Press conference by President of the French Republic and President of the Government

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

22 May 2012 · Joint press conference with the Prime Minister of Spain

Context
Rajoy and French President Hollande held a joint press conference in Paris on 22 May 2012 ahead of an informal European Council meeting.
Main themes
European Council informal summit, eurozone crisis and euro stability, economic growth pact, banking system liquidity, fiscal consolidation and deficit reduction, Franco-Spanish bilateral relations, counter-terrorism cooperation, structural reforms, European financial system, market speculation protection
Duration
~40 min
90th percentile
Words
4,778
90th percentile
Sentences
184
87th percentile
Readability
53
71st percentile
Grade
12.1
46th percentile
Syntax
3.13
65th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
11th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

184 sentences in 74 paragraphs

We have spoken about our bilateral relations, which are excellent in all areas, including security, which we most definitely discussed and which will be one of our common areas for concern in the coming months.

I also wanted to speak with Mr. Rajoy about the informal European Council which will be held this afternoon. We hold positions which may converge, not on all matters, but on those priority areas. The first is to inject liquidity into the European financial system to consolidate all European banks. We also have the problem of growth. Each one of us, at our own level, is implementing policies of budgetary consolidation and Spain is making a great effort; but we are also aware that growth must also be on our agenda because, if not, how will it be possible to make headway in reducing the deficit or controlling debt if there are no complementary activities?

This afternoon, for my part, I will try to push the following two areas forward at the European Council: firstly a growth pact, in addition to what needs to be done at a budgetary level, and the matter of liquidity so that our banking system can be made sounder, and secondly to protect ourselves from speculations that may affect the markets from time to time.

That is what we spoke about at our meeting, which will not stop there because we hope to hold another meeting towards the end of the year.

President of the Government.- Good afternoon. Thank you for your words, Mr. President.

In reality, President Hollande has explained matters very well, he has summarised the content of our meeting perfectly, so in fact I will be saying virtually the same but put another way.

Firstly, I want to say that I am very pleased and satisfied to be here, and I want to thank President Hollande for the splendid welcome he has given me and those who have accompanied me to this meeting.

Our bilateral relations, as the President said, are very good, as indeed they have been for some time, and we are both absolutely convinced that they will remain so in the future. I thus won't dwell on this matter any longer.

I would like to thank the President of the Republic, because, when I called him to congratulate him on being elected as president, he told me that France would continue collaborating with all the resources at its disposal in the fight against terrorism. In fact, a meeting was held just recently - in Denmark I believe it was - between the French and Spanish Ministers for Home Affairs, and on 29 May the French Home Affairs Minister will be visiting Spain where he will undoubtedly be well received. Hence, I would like to express my gratitude for the collaboration shown by the President.

I would also like to point out that, after three years without meetings between the two States, we have agreed to hold one towards the end of this year, a meeting to deal with matters that may be of interest to public opinion and which will serve to improve the situation of our citizens. I repeat that this meeting, this summit, will be held, in principle, in the final quarter of 2012.

Finally, as the President said, we have spoken about the European Council meeting to be held this afternoon and, in general, about what is happening in Europe and what we can do to improve things in the future.

I explained to the President, and I will do the same now, summarising as far as possible, how I see things. I believe that Europe is, at this time, in a moment of crisis and I believe that we must make an effort to strengthen the euro, which undoubtedly forms a part of our political project, as it should be, and which is an instrument to increase the level of well-being, wealth and employment in all Member States of the European Union.

The position adopted by Spain at this time is based on five points, which I will summarise, and about which there is substantial consensus with the position adopted by France.

We have already signed a Fiscal Compact which we have incorporated into our Constitution, we have approved a Constitutional Law to implement this Fiscal Compact and our aim is to meet our commitments in matters of the public deficit, which is set at 5.3% for this year, and at 3% for 2013. That is the first important point for our economic policy.

Secondly, as President Hollande mentioned, simply controlling the public deficit is not enough; we need to make policies that stimulate growth. We need to undertake reforms to make our economies more competitive and more flexible. This needs to be done at a national level. Spain is working on this; it has carried out a labour reform, it is undertaking a reform of the financial system and we are working on reforming our energy system, reforming our public authorities and on market unity. I repeat, yes to controlling the deficit but also to reform policies, which are the policies which, together with controlling the deficit, will lead to growth.

