Interview with the President of the Government on the program "Hoy por hoy," from Cadena SER.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

27 October 2015 · Interview on the program "Hoy por hoy" on Cadena SER

Context
Rajoy was interviewed on Cadena SER's 'Hoy por hoy' program on October 27, 2015, amid a Catalan independence resolution presented to the regional parliament.
Main themes
Catalan independence crisis, constitutional legality, Spanish unity, government response to separatism, unilateral declaration of independence, rule of law, national sovereignty, legal instruments, Catalan parliament resolution, proportionality in governance
Duration
~87 min
98th percentile
Words
10,396
98th percentile
Sentences
610
99th percentile
Readability
65
94th percentile
Grade
8.2
6th percentile
Syntax
2.73
15th percentile
Vocabulary
1.94
5th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

610 sentences in 257 paragraphs

Pepa Bueno: Good morning.

President: Good morning.

P. Bueno: Welcome to Cadena SER.

President: Thank you very much.

P. Bueno: What is happening in Catalonia, Mr. President, is it an institutional coup d'état?

President: I believe that what is happening in Catalonia is something of enormous gravity, because a resolution proposal has been presented that, if put into practice, would mean liquidating our constitutional norm and our entire legal system. Therefore, it is something of enormous gravity, and what I have to say about this matter, to all Spaniards, is that the Government knows what it has to do, that in no way will they achieve those objectives, and that, of course, the unity of Spain is preserved; national sovereignty, too, and the absence of privileges for some, as well. The law will be applied; it is the expression of the popular will, and the Government will not hesitate, at all, to make the decisions it has to make.

P. Bueno: President Rajoy, this morning on SER. We will continue talking in a few minutes.

P. Bueno: I understand, Mr. President, that prudence is very necessary at this moment, but what do you mean when you say "I will do everything I have to do, with all the instruments at my disposal, to prevent a unilateral declaration of independence in Catalonia"? What do you mean?

President: I mean that Spanish laws, starting with the Constitution itself and all the rest of our legal system, have sufficient instruments for the Government to guarantee the unity of Spain, national sovereignty, that is, the right of all Spaniards to decide what their country is, and equality among all Spaniards.

Therefore, there are sufficient instruments, and what I must say is that, with proportionality, and seeing how events unfold, the Government will prevent the realization of the claims set forth in the document that was delivered yesterday at the Parliament's Table.

P. Bueno: To be specific, will the Government challenge that document before it is approved in the Parliament, as Ciudadanos is asking, or will it wait until it has been approved?

President: We will challenge it whenever the legal services of the Government tell us that it is appropriate to do so. For now, what exists is a document presented at the Parliament's Table, and today our party in Catalonia will ask the Table to revoke it. In the event that it is not revoked at the Table, if our legal services recommend filing the challenge, we will do so. That is to say, we are not going to act with anxiety, challenging everything that comes to mind...; no, things are first studied, and then decisions are made. It is done calmly to avoid mistakes or overreacting.

What I have to say is that the Government guarantees and tells all Spaniards: be calm because the claims of the independence supporters in Catalonia will not succeed because they contravene Spanish legislation.

P. Bueno: But we have been hearing that for the last three years, Mr. President, and the "roadmap" of the independence supporters has been fulfilled time and again until we reach the moment we are in, where a unilateral declaration of independence is going to occur next week, because they announce that they will not obey Spanish laws and they have a majority of seats.

President: That what the independence supporters wanted has been fulfilled is not true, because the requests made to me were, first, a system like the Concierto or the Convenio, the so-called Fiscal Pact, and I said no and told them to take it to the Cortes Generales. Then, I was asked for authorization to hold a referendum, I took it to the Cortes and we said no. Therefore, none of the claims of those groups have been fulfilled, which is not the same as saying that they have been fulfilled.

P. Bueno: Their alternative "roadmap" has been fulfilled.

President: Well, their alternative roadmap... They have continued to do things, but none of them have succeeded: neither the Fiscal Pact has succeeded, nor has that referendum they wanted to hold with legal effects, which the farce we saw on that day had none. And what I say is that, just as the fiscal pact did not succeed, just as that referendum that liquidated national sovereignty was not held, what is stated in the document they presented yesterday in Parliament will not be fulfilled. I tell people to be calm and not to rush. I understand that everyone wants to say things, political parties, let's see if this is so or otherwise..., but the Government knows very well what it has to do, as has been demonstrated with these two very important examples I have given.

P. Bueno: Yes, but we Spaniards also have the right to know what your forecast is in the announced case that a directive from the Constitutional Court, a ruling, is disobeyed in Catalonia. It says so in the paper.

President: It is to apply the law.

P. Bueno: And what is applying the law?

President: Applying the law is what the Spanish Constitution says, and applying the law is to implement the reform law of the Constitutional Court that we presented in the Cortes not long ago and which, by the way, received criticism from some. Therefore, it is to apply the law. That is what we are going to do. We are not going to go into details about what happens in the event that one thing happens or another.

P. Bueno: I ask you about one thing and another, Mr. President. Please continue.

President: We are going to apply the law and we are not going to go into details. I tell you, so far all their claims have been seen nowhere. By the way, with the criticisms of some who also said: "hey, negotiate, negotiate." What am I going to negotiate? The Fiscal Pact? That they hold the referendum or this declaration they have now put forward to the Cortes Generales?

I tell you, be calm, anxiety does not solve problems, and as events unfold, we will have to provide answers, always with prudence and proportionality, but also with firmness and determination. And that is what I guarantee I will do.

P. Bueno: When they asked you for negotiation on the Fiscal Pact, on issues unrelated to sovereignty and independence, there was a percentage of independence supporters that has doubled with the political inaction of the central Government, Mr. President. The political problem we have today is much more serious than it was then, when you did not reach any agreement. Not that they granted it to you, but that you could have used that negotiation to open a channel of dialogue, which would have prevented us from being on the brink of an unconstitutional secession right now.

