Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

18 June 2013 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions from MP Rosa Díez during a June 2013 congressional control session on child poverty and malnutrition in Spain.
Main themes
Child poverty, malnutrition among children, social welfare policy, employment as poverty solution, government austerity measures, constitutional social state obligations, inequality, education scholarships, public pensions and healthcare, Royal Decree Laws, social inclusion plan, Autonomous Communities competences
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,740
72nd percentile
Sentences
100
63rd percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
13.0
57th percentile
Syntax
3.18
70th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 46%46%
  • Social 18%18%
  • Institutional 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Geopolitical 9%9%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

100 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. Rosa Díez, of the Parliamentary Group Union, Progress and Democracy

Ms. Díez.- 2,200,000 children live in households below the poverty line in Spain; 30.6 percent of minors are at risk of poverty; 16.7 percent of children live in households suffering from extreme poverty; for the first time in history, children are the poorest age group in Spain, more so than those over 65 years old; in Barcelona, 2,865 cases of schoolchildren with malnutrition have been detected, some fainting in class; in Andalusia, breakfast and snack bags are distributed daily to 11,000 schoolchildren, precisely to prevent these cases of malnutrition; the Red Cross announces an emergency food plan in Spain...

Do you believe, Mr. President, that these data are compatible with the definition in Article I of our Constitution, which states that Spain is constituted as a democratic social state governed by the rule of law? What does your Government plan to do to combat the obscene and unacceptable growth of poverty in general, and particularly child poverty?

President.- Thank you very much, Ms. Díez.

Child poverty, as you know, cannot be assessed in direct relation to the children who suffer it, but rather to the economic, labor, and social situation of the household in which they live. That is to say, children normally live in a family, and the situation of that family is, logically, what determines their own situation. A family in a good economic situation, with work and a reasonable living environment, will undoubtedly take better care of the children.

The first thing is to ensure that there is employment and, therefore, resources that allow people to live, carry out a life project, and take care of their children. From there, when there is employment, as you know, there are also more resources to implement all the social policies that can resolve a good part of the problems you have referred to.

Therefore, this is the basic priority and the fundamental objective, as you know, of the Government I preside over.

But in addition to that, it is necessary to carry out social policies that address people in situations of special difficulty. It is important to maintain the public pension system, healthcare, education, and the social policies of the State and also of the Autonomous Communities, and in a difficult situation like the one we are experiencing from a budgetary point of view, the Government and all the Administrations that also have competence are making every effort within their reach to overcome this situation; efforts that must be increased in the coming times if things continue as you have described.

Ms. Díez.- Yes, Mr. President, indeed, it is not the children; it is the children living in Spain, 16.7 percent of them in households suffering from extreme poverty. Child malnutrition is typical of underdeveloped countries, not of a country with a per capita income of 22,700 euros. The increase in poverty and inequality cannot be explained or justified by the economic crisis; the increase in poverty and inequality is a direct consequence of the policies of the Governments, in this case, yours. Child malnutrition is directly related to the reduction of scholarships, with the reduction of lunch scholarships, between 20 and 30 percent.

Look, Mr. President, over the last year and a half, your Government has approved and brought to the Chamber 35 Royal Decree Laws on various matters. Do you not think that there is nothing more urgent, that justifies a Royal Decree Law more than acting to rescue the children suffering from poverty and malnutrition, and exclusion, by the way? I already know that you think that not acting is also a political decision. Could you not make an exception in this case, in the case of poverty and child poverty, to your own rule?

President.- Thank you very much, Ms. Díez.

I insist that policies to create employment are, without a doubt, crucial for these purposes. It is true that we have made budgetary decisions as a consequence of the situation we are in, and whose basic objective is to achieve economic growth, employment, and improve social policies; but it is also true that we have done so equitably. The pension policies and the policies regarding unemployment, which undoubtedly also affect children, the children or grandchildren of those people, we have maintained.

