings bad consequences. But not just bad; they will get worse. Therefore, the longer it takes to say "we end this situation and submit to the rule of Law," as happens in all European democracies, the worse it will be for everyone.

J.A. Vera.- Have you felt supported by the International Community, especially by the European Union, regarding the whole issue of Catalonia? Puigdemont has warned that what happens to him in Catalonia could also extend to other regions in Europe. Do you think that will also influence, in some way, the image of the Generalitat abroad?

President.- Making such a statement gives one pause, because, of course, to announce that, in addition to what Mr. Puigdemont is doing, this could happen throughout Europe is tantamount to telling the world, "Hey, let's throw everything out the window, let's break Europe and see what we do in the future."

I tell you one thing with absolute frankness: one of the basic principles of what today is the European Union is the rule of law, respect for the Law, and the guarantee of the individual rights of citizens. This is what is being liquidated by some with the proposals they are making in Catalonia.

And that, of course, is supported by Europe. I have received calls from practically all European leaders, and I continued this morning talking with some people. I spoke with the British Prime Minister, the German Chancellor, the President of the French Republic, the President of the European Commission... Yesterday there was a debate in the European Parliament where it was stated very clearly that the Law must be complied with and where it was also stated very clearly that there was no referendum last Sunday and that everything that was done is not valid. Things that we all knew and that are obvious, but it is good that they are also endorsed from outside.

No one in their right mind can support a situation of this nature where the Law is liquidated, everyone does what they want, and if someone disagrees, I go after them. That is not democracy; that is a very serious attack against the basic principles of democracy.

J.A. Vera.- What is your opinion, Mr. President, of the attitude maintained by Lehendakari Urkullu regarding the Catalan crisis? Do you think it is possible to convince the PNV under the current circumstances to support the Budgets, for example?

President.- I believe that the Lehendakari sincerely wants this to be resolved in a reasonable manner. I see it that way. Another thing is that we may have the same opinion or the same criteria.

Regarding the Budgets, I believe that the Budgets have nothing to do with the situation that is occurring in Catalonia. Therefore, we will present our Budget project in the coming days and will try to obtain sufficient support, as happened last year, to push it forward. They are very important to consolidate the recovery and to help ensure that employment, which is growing in Spain, does so at the same pace over the next few years and that we achieve twenty million Spaniards working, which is the challenge we have set for this Legislature. Employment is growing. Approximately five hundred thousand Spaniards find a job each year. We need, at least, three more years creating five hundred thousand jobs a year to be in a position to definitively consolidate the recovery.

J.A. Vera.- Mr. President, to conclude. We began this interview by saying that there is great concern, because there is, among the citizens regarding the situation in Catalonia. Do we have reasons for hope? Do you see that there may be reasons for hope? Do you see it possible to return to a scenario of normality?

President.- Absolutely. Yes, I believe so. Spain is a country that throughout its history has experienced very difficult, very complicated situations; we were able to move forward, and today, as I told you before, we are one of the most important countries in the world: the 12th largest economy in the world.

We have overcome, even while I was President of the Government, extreme circumstances, because at the end of 2011, when we came to power, and in 2012, Spain was on the brink of bankruptcy. No one would lend us money; there were Autonomous Communities that could not access the markets, and the State had to come to their rescue. Everyone said that Europe was going to rescue Spain and that we were going to be placed in a situation like Greece. We were living through an economic crisis with five consecutive years of negative economic growth.

Well, the Spanish people were able to resolve that situation. I remember that many people were telling me what I had to do. Many people told me: "What you have to do is accept the bailout and put yourself at their orders, and you have to do it now." At that moment, I did what I believed I should do, and now, because it is my duty, because that is why I am the President of the Government of Spain, I will do what I believe I should do, what I believe is best for Spain and at the moment that seems most appropriate to me.

I will listen to everyone, but the decision is mine. I know it is not easy, but I also had to make another decision at the time that was not easy either.

J.A. Vera.- Thank you very much, Mr. President, and good luck.

President.- Thank you very much.