President: I was not presented with any negotiation. I was presented with a contract of adhesion; that is, "here, either there is a Fiscal Pact or I go to the referendum." I said: there is no Fiscal Pact. Referendum? There has not been a referendum either.

Then there is something that is important and that we should all take into account, because now I am already seeing what is going to happen and I am already seeing what some are doing: let's see if we can blame some or others, everyone wants to fish in troubled waters... But the responsible parties for what is happening here are none of the political forces, nor any of the vast majority of Spanish citizens, nor any of the millions of Spaniards who defend the Constitution, the law, national sovereignty, and the equality of Spaniards. Those, no; the true responsible parties --it is important not to confuse adversaries-- are those who want to liquidate, in a democratic country and in the 21st century, a Constitution like the Spanish one. Those are the true responsible parties, and the law will be applied to them, and in no way will they be allowed to get away with it.

Therefore, let us not confuse who has responsibility and who does not have responsibility. The responsibility lies with those who are proposing the liquidation of Spanish legislation. It is profoundly undemocratic and something unworthy of a country like Spain. It has nothing to do with what the European Union is, a space of civilization, of freedom, where the law and the rule of law prevail above any other consideration. That is the adversary, and that is who must be criticized.

P. Bueno: That said, you are the President of the Government of Spain, also of the Catalans, including those who want to leave. Mr. President, did you analyze the twenty-three points that Artur Mas delivered to you on July 30, 2014, just a year ago? The issues raised there were unrelated to the sovereignty consultation; they were presented by the legal representative of the Catalan people. Did you review that list of twenty-three points?

President: Yes. And in some, there was agreement, and some have already been fulfilled, and in others, there was no agreement.

But let us not deceive ourselves, eh! Let us not dig into the past now. What was presented to me --I was there--, and in many hours of conversation was that I should create a system that went against the equality of all Spaniards. And I even spoke with the Secretary General of the Socialist Party: hey, how do you see the Fiscal Pact? "Well, very badly." And I told Mr. Mas: please present it in the Cortes, as they are the ones who have national sovereignty; present it yourself. And he said to me: "no, you present it because you are the President of the Government." And I said: I am not going to present something I do not believe in and that, moreover, the Cortes will not approve.

The same happened with the referendum. It is not a problem of twenty-three, nor of a road, nor of a shuttle, the train from the airport and so on; no, the real problem is, either the Fiscal Pact, or the referendum. I could not accept both, and the margin for negotiation was none. And the responsible party is not the one who defends the law and the Constitution, but the one who seeks to liquidate it.

P. Bueno: That is clear, Mr. President.

President: I am glad that it is clear.

P. Bueno: We are not going to discuss who initiated the process of an unconstitutional secession. I ask you, as the President of the Government, if that list of twenty-three points, if the opportunities that have existed, that one, the most recent, to bring together all the democratic forces of Spain and put them in a sense of negotiation, in technical committees, in Congress, in the Senate... Because the soufflé was not going down, Mr. Rajoy. We all saw that the number of independence supporters continued to grow, and you said: it will go down, it will go down, it will go down. It has not gone down, Mr. President. We have two million votes from Spaniards who do not want to be. Do you feel that you have any responsibility in that reality?

President: The responsibility, probably, lies with everyone; but, of course, the most important responsibility lies with those who want to liquidate the law, which is what I want to make clear here. They are the ones who have the most important responsibility.

Then, there are responsibilities from everyone. What I do not know is whether it makes sense for me to start talking about the decisions made by the tripartite government, which was presided over by a socialist allied with Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya and with Iniciativa per Catalunya. What I do not know if it makes any sense is for me to start debating, turning it over, analyzing why the Socialist Party of Catalonia, which always won, and with a large majority, elections in Catalonia, then began to lose votes for not defending the classic positions of its voters.

That is to say, does that make any sense today? It makes no sense.

P. Bueno: No, because we could also talk about how the PP has fallen.

President: No, but we have always had the votes we have had, Pepa. Let us not deceive ourselves. Let us be constructive and look to the future.

P. Bueno: We need to know what has happened to know what we need to fix. What does the President of the Government, what does candidate Rajoy, have for the two million Spaniards who want to stop being so in Catalonia?

President: Well, look, I have, first of all, history. Spain is the oldest nation in Europe, five centuries living together, and problems like this in Catalonia are not the first time they have arisen.

P. Bueno: But if we are going to talk about the future, Mr. President, not about history.

President: Yes, but that is important, because in history are the emotional ties, for example; there are commercial ties; the unions between people; there are hundreds of thousands of people who came from other parts of Spain to Catalonia and helped build Catalonia: many Galicians --I am Galician, as you know--, many Andalusians; many Extremadurans --you are from Extremadura--, many people. Many people who married Catalans and with people who were not Catalans. Catalans who live in Madrid or in other places in Spain. Commercial relationships unite us, our history unites us, and the last forty years, the Spanish Constitution. Spain, the country, of the five in the world, where per capita income has grown the most in the last forty years.

The European project unites us. Why should a Catalan now stop being Spanish and European? It makes no sense, being able to be Catalan, Spanish, and European. A future unites us, which is European integration, and the direction of the world unites us. The world is moving towards processes of integration. What is the European Union? Going towards processes of separation or division is characteristic of stages that are already very much surpassed. That is indeed characteristic of the past.

We are united by many things, and therefore, that is what we need to explain to the people. On the other hand, it is good to remember one thing, which is that in Catalonia there are many more Catalans than there are independence supporters, and many more non-independence supporters than independence supporters. Therefore, we also… We need to make an effort, yes, to convince everyone; but it is not about, at the cost of defending the independence supporters, abandoning the positions of those who are not independence supporters.