We have also made some decisions that are undoubtedly very useful for people: first, long-term unemployed individuals will not have to pay pharmaceutical expenses; all 0.7 percent of the Personal Income Tax will be dedicated to child poverty; we have extended the Prepara Plan; we have made decisions regarding social housing; we will take measures to pay the contracted social centers of the Autonomous Communities; we have approved the National Strategy and Plan for Childhood and Adolescence, and this year we will present the Social Inclusion Plan and the Plan against Child Poverty, for which we will count on all the contributions that you or any other member of this Chamber wish to make, from the conviction that we are facing a certainly difficult and complex issue...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Cayo Lara, of the Parliamentary Group of the Plural Left

Mr. Lara.- Mr. Rajoy, do you plan to propose the repeal of the modification of Article 135 of the Constitution?

President.- Mr. Lara, thank you very much. As you know, when we were in opposition, we approved the reform of the Constitution, of its Article 135. Then, while already in Government, we approved the Organic Law on Budgetary Stability and Financial Sustainability that develops this reform, and over the last few months, we have made a great effort together to correct the public deficit and to clean up public accounts.

None of these three decisions was arbitrary. One of the lessons that I believe we have all learned is the need to keep public accounts in order, and for that, nothing better than having a framework of budgetary discipline for all levels of Administration. I say this because the public deficit only leads to the loss of wealth, to putting our Welfare State at risk, and to the loss of decision-making capacity over economic policy. But, in addition, budgetary discipline is a requirement to guarantee stability in the eurozone. It was from the beginning. When we entered the euro, we did so because we met certain conditions regarding public deficit. It was so later with the Stability Program, and it is now, after the approval of the Fiscal Pact that obliges all countries in the European Union to include it in their own constitutional text.

In the event that we were to repeal Article 135 of the Constitution, what we would be doing is leaving the eurozone, something that neither I desire nor do I believe a majority of members of this Chamber wish. Another thing is that there are European decisions that I would like to see taken, and another thing are the deadlines for correcting the public deficit, which is also a different, although very important, issue.

Therefore, it is not among my priorities nor is it my intention, on the contrary, to propose a reform of the Constitution to repeal Article 135.

Mr. Lara.- Mr. Rajoy, we are not raising the issue of leaving the euro with this question. We understand that the application of Article 135 has a name: it is called hunger. When you sealed in the Constitution that the payment of the debt and the interests would have absolute priority, you handed over national sovereignty to the "troika" and to the financial markets; you facilitated the destruction of public employment; increased poverty, social exclusion, the loss of dignity of many people, hunger, and cuts in healthcare, education, and social services.

The growing debt and the interests are unpayable. One hundred million euros every day in interest, which is what it costs to build a five-hundred-bed hospital, is intolerable.

It is urgent to audit and know the part of the illegitimate debt. We must confront and renegotiate. For this, obviously, we must reduce the deficit and dependence on credit, we are aware; but not through cuts, which is the vicious circle that continues to sink consumption and our economy. Yes, through greater revenues, fighting against the immense tax fraud that exists in our country and a tax reform that taxes the profits of capital, the Corporate Tax of companies, and the large fortunes, which are the ones that pay the least throughout the democratic period of all citizens.

The objective for us is to reduce the deficit by three points and to stand firm against the payment of interest. It is radically incompatible to pay the interest and the debt, and to say that we must preserve education and healthcare without more income. The deficit cannot be the excuse to cut in healthcare and education, and to deteriorate them; as to reduce services in the Town Halls and, ultimately, to justify their privatization.

Therefore, repeal the modification of Article 135 of the Constitution, confront the "troika," we want to recover our sovereignty, and guarantee the basic rights that are indeed enshrined in the Constitution.

Mr. Rajoy, yes, it is possible, as many voices in this country say. It is just a matter of political will.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Lara.

I believe that Spain must pay the interest on its credits, and in fact, Spain does so, as does any other country in the world. If we do not pay the interest, what will happen is that no one will ever lend us money, and therefore, we will not be able to finance the economy, and thus, there will be no welfare policy, no infrastructure policy, no public services, or anything.

You say that you do not propose leaving the euro, but the proposal you are making leads us directly to leaving the euro; therefore, what you are proposing is leaving the euro, and it is another thing that you do not want to state it that way.

I believe that the public deficit is not good for many reasons, first, because the more we get into debt, the harder it is to finance and the greater the burden of interest. Every euro we have to pay in interest is one less euro for public services. The Administration absorbs all the credit that could go to small and medium-sized enterprises that could generate wealth and employment. And the Administration stops paying its suppliers.