Thirdly, we also need to undertake reforms to make Europe grow. It is very important to take decisive steps towards greater market integration.

Fourthly, and for me today, and for Spain, the most important matter, we need financing, we need liquidity and we need sustainable debt. There are many countries making a great effort at controlling the public deficit and at structural reforms, but we cannot survive with these differentials with other countries when seeking funding. With things as they stand, it is very complicated for the policies to control the deficit and for the structural reform policies to be effective. Hence, what we need is to dissipate any doubts regarding the euro, for an effort to be made at sustaining the debt of all those countries that are meeting their commitments to the European Union, and for there to be financing and liquidity. That is the main objective, and for Spain, the most urgent at this time.

Finally, I also believe that we must work at a European level - this is my opinion, something which we share- for greater economic, fiscal and political integration.

These matters are the ones which I, in essence, will also raise today at the European Council. Today's European Council is an informal meeting, decisions will not be taken, but it is the prologue of a Council meeting that will take place, as you are aware, at the end of June this year, where I hope that decisions will be taken on these important matters, some of which, I repeat, I believe to be very urgent.

Thank you very much, once again, Mr. President. We have felt the warmth of your treatment and I thank you for your kindness and warm welcome.

Q.- I would like to ask both of you if you agree on supporting the intervention of the European Central Bank in Brussels today to help countries like Spain.

I would also like to know whether you spoke about the situation of the Spanish banks and what was your position regarding the need, or not, for these banks to resort to European bailout funds.

President of the Government.- As regards the first matter, what you are asking is whether at today's European Council we are going to speak about the European Central Bank or not. What I will be saying in Brussels - I have just summarised it for you, and I don't want to go on about it - is that, for me, there are four or five areas that are fundamental, I repeat, controlling public spending, reforms to stimulate growth, reforms for growth within Europe and, fourthly, liquidity, the sustainability of debt and financing.

Let me elaborate on this last point. What I mean is that Europe must respond and is indeed obliged to do so, because we can't go on like this much longer, with such high differentials when seeking financing, and because, furthermore, these differentials are what make policies, which we as Europeans believe in, on controlling public spending and reforms to boost growth, unsuccessful at the end of the day.

Secondly, you are referring to the Spanish banks. In Spain, we are doing, in the same way as with the public accounts - where we have published our public deficit figures, which have been very high and which we will try to correct this year - in Spain we will carry out an exercise in transparency of the first order with all our financial entities so that any doubts are dispersed and so that no-one can imagine something that simply isn't there.

As you are aware, we have taken the decision to nationalise one of the leading Spanish Banks - Bankia - and in the next two months independent evaluators will tell us exactly what the situation of Spanish banking is. Stress test exercises and analyses by the International Monetary Fund have already been performed. It is likely that a certain amount of funding will be required - I don't believe this will be a significant figure - in order to recapitalise certain Spanish banks, but of course, at today's date, the Government is not interested in, nor does it have any intention of resorting to any fund from the European Union or from any other body. We are only interested in sending out a clear and comprehensive message about a financial system that shouldn't have doubts cast about it, because those doubts are unfounded.

Mr. Hollande.- As regards the role of the European Central Bank, I consider that this forms part of the debate we will have over the coming weeks, both in terms of contributing towards growth, which is a way of intervening in the markets with full independence, and also in terms of the way of contributing liquidity, something which it has already started to do, because the banks are entitled to receive loans from the European Central Bank at particularly low interest rates.

Would it be desirable for the European Financial Stability Fund to play a more significant role than it has today for those banks that finally require its help? Why not, without resorting first to Member States? This all forms a part, as I said, of a debate that we will have in the coming days within the framework, moreover, of the informal European Council meeting to be held this evening, at which we will deal with this matter of liquidity and at the European Council meeting to be held in June.

I hope that decisions are taken in this respect because, the more fluid our financial system, the sounder it will be and, of course, at this time it could result in better conditions for growth. We must contribute more liquidity and have sounder financial institutions; that is also the sense behind a growth policy.