Q. Well.- Mr. President, you have talked to me about the past and you have talked to me about the European project, the global, world project. Do you renounce to win over the two million Catalans who want to stop being Spanish? Is there not even a specific Spanish project for them?

President.- Absolutely not. I do not renounce… Of course I have a Spanish project for them. The project for the next four years is to create two million jobs in Spain, and it can be done. Thanks to that, well-being and wealth will improve. The project is to continue the process of modernization of the country, with more R&D and with the Digital Agenda. The project is to continue in the process of European integration. We have established the Banking Union, we need to move towards Fiscal Union and Political Union. The project is to make Spain one of the leading powers in the world. Right now we are twelfth or thirteenth in per capita income, and we can be among the top ten if there is political stability, certainty, and we maintain an economic policy that allows us to grow. Of course there is a project.

Q. Well.- And a constitutional reform as, for example, Ciudadanos proposes, which could be your hypothetical government partner? Not just for this, eh! Not just for this, but also for this.

President.- I believe that constitutional reform… The Spanish Constitution was one of the great achievements of our history; I believe it, because it meant overcoming forty years of authoritarian regime. I believe it brought democracy, brought freedom, and brought human rights. It allowed us to reach Europe and it allowed us to progress in the last forty years like never before in our history.

Evidently, it can be reformed. Of course it can be reformed. In fact, we have already reformed it twice; but, of course, what I believe cannot be reformed is to give the independence supporters what they want. That is to say, if someone wants to touch the unity of Spain, national sovereignty, the rights of Spaniards, or the equality of Spaniards, I will be against it.

Q. Well.- Do you think that the Basque Concert does not break the equality of Spaniards? They have their own treasury and the rest do not?

President.- Yes, and the Navarre Agreement. Yes. That was a decision we made in 1978 by the vast majority of Spaniards and all political forces. It has been included in a Transitional Provision; it was something that was in History, even with Franco, Álava and Navarra had it; it was extended to Guipúzcoa and Bizkaia, and I am in favor at this moment of not opening that topic and of maintaining it.

Q. Well.- And in Spain in 2015, Mr. President, why can’t we reach an agreement, as was reached in 1978, and renew the norm that governs us? I am not saying in what sense, but to sit down and talk.

President.- You are not saying in what sense, but the important thing is to know in what sense.

Q. Well.- That is up to you, not to me, as I am a journalist. I ask.

President.- Not to me, because I have not proposed the reform. It is up to those who have proposed the reform. But, of course, if the objective… There are things that can be done: the succession in the Crown, of course that can be done; naming the Autonomous Communities, also; saying that we are already in Europe, also. But the issue, the important issue that is being talked about, is this and all these stories of federal Spain, which it already is in practice… It is very easy to say: I am going to reform the Constitution. You already have the headline, you already have the slogan. However, the problem is what is the content? Or, as you say, in what sense? Whoever wants to do it should say so. I, at this moment, have not proposed it.

Q. Well.- The rest of the parties are saying it. Have you not seen anything negotiable in what the PSOE proposes or in what Ciudadanos proposes? They are talking.

President.- What do they propose? Pepa, what do they propose?

Q. Well.- They are talking. Haven’t you read anything?

President.- How could I not have read it! But if you know what they propose, tell me.

Q. Well.- Yes, yes. A federal reform of Spain. But I ask the president of the Government, do not ask me. The questions are asked by journalists.

President.- It is that you are asking me. I have already told you…

Q. Well.- Have you found nothing attractive or negotiable in what the other parties are proposing?

President.- I have already told you that there are things that can indeed be done: naming the Autonomous Communities…

Q. Well.- In territorial matters, right?

President.- In territorial matters, there are some who are proposing that the State have more powers than it currently has, there are others who are proposing that the State have fewer powers than it currently has, and I say that at this moment I do not see that we are in a position to reach a great consensus. Because, of course, constitutional reform cannot be done by majority, right? That requires the vast majority of the Chamber, not an absolute majority, not even the majority of the large parties, the Popular Party and the Socialist Party. In fact, in the 1978 Constitution, there were United Left, or whatever it is called now, there was also Convergència i Unió, and there was practically all political forces.

What I say is that I do not close myself to that; but what I also want to say is that, of course, proposals like the one made yesterday, that of the independence of Catalonia, will not be resolved because we make a constitutional reform, unless someone wants to, in which case let them say so, that in that reform they will accept the proposals of these gentlemen. I, of course, say very clearly that no.

Q. Well.- To conclude, Mr. President, to move on to another issue, do you, as the president of the Government at this moment, and as a candidate for La Moncloa for the Popular Party, believe that only the application of the Law resolves the fracture we are seeing in Catalonia? Only the application of the law, that politically there is nothing to be done.

President.- No. That is what you say, not me. I say that the application of the Law is fundamental. That is to say, in what civilized country in the world, where we live, are there people questioning whether the application of the Law resolves it or not? The Law must be applied. If we are saying that the Law should not be applied, all the citizens who are listening to us at this moment, too.

And we can talk. What cannot be talked about, which is what I have told Mr. Mas in the multiple conversations I have had with him over the years, is about what belongs to the Spanish people. Not even in the national Parliament can sovereignty be liquidated. That corresponds to the people, and national unity corresponds to the Spanish people to vote if they do not want it, not to a part of the Spanish people, nor to the Parliament, much less to the president of the Government.

Therefore, I am not willing to talk about the equality of Spaniards, about the fundamental rights of Spaniards, about the right of Spaniards to decide on what their country is, and about the unity of Spain. About everything else, yes.