Therefore, it is essential, in addition to our European commitments, to fight against the public deficit, because this is the same as fighting against the lack of economic growth, against the lack of employment, and against the lack of improvement in the level of well-being and wealth of all citizens.

That is my opinion, that is the opinion of the twenty-seven of the Union. Another thing is that the deficit needs to be reduced over a longer period, they have given us more time, and I believe that is good news.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. Rajoy, do you consider that the Research, Development, and Innovation policy that your Government is developing is what Spain needs?

President.- I consider that R&D&I is a key piece for the competitiveness of a country. I consider investment in R&D&I to be very important. I believe it is an essential asset to compete in the economies of our environment, and I also believe that our talent should not be wasted and that researchers should have more and better opportunities.

That said, I would like to point out some weaknesses of R&D&I in Spain. First, the low intensity of R&D&I in our companies, half of the European average, although it is improving; however, public financing is aligned with the countries in our environment. There is a second concerning issue that we are working on, which is the low utilization of European funding: Spanish groups receive less than what we contribute, not so much companies, but universities do. And finally, I must add the budgetary problems that you are aware of.

From there, we have made some important decisions. First, in the Law to Support Entrepreneurs: after the budget reduction in 2012, just as had happened in 2010 and 2011, we have made a greater effort this year, 2013. We are also making an effort to develop Spanish participation in European programs, and we have recently approved the Strategy and the State Plan 2013-2016 to give a boost to R&D&I in our country, starting from the basis and with the conviction that, without a doubt, there is a certainly important element of competitiveness here that, therefore, affects our well-being and our wealth.

Thank you very much.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba. - Mr. Rajoy, last Friday the scientific community answered the question I just asked you. They did so unanimously and emphatically: the rectors, the scientific societies, the young researchers, and the unions told you in capital letters that "No" to your scientific policy. They are not alone. The most prestigious scientific journals have been denouncing this frequently, and here, in this very chamber, during the debate on the National Reform Plan, I told you two things. I told you, first, that the data you sent to Brussels was not true because in 2012 R&D expenditures fell, and in 2013 they are falling even faster; and I told you that we could not give up the goal of 3 percent for 2020 because in science, as you well know, to stop is to go backward.

The problem with this scientific policy is that behind the budgetary contempt for R&D lies a growth model that you systematically defend, which consists of gaining competitiveness by lowering wages -- that is why you enacted the labor reform -- lowering wages unilaterally and without considering the benefits, which is something like saying "injustice for today and hunger for tomorrow," because you know, Mr. Rajoy, that we cannot lower wages indefinitely, and you know that, no matter how much we lower wages, there will always be countries competing with lower wages.

That is why I am going to ask you, in relation to the scientific community, to the scientists, three things: first, do not despise them, receive them, do not leave them at the door of the Ministry of Economy because they are people who deserve attention and respect; second, do not punish them and ensure that there are no research groups left without funding because their Autonomous Communities do not meet the deficit targets, because that is happening; and third, do not expel them, because, you see, Mr. Rajoy, there is no brain drain here, there is brain expulsion, and that means you have to call for scholarships on time, contracts on time, and positions on time.

In summary, Mr. Rajoy. As a professor from Complutense said last week, what I am asking you is that in trying to fix the present, you do not burden the future.

President. - Thank you very much, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.

I must say that I cannot share some of your value judgments. I believe that R&D is a key element for the competitiveness of the Spanish economy, and as soon as we recover budgetary normality in our country, because we are in a situation of extreme difficulty, you will see that reflected in the General State Budgets.

I also cannot share your statements about contempt and expulsions. They are not true. We are doing everything in our power in a difficult moment. We have recently approved the Entrepreneurs' Law which, among other things, establishes a refund system for deductions in R&D. It will not be necessary to obtain profits to apply it. That is to say, for the first time there is a negative Corporate Tax. There are also other tax improvements that will make 570 million euros available to the scientific community.

We have created the scientific visa; restored the social security contribution bonuses for research staff; loans will be below 1 percent; we are going to approve in the coming days an extraordinary credit for the CSIC and for the new R&D plan; we are making important decisions to achieve returns in Europe, and the situation has improved compared to last year, 2012…