Q.- One question for Mr. Rajoy and another for Mr. Hollande. Are the matters of the 'eurobond' and the tax on financial transactions two unconditional points to be brought to a satisfactory end in the negotiations that will be held tonight? That's the first question.

The second question, for the French President. How will you tackle tonight's meeting? Will it be more difficult with your European partners than it was with the G-8 partners or with NATO?

President of the Government.- You are specifically asking me two questions. Regarding the tax on financial transactions, I don't know whether it will be the subject of debate at today's European Council or not, we are in favour of a tax on financial transactions; but it is very important that this tax does not mean, in the end, an additional cost due to an increase in commissions for private individuals. It is very important that this tax is not only applied by one or two countries, because this could generate serious problems in the markets. Hence it would be good if it was a tax approved by a majority of countries.

As regards the matter of the 'eurobond', in the short term, I repeat what I said earlier, it is very important - I repeat, in the short term, or in fact in the very short term - to resolve the problem of financing, of liquidity and of the sustainability of our debt. We can then have a debate in Europe about more Europe and about European integration.

You are aware that Europe has been around for a long time. Its construction process started a long time ago. It was precisely France and Germany, with the European Coal and Steel Community that started it; then came the Treaty of Rome in 1957, and the process of constructing Europe progressed little by little since then. We now need to start to think about whether we should go further in the process of economic, financial and political integration or not. And, on this matter, within this process and within this debate, lies the matter of the 'eurobond' debt bonds; but I don't believe that this is a matter that will be resolved at today's European Council.

I repeat, at today's Council meeting, I believe that the most urgent matter is resolving the problem of financing, of liquidity and of the sustainability of our debt. Everything else will fall under a debate that Europe must hold to establish where we are, what type of Europe we want to have and to decide on where we are heading.

Mr. Hollande.- The objective of tonight's European Council, which is informal and which will not be taking decisions in this respect, is to lay out all our ideas on growth and liquidity on the table; for each country to make its proposals. There are many. Some insist on structural reforms, others on the integration of the markets or on the tax on financial transactions. For my part, I will speak about what Europe can do very quickly, in other words, over the next twelve months, regarding whether it is capable of adopting measures to foster economic activity and job creation without this being too burdensome for the Member States, in such a way that, as countries start to see the recovery of their public accounts, this can also be accompanied by a more active growth policy throughout Europe.

Among the proposals that I will be putting on the table is the matter of the 'eurobond', not to enter into conflict with other countries, but because each one should come here with one's own intentions, since we must find solutions together at the end of June. It would be a shame not to bring these proposals to fruition.

As regards the 'eurobond', what is the idea? It is not simply to make a 'bond project', something which will also be proposed, but to reflect on a method of financing that allows EU Member States which have made an essential effort to recover their public accounts to gain access to a type of financing with interest rates as low as possible so that they can be placed as a guarantee against speculation or doubts raised by a number of markets.

Is it acceptable that certain sovereign debts are obliged, in order to receive financing, to consent to interest rates in excess of 6% while other countries, which are undoubtedly better considered, manage to attain financing with interest rates close to zero in the same Monetary and budgetary Union? That is why I am in favour of debating this instrument within the framework of a work programme that we have set for this European Council.

It will be more difficult than the G-8. At the G-8 there were participants who perhaps initially were not in favour of our argument, and furthermore didn't attend, but which do consider that growth should have been a dimension of policies that we needed to take into account.

As regards the NATO Summit, we have made our proposals and decisions count while maintaining good relations with our allies. In the same way, faced with the perspective of holding the European Council at the end of the month of June, we must try to be convincing and seek agreements.

I defend budgetary discipline and we will meet our commitments to reduce our deficit for 2013, but I also consider that growth is a condition for achieving these objectives and we shouldn't accept a Eurozone with zero growth in 2012 and only weak growth in 2013. That is why we must apply policies - in each one of our countries there are reforms that their Governments have adopted for a number of years now, which will be complied with by all - but also carry out a policy of growth at a European level. There we will have all the proposals, which will be added one to another and which will allow us to have this growth dimension that is lacking.