Q. Well.- Do you regret, Mr. President, not having tried earlier the left hand, the skill, the intelligence, which, as you said on Televisión Española, the situation in Catalonia requires? Do you regret having traveled Spain collecting signatures against the Statute of 2006?

President.- I was radically against the Statute of 2006, others were in favor. The Statute was on the verge of not being approved. A great effort was made for it to be approved, but, as the Constitutional Court said, the Statute contravened what the Constitution said, and in the end, listen, if we have a norm, it is advisable that we observe it because, if not, we enter a different stage that I certainly do not wish for Spain. I believe in the rule of law.

Q. Well.- Is it the greatest failure of your Government to leave to the next one a territorially broken Spain, with a declaration of secession?

President.- I aspire to be the one who presides over the next one. But Spain is not territorially broken. Spain, at this moment, is a country that is recovering economically, that continues to advance in the process of European integration; a country of which we can be proud of many things; that still has to improve because there are still many people in difficult situations, and that at this moment has a problem, but the one who has generated it is the one who has generated it. That is important because sometimes one has the feeling that there are those who take advantage of anything to see if we can "zap" someone.

Q. Well.- No, Mr. President. When we have a representative of the independence supporters here, we ask them, and when we have the president of the Government of Spain, we want to know if the Constitutional Court disqualifies, removes functions from those who break the Spanish rule of law from now on in Catalonia, and there they disobey, what is the Government of Spain going to do.

President.- Everything that the Constitutional Court does, of course, I respect, I comply with, and it must be fulfilled.

Q. Well.- And if it is not complied with, will you apply Article 155?

President.- Well, I would not like to reach that. Frankly, I would not like to reach that. I believe that responses… When governing, especially, but in any facet of life, one must act with prudence and proportionality. Therefore, I will try to ensure that it does not come to that.

Q. Well.- When you say "while I am President of the Government, I guarantee the unity of Spain," do you mean that Pedro Sánchez, Albert Rivera, or Pablo Iglesias do not guarantee it?

President.- No, not at all. I suppose they do too. I, of course, speak for myself; not for them, as is natural.

Q. Well.- But this is a matter of State, not of party, nor of you. You are aware of that, I mean. Will you summon them? Will you meet with them?

President.- But I am the president of the Government. Yes, I am going to meet. I spoke with Pedro Sánchez yesterday and I have also spoken with Mr. Rivera. I have no objection to talking to everyone, and we will do so over the coming days.

Q. Well.- With Podemos too?

President.- Also, although, of course, Podemos' proposal is in favor of the right to self-determination and the liquidation of national sovereignty. If they change their mind, I will be very happy, but defending those proposals, you will understand that it does not generate great enthusiasm for almost anyone.

Q. Well.- Are you telling me that you will summon them? Will you call them to La Moncloa?

President.- Yes. I already spoke with some of them yesterday and I will continue talking with them.

Q. Well.- But are you announcing a meeting or not, Mr. President?

President.- I will announce it after it takes place.

Q. Well.- Have you spoken with the King?

President.- Yes, of course.

Q. Well.- After yesterday?

President.- Yes, of course.

Q. Well.- Is His Majesty worried?

President.- It does not seem reasonable to publicize my conversations with the King.

Q. Well.- Speaking of the economy, Mr. President, and the legacy that you or your successors will receive, what the Spaniards decide…

President.- That’s right. What the Spaniards decide. You have done very well there.

Q. Well.- Why do you insist on saying that Spain is the country that grows the most in the European Union? Because that is not the case. We are not. I have the data here.

President.- Are you going to bring up Latvia and…?

Q.- Well.- No. I tell you, we are fifth in the European Union, third in the Eurozone, and sixth in the G-20. With a country that grows, as ours does, after a recession, that grows a lot, should we exaggerate?

President.- No. Spain in 2012 had negative economic growth and in 2011 and 2013. In 2012 we were on the verge of rescue and bankruptcy, the ones I had to go through!, and today, who would have said it, is what I say, Spain grows more than the European average, more than the Union average, more than Germany, Italy, and France. So, that is neither exaggerating nor not exaggerating. That is the truth.

Q. Well.- You say it is the one that grows the most in the European Union. That was the nuance.

President.- Of the large countries in the European Union, including the United Kingdom. Obviously, Latvia grows more than Spain and it is likely that there are a couple of others among the small ones. I mean of the large countries. I am not going to compare myself, with all due respect, to Latvia; I will try to aspire, and I believe that is what we must do, to get closer and closer to the large ones.

Q. Well.- You say that this exit from the crisis --you said it this week-- has not left anyone by the wayside. Let me give you some data to see if we are talking about the same thing: there are twelve million Spaniards at risk of poverty, according to the European Network of Poverty and Social Exclusion, the long-term unemployment rate is 60 percent, Mr. President: we currently have 2,940,000 unemployed who have been unemployed for more than a year, and of them, 2,150,000 have been unemployed for more than two years and have run out of benefits. Can we say that we have not left them by the wayside?

President.- If you want, we can have a debate about figures.

Q. Well.- No. As you used it, I bring you these.

President.- I agree, but I think in life it is advisable to go for the greater good, right? So, we must be fair and proportional when making a judgment or taking stock.

We lived --I tell you what I lived and also what many Spaniards lived-- on the brink of rescue and I had to endure the pressures of many; on the brink of bankruptcy and in recession, without economic growth. When I arrived, 1,400 jobs were being lost every day. Well, from that situation, three years later, we have gone to being the one that grows the most in Europe among the large countries, okay?, to being the country in Europe that is creating the most jobs and to an increase in confidence. The risk premium is no longer even talked about. We were in ruins.

So, let's get to the bigger picture. Are there many things left, and can you give me many data and I, many others? But, come on, please, let’s elevate ourselves a bit and make value judgments. Is there still a lot to do? Yes, of course, there are still many people unemployed, people in difficulties.

P. Well .- Mr. President, do you think it is elevating to say that we have 46 percent of young Spaniards unemployed, that those over 50, according to the EPA, are the ones taking the longest to find work because they come from declining sectors and, moreover, they have to retire? Is that elevating?

President .- No. That is true and it is also true that youth employment is growing in 2015 at a rate of 11 percent, and that eight out of ten people unemployed who found work in the last year were long-term unemployed, and that 73 percent of Spaniards have a permanent contract.

In other words, we have a certain tendency to make news only about the bad. Come on, there are some positive things in this country, right?, and I believe that the change in the economic situation that has occurred… Hey, the other day I read the economic balance of Cadena SER for the first half of the year. Well, local advertising --I’m not even talking about the other-- is rising above 10 percent. That is fantastic for everyone: for you, for Cadena SER, for the shareholders, for those who work here, for me who am here now, and, moreover, it is the demonstration… That local advertising, which is the local commerce, growing more than 10 percent is enormously positive.

Now, is all that enough? Not at all. That’s why I say: in the next four years, Spain needs to create two million jobs and reach twenty million, and that can be done as long as we are able to maintain the same economic policy.

Data like those you mentioned…

P. Well .- Are they true?

President .- Of course they are true.

P. Well .- Okay. And if they are true, Mr. President, you have the right to campaign, but I have to ask you…

President .- I am not campaigning. I am responding and saying what I believe is true.

P. Well .- You are, of course, entitled to say what you deem appropriate, Mr. President. That would be the least!

President .- I appreciate that very much.

P. Well .- I wanted to ask you about, for example, the temporary employment rate, which was one of the mantras at the beginning of this Legislature. It has gone from 21 percent to 26 percent.

President .- That is not true.

P. Well .- From the fourth quarter of 2013, according to the EPA. I might have the wrong data.

President .- Now you’re bringing up 2013.

P. Well .- From when we were worse off to now, because then temporary jobs were being destroyed. What I want to ask you is whether the jobs we are creating are quality jobs or temporary jobs, which is what people are telling us. People call us and say: "I need three jobs to make ends meet because I can’t make it with one."

President .- 73 percent are permanent jobs and then there are others that are temporary jobs. There are many sectors of economic activity where it is very difficult for them to stop being temporary jobs because there are, as you know, some activities that are seasonal, especially in the field of agriculture; also, in general, in the field of hospitality, in the tourism world… that, in Spain, and in any other country in the world. Last year we had a significant increase in the number of permanent contracts but, of course, the great challenge for Spain and the great objective remains to improve unemployment figures. That is evident, right? I am not going to question that. But, of course, for that we have made reforms and for that battles have been fought, and today we are creating many more jobs, while before they were being destroyed. Sufficient? No. Absolutely insufficient.

P. Well .- Does the President get very angry when we bring up the negative data of the economy? He has said it many times this week: "you do not emphasize the positive." Mr. President, it is that journalists are in contact with many people, who tell us that the exit from this crisis leaves them by the wayside, that they have lost rights and that they are not recovering them, that they have very low salaries and that they barely make it to the end of the month. This is happening, it happens to us every day and you tell us: "don’t be pessimistic or doomsayers." Are we ignoring the Spaniards who are having a hard time?

President .- I do not get angry when you tell me that. Sometimes, I have the feeling that someone gets angry when I talk about the good evolution that the economy has experienced in recent years. That feeling I do have habitually.

However, what you have said is true. There are many things left to do and I know that there are people living in extreme difficulty; but what is also fair to recognize is that things are evolving for the better. It is that radio in Portugal has grown in advertising by 1 percent and here, by 10 percent. Hey, well, something is working well in Spain. What it is about, and I have said it, and that is the future, is that we are able to persevere so that there are two million more Spaniards working in Spain. That is the challenge.

P. Well .- If everything goes well, Mr. President…

President .- I did not say that everything is going well.

P. Well .- No, I am saying it.

President .- Ah! If you say it. I disagree. Not everything is going well.

P. Well .- I was going to say: if everything goes well in the future, Mr. President…

President .- Hopefully.

Pepa Bueno .- …will the severance pay in Spain return to exceeding twenty days per year worked? Do you think it is possible to undertake the legal reforms to raise that amount, which was up to 45 days, in the next Legislature?

President .- The labor reform has been one of the best decisions that the Government I preside over has made. I tell you this with absolute frankness. I have been with important businessmen in the automotive sector, who, as you know, have continued to invest in Spain, and a lot. I have been in Palencia, I have been in Valencia, I have been in Zaragoza, I have been in Martorell recently and I also have a pending visit to Vigo and some of the other large factories. The automotive sector has been up to the task and the fundamental reason they have come here has been the labor reform.

If you read the reports of whoever wants to read --well, the unions are against it, but what can we do--, I believe that the labor reform has been fundamental, among other things, because by flexibilizing relations there was already a different alternative, when companies were doing poorly, to dismissal; there was already one. And I believe that reversing, as some intend, the labor reform is nonsense, from the point of view of the interests of the people and, above all, from the point of view of the interests of the people who are waiting to get a job, colossal. I tell you as I feel it.

P. Well .- To be specific, I was asking you if we will return to having 45 days per year worked in a future labor reform, if everything goes well. Has that been lost forever?

President .- The fundamental objective, the priority, is that everyone has a job and does not lose it, and therefore, we should not enter into that discussion. That is the objective of the labor reform and that is what we must persevere in: that there is no dismissal and that we are not discussing what the severance pay will be.

P. Well .- So, it is that no to that, Mr. President. It is that no. That in your opinion it should not return, not even if things go well.

President .- In my opinion, the objective should be to create jobs. It is that when things are going well, there are no dismissals. That is the issue and that is precisely what it is about.