I hope that a growth pact will be proposed and approved at the end of the month of June. We could talk more in this regard after tonight's informal meeting, although I should say that decisions won't be taken, but rather there will simply be an exchange of opinions.

Q.- Mr. President of the Government, I wanted to ask you about the renewal of the Constitutional Court judges, who have asked both you and the opposition for a solution. I don't know whether you have spoken with the leader of the opposition already on this matter and whether you have reached an agreement.

You spoke with him yesterday, have you shared with him the implications for today's Summit and have you asked him for his opinion?

A question for both of you. There has just been breaking news that the Eurogroup has asked the national governments to start preparing a contingency plan for Greece's exit. I don't know if you can confirm this, if you are already discussing this matter, and perhaps you could let us know your opinion on Greece's possible exit from the euro.

President of the Government.- I am indeed aware, as I should be, of the request from the Constitutional Court, which was made unanimously, for us to proceed to the swift renewal of those members who are up for renewal. I believe they are right. I will meet on Friday with the leader of the opposition and I am absolutely convinced that we will reach an understanding and that we will shortly proceed to renew the Constitutional Court.

As regards our position on the European Council, I did indeed have a conversation with him yesterday, I also had a conversation with Mr. Duran and it is my intention to have one with the rest of the Parliamentary groups in the near future. I believe that there is agreement on the core matters. In fact, European policy in Spain has always been the result of major agreements, and we even defended our positions together in a referendum - we went into the euro together - and before that, in 1986. And just a short time ago, the People's Party (PP) and the Spanish Socialist Workers Party (PSOE) jointly agreed to reform the [Spanish] Constitution. Hence, I don't think there will be major differences on this matter between the PP and the PSOE, because there never has been on European matters. There may be differences regarding the finer points, but I don't believe there will be major differences.

As regards the information that you have just given us here, I, at least, have not received this information. I simply hope that the Eurogroup does not have a lot of work to do on this matter and that Greece remains in the euro. I sincerely believe that this is the best outcome for Greece and the best outcome for Europe. That is my assertion and my desire.

Mr. Hollande.- I can only answer the second question.

As regards Greece I will do all I can, from my position, to convince the Greek people that they should choose to remain in the Eurozone and respect the commitments they have agreed to adopt, and also do everything possible to convince those Europeans that might doubt the need for Greece to remain in the euro.

It is not something that only matters to the Greeks, neither is it something that only matters to the Eurozone; it is important for Europe and for growth in the whole world. This may appear to be disproportionate but, if there were a crisis in Greece that were exacerbated by the elections set for 17 June, this would also necessarily impact on the conditions for growth in Europe and hence in the rest of the world. I don't wish to overstate this matter, but equally I do not wish to understate it.

Am I aware of the work done by the Eurogroup to prepare a fallback plan in the event that Greece exits the euro? My answer is no. I have no information on this matter, and moreover, neither have I requested it, because that would mean that I am thinking about this possible outcome, something I reject.

If, through you, I can address the Greek people, I would like to tell them that I believe in them. And I already expressed, when I won the French elections on 6 May, what my attitude would be in relation to Greece, but also to the commitments in place between Greece and Europe. But there can be no doubt whatsoever regarding Europe's intentions or Greece's intentions. We must move forward together.

I am not preparing for any other scenario aside from this.

Q.- One short question and then a more general question for the President of the Republic and for the President of the Government. You have been talking about liquidity. According to you, should the European Monetary System (EMS) be the reference point for an injection of liquidity into the banking system? Should it have a banking licence? Should it be this way?

Mr. Venizelos believes that Greece should be given a little more time to reduce its debt. Do you agree? How much time should be given to Greece to reduce its debt?

And, on a more general note, you are meeting for the first time, you are both fairly new in your respective posts. According to you, in relation to your predecessors, why is this crisis lasting for so long? What is the original sin that means that you, who have just arrived, are still faced with this crisis?