P. Well .- So, even if things go well, we will never return to that.

President .- No, I said that when things are going well, there are no dismissals and, therefore, we are not in that issue.

P. Well .- But, as people are also dismissed, hypothetically…

President .- Yes, but much less, Pepa; much less.

P. Well .- Mr. President, another thing you said this week: "we are the champions of the deficit." And I asked, is that true? We have not met the deficit in any of the years of the Legislature. There was a final correction for 2014. I said: in 2014, yes. Well, Eurostat corrected me, and neither.

President .- Pepa, when I arrived at the Government --this makes me laugh--, the public deficit was 9 percent and the target was 6 percent; there was a deviation of three points. Well, look, now that the Legislature is about to end, I don’t know if it has technically already ended, Spain is going to leave the deficit at less than half. Throughout Europe, the effort we have made is recognized. The International Monetary Fund said that in the reduction of the primary structural deficit we were the first country in the OECD; the first country in the OECD, come on! We had to reduce the deficit in recession, that is, when there was a drop in public revenues.

You can criticize this Government for many things but, after coming from where we come from, to say that in terms of deficit reduction, we have not made a great effort and we have had to ask many efforts from the Spaniards, is a bit unfair, allow me to say that.

P. Well .- I have not talked about the effort, I talk about the fact that the President of the Government says that we have complied. We have not complied. If that effort is like that and if we are growing, why not say exactly what has happened? The deficit has not been met in the four years of the Legislature.

President .- I believe that substantially it has been met. Last year we had a problem with a ruling, that of the "sanitary cent," from the European Court, which put us almost two tenths of deficit and left us with that. But, of course, the European Commission had no concern with that matter, right?

P. Well .- You maintain that you cannot spend more than you earn. We have heard you say that in many ways and with many nuances.

President .- As a general rule, yes.

P. Well .- And you have criticized the Rodríguez Zapatero Government, which you succeeded, for doing the opposite. In these four years, Mr. President, you have done just that, spend more than you earned, because we have increased --I try to be exact-- our public debt by three hundred billion euros.

President .- Yes, among other things, because we have had to support the finances of many Autonomous Communities, because we have had to pay suppliers…

P. Well .- Most of them from your party or many from your party; some. Valencia, for example.

President .- Yes, yes. But, of course, if someone, at the time, had taken care to control the spending of the Autonomous Communities, whether from my party or any party, we would probably be in a different situation, because now, of course, we are taking care of that.

We had to pay suppliers. Social centers that served people in difficulty were not being paid. Healthcare suppliers were not being paid. How many small businesses had to close because they were not being paid? We had to attend, you see, to the debt maturities of some Autonomous Communities because they could not go to the markets. It is that sometimes we do not realize. It is that when we arrived here, the Generalitat of Catalonia was paying 7.75 percent per year for money and now the creditor is the Government and pays zero interest per year.

Governing is not easy. Making speeches and criticizing the Government is much easier, but governing is not easy.

P. Well .- I was asking you why those inaccuracies that can be avoided, if, in your opinion, you can present a good economic balance.

President .- Inaccuracies… Well, two tenths of deficit; okay, two tenths of deficit. I have already explained some cases and could explain others.

P. Well .- You did not request the country rescue, you have already said it; we applaud that here, but you had to request the rescue for the banks. The big hole in the banks was in Bankia. Would you say today that you were wrong to promote the presidency of CajaMadrid for Rodrigo Rato?

President .- Yes, we had to request it, because do you know what the alternative was, which some also raised? It was to close all those financial entities and, by closing those financial entities, I ask: who would pay the deposits of the people who had their money there, and what would happen to the investment funds and what would happen to the workers? It is that sometimes, really, there are things that truly surprise you.

Well, yes, we did it and now we have achieved something that is capital, and of which you spoke to me in the last interview we had, which is credit. I told you: we have to fix the credit issue because, if there is no credit, it is very difficult for there to be investment in economic activity. That has been getting better.

P. Well .- In that interview, sixteen months ago, Mr. President --we invite you more often whenever you want to come-- we did not know the things we know today about Rato. Did you make a mistake in promoting the presidency of CajaMadrid for Rodrigo Rato?

President.- I do not know exactly what has happened or everything... There is an open procedure, I believe, in the National Court regarding the IPO of Bankia and the merger of Bankia with Bancaja. I do not know. Certainly, what I assume is that President Rodrigo Rato must have acted on all these matters -- there is no other way to do it -- in accordance with the Government, the Bank of Spain, and the National Securities Market Commission. But I do not know that, and, really, it will be the Courts that have to establish the responsibilities of each party.

Q. Well.- How could a presumed criminal, a presumed, I insist, deceive so many for so long? He was your colleague in the Council of Ministers, he was vice president, he was president of Bankia...

President.- He was my colleague in the Council of Ministers, indeed, for many years and a good friend. Look, let us wait for the Courts to decide. I do not know. I know what I have read about the fiscal problems, and I know about Bankia that I just mentioned; but let us wait for the Courts to decide and let us not set ourselves up as judges, which, at least, is not my role.

Q. Well.- You repeat that corruption has done a lot of damage to the Popular Party; but it has done more damage to the Spaniards, do you not think? Because it has left many empty coffers.

President.- Corruption harms the country in general and us, as a party, too. It harms everyone.

Q. Well.- You are risking your seat, and the rest of us are risking the Welfare State, because in many places we have seen how money from public contracts has gone into the pockets of individuals.

President, I am going to give you a list of the official accounting of the Popular Party, the one sent to the Court of Auditors, in which there is no trace of the money given to Pío García Escudero, the president of the Senate, for the renovations of his apartment, something he has acknowledged. The extra salary of Calixto Ayesa for one year, acknowledged by him, is also not listed in those accounts; nor is the money spent on the rental of Jaume Matas' apartment here in Madrid, acknowledged by him; nor the extra salary admitted by the party manager, Cristóbal Páez, acknowledged by him; nor the subsidy to Eugenio Nasarre, acknowledged by him; nor the aid given to the widow of a councilor murdered by ETA, acknowledged by her. All this money that did not appear in the official accounting of the PP, which was therefore not declared to the Treasury, which was therefore black money -- not even speculated on its origin -- allows those investigating this case to deduce that there was a parallel slush fund in the PP. Did you never suspect it?

President.- No. Really, no. The responsibility in this matter was not carried by the people who were dedicated to political activity. And I already said at the time that all of that seems lamentable to me. The people who then had that responsibility, specifically Mr. Bárcenas, are no longer in the Popular Party, and we, of course, submit now to what the courts of justice say.

But, look, in a political party, as I suppose in so many companies in life, everyone has their function and, of course, neither the general secretary of the party, nor the spokesperson of the Parliamentary Group, nor the spokesperson in the Senate, nor the president of the party, are involved in these matters to which you have just referred. Neither in these, nor in many others.

Q. Well.- Do you feel tempted to close the headquarters at Génova 13, after yet another judge has requested information about the works allegedly paid for with black money?

President.- We already answered the same day that Judge Castro sent us that document regarding the works that were done in the Popular Party.

Q. Well.- I am asking if you feel tempted to close it.

President.- I have not considered it either. Simply, if we have any responsibility… You will understand that in no executive committee, nor in any body of the party, does anyone find out how the works are awarded, nor what is being done, nor how it is paid. It is true that there is a person who, according to what the Courts have said in the investigation phase, did not act properly and, therefore, let the weight of the Law fall on whoever it should fall on.

Q. Well.- You mentioned Bárcenas. Do you regret having appointed him treasurer?

President.- Yes. If I had known what I know now, I would not have appointed him, as is natural. But at that time I did not know.

Q. Well.- President, why has the PP not signed the manifesto calling for a consensus president for Radiotelevisión Española? Why is consensus bad?

President.- Consensus is not bad at all.

Q. Well.- It is just that you have not signed a document that asks for that, a reinforced majority.

President.- Who said that consensus is bad? I am in favor of consensus.

Q. Well.- And why have you not signed that document?

President.- There is a law, which is in force, that was approved at the time, regarding how the president of Radiotelevisión Española is appointed. That Law was agreed upon by the Socialist Party and the Popular Party, and I see no reason to change it because there are others who think differently from how the vast majority of Spaniards represented in the Congress of Deputies thought at the time, where national sovereignty resides.

Of course, sometimes some people appear saying one thing and other people say the opposite. Those who are there for that are the General Courts, because that is what Parliaments are for.

Q. Well.- Do you think the refugee crisis could take Merkel down? Her popularity is plummeting.

President.- I believe that this is the most important issue we Europeans have for the next twenty-five years at least, and that, if we do not take it seriously and carry out a large-scale action on the African continent and some countries in Asia, we are going to have a first division problem. I believe it is the most important problem.

Q. Well.- I give you some news: Austria has just announced that it will erect a fence in part of its border with Slovenia. Thus, to stop it.

President.- I know, with Slovenia. That was this morning.

Q. Well.- But I ask you if it will take Merkel down.

President.- I do not think so. What Merkel is maintaining is a position that I am also maintaining. Merkel is in favor of the right to asylum. I believe that all those people who are persecuted for political reasons or who live in a country that is at war we must grant asylum to in Europe, because that is European civilization, democracy, and freedom. Another thing is irregular immigration for economic reasons, where I believe that a large operation should be carried out in Africa, led by the European Union, trying to ensure that in those countries they effectively fight against poverty and respect human rights because, as long as people cannot eat in their country and lead a dignified life, they will come here, because you would do it and I would too.

Q. Well.- Official development aid from your Government has decreased by 60 percent during this Legislature, President.

President.- The situation in our country was such that all budget items have decreased except for pensions, which have increased over these years, and except for unemployment. We had to prioritize. Seventy billion euros had been lost, we had to prioritize and we said: pensions and unemployment will not be touched. From now on, we can start, and already in the 2016 budget many items increase. They already did in 2015 and also in 2016, because now we are collecting more, because the economy is doing better.

Q. Well.- Your number two for Madrid, Soraya Sáenz de Santamaría, right?

President.- Who?

Q. Well.- The number two on the electoral list.

President.- The truth is that, yes, we have to make the lists. We have not started yet.

Q. Well.- And will Soraya Sáenz de Santamaría be number two?

President.- Well, I have not considered it; but I am certainly delighted with the work she has done over these last few years. I suppose so. I cannot think of any reason why she would not be.

Q. Well.- Ah! I thought it was clear.

President.- Clear about what?

Q. Well.- That she would be number two.

President.- Yes, I think she will be number two; but I have not yet spoken to anyone about this matter.

Q. Well.- And will the general secretary be number one for Toledo?

President.- Well, I do not know, because I have not spoken to her either. I do not know if she wants to stay in Castilla-La Mancha or run for deputy in the General Courts.

Q. Well.- Do you, President, feel that people speak to you sincerely in your environment? I tell you why: because many PP leaders privately tell journalists that you as a candidate are a burden.

President.- Well, one of two, either they are not telling the truth when they talk to me, or they are not telling the truth when they talk to you. I hope it is when they talk to you that they are not telling the truth.

Q. Well.- Do they not tell you?

President.- No.

Q. Well.- If your party has to negotiate to govern and the condition set by others is that you are not the president, will you step back? Will you be generous, Mr. Rajoy?

President.- I do not believe that the other parties will not respect the popular will and the candidate that the people vote for. I do not believe so. I think their democratic sense would prevent them from doing what you say.