President of the Government.- I believe that that there are considerably quicker instruments available, which is what is important, than the European Financial Stability Fund (EFSF), which you didn't mention, and than the EMS, which will come into force shortly; in other words, it is not actually in force yet. But there are much quicker instruments available to resolve problems of liquidity and financing.

As regards Mr. Venizelos, I would repeat the assertion that I made earlier. I sincerely believe that the best thing for Greece is to remain in the euro. I know that the Greek people have suffered greatly, they have had to take some very tough measures, but I believe that these measures - taken within the context of the euro - will bear fruit in the not too distant future. That, in the end, will result in growth and job creation in Greece, and an improvement in the standard of living for everyone. I sincerely believe that this is for the best. If I were Greek, I can assure you I would have no doubts in this regard. And I am absolutely convinced that we Europeans want Greece to remain with us. We will thus act accordingly.

Why has this crisis lasted so long? Many people have spoken about this and there are all kinds of analyses and opinions. I am not going to give a lecture here, but I will say one thing: there is something which is very important in any walk of life, when speaking about the euro or speaking about any other matter, and that is certainty. At this time, If Europe needs anything it is certainty about Europe, about the future of Europe and about the euro.

For me, the euro forms a part of the Spanish political project and of the political project of all Europeans, and we must all be clear and convey the message that the euro will be part of our lives forever, and, at the same time, that there will be no country in the Eurozone that will enter into default. Hence, there will be, and this in one of the matters I mentioned earlier, procedures to sustain the public debt of the different countries.

What we need today, fundamentally, is to provide certainty, security and cast away any doubts, rumours or tales that are being spread.

Hence, I believe that the day we provide certainty and security will undoubtedly be the day that the crisis in the Eurozone will come to an end.

Mr. Hollande.- Should we allow the European Financial Stability Fund to intervene, since it hasn't done so already? Is that's its mission: to provide stability? Should it have a banking licence? That will form a part of the subjects open to debate. Should it be bound to the European Central Bank? That also forms a part of the questions that must be raised.

Hence, while Member States do their homework as regards their banking systems, while there are injections of liquidity from the European Central Bank… But when a fund is applied that is going to transform itself into a European solidarity mechanism, we must use this fund or this mechanism so that the banks can be correctly financed.

As regards the position of Mr. Venizelos, it consists of saying, "allow me to respect the memorandum, but also give me more flexibility". I prefer to say that this memorandum exists, and after that, there exists everything that we can do as from now to support growth in Greece, to contribute more structural funds and to help the population to live in better conditions, with direct intervention from Europe, without calling into question the obligations that Greece must respect in relation to the agreement it made. But we cannot allow the Greeks to think that we are not there to help and support them. There was, from the moment in which they elected to participate in the Eurozone, a consistency and a force that inspires confidence in Europeans.

If you ask why there have been so many European Council meeting held over the last two and a half years, and so many disappointments as regards a certain number of matters which are still on the table, especially Greece, I believe that we have a problem with the decision-making mechanism available to the European Union. Certain instruments have assuredly been created and I have spoken about the European Financial Stability Mechanism, but we must go quicker and be more resolute. There quite simply cannot be a budgetary dimension, which has been chosen through the Treaty that you are aware of, without also having a growth pact and a medium-term commitment.

Europeans need to know where Europe is heading. There must be political direction and we must establish certain stages and then objectives to be set. And if there is mistrust - I can verify this through a certain number of local and national elections taking place around Europe - it is because Europe, which is our project, has not responded quickly enough to certain problems, above all unemployment, economic activity and our common future.

Hence, this all forms a part of what I will say tonight. Tonight, at the European Council, we must reflect on economic issues - how to return to growth - and on financial issues - how to obtain liquidity - but we must also speak about other political projects, "What do we want to do together in Europe? What are our projects? And the political dimension, because I don't want Europe to be won by populism that prospers on the idea that the south doesn't need helping or for there to be populism in the southern countries because the people cannot continue to be subject to austerity policies.

And hence, there we have a democratic and political element of the first order, which must be debated, including here at today's European Council.

Thank you very much, Mr. President of the Government, for coming to Paris to this extremely important meeting.

President of the Government.- Thank you very much.

Mr. Hollande.- Thank you all very much.