Q. Well.- But in Spain we do not vote for presidential candidates. This is a parliamentary democracy. We choose lists, closed lists moreover.

President.- Technically it is as you say: this is a parliamentary system and not a presidential one. But, having said that, you know that since 1977, when the first elections were held in our country, the parties present a candidate for president, although it is true what you have just pointed out.

Q. Well.- Really, no one questions your leadership directly like you do? President, I say this as part of the reality, of the analysis.

President.- I understand you perfectly. Although some may not like it, it is so. They do not question it.

Q. Well.- And do you not think you are a burden for your party?

President.- Absolutely not. I believe that I have had to govern, with my government and with the support of my Parliamentary Group, in the most difficult Legislature in decades in our country, sincerely. Although, as I told you before, there are still many things I have to do and there are still many people in difficult situations, I believe we have acted with determination and courage, although I am fully aware that this has meant that many people have been upset, and they have every right to be, with me and with the decisions my Government has made.

Q. Well.- Any news about the three missing soldiers in the Atlantic?

President.- No. I have spoken with the Minister of Defense, who has been there for four days... The last time was yesterday and, unfortunately, we still do not know anything, despite all efforts being made. He is in Gando, there in Gran Canaria.

Q. Well.- Was precious search time lost due to incorrect information from Morocco?

President.- That will have to be seen at the time, but I do not think so, and I must say that the Government of Morocco is helping us with material means to try to find out what has happened.

Q. Well.- President, you are going to the Climate Change Summit.

President.- Yes. That is, I believe, on November 30 in Paris; it is a Monday.

Q. Well.- What does your cousin say?

President.- When one makes a mistake, the best thing is to rectify, and I have rectified many times in life, because I often make mistakes, although it is true that it is better for me to make mistakes as few times as possible for the good of everyone. I made a mistake then and I have rectified.

Q. Well.- Do you think it is a serious problem?

President.- Yes. I think it is a serious problem and I am very happy because the other day, on October 18, at the United Nations we presented the document that certifies that we have fulfilled our commitments with Kyoto. Believe me, it was a day for me when I was very happy.

Q. Well.- I want to be precise, President. I believe there is not a single euro in the Budgets for next year, nor has there been in the last three, to recover from the Spanish ditches the bodies of the victims of Francoism, basically, and some from the Civil War, and, however, you have given the Francisco Franco Foundation 150,000 euros. Do you have any explanation for this?

President.- I was unaware of what you just told me. I did not know.

Q. Well.- Because you do not find an explanation for this, do you?

President.- I did not know. I do not know, I am unaware.

Q. Well.- Do you eat red meat?

President.- Yes. Really, I do not want to get into anyone's business and least of all talk about what I do not know, but, of course, this thing about releasing a document, no less than the World Health Organization, transmitting to the world, because they transmit to the world, that if they eat meat or if they consume sausages or such, they could die, seems very strong to me. I miss strong and clear information from those who can provide it, because this is no joke.

Q. Well.- So, do you think what the World Health Organization says is exaggerated?

President.- No, because I don't know a word; but I believe that throughout humanity we have all eaten meat. The countries that eat the most meat in the world are Brazil, Argentina, and Uruguay, and then the United States, Israel, just look at that, and Australia. But in Spain, a lot of meat is eaten, and Spain is the second country in the world in life expectancy, behind Japan. In Japan, they eat little meat, they eat more fish and rice; but we are second. But I cannot express an opinion on what I do not know. Well! What I would like is for someone with sufficient knowledge to tell us whether that is true or false. Because what is the World Health Organization saying? That we should not eat meat or are they telling governments to prohibit the commercialization of meat? Of course, we need to...

P. Well.- They are saying to eat it with caution, Mr. President.

President.- Well, how much is that? We need more information.

P. Well.- Have you spoken with the sector? I imagine you are concerned about the meat industry.

President.- I am concerned about the meat industry, but I am much more concerned about the health of the people. That worries me much more.

P. Well.- Ah! That’s why I said, because today we reported here that there has been a spectacular increase in colorectal cancer in Spain in the last thirty years, just when we abandoned our Mediterranean diet.

President.- Yes, the Mediterranean diet, of course, should be preserved, and we should eat fruits, legumes... Of course, then they talk to you about pesticides and such. I believe that food safety is one of the most important challenges for the future, one of the most important challenges. Now there are many fish farms, there is a lot of pre-packaged food, etc., etc., and I think that there the states must make a great effort.

P. Well.- Four years ago, when you were about to arrive at La Moncloa, I interviewed you on Televisión Española and asked you for the names of three people who had not let you down. You were coming from 2008, you had been fiercely criticized within the party, and you gave me the names of three women.

President.- And which ones did I give you?

P. Well.- Carmen Martínez Castro, who is here, the Secretary of State for Communication, Soraya Sáenz de Santamaría, and Dolores de Cospedal.

President.- The three are still working intensely in a very difficult situation, and I could give you the same answer I gave you in 2011.

P. Well.- Tell me someone who has let you down.

President.- Is it worth it, Pepa?

P. Well.- Yes, because there is a good part of the life of the Spaniards in the middle of that.

President.- Someone from my party or outside my party?

P. Well.- From your party, from your environment. I will ask the others, Mr. President; those from outside.

President.- It’s just to poke a little fun at those from outside, because they already criticize my party enough.

Really, I have been in the party for many years, I am very in touch with the people, and there are, logically, people with whom I have more relationship, people with whom you understand better and worse; but there is no one I can reproach for having done something with malice, or with the spirit of causing trouble, which is what is really bad in life: when you hurt for no reason. I have not seen that in my party.

P. Well.- Mr. Rajoy, thank you for being on SER. Good morning.

President.- Thank you